Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Regenerative Agriculture Podcast

Regenerative Agriculture Podcast artwork

Episode 194: Glyphosate and the Herbicide Treadmill with Chuck Benbrook

Oct 30, 20261 hr 19 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Chuck Benbrook is an agricultural economist with a PhD in agricultural economics who has also farmed commercially. From 1979 to 1997 he worked on agricultural policy in Washington, D.C., including as executive director of the National Academy of Sciences' Board on Agriculture and of a House Agriculture subcommittee. He has spent more than 40 years researching farming systems, pest management, and pesticide regulation. For the past 25 years, Chuck has served as an expert witness in pesticide litigation involving glyphosate, chlorpyrifos, and paraquat. His 2025 paper proposes that glyphosate can persist in human bone. He is involved with the Heartland Health Research Alliance, which is running a Midwest birth cohort study on herbicide exposure. In this episode, John and Chuck discuss: Why weed control in 1996 often took three to five herbicides, and how Roundup Ready crops replaced that with one pass. How glyphosate use grew about 20-fold, reaching 80% of U.S. row crop acres at its peak. Why the first glyphosate-resistant marestail in 2004 started farmers on the herbicide treadmill. How seed and pesticide costs for corn, soybean, and cotton farmers have roughly tripled since 1996. Chuck's hypothesis that glyphosate binds to calcium and is stored in bone, then slowly released back into the blood. How Don Huber's work on glyphosate tying up minerals in soybeans helped Chuck connect the dots. Why pre-harvest desiccation is only 2-3% of glyphosate use but may drive about 90% of dietary exposure. How John uses boron as a maturity enhancer to replace a chemical desiccant and improve grain quality. Why Chuck believes current EPA toxicity testing misses chronic health effects, and what he would change. Additional Resources To read Chuck's paper on glyphosate persistence in bone, please visit: https://link.springer.com/article/10.1186/s12302-025-01057-1 To read Chuck's widely cited paper on trends in glyphosate use, please visit: https://link.springer.com/article/10.1186/s12302-016-0070-0 To read Chuck's widely cited paper on how genetically engineered crops changed pesticide use, please visit: https://link.springer.com/article/10.1186/2190-4715-24-24 To learn more about the Heartland Health Research Alliance, please visit: https://hh-ra.org To read about the Heartland Study, a Midwest birth cohort study on herbicide exposure, please visit: https://bmcpublichealth.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186/s12889-023-17171-9 To listen to John's conversation with Don Huber, please visit: https://advancingecoag.com/podcast/season-2-kickoff-with-don-huber/ Disclaimer: The views and opinions expressed by speakers on the Regenerative Agriculture Podcast are their own and do not necessarily reflect the views, positions, or policies of Advancing Eco Agriculture (AEA) or its employees. Appearances do not constitute an endorsement by AEA, and AEA does not guarantee the accuracy or completeness of statements made by guests. This podcast is for educational and informational purposes only and is not a substitute for professional agronomic, medical, legal, or financial advice. Always follow product labels and applicable laws, and consult a qualified professional before making decisions for your operation or your health. About John Kempf John Kempf is the founder of Advancing Eco Agriculture (AEA). A top expert in biological and regenerative farming, John founded AEA in 2006 to help fellow farmers by providing the education, tools, and strategies that will have a global effect on the food supply and those who grow it. Through intense study and the knowledge gleaned from many industry leaders, John is building a comprehensive systems-based approach to plant nutrition - a system solidly based on the sciences of plant physiology, mineral nutrition, and soil microbiology. Support For This Show & Helping You Grow Since 2006, AEA has been on a mission to help growers become more resilient, efficient, and profitable with regenerative agriculture. AEA works directly with growers to apply its unique line of liquid mineral crop nutrition products and biological inoculants. Informed by cutting-edge plant and soil data-gathering techniques, AEA's science-based programs empower farm operations to meet the crop quality markers that matter the most. AEA has created real and lasting change on millions of acres with its products and data-driven services by working hand-in-hand with growers to produce healthier soil, stronger crops, and higher profits. Beyond working on the ground with growers, AEA leads in regenerative agriculture media and education, producing and distributing the popular and highly-regarded Regenerative Agriculture Podcast, inspiring webinars, and other educational content that serve as go-to resources for growers worldwide. Learn more about AEA's regenerative programs and products: https://www.advancingecoag.com

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Speaker 1: Hi friends, this is John. Speaker 1: Welcome to the Region of Agriculture Speaker 1: podcast. Sometimes it's worth having Speaker 1: controversial conversations. Speaker 1: Conversations that challenge our thinking, Speaker 1: that inspire our thinking. Speaker 1: And the reality is if we're all thinking Speaker 1: similar things, if we're all, I suppose Speaker 1: you could say, preaching to the choir. Speaker 1: One of my advisors and mentors in the Speaker 1: early, still a good friend of mine, he Speaker 1: used to say that if you have a group

Speaker 1: of people around the table and they all Speaker 1: agree, one of them is doing all the Speaker 1: thinking. And so I've wanted to have a Speaker 1: conversation to challenge all of our Speaker 1: thinking and to help us, perhaps give us Speaker 1: different perspectives on some of the Speaker 1: opportunities and the challenges that we Speaker 1: have in agriculture. Speaker 1: And so I'm very pleased and very honored Speaker 1: to have with me today. Speaker 1: Chuck Benbrook. Chuck, I I can't even.

Speaker 1: You you have done a wealth of work Speaker 1: in in a number of different domains, and Speaker 1: I want to get into some of that Speaker 1: and and bring out some of the more Speaker 1: challenging things that you've worked on, Speaker 1: or I should say, things that are perceived Speaker 1: as a challenge to contemporary Speaker 1: agriculture. Can you tell us a bit about Speaker 1: your story, the background, the? Speaker 1: Scope of your work. Speaker 1: What has brought you to the work that

Speaker 1: you're doing today? Speaker 1: Sure, John, and thanks for inviting me to Speaker 1: your podcast. I've I've had a long career Speaker 1: working at the nexus of agriculture, the Speaker 1: environment, public health, policy, and Speaker 1: economics. I have a PhD in agricultural Speaker 1: economics. I've farmed commercially. Speaker 1: I've conducted research for 40 plus years Speaker 1: on a wide range of farming systems. Speaker 1: And technology. I've done continuous work Speaker 1: on pest management and pesticides,

Speaker 1: pesticide regulation. Speaker 1: And when biotechnology came along, I Speaker 1: got heavily involved with assessing the Speaker 1: initial technologies that became part of Speaker 1: the Agricultural biotechnology revolution Speaker 1: technology revolution. Speaker 1: I've had a just a wonderful Speaker 1: career opportunities to work with so Speaker 1: many wonderful farmers and scientists and Speaker 1: thinkers and people trying to help Speaker 1: American agriculture find its way to

Speaker 1: do a better job for the Speaker 1: general public, the environment, and rural Speaker 1: communities. So glad to talk about Speaker 1: any and all of it with Speaker 1: you. It is. It's my understanding. Speaker 1: We're just going to dive right Speaker 1: into the deep end, if you Speaker 1: will. We have a very polarizing Speaker 1: conversation generally in agriculture when

Speaker 1: we start talking about pesticides and Speaker 1: the challenges that are represented by Speaker 1: just pesticides generally. Speaker 1: And there are some specific compounds. Speaker 1: I know I've had John Lundgren Speaker 1: on. He's talked very clearly about Speaker 1: the challenges that he observed with. Speaker 1: Insecticides, we are coming to understand Speaker 1: that. We have very significant ecosystem Speaker 1: effects from pesticides and we have also

Speaker 1: public health effects that we're coming to Speaker 1: find are very significant but they're Speaker 1: perhaps difficult to tease out and to, if Speaker 1: we look at from a macro perspective, it's Speaker 1: easy to point the finger and for those of Speaker 1: us involved in agriculture we want to say Speaker 1: that oh it's everything else. Speaker 1: It's food processing is this or that or Speaker 1: the other thing. It's not something that Speaker 1: we are doing. And yet The reality is, the Speaker 1: evidence clearly suggests that there are

Speaker 1: things that we are doing. Speaker 1: So, it's my understanding that you were a Speaker 1: key witness during glyphosate and non Speaker 1: Hodgkin's lymphoma litigation, and you are Speaker 1: also involved with other litigation. Speaker 1: You know, there are many people within the Speaker 1: farming community who look at what Speaker 1: happened as the glyphosate litigation was Speaker 1: ongoing, saying, how can these Verdicts be Speaker 1: reached? Like there is no science, there's Speaker 1: no evidence to support that glyphosate Speaker 1: causes cancer, that it has any of

Speaker 1: these challenges. And yet, obviously, when Speaker 1: you have a pattern of prevailing in Speaker 1: court, you have to ask the obvious Speaker 1: question, how did that come about? Speaker 1: And what evidence was used to achieve Speaker 1: that? So there's a lot there to Speaker 1: unpack, You were very instrumental in that Speaker 1: process. Tell us about... Speaker 1: The background of the history of Speaker 1: glyphosate and your perspective on Speaker 1: glyphosate being carcinogenic and all the

Speaker 1: other challenges that it has. Speaker 1: Let me go back a bit farther, Speaker 1: John, and tell you how I got Speaker 1: into this second part of my career Speaker 1: where I've spent a lot of time Speaker 1: and made most of my income from Speaker 1: serving as an expert witness in high Speaker 1: dollar pesticide litigation. Speaker 1: The first Half of my career where Speaker 1: I came back into Washington, D.C., and

Speaker 1: got engaged with the policy process was Speaker 1: at the end of the Carter administration, Speaker 1: a long time ago in the late Speaker 1: 70s. From the 70s through the 90s, Speaker 1: I was heavily involved in pesticide use Speaker 1: and regulation and risk assessment and Speaker 1: became. A known national figure and expert Speaker 1: in pesticide regulatory policy and Speaker 1: pesticide science. Speaker 1: I moved out of DC and was

Speaker 1: living on the Grand Ronde River in Speaker 1: Northeast Oregon, enjoying steelhead Speaker 1: fishing. And I got a call from Speaker 1: lawyers in Minnesota who were representing Speaker 1: farmers in the Red River Valley who Speaker 1: had sued BASC in the Red River Speaker 1: Valley who had sued BASF over a Speaker 1: dual pricing scheme that they had put Speaker 1: in place for post and post plus Speaker 1: herbicide, sethoxydim. Speaker 1: And I had never done anything with

Speaker 1: lawyers. And this law firm found me Speaker 1: because of my history with pesticide Speaker 1: regulation. And I was asked to come Speaker 1: into the litigation as an expert in Speaker 1: federal pesticide regulatory policy, Speaker 1: because the way that BASF manipulated the Speaker 1: regulatory process and regulatory agencies Speaker 1: was really at the heart of the Speaker 1: case. Speaker 1: Basically, the farmers were being screwed. Speaker 1: They were being charged twice as much

Speaker 1: for POST plus that they used on Speaker 1: sunflowers and pumpkins and sugar beets Speaker 1: and other specialty crops compared to the Speaker 1: POST product that was registered for Speaker 1: cotton and wheat and soybeans. Speaker 1: And BASF claimed in public and in Speaker 1: court that they had to charge more Speaker 1: for POST Plus because of all the Speaker 1: extra testing that they had to go Speaker 1: through in order to secure and maintain

Speaker 1: registrations for the specialty crop uses Speaker 1: of POST Plus. Well, it was all Speaker 1: BS, basically. They had very insignificant Speaker 1: additional costs. And it was my job Speaker 1: as the expert in how BASF. Speaker 1: Interacted with both the federal EPA and Speaker 1: the state of North Dakota via Section Speaker 1: 24C registrations for POST. Speaker 1: That my contribution to that case Speaker 1: convinced the jury that, in fact, BASF

Speaker 1: had just carried out this scheme to Speaker 1: charge specially cropped farmers more Speaker 1: money for a product that didn't cost Speaker 1: them any more to manufacture. Speaker 1: And I enjoyed it. It was a Speaker 1: hell of an experience. Speaker 1: I went to the beautiful courthouse in Speaker 1: Ada, Minnesota for the trial. Speaker 1: I was on the stand for a Speaker 1: day and a half. It was so

Speaker 1: incredibly intense. Speaker 1: But that was my first experience. Speaker 1: And basically, since then, for 25 years Speaker 1: now, I've had a series of cases. Speaker 1: I've probably been involved in 30, 35 Speaker 1: cases now. By far the biggest and Speaker 1: most extensive has been the Roundup Non Speaker 1: Hundreds of FOMA litigation, which I was Speaker 1: asked to join in the fall of Speaker 1: 2016, which was about two years before

Speaker 1: the first case went to trial in Speaker 1: the summer of 2018, the Lee Johnson Speaker 1: case. I was Asked to get involved Speaker 1: with that litigation because I had had Speaker 1: years of experience researching glyphosate Speaker 1: and Roundup and from really all Speaker 1: perspectives. But because the Roundup Speaker 1: Ready gene and Roundup Ready crops were Speaker 1: the primary agricultural biotechnology Speaker 1: that I, again, was very involved with

Speaker 1: from a policy perspective. Speaker 1: I had... I just had a lot Speaker 1: of, of background knowledge about the Speaker 1: technology, the molecule, Monsanto's Speaker 1: corporate ethics and behavior, et cetera. Speaker 1: And when I was asked to get Speaker 1: involved with that litigation, I had a Speaker 1: pretty good idea of what it was Speaker 1: going to entail. And, and it, it Speaker 1: unfolded much like I, I expected it

Speaker 1: to. I've been doing it now for Speaker 1: almost 11 years and still have active Speaker 1: cases. Speaker 1: I'm the last of the original Speaker 1: Experts in the litigation that's taking Speaker 1: new clients and still looking forward Speaker 1: to participating in future trials. Speaker 1: Over the years, I've also been Speaker 1: involved with a major case involving Speaker 1: chlorpyrifos or Lorisban insecticide, a

Speaker 1: Dow AgroScience product, which causes Speaker 1: developmental effects in fetuses when Speaker 1: pregnant women are exposed to it. Speaker 1: And also the paraquat Parkinson's disease Speaker 1: litigation, which has me tied up Speaker 1: pretty heavily now. Speaker 1: I'm working on a new expert Speaker 1: report that's due in about a Speaker 1: week on a next round of Speaker 1: cases that Syngenta is facing over

Speaker 1: Paraquat and Parkinson's disease. Speaker 1: So I've been deeply involved in Speaker 1: the science and regulatory issues of Speaker 1: chlorpyrifos, which Was the major OP Speaker 1: insecticide and the most important Speaker 1: pesticide in the whole debate about Speaker 1: the Food Quality Protection Act, Speaker 1: glyphosate and non-honchos of FOMA, which Speaker 1: of course has been the most Speaker 1: significant pesticide litigation ever.

Speaker 1: I mean, the bear has spent Speaker 1: well over $20 billion dealing with Speaker 1: it, and they're going to spend Speaker 1: at least another $10 billion. Speaker 1: Before they're out of it. Speaker 1: It's a massive, hugely significant body Speaker 1: of litigation. And paraquat and Speaker 1: Parkinson's disease is also very Speaker 1: significant. And I mention all this Speaker 1: because I've now had an opportunity

Speaker 1: spanning almost 15 years to study Speaker 1: in detail how Dow AgroSciences and Speaker 1: the context of chloroplasty. Speaker 1: Sciences in the context of chlorpyrifos, Speaker 1: Syngenta and its predecessor companies in Speaker 1: its stewardship of Paraquat, and Monsanto, Speaker 1: Bayer with Roundup and non-Hodgkin Zafoma. Speaker 1: I've seen how the chemical companies, Speaker 1: when faced with significant public health Speaker 1: impacts and litigation, how they respond

Speaker 1: and what they do, and how Speaker 1: over the years They try to Speaker 1: insulate themselves from legal liability Speaker 1: for poisoning people, making people sick. Speaker 1: And they're very good at it. Speaker 1: And they invest millions and millions Speaker 1: of dollars proactively in trying to Speaker 1: lessen the chances that they're going Speaker 1: to be held accountable for the Speaker 1: risks that they take with their

Speaker 1: customers, the farmers. Speaker 1: And ranchers and other pest managers Speaker 1: that buy their products and are Speaker 1: not aware of how dangerous they Speaker 1: are and how important it is Speaker 1: to use them very carefully. Speaker 1: So I have developed a very Speaker 1: negative perspective if you will, about Speaker 1: the pesticide industry as a result Speaker 1: Of being able to study in

Speaker 1: depth their own emails, their internal Speaker 1: emails and internal actions involving Speaker 1: these high-risk pesticides. Speaker 1: It's a sad story and explains Speaker 1: a lot about why is it Speaker 1: in the United States of America Speaker 1: with probably the most advanced public Speaker 1: health science and regulatory Programs and Speaker 1: understanding of how pesticides are Speaker 1: harming people. Are there so many

Speaker 1: high risk pesticides still widely used Speaker 1: that aren't legal to use in Speaker 1: much of the rest of the Speaker 1: world? Yeah, it's fascinating. Speaker 1: It's a fascinating question. Speaker 1: We're considered an advanced civilization, Speaker 1: comparatively, an advanced society, and Speaker 1: yet we have higher use of Speaker 1: a lot of these compounds. Speaker 1: But, you know, there are several Speaker 1: questions. There's lots of questions that

Speaker 1: come to mind, Chuck. Speaker 1: I find it fascinating whenever we have Speaker 1: conversations, we as a society Speaker 1: collectively or even in a group setting, Speaker 1: when we have conversations about Speaker 1: substances that create dependencies, could Speaker 1: be talking about drugs could be nicotine, Speaker 1: could be any one of different things, Speaker 1: could be all kinds of different habits, Speaker 1: social media, whatever the case might be. Speaker 1: Ultra processed food.

Speaker 1: When we have these conversations about Speaker 1: things that create dependencies and we Speaker 1: begin describing the negative impact they Speaker 1: have, it's usually the people who squeal Speaker 1: the loudest who are the most dependent and Speaker 1: who perceive themselves as being hurt by Speaker 1: these things being removed. Speaker 1: And I bring this point out because it's Speaker 1: been absolutely fascinating to me to Speaker 1: observe farmers who supposedly should care

Speaker 1: a great deal about producing quality and Speaker 1: about producing a high quality product for Speaker 1: their customer, the people who are buying Speaker 1: food. And they are often the staunchest Speaker 1: advocates for the pesticide products, Speaker 1: saying, we can't in the case of Speaker 1: glyphosate, like we can't farm without Speaker 1: them. And of course, yes, our farming Speaker 1: systems have changed dramatically since Speaker 1: those herbicides were introduced because Speaker 1: of the farming management practices that

Speaker 1: they facilitated that were able to be Speaker 1: adopted that hadn't been, that the scale Speaker 1: works today that didn't work 40 years ago. Speaker 1: So it's fascinating to me to observe that Speaker 1: we have these dependencies, the behavior Speaker 1: of the users is suggesting that we have Speaker 1: an addiction, that we have a product Speaker 1: dependency. And within that, you know, Speaker 1: there's this one quote from I think it's

Speaker 1: Charlie Munger. I'll paraphrase it a Speaker 1: little bit, but he says something to the Speaker 1: effect of You have no business having an Speaker 1: opinion until you can articulate the Speaker 1: opposing point of view better than the Speaker 1: opposition. In other words, you have to Speaker 1: have A deep understanding of both sides of Speaker 1: the issue. And when I attempt to have Speaker 1: that conversation with people to say, all Speaker 1: right, you don't believe that these

Speaker 1: pesticides cause harm, that they are Speaker 1: challenging. And have you looked at the Speaker 1: evidence of the opposing point of view? Speaker 1: Have you done, do you have a qualified Speaker 1: opinion? And I seldom find people able to Speaker 1: have. A coherent conversation about the Speaker 1: opposing point of view. Speaker 1: And so, one of the reasons I Speaker 1: wanted to have this conversation with you Speaker 1: was to draw to light and to

Speaker 1: reveal what some of the opposing Speaker 1: perspective is, but also to give guidance Speaker 1: where can we learn more? Speaker 1: Where can we learn? Speaker 1: Where can we dig deeper? Speaker 1: So, yeah, there's a lot there for Speaker 1: you to respond to. Speaker 1: Well, I have also been fascinated in Speaker 1: observing the changes in attitudes among Speaker 1: large scale commercial row crop farmers. Speaker 1: Let me just say that one thing

Speaker 1: is crystal clear to me at this Speaker 1: stage of my career, having spent a Speaker 1: half century watching changes in Speaker 1: agriculture, and that is that there's Speaker 1: really Two major agriculture. Speaker 1: There's really two major agricultures Speaker 1: that are very different in Speaker 1: terms of the challenges that Speaker 1: they face, the public policy Speaker 1: issues that arise from them.

Speaker 1: One is the just simply, Speaker 1: I think everybody will understand, Speaker 1: your viewers and listeners are Speaker 1: familiar with this dichotomy. Speaker 1: You have Midwestern, mostly Midwestern, Speaker 1: Southeastern row crop, CAFO agriculture, Speaker 1: which is relatively narrow in Speaker 1: the products produced, uses large Speaker 1: scale chemical intensive technology, has Speaker 1: succeeded in reducing the number

Speaker 1: of human beings and labor Speaker 1: required to operate a large Speaker 1: commercial farm, versus especially crop Speaker 1: agriculture, mostly fruits and vegetables, Speaker 1: horticultural crops that are so Speaker 1: important. Mostly on the coasts Speaker 1: and in states like. Speaker 1: Florida, Arizona, New Mexico. Speaker 1: Very different issues, very different Speaker 1: challenges. And one of the

Speaker 1: fascinating political dynamics that's Speaker 1: playing out now, John, is Speaker 1: how is the US Congress Speaker 1: going to deal with the Speaker 1: fact that really both specialty Speaker 1: farmers and agriculture in the Speaker 1: coast and agricultural in the Speaker 1: middle, row crop, CAFO agriculture, Speaker 1: are unsustainable and are facing Speaker 1: significant peril because of economics,

Speaker 1: lack of labor, degraded soil Speaker 1: health, unacceptable adverse effects on Speaker 1: the environment, like in Iowa. Speaker 1: Where you have the current midterm Speaker 1: elections are being dominated by Speaker 1: discussions about nitrogen fertilizer and Speaker 1: manure use and pesticides and cancer Speaker 1: in Iowa, which whoever would have Speaker 1: predicted that in 2026, the political Speaker 1: future of Iowa would be determined

Speaker 1: by water quality and Pesticides and Speaker 1: cancer. It's just, it's really quite Speaker 1: striking. So I, I It's really Speaker 1: quite striking. So, I've of course Speaker 1: spent lots of time speaking with Speaker 1: conventional agriculture, conventional Speaker 1: farmers, people that work in and Speaker 1: believe in and support that space. Speaker 1: And what it is, the big Speaker 1: change that I see happening now

Speaker 1: is that it's become okay for Speaker 1: large scale GMO conventional farmers to Speaker 1: question whether. Cortiva, Bayer, BASF, Speaker 1: Syngenta, the fertilizer industry, really, Speaker 1: quote unquote, have their backs. Speaker 1: I think up until a few Speaker 1: years ago, you'd be hard pressed Speaker 1: at a meeting of conventional farmers Speaker 1: to find too many farmers that Speaker 1: would openly question whether these large

Speaker 1: agribusinesses have really been working to Speaker 1: assure a viable future for them. Speaker 1: But boy, I'll tell you now, Speaker 1: there's a lot of people that Speaker 1: are skeptical. And I think that Speaker 1: that segment of the conventional ag Speaker 1: community is going to grow, which Speaker 1: is why the day is coming Speaker 1: when there will be a significant

Speaker 1: reset in food. And agricultural policy in Speaker 1: this country. And I hope and pray that Speaker 1: I'm still on my feet when that day Speaker 1: comes, because I could remember in the Speaker 1: 1980s and the 1985 Farm Bill process Speaker 1: thinking, well, maybe this is going to be Speaker 1: the one that really changes things. Speaker 1: And ever since the 85 Farm Bill was Speaker 1: the last one with some significant Speaker 1: positive changes in it.

Speaker 1: And it's been down. Speaker 1: Significant positive changes in it. Speaker 1: And it's been downhill from there in terms Speaker 1: of national policy affecting food, Speaker 1: nutritional quality, food safety, and the Speaker 1: sustainability of large scale conventional Speaker 1: row crop agriculture. Speaker 1: So let's dig into it. Speaker 1: There are so many directions we could take Speaker 1: this conversation, Jeff, but let's dig Speaker 1: into glyphosate as a challenge Speaker 1: specifically. To take a contrarian Speaker 1: perspective, or just kind of as an opening

Speaker 1: question, where's the evidence? Speaker 1: What is the evidence that glyphosate is Speaker 1: carcinogenic and that it is a problem? Speaker 1: And in particular, one of the things I'd Speaker 1: like to get into is in an interview Speaker 1: with Don Huber several years ago, he Speaker 1: described, and I don't remember the exact Speaker 1: terminology and language that he used, but Speaker 1: he described how, if I understood Speaker 1: correctly, you had developed an index of Speaker 1: the biological impact, the degree of

Speaker 1: biological impact of various toxins. Speaker 1: And how highly glyphosate ranked on Speaker 1: that index compared to many other Speaker 1: toxins. Can you speak to that Speaker 1: as well? Sure. So, glyphosate is Speaker 1: without a doubt the most remarkable Speaker 1: herbicide ever discovered. Speaker 1: When you look at its combination Speaker 1: of efficacy, physical and chemical Speaker 1: properties, and mammalian toxicology, it's

Speaker 1: just an extraordinary product. Speaker 1: And when Monsanto realized that they Speaker 1: could use genetic engineering to create Speaker 1: glyphosate tolerant crops, it opened up Speaker 1: the entire corn, soybean, cotton complex Speaker 1: to annual use of Roundup as Speaker 1: the primary and on many farms, Speaker 1: the sole weed management technology. Speaker 1: It was just a phenomenal change.

Speaker 1: You know, John, I don't know Speaker 1: how much you remember back in Speaker 1: 1996, the year that Roundup Ready Speaker 1: soybeans and cotton came on the Speaker 1: market. Conventional soybean and cotton Speaker 1: farmers were having terrible problems with Speaker 1: herbicide resistance, herbicide carryover, Speaker 1: damage to rotational crops. Speaker 1: They were having to spray three, Speaker 1: four, even five active ingredients to

Speaker 1: get a crop through the season Speaker 1: and in the barn. Speaker 1: There were all these adverse interactions Speaker 1: with the different herbicides they were Speaker 1: having to use. There were incompatibility Speaker 1: with liquid fertilizer. Speaker 1: There were incompatibility with liquid Speaker 1: fertilizers and insecticides they wanted Speaker 1: to put in their tank mixes. Speaker 1: It was just a mess. Speaker 1: Weed management for corn, for soybean and Speaker 1: cotton growers in 1996, it was expensive

Speaker 1: and getting more expensive. Speaker 1: It was working less well. Speaker 1: It was screwing up their operations in all Speaker 1: sorts of ways. And from a technical point Speaker 1: of view, farmers were feeling that they Speaker 1: were losing control over weeds. Speaker 1: They felt that way. Speaker 1: Control over weeds. Speaker 1: And they felt that way because it was Speaker 1: happening. The system was falling apart. Speaker 1: And all of a sudden, here is this Roundup Speaker 1: Ready system where all you have to do is

Speaker 1: buy the genetically engineered seeds and Speaker 1: pay the premium for them, plant the Speaker 1: Roundup Ready seeds, and then wait till a Speaker 1: couple, three weeks after germination and Speaker 1: spray Roundup over the top of your crop. Speaker 1: And in the early years for three or four Speaker 1: or five years, a lot of soybean and cotton Speaker 1: farmers got through the year with only one Speaker 1: application of Roundup, and that was it. Speaker 1: And it was robust.

Speaker 1: It was virtually impossible to screw it Speaker 1: up. And if they happened to make an Speaker 1: application and soon after it rained, so Speaker 1: that the Roundup got washed off the weed Speaker 1: leaves before it got in through the weed Speaker 1: epidermis. Thank you. Speaker 1: The weed leaves before it got in through Speaker 1: the weed epidermis, they could just make Speaker 1: another application. Speaker 1: And in fact, it wasn't very long before Speaker 1: Monsanto said to farmers, Hey, if the Speaker 1: Roundup doesn't work, we'll give you the

Speaker 1: active ingredient to make a respray. Speaker 1: It's part of their loyalty program. Speaker 1: Well, just, I mean, think of how Speaker 1: incredibly welcomed this was. Speaker 1: It's a very low tox product, it has the Speaker 1: least worrisome signal word. Speaker 1: The damn label didn't even require farmers Speaker 1: when mixing and loading and applying to Speaker 1: wear gloves. I mean, it was just nothing. Speaker 1: And obviously, farmers were well aware Speaker 1: that Roundup was much safer than Paraquat, Speaker 1: which they also could use in no till

Speaker 1: systems. Now, of course, there weren't Speaker 1: Paraquat tolerant soybean and cotton Speaker 1: varieties on the market, but Roundup was. Speaker 1: A phenomenal new technology that worked Speaker 1: incredibly well. It didn't save farmers Speaker 1: any money. Monsanto priced it so that Speaker 1: there really wasn't a big change in Speaker 1: weed management costs, but it just worked Speaker 1: so much better and it was forgiving.

Speaker 1: And it was, at the time, it Speaker 1: seemed safe because it was, you know, Speaker 1: very low acute toxicity and there wasn't Speaker 1: a lot of evidence that there was Speaker 1: any risk of cancer or damage to Speaker 1: DNA. But what happened with Roundup, you Speaker 1: know, it's the same thing that happened Speaker 1: with the neonicotinoid insecticides and Speaker 1: with, you know, 20 years earlier with

Speaker 1: the triazines and then these acetylaniline Speaker 1: herbicides. Once a technology comes on the Speaker 1: Market and works and the manufacturers Speaker 1: price it competitively, they tend to Speaker 1: rapidly gain market share. Speaker 1: And so, what really started to create Speaker 1: problems for Roundup was it was used Speaker 1: too much. Speaker 1: Farmers adopted it too widely. Speaker 1: And it was what, 2004, eight

Speaker 1: years after the first Roundup ready Speaker 1: soybean was planted. Speaker 1: That the first Roundup Resistance Marstail Speaker 1: was identified in Delaware in a Speaker 1: no-till Roundup Ready soybean field. Speaker 1: And that, you know, so from Speaker 1: 2004 for about the next four Speaker 1: years, the Roundup Ready revolution Speaker 1: started to sort of run into Speaker 1: the brick wall. As Roundup Resistance

Speaker 1: of run into the brick wall Speaker 1: as Roundup-resistant Palmer amaranth, Speaker 1: Roundup-resistant horsetail, and Speaker 1: Roundup-resistant pigweed started to Speaker 1: emerge and spread first in the Speaker 1: southeast where farmers were making two, Speaker 1: even three applications of Roundup in Speaker 1: a year to control weeds over Speaker 1: the much longer season that was Speaker 1: occurring. Speaker 1: Things started to go south, but you know,

Speaker 1: the use of Roundup went up like 20 Speaker 1: fold. And so it was Being sprayed on Speaker 1: 80% of the row crop acres in the Speaker 1: country. You know, I published a paper in Speaker 1: 2012 that reported that there was enough Speaker 1: Roundup sprayed in recent years in the Speaker 1: United States to apply three quarters of a Speaker 1: pound of active ingredient of the Speaker 1: glyphosate in Roundup on every cropland

Speaker 1: acre in the country. Speaker 1: That's a big number. Speaker 1: Every cropland acre in the country. Speaker 1: And actually, globally, it was two thirds Speaker 1: of a pound. So, I mean, this is Speaker 1: like unprecedented. Speaker 1: At peak use of glyphosate, which happened Speaker 1: around 2015, 2016, depending upon what Speaker 1: metric you use, at peak use, there was Speaker 1: over three times more glyphosate used than Speaker 1: the second most widely used pesticide in

Speaker 1: the world, which was atrazine, the corn Speaker 1: insecticide, the corn herbicide. Speaker 1: And no, in the history of farming, no Speaker 1: other pesticide had even come close to how Speaker 1: widely and heavily glyphosate was being Speaker 1: used. So it's not, it shouldn't be a Speaker 1: huge surprise to anybody that Roundup Speaker 1: started to show up in water. Speaker 1: Of course, it was in soils all over Speaker 1: the world. Then it became, started to

Speaker 1: be detected in waters, in the Speaker 1: air, in food, and then in Speaker 1: our bodies. Today, probably over 90% Speaker 1: of the human beings on the Speaker 1: planet are peeing glyphosate almost every Speaker 1: day because it is so ubiquitous Speaker 1: in the environment, in water, and Speaker 1: in food. And the, you know, Speaker 1: so it was this massive use Speaker 1: that brought that about.

Speaker 1: And it's also what drove the Speaker 1: emergence and spread of resistant weeds, Speaker 1: which caused farmers to start increasing Speaker 1: the application rate of Roundup, caused Speaker 1: farmers to make two applications where Speaker 1: in past years one application had Speaker 1: been effective, and really draw Speaker 1: application had been effective and really Speaker 1: drew conventional corn, soybean, cotton Speaker 1: farmers on what we call the

Speaker 1: herbicide treadmill. Speaker 1: Very negative development and one which Speaker 1: we're still dealing with it. Speaker 1: US agriculture is still on the Speaker 1: herbicide treadmill. Speaker 1: I mean, it's not uncommon now Speaker 1: for corn, soybean, cotton far An Speaker 1: acre on herbicides when 20 years Speaker 1: ago they were spending maybe $20. Speaker 1: Well, that's a big change, especially when Speaker 1: you realize they're also spending three or

Speaker 1: four times more for seed. Speaker 1: So when you look at what has Speaker 1: undermined the economic sustainability of Speaker 1: corn, soybean, cotton, large scale GMO Speaker 1: farmers, it's what they're spending on Speaker 1: seed and pesticides, it has gone up Speaker 1: probably triple has gone up, probably Speaker 1: tripled over 1996 when the ag biotech Speaker 1: revolution happened. Speaker 1: Now, the other changes in soil health Speaker 1: and other problems have just added more

Speaker 1: fuel on the fire. Now, you ask Speaker 1: about the evidence of glyphosate and Speaker 1: Roundup and cancer. Speaker 1: And I have a leading question into Speaker 1: that. You just you mentioned the Speaker 1: ubiquitous presence of glyphosate today in Speaker 1: water, in rainfall, everyone is peeing it Speaker 1: out. The argument that gets made is Speaker 1: that it is present in such infinitesimally Speaker 1: small quantities, in a few part per

Speaker 1: billion concentrations, or perhaps a bit Speaker 1: more than that, that it doesn't really Speaker 1: have a biological impact at those levels. Speaker 1: Yeah, well, too bad that that is Speaker 1: just not true. What in the early Speaker 1: 1990s, independent scientists, mostly Speaker 1: academic scientists, started to test Speaker 1: glyphosate more regularly because of the Speaker 1: fact that they knew that these Roundup Speaker 1: ready crops were coming and that there

Speaker 1: was likely to be a big increase Speaker 1: in the use of Roundup. Speaker 1: And lo and behold, a number Speaker 1: of papers started to appear in Speaker 1: scientific journals reporting that Speaker 1: glyphosate was genotoxic. Speaker 1: Now, what does that mean? Speaker 1: That means that glyphosate and formulated Speaker 1: Roundup have the ability to damage Speaker 1: DNA or disrupt the expression of

Speaker 1: genes through impacts on DNA. Speaker 1: So there are multiple things that Speaker 1: cause cancer, but two of the Speaker 1: most important are when chemicals actually Speaker 1: mutate. DNA and change it in Speaker 1: a way that gives a leg Speaker 1: up or starts the growth of Speaker 1: cancerous cells, or the chemical disrupts Speaker 1: the communication and the regulation of

Speaker 1: genes in a way that our Speaker 1: immune systems become less effective in Speaker 1: snuffing out the growth of cancerous Speaker 1: cells. Most people in America, John, Speaker 1: don't know that every day we're Speaker 1: alive, from the day we're born Speaker 1: to the day we die, we Speaker 1: have hundreds of thousands of cancerous Speaker 1: cells start their path to cancer

Speaker 1: in our bodies every day. Speaker 1: Every day we're alive, it's a Speaker 1: normal process. Hundreds of thousands of Speaker 1: them. But we have this miraculously Speaker 1: effective and redundant process. Speaker 1: Miraculously effective and redundant Speaker 1: immune system that is capable of Speaker 1: detecting those cells and killing them, Speaker 1: controlling them, starving them in one Speaker 1: way or another, turning them off.

Speaker 1: However, the reason that some people Speaker 1: get cancer, let's just talk smoking Speaker 1: for a minute. Not everybody that Speaker 1: smokes two packs a day gets Speaker 1: cancer. Right. Why? Speaker 1: Because their immune system really worked Speaker 1: well and snuffed out the cancerous Speaker 1: growth in their lungs that other Speaker 1: people succumbed to and got the Speaker 1: disease. Well, what we know, what

Speaker 1: we've known now since the early Speaker 1: 2000s is that the glyphosate molecule Speaker 1: triggers oxidative stress through damage Speaker 1: to mitochondria which are the little Speaker 1: energy packed inside cells. Speaker 1: And glyphosate also can trigger breaks Speaker 1: or damage in DNA that cause Speaker 1: a rearrangement of DNA in the Speaker 1: cells. And furthermore, we know that Speaker 1: this primarily happens in our bone

Speaker 1: marrow. Now, why is that important? Speaker 1: Well, your bone marrow is where. Speaker 1: All of your what's called a Speaker 1: Stem cell, the fancy name is Speaker 1: hematopoietic stem cells. Speaker 1: These are the cells that every Speaker 1: day are producing millions of new Speaker 1: red blood cells, white blood cells, Speaker 1: platelets, and neutrophils. Speaker 1: It's what the stem cells in Speaker 1: your bone marrow are what rejuvenate

Speaker 1: or regenerate the human body. Speaker 1: And if those cells didn't do Speaker 1: that none of us would exist Speaker 1: beyond a few months of birth. Speaker 1: So, what started to become clear Speaker 1: by 2000 is that once glyphosate Speaker 1: gets into your blood, and it Speaker 1: doesn't matter whether it's from drinking Speaker 1: water that has glyphosate in it, Speaker 1: consuming food that has glyphosate in

Speaker 1: it, breathing glyphosate in the air, Speaker 1: or herbicide spray solution falling on Speaker 1: your skin and moving through your Speaker 1: epidermis into your bloodstream. Speaker 1: Once glyphosate gets in your blood, it Speaker 1: is immediately being pumped through bone Speaker 1: marrow. At any point in time, as Speaker 1: every day we're alive, something around Speaker 1: 10% of cardiac output, the blood that Speaker 1: our heart is pumping, is being pumped

Speaker 1: through bone marrow. Speaker 1: Now, why is that? Because all of Speaker 1: those stem cells, those millions of stem Speaker 1: cells that have to be directed by Speaker 1: the body to become either a white Speaker 1: blood cell, a red blood cell, a Speaker 1: platelet, or something else, they have to Speaker 1: go through their metamorphosis, if you Speaker 1: will. And when a hematopoietic stem cell

Speaker 1: is directed to become a Red blood Speaker 1: cell, for example, it has to go Speaker 1: through a very, very precise rearrangement Speaker 1: of its DNA so that it becomes Speaker 1: a functioning, healthy immune cell. Speaker 1: Well, unfortunately, we now know that Speaker 1: when glyphosate flows into bone marrow Speaker 1: in blood, because the blood has Speaker 1: to feed these stem cells with

Speaker 1: energy and nutrients so that they Speaker 1: can grow and reproduce, the glyphosate Speaker 1: can sometimes attack and get into Speaker 1: the inside of those stem cells Speaker 1: as they're going through this elaborate Speaker 1: genetic metamorphosis and disrupt their Speaker 1: growth. In fact, scientists now have Speaker 1: documented the precise mutations, not all Speaker 1: of them, but some of them,

Speaker 1: that set a hematocyte. Speaker 1: Poetic stem cell on the path Speaker 1: to either leukemia or non honchosophoma, Speaker 1: both of which are blood cancers. Speaker 1: So, this is what started to Speaker 1: become clear in the decade of Speaker 1: the 2000s. And really, by 2010, Speaker 1: it was getting pretty clear. Speaker 1: And by then, there had been Speaker 1: several epidemiological studies that

Speaker 1: linked heavy use of glyphosate based Speaker 1: herbicides with increased risk of cancer. Speaker 1: There had been multiple genotoxicity Speaker 1: studies, both in live animals like Speaker 1: mice and rats, as well as Speaker 1: in cell culture, using both glyphosate Speaker 1: and glyphosate based herbicides, i.e., Speaker 1: including Roundup, which showed that the Speaker 1: actual formulated Roundup that has the Speaker 1: POEA surfactants is much more genotoxic

Speaker 1: than the glyphosate by itself. Speaker 1: And this is a very important Speaker 1: finding because the other thing that Speaker 1: the POEA surfactants that are added Speaker 1: to the glyphosate to make Roundup, Speaker 1: the reason that Monsanto had to Speaker 1: put them into Roundup, into the Speaker 1: formulation was to get the Roundup Speaker 1: more quickly through the weed epidermis

Speaker 1: because the Roundup has to get Speaker 1: inside the weed tissues to kill Speaker 1: it. Speaker 1: And so the POA surfactants have Speaker 1: the chemical property of accelerating the Speaker 1: movement of the glyphosate through the Speaker 1: weed epidermis. But lo and behold, Speaker 1: You know, in the two thousands, Speaker 1: Monsanto also learned that the POEA Speaker 1: surfactant. Monsanto also learned that the

Speaker 1: POEA surfactants did the same thing Speaker 1: with the human skin epidermis. Speaker 1: And European regulators were becoming Speaker 1: aware of this fact and were Speaker 1: concerned about it and were forcing Speaker 1: Monsanto in Europe to develop better Speaker 1: data on the rate of dermal Speaker 1: penetration of the glyphosate in Roundup, Speaker 1: since no farmer applies just to Speaker 1: glyphosate in Roundup, since no farmer

Speaker 1: applies just glyphosate herbicide, it's Speaker 1: always with a surfactant. Speaker 1: And so all of these changes Speaker 1: in our understanding accumulated in the Speaker 1: decade of the 2000s, and really Speaker 1: came to a head in 2015, Speaker 1: when the International Agency for Research Speaker 1: on Cancer published its Assessment of Speaker 1: glyphosate and Roundup or glyphosate based Speaker 1: herbicide oncogenicity.

Speaker 1: And to the amazement and shock of people Speaker 1: like me, who knew a lot about Roundup Speaker 1: and the testing that had been done on Speaker 1: it, when IARC classified Roundup as a Speaker 1: probable human carcinogen, I mean, it was Speaker 1: like a tsunami went off in the herbicide Speaker 1: market. It was, you know without a doubt, Speaker 1: the most unexpected and consequential Speaker 1: change in scientific understanding in my Speaker 1: 50 year career. I mean, it was like,

Speaker 1: I mean, can you imagine if all of Speaker 1: a sudden we realized that gasoline causes Speaker 1: cancer and we have to stop using gasoline? Speaker 1: Well, that's about the same. Speaker 1: If you were a corn, soybean, cotton, GMO Speaker 1: farmer in 2015 and were told, you got Speaker 1: a farm next year without In 2015 and Speaker 1: we're told, you got to farm next year Speaker 1: without roundup, they would say, it's not Speaker 1: possible, I can't do it.

Speaker 1: And the reality is that that was Speaker 1: absolutely an honest response on their Speaker 1: part. If you were a farm family with Speaker 1: 3000 acres of corn, soybeans, and cotton, Speaker 1: two combines, three or four people working Speaker 1: on the farm. The only way you could Speaker 1: manage that scale of an operation with Speaker 1: three or four people is with a really Speaker 1: simple weed management system like Roundup Speaker 1: Ready crops. Now, of course, by 2015, they

Speaker 1: weren't working so good anymore because of Speaker 1: so many glyphosate resistant weeds, but Speaker 1: the industry engineered dicamba Speaker 1: resistance, 2,4 D resistance into the Speaker 1: crops. And, you know, the next generation Speaker 1: of Herbicide treadmills came on the Speaker 1: market, if you will. Speaker 1: But when I got involved, in the Speaker 1: litigation in the fall of 2016. Speaker 1: And part of my job was to Speaker 1: look at the data that Monsanto had

Speaker 1: developed and submitted to EPA and EFSA Speaker 1: the European Food Standards Agency In Speaker 1: Europe, because it was really the Speaker 1: Europeans and the Americans that were Speaker 1: carrying out the most sophisticated risk Speaker 1: assessments of Roundup and glyphosate Speaker 1: based herbicides. And so I looked at, Speaker 1: I was looking at the rat metabolism Speaker 1: studies that Monsanto had carried out in Speaker 1: the mid 1990s and early 2000s to

Speaker 1: satisfy. And in the early 2000s, to Speaker 1: satisfy mostly European regulators. Speaker 1: EPA hadn't requested them. Speaker 1: It was the Europeans that were pushing Speaker 1: for better data. There were some odd Speaker 1: things that didn't add up when you Speaker 1: looked at these rat metabolism studies. Speaker 1: And they tested the metabolism, which Speaker 1: means the fate of both glyphosate by Speaker 1: itself and Roundup.

Speaker 1: Say by itself and Roundup, formulated Speaker 1: Roundup in the bodies of the rats, Speaker 1: you know, where did it go in Speaker 1: the rats? What level got in? Speaker 1: How long did it stay in? Speaker 1: What was excreted through urine? Speaker 1: What was excreted through feces? Speaker 1: What levels were detected in different Speaker 1: tissues in the body of the rats, including Speaker 1: bone and bone marrow and the brain? Speaker 1: And I'm looking at all, there were like

Speaker 1: 20 new studies that Monsanto had done. Speaker 1: And as I read through the summary Had Speaker 1: done. And as I read through the summaries Speaker 1: of them in a regulatory document that EFSA Speaker 1: had generated, you know, this massive 800 Speaker 1: page volume, some things just didn't add Speaker 1: up. And I got suspicious because it Speaker 1: appeared that the Monsanto scientists in Speaker 1: describing these studies were kind of Speaker 1: dancing around certain issues that they

Speaker 1: really didn't want to deal with. Speaker 1: And so I started digging and digging to Speaker 1: try to understand what was going on. Speaker 1: And this led me down the road to Speaker 1: understanding the impact of the POEA Speaker 1: surfactants on the dermal penetration rate Speaker 1: of formulated Roundup. Speaker 1: It led me to understand why was Speaker 1: so, what the data showed that when Speaker 1: the rats were. When the rats had

Speaker 1: glyphosate injected into their Speaker 1: bloodstream, like an intravenous drug Speaker 1: user, it rapidly left the blood and Speaker 1: went into bone marrow. Speaker 1: So, as the level in blood went Speaker 1: down, the level in bone marrow went Speaker 1: up. And I go, wow, isn't that Speaker 1: interesting? And then, soon after the Speaker 1: level in bone marrow went up, it Speaker 1: started to go up in bone, actually

Speaker 1: in the bone. And then the really Speaker 1: first key piece of the puzzle that Speaker 1: came into place for me the longer, Speaker 1: some of those rat metabolism studies, Speaker 1: Monsanto tracked where the glyphosate was Speaker 1: in the body of the rat for Speaker 1: seven days. Well, in all of Speaker 1: the studies, by seven days, there was Speaker 1: very little left in the body, but

Speaker 1: almost all of it was in the Speaker 1: bone. Ah, now what's going on here? Speaker 1: In comes Don Huber, someone that you Speaker 1: and our community appreciate so much his Speaker 1: contributions to science. Speaker 1: Well, Don was the first person that Speaker 1: sort of explained to me, well, glyphosate Speaker 1: is a divalent cation. Speaker 1: It wants to bind to a metal. Speaker 1: And Don's work on.

Speaker 1: Roundup and soybean health was all about Speaker 1: the glyphosate molecule in the soybean Speaker 1: tying up magnesium and other minerals that Speaker 1: impaired the soybean plants immune Speaker 1: response. You with me? Speaker 1: Yep. Okay, so Don explained to me that Speaker 1: that was what was going on in the Speaker 1: soybean plant. And what was behind that? Speaker 1: And what was behind the, remember what Speaker 1: they called it? It was soybean sudden

Speaker 1: death syndrome or whatever? Speaker 1: SDS, sudden death syndrome. Speaker 1: Yeah. And what was the name of the Speaker 1: wonderful scientist from Missouri that did Speaker 1: such. Robert Kramer? Speaker 1: Yeah, Robert Kramer. Speaker 1: Robert Kramer has now passed away. Speaker 1: Yeah. I spent a lot of time talking Speaker 1: with him to understand that. Speaker 1: And I started applying what their research Speaker 1: suggested. That glyphosate was binding to Speaker 1: minerals and impairing the immune response Speaker 1: of the plants, and saying to myself, well,

Speaker 1: gee, could something like that be going on Speaker 1: in the human body? Speaker 1: Well, now wait a second here. Speaker 1: Glyphosate that goes into the bone marrow Speaker 1: and then it gets tied up in the Speaker 1: bones. Why would glyphosate be lodging or Speaker 1: immobilized in bones? Speaker 1: Well, bones are made out of calcium, Speaker 1: calcium is a divalent cation. Speaker 1: So all of a sudden, this light went Speaker 1: off that the reason that you, I, almost

Speaker 1: everybody on the planet has glyphosate in Speaker 1: our urine every day isn't because we're Speaker 1: exposed to almost the same amount of Speaker 1: glyphosate every day in our urine. Speaker 1: It's because all of us have about the Speaker 1: same amounts of glyphosate immobilized in Speaker 1: our bone because there's so when the blood Speaker 1: comes, so we all have a similar size Speaker 1: reservoir. Yeah, so just bear with me Speaker 1: here. I know this is a little complicated,

Speaker 1: but I just love having an opportunity to Speaker 1: explain this to people because it took Speaker 1: years to figure this out. Speaker 1: We know that the glyphosate flows with the Speaker 1: blood into the bone marrow, and the way Speaker 1: that the after the, you know, that gives Speaker 1: its oxygen and nutrients to the stem cells Speaker 1: in the bone marrow, the blood's got to Speaker 1: get out from the inside of the bone

Speaker 1: to the outside, right? Speaker 1: So that more blood can come in. Speaker 1: It's a flow. Well, this German, this team Speaker 1: of German scientists did this incredibly Speaker 1: elegant project and showed that the blood Speaker 1: that goes into the inside of bones exits Speaker 1: the bones through these tiny channels that Speaker 1: go laterally through the bone. Speaker 1: So, those tiny channels, it's like a Speaker 1: little pipe, right? Speaker 1: But what's all around it? Speaker 1: Calcium, because there are channels in

Speaker 1: bone. So, all around them is calcium. Speaker 1: So, each one of those calcium molecules is Speaker 1: a potential binding site for glyphosate as Speaker 1: it flows through the bone. Speaker 1: And so, that's why our bones carry a Speaker 1: certain amount of glyphosate. Speaker 1: Because, you know, on Tuesday, you know, Speaker 1: yesterday I might have had an oat bar Speaker 1: and there might have been some glyphosate Speaker 1: in the oat bar. And the part of

Speaker 1: the glyphosate that got into my blood, Speaker 1: when it got pumped through my, you know, Speaker 1: through the bones, if there were binding Speaker 1: sites available, it could be immobilized. Speaker 1: And then the very. Speaker 1: Last piece of this puzzle that I finally Speaker 1: figured out was when I said, Well, I Speaker 1: need to understand more about the Speaker 1: physiology of bones. Speaker 1: So I started reading about bones. Speaker 1: And it turns out that bones are

Speaker 1: the reservoir of calcium in the human Speaker 1: body. And when the human body needs Speaker 1: extra calcium, the bones give it up, Speaker 1: it sheds it. And it turns out Speaker 1: that. The shedding of calcium into the Speaker 1: blood supply to meet metabolic and Speaker 1: physiological needs is really very stable Speaker 1: over time. So, bingo. Speaker 1: That's the reason that most people on

Speaker 1: the planet have roughly the same amount Speaker 1: of glyphosate in their urine year round, Speaker 1: including in the winter when nobody's Speaker 1: spraying glyphosate, right? Speaker 1: Is because it's Immobilized in our bones Speaker 1: and as our bones shed calcium to Speaker 1: meet the body's needs, the glyphosate Speaker 1: catches a ride with the calcium and Speaker 1: moves back into the blood supply. Speaker 1: So that's what we now understand about

Speaker 1: how glyphosate is really ever present in Speaker 1: our bone marrow and our bone marrow Speaker 1: where all this elaborate cell division is Speaker 1: happening. And scientists have shown Speaker 1: clearly in vivo animal studies that the Speaker 1: glyphosate molecule can trigger a mutation Speaker 1: in hematopoietic stem cells, the precise Speaker 1: mutation that sets a hematopoietic stem Speaker 1: cell on the path to non hydroxyphoma.

Speaker 1: That the actual mutation to non-Hodgkin's Speaker 1: lymphoma. That the actual mutation is now, Speaker 1: there's a couple of them, has been Speaker 1: documented and scientists have now shown Speaker 1: in live animal studies that glyphosate can Speaker 1: cause that mutation. Speaker 1: So that's kind of, the dots are Speaker 1: all connected now, right? Speaker 1: So the question is, is there enough Speaker 1: glyphosate in In the human body that's

Speaker 1: flowing with blood into the body that's Speaker 1: flowing with blood into bone marrow into Speaker 1: contact with hematopoietic stem cells to Speaker 1: cause a problem. So, in my last Speaker 1: paper on glyphosate, which I worked on Speaker 1: for years into trying to understand all Speaker 1: this, I decided to do something very Speaker 1: unusual. I wanted to answer the question. Speaker 1: So, let's say a farmer had applied

Speaker 1: glyphosate. Roundup herbicide for six or Speaker 1: eight hours. And had a typical level Speaker 1: in their blood as reported in field Speaker 1: monitoring studies around the world. Speaker 1: We sort of know if you applied Speaker 1: glyphosate for six or eight hours in Speaker 1: a day, we have a pretty good Speaker 1: idea how much would be in your Speaker 1: blood right after that exposure episode. Speaker 1: So I calculated how many glyphosate

Speaker 1: molecules would be in the bone marrow Speaker 1: of a 70 kilogram person, an adult Speaker 1: person, that had applied Roundup for six Speaker 1: or eight hours compared to the number Speaker 1: of hematopoietic stem cells that are in Speaker 1: our bone marrow. That's a well known Speaker 1: number. It's in the literature. Speaker 1: And it turns out that there's somewhere, Speaker 1: my calculation, if I remember it

Speaker 1: correctly, it was somewhere between Speaker 1: 800,000 and 1.5 million glyphosate Speaker 1: molecules for every single hematopoietic Speaker 1: stem cell. Now, a hematopoietic stem cell Speaker 1: is much bigger than a glyphosate molecule, Speaker 1: but there's also hundreds of thousands of Speaker 1: them trying to get in. Speaker 1: And so that's the last piece Speaker 1: of the puzzle. How do we Speaker 1: understand and quantify the risk to

Speaker 1: DNA damage to hematopoietic stem cells Speaker 1: that starts aberrant cell growth on Speaker 1: the way to either leukemia or Speaker 1: non hydroxyphoma. So, one of the Speaker 1: reasons that I wanted to go Speaker 1: through this with you is that Speaker 1: this would not be known had Speaker 1: it not been for this litigation. Speaker 1: It was the fact. That I Speaker 1: had years to deeply research and

Speaker 1: try to connect all these pieces Speaker 1: of the puzzle together and an Speaker 1: opportunity to talk to top cancer Speaker 1: biologists who are also involved in Speaker 1: the litigation, who taught me about Speaker 1: hematopoietic stem cells and lymphocytes Speaker 1: and leukocytes. To a poetic stem Speaker 1: cells and lymphocytes and leukocytes, and Speaker 1: the way that glyphosate mutates DNA Speaker 1: that's associated with the risk of

Speaker 1: cancer. So, as I was doing Speaker 1: that, drawing on the insights that Speaker 1: the litigation was really opening up Speaker 1: to me and other people involved Speaker 1: in it, there were scientists around Speaker 1: all over the world doing this Speaker 1: research. And lo and behold, the Pieces Speaker 1: of the puzzle really have been put Speaker 1: together fairly tightly now. Speaker 1: And I don't, I'm absolutely convinced that

Speaker 1: given that almost everybody on the planet Speaker 1: now has glyphosate in their bodies and Speaker 1: we know it damages DNA, it's clearly Speaker 1: contributing to, in particular, blood Speaker 1: cancers, but probably other problems, you Speaker 1: know. Blood cancers, but probably other Speaker 1: problems. And we know definitely that Speaker 1: glyphosate is disrupting the microbiome in Speaker 1: the human GI tract, and that that's

Speaker 1: causing all sorts of problems from Speaker 1: developmental issues to neurological Speaker 1: issues to disruption of the immune system. Speaker 1: So, despite the fact that from a Speaker 1: traditional toxicology point of view, the Speaker 1: kinds of studies that EPA requires Speaker 1: pesticide manufacturers to do On all Speaker 1: pesticide active ingredients. Speaker 1: Glyphosate looks about as non toxic as Speaker 1: any major registered pesticide ever.

Speaker 1: Lo and behold, there are these other Speaker 1: things that current EPA testing Speaker 1: requirements don't get at, don't test for, Speaker 1: have no way of predicting that are Speaker 1: really at the heart of why glyphosate Speaker 1: and Glyphosate-based herbicides now have Speaker 1: become so important as a driver in Speaker 1: chronic health problems in the U.S. Speaker 1: and around the world. Speaker 1: I want to get to a conversation

Speaker 1: about how do you remediate from a Speaker 1: personal human health perspective. Speaker 1: I'm sure that's a question that many Speaker 1: people will have, but perhaps before we Speaker 1: dive into that, just on your closing Speaker 1: comment about Toxicology and the current Speaker 1: toxicology evaluations not not being Speaker 1: fitted for finding these types of systemic Speaker 1: issues, one of the questions that comes to Speaker 1: mind for me is: to what degree we probably Speaker 1: don't know the. I'm sure we don't know the

Speaker 1: answer, but when we look at glyphosate, we Speaker 1: now understand that it has a very Speaker 1: different toxicity. Speaker 1: Psychology profile from what we originally Speaker 1: thought. How probably how. Speaker 1: Profile from what we originally thought. Speaker 1: How likely is that to be true for a Speaker 1: broad range of other pesticides? Speaker 1: And we simply don't know because we Speaker 1: haven't studied them to the same degree Speaker 1: that we've studied glyphosate based Speaker 1: herbicides. What an easy question, Speaker 1: finally, Jim. It's absolutely certain that

Speaker 1: the same thing applies. Speaker 1: There's not one shred of doubt about that. Speaker 1: I wish that wouldn't have been Speaker 1: such an easy answer. Speaker 1: It's why we have to convince Speaker 1: the Congress, we have to convince Speaker 1: the public health community that we Speaker 1: have to redo our federal pesticide Speaker 1: law because it doesn't work anymore Speaker 1: to protect the American public from

Speaker 1: the chronic diseases that really are Speaker 1: contributing to both morbidity and Speaker 1: mortality in the U.S. Speaker 1: population. Bottom line, we have to Speaker 1: evaluate toxicity differently. Speaker 1: It's not about absolutely. Speaker 1: And the good news is that Speaker 1: there is a consensus emerging globally Speaker 1: about how to do it. Speaker 1: And I actually, I've got a Speaker 1: paper that I'm trying to get

Speaker 1: done and submitted that I've written Speaker 1: with some colleagues that explains how Speaker 1: the EPA needs to do it. Speaker 1: Explains how the EPA needs to Speaker 1: start doing this. It's going to Speaker 1: take a generation to do the Speaker 1: new science, to refine the new Speaker 1: testing protocols, and to understand how Speaker 1: to translate the results from the Speaker 1: new kind of testing that needs

Speaker 1: to be done into quantitative estimates Speaker 1: of public health risks so that Speaker 1: we know which pesticides used on Speaker 1: which crops in what ways are Speaker 1: actually contributing significantly to Speaker 1: adverse public health outcomes. Speaker 1: It is not in the cards Speaker 1: for regulators around the world to Speaker 1: just ban all pesticides. Speaker 1: It's going to happen. Speaker 1: So, the logical way to move forward

Speaker 1: is to identify those. Speaker 1: Few pesticides that are contributing most Speaker 1: significantly to adverse public health Speaker 1: outcomes and getting them out of the Speaker 1: food supply, stopping them from being Speaker 1: used. We know how to do that Speaker 1: now. And if we went about that Speaker 1: systematically over time, always looking Speaker 1: for the riskiest and driving it out Speaker 1: of the system, the overall outcome is

Speaker 1: going to be. Much less frequent and Speaker 1: less serious adverse public health Speaker 1: outcomes from farmers' use of pesticides. Speaker 1: That's what I'm devoting the rest of Speaker 1: my life to bringing about because it Speaker 1: is within reach now. Speaker 1: I'd like to have a conversation about Speaker 1: a few other active ingredients as well. Speaker 1: But before we shift to that, if Speaker 1: we have this quasi universal exposure to

Speaker 1: glyphosate and there is a reservoir or Speaker 1: reserve of glyphosate and glyphosate based Speaker 1: herbicides in everyone's bone and bone Speaker 1: marrow, leading to this constant release. Speaker 1: How do you bioremediate? Speaker 1: How do you remediate your own bone Speaker 1: system? And how do you get that Speaker 1: stuff out of your system? Speaker 1: And how do you prevent? Speaker 1: How do you avoid accumulating more? Speaker 1: Well, you eat organic food.

Speaker 1: That's absolutely critical. Speaker 1: Most of the exposure. Speaker 1: For the general population to glyphosate Speaker 1: is from the diet. And it's the Speaker 1: small grains, in particular wheat and oats Speaker 1: and edible beans that are treated with Speaker 1: glyphosate based herbicides as pre harvest Speaker 1: desiccants. That's where the exposure is Speaker 1: coming from for the general population, Speaker 1: for the most part. Speaker 1: Now, if you live in the Midwest,

Speaker 1: in the Southeast, where a lot of Speaker 1: glyphosate is used on row crops, there Speaker 1: could be glyphosate in your drinking Speaker 1: water. As well. But for the general Speaker 1: population around the world, it's the Speaker 1: diet. And the only foods where there's Speaker 1: significant glyphosate showing up in food Speaker 1: are the ones where glyphosate has been Speaker 1: used as a pre harvest desiccant. Speaker 1: And it's just so crazy.

Speaker 1: I think it's, I'm absolutely positive that Speaker 1: pre harvest desiccation doesn't account Speaker 1: for more than 5%. Of glyphosate use Speaker 1: in the United States. Speaker 1: Probably even less. Speaker 1: It's probably somewhere between two and Speaker 1: 3%. And if we just got rid Speaker 1: of that, it would probably eliminate 90% Speaker 1: of typical daily exposure to glyphosate Speaker 1: through the diet. That's gonna have a Speaker 1: enormous impact on getting glyphosate out

Speaker 1: the human body. Now, if somebody basically Speaker 1: Chose to predominantly eat organic food, Speaker 1: the glyphosate in bones is going to Speaker 1: be cleared in a matter of certainly Speaker 1: a year or two, and maybe in Speaker 1: months, but nobody's done that work to Speaker 1: understand how long it takes. Speaker 1: But there's, I think, really clear Speaker 1: evidence that for really any of the major Speaker 1: pesticides. That we're concerned about, if

Speaker 1: you eat organic food, you're going to so Speaker 1: dramatically reduce your exposures that Speaker 1: your body will clear itself in a matter of Speaker 1: months. So, this is a bit of a sidebar, Speaker 1: but I think it's important to interject Speaker 1: here for all of our listeners. Speaker 1: I wrote a blog post years ago about this Speaker 1: that you can look up, and we've had Speaker 1: continuing experience since then. Speaker 1: You can essentially desiccate a crop. Speaker 1: You can speed up the senescence and

Speaker 1: maturity of a crop dramatically by Speaker 1: providing flowable boron. Speaker 1: Boron accelerates sugar movement out of Speaker 1: the leaves into the fruits or seeds, and Speaker 1: you can eliminate the need for desiccant. Speaker 1: There's no money to be made in selling Speaker 1: boron, which is why this is not more Speaker 1: widely known and not more popular. Speaker 1: But you can. Eliminate the need for a Speaker 1: desiccant, or maybe a better way to say Speaker 1: this you can use boron as a maturity

Speaker 1: enhancer, as a senescence enhancer, and it Speaker 1: will do the same job as a desiccant. Speaker 1: But you get higher quality grain, higher Speaker 1: sugar content, test weight, protein Speaker 1: content, nutrient density. Speaker 1: You get this long list of positive Speaker 1: benefits from using boron, and it will Speaker 1: solve the same problem. Speaker 1: Yeah, isn't it amazing that so many simple Speaker 1: solutions like that just fall by the Speaker 1: wayside despite the fact that there's been Speaker 1: more than ample high quality science

Speaker 1: supporting the trifecta of benefits. Speaker 1: We could say the same thing Speaker 1: about soil health, couldn't we? Speaker 1: (Laughs) - Yeah. So one final Speaker 1: question. This has been such an Speaker 1: intriguing and interesting conversation Speaker 1: are developing our understanding of Speaker 1: glyphosate. But we also have already Speaker 1: A reasonably well developed understanding Speaker 1: of clorpyrifos and atrazine and paraquat. Speaker 1: What happens next?

Speaker 1: What's the pathway look like for Speaker 1: you and your perspective of things Speaker 1: that you're working on with these Speaker 1: compounds? Well, paraquat needs to be Speaker 1: banned worldwide, and it's pretty close Speaker 1: to being done. There are only Speaker 1: a handful of countries with significant Speaker 1: agriculture. That still allow any Paraquat Speaker 1: to be used. And of course,

Speaker 1: the US being the poster child Speaker 1: of having missed that train. Speaker 1: It is such a stain on Speaker 1: our Environmental Protection Agency for Speaker 1: their unwillingness to act to end Speaker 1: pre harvest crop desiccation uses of Speaker 1: glyphosate and Paraquat. Speaker 1: It would be completely irresponsible to Speaker 1: end pre harvest desiccation use with Speaker 1: glyphosate if they left Paraquat on

Speaker 1: the market and still labeled for Speaker 1: pre harvest desiccation, which it is Speaker 1: in the United States, which just Speaker 1: blows my mind that that's the Speaker 1: case. But one of the FIFRA Speaker 1: reforms, FIFRA is the Federal Insecticide, Speaker 1: Fungicide, and Rodenticide Act, that I Speaker 1: hope the Congress and a new Speaker 1: administration will give very serious

Speaker 1: consideration to. It's basically ending Speaker 1: pre harvest crop desiccation use of any Speaker 1: synthetic chemical. Speaker 1: It's just, it shouldn't be done because Speaker 1: when you apply a synthetic chemical on any Speaker 1: plant a week or two before harvest, you're Speaker 1: obviously going to have much, much higher Speaker 1: residue. Obviously, going to have much, Speaker 1: much higher residues in in the food, and Speaker 1: there's just no reason to do it. Speaker 1: Well, in the in the case of boron, could Speaker 1: do the same thing. Speaker 1: In the case of glyphosate, being a one,

Speaker 1: it's desired to bond to divalent cations. Speaker 1: And at that particular stage of plant Speaker 1: development and plant physiology, where Speaker 1: are the cations being transported to? Speaker 1: They're all being transported. Speaker 1: Into the seed, so you have large amounts Speaker 1: of nutrient mobility occurring where Speaker 1: nutrients and sugars and everything else Speaker 1: is moving into the seed and the glyphosate Speaker 1: is carried along with them. Speaker 1: I don't know that that's true in the case Speaker 1: of paraquat, but you're getting Speaker 1: essentially dynamic accumulation of Speaker 1: glyphosate in the seed when you do an

Speaker 1: application just before harvest. Speaker 1: Yeah, you know, I hadn't thought of Speaker 1: that. Thank you for connecting those dots. Speaker 1: I have a feeling there's lots of Speaker 1: dots that are known that we could Speaker 1: connect further. Well, Chuck, this has Speaker 1: been, I've enjoyed. Speaker 1: This conversation immensely. Speaker 1: I know that we've covered probably 1% Speaker 1: of what there is to discuss, but

Speaker 1: thank you for the overview. Speaker 1: Where can people go to learn more? Speaker 1: Well, there's a massive scientific Speaker 1: literature, there's a lot on The website Speaker 1: of the Heartland Health Research Alliance, Speaker 1: which is an NGO that I've been Speaker 1: involved with that is conducting a large Speaker 1: birth cohort study on herbicides in the Speaker 1: Midwest. That's hh ra.org. Speaker 1: And John, I assume your podcast has

Speaker 1: a homepage and you could. Speaker 1: We can share show notes, absolutely. Speaker 1: Well, I'll. I'll send you my peer Speaker 1: reviewed paper that explains. Speaker 1: What I went through earlier on the Speaker 1: podcast about how glyphosate in blood Speaker 1: moves into bone marrow, et cetera. Speaker 1: That's a published paper. Speaker 1: There's also been a major symposium in Speaker 1: April of this year in Seattle at the

Speaker 1: University of Washington on glyphosate and Speaker 1: public health risks and the Conclusion of Speaker 1: that team of international scientists that Speaker 1: came together. I was among the Speaker 1: participants, is also going to be Speaker 1: available soon. So I'll send you Speaker 1: information on that and you can post it, Speaker 1: and hopefully, more people will follow Speaker 1: down this rabbit hole. Speaker 1: Thank you. Thank you, Chuck. Speaker 1: Thank you for sharing your wisdom and

Speaker 1: experience. The team at AEA and I are Speaker 1: dedicated to bringing this show to you Speaker 1: because we believe that knowledge and Speaker 1: information is the foundation of Speaker 1: successful regenerative systems. Speaker 1: At AEA, we believe that growing better Speaker 1: quality food and making more money from Speaker 1: your crops is possible. Speaker 1: And since 2006, we've worked with leading Speaker 1: professional growers to help them do just Speaker 1: that. At AEA, we don't guess, we test, we Speaker 1: analyze, and we provide recommendations Speaker 1: based on scientific data, knowledge, and

Speaker 1: experience. We've developed products that Speaker 1: are uniquely positioned to help growers Speaker 1: make more money with regenerative Speaker 1: agriculture. If you are a professional Speaker 1: grower who believes in testing instead of Speaker 1: guessing, someone who believes in a better Speaker 1: more regenerative way to grow, visit Speaker 1: advancingecoag.com and contact us to see Speaker 1: if AEA is right for you.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Episode 197: What 2,000 Farms Reveal About Regenerative Agriculture with Jonathan Lundgren

    Nov 19, 20261 hr 6 minAudio

    Jonathan Lundgren is an agroecologist and entomologist with a PhD in entomology from the University of Illinois. He spent 11 years as a research scientist with USDA's Agricultural Research Service before founding the...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Episode 196: Getting Paid for Nutrition Instead of Yield with Eric Smith

    Nov 12, 20261 hr 13 minAudio

    Eric Smith is the cofounder and CEO of Edacious, a public benefit company that measures and reports the nutritional quality of food. He spent his earlier career at what he calls the intersection of economy and ecology,...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Episode 195: Your Soil's Water Reservoir Is Smaller Than You Think with Jerry Hatfield

    Nov 5, 20261 hr 14 minAudio

    Jerry Hatfield earned his PhD in agricultural climatology from Iowa State University and worked at UC Davis before spending his career with USDA's Agricultural Research Service. He led the National Laboratory for...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Episode 193: A Different Perspective on Fusarium with Heber Hall and Kirk Mersil

    Oct 22, 20261 hr 46 minAudio

    In this episode, commercial indoor producer Kirk Mersil shares his journey managing a 10,000-square-foot controlled-environment facility through an unexpected crop health crisis. Facing harvest losses exceeding 50% due...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Episode 192: Breaking Up Compaction with Roots Instead of Steel with Lloyd Murdock

    Oct 15, 20261 hrAudio

    Lloyd Murdock grew up in Oklahoma, earned his PhD in soils at Virginia Tech, and found his way to the University of Kentucky while stationed at nearby Fort Knox. He has spent more than four decades there as Extension...

    Credit the people on this episode