This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit nickestes.substack.com/subscribe
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_01This is Nick Estes here with the Red Scare Podcast. I'm just doing a quick live today to talk a little bit about this historic day, which is the 150th anniversary of the Battle of Greasy Grass. Nick Estes
SPEAKER_01This is sort of the brunt of a lot of jokes in Indian country and specifically Lakota people. We defeated Custer and Custer has become sort of this immortal enemy of ours that a lot of people talk about. There's a famous book called Custer Died for Your Sins by Vindeloria Jr. There's also... Various landscapes that have been named after Custer,
SPEAKER_01such as Custer State Park, which is within Hesapa, the historic territory, the ancestral territory of Lakota people, as well as 50 other indigenous nations. Nick Estes nickestes Red Scare
SPEAKER_01But also thinking about it kind of in a broader historical context in a war for the continent and what the United States called its Indian Wars. So I wrote an article today, I published it. It's very much in line with the festivities that are happening on the 150th anniversary of Custer's defeat in Lakota Victory at the Battle of Greasy Grass. But also thinking about the context of the 250th anniversary of the United States,
SPEAKER_01I think there's an argument to be made around the sort of Trumpian nature of Custer who was very much a charismatic, very arrogant figure who believed in westward expansion and the inevitability of indigenous decline. He was somebody who very much talked to newspapers, very much crafted an image of himself. He was very flamboyant. in his presentation to the media, very much so like a Trump, a very sort of flamboyant figure.
SPEAKER_01But Custer himself wanted to gift the United States a sort of military victory on the eve of it celebrating its centennial, a hundred years of existence. That may strike you as a little bit familiar, especially in this moment in time when Nick Estes
SPEAKER_01So I think it's kind of historic in this moment in time to think about the, you know, the idea of U.S. empire, but also looking at Custer's defeat at the Battle of Greasy Grass. And just to kind of give you some sort of context here, you know, that again, for those who are joining, that was 150 years ago today. There are many people who are gathering, thousands of people, of indigenous people who are gathering in Montana at the Custer battle site at the Battle of Greasy Grass to commemorate this event.
SPEAKER_01It is a date that has been sort of made a national holiday in Lakota and Oceti Chalkhoni territory as well as Cheyenne Arapaho territory. Nick Estes nickestes Red Scare
SPEAKER_01Nick Estes nickest is defending your homelands and it's creating this ideological idea
SPEAKER_01that these are outside invaders. In union organizing, they always say The Boss Is The Best Organizer Because Whatever The Boss Does If They Punish A Worker If They Fire A Worker It Will Galvanize Workers To Band Together Against The Boss Right And Perhaps The Colonizer Is The Best Organizer Of Indigenous Resistance Because Indigenous People Have To They Respond To These Incursions By Unifying Right Sometimes Obviously In Colonial Context A Lot
SPEAKER_01Of Indigenous Nations Especially Against Us who allied themselves with the colonizer and in fact Custer himself had several Crow Scouts who were traveling with him that day and according to some accounts those were the only bodies that were mutilated were these Crow Scouts and that they had left untouched the bodies of the slain soldiers including Custer himself and there's varying sort of interpretations of that but nonetheless Custer
SPEAKER_01hope to give the United States a decisive military victory over the Cheyenne, Arapaho, and Lakota alliance on the Northern Plains. It was meant to lock down the remaining frontier territory in the United States and conclusively win the nation's longest conflict, which was at the time the Indian Wars, which had been raging since the Nick Estes nickestes Red Scare
SPEAKER_01indigenous nations and committing acts of genocide during that war against primarily Haudenosaunee people who were resisting and had allied themselves with the British. And overwhelmingly, indigenous participation in the so-called Revolutionary War of 1776 was fought on the side of the British because they recognized the United States as a greater threat. And In the case of 1876 and the U.S.
SPEAKER_01War on Lakota people, that was a battle fought at the tail end of the United States' rapid expansion westward. in its attempt to seize more than a billion acres of indigenous territory. The first battles that the United States had with indigenous nations became sort of the bloody blueprint or architecture that set in motion this idea of constant warfare.
SPEAKER_01But instead of achieving victory, Custer himself suffered a humiliating defeat at the hands of Lakota, Cheyenne, and Arapaho forces. According to Cheyenne oral histories, a Cheyenne woman named Buffalo Road Woman actually knocked him from his horse. That day, the 7th Cavalry, which was his regiment, had lost 268 men, including Custer himself.
SPEAKER_01But I think putting this into a broader context, though, Custer Nick Estes nickestes Red Scare North Dakota and he led a uh a military train into the Black Hills because there was
SPEAKER_01the discovery of gold in in Haysapa at that particular time and it's kind of a fascinating his first stop was not actually in the Black Hills believe it or not he had heard through his indigenous sources that there were there was a power in this place um that is near like Ludlow South Dakota today in um the sort of Badlands dry area. and he had gone into that area looking for potential gold or resources that he could plunder.
SPEAKER_01But in fact, instead his soldiers just carved graffiti across the sandstone cliffs, much of which was kind of decorated with indigenous petroglyphs. And you can go there to this day and find the years of 1870s In the 1870s you can find the graffiti that Custer's men, the vandalizing of those petroglyphs in this area called Ludlow.
SPEAKER_01According to our oral histories, that was actually a place of immense power. and what they discovered later was that there was actually a large uranium deposits in that particular area and so there was an understanding at least by Lakota people that there were these resources and minerals that had power and I think they had an understanding of what uranium was maybe they didn't understand what radiation was but definitely later on when that place became mined it is an area
SPEAKER_01where there are sort of un tapped or uncapped uranium mines that still exist and that do leach radiation into the surrounding area but also into the groundwater but he didn't find anything there so he continued his wagon train into the Black Hills and in fact ended up kidnapping Lakota men and holding him hostage to secure his safe passage into the Black Hills and this was a common tactic that
SPEAKER_01That dates back to even Lewis and Clark in the early 1800s when they were making their way up the Missouri River or Mini-Shosheh that they had captured Lakota Sichangu people, my people their leaders or one of their leaders to actually secure their passage upriver because we wanted to collect a toll from them and saying you don't have the right to pass through our territory an exertion of sovereignty much in the same way that Lakota people didn't want Custer entering into this particular territory so
SPEAKER_01to secure his safe passage he ended up kidnapping an individual of course his military expedition confirmed the presence of gold there which led to a sort of gold rush an illegal gold rush that the The United States didn't do much to sort of curtail and Custer and the U.S. military was actually stationed there to uphold essentially or ostensibly the treaties that guaranteed or the treaty,
SPEAKER_01the 1868 Fort Laramie Treaty that guaranteed Lakota people a permanent homeland, you know, a permanent home in the area that is now known as western half of South Dakota, which included the Black Hills or Hesapa. And so What happens is Custer, you know, a lot of people, figures like Crazy Horse, Tashunka Witko, begin to resist this illegal mining operation. And the signers of the 1868 Fort Laramie Treaty mount a resistance.
SPEAKER_01They say, hey, this is violating this treaty. And so there's actually this split that sort of happens. There's those leaders who want to continue living free as Lakota people and not bound by the ill words and the false words of the U.S. colonizer and to resist and to maintain their sort of hunting lifestyle, their buffalo hunting lifestyle. Nick Estes nickestes Red Scare
SPEAKER_01Even though Crazy Horse was a resistance leader, he still had relations with other leaders of Lakota people who were not on the side of armed resistance against the United States government So anyways, instead of upholding the treaty and preventing white incursion into the Black Hills and the theft of gold Nick Estes
SPEAKER_01and oftentimes to spend times alone going on these kind of solo or small war party missions into the Black Hills and he began to kill miners, right? And then this sparked a sort of reaction. We see the same sort of thing like on the West Bank, right? Where you have a settler moving into a Palestinian territory illegally, right? And then and trying to provoke a violent reaction so that the IDF soldier who's standing right behind him will intervene
SPEAKER_01to defend this invader who's doing illegal activities. So this was essentially what Custer was doing at this particular time, is that he was retaliating against these people who refused on one hand to accept the illegal theft and occupation of the Black Hills, But also refused the confines of reservation life. And so he was there essentially to round up this recalcitrant band of Lakota people
SPEAKER_01who had allied with Cheyenne and Arapaho people to send them back to the reservation. And this is where you get the sort of figures, the very... famous figures such as Crazy Horse and Sitting Bull who were at this battle. And I want to read some sort of firsthand or oral history accounts of this. And I want to read it specifically from um this book called Sitting Bull His Life and Legacy which is by Ernie LaPointe who is the great grandson of Sitting Bull um you can see the cover of this here
SPEAKER_01and this is from a chapter where he is talking about um this uh this this vision that he was or this dream that he was granted um um Tatanko Iwatake who is known as Sitting Bull in English um Nick Estes nickestes Red Scare
SPEAKER_01More Lakota, Cheyenne, and Arapaho were arriving every day. They said they were guided there by the four-legged and the winged to find the camp.
SPEAKER_01The camp started moving south along the Rosebud River. They had traveled and camped for two days when they came upon a Cone Butte and the decision was made to camp beside it. They had an inipi, which is a sweat lodge ceremony, the first night, and some Cheyenne elders attended the inipi. Tatanko Iotake, or Sitting Bull, told of his vision. When he finished, the Cheyenne elders said they knew of this rock formation with the blue streak down the middle. It was a very sacred place to their people,
SPEAKER_01and it was just a little farther down the Rosebud River. They called it Deer Medicine Rocks. The next morning, Tatanko Iotake climbed to the top of the Kohen Butte, he filled his chinupo or his pipe, and made a commitment to Wakantanka that he would perform the Wiwong Wachipi at this sacred place. He also prayed and said he would offer a whole buffalo and a red blanket. So this is the vision that he had to hold this Sundance
SPEAKER_01to bring together Cheyenne Arapaho people.
SPEAKER_00And I'll read a little bit more about that in just a second. So this is after he began to have
SPEAKER_01Nick Estes nickes Red Scare His prayers through the eagle bone whistle. This was during the Sundance. His hunka brother, Jumping Bull, then began removing small pieces of flesh from Totaku Iotake's left shoulder. Jumping Bull continued until he had taken 50 pieces of flesh from each arm.
SPEAKER_01This is well known that he offered 50 pieces of flesh for both arms, or 100 in total. After about 30 minutes, Totaku Iotake's offering of a red blanket was completed. Bleeding profusely, Totalko Iotake rose and started to dance while gazing at the sun. The blood flowed freely down his arm. His feet, cut by the sharp gravel, left bloody marks on the ground. The Uwang Wachipi Wachasha continued his offering and his prayers. The sun sank below the horizon, but he danced on.
SPEAKER_01The next morning, he greeted the sun with the shrill of his eagle-bone whistle. He continued to dance ceaselessly, staring at the sun until noon. When his friend Black Moon ran to him and lowered his exhausted body to the ground. Tatanko Iotake spoke to Black Moon in muted tones. When the others came to attend Tatanko Iotake, Black Moon told the people his friend had had a vision. He said Wakantanka answered Tatanko Iotake's prayers.
SPEAKER_01Black Moon said his friend asked him to tell the people of his vision. As Satanko Iotake danced, gazing at the sun, a voice spoke to him. The voice told him to look just below the sun. When he did, he saw many long knives, or milahaska, which is our name for American soldiers, falling into camp. Nickestes Red Scare
SPEAKER_01The Lakota interpreted Tatanku Iyotake's vision as a prediction of a great victory over the forces of the wasichu, or the white people, who would not listen. Clearly, Wakantanka had spoken. The camp had grown quiet by this time. Grass for the horses was getting scarce and provisions for the people were running low. Scouts went in different directions to locate suitable pasturage for the horses and
SPEAKER_00to hunt game. Um... Nick Estes nickestes Red Scare
SPEAKER_01Custer assigned Captain Frederick Benteen 350 men and sent them to circle the west of the Lakota camp. So this is right after the Lakota and Cheyenne Arapaho had had the Sundance and Tatanko Iotake was given this vision, right? So people were in a state, you know, they were in a state of prayer, they're in a state of reverence, so to speak. He assigned Major Marcus Reno 150 men and ordered them to approach from the south.
SPEAKER_01Custer took the remaining 225 men to attack from the east. So this is a three-pronged attack. Reno was the first to engage the Lakota when he charged the Hunkpapa camp. The first volley from his troops killed Chief Gall's two wives and his two daughters. Nick Estes nickestes Red Scare
SPEAKER_01Reno ordered his troops to dismount at the edge of the tree line and form a skirmish line, standing next to his re-scout bloody knife. Reno prepared for the upcoming battle. Then a bullet from a Lakota rifle struck bloody knife in the head. Blood and brain splattered all over Reno's head and clothes. Dazed and horrified, Reno called for an all-out retreat back to the river to the top of the hill. There he waited for Benteen to reinforce him. Meanwhile, Custer led his 225 men under the cover of a deep ravine to the eastern edge.
SPEAKER_01Nick Estes nickestes Red Scare Nick Estes nickestes Red Scare
SPEAKER_01Titanko Iotake was preparing himself to join the battle. He was readying his favorite horse when his aged mother stopped him. She pointed out that he did not have to fight because he did not have anything more to prove to the people. She reminded him that he had two wives and small children to take care of. Since he was a mature man of 45 years, he could let the younger warriors prove their worth by protecting the camp and defending the people. So he actually ends up listening to his mother He doesn't,
SPEAKER_01you know, he stays back And tries to live, you know, another day But the Essentially From Sitting Bull's perspective You know, his vision was fulfilled Like these soldiers literally fell into camp And he says, you know, it was quickly that over The fact that Longhair Custer was present was unknown to Tonka Iotake or to any of the Lakota Cheyenne
SPEAKER_01or Arapaho warriors meaning they didn't know that Custer was actually in the attacking force you know he was they had no idea until after they had killed him essentially and identified his body so at the end you know when the fighting was over Tonka Iotake rode through the battlefield and observed the aftermath Nick Estes
SPEAKER_01So there were some people who ended up mutilating the bodies, and that was against the vision that Sitting Bull had. The last one I'll read is an account from a moving robe woman.
SPEAKER_01She actually fought in the battle of Little Bighorn. There were a lot of warrior women who fought alongside men. Oftentimes it was because their husbands or their brothers or perhaps their sons were killed in battle and they took up their place as soldiers within the ranks of Lakota people. and she writes or she says I'm going to tell you the greatest battle this is the fight against Pehehaska or General Custer's
SPEAKER_01who they called Long Hair Pehehaska she says I was several miles from the Hunkpapa camp when I saw a cloud of dust Rise beyond a ridge of bluffs in the east. The morning was hot and sultry. Several of us Indian girls were digging wild turnips. I was then 23 years old. We girls looked toward the camp and saw a warrior ride swiftly shouting that the soldiers were only a few miles away and that women and children, including old men, should run for the hills in the opposite direction.
SPEAKER_01Nick Estes Nick Estes nickestes Red Scare
SPEAKER_01So she talks about pushing them back in the defeat of Custer who she also didn't know was at the battle at the time and she talks about seeing the body of Longhair Custer Of course, we did not know who the soldiers were until an interpreter told us that the men came from Fort Lincoln, then Dakota Territory. The saddle blankets were the cross-saber insignia of the figure 7, which is the 7th Calvary.
SPEAKER_01Over 60 Indians were killed and they were brought back to the camp for scaffold burial. The Indians did not stage a victory dance that night. They were mourning their dead. Nick Estes nickestes Red Scare
SPEAKER_01Nickestes Red Scare a moving robe woman about sort of a young woman's perspective of fighting in that battle at the age of 23 after her brother was killed and taking up arms against
SPEAKER_01the United States government and so I just kind of want to end I just wanted to bring that up to folks you know this was just a kind of a history day to kind of revisit this particular history and I want to just sort of end by reflecting on you know a century later that the Supreme Court like ruled that the taking of the Black Hills which was eventually happened even though Custer was defeated the United States took the Black Hills extracted gold from it and
SPEAKER_01the Supreme Court later ruled that the United States had done so illegally and against in violation of the treaty and therefore that taking was unconstitutional Nick Estes nickestes Red Scare
SPEAKER_01Sitting Bull was later killed by his own people. Also shortly after this battle, I think it was two years after this battle, Crazy Horse was also killed by one of his own people. Sitting Bull was killed in the lead up to the Wounded Knee Massacre in December of 1890. Nick Estes nickestes Red Scare
SPEAKER_01and these were all wars that had never been declared right so you can render the outcome of these wars which is the plundering of indigenous lands illegal but you can't render um or call the wars themselves illegal, which I find really fascinating. This is something I've been thinking about recently. I just published a piece on the Substack that you're all encouraged to look at and thinking about this 250th anniversary of the United States and these sort of endless wars that have been engaged in that are literally just extensions of
SPEAKER_01the Indian wars that Nick Estes nickestes Red Scare executive legal briefs and talking about the justification for war.
SPEAKER_01The last time the Indian Wars were cited was actually by Trump himself in 2018 when the United States bombed Syria. But that all kind of goes back to this idea that and how the Indian wars today are weaponized and have extended to a global reach. And I think on Victory Day, we have to understand that not all is lost, right? US imperialism hasn't won the day. And the celebration of Victory Day against the US military demonstrates that
SPEAKER_01the Lakota nation's best days aren't necessarily behind it, but they actually remain in front of it. and I want you all to remember that as we go into this day and we kind of reflect on this history and thank you for listening to this kind of brief history lesson again the book that I had cited I read The Sitting Bull testimony from was Sitting Bull his legacy or his life and legacy by Ernie LaPointe who is the great grandson of Sitting Bull the other one was
SPEAKER_01by Moving Robe Woman and this is from an edited collection called Lakota Recollections of the Custer Fight, new sources in Indian U.S. military history. It's an edited volume. It's okay. It's mostly like what came in print material, but I just thought I would give those two perspectives from kind of two different people of the Lakota nation and their experiences at that particular time. So check out the The piece that's just on the Substack I just posted it today and also I just did
SPEAKER_01a collaboration with Rebecca Nagel featured on her new podcast First America you can check that out you can just go to firstamerica.info where we talk a lot about these things but thank you so much
On October 6, I presented a talk at the 2026 Nobel Conference hosted at Gustavus Adolphus College in St. Peter, MN. The theme of the conference was the Mississippi River. My talk centered the enduring legacy of...
In this episode of Red Scare, Sina and I discuss my recent article, “Ward Churchill: Free Speech Warrior or Pretendian?” We dive deep into the harms of Pretendianism and what it means for modern Indigenous sovereignty....
I joined Millennials Are Killing Capitalism for a discussion connecting the ICE invasion of Minneapolis to U.S. imperialism. This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access...
Vinny Dionne, from Indigenous Protector Movement, joined The Red Nation Podcast to discuss how the Native community in Minneapolis is organizing amid the ICE invasion. This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss...