Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Recruiting Conversations

Recruiting Conversations artwork

Anxiety Means You Care: Why Recruiting Still Feels Risky Even When You're Experienced

Feb 24, 20266 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

You've recruited dozens. Maybe hundreds. You know the scripts. You know the process. You understand the industry. So why does recruiting anxiety still show up? In this episode of Recruiting Conversations, we get honest about something even high-performing leaders rarely admit: recruiting is personal. And when something is personal, it can feel vulnerable. If you've ever hesitated before making the call or felt resistance before following up, this episode will help you understand why, and what to do about it. Episode Breakdown [00:00] The Real Question Why does recruiting anxiety show up even when I've been doing this for years? [01:00] Recruiting Is Personal You're not just filling a role. You're asking someone to consider a major life change. That carries weight. [01:45] Reason 1: You Care About People Leaders who lead with heart don't want to pressure or manipulate. That care is good. Unchecked, it can turn into hesitation. [02:15] Reason 2: The Stakes Feel Higher When top producers consider joining you, it matters. They're trusting your leadership. Perfectionism can creep in and create paralysis. [02:45] Reason 3: Past Rejection Leaves Scar Tissue Ghosting. Silence. Hard no's. Even experienced leaders carry recruiting wounds they never processed. [03:15] Reason 4: Your Standards Have Grown You're no longer talking to anyone. You're looking for culture carriers. And when the bar rises, the fear of missing it rises too. [03:40] Reason 5: Imposter Syndrome Never Fully Disappears Even successful leaders have days where the voice says: Who am I to invite them into this? That voice doesn't mean you're unqualified. It means you're human. [04:00] What Do We Do About It? Acknowledge it. Normalize it. Build systems that move you forward anyway. Confidence is not the absence of anxiety. It's the presence of clarity. Clarity about what you're building Clarity about your value Clarity about your outreach rhythm Clarity about why your leadership matters [04:45] Final Reframe If recruiting still makes your stomach flip, that's not weakness. It's evidence that what you're doing matters. Start the call anyway. Hit send anyway. Follow up anyway. The best recruiters don't wait to feel confident. They take action and let belief grow along the way. Key Takeaways Recruiting Anxiety Is Normal - Especially for leaders who care deeply High Stakes Create Emotional Weight - That doesn't mean you're not capable Past Rejection Can Linger Quietly - Process it instead of carrying it Raising Your Standards Raises the Pressure - That's maturity, not weakness Clarity Beats Confidence - Build systems that guide action even when emotions fluctuate Recruiting changes lives. It reshapes teams. It creates new futures for people. If it feels weighty sometimes, that's because it is. But don't let the weight stop you. Let it remind you that what you're building matters. Ready to Build a Recruiting System That Reduces the Pressure? If this episode resonated with you and you want help building a recruiting structure that replaces hesitation with clarity, let's talk. You can book time directly on my calendar and we'll walk through: Where anxiety is showing up in your recruiting rhythm What systems might be missing How to build a consistent, confident outreach cadence And how to scale recruiting without carrying the emotional weight alone Go to bookrichardnow.com and grab a time that works for you. You do not have to figure this out by yourself. Let's build a system that makes recruiting feel lighter, clearer, and more powerful.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Richard: So the big question is this, how do recruiting leaders like us who have 12 to 15 other job responsibilities win at this game of recruiting? How do we build a system that allows us to recruit effectively in a minimal amount of time while motivating recruits towards meaningful change? That is the question, and this podcast will give you the answers. My name is Richard Milligan, and welcome to Recruiting Conversations.

Hey everybody. Welcome back to Recruiting Conversations. I'm your host, Richard Milligan, and today we're getting real about something that even the most experienced leaders deal with. Why does recruiting anxiety show up? Even when I've been doing this a long time, this is a conversation I've had more times than I can count with leaders who've built successful teams, who've recruited dozens, even hundreds of people who know the scripts, know the process, know the industry, and yet they still find themselves hesitating.

To make the call procrastinating the follow up, feeling a little uncomfortable asking someone to explore a move, and the response is usually something like, I don't get it. I've done this before. I know how this works. Why does it still make me anxious sometimes? The answer, you're human. And recruiting is personal. Even though it's a business function, even though it drives growth, even though it's repeatable. Recruiting always involves risk. You're putting yourself out there, you're asking someone to consider a major change. You're stepping into someone else's story, and you're doing it in a

world where rejections, silence, and resistance are part of the process. Let's name a few reasons. This anxiety shows up even for high performing experienced leaders. First, you care about people. Leaders who lead with heart feel the weight of the conversation. You're not just trying to hit a number. You wanna have an honest dialogue. You want to add value, and sometimes that care turns into hesitation. You don't want to come across the wrong way. You don't want to feel like you're pushing or pressuring someone.

That's a good instinct, but if it's not checked, it can keep you from taking action. Second, the stakes are high. When you recruit someone, especially a top performer, especially someone who's trusted where they are, it feels significant because it is, you know that if they come, they're stepping into your leadership. They're trusting your word, they're risking. Their reputation. And if you've ever had someone come over who wasn't a fit or someone who didn't thrive, that can weigh on you.

You want to get it right, but perfectionism can create paralysis and that tension can show up as anxiety. Third past rejection sticks. It's amazing how many leaders carry around recruiting scar tissue. A few hard conversations, a few people who ghosted you, a few recruits who said no after you gave them everything. That stuff adds up, especially when you don't take time to process it. And even if it was years ago, even if you've moved on, that fear of being dismissed or misunderstood can still linger in the background.

Fourth, your standards have grown. Early in your leadership, you were probably willing to talk to anyone, but now you're more focused. You're looking for high caliber people. You want vision, fit, culture fit people who will stay and scale with you. And because the bar is higher, the fear of messing it up or wasting someone's time can grow. You hesitate. Not because you're unqualified, but because you've matured. You want your message to match the weight of what you're inviting someone into. Fifth imposter syndrome doesn't go away just because you're successful.

You might be experienced, you might have built something great, but there are still days where that little voice creeps in and says, who am I to ask this person to consider a move? What if I don't have enough to offer? What if they're doing better than me? That's normal and left unchecked. That voice will keep you quiet, even though your experience says you know how to lead. Your fear says Play small. What do we do about it? We acknowledge it, we normalize it, and then we build systems that help us take consistent action anyway.

Because confidence isn't the absence of anxiety. It's the presence of clarity. When you know what you're building, when you've clarified your value, when you have a rhythm for outreach and follow up, when you have a script actually sounds like you. And when you've done the inner work to know that your leadership matters, the anxiety gets quieter. It may not disappear, but it no longer leads. So if recruiting still makes your stomach flip sometimes, welcome to the club. It doesn't mean you're not good at this.

It means you care. It means you're growing. It means you're doing something that matters. Recruiting does matter. It changes lives. It reshapes teams. It accelerates growth. It gives people a new story to live in. So don't let the anxiety stop you start the call. Anyways, hit send. Anyways. Follow up anyways. The best recruiters I know don't wait to feel confident. They take action. They learn and they build belief along the way. That's it for today's episode of Recruiting Conversations. If this one resonated with you and you want help building a structure that

takes the pressure off of recruiting. So you can lead with more consistency. Reach out. I'd love to walk through it with you. Until next time, keep growing, keep showing up and keep leading forward. I'll see you soon. Want more recruiting conversations? You can register for my weekly email@fourcrecruiting.com. If you need help creating your own unique recruiting system, you can book a time with me@bookrichardnow.com. I.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Leadership Treats Recruiting Like a Line Item: 5 Moves to Get It Funded

    Nov 17, 202610 minAudio

    You're sitting down to map out 2027 right now, and at some point you have to walk into your leadership team and make the case for recruiting. Here's the problem most leaders run into. They walk in and ask for recruiting...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. The Recruit Who Works With Family: 5 Moves to Win Without a Fight

    Nov 10, 202610 minAudio

    You found someone you'd love to have, and they work with family. Maybe it's their dad's company, maybe their spouse is on the team, maybe a brother, a sister, an in-law. You can feel the extra weight on the...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. You End Full Days With an Empty Pipeline: 5 Moves to Stop

    Nov 3, 20266 minAudio

    You end the day exhausted, you worked hard the whole time, and somehow the one thing that actually grows your business, recruiting, never got touched. You weren't lazy. You were busy, even productive. You just spent the...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. The Poison Apple on Your Team: 5 Moves Before It Spreads

    Oct 27, 20266 minAudio

    You know the person I mean. Great numbers, maybe your best numbers, but the way they treat the team, the attitude they carry, the quiet undermining in the corners, it's costing you something that never shows up on a...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Your Team Wonders If You're All Talk: 5 Moves to Prove the Vision Daily

    Oct 20, 20269 minAudio

    You love painting the big picture for your team, and then you look at your calendar and your capacity, and the vision starts to feel like a fantasy you can't back up. So you either shrink the dream to something safe, or...

    Credit the people on this episode