Big box lenders are writing big checks, but that's not what's costing you top producers. In this episode of Recruiting Conversations, I break down how to protect your team from being poached by creating an environment where no amount of money can compete with your leadership, vision, and culture. If you've ever been blindsided by a recruiter offering a six-figure bonus to one of your LOs, this is the strategy episode you've been waiting for. Episode Breakdown [00:00] Introduction - The real threat isn't the bonus. It's the gap in belief that existed before it showed up. [01:00] Understand the Root Issue - Signing bonuses only work when your LO believes money will fix a deeper problem. [02:00] Strategy 1: Build a Leadership Rhythm - Stay connected weekly through 1-on-1s, vision check-ins, and personal coaching. [03:00] Strategy 2: Create Long-Term Clarity - Help LOs visualize what their future looks like under your leadership. [04:00] Strategy 3: Stay Curious When They Mention a Bonus - Don't panic. Ask good questions to understand the "why" behind the interest. [05:00] Strategy 4: Don't Lead With Counter Offers - Retain people because of shared mission, not short-term money matches. [06:00] Strategy 5: Build Identity Around Culture - When LOs see themselves as part of something rare, they won't chase a quick payout. [07:00] Strategy 6: Anchor With Belief - Vision, support, and belonging always beat a check if you lead from the heart. [08:00] Final Challenge - Connect with three LOs this week and have a purpose-driven conversation, not a production check-in. Key Takeaways Money Isn't the Real Motivator - The signing bonus just exposes gaps in connection, vision, or belief. Retention Happens in Rhythm - Regular check-ins, coaching, and conversation are your best defense. The Right People Don't Just Want More - They want meaning, leadership, and momentum. Don't Compete With Big Checks - Compete with clarity. Compete with connection. Play the Long Game - Build something worth staying for and let that be what your people align with. The best recruiters are playing chess, not checkers. And when you play the long game, you don't lose top talent to a quick check. Want help building a culture and system that attracts and retains the right people? Subscribe to my weekly email at 4crecruiting.com or book a session at bookrichardnow.com. Let's build a team that no one wants to leave.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
So the big question is this, how do recruiting leaders like us who have 12 to 15 other job responsibilities win at this game of recruiting? How do we build a system that allows us to recruit effectively in a minimal amount of time while motivating recruits towards meaningful change? That is the question, and this podcast will give you the answers. My name is Richard Mulligan, and welcome to Recruiting Conversations.
Hey everybody. Welcome back to Recruiting Conversations. I'm Richard Milligan, and today we are talking about one of the most frustrating and disruptive challenges facing recruiting leaders in the mortgage industry right now. How do I combat the poaching of my los from big box lenders offering unrealistic signing bonuses? You know the situation. You have built a solid team. Your people are producing, you are investing in culture, you are coaching, you are retaining. Then someone shows up with a check out of nowhere.
One of your los is approached by a recruiter from a national brand. They dangle a massive signing bonus, sometimes six figures, sometimes paid upfront and suddenly. The LO, who was loyal, who was happy, who was growing, starts to waver. And as a leader, you are stuck asking, how do I even compete with that? How do I keep my people focused? How do I protect my culture? How do I respond without becoming reactionary or resentful?
This is real. And today I want to help you shift your mindset. Sharpen your strategy and create a leadership model that actually inoculates your people from this kind of disruption. Because the truth is you cannot control what big box lenders offer, but you can control what your people believe. So let's start there. The root issue here is not the bonus, it is the belief. Assigning bonus only works when the LO believes that money will solve something. Maybe they are burned out, maybe they feel underappreciated.
Maybe they're comparing their comp to someone else. Maybe they are frustrated with ops, maybe they are feeling stagnant, or maybe they just do not feel seen. The bonus is just the trigger. The real issue is what was already brewing underneath. So the question is, what are you doing today to build belief before the bonus shows up? Let's talk about that. Retention is not built in reaction. It is built in rhythm. The leaders who keep their people are not the ones who offer counter offers. They're the ones who build relationship, who cast vision, who
coach consistently, who stay in the trenches, who speak to the identity and the potential of their people. If your los only hear from you, when something goes wrong, you are already behind. So the first strategy is to increase visibility. You need a rhythm of one-on-one connection. You need coaching calls, pipeline reviews, personal check-ins. Vision conversations, not just production talk, but purpose talk. Ask questions like, how are you feeling about the pace you are running?
What do you want your business to look like in 12 months? Where are you feeling stuck? What would make this season feel more aligned? What can I do to support you better? This kind of leadership builds loyalty because it shows you are invested in the person, not just the pipeline. Next, you need to cast long-term vision. The biggest weapon against short-term temptation is long-term clarity. If your los cannot see where they're going, if they cannot see how they are growing, if they cannot.
See what they're building. Then a big check looks like a shortcut. So show them the future. Help them build a two year roadmap, not just production goals, but lifestyle design, marketing, visibility, team structure. Personal growth. When someone sees their name on a plan, they're less likely to chase a bonus because they're already building something they believe in. Now, let's address the bonus itself. When an LO brings it up, you do not get defensive. You do not panic. You lead with curiosity.
You say, let's talk about it. What does that offer mean to you? What problem does it solve? What would it change? What would you lose by taking it? What are you not getting here that made this appealing? You are not trying to sell. You are trying to understand. And once you understand, you can lead. Sometimes the bonus is solving something real. Debt, burnout, lack of clarity. Sometimes it is solving something imagined. A feeling of missing out, a perception of value, a comparison game.
Either way, you have to re-anchor them and what matters. You might say, that number sounds big, but let's look at it over the next 24 months. Let's look at how your production is trending. Let's look at how your time is being spent. Let's look at your client experience. Let's look at your mental bandwidth. Let's talk about your family, your pace, your purpose. That bonus might give you a boost, but what does it cost you? You have to remind them. Leadership is not about the short game. It is about the long game.
Now, sometimes the conversation will still move toward the bonus, and you have to decide, will you counter, will you match? Will you release? Here's my take. You never wanna retain someone who is only staying for money. That is not a sustainable relationship. That is not leadership. That is leverage. And leverage breaks down when someone else pays more. Instead, you want to retain people who are aligned with your mission, who believe in your leadership, who trust your model, who see their future and your framework. So if someone is moving for money. Let them move.
Bless them, release them, celebrate them, and then double down on your culture because the people who stay are watching how you respond. And your leadership moment is not just in retention, it is in reaction. Now, let's talk about the long-term strategy. If you want to prevent poaching, you need to build identity. Your people need to see themselves as part of something rare, something that cannot be bought. Something that matters. That comes from community, from purpose, from shared values, from stories.
You need to share stories, often stories of impact, stories of wins, stories of growth, stories of resilience. You need to create moments, retreats, recognition, surprise, rewards, personal touches. You need to show them. We are not like every other company. We are not trying to be, we are building something different and you are a part of it. That identity becomes armor. It protects them from shiny offers because they know they're not just
producing, they are belonging. Lemme share a story from one of my clients. He had an LO who was approached by a national lender, big bonus, upfront cash, new title. The Lo, brought it to him, said he was considering it. The leader did not panic, he said. Let's talk it through. Let me remind you what we are building. Let me show you how far you have come. Let me share where I see you in 12 months and then do what
is best for you that lo stayed. Not because of money, but because of belief. Because when someone sees that you are not panicking, that you are still coaching, still vision, casting, still calm, they feel anchored. That is leadership. Let me wrap with this big box. Lenders will always offer big checks. They are playing a short game. They are trying to win with incentives. But you are playing a different game. You are building something real, something rooted, something
that multiplies over time. And if you want to keep your people, you have to lead their hearts. Not just their wallets. You have to be in conversation before the bonus ever shows up. You have to be casting vision before fear enters. You have to be building systems that reinforce culture. You have to be creating a rhythm that creates my 50 because people stay where they feel seen. People stay where they are growing people stay where their story is valued. People stay where the leadership is clear.
So here's your challenge this week. Pick three lows on your team. Reach out. Have a vision conversation, not about numbers, but about purpose. Ask them where they want to be in 12 months. Ask what makes this work worth it. Ask what would help them feel more supported. Then build from that. You'll be amazed what, what happens when you lead with belief instead of defense. That is all for today's episode. Go anchor your team. Go build long-term belief, and I will see you next time on recruiting conversations.
Want more recruiting conversations? You can register for my weekly email@fourcrecruiting.com. If you need help creating your own unique recruiting system, you can book a time with me@bookrichardnow.com. I.
You're sitting down to map out 2027 right now, and at some point you have to walk into your leadership team and make the case for recruiting. Here's the problem most leaders run into. They walk in and ask for recruiting...
You found someone you'd love to have, and they work with family. Maybe it's their dad's company, maybe their spouse is on the team, maybe a brother, a sister, an in-law. You can feel the extra weight on the...
You end the day exhausted, you worked hard the whole time, and somehow the one thing that actually grows your business, recruiting, never got touched. You weren't lazy. You were busy, even productive. You just spent the...
You know the person I mean. Great numbers, maybe your best numbers, but the way they treat the team, the attitude they carry, the quiet undermining in the corners, it's costing you something that never shows up on a...
You love painting the big picture for your team, and then you look at your calendar and your capacity, and the vision starts to feel like a fantasy you can't back up. So you either shrink the dream to something safe, or...