What if your entire market has fewer than 100 LOs? Is hiring a recruiter still worth it? In this episode of Recruiting Conversations, I walk through the exact framework for determining whether a recruiter is the right move in a small market. I cover the systems, mindset, math, and sequencing that make it work, and share a real-world story of one leader who turned 85 LOs into 9 hires in 12 months. This isn't about headcount. It's about mastery, clarity, and building a system that multiplies your time. Episode Breakdown [00:00] The Question - Is it worth hiring a recruiter if I only have 70 to 100 loan officers in my area? [01:00] Why Market Size Is the Wrong Lens - It's not how many LOs exist, it's how many are aligned and how strong your system is [02:00] Visibility vs. True Recruiting - Reaching out once is not recruiting. You need consistent, structured engagement [02:30] Real Story: Midwest Leader With 85 LOs - After mapping the market, he realized very few LOs had received consistent value or follow-up [03:30] Question 1: Is Recruiting a Top 3 Priority? - If not, a recruiter becomes an admin, not a multiplier [04:00] Question 2: Do You Have a System? - CRM, avatar, cadence, scripting, follow-up, all must be in place before hiring [04:45] Question 3: Are You Recruiting for Fit or Volume? - In small markets, alignment is more important than raw production [05:20] Question 4: Can You Tell a Clear Story? - If your recruiter can't communicate your value clearly, you'll lose to comp-focused competitors [06:00] The Math That Makes It Work 3 key hires = $60K/month revenue $720K annually More than enough to justify the hire [06:30] What a Recruiter Should Be - Not a cold caller, but a connector who runs value plays and books warm calls [07:00] When to Delay the Hire - If your system is messy or undefined, wait. Build first. Then hire [07:30] Real Results - The Midwest leader built a system first, hired a recruiter second, and scaled to 9 hires in a "too small" market [08:00] Action Steps Build a clean LO list Document your recruiting message Create a 90-day value-add follow-up plan Prove it works Hire a recruiter to run the top of funnel [09:30] Closing Thought - You don't need more market. You need more mastery. Strategy wins, not size Key Takeaways It's Not About Market Size. It's About Market Mastery - A recruiter in a small market works if the system is already built Recruiting Must Be a Top Priority - No hire can replace your ownership of the vision Build First, Hire Second - Document your message, process, and rhythms before bringing someone in Focus on Alignment Over Volume - In a small market, values and vision matter more than raw numbers Your Story Wins the Game - When your message is clear, your recruiter becomes a magnet, not a salesperson A small market doesn't limit your impact. Lack of clarity does. Build the system. Then scale it with the right partner. Want help building your recruiting system so a recruiter can multiply it? Subscribe to my weekly email at 4crecruiting.com or book a strategy session at bookrichardnow.com. Let's help you win in any market no matter if it's big or small.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Richard: So the big question is this, how do recruiting leaders like us who have 12 to 15 other job responsibilities win at this game of recruiting? How do we build a system that allows us to recruit effectively in a minimal amount of time while motivating recruits towards meaningful change? That is the question, and this podcast will give you the answers. My name is Richard Milligan, and welcome to Recruiting Conversations.
Hey everybody. Welcome back to Recruiting Conversations. I'm Richard Milligan, and today we're tackling a question I've heard from dozens of market leaders over the years, especially from small or mid-size cities who are trying to figure out how to scale their growth. It goes something like this. Richard, is it worth hiring a recruiter when I only have 70 to 100 loan officers in my area? This is a very real question and it deserves a thoughtful answer because on the surface it might seem like a numbers game.
You think, well, if I only have 70 loan officers within driving distance, and half of them are happy where they're at, is it really worth investing in a full-time recruiter? What you're really asking is. Can I justify this hire? Will there be enough traction? Can I get a return on this investment? So today I wanna walk you through exactly how to think about this decision. We're gonna look at it through the lenses of strategy, psychology, systems, and math, and I'll share some stories and coaching conversations
that shed light on what works and what doesn't in smaller markets. Let's start with a bigger truth. The size of your recruiting opportunity is not just about how many people are in the market. It's about how well you understand that market and how strong your systems are. You can be in a market with 70 loan officers and struggle, or you can be in that same market with the right strategy and dominate it. It's not about market size, it's about market approach. Now, let me give you a principle that I, I teach all my leaders.
You don't need dozens of wins. You need a few strategic wins that build momentum, credibility, and visibility. Let me give you an example. One of the leaders I coached a few years ago was in a smaller, uh, Midwest city. I think there were about 85 loan officers total in that metro area. He was the producing manager for a national IMB and had always handled recruiting himself. He'd made a few good hires over the years, but it was slow going.
He was frustrated, tired, and wondering if bringing on a recruiter would help, but he kept saying, Richard, I just don't think there's enough meat. I think we've already talked to most of these people. We've sent emails, we've done the coffees. I don't know if there's enough to warn a recruiter. So we did something simple. We built a visibility map. We looked at how often he had actually followed up with those 85 loan officers . In the past six months, how many had received value? How many had heard his vision?
How many had seen social proof from his team? How many had been nurtured beyond the first conversation? The answer was clear. Very few. He had reached out, sure, but he hadn't truly recruited them. There's a big difference between being known and being considered. There's a big difference between making a call and running a system. So let's get practical. Here are the key questions you need to answer before deciding to hire a recruiter in a small market. Question one. Is recruiting a top three priority in your business?
If it's not, no recruiter will solve your problem. Hiring a recruiter is not outsourcing recruiting. It's building a machine you intend to lead. If you are not personally invested in the vision, the message, the strategy, and the follow up, a recruiter becomes just another admin and you won't get traction. But if recruiting is core to your growth strategy, if you know that bringing in two to four key hires in the next 12 months would change everything, then a recruiter becomes a force multiplier.
Question two, do you have a system to support the recruiter? A recruiter in a small market needs structure? They need clarity. They need scripting. They need a CRM. They need templates, a pipeline, a cadence for follow up. If you just just say, go get us, some people, they'll, they'll burn out. They'll guess they'll chase people in circles. But if you say, here's our avatar, here's our value prop, here's our cadence, here's the warm list we've built, here's how we measure success.
Now you've set them up to win. Question three, are you recruiting for fit or for volume? In a small market, you can't recruit based on production alone. You don't have the numbers to play that game. You have to recruit based on alignment. That means you are looking for people who believe what you believe, who want the kind of culture you've built, who are frustrated by the gaps you can fill, who want to be led in the way you lead. That requires a deeper conversation. That requires storytelling, that requires persistence.
A recruiter helps you run those plays more consistently. question four. Can you tell a clear story in the market? The number one tool your recruiter needs is a compelling story. What are you building? Why does it matter? Who is it for? What makes it different? What do people experience when they join your team? If you can't answer those questions, the recruiter can't sell the vision. They'll end up defaulting to comp and rates and perks, and that's where you lose the game. If you've clarified your story, if you've articulated your culture, if
you've documented your onboarding, if you've captured wins from your team, now your recruiter is showing up with proof, not pitch. Let's talk about the math. If there are 100 LO's in your market, how many do you really need? Do you need 10? Do you need five? Do you need three key hires in the next year? If your revenue per lo is 20,000 a month and you bring in three aligned producers, that's 60,000 in monthly lift over a year.
That's $720,000 in top line revenue that absolutely justifies the cost of a recruiter even in a small market. The key is that the recruiter can't be a cold caller. They have to be a connector. They're running value plays. They're building relationships. They're feeding warm leads into your calendar. You're showing up to cast vision, not chase interest. Now let's talk about sequencing. One of the biggest mistakes I see leaders make is hiring a recruiter
before they've built the system. If you're CRM is a mess, if your messaging isn't clear, if your own follow up is inconsistent. If your onboarding is clunky, then don't hire the recruiter yet. Um, build the system first. But once the system is in place, once you've proven that your recruiting blueprint works, then a recruiter is what helps you scale it. They bring consistency, they bring structure. They buy back your time. Let's go back to that leader in the Midwest. He finally hired a recruiter, but only after we built the system.
We scripted everything. We segmented the market. We built a 90 day playbook. We created a list of 80 loan officers ranked by alignment, not just production. And we built a rhythm where he would talk to three to five warm leads per week, and the recruiter handled all follow up and outreach. Guess what happened? Within 60 days, they had their first hire. Within six months, they had added four people. Within 12 months, they had nine new hires in a market that was too small.
They didn't grow 'cause the market got bigger. They grew because their system got better. And that's the mindset shift I want to give you today. You don't need more market. You need more mastery. You don't need more data. You need more depth. You don't need more people. You need more precision. In a small market, every interaction matters. Every follow up matters. Every story you tell matters, and a recruiter helps you keep showing up. When most people quit after one call, lemme give you some action steps. Step one, build a clean list of every LO in your area.
Segment it. Prioritize based on alignment, not just numbers. Step two, document your recruiting message. Why do people join your team? What do they get here? They can't get elsewhere? How do you cast vision? Step three, create a 90 day follow-up plan. Phone, text, email, video, social, handwritten notes, not just chase messages, but value ads. Step four, run the playbook yourself. Book calls, cast vision, track results, prove the system works.
Step five, bring in a recruiter to run it with you. Let them manage the top of funnel. Let them handle, nurture. Let them feed you. Warm calls. Now you're not guessing. You're leading, you're scaling. Let me close with this. Recruiting in a small market is not about size. It's about strategy. It's about story. It's about showing up consistently when others don't. Hiring a recruiter in a market of 70 to 100 los is not only possible, it can be one of the most impactful hires you ever make, but only if you do it with a system.
Only if you lead it. Only if you see recruiting as a strategic machine, not a hopeful activity, you can win in your market. You just need a plan, a partner, and a process. That's all for today's episode. Go lead with vision. Go recruit with purpose, and I'll see you next time on recruiting conversations. Want more recruiting conversations? You can register for my weekly email@fourcrecruiting.com. If you need help creating your own unique recruiting system, you can book
You're sitting down to map out 2027 right now, and at some point you have to walk into your leadership team and make the case for recruiting. Here's the problem most leaders run into. They walk in and ask for recruiting...
You found someone you'd love to have, and they work with family. Maybe it's their dad's company, maybe their spouse is on the team, maybe a brother, a sister, an in-law. You can feel the extra weight on the...
You end the day exhausted, you worked hard the whole time, and somehow the one thing that actually grows your business, recruiting, never got touched. You weren't lazy. You were busy, even productive. You just spent the...
You know the person I mean. Great numbers, maybe your best numbers, but the way they treat the team, the attitude they carry, the quiet undermining in the corners, it's costing you something that never shows up on a...
You love painting the big picture for your team, and then you look at your calendar and your capacity, and the vision starts to feel like a fantasy you can't back up. So you either shrink the dream to something safe, or...