Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Recruiting Conversations

Recruiting Conversations artwork

The Bait and Switch That's Costing You Producers: 5 Moves to Fix It

Jun 2, 202611 minAudio

Here's the summary rewritten in Richard's voice, speaking directly to the listener. You're growing, which means you're recruiting. But every time you go hard after new talent, this quiet fear shows up. Are you telling your best people they're replaceable? So you slow down. You recruit with one hand on the brake, and both your growth and your retention suffer for it. In this episode I want to flip that tension on its head, because recruiting and retention aren't competing priorities. They're the same skill pointed in two directions, and I'm going to hand you a five-move framework I call the Inward Playbook so you can win at both at once. Episode Breakdown [00:00:53] The Tension Every Recruiting Leader Feels Growth requires recruiting, but the second you go hard after new talent, that fear shows up that you're telling your current team they're not enough. So you recruit with one hand on the brake, and that's exactly why both your growth and your retention suffer. [00:01:25] The Twenty-Six-Year Marriage Principle I've been married to Leah for twenty-six years, and it's not because I was a good dater. It's because I never stopped courting her. The pursuit didn't end at the wedding. The pursuit became the marriage. And the same thing is true for the team you lead. [00:01:53] The Bait and Switch Most of us recruit like a great date and then lead like a flat partner. We pursue a producer hard, we cast vision, we make that person feel like the most important talent in the market, and then the moment they sign, we disappear into operational mode. About three to four months in, that producer realizes the person who recruited them isn't the person they work for. They won't always say it out loud, but they feel it, and they start answering the phone when your competitor calls. [00:02:43] The Framework: The Inward Playbook Whatever makes you compelling to a recruit on the outside, take that same energy and point it inward at the people you already have. Because if we're awesome externally and average internally, we can expect to lose our people. [00:03:15] Move 1: Cast the Vision Out Loud When your team constantly hears where you're going over the next one, three, and five years, recruiting stops feeling threatening and it starts feeling necessary. They get that adding people is how the vision actually gets built. But when your team never hears the vision, recruiting feels random, like you're chasing instead of building. [00:03:52] Move 2: Court the Team You Already Have Retention isn't about perks, it's about connection. Are you having consistent one-on-ones? Do your producers feel like you understand their goals? Do they know exactly how they fit into the next phase? Take the same pursuit you'd give a brand new recruit and turn it around and give it to the producer who's been with you for three years. When people feel seen, they don't feel replaced by growth. They feel like they're part of it. [00:04:20] Move 3: Make Recruiting a Team Sport When you get seven people involved with a candidate, that candidate is 71% likely to join the organization. So bring your team into the process. Tell them the kind of person you're looking for, ask for referrals, let your best people meet the recruit. And here's what's interesting, your best people tend to attract more people just like them. That's how culture scales. [00:05:01] Move 4: Recruit Up, Never Down When you recruit the right way, it raises the level of the team, it doesn't threaten it. Back in 2015 I sat down and looked at the prior year, and anybody I'd added that year grew their business by 32% on average. Growth isn't a threat to your current team. Growth is the rising tide. So the question is never am I recruiting too much, it's am I recruiting the right people. [00:05:40] Move 5: Name It and Put It on the Calendar First, name it out loud. Tell your team the truth, that you're going to keep growing and bring in strong people, and at the same time you're committed to helping every one of them grow inside of this. That kind of transparency removes the tension, because now nothing feels hidden. Second, protect it on the calendar. You can't spend all your time recruiting and expect retention to take care of itself, and you can't spend all your time managing and expect growth to show up on its own. You need rhythms, and when those rhythms are consistent, nothing gets neglected. [00:06:27] Why It Works People don't leave because you recruited. They leave because the version of you that recruited them disappeared. We're all wired to notice when attention we used to have goes away, and that drop gets felt way more sharply than the absence of attention we never had in the first place. So when you stop courting your team, it doesn't register as neutral, it registers as loss. And that's also why involving the team lands at 71%. Belonging isn't one relationship with the leader at the top, it's a web of relationships across the whole organization, and the more threads there are, the harder it is to walk away. [00:08:02] Your Small Win Tonight Take out a piece of paper and write down three things you do during recruiting that you don't do for your current team. Maybe it's the energy you bring to the call, maybe it's how clearly you cast the vision, maybe it's just how often you reach out. Pick one and do it for a current producer before you go to bed tonight. One text, one call, one conversation. [00:08:43] Three Bigger Moves This Week Write a team-level vision that names what each of your producers personally gets out of the next three years, and share the rough draft even if it isn't perfect yet. Put three questions at the top of your next team meeting and answer them out loud before anything else, where have we been, where are we now, and where are we going. Then build yourself a one-page retention playbook, the same way you'd build a recruiting playbook, just aimed inward. Key Takeaways Recruiting and retention aren't competing priorities. They're the same skill pointed in two directions. The bait and switch isn't about pay. It's about the experience of being pursued disappearing the moment your producer signs. Cast the vision out loud and recruiting stops feeling like a threat, it starts feeling like the plan your team is part of. Get seven people involved with a candidate and they're 71% likely to join, because belonging is built on a web of relationships, not a single thread to you at the top. Recruit up, never down. Growth is the rising tide that lifts your current producers, an average of 32% in my own numbers. People feel a loss of attention far more sharply than they ever felt its absence, so staying consistent is what keeps them. You can't recruit all the time and expect retention to handle itself, or manage all the time and expect growth to show up on its own. Protect both on the calendar. If you want help building a retention playbook that lets you recruit aggressively without losing the team you've got, reach out. Visit bookrichardnow.com and grab time on my calendar, and we'll think through it together. And if you'd rather build it live, I host a biweekly working lunch where we put this kind of thing together in real time. The next one's this Friday, June 5th at 12:00 PM Eastern, and you can RSVP here.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Richard: So the big question is this, how do recruiting leaders like us who have 12 to 15 other job responsibilities win at this game of recruiting? How do we build a system that allows us to recruit effectively in a minimal amount of time while motivating recruits towards meaningful change? That is the question, and this podcast will give you the answers. My name is Richard Milligan, and welcome to Recruiting Conversations.

Hey, everybody. Welcome back to Recruiting Conversations. I'm your host, Richard Milligan, and today I want to answer a question that almost every recruiting leader feels, but very few say out loud. How do I keep recruiting aggressively without making my current team feel like they're not enough? Because here's the tension. You know, growth requires recruiting. You can't just maintain, you've gotta expand. But every time you go hard after new talent, this quiet fear shows up.

Am I telling my best people they're replaceable? And so you slow down. You recruit with one hand on the brake, and both your growth and your retention suffer for it. So here's what I want you to walk away with today. Recruiting and retention aren't competing priorities. They're the same skill pointed in two directions. And once you see that, the fear goes away, and both of them get stronger. So here's a real-life analogy for you. I've been married to Leah for twenty-six years, and I've had to figure some

things out over those twenty-six years. Here's one of them. If I'd only been a good dater, if I'd pursued her hard at the beginning and then gone flat once she said yes, we wouldn't have made it twenty-six years. The reason we're still married is that I never stopped courting her. The pursuit didn't end at the wedding. The pursuit became the marriage. Now here's why I'm telling you this. Most leaders recruit like a great date and then lead like a flat partner. They pursue a producer hard. They call, they cast vision, they make that person feel like the most important

talent in the market, and then the moment the producer signs, the leader disappears into operational mode. The calls stop, the vision talk stops, the producer who felt courted now feels managed. And about three to four months in, that producer realizes the person who recruited them isn't the person they work for. That's a bait and switch. They won't always say it out loud, but they feel it, and they start answering the phone when your competitor calls. We don't usually think of recruiting as courtship, but that's exactly what it is, and the leaders who keep their people are the ones who never stop

courting the team they already have So here's the framework I want to give you today. I call it the inward playbook. The idea is simple. Whatever makes you compelling to a recruit on the outside, you take that same energy and you point it inward at the people you already have. Because if we're awesome externally and average internally , we can expect to lose our people. One of the things I work on with leaders is literally building out a retention playbook, and what they find is that it's not that

distant from a recruiting playbook. So let me give you five moves. Move one, cast the vision out loud, not just the activity. When your team constantly hears where you're going over the next one, three, and five years, recruiting stops feeling threatening and it starts feeling necessary. They get that adding people is how the vision actually gets built. But when your team never hears the vision, recruiting feels random, like you're chasing instead of building.

So ask yourself, does my team actually know why we're growing? Because when they do, retention gets stronger, not weaker Move two, court the team you already have. This is the marriage principle in practice. Retention isn't about perks, it's about connection. Are you having consistent one-on-one conversations with your current producers? Do they feel like you understand their goals? Do they know exactly how they fit into the next phase? When people feel seen, they don't feel replaced by growth.

They feel like they're a part of it. The same pursuit you give a brand new recruit, turn it around and give it to the producer who's been with you for three years. Move three, make recruiting a team sport. Most leaders silo themselves. It's me, myself, and I. I'm the recruiting team. But the data says that when you get seven people involved with a candidate, that candidate's seventy-one percent likely to join the organization. So bring your team into the process. Tell them the kind of person you're looking for.

Ask for referrals. Let your best people meet the recruit. Now, growth is something you're doing together instead of something that's happening around them. And here's what's interesting. Your best people tend to attract more people just like them. That's how culture scales Move four: Recruit up, never down. When you recruit the right way, it should raise the level of the team, not threaten it. Your current producers should feel like they're surrounded by stronger thinkers and higher standards, and that creates energy.

And recruiting uplifts the people you've already got. I've watched it in my own numbers. Back in twenty fifteen, I sat down and looked at the prior year, and I noticed that anybody I'd added that year grew their business by thirty-two percent on average. Growth isn't a threat to your current team. Growth is the rising tide. So the question is never am I recruiting too much. The question is, am I recruiting the right people? Move five: Name it and put it on the calendar. Two parts here. First, name it out loud.

Tell your team the truth. We're gonna keep growing. We're gonna bring in strong people, and at the same time, I'm committed to helping every one of you grow inside of this. That kind of transparency removes the tension because now nothing feels hidden. Second, protect it on the calendar. You can't spend all of your time recruiting and expect retention to take care of itself, and you can't spend all of your time managing and expect growth to show up on its own. You need rhythms, time for recruiting outreach, time for one-on-ones,

time for developing the team. When those rhythms are consistent, nothing gets neglected Now let me tell you why this works, because I don't want you to just run the plays. I want you to understand them. People don't leave because you recruited. They leave because the version of you that recruited them disappeared. Think about what actually happened in that bait and switch. Nothing changed in the producer's pay. What changed was the experience of being pursued. We're all wired to notice when attention we used to have goes away,

and that drop gets felt way more sharply than the absence of attention we never had in the first place. So when you stop courting your team, it doesn't register as neutral. It registers as loss This is also why involving the team lands at 71%. Belonging isn't built by one relationship with the leader at the top. It's built by a web of relationships across the whole organization. Seven people involved isn't seven sales pitches, it's seven threads tying a

person to the group, and the more threads there are, the harder it is to walk away. That's true for the recruit you're chasing and is just as true for the producer you already have. And raising the standard works because recruiting at its core is a transference of energy and passion. Strong people raise the standard. A higher standard creates energy. That energy improves the culture, and a stronger culture improves retention. It compounds, which is the whole point of today.

Done right, recruiting and retention aren't pulling against each other. They're feeding each other So here's your challenge, and I want you to start today, not someday. Your small win for tonight is this. Take out a piece of paper and write down three things you do during recruiting that you don't do for your current team. Maybe it's the energy you bring to the call. Maybe it's how clearly you cast the vision. Maybe it's just how often you reach out. Write down three of them, then pick one and do it for a current producer

before you go to bed tonight. One text, one call, one conversation. That alone starts closing the gap that makes a producer feel managed instead of pursued, and that gap is exactly what makes them pick up the phone when your competitor calls. Then this week, I want you to run three bigger moves on the team you already have, and I'll tell you what each one does for them First, write a team-level vision that names what each of your producers personally gets out of the next three years and share the rough draft with

them, even if it isn't perfect yet. Don't hand them the corporate vision. Nobody stays for that. People stay when they can see what's in it for them. So when a producer can picture their own three-year payoff, they stop being somebody else's recruiting target. Second, put three questions at the top of your next team meeting and answer them out loud before anything else. Where have we been? Where are we now? Where are we going? Vision isn't a poster on the wall. It's a baton you hand off in every meeting. When your team hears it on a rhythm, growth stops feeling

like a threat and starts feeling like the plan they're a part of Third, build yourself a one-page retention playbook, the same way you'd build a recruiting playbook, just aimed inward. Write down how often you'll connect with each producer, what you'll talk about, and how you'll keep showing them they're seen. Because if you're awesome external and average internal, you lose people. The leader who stays as compelling on the inside as they are on the outside is the one who keeps their team when the market gets shaky. Do the small win tonight, run those three this week, and you'll feel the

difference in how your people show up. Keep courting the team you already have. That's it for today's episode of Recruiting Conversations. If you want help building a retention playbook that lets you recruit aggressively without losing the team you've got, reach out. I'd be glad to think through it with you. And one more thing before you go, I host a biweekly working lunch where we get together and build this kind of stuff in real time, and the next one's this Friday, June 5th at 12:00 PM Eastern.

You'll find the RSVP link in the description, and it'll add that one plus all of our other 4C recruiting events right to your calendar. Until next time, keep building, keep growing, and keep leading with intention. I'll see you soon want more recruiting conversations? You can register for my weekly email@fourcrecruiting.com. If you need help creating your own unique recruiting system, you can book a time with me@bookrichardnow.com. I.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Leadership Treats Recruiting Like a Line Item: 5 Moves to Get It Funded

    Nov 17, 202610 minAudio

    You're sitting down to map out 2027 right now, and at some point you have to walk into your leadership team and make the case for recruiting. Here's the problem most leaders run into. They walk in and ask for recruiting...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. The Recruit Who Works With Family: 5 Moves to Win Without a Fight

    Nov 10, 202610 minAudio

    You found someone you'd love to have, and they work with family. Maybe it's their dad's company, maybe their spouse is on the team, maybe a brother, a sister, an in-law. You can feel the extra weight on the...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. You End Full Days With an Empty Pipeline: 5 Moves to Stop

    Nov 3, 20266 minAudio

    You end the day exhausted, you worked hard the whole time, and somehow the one thing that actually grows your business, recruiting, never got touched. You weren't lazy. You were busy, even productive. You just spent the...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. The Poison Apple on Your Team: 5 Moves Before It Spreads

    Oct 27, 20266 minAudio

    You know the person I mean. Great numbers, maybe your best numbers, but the way they treat the team, the attitude they carry, the quiet undermining in the corners, it's costing you something that never shows up on a...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Your Team Wonders If You're All Talk: 5 Moves to Prove the Vision Daily

    Oct 20, 20269 minAudio

    You love painting the big picture for your team, and then you look at your calendar and your capacity, and the vision starts to feel like a fantasy you can't back up. So you either shrink the dream to something safe, or...

    Credit the people on this episode