This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit recoveringcatholic.substack.com/subscribe
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_00We're live. This is so fun. Welcome, everybody. Happy Wednesday. Paul, how's your family doing? What's going on in the Fahey household?
SPEAKER_01Oh, we are scrambling because we're in the process of moving soon. So there's like a whole list of cleaning that we have to do and somehow managed to keep five kids from like... We're like, guys, once we clean, it has to stay clean for... a relative amount of time.
SPEAKER_00You may not take the crayons out after we clean. When I put this magic eraser away, no one touch anything.
SPEAKER_01How about you?
SPEAKER_00Well, I mean, I hate to be the person who's like, I hate daylight savings time because I feel like everybody is complaining about daylight savings time right now, but I have never felt this crazy, I think, in my life. Like, the level of not sleeping that is happening in my house is... It is not. It's insane. So we've had... I think we're on about a three and a half week stretch of kids in our bed every night. Kids waking up in the middle of the night every night.
SPEAKER_00And then kids waking up at like 4.45 in the morning every morning. Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I was fine with daylight savings time until I had kids. And then having kids is the worst.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, because when you're single, it's like fall back. Great. Extra hour of sleep. For me, that's awesome. And when you have kids, you're like, all right, we need to do like a nine-day ramp up to this thing. We're going to like taper your sleep back an hour. And it's just insane. So we're adjusting and it's tough. And also, I don't know what the daylight situation is in Michigan, but here in Minnesota, it's like... It's it's pretty tough. I remember when I lived in Ohio, I lived in Columbus for a couple of years, and I remember noticing that there was more daylight.
Like we got about a half hour extra on each end just because of where we were laterally.
SPEAKER_00And yeah, it makes a difference.
SPEAKER_01It's dark at five o'clock in this time of the year.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. Yeah, it's tough. It's tough. We need to get we got our happy lights. Well, okay. We're here. We're going to talk about Delixie Tay tonight. I'm excited to be here with Paul Fahey, who I feel like he should really be the host and the champion of the night because this was really his idea. And he's got all the best thoughts. But we're here together to talk about pope leo's exhortation on love for the poor which was released
uh november 9th is that right it was early november about a month ago um yeah i it was signed in the beginning of october on the feast of saint francis and then it was released yeah
SPEAKER_00sorry yeah my months are bleeding together that's what's happening So, yeah, early October and here we are about a month later and we've all had some time to read it, kind of process it, think about it a little bit. Paul has done some great writing on it. So we thought we would just come on here and have a little chit chat. And then if if there are questions from any of you who are joining us live, we'd love to see those in the chat. Paul and I will be monitoring that and just seeing kind of
what's coming out. If there's thoughts or questions or topics you'd like to hear us address tonight,
SPEAKER_00please drop those in the chat and we will try to get there. For those of you who don't know both of us, my name is Sarah Carter. And I am the author of Recovering Catholic on Substack and the Popelio Weekly on Substack. So Recovering Catholic is kind of a, it's like my, I guess my intellectual drop box. I write essays on questions about times of transition and difficult questions in the church. It's for people who are kind of going through
times of change and growth and who need kind of new language around the old concepts.
SPEAKER_00And that's a project that started a couple of years ago. Paul and I talked about that on his podcast a couple of weeks ago. So if you're curious to learn more about that, I would go listen to his podcast episode. And then the Popelio Weekly, which comes out every Monday morning and just is a little... quick dive analysis on something that Pope Leo did that was interesting in the last week. And I'll let Paul introduce himself and tell you all a little bit about what he's doing here on Substack.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. For any of my followers here, go check out Sarah's Substack. She had, well, the article we talked about for the podcast was, I'm forgetting the title, but it was on evangelization. And it was like, Just one of the best explanations of evangelization from someone who... was was like it was clear to me reading it for the first time this is someone deeply steeped in the thought of pope francis um i mean i've
read so much pope francis i can like smell it out um and uh yeah it was it was so good so sarah's stuff is definitely worth reading um i'm i'm paul fahey i run the third space
SPEAKER_01Substack the third space podcast i'm mental health counselor in michigan and i do workshops and resources about addressing spiritual abuse in in the catholic church um I have five kids. We're moving. That's my life. I'm breaking my rule. I've had a rule since I've been recording things on the internet,
SPEAKER_01which goes back to the pandemic, which is to always wear a collared shirt. But I broke that rule. Sure. Just so I could wear this Magnificat shirt just for the exhortation tonight.
SPEAKER_00I love it. I love that. You know what? We're live. We're casual. I'd be lying if I said I'm wearing jeans right now. I've got my sweats on. We're hanging out. It's fun. It's casual. Cool. Yeah. So we're going to we've got a little Paul's got a little tea. I've got a little red wine. We're going to talk about deluxe tea. We're going to just have a little conversation. And again, for those of you who are just joining, drop your questions or anything you'd like for us to address in the chat. And we'll try to we will get to that. There's like we've got a small enough group here.
SPEAKER_00We can we can get your questions. And I don't know, Paul, do you want to say anything about we do have a virtual tip jar tonight? That's like a totally optional thing. But do you want to say anything about that, Paul? Yeah, so if you want to throw a tip at Sarah and I, we'll split all the tips.
SPEAKER_01And that's at my Venmo, which is at Catholic Third Space. And it should have my logo on it. Just because we do this for fun, but we also don't only do this for fun. We have kids and we have spouses that we have to justify the time we put into this too. So that would be helpful.
SPEAKER_00I did tell Will. I mean, I don't know if I'm going to make a lot of money tonight. No, I'm just kidding. It is funny to be like, yeah, I'm going to go downstairs and go on the internet for an hour.
SPEAKER_03Have fun.
SPEAKER_00We'll see. Enjoy bedtime. Yeah, no, it's good. Okay. So let's talk a little bit about the exhortation. So like I said, this came out early October. It's Pope Leo's first official teaching document of his papacy, which is significant. It kind of gets our eyes on that. We're curious. What's he going to say? What topic is he going to take on? How is he going to be different? How is he going to be similar to Francis?
And just like with Francis, when he became Pope, he inherited some texts.
SPEAKER_00So when Pope Francis became Pope, he inherited a partial encyclical that Pope Benedict XVI had been writing called Lumen Fide, The Light of Faith. And Francis finishes Lumen Fide and publishes it under his name. Similarly, we have some kind of draft that gets left behind by Pope Francis. How much of a draft? We don't know. How complete is it? We don't know. How much of the rest of it did Leo write? We just don't really know. We don't have clear answers to that. But what we do know is that Pope Francis started the draft of
Delexite as a sequel
SPEAKER_00to an encyclical, right, Paul? Yeah. Called Delexite Nos on the sacred heart of Jesus and the divine and human love of Jesus. So we have de Lexi Nos, which is released before Pope Francis dies. Pope Francis dies, we get Pope Leo, and then Pope Leo completes de Lexi Te as a follow-up to de Lexi Nos, and he publishes it under his name. Yeah, go.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, to jump in with that, I mean— Okay, it's been a long time since I've read Lumen Fide, but if I remember correctly, it didn't sound like Francis. It very much read like Benedict, especially in comparison to Francis's first document that was his own Evangelii Gaudium that came out a handful of months after that. Yeah. This, this document, Adlexité, I mean, I've read a lot of Pope Francis,
SPEAKER_01and there were parts that felt like Francis, but a lot of it didn't. Like, my assessment was, this was very much Leo's document. I mean, he took Francis's draft, but... Yeah. And I've heard commentators like, oh, yeah, like Leo was kind of stuck with this, that this wasn't really like this was important to Francis. So he's like doing the legacy of Francis a favor. And I'm like, no, this I believe this topic of the preferential option for the
poor is something
SPEAKER_01Leo's deeply invested in. And this seems to be coming from him as much or more than coming from Francis. Yeah, I'm glad you said that because I feel very similar about this document. There were so many parts of it that felt very much, you know, like I hear Francis here.
SPEAKER_00That feels very clear. But yeah, you kind of toggle into these sections where it kind of it feels like a new voice. I'm thinking of the section on Augustine, particularly which like, you know, that's that's cheating. Yeah. And obviously, Pope Leo wrote the section on Augustine. But there are other parts of the text, too, where it just feels like there's it feels like a different speaker. And so I would be inclined to think that, yeah, this wasn't like a very this wasn't a complete draft.
SPEAKER_00And I think reporting is that Leo had a pretty heavy hand in it, that he did a lot of editing, that he added a lot of things. Yeah. So it certainly bears Francis's fingerprints, but it is definitely giving us some insight into Leo and his priorities and his voice and the sort of way that he speaks to the church. So right off the jump...
SPEAKER_00I don't know. Maybe we should just go really like we'll just buzz through like an overview. So it's five sections long. Let's do it. We'll go really, really quick. OK, because like I want to hope that some of the folks here joining us have read this document. So five sections. It's 200. How many paragraphs is it? 121. Yeah, it's small. Yeah, it's very short.
SPEAKER_01Which is also a sign that it's from Leo and not Pope Francis.
SPEAKER_00I know, Francis. Loquacious. He had a way with many, many words. I read an article or I saw a headline titled The Many, Many, Many, Many Words of Pope Francis. No, that was funny. He is definitely verbose. So anyway. Okay. So five sections. We have chapter one, a few essential words. This is pretty standard papal document fair, where you just kind of get like, we're setting the table. Here's the context.
SPEAKER_00Here's why I'm writing this. Lots of interesting stuff in that section that I hope we talk about. Chapter two is basically like theological foundations for love of the poor. It's called God Chooses the Poor. And he goes through like, here are the kind of main theological convictions that we have as Christians that orient us towards our view of the poor. Yeah.
SPEAKER_01And this section in particular is not only deeply charismatic, right? Like it's very much rooted in like what is the good news? Like what is God's character and what's the good news that flows from that? But it's also deeply Christological. Like this document has, as much as it's a moral exhortation, it is a deeply theological document grounded on the person of Christ.
SPEAKER_00Very much. Yes. Yep. We'll put a bookmark in that because I definitely want to come back to that. Then we get chapter three, basically like a historical survey of the history of the church and many witnesses to the church's preferential option to the poor, including, I just want to know, a lot of women, which I think is interesting, who So he kind of goes through history and talks about the early church and then just kind of chronologically highlights a bunch of different figures
in Christian
SPEAKER_00history all the way up into the modern period. Very interesting section. I don't know if I've ever seen a survey style thing like this happen in a teaching document before. I don't know if you had the same thought, but...
SPEAKER_01It's usually, if I'm remembering correctly, it's usually scripture, sometimes specific church fathers or specific saints. But this was like, it seemed to me he was trying to make the historical case. The church has always been on the side of the poor. Yeah. Here's the threads from Christ onward.
SPEAKER_00Yep. Yep. It's really fascinating. Really interesting. Yeah. And at first when I was reading that section, I was like, oh, like, I don't know. I got a little bit like, oh, we're going to read. It's going to be like reading a history textbook and I'm like getting a little bored. And but by the end of that section, I was actually finding myself really edified and really called on like, wow, OK, there is this kind of like chorus of witnesses throughout the church's history. And that is powerful to see that just kind of laid out like that. And he really makes the case.
SPEAKER_00I think he makes the case really well.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I think a key point at the end of that section that I'll jump into later is he spends several paragraphs, more paragraphs than I think than any other section, talking specifically about the theology about the poor coming from the Latin American church, post-Vatican II Latin American church. Over 10% of the document is specifically expounding on and drawing from Latin American theology.
So his theological framing for the present isn't only shaped by Vatican II,
SPEAKER_01and he says that explicitly, but it's more specifically shaped by the reception, interpretation, and lived reality of Vatican II in Latin America.
SPEAKER_00Yes, super important point. This was another reason, I don't know, this is totally a speculation. But this is another reason why or another section that I really felt showed Leo's pen, a paragraph 89 specifically, where he's talking about the conferences of the Latin American bishops. And he's he's talking about Medellin and Puebla and Aparecida and really saying, like, I am indebted to these conferences.
to this work that the Latin American bishops has done as someone who lived in Peru
SPEAKER_00for many years. I really have this like debt to this. Well, what does he say? I am greatly indebted to this process of ecclesial discernment, which Pope Francis wisely lay. And I mean, to me, that just said like, yeah, that's Leo, because I don't know if Francis would have felt the need to sort of like rehash that again, because he's talked, I mean, yeah, the Latin American conferences are just like, they're so woven into Francis that he almost doesn't even really like make it explicit anymore. So I thought that that was really important when we saw that in
Deluxe Itay,
SPEAKER_00because not only is that showing like okay this is leo but it also he's really like kind of putting his stake in the ground on saying like this is the way that i see things this is the way that i see the church this is where i see us going and i we i i really think we have to pay attention to that because that's going to give us a lot of information about what to expect from a leonine papacy going forward because if he sees If he sees the church and if he sees evangelization and the
church in the modern
SPEAKER_00world through the lens of the work of the Latin American bishops, that has really significant implications that are exciting, I think.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. As a part of that, too, a part that felt like Leo was paragraph 98, he draws specifically from Ratzinger as head of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith and Ratzinger's critique of liberation theology. But the section that he pulls is very much a defense of the preferential option for the poor. Yeah. So there seems to be a...
SPEAKER_00And he's almost saying like, look, there was a legitimate critique of liberation theology that needed to be issued. But the reason why it came up in the first place is legit, is a legitimate reason.
SPEAKER_01And it felt like a... We're going to move beyond that. Because the church has moved beyond that. You look at Apresita, which happened in the early 2000s, that Ratzinger attended, and that Bergoglio, I think, was the head of, or at least a leader in.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, main writer for the Apresita document. And then Evangelii Gaudium was essentially the apperceded document brought into the
SPEAKER_01Universal Magisterium. And so much of Francis's Magisterium was. And now Leo in this document, that it also felt like the Magisterium's hashed this out. We don't need to be threatened by this theology coming out of Latin America anymore.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, that's a great point. Totally agree. I thought that section was super interesting too. Okay, yeah. So section four... A History That Continues. This was a really interesting section where Pope Leo basically goes through the development of the church's social doctrine, starting with Rerum Novarum. Yeah, go ahead.
SPEAKER_01I jumped ahead. I thought the liberation theology was in the last one.
SPEAKER_00No, no, no, it's okay. No, it's all good. Let's just, let's, you know, we're casual here, but... No, it's an important point too. So we have section four, which just basically talks about, yeah, the development of the church's social teaching from the beginning of the 20th century up to Vatican II. And then he kind of like slows down a little bit to take just a... just to linger a little bit longer over the papacies of John Paul II, Benedict XVI, and Francis.
SPEAKER_00And then at the end of that section, he kind of dives right into the conferences of the Latin American bishops and the specific themes that have come out of that work that he thinks are important and crucial for the church today. And those themes are two. So one, structures of sin, which we just, it's so interesting because we take a lot of these things for granted now, but they really are like, we owe such a debt of gratitude to these conferences in Latin America.
SPEAKER_00And I didn't realize that until like less than a year ago. It's amazing. And then the poor as subjects of evangelization, not objects of evangelization. So those are the two sort of themes. Anything you wanted to jump in there on?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, so he names those two as headers, but then mixed in is the need to be evangelized by the poor, that it's not just that we as Christians ought to serve the poor, and it's not that because we're Christians we ought to serve the poor, it's that we, in a very real way, encounter christ in the poor and need to be evangelized by christ through the poor and the church needs to be renewed through the uh by the poor
and then the other theme that was throughout the entire document that i think is really what the document is about like it's not just about the poor it's about the preferential option for the poor which explicitly came out of latin america as well yeah
SPEAKER_00And then finally, we have chapter five, which basically just kind of wraps it up and reiterates the principles that have sort of guided us through the whole document. He ends with an exhortation to almsgiving, which I think is really interesting. And kind of just speaking about almsgiving as like a spiritual action that sort of disposes us well in these areas. So there we go. There's the outline of the document. Paul, can I throw it back to you a little bit?
And I would love to hear from you about what you like about this document and what
SPEAKER_00you think the biggest or like what your biggest takeaways were from it.
SPEAKER_01So I went into it expecting, um, a really strong, a really strong moral exhortation to care for the poor, uh, and the marginalized in the world. Um, I mean, that's, that was throughout Francis's pontificate and so many of his addresses. Uh, it was really explicit in a fertility. Um, that's what I was expecting. And, um, That was definitely present, and I don't want to dismiss the moral exhortation part of this.
SPEAKER_01But the part that really surprised me was how much this proposal, this doctrine on the preferential option for the poor... If we take that seriously, how much that shapes our theology, how much that shapes who God is, how much that shapes our understanding of the church, how much that shapes our understanding of the church's mission in the world, and how much that has to shape my actions individually—
SPEAKER_01that really surprised me. And I mean, for, for weeks after I read this, like I kept going back to it as like, yes, this is the Catholicism that I love.
SPEAKER_03Hmm.
SPEAKER_01And some of that was like more critical of like, this is what I don't see in my church, in my church local, in my diocesan church, and then also in the national church. It's like, I'm not seeing this.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. But then in the more positive sense, it's like, oh, this is why I'm here. Like, this is why I stay. Because this vision of God and this vision of the world and what my purpose is in the world and our purpose is in the world, this is beautiful. This is compelling. And I felt evangelized by it. Like, I felt like the Kerygma was proclaimed to me through this document. In a way I wasn't expecting because I was expecting a moral exhortation.
SPEAKER_01So yeah, I think that was maybe my biggest takeaway and one that ended up being and still is the most fruitful in the weeks following reading this.
SPEAKER_00You know, I'm thinking about, I'm like, I can't help but just ask as you're saying that or like ask myself why it is that this is so not the experience of so many Catholics. And why is it that Francis and now Leo have felt the need to rehash this and like really like re, I don't know, like re-catechize the whole church on this as, as like love for the poor and solidarity with the poor as part
of our faith.
SPEAKER_00And I don't really know the answer to that, but I I've lingered over um this section it's paragraph 11 here and I feel like this is a great diagnosis by Leo of what's happening at least I see this happening I see this happening in myself I see this happening in other people so like this isn't I mean like I was convicted by this personally but I think there's macro issues too so I'll just read this um
The illusion of happiness derived from a comfortable life pushes many people towards a vision of life centered on the accumulation of wealth and social success
SPEAKER_00at all costs, even at the expense of others, and by taking advantage of unjust social ideals and political economic systems that favor the strongest. Thus, in a world where the poor are increasingly numerous, We paradoxically see the growth of a wealthy elite living in a bubble of comfort and luxury almost in another world compared to ordinary people. And this was the first thing that I read in this document that really kind of made me stop. It struck me.
SPEAKER_00And like I said, I think that's a pretty accurate and penetrating diagnosis of what's going on, at least in the developed world in the church. I can't help but think of the ideas of the globalization of indifference that Pope Francis always talked about. We have this globalized world where... we become numb to the suffering of other people we aren't moved by it we aren't touched by it it feels so far away from us like ironically and kind of paradoxically as we have the whole world in our pocket on our
phone we somehow feel
SPEAKER_00less true solidarity with our fellow human beings and are more inclined to just sort of dismiss them. And it makes me also think of the throwaway culture, that whole idea that we get into this mentality where I only want things insofar as they're useful to me. And when they're not useful to me, I throw them away. And that stuff, like it begins with things, right? Like we have too many things. We have so much money and stuff that we don't know what to do with it.
SPEAKER_00And And as it becomes unuseful to us, we throw it away. And that mentality inevitably trickles into our relationships with other people. We start seeing them as you're inconvenient to me. You're bothering me. You ask something of me that I don't want to give. And my response to that is I need to get rid of you. And if I can't get rid of you, I can at least just ignore you. I can just find a way to distance myself from you. And not sort of have to be confronted by you, if that makes sense.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Yeah. There's a line. I'm going to butcher it. There's a line in Pope Francis's book, Let Us Dream, that came out after Fratelli Tutti. That was kind of a commentary on Fratelli Tutti.
SPEAKER_00Yes, that book was great.
SPEAKER_01Francis was talking about how the technocratic paradigm, the throwaway culture, how that... I'm going to butcher the quote. It was something like... It allows us to do everything we can to avoid the imposition that another person's dignity puts on me. And I really loved that because as a parent, I'm very acutely aware of the imposition that other people put on me.
SPEAKER_01And I'm also acutely aware of how, as a parent, embracing that imposition has changed me, um, in really fundamental and really positive ways. Um, but yeah, we, we have this desire as you articulated it to like, um, I don't want to be uncomfortable by the reality of other people's suffering.
SPEAKER_03Yeah.
SPEAKER_01I would rather just, just avoid it. I think too, as, as you were talking earlier, something that something that struck me even even more i think even deeper than the desire for the uh comfort and the accumulation of wealth even more fundamental than that i think is the desire for security There's a letter from Dorothy Day,
SPEAKER_01and I think she was critiquing a particular Franciscan community. And she was critiquing them for the way they lived out their vow of poverty. So she was commenting on this evangelical council of poverty. And she said that the heart of it, the heart of the vow of poverty is... living in a state of precarity. So this word precarity being related to precariousness. So I think of like standing on the edge of a cliff feels precarious.
SPEAKER_01She's like, the heart of the vow of poverty is That I have what I need. This is my words, not hers. That I have what I need for today. And after today, there's a cliff. And I don't know if I'm going to have what I need for tomorrow. And there's something in my mind that resonated with me personally is the opposite of precarity is security. And even if I'm not chasing after comfort and pleasure and the accumulation of goods...
SPEAKER_01So much of my energy is spent chasing after security. Security from, you know, financial collapse, health collapse, etc., etc. But the reality is, life is precarious. Even if I have all of the things that can make me as secure as possible, I could die tomorrow. A family member could die tomorrow. Life is precarious.
So I can either spend all of my energy seeking after security my entire life, or there's a particular kind of freedom to just embracing the reality of precarity
SPEAKER_01and not pretending that I can protect myself from it. So I think there's something there. Even deeper than the search for comfort and pleasure, but the search for security that the church's understanding of poverty that this document challenges.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. I think a key thing with that, too, is the precarity that you're talking about. is like a precondition of actually being in relationship with god and i think that's that's one of the reasons why wealth and riches are such a spiritual danger because they give the illusion of security sufficient that i don't need anybody and
if yeah if i don't need other people then i sure as hell don't need god you know
SPEAKER_00like i i've got what i need i'm good But precarity kind of forces you into relationship. It forces you into human relationship because you can't do it on your own. But it's also, it disposes you to actually be in like loving relationship with God and to depend on him. And that's ultimately living in reality. And I think that that's a really, so I'm thinking too of, I love this section on Jesus, the poor Messiah. This is paragraphs 18.
through 23 and leo kind of he talks about how i mean there's a lot here there's so much theology um and leo's also saying oh yeah jesus was also poor and we can tell he was poor because of these things that happened in the gospels and they didn't
SPEAKER_00have a lot of money and he lived as a carpenter and Mary and Joseph brought the two turtle doves or, you know, all of these kind of circumstantial things in his life that give us hints that they didn't have a lot of money. And I was sort of thinking to myself as I was reading through this, like, yeah, it's actually, it's fitting that Jesus was poor, like in his humanity, that he didn't have a lot of money, that they didn't have a lot of material means, and that we see these external conditions of poverty in the life of Jesus.
SPEAKER_00But at the end of the day, the external conditions, the material poverty, the manger, the turtle doves, all of that, those really are just signs. They're almost like sacraments of something that's happening on a deeper level, which is the existential poverty of God, the self-emptying of God.
SPEAKER_00like water, blows to the lowest point, that that is who he is, that he falls to the lowest place that he can go and enters into this deep solidarity with us in our poverty, and that that's who Jesus is, and that's who he is, and that's how he saves us. And I think this is, um, hopefully I'm getting at kind of like a key point for you when
you talk about like the theology and the sort of like framing up of this issue of poverty and how it
SPEAKER_00shapes everything. Like for me, this is, this is like the golden kernel of this document, this idea that we don't have this sort of like precious view of poor people where we're like, Oh, the poor people, we, we want to be nice to them and sweet to them and help them, um, But that it comes from this knowledge of who God is, that God kind of is, I don't know, he is this self-emptying poverty for us,
SPEAKER_00for our sake. And so when we encounter our own poverty... And when we encounter the poverty of others, we are meeting God in that, in that lack, in that poverty, because that's where he is, because he meets us in that. And I just think that's really important to sort of, like, dispel this maybe, like, tendency that we have towards, like, being really precious and sweet over all of it. Like, this is a really important theological claim, and it, like— fires our motivation to love other people and to serve the poor.
SPEAKER_00It's not in like a make the world a better place kind of a way. It's this real like, I don't know, it's like more visceral than that, if that makes sense.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Yeah, there's, I just want to read whole sections. I'm going to read paragraph 16, which I think really is like the thesis of the entire document, paragraph 16. Leo says, God is merciful love. And his plan of love, which unfolds and is fulfilled in history, is above all his descent and coming among us to free us from slavery, fear, sin,
SPEAKER_01and the power of death. So just that sentence, we can unpack. But we have this vision of God as... God isn't a judge. God isn't a distant creator. God the Father isn't just filled with wrath because of our sin and he has to lash out in some way.
SPEAKER_01God's desire, well, his identity is merciful love. And his desire is to descend to the lowest place to free us from slavery, fear, sin, and death. This is the proclamation of who God is. And the Leo continues. He says, addressing their human condition with a merciful gaze and a heart full of love, he turned to his creatures and thus took care of their poverty. Yeah. Precisely in order to share the limitations and fragility of our human nature,
SPEAKER_01he himself became poor and was born in the flesh like us. We came to know him in the smallness of a child laid in a manger and in the extreme humiliation of the cross where he shared our radical poverty, which is death. So we talk about like descending to the lowest place.
SPEAKER_03Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Death is the lowest place. Yeah. I think this is extremely important because if we get God's character wrong, we get everything else wrong. There's numerous times, I think half a dozen times throughout this document, where it talks about God's desire being liberation. That's who God is. It's a God who desperately desires our liberation from slavery
and fear and sin and death.
SPEAKER_01That's God's identity. Um, and so often we get that wrong. I think we get that wrong thinking of like the church in the U S I think we get that wrong in ways in which like Protestant atonement theology, like substitutionary penal atonement has seeped in and like given us this, this portrayal. I mean, I've heard homilies about this. Um, that were just like disgusting uh we have hymns about this on
how like the wrath of god being satisfied on um on how it presents a vision of god who is pleased to crush his son yeah um which is a passage from isaiah but that's taken out of context and then extrapolated into this vision of god as this monster mm-hmm
SPEAKER_01Or, more subtly, we have a very transactional understanding of God. That God's love for me, my belonging to God, is dependent upon my behavior in some way, my performance in some way, my belief in some way. That if good things happen to me, it's because God has blessed me because I have been good. Or if bad things happen to me, it's because God has cursed me. Or let bad things happen to me, because I have been bad.
And the story of Scripture, based on the identity of God, is that that is fundamentally wrong.
SPEAKER_01Gustavo Gutierrez, the liberation theologian, the word he used was gratuitous, God's gratuitous love that is profoundly non-transactional. And the line from Leo is, God is merciful love. That's his identity. Yeah, it makes me think of Henri de Lubac made this argument in his book Catholicism that...
SPEAKER_00And he's basically coming against certain theories of the atonement. And he says that, I mean, if you want to get kind of, you want to really think about it, the incarnation itself presupposes forgiveness. Like the very fact that that God was, that the word was made flesh. The very fact that God came among us, that he pinched, pinched, pinched, that he pitched his tent among us, that he, that he condescended to our level like that,
SPEAKER_00that pre, that, um, it sort of like presupposes like all it's all already been forgiven and he's coming after us now to, it's a rescue mission, not this, um, juridical, um, like, sort of legalistic thing that he has to satisfy.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. It's his desire. I think of... Oh man, I'm going to start like preaching now. I think of the parable of the 99 sheep. And you have, you know, there's a shepherd with a hundred sheep and 99 are faithful and stay and one wanders away. And Jesus presents this image of God who is not just willing, but seems like happy to go off and to leave the 99 to go and find this one.
SPEAKER_01and gets down into the ditches and the thorns to go and seek after. And in, I believe it's Luke's retelling of this parable, it says that the shepherd goes after the sheep until he finds it. There's an unending persistence to that. And then when he finds the sheep, there is no annoyance. There's no bitterness. There's no, I can't believe you made me go and do this.
SPEAKER_01There's rejoicing. That's the parable. There's rejoicing. And this is tied to on Holy Saturday in the Liturgy of the Hours. The church directs us to read this ancient homily about Holy Saturday. And it echoes some of the language of the parable of the Good Shepherd. And it recounts Christ descending into hell.
SPEAKER_01specifically to go after Adam until he finds him. How far did Christ go to find Adam? We just went through all of that through Holy Week and all of the horrors Christ experienced, even the horror of death. That's what Christ went through. That's the persistence of his pursuit to find Adam. And then when he finds Adam, he's not annoyed. He's not pissed off.
SPEAKER_01There's a conversation between them in this homily. And what Christ says to him is now you're glorified. You are now crowned, given a throne room above the angels. You are deified. Right? The rejoicing isn't a temporal rejoicing. It's theosis. It's divinization. This is not an angry God.
SPEAKER_01Who's, you know, wrathful at us wandering away. This is a God who takes pleasure, who wants to chase us down and give us all good things.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. I really, I mean, I'm totally sold out that if the church wants to preach the gospel in the modern world, we have to rediscover, reclaim God. and wager everything, wager the whole proclamation of our message on this canonic element in the gospel. This is it. Like, this is the message. The message is that the gospel is a rescue mission.
SPEAKER_00It's not a legal event. And exactly what you're saying, like, Jesus is after you, and he is willing to go all the way down for you. He will go as low as he can go. The lowest place you've been and lower. He goes all the way. He doesn't just go into the tomb. He goes into hell. to harrow it to empty it out and to to rescue us from it so i
and i just think about like what are sort of the and this is this is speaking in kind of like a western developed way but like in the developed world in the western world what are we seeing in terms of i mean like the great sufferings of our day our loss of the sense of meaninglessness um loneliness isolation despair anxiety depression mental
SPEAKER_00illness all of these like it's almost like there's just something within the human being that's just like screaming out, um, in pain and in suffering. And you, you probably see that. I mean, you see that every day when you're working with clients and, um, There's this kind of like hell on earth experience that I think a lot of modern individuals are experiencing because of how alienated and
lonely and hurt they are,
SPEAKER_00how alienated from God, how isolated from other people they are. So if we want to proclaim the gospel in a credible way to these people, not to people who lived 50 years ago and not to people who lived 100 years ago and not to the imaginary people in our head who have all these imaginary problems, but the real people in front of us in the real world, then I think we have to take a really good look at This is the hell that they're experiencing.
SPEAKER_00This is the tomb that they are in. And then how do we preach the message that Jesus is going there? He is going after you. He is coming there for you. And he's with you in that. And not only is he with you in it, you're not there because you're being punished. You're not there because you deserve it. You're there because we live in a world where like under the weight and the tyranny of sin. Like we live in a broken world and suffering comes.
SPEAKER_00And God comes into it with us. That's good news. I think that's good news. To me, that's good news.
SPEAKER_03Yeah.
SPEAKER_00And I used to really believe that if something bad was happening to you, it was either because, yeah, you were doing something wrong and you deserved it or because God was kind of like trying to teach you a lesson through it. You know what I mean? Yeah. And I think that that's still really prevalent in people that I know. And even in myself, like, oh, yeah, like I'm suffering through this thing. God is really like, he must be wanting to teach me a lesson here. And I think there is something a little off about that.
SPEAKER_00Does God teach us lessons through our suffering? Yeah. Yeah, he always does. But to kind of frame it up like that, like, oh, God wants me to learn this or he wants me to get more virtuous in this way or he wants to challenge me in this way. this suffering has come along kind of like from his hand i do think i'm i i think that's kind of misunderstanding and if we want to preach the gospel in the modern world we kind of have to let that go yeah yeah oh man there's a
few different
SPEAKER_01things um First, I'm scanning the comments for questions, and I've seen comments. I'm not sure I've seen questions. If you have questions... Yeah, same.
SPEAKER_00I was going to say the same thing.
SPEAKER_01I'm thinking back to the day after All Souls. Pope Leo gave a homily. It was a mass commemorating the death of Pope Francis and all the cardinals who have died over the past year. And in it, he says he picks up the Canticle of St. Francis of Laudato Si. And there's a line in that canticle that is something like,
blessed are you, sister death.
SPEAKER_01But he starts the first half of the homily and he says, essentially it's blasphemy to say, blessed is death. And he talks about how death is evil and suffering is evil. And then he talks about the resurrection. And he says, only in light of the resurrection can we say, blessed are you, sister death. And too often, what I see in real life, in real conversations...
SPEAKER_01from the pulpit, but also like in coffee and donuts after, is people are talking about real suffering and grief in their life. And it's jumped over. We don't actually want to spend time in other people's suffering.
SPEAKER_03Yeah.
SPEAKER_01We want to skip to like, yeah, but it's fixed now and give some nice like spiritual platitude for it. But we actually need to spend the time in the fact that no suffering is evil. It ought not be. God does not desire suffering. He does not desire death. It's wrong. And if someone is feeling pain because of that, it's because it's wrong. It ought not be. And then in that accompaniment,
someone, hopefully, eventually, the Lord brings them.
SPEAKER_01And it's a grace to come and see. I think of, I share this story a lot. About 10 years ago, Stephen Colbert was interviewed by Anderson Cooper. Yeah, I remember this. And Colbert, he's talking about as a child how his dad and his brothers were killed in a plane accident. And he was left as like an adolescent taking care of his mom
and just the profound
SPEAKER_01suffering of that. And Anderson Cooper says, you've talked about this before, and you have said something, I think maybe quoting Tolkien or something, about how seeing this as a curse, and ought we not thank God for these curses? And he's like, how can you believe that? And Colbert's response is this. He says, if I could go back and prevent that from happening, I would, in a heartbeat.
And also, I know that I would not be the person I am today had that not happened.
SPEAKER_01And I can be grateful for that. And that being able to hang on to both of those things. But it's not for someone else to go up to someone who's experienced the suffering and grief that Colbert was describing and saying, well, you should just be grateful for all the good things that have happened from that. No, that was something that God led him to see. But too often we are uncomfortable with other people's suffering,
SPEAKER_01so we want to keep that at a distance, jump to God's going to take care of it in some way, and not be present in that poverty that someone is experiencing.
SPEAKER_03Mm-hmm.
SPEAKER_00Maybe this is taking us a little bit far afield, but I want to ask you as a, you're a mental health counselor. What is it that we're missing out on when we, when we're not willing to be with someone in their suffering? I don't know exactly like, or let me rephrase that. When we're so uncomfortable, when we become uncomfortable because other people are suffering and we don't want
SPEAKER_00to, we sort of don't want to go there with them. Like, where does that come from? What is that coming from in your experience and in what you see in your patients? And what is it that, yeah, what is it that we're like, people who are suffering need from us that we're not able to get when we do that?
SPEAKER_01Yeah. I think it's often motivated by a few different things. One is practically, we don't know what to say because we want to be able to fix it. We can't fix it. I think part of it is other people's suffering and grief remind us of the precarity of our own life. And we'd rather not be reminded of that. What we miss out on, what I have experienced,
is we miss out on christ i have been evangelized more by people who've experienced and in my work specifically people who have experienced profound harm in the church by the church uh i've encountered christ in their stories and in their presence and
SPEAKER_01in their witness um Maybe more than I've encountered Christ in the sacraments at this moment in my life. So I think that's what we miss out on.
SPEAKER_00Thanks. Yeah, wow. I don't know what to say most of the time. I feel like that's usually my issue. And I feel the same way when I encounter someone who's materially poor, too. Yeah. I don't know what to do. I don't know how to help. I feel unprepared for the encounter. And, or I feel like condescending or even rude sometimes to be like,
SPEAKER_00oh, here's $5 or, you know, something like that. It doesn't feel like enough. And so it almost feels as if it's better to do nothing than to do it badly. Do you know what I mean?
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Yeah. I mean, yes, all the time. And I'm usually on my way. I'm busy. I'm running late. And I don't want to be imposed upon by someone wanting to have a conversation, et cetera, et cetera. Yeah. There's a whole lot of reasons to be uncomfortable. Yeah. Yeah.
SPEAKER_00Do you want to get to a couple? There are a couple of questions in the chat now.
SPEAKER_01That sounds great.
SPEAKER_00Why don't we see what we got here? So Don says, Francis critiqued the economy that kills and many American Catholics wrote him off as a socialist out of touch with the way things work. Do you think Pope Leo will be able to break through that mentality among U.S. Catholics? Yeah. We did just have an election at the USCCB. We have a new president, new vice president. Archbishop Paul Coakley from Oklahoma City is now the new
president of the USCCB. So I don't know if you have any thoughts about him specifically as a leader of the USCCB.
SPEAKER_00Maybe we don't need to get into that if you don't want to. But I mean, we have new leadership. It's kind of a new moment. Is Leo going to, yeah, will he have a kind of different gravitas for U.S. Catholics? Will he be able to break through the crust that Francis really didn't seem to break through? Okay. Yeah, okay. No, I have thoughts, but you go ahead. No, it's okay. Go ahead. Okay.
SPEAKER_01The profound cynic in me is that, I don't know, the last 130 years of Catholic social teaching hasn't broken through. So I don't think Leo is going to change that on a... holistic level, the U.S. Church does not prioritize catechizing around the Catholic social teaching. The closest that we get to is our preaching on human dignity when it comes to life
SPEAKER_01issues surrounding abortion and euthanasia. But even then, that has become so politically influenced and so distorted that It is certainly far, far from the fullness. Like, where we can have people, and Pope Leo just called this out, who call themselves pro-life and are okay with immigration policies that dehumanize immigrants. Like, that's how much this anti-catechesis that's been wrapped in pro-life language has
SPEAKER_01seeped into the U.S. Church. So, I'm deeply cynical about it. I will say... Pope Liu has broken through to me, and I'm as much the church as president of the USCCB. So that's what I'm responsible for. I also wonder if the immigration issue and how in our face it
is right now might be
SPEAKER_00an opportunity and may... create a breakthrough opportunity for the Catholic church in the United States to sort of, I don't know, like reevaluate itself and, um, I do think it's interesting that Coakley is going to be the new president of the USCCB because he is kind of like a paradigm transcender. You know, he is kind of the pro-life conservative bishop on the one hand
who was very
SPEAKER_00involved in the Eucharistic Congress and all of that. But he's been very outspoken against the death penalty in Oklahoma. And now he's been very outspoken in favor of humane policies around immigration. And I don't know. I wonder if just the immigration issue, the fact that Hope Leo is American, you know, like he's not kind of like your typical American, like he's not dyed in the wool American person.
bishop you know like he's he's kind of an outsider insider character um so i wonder
SPEAKER_00if i just i just sort of wonder if there's enough sort of like category transcending and category breaking that um maybe maybe there's an opportunity here for for a little bit of change i'm seeing it i mean i'm seeing a little bit of it like people are starting to like be open to i don't know asking different questions and
SPEAKER_01Bernie Sanders in me is much more pessimistic. I am very happy about Bishop Flores. He's great. I really like Flores. But I have this belief... that money corrupts. And one thing that I found really discouraging was Coakley's, I think he's the chaplain for the Napa Institute. And it's like,
SPEAKER_01when the Pope is talking about, and the last Pope, and all of Catholic social teaching talking about how Excess wealth in and of itself, regardless of how it was procured, is unjust and is theft. Belongs to the poor. Um... And that when I teach that to people and can quote, you know, eight different, I mean, this document and like eight different, you know, church fathers who say this,
SPEAKER_01Pope Leo XIII who said it in the 1890s, et cetera, et cetera, that I'm looked at like I'm a socialist. And I'm like, no, this is the church's teaching that having excess wealth on its own is profoundly sinful. And I don't mean that in, like, I'm not making judgments on individuals' culpability, but I am making judgments on their choices. And the choice to have that wealth, I think, is a profound anti-witness.
SPEAKER_01So, that's discouraging.
SPEAKER_00Well, I think this is kind of the elephant in the room with American Catholicism because it is a capitalist country. And I don't... I don't think it's right to say that Catholic social teaching precludes capitalism as a kind of way of running the economy and building a just society. It seems like it's possible within the framework of what we have in Catholic social teaching. And John Paul II... was very critical of just like the free market.
And I really like William Kavanaugh on this because he's always asking the
SPEAKER_00question, like, what makes a market free? And when we talk about the free market, how free really is that when Amazon is paying its workers, you know, like $13 an hour and they're peeing in bottles because they don't have any time to take a bathroom break or whatever? Is that really a free market? So I don't know. It's tricky because When you look at the United States and we're we're very invested in the sort of capitalist project and part of.
SPEAKER_00Part of capitalism is capital, meaning like wealth, you know, so like how do you how do you have how do you build a just society? in a system that's predicated on wealth and capital. I don't know the answer to that, but I just think it's a tricky needle to thread. And I kind of say that tongue-in-cheek with the camel and the eye of the needle thing. But anyway.
SPEAKER_01I think that the discomfort... Okay, here's what I want to say. If a practicing Catholic is living with someone who they're not married to, I want to see them, not me personally, but like, I think a healthy conscience is one that's wrestling with that, that there's discomfort in that discontinuity between professed
beliefs and values
SPEAKER_01and choices that someone's making. So this isn't judgment on individual culpability, but I would hope that there's friction in their conscience because that's like the sign of a functioning conscience. I would say, likewise, any Catholic who is supporting inhumane immigration policies or death penalty policies, that there would feel that friction. I would say just as much of someone who is a multimillionaire or a billionaire— would feel that friction.
SPEAKER_01And for me, a sign of a healthy conscience. Yes, it's murky. There isn't like a clear path. We're in a capitalist economy. But say that to us. Show us that you're really, really wrestling with this. I think that's what I want to see in order to trust. individuals in the church with that kind of wealth yeah yeah I
think this is such an important point and you called it anti-witness and I this is I think I posted a note about this a couple weeks ago like the kind of McMansion phenomenon in the
SPEAKER_00United States probably everywhere but this idea that wealth is sort of value neutral and people can do whatever they want with their money. And there's, there's really nothing, you know, it's your money, you earned it, you can do whatever you want with it. And I think that's so ingrained in the American consciousness.
SPEAKER_01And it's absolutely opposed to the church of social teaching.
SPEAKER_00I was going to say, like, it's just so not the gospel. And so like, It's literally always bothered me, like, seeing people who say, like, I'm a Christian. I am, like, I'm a pastor or I'm this really good Catholic. And then you walk into their house and you're like, you have... I mean, your chandelier alone costs more than my whole house. And I don't really know what to do with that when I walk into your home because that says something to me about you.
SPEAKER_00And that's an extreme, and it says something about you. It says something about your life, your choices, your priorities that I kind of like can't not see. I don't know how else to put it. And that's like an extreme example, but it kind of calls me too to look at I don't have that kind of means. I mean, I don't have... We don't have that kind of money. But every... Like, this is Pope Francis. Like, purchasing is always a moral act. Economics is a moral act.
SPEAKER_00So the things that we buy... And the things that we own and the things that we invest our resources and our time in, the car that we drive, that's like a big one that I think about all the time. This says something to others. This is part of our witness. It's part of our evangelical call. The things in our life actually say something and they speak about what matters to us. And I... And I don't know, like, I don't really know what to do with that because I don't want to just sit in judgment of everybody who's like driving an Escalade up to the
Catholic school in
SPEAKER_00the morning. Like, that's not a good way to live to be like, oh, you and your like nice car. But at the same time, it's almost like, ah, I just can't. I have a hard time not seeing it. And it makes me want to really commit to simplicity as kind of a way of life as part of God's made it really easy for me to be simple because we have no money. So that's the other thing is like I have it easy because God didn't give us any money. So but if I if I had a lot of money, I'm sure I'd be driving the Escalade like full disclosure.
SPEAKER_01But what's the line from C.S. Lewis? Don't feel don't feel so good about yourself. Don't don't judge others for vices that you don't struggle with.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, exactly. Or that or don't have the means to indulge in like I don't I just don't have money. So I can't be I can't like, you know, flaunt wealth. But I'm I'm certain if I if I had it, you know. But anyway, like it just I don't know if any of that like resonates with you or if anybody in the who's here with us, if that resonates with any of you or if I'm told I don't know.
SPEAKER_01There are a few more questions.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, yeah. Let's do it.
SPEAKER_01Okay. So from Rhonda, she's following up on Dawn's question. And she says, how can lay Catholics in the U.S. encourage bishops to speak and act in greater alignment with the ecclesial and social visions of Pope Leo and Pope Francis? I'll throw that to you first.
SPEAKER_00How can lay Catholics in the U.S.? Well, I guess the first thing that comes to mind is, man, I mean, I hate to be this person, but I sort of feel like there is this way that we lean on the Episcopate in the church and we should expect less from our bishops in terms of leadership. Yeah.
And that's not to say that they don't have an important role and we shouldn't
SPEAKER_00expect them to give a witness and be disappointed when they don't. But this idea that the bishops have to say something for it to be real or for it to be valid or for it to be coming from the authentic heart of the church— I think while there is truth in that, lay Catholics have to sort of acknowledge that there's this vacuum and there's this void and, like, what are you like, what am I doing about it?
SPEAKER_00What are we doing about it? How are we like, how are we working together, associating and building things that speak to the culture about what we, what we believe is true about the human person and about God and about what a good human society looks like. And the truth about it is like the bishop's And God bless them for it. It probably sucks to be a bishop because you're basically like this combination of a politician and like a public figure.
SPEAKER_00You just get kind of ushered from place to place. You don't have control over your schedule. You don't write your own speeches. You like maybe don't even write your own homilies a lot of the time. Like this is not... this is probably a very difficult life that they have to live. So I don't mean to be hard on them. I just mean the way that the system works, and at least in the United States, is These are not people who are set up systemically to sort of live as fathers and as shepherds for the church.
SPEAKER_00And that system needs to be reworked and needs to change. I think, personally, that's just my opinion, is we need to see sort of like a reimagining of the episcopate for the modern world because it's kind of getting all of the life sucked out of it by bureaucracy. And fear of being sued, frankly. So, I don't know. Like, I would just, in this way, I guess,
SPEAKER_00like, I feel, like, convicted about wanting to, like, pray about how lay people can, I guess, can encourage bishops by our witness and by the radical new ways of life that we are willing to build. Because we have the freedom to build stuff. We're not, we're not answering to lawyers for everything that we do and say like the bishops are a lot of the time we have the freedom to take risks we have the freedom to go out there and get messy we have the freedom to try things and we're
baptized we're adults in in our in our baptism we are adults in christ so we actually like have the sort of like kingly authority to build things in the kingdom of god and we should we should
SPEAKER_00take ownership of that
SPEAKER_01We are other Christ, the catechism says, because of our baptism. Like, we are Christ. Yeah. Which is, yeah. The thought that comes to my mind. So, yes, lower my expectations of the bishops. Also, I think there's a reality in the church with technology and media that lay people can have as much or more influence in swaying opinion amongst the faithful as bishops can,
SPEAKER_01and it's kind of this democratizing of communication. But what comes to my mind, though, because I believe that, and also, I also want the bishops, I want my bishop, to preach this vision.
SPEAKER_03Yeah.
SPEAKER_01So I'm reflecting on this question, like, why do I want that? And what I want that personally, and I suspect I'm not unusual, is because I also want to feel safe in the church, like I have a place here. And if my bishop isn't speaking out against inhumane immigration, if my bishop is platforming MAGA influencers who give Nazi salutes,
SPEAKER_01I don't feel safe. Not materially safe, but my church doesn't feel like a home. And if my bishop was doing more of those things, it would feel more like a home. So it means I know that by believing in the church and the vision that Leo and Francis have articulated, that I have the minority view. in my area, that's uncomfortable.
SPEAKER_01I'd, I'd rather not be the turd in a punch bowl. Um, so that's part of my own, like, like what I want the bishops to feel up, to speak up and have this vision because I, I want to feel more secure in my relationship with the mainstream church. I'm not saying that's good or bad, but that's,
SPEAKER_00No, that's real.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_00That's real. I've been very grateful just on the record. I have been very grateful for Archbishop Hebda here in the Twin Cities. I think he's been just excellent on all of this and the Minnesota Catholic Conference. There's lots of good efforts underway. A lot of states also have Catholic conferences. Like Minnesota, we have one. I know Michigan has one. Many, many, many states have a Catholic conference that's sort of comprised of lay people that work with the state bishops,
SPEAKER_00and they work on issues at the state legislature. And It depends on what state you're in, but I think that there are places where that vision is being articulated and being promoted by the Catholic Conference in the state. So it's a good resource for a lot of us in the United States, at least on state policy. But that can help be sort of a catalyst also for federal too.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Chad has a question. How do we approach the people who are believers in the Deuce Volt approach to Catholicism with a message that Leo and Francis have been teaching?
SPEAKER_00I might need help on that reference.
SPEAKER_01Deuce Volt. I think it's, from my being too online, I think it's like a crusader reference.
SPEAKER_00Okay, okay. Like triumphalists.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, and like want to bring about a new Christendom. yeah how do we approach the people who are believers in the dave's will approach to catholicism okay um how do wow how do we approach um that's an interesting question because it's i don't think the approach is apologetics i don't think the approach is well here's everything that the pope leo just said in this document um
SPEAKER_01I think people do a lot of things out of fear. And people are involved in groups because that's the place where they find belonging, and there's the fear of not belonging. So I think that these conversations happen on a very individual basis and have to start with empathy and curiosity and non-judgment. to hold enough space for people to articulate what's actually motivating them.
SPEAKER_01I realize I sound like a therapist here, but I think people only change in relationship, not through apologetics.
SPEAKER_00And I do think there is, I mean... There's a reactionary element in things like this, too. It's hard at this point to even know what's the action and what's the reaction because there's been so much ping-ponging back and forth between hyper-progressive Catholicism and then uber-traditionalist Catholicism. But I think there's, at least in the United States, there's kind of these two,
like, really extreme opposites happening and neither one of them is healthy and they're both sort of reacting against one another and so the reactions become more and more and more extreme which is why you see like you know progressive Catholics who are just getting more and more crazy and playing faster and looser with church teaching all the time and then on the other hand you have traditionalists who are getting
SPEAKER_00more and more rigid and um and more and more unforgiving and more and more scary in their own way. And we have both of these things happening at the same time. I think there's a much more interesting conversation happening between those two poles. So I don't know if there's a way to entice people on these fringes to sort of get into the more interesting conversation where there's a little you know push and pull like Paul and I like we don't agree on everything we're not like we're not identical in
terms of the way that we see things within the church but like here we are having this great
SPEAKER_00conversation and there's a little bit of push there's a little bit of pull it's good like that's good for us that sort of tension and dynamic um conflict within the church is good but you get out to these like fringe elements and there's really no like there's not a lot of convincing that can happen um And that doesn't mean you dismiss people or just consider them totally lost, but just acknowledging these are ideologies that are kind of
hard to crack through.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I think ideology is the right word. Yeah, Francis would call that out. When I'm motivated by something other than the gospel, when I refuse to let my beliefs be challenged by reality, um i've moved into a space of ideology yeah okay here's another question go for it holly um which okay i will just say holly if you're still here
i still think about
SPEAKER_00your piece about um oh my gosh that guy who gave the The guy who gave the commencement speech, Harrison Butker, you wrote such a good piece on that. After that happened, just kind of breaking down all of the things that he said in that speech that were not right. So thank you for that piece. And I recommend everybody go read that. Holly Taylor Kuhlman. But she says, what could it mean for American Catholics who are so captured by materialism to really turn their hearts toward the poor? Are there concrete examples that give you hope?
SPEAKER_00Yeah. Yeah. Wow. There are concrete examples that give me hope. I think of the Catholic worker movement and these sort of chosen voluntary modes of poverty that I see some lay people embracing. Like literally just choosing to not
yeah just choosing to live in poverty and choosing to live in sort of a shared reality where this isn't mine this house isn't mine my my money is not just for me my goods are not for me um i know i know it's one family who literally pooled their
SPEAKER_00money with another family like is and they bought a house um together and like emptied their bank accounts basically emptied their savings account to buy this house and to renovate it so that it could be sort of this like transitional home for people who are coming out of poverty and struggling and they're like living with these people in this house so it's this kind of um like yeah radical solidarity with people who don't have that much people who are poor
SPEAKER_00and who who need friends and need accompaniment so I mean I see a lot of examples of it I think where I mean I just lack the courage there so I think I what I'm always praying for these days especially after reading Delefcite is like Lord convict my heart and then like make the opportunities present themselves of like what do you how do you want me to live and I I think that's part of the call is for lay Catholics right now to be really like on
SPEAKER_00their begging the Lord on their knees. Like, how do you want us to live differently? How do you want us to look different from the world around us? What do you want from us? How do you want us to give witness? Because if we look the same as everyone around us, what good is that? We have to create new modes of life, new ways of life together that actually speak of the Lord and his goodness and his merciful love.
SPEAKER_01What comes to mind with that question? Where are places of hope? I think there's always places of hope. I think the historical survey that Leo does in this document, he's looking at individuals and religious orders. He's not looking other than Oscar Romero, maybe. They're not bishops. They're not bishops' conferences.
SPEAKER_01He's looking at individuals. I think of St. Francis in particular. There's a line, I think it's from Chesterton, who talks about how the church, like its founder, finds new life only through death. And that the new life comes up out of places of death.
SPEAKER_01So I think there's always signs of hope. I think they're very rarely at the top. with the signs of hope that I see now in the work that I'm in with abuse in the church. So if I expand this idea of poverty as being in the way that Leo and Francis both have of anyone who's been marginalized and oppressed. And if I expand this view of materialism to include like a life
seeking after material security.
SPEAKER_01I mean, I think of organizations. It's not really me online if I'm not talking about Awake and the Sisters of the Little Way. But those are the places where I see hope. where I see people embracing a very real kind of poverty to live in solidarity with a particular kind of poverty. And as a profound witness, I think of the Sisters of Little Way. They're releasing a podcast series right now, Descent into Light.
And the newest episode that dropped today, they shared how they experienced in the church Betrayal and ostracization and not belonging for speaking out on behalf of survivors.
SPEAKER_01For speaking out to protect vulnerable people. That is not uncommon. That's very true. So... That's where I see hope are those specific places with this particular kind of poverty. But I do think this has to be. As you said earlier, Sarah, we need to lower our expectations of the bishops.
SPEAKER_01Not in the sense of, I think, at the first reading today from wisdom addressed to, like, kings and those who misuse the authority that they have and all of God's judgment coming upon them.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. The old testament.
SPEAKER_01It made me happy.
SPEAKER_00You've got your sweatshirt on. You're ready. Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, they will be held accountable. But when I say lower expectations, I don't mean lower those objective expectations. I mean, I'm not going to wait around for examples or models or reform from them before I try and reform my life to live more in accord with this vision of the church, with the gospel.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. Amen. I feel like that's a really good place to wrap up. But yeah, couldn't say it better myself. So if there's any, maybe if there's any last minute items, but Thanks all of you for joining us. And if you have other questions or want to chime in, this live conversation we'll post on Substack so we can have an ongoing discussion in the comment section if there's follow-up thoughts. And if you liked this live and you want to see more things like
this on Substack
SPEAKER_00from us, we'd love to hear that from you. And I'll take this opportunity too to just say thank you, Paul, again for It was really fun to have this conversation and to get you preaching a little bit. I like that. It's good.
SPEAKER_01It's way easier to do this with a second person.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Also, to plug our tip jar, if you want to see more of these things, it helps, like I said earlier, to justify to our families the time we spend on this. So if you want to throw a tip, Sarah and I will split the tips. So you can use my Venmo, which is Catholic Third Space or at Catholic Third Space on Venmo. Just make a note that it's for the live stream. So I know what to split with Sarah.
anything is appreciated and if you didn't like anything that i said then you can just earmark it like this is a restricted gift just for paul yeah i'll just split it with sarah well thank you paul this was so fun and um yeah let's do it again i don't know this is this is great this yeah this is so good thank you sarah yeah
SPEAKER_00thanks everybody have a wonderful night god bless
*Show notes are AI-generated and edited by me for clarity and organization Sarah and Helen speak with Elena Trueba of Unholy Alliances about her experience growing up in evangelical and fundamentalist Christianity, the...
*Show notes are AI generated and edited by me for organization and clarity Sarah Carter sits down with Craig of Uncharted Catholic Man for an honest conversation about the realities of natural family planning, the...
*Shownotes are AI-generated and edited by me for organization and clarity. Mike Lewis of Where Peter Is joins Sarah Carter to discuss Father Chad Ripperger’s growing influence among American Catholics, controversial...
This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit recoveringcatholic.substack.com/subscribe