Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Reckoning with Jason Herbert

Reckoning with Jason Herbert artwork

Episode 208: Patton with James Ellman

Nov 2, 20261 hr 15 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

How much of what we know about General George S. Patton comes from George C. Scott? Author James Ellman joins historian Jason Herbert to revisit the classic 1970 film Patton and challenge the legend of one of World War II’s most celebrated commanders. Drawing on his book Patton Reconsidered and the general’s own diaries, Ellman makes a provocative case for reassessing “Old Blood and Guts.” From North Africa and Sicily to the Battle of the Bulge, we examine Patton’s battlefield achievements, his relationships with Dwight Eisenhower and Omar Bradley, and the powerful connections that helped protect his career. Did the Germans really fear Patton? Did the 101st Airborne need rescuing at Bastogne? And what does Hollywood’s portrait leave out about his assaults on soldiers, racism, antisemitism, and response to the killing of prisoners of war? Along the way, we discuss the disastrous Hammelburg raid, combat fatigue and military leadership, and the overlooked American commanders Ellman believes deserve more credit. It’s a candid conversation about World War II, war movies, and how America chooses - and keeps - its heroes.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_00Everything that I know about George Patton, I know from the film Patton that came out in 1970, starring George C. Scott as the general. At least that's what I thought I knew until I read James Ellman's Patton Reconsidered General George S. Patton Jr. as a wartime commander. And that really kind of pulled the curtain back on this guy that I thought I knew, but it turns out that I really didn't know it all. So today I invited James on to talk about the film Patton, which won all the awards.

SPEAKER_00And maybe the mythology of the man, the history behind this general, and his legacy today. This turns out to be a really cool conversation with a great historian about a really turns out controversial figure in American history. I think you'll like it. The film's amazing, the man a lot more complicated. Sit back and relax. Because reckoning with Jason Herbert starts right now. Every story has a history, especially the ones we think we know. Each week, we sit down with historians, writers, and filmmakers to ask big questions about the past and how we live with it today.

SPEAKER_00We follow the evidence, challenge each other, and find stories too good to leave buried. Sometimes we start with the book, sometimes we start with a movie. We always end up somewhere worth talking about. I'm Jason Herbert, and this is a record. So where am I calling into anyway? Where are you where are you at?

SPEAKER_01I live in Tiburon, California, just north of the Golden Gate Bridge.

SPEAKER_00Thank you for being that way because uh so many of my pods are East Coast and like recording. Once I moved out here to the mountains, it just became this huge nobody's on Mountain Time. There are 17 people that live out here in Mount. It's it's a it's a huge pain in the ass. So uh thank you for being flexible on this. Um, dude, thank you for writing this book. I um I was talking to a friend of mine uh in uh who's a military historian in England, Waiteman Bourne, about your stuff this morning. And I was like, dude, Patton, oh my god, I had no idea.

SPEAKER_00He goes, Yeah, right? I was like, yeah. Uh I feel like that might be the review of the book is, oh wow, yeah.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, and and and hopefully it came through pretty clearly that I'm not just one you know independent guy here on the periphery of the empire uh writing about it, that uh this is reasonably well sourced, and much of it's in Patton's own words. And what's surprising is how so many major historians and biographers of this guy knew about almost everything I've mentioned, and they just kind of hand wave it away and say, Oh, yeah, but he was a G he was great. And I just don't understand how you get there.

SPEAKER_01But uh, they've been I I don't understand why many people that I think have not had the uh intestinal fortitude to be willing to say much bad about him.

SPEAKER_00I know, you know, I'm an early Americanist, you know. I I write about indigenous history and environmental history in the early Americas. So my understanding of Patton was always we're a hero, slapped a guy, right? And that was about it. And frankly, a lot of it was informed by this film that we're gonna talk about today. And then reading through stuff, I was like, oh, oh dear, there's so much more there. And I kept thinking, wow, this guy may have had the best press agent in the history of the world for for us to think the way that we do about him now that I know all the all of the things, and some of it's kind of icky.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, he and MacArthur, great, great PR agent, whoever it was, hire that guy.

SPEAKER_00I I guess. Um, but but you know, you mentioned other great historians, but before we jump into this too much, you yourself, sir, have written a bunch of stuff. Do you want to introduce yourself and like talk about what it is that you do and what you're doing here?

SPEAKER_01Sure. I I mean I'm I think Patton is a whole lot more interesting than I am.

SPEAKER_00So this is not your first foray into military history. You've written on other guys and and so forth.

SPEAKER_01Right. This is my sixth uh book of military history. Uh, I come from a background uh in the mutual funded hedge fund space, picking stocks, where the primary thing you do is you question consensus and try and figure out where Mr. Market and most people are wrong. And that's where you can commit capital and make bets. And if you make the wrong bets, you're gonna get fired. If you make the right bets, of course, you uh are able to generate some returns for your investors.

SPEAKER_01And I don't want to just write yet another book about patent. I want to only write books that uncover something that is non-consensus, that is not what most people believe, that I can well source and well document. So I've written one book on Hitler's War in the East, written a book on um MacArthur, MacArthur reconsidered, which is a companion book to patent reconsidered, uh Seeds of Victory, which really talks about how the United States um its way of war is not just throwing a lot of uh metal and um uh artillery out of target uh versus people.

SPEAKER_01Uh it's also uh losing a lot and somehow not only losing terribly badly strategically on many occasions through its relatively short history, but finding a way to react, recover, and find a way to win very quickly. Uh that book is Seeds of Victory. Um I also um am the editor of a book of Communiques of General MacArthur. MacArthur put out a communique every day. It was basically a long tweet. He would have loved Twitter or Truth Social.

SPEAKER_01And uh these communiques have been are quoted quite often by the historians of the period, but they were not public. They were only on microfiche uh over at the MacArthur Memorial in Norfolk, Virginia. I got a copy, transcribed them all, edited them, uh stitched them together, and helped show how MacArthur was trying to personally write the first draft of history that would show up in the newspapers and then the history books to try to influence how people thought of him and what he did.

SPEAKER_01Also, he's the listed uh author, and he hadn't published anything for a while. So it's kind of cool that he just published a book.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, I have to tell you, when I finished your book here on Patent, the first thing I wanted to do was like, I was like, oh, now I need to know about MacArthur. Like, what's the deal with this dude? And maybe that's a conversation we can have at another pod uh down the road because I was fascinated with this book as I read through it, uh, really shaping the way I saw this film. And I had seen this movie really years ago. You know, this came out seven years before I was born, but it was still always one of these films that you kind of knew was out there. I remember watching it in my teens or maybe early 20s or something like that.

SPEAKER_00Uh, and it was kind of there. And when I, you know, when the press came to me about your book, I was like, this we've got to talk about this film. Um, but I've got a question. So when you when you find yourself walking around and you're talking to people about what you're doing and stuff like, oh, I'm writing this book on patent, are there immediate misconceptions that you've found when people, when you start to talk to people? Like was there, was there an effort where we're like, wait, there's this idea about this guy. You talk about wanting to go against a consensus. What were you hearing about this guy that drove you to this?

SPEAKER_01Well, of course, uh there is a certain significant percentage of the population. Uh, and my wife is in that part of the Venn diagram, who really doesn't care too much about General George S. Patton Jr. And uh she, I don't think she's ever read my books, and that's just fine, uh, probably for the best. Uh, for those who really care about Patton, care about World War II, care about military history, and there are a lot of those people out there, and of course, I that's sort of many of the people I speak to. Uh, as you mentioned, their image of Patton to a great extent is that 1970 movie.

SPEAKER_01George D. Scott is Patton in their mind. Uh, there is a recording of a speech that anybody can pull up on YouTube or Internet Archive and hear his voice. His voice was described as squeaky by most of high-pitched and squeaky by most of his biographers. I I don't think that's how I would describe it, but it's not the gravel of uh uh George C. Scott. So um, you know, I one of my good friends told me after after I told him I was writing this book, he said, Oh no, not George.

SPEAKER_01Be nice to George. And it's amazing how uh many misconceptions there are about him, uh, things such as his ordering his men to shoot POWs and then trying to cover up the massacres when they took place, um, about the repeated assaults, uh not just uh a slapping incident, but of repeated assaults he had on enlisted men throughout his career, his gross insubordination, his rabid racism and anti-Semitism, and how um an old boys' network at the uh in the military to a great extent protected him through his career, but finally, finally had to force him out.

SPEAKER_01And uh I I do think that there are a lot of misconceptions out there about Patton, and perhaps particularly because uh of the uh importance his legend, his legacy is getting today makes it somewhat more important, uh imperative, perhaps, to consider who really was Patton if he was not George C. Scott.

SPEAKER_00I kept thinking about like Patton is like as portrayed in the film, as like this rugged masculinity, and yeah, he's headstrong, but he does this, you know, the way he's portrayed in this film is almost like okay, yeah, he's a he's a w Omar will take care of him. Uh, you know, he'll he'll keep him in line. And and that's just you really see the faults, you see some of the faults in Patton in this film, but they're nowhere near as what you detail in the book about him. I mean, he's frankly, I don't want to spill the beans here much, but he really comes across as a really despicable human being uh on a very you know um human level, you know, as I'm reading about him.

SPEAKER_00There's just not a lot here to like about this guy. And then yet he becomes this really revered guy. And I wonder, were you worried about backlash when when you're writing this going, wait a second, I'm telling this how it is, but people are gonna like it when I reveal the ugly truths about this man.

SPEAKER_01Uh there was a very small amount of trepidation there. I've I've pretty thick skin. Uh, people aren't going to be happy with the message. They're probably not going to be happy with the messenger. Um, all I would say is for many of the things that some who might uh be in your audience but they hear what I have to say today or what we talk about, most of these discussions of court-martial offenses and arguably war crimes that should have led to a court-martial for Patton are described in his own handwriting, in his own diaries.

SPEAKER_01And anybody can look them up on the Library of Congress website, and you can pull them down. On the right side, you can see the um handwritten diary, and on the left side, there's a transcription of it, make it a whole lot easier to read his handwriting. And um spelling was always a bit of an adventure for that guy as well. So it's nice that the Library of Congress uh cleaned it up for us. Uh I I do display a couple of those images um from his own documents in the book, but uh, if you don't like the idea that I'm saying that he ordered a suppression and a falsification of a report about the uh US soldiers on two different occasions, actually three different occasions, massacring POWs, you don't have to believe me.

SPEAKER_01You can just go to the Library of Congress website and look it up yourself.

SPEAKER_00It's it's incredible. Um I want to draw the conversation here back to the film for a quick second. You know, whenever I think about Patton, and we all it's almost impossible, James, to separate my image of I don't think about the man on the cover of your book, I think about George C. Scott. Whenever I think about Patton, at least for me as a as a lay person when it comes to World War II history. And the first thing I think about is that grandiose opening scene of him in front of the flag, and he's giving this, he's you know, he's giving this monologue and all these things.

SPEAKER_00And I'm kind of wondering, if we're just if we're jumping into World War II, when we when we see him on screen for the very first time, can you kind of bring us up to speed about who this guy is, where he's from? He's gonna really feel like unlikely, uh, right? You know, unlikely background, at least for me, as uh as I'm reading about him. Who is George Patton before he gets into World War II? Like, is is he is he always a pain in the ass? Like, who is this guy?

SPEAKER_01Sure. And first of all, I would agree with you that in my mind it's it's very difficult from watching that 1970 film multiple times when I was uh a kid uh to distinguish between the actor, the movie, and the real guy in real life. Um and I would point out that George C. Scott was not particularly happy with that scene where he gave the speech in front of the flag. That was uh a mishmash of three or four speeches that Patton actually did give uh close together in um England uh before the D-Day invasion.

SPEAKER_01Um so it took place in 1944. So it opens the movie, so it's not chronologically in order. And um uh George T. Scott said, I I you know, this better not be the opening of the movie. And he was promised uh by the director, oh yeah, don't worry, it'll it'll it won't be. And of course, that's where it ended up being. Um so it it they give you that scene that takes place in England in 1944, and then they jump to um to Casablanca uh in 1942.

SPEAKER_01All right, sorry about that. To answer your question specifically, yes, Patton was an interesting cat, uh, a very unusual guy for the U.S. military. And um, he was born in the LA area in the 1880s. Uh he had uh a younger sister, but he was really doted upon by his mom and his aunt who lived there and his father. He was from a very wealthy, very politically connected family. He grew up on a huge estate uh riding polo ponies and um uh was homeschooled until he was 12, which may have helped lead to his um sense of self-worth.

SPEAKER_01He always wanted to be in the military. Uh his he had grandfathers who had been in the Civil War. Um and he used to parade around the house with a wooden sword in his belt, declaring that he was Lieutenant General George S. Patton Jr. And uh he never wanted to do anything else. He ended up going to West Point, uh, failed out for a time due to a poor math score. I also mentioned spelling and writing was a bit tough for him, uh, but went to VMI, did an extra year there, went back to West Point and graduated in the middle of his class.

SPEAKER_01So he wasn't a great student, particularly, but he was a great athlete. He did play a little football, but mostly he was an individual athlete, horseback riding, marksmanship, running, swimming, and he did so well he ended up going uh in the 1910s to the Olympics, to Stockholm to compete in the modern pentathlon. And um he didn't get a medal, but he did quite well, uh, just missed a medal by a few places. And um perhaps that individual uh excellence that he had in some sports, but lack of team sports made him a very different person, for example, than let's say Eisenhower and most of the other um Marshall men who George Marshall picked, who were guys who were uh from more humble backgrounds and uh were team players.

SPEAKER_00I'm wondering, you know, uh we'll get into Eisenhower in a bit because there was a lot here on Ike that I simply did not know. He I think they do a really brilliant job by never actually seeing Ike in this film. Oh, I Eisenhower, it's very interesting.

SPEAKER_01Eisenhower never appears in the movie, despite the fact that they have been great friends since they were next-door neighbors in 1919. And Eisenhower was his great patron after Eisenhower was jumped up uh through the promotion uh stampede by uh Marshall over scores of other more senior officers to become the Supreme Commander, first of the Torch landings in Africa, then the Husky landings in Sicily, and then finally, of course, most famously the D-Day landings and the march on Berlin.

SPEAKER_00You know, I kept thinking about another film entirely when when I was reading about the Eisenhower Patton relationship, which was actually Top Gun Maverick, and thinking about and thinking how Iceman turns out to be the guy who who kind of keeps Maverick in the business for the longest, you know, for the longest time. And then I started thinking, well, Jesus, is Maverick also an asshole? Like, you know, uh, do I have to do I have to critically reinterrogate Pete Mitchell, you know, at this point in time? I don't think he's as bad as Patton turns out to be, but like there's a reason why he can't keep a relationship, maybe.

SPEAKER_01Well, well, Patton used to uh and Eisenhower, they uh in the 1920s, they were best buddies. Uh they loved tanks, they were both armored corps guys before the armored corps was disbanded for a decade. Uh they loved uh firing tanks, driving around tanks, taking apart tanks, putting them back together, and then they hang out at night and have all night bull sessions, drinking a bourbon concoction called armored diesel. And uh, which is a strong drink if you want to give it, look it up and give it a try. And uh Patton said, uh, just kind of like uh you were talking about Iceman ends up being the Admiral uh versus Maverick, um, Patton said to Eisenhower, hey, in the next war, you be Lee, I'll be Stuart.

SPEAKER_01You know, he wanted to be the cavalry commander dashing about lightning strikes into the enemy rear, where Eisenhower was the planner, the cerebral guy, the politician, the diplomat who could run the entire war.

SPEAKER_00So we jump into Northern Africa right after that speech, right? And in the movie. Yeah, in the film, yeah. Um, and the first thing that we start to see is, and I guess maybe this starts to build that mythology of Patton right away, is like he kind of comes into an army that that is poorly trained, not doing well, seems like they're really kind of getting getting hit pretty hard, and he whips them into shape. Is that true to form with with Patton? Was he a good trainer of of armies? Like, what were his strengths as a soldier and I guess as a commander?

SPEAKER_01Uh I think as a trainer of tactical units, I think yes, he was uh he was excellent. Uh, soon before World War II began, he had been sent out to um eastern, southeastern California and over the border into Nevada to set up a desert training center to train guys in how to use tanks in the desert. So he got very lucky because there was a real thought that the U.S.'s first major operation in the European theater would be an invasion of Norway, try and get into Sweden and get at the uh the iron ore and the ball-bearing plants.

SPEAKER_01Uh, that wouldn't have been great for um for Patton. He was not a mountain warrior or skier. Uh so he got lucky that, of course, we ended up going to the desert first. Um I would say a couple things. First of all, let's just think about what we know about Patton in combat beforehand. In 1916, in Mexico chasing uh Pancho Villa, uh, he was sent after a um lieutenant of Villa, and um he was able to get him uh by finding this guy, uh Cardenas' uncle, uh, torturing the uncle, who gave up the information as to where this guy Cardenas would be.

SPEAKER_01Patton and his men ambushed him, shot him and two other of his bodyguards dead. Patton tied the corpses to the hood of his car, drove back into um uh General Pershing's headquarters in northern Mexico at the time, uh, triumphantly showing off these corpses, and stripped uh Cardenas' uh silver spurs and silver saddle for personal souvenirs. These are all things that were not legal then in Rules of Land Warfare for the U.S. Army, and they're not legal now. Um but the press loved him and he was known as uh the bandit killer.

SPEAKER_01Then in World War I, of course, he famously becomes a tank brigade commander and is uh rapidly promoted to lieutenant colonel. But his boss, General Rockenbaugh, head of the U.S. Tank Corps, he found Patton to be a real pain in the ass as a subordinate. He was constantly rushing off to the front, even ahead of the front lines, off on his own, because he just had to keep proving his manhood to himself and others around him. And um in terms of foreshadowing the slapping incident, he talks about how on the last day of his combat in World War I, Patton picked up a shovel and started digging to uh make a path for some of his tanks to get through, and there was one enlisted man who wouldn't help.

SPEAKER_01So Patton hit him over the head with the shovel and believes he killed him. Again, that's definitely not uh something that's okay in the U.S. Army. General Samuel Rockenbach actually put a formal letter of reprimand in Patton's file for insubordination, for constantly rushing off to the front, not staying at his headquarters and keeping his superiors informed as to what was going on in the battle. And Rockenbach even took the unusual step of. Sending a letter to Mrs. Patton, Beatrice Patton, imploring her to ask her husband to please not throw his life and his career away.

SPEAKER_01Because he saw something in him, but not if he continued on his current path. So I'm sorry, that's a quite a preamble. Now to get to your question, that he first lands in Morocco. Actually, when he lands in Morocco, he kicks a guy in the ass with all his might, a U.S. soldier, he hits a bunch of U.S. soldiers, he hits a bunch of Arabs. He really hated Arabs almost as much as Sicilians and Jews, Jews probably the most, and blacks, but you know, and British women. He hated just about anybody who wasn't a Christian white male.

SPEAKER_01He is pulled in as Eisenhower's third choice to replace the corps commander after the Battle of Kazarine Pass to run the second corps. Patton shows up, he believes one thing he should do is change the dress code and be much more strict. This is a relatively standard thing one is taught in business school and management if you come into a situation how to get everybody's attention and have them start listening to you.

SPEAKER_01But you know, in the movie, it sounds like it's a really good thing. Bradley, his deputy commander, wrote, after just a few days of this, uh the men of two corps were fighting mad. Not at the Germans, but at George Patton himself. And uh not in the movie, of course, is an instance where Patton um humiliates one of his subordinate generals in front of that general's troops to such an extent that Patton is almost shot by his own men and has to make a quick getaway.

SPEAKER_01Uh be happy to go into that, or we could go right into the.

SPEAKER_00Listen, you can't, you can't you can't stop right there. Our listeners are the listeners might shoot me at this point in time. That's too juicy at this point.

SPEAKER_01All right. So the head of there are three and move up to four divisions in two corps that Patton takes over in early 1943. One of them is the famous Big Red One, the 1st Infantry Division at the time, uh, and through the end of the Sicily campaign, commanded by General Terrible Terry Allen and his deputy commander uh Teddy Roosevelt Jr., son of the president. And Patton shows up uh to inspect the headquarters of the 1st Infantry Division, and he sees a whole bunch of slit trenches outside the tents because Luff Watha had been bombing them from time to time, and they dug these trenches so the officers could jump into the trenches during air raids.

SPEAKER_01Well, Patton thought jumping into a trench was a sign of cowardice. So he asked uh Terry Allen, which trench is yours? And Allen pointed at one, and Patton walked over, uh, unbuttoned his fly, and took a leak into the trench, and then said to Terry Allen, now try and use it. And both uh Roosevelt and Bradley relate uh later that um there was an audible sound of the safeties being taken off of the uh or being switched off on the Tommy guns uh held by Terry Allen's personal bodyguard.

SPEAKER_01And Patton realizing, you know, I probably don't want to get shot, maybe I've overdone it, he jumps in his Jeep uh with his driver and uh takes off as fast as he can. Um the first infantry division hated Patton. They hated him in Tunisia, they came to hate him even more in Sicily. Uh when he apologized to them after the slapping incident, when he finished speaking, there was nothing but stony silence from the troops.

SPEAKER_00We see throughout the film, you know, there there are several remarks where like, oh, your men must love you. He's like, I don't know, they hate is like I don't need them to love me. I just need them to do be soldiers and blah blah blah. Is he just utterly unaware of the fact that like he rubs people the wrong way? Does he simply just not care? Is he like what happens with this guy?

SPEAKER_01Well, uh, you know, Patton before the uh World War II begins, he's one of the wealthiest men in the army. He's already rich and he marries Beatrice Eyer from a very wealthy New England family. He's probably the richest man in the army, by far, one of the probably one of the richest men in the United States. And men in the army, officers in the army are not paid much. And he um he throws big, big, extravagant parties. Polo matches, balls, uh, cocktail parties.

SPEAKER_01Um and that helps him become friends with Eisenhower, with uh John Marshall, who becomes, I'm sorry, George Marshall, my mistake, who becomes chief of staff, uh and uh Henry Stimson, who he had been aide to when Stimson was uh Secretary of War in the 1910s, and just luckily for Patent becomes Secretary of War again for World War II, he often would yell and scream and cry and um and swear, uh use a just a blue streak of bad language in mixed company at these parties, and uh he definitely made some enemies, he definitely made some friends.

SPEAKER_01And this continues through Patton's entire career in World War II. So, yes, he knew he rubbed some people the wrong way. I think it's a fair statement to say, I don't need them to love me, I just hope they'll fear me. Uh that's what Machiavelli might have said, better, better the fear. Um and then so that comes down to a question: you know, did the GIs love Patton or did they hate him? And I think the answer is many of them loved him, many of them hated him, some of them it was both.

SPEAKER_01Uh, at the end of the Sicily campaign, there was a correspondent who went to Eisenhower to complain to him about the slapping incident, which I'm sure we'll get to, and said there are 50,000 men on this island who are ready to shoot General Patton. And he was talking about U.S. soldiers. Uh, U.S. soldiers complained that about Patton's nickname, Old Blood and Guts. Uh, it was uh Our Blood and His Guts. Many of the correspondents from Yang and Stars and Stripes that spent so much time with the GIs, men like Ernie Pyle or Andy Rooney or Bill Malden, the cartoonist, they came away with a very negative opinion and said very negative things about Patton and said that's what the GIs thought of him.

SPEAKER_01But of course, Patton had a fabulous reputation back home. And uh I think to a certain extent, many of the men who came home who maybe didn't love Patton, who cared about their uh battalion or their company, that's what they cared about more than their division or their corps or their army, uh, then soon they would say, I was with Patton. Because if you had been with Patton, you were seen as uh being a hero because Patton was the greatest hero of the European theater to most Americans on the home front.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, he seems like a rock star in some ways in this era pre-internet, something like, I mean, like I said, the mythology of this guy seems to build, and then once he's established as a hero, and this is you know, this is obviously a time uh when we when during World War II we're looking for heroes, right? Like, you know, there's John Basilone or any number of other guys, Audie Murphy, uh, and I'm thinking about, right? And then of course, in the United States, we'll talk about this a little bit later on. We love a good general, even if apparently, James, that general isn't all that good to begin with.

SPEAKER_00And I, you know, you talk about this, I kept thinking about you know you you mentioned his talking to Eisenhower, and he he does feel like he's he's trying to emulate Stuart just kind of running around all over the place because Stewart was in love with his own glory, it felt like, and constantly off doing something else. There are so many illusions here that I want to make.

SPEAKER_01Well, to make it to make one really important distinction, back in the 1860s, Jeb Stewart could ride off his cavalry, and he and his men could live off the land. The horses could eat the grass, they could raid for some supplies. The tooth-to-tail ratio is a whole lot different in the 1940s. And the ability to surge a large mechanized formation behind enemy lines without securing your flanks, securing a constant supply of uh fuel, of um lubricants, of food and ammo, you're not gonna last very long.

SPEAKER_01So it's very different than what Patton had in his mind's eye as to hey to Eisenhower, hey, the next war you be Lee, I'll be Stuart.

SPEAKER_00Well, I've got a question here that you know, we talk about how the American perception or the soldiers' perception uh of Patton, and one of the little things we see throughout the film is every so often they'll they'll flip to the Germans watching Patton, talking about Patton. And I almost feel like this this goes to again elevate Patton himself because they're singling him out. Do we get a sense of, and this is kind of a two-part question, do we get a sense of how the Germans viewed Patton? And was their focus on Patton a singular thing, or were they kind of watching all the generals?

SPEAKER_00I have to imagine they're watching Montgomery as well, and some of these and these other guys trying to get a sense of who they're going up against and what they're what that guy might do.

SPEAKER_01Unfortunately, the uh image from the movie that Patton was greatly feared by the Germans is simply not true. Uh, it comes out of two things. One, it comes out of uh a suggestion from an officer on Marshall's staff after the slapping incident to use Patton as a decoy around the Mediterranean when Patton's uh reputation is too hot and he just can't be used in combat anywhere. Uh, but Marshall and Eisenhower are trying to find a reason not to relieve him and bring him back to the States.

SPEAKER_01Um, so they were just thinking, well, he had been one of the leaders of one of the three landings in Torch. He had commanded Second Corps for a little while and he had been in charge of the Sicily campaign landings for the U.S. troops. The Germans must fear him. The truth of the matter was they didn't. And that's not my opinion. Uh there is a scholar, Harry Yeedy, who wrote a book entitled Fighting Patton, which is the view of Patton from the German side, and he's gone through all the German archives, and they just they didn't fear him.

SPEAKER_01They saw him as a good tactical commander, but um, he was not a theater commander, he was not an army group commander, um, he was not a strategist. Um, I argue with my book, he was not particularly good at operations, and that just leaves tactics. And I argue in my book on many occasions, he wasn't very good at tactics, and he acted more like uh what we criticize World War I generals for rather than acting like a World War II general. Um so unfortunately, uh Ladislav Farrago, who wrote the book that became the uh foundation for the screenplay of the movie Patton, uh, incorporated that image of Patton being um someone that was feared by the Germans.

SPEAKER_01And um Farrago talks about it in the book that the Germans watched Patton's comings and goings across the Mediterranean like spectators at a Wimbledon match, with their head going back and forth watching the the ball. That just is not the case. Germans, of course, they knew about Patton, they did want to know about him, but as you mentioned, according to Harry Edi's book, they really did care about where Montgomery was and they feared Montgomery. But if they feared anyone, they feared Zhukov, they feared the Red Army. They were not that worried about the U.S.

SPEAKER_01Army. So um the image of Patton back home in the U.S. versus the image to the German uh soldiers or just German military intelligence was a whole lot different. And just to relate for one moment about how Patton was seen at home, as you were saying, he was held up as a hero. Oh, absolutely. The War Department um put up posters of Patton looking tough with his war face. Patton used to practice his war face in the mirror to look tough, um, with you know, with the shiny helmet on at the front, with these uh messages under it exhorting the workers in the war production plants to work harder, work an extra shift, buy war bonds.

SPEAKER_01And that probably was Patton's greatest contribution to the war for the U.S. was undoubtedly he got the American people to believe in the war and work harder and work longer and contribute more to the war than maybe they would have otherwise. And that probably isn't why most people think of Patton as being a good general, but I do believe that was his greatest contribution to the war effort.

SPEAKER_00James, you and I both obviously love history. Uh the people that are listening to this pod love history. We he we see Patton talking about history all the time. I I, as a child, even I remembered him getting up there and talking about places being the most conquered in the history of the world, and blah, blah, blah, we've conquered it too. Um, do you get a sense when you're going back through the archives and you're reading the man's writing and his own memoirs and his own thoughts? How did he internalize history? Was he a fan or was this kind of made up that we see in the film? Like, what role did history play in its own you know internal debate?

SPEAKER_01Sure, it is in no way made up in the movie. Patton was a very well-read student of military history. Um, he was in he loved European history, he spoke French fluently, and uh he did study things like uh, for example, when he was going to join the Normandy campaign late in the Normandy campaign as head of the newly activated Third Army, he was reading through the Norman conquest because William the Conqueror was running about Normandy before he sailed to England.

SPEAKER_01And Pat was trying to take a look at what roads he followed because he figured if the roads were good enough to be used in uh the 11th century, they're probably ones that um would be pretty good roads today in the 1940s to use. But a point that's quite important to make is the movie almost seems to make it out as if Pat was the only US general who ever picked up a book. And nothing could be further from the truth. You you could not get through uh an RTC program or VMI or most importantly West Point without becoming a real student of military history.

SPEAKER_01Um, you know, Bradley was a real student of military history. Eisenhower was a deep thinker and a deep reader on all these pillar books of Western Civ. Um Walter Krueger, who was the um ended up being the commander of the 7th Army in the Pacific, uh, he spoke uh French, English, uh, German, and Spanish fluently and taught at the naval uh in the Naval War College for many years, teaching amphibious operations, combined armed operations.

SPEAKER_01Patton was not the only well-read person who cared about history and cared about being a warrior and what warriors had been in the past. And of course, this comes into a real conflict between what Patton had read about what we now call PTSD and what the U.S. Army Medical Corps believes they should do about what they then called combat fatigue, and we now call it PTSD, versus Patton's belief that any man who shies away from a fight is just a coward. So Patton was a great student of history, but it doesn't mean he drew the conclusions that many of his peers and many others drew who are also students of military history.

SPEAKER_00Well, you talk about his peers here, and you know, the guy that I kept following when I'm watching this is actually Carl Malton. And I'm I'm kind of fascinated with Omar Bradley as I'm as I'm watching this, and I'm you know, I know Omar Bradley, you know, he's five the final five-star general, if I'm correct. What was that relationship like between the two? And of course, Bradley becomes his superior over time. What happens between the two? Do the do the men like each other? Bradley writes about Patton. Uh what's that dynamic between the two of these two uh men?

SPEAKER_01Uh I think complicated is definitely the best adjective to use for that relationship. Uh, when Bradley was sent in by Eisenhower to become the uh he became the deputy commander of two corps in Tunisia under Patton for about five, six weeks. Um, he called in his memory, he thought that Patton was a maniac uh in terms of having, he said, you know, get me my helmet quick before that maniac comes in here and sees that I don't have my helmet on. Uh, he, of course, was not happy with what uh Patton urinating in a um a seasoned commander's uh general trench.

SPEAKER_01Um Patton writes in his diary about how he slaps a chaplain in Tunisia. Um, you know, I don't know why he slapped the chaplain. He just says he did it. Uh, and anyone can look it up and see in his handwriting in the Library of Congress that he did. Um soon as Patton handed over Tucor to Bradley, Bradley relaxed the draconian dress codes that Patton had imposed. And I know it may be a shock, but uh efficiency and combat performance of Tucor did not collapse when the men didn't have to wear neckties into combat in the desert.

SPEAKER_01And uh Tucor under Bradley did quite well and took Bersert, uh, the island of the city of Bersert at the same time the British took uh Tunis. In uh Sicily, things get a lot worse. Uh Bradley said that, said writes that had he had a say, he would have relieved Patton of command. Um, when men of the 45th Infantry Division, as I mentioned earlier, um, execute uh about uh 75 uh Tyne and German prisoners at the Biscarry airfield.

SPEAKER_01Bradley finds out about it, brings it to Patton. Patton writes, Bradley, a good man, brought this to me, and he's all excited about it. But look, these men there are dead, so there's nothing we can do about it. So falsify the report, say they were snipers or trying to escape or something. Anything but, you know, they were murdered by troops. And Patton had given two speeches to the men of the 45th, telling them to bayonet in the chest men who are trying to surrender, enemy who are trying to surrender.

SPEAKER_01And some, of course, will just say, oh, well, that was Patton being Patton, you know, isn't wasn't he great. But there's a real there was a real uh military reason not to kill prisoners. Because if you kill prisoners, then German soldiers won't give up and they'll keep fighting and more Americans will die. And also then when Americans are captured, the Germans will shoot the American prisoners. And we wanted to get those guys back at the end of the war if they were taken prisoner. So Bradley is not happy with that. He's not happy with um the friendly fire incident that uh that Patton orders.

SPEAKER_01We could talk about that. Uh, it's the worst friendly fire incident in um World War II for U.S. forces. And uh also he is disgusted by Patton uh wanting to be the first into um Messina and also uh beating Montgomery to Messina and then leading the forces personally into Messina. Um Bradley later, when he is made head of U.S. Forces landing in D-Day, he is not consulted by Eisenhower when Eisenhower comes to tell him that Patton is gonna run Third Army and you're gonna be his boss.

SPEAKER_01And uh Bradley wrote, I would not have chosen him. I would have been against it if my opinion had been asked, but it wasn't asked, and I'm a soldier, so we're gonna go ahead and do it. Bradley does say that Patton behaves himself a lot better during um the campaign in France and Germany. He doesn't mention anything about the wholesale theft of supplies that are supposed to go to Bradley's first army, uh, and Patton is stealing for the third army. I don't know how much he knew about it. Uh Bradley did write about the Hammelburg raid we could write about, where Patton sent an armored company behind German lines for his own greater glory and to try and um uh rescue his Patton's own son-in-law, who was in the POW camp.

SPEAKER_01Bradley's, instead of relieving him of command, says that Patton's failures is his own chastisement. Um, and since scores of generals were relieved by Bradley as well as other um senior generals in World War II, you know, there are many generals in World War II who wish that their failure would have been their only punishment. By the end of the war, things are not good. And as I understand it, uh Patton on his deathbed tells his wife, I don't want Eisenhower nor Bradley at my funeral, and they're not there.

SPEAKER_00Okay, there's so many places to go here. Uh, and I don't want to give away the entirety of the book because I want people to read this because I found it effectively.

SPEAKER_01And I apologize that that was such a long answer, but boy, there's a lot to unpack there when you say, What was the relationship?

SPEAKER_00No, James, I gotta tell you, when I when I do these pods, the best conversations I have is where I can sit there and I can go, and then what happened? So it's good. Um but I do want to know because I hadn't what I didn't know about this. I didn't know about this friendly fire incident. Again, we don't see it in the film. It's not really publicized, at least I wasn't familiar with it. Can we talk a little bit about what happened there? Because this is the largest friendly fire incident in World War II. Is that correct?

SPEAKER_01Uh there are a couple of larger ones. There's one uh at the beginning of uh Operation. Cobra in Normandy, where US bombers uh drop some of their bombs short. Uh, there's also uh bombing of a POW train in um Western Europe and in Germany, uh, where Americans are killed. But uh because more than 200 elite U.S. paratroopers are killed, and about 25 uh transport C-47s are shot down along with their pilots, uh, who are elite, uh part of an elite unit as well.

SPEAKER_01This is by far the most um militarily expensive, largest, most critical friendly fire incident of the war. And it was one that could have oh so easily have been um avoided.

SPEAKER_00It feels to me the thing he's most famous for is the slapping incident. And it feels like that's where the film itself turns. Everything feels like it's a kind of building up to and uh and is a response to the the incident. Can you kind of bring us back up to this and talk about what we see on screen? Uh you said earlier, he he just views anybody who's not fighting as a coward, but that comes across in the film pretty well. What happens with this slapping is uh on the on the guy's helmet? Like what happens here?

SPEAKER_01Sure, and of course, it is a great story. It's a great American story. It's got this great hero, then he has this tragic fall from grace, and then he has to be redeemed and redeems himself and rides off to good to glory. Great story. Um, as I think I've just expressed uh in the last 20 minutes, you know, Patton struck people in France, he struck people, his own troops in France, in Morocco, in Tunisia, and then we get to Sicily. Uh so he's already gone. This is a pattern of behavior. And Patton goes to an evacuation hospital near the front, near Messina, uh, close to the end of the campaign, and he is visiting wounded troops, and there's a soldier there who is looking a little disoriented but doesn't seem to be wounded, and he says, Hey son, well, you know, where were you hit?

SPEAKER_01And he says, I wasn't. Well, why are you here? And he says, I just can't take it anymore. And Patton doesn't ask the doctors what's going on. He just flies into a rage and uh slaps him with his gloves and knocks his uh helmet off and tells him to get back to the front. Now it turns out this private, private uh Cole, K-U-H-L, uh, was suffering from malaria and was running a high fever at the time. Um, but this wasn't the only time. There were two slapping incidents because Patton goes back a week later and he thought doing it the first time was great.

SPEAKER_01And remember, he's asking the press to come with him. And he goes into a different evacuation hospital. He sees a bunch of wounded guys he talks to, then he sees another man who doesn't seem to be wounded, uh, Private Bennett, and he slaps this guy, and then he pulls out one of his famous ivory handled revolvers, aims it at his face, and says, I ought to shoot you myself right now. Orders him back. And then he storms out of the, uh, after slapping him, storms out of the tent, and he's been yelling and screaming.

SPEAKER_01So a crowd of nurses and doctors are confregating, and Patton yells out, There is no such thing as shell shock. It is an invention of the Jews. And that definitely did not make it into the 1970 movie. Not so much. Then a couple days later, Patton puts out a formal memorandum under his signature to all commanders in Seventh Army, his army at the time, that there will be no combat fatigue cases in his unit or in his command.

SPEAKER_01Uh, they will not be sent to field hospitals or aid stations, and they will be court-martialed in place. So this is exactly what he believed, and he thought he was doing a good thing. I would like to point out this is very different than the US Army Medical Corps, which knew about what they called combat fatigue. They believed in combat fatigue, and they believed that their regimen, that was known as Pi, P I E for proximity, immediacy, and expectancy, was the most the best way to improve combat readiness and combat effectiveness of the unit.

SPEAKER_01You would take these men in at an aid station or uh an evac hospital, you'd give them, you'd keep them, so proximity, you'd keep them close to the front expectancy, you would tell them that, hey, you're gonna be fine soon, you're gonna be back with your unit, you're gonna be fighting again soon. You give them barbites and food, have them rest and get them back to the front line where they might get killed. But at least about 75% of these men were able to get back to the front and keep fighting. And if the U.S. Army had followed Patton's uh advice, it would have taken longer to win the war against Germany.

SPEAKER_01So, in any event, this story is suppressed by Eisenhower. And the censors don't write about it, or don't allow any writing about it. But the journalists don't even write about it. A bunch of them, emissaries, go to Eisenhower's headquarters and say this was terrible. And Eisenhower says, You're absolutely right. And I know about it. I got a report from the U.S. Medical Corps. And they say, Well, what are we going to do about it? We you know, you gotta punish Patten. And Eisenhower says, I'll tell you what, I'll promise you, I will punish Patton as long as you don't write about it.

SPEAKER_01And the journalists shake hands with him, and one of the journalists said, We're Americans first and journalists second, and if this story got out, it would be bad for the war effort. So it doesn't come out until some soldiers go back to the U.S. and talk about it, and it gets to Drew Pearson, a famous correspondent in Washington Newscover late night radio show, and he breaks it on his radio show, and Drew Pearson says, There's one slapping, one incident, nothing about the Jews, nothing about this memo, uh, that there are no combat fatigue cases allowed.

SPEAKER_01And um, Drew Pearson says that Patton will never command GIs in combat again. And um for a while it looks like that actually might be the case.

SPEAKER_00Eisenhower is constantly coming to Patton's rescue in the sum. We've kind of alluded to it. We also know this relationship ends poorly uh at the end. What is it that Eisenhower does Eisenhower just have this rugged Cansan uh loyalty to people? Like, what is it in Patton that Eisenhower sees and why does he continue to kind of shield this guy and kind of bring him back up?

SPEAKER_01I thought about it many times, and it came up many times when I was writing this book, Patton Reconsidered, and I don't have a great answer for you. I think some of it was loyalty, but remember, it wasn't just Eisenhower, it was Marshall as well, and Stimson as well, and to a certain extent, Pershing as well, though Pershing finally broke with Patton after the slapping incident. He was just too appalled he he they never corresponded or spoke again. Um The Washington Post, another time when Patton caused uh got himself in trouble in the Knoxford affair.

SPEAKER_01It's also in the movie where he says the the British, the Americans, and the Russians are destined to rule the world. That's probably not great for the French and the Chinese uh and many other Allied peoples who are fighting to find out they're going to be ruled by uh this triumph of countries. Um the Washington Post editorial page has an editorial saying uh once again the um the this click of senior army officers are circling the wagons around uh one of their own who has acted out and are protecting him.

SPEAKER_01And Marshall actually quotes from this editorial in his letter to Eisenhower. And I think there's some truth to it. So I think there are multiple parts to the answer, but um sorry, Jason, I I don't have a really clear-cut answer for you as to why Eisenhower just didn't pull the plug on this guy when he did pull the plug and relieved so many other generals and colonels throughout the war.

SPEAKER_00I want to talk about Patton's relationships to other people. Uh, because we see one African-American soldier, his valet, in the film. And that relationship seems to be pretty good, seems to be pretty respectful from what we see on screen. And I have become dismayed at what I learned more and more about Patton as this horrible racist and anti-Semite. Can you talk about how Patton saw race and like this is pretty true? You know, desegregating the troops. Like, how does Patton see African American soldiers?

SPEAKER_01Well, they were certainly good enough to be ballets for him. Um, there is a moment in that movie where his valet says, oh, just one slap, one dog face, meaning one GI, one slap once, and that was all it did. Of course, as we've just discussed, it was more than just one slap that done. Uh Patton uh did express when he got some tankers uh that were black that he thought that blacks could fight, but they just didn't have the brain power or the reactions to be able to fight in armor.

SPEAKER_01Though, again, he he didn't like blacks too much, but he disliked a lot of people. Uh, you know, when he was sent around the Mediterranean, if you read through his uh diary, he engaged in a lot of freelance uh racism. He hated just about everybody he met, uh, besides the French and um American Christians. I will point out that during the Battle of the Bulge and soon after, when there was a real manpower shortage in rifle companies uh because of too many U.S. casualties, we did have some integration which took place and did take place in Third Army under patent.

SPEAKER_01So perhaps that um should be something that we should point out as a positive form. And also he did say, you know, I don't care what color you are, if you're willing to fight for me, I'll give you everything I've got. And um, you know, I will note that you know he hated Jews, but when he wanted his um son-in-law to be rescued from a POW camp, he sent this guy Baum, Task Force Baum off. And Bomb was a Jewish guy, and it was a suicide mission. Uh Baum didn't actually die, he was wounded.

SPEAKER_01And uh as he was being captured, he tore off his dog tags because they had a star David on it, and he threw him into the bushes so uh he wouldn't end up in a concentration camp and get shot by the Germans, because um it was well known that that many Jews who were captured never either never made it to a POW camp, uh, or you know, they ended up in a different sort of camp than a POW camp. So uh Pat was willing to use whoever he got, but it didn't mean he liked it.

SPEAKER_00Well, I'm gonna hop over to Europe for a second here, uh to main to mainland Europe, because the image we get here, this is building up to his uh boy, growing up in Kentucky, this is this is a tough one to talk about. Uh, you know, his his his rescue of the 101st. And I know that my my folks back in Fort Campbell uh are gonna debate this, but you talk a lot about you know that a lot of the prowess and victories that he's attributed to, this this cunning and success, luck, right guy, right place.

SPEAKER_00Other other generals could have done the same thing. Like, how do we think about Patton as a battlefield commander as he's heading up to Bastone and these wins and he's amenacing and so forth? How do we account for that?

SPEAKER_01All right. Well, first of all, in terms of luck, absolutely, Patton was a very lucky general. And of course, Napoleon said, hey, lucky that's the primary characteristic I wanted my generals. So Patton would have been a great Napoleonic general. Of course, he said he was, but that's right. Um actually, I believe he would have said he was a soldier and remembers crossing the Danube with Napoleon at a big rock. And um, so he was very lucky. You know, he was lucky that he wasn't relieved on many occasions. Before World War II, he had the luck or skill to make the right friends.

SPEAKER_01Um, in the armored corps right before World War II, he was lucky that uh one of his superiors got cancer and died, which sucked him up a level, and then his direct superior got sent off to be a liaison to the British in Africa in Cairo, and that sucked Patton up another promotion level. And then for the Torch Landings, he wasn't supposed to be the head of the Western Task Force in Morocco. That was supposed to be General Eichelberger, who MacArthur really liked, and MacArthur demanded that Robert Eichelberger be sent out to be a corps commander for him in the Southwest Pacific, and then Patton got the job.

SPEAKER_01And then for two corps, when Eisenhower wanted to uh relieve Fredenal after Kazarine passed, first he asked General Harmon, Harman said no. Uh, he asked General Clark, Clark said no. So Eisenhower went to his third choice, Patton. A lot of luck here. And in um battle after battle, you almost always see that uh throughout the European theater, Patton is almost always uh up against the weakest part of the opposing line, and almost always is up against uh men who are um either uh demoralized, fought out, or actually beginning to um uh to pull a retreat or surrender.

SPEAKER_01Um in terms of Baston, uh the Battle of the Bulge is probably Patton's greatest moment, and he deserves credit for it. Um however, the first army, men of the first army were very unhappy with how much credit Patton got for winning uh the so-called quote-unquote winning, the Battle of the Bulge. They felt that he did not, and he he did the men of the First Army did create the breakout in Normandy um uh in earlier in 1944, so that Patton was able to break out.

SPEAKER_01That was done by the fighting of the First Army. First Army guys said Patton didn't break out, he walked out. And then when the Germans had a counterattack at Mortain to uh cut off um Patton's Third Army supply line, it was the First Army that stopped that counterattack. In Battle of the Bulges, First Army did almost all, did most of the fighting. But as you mentioned, 101st uh went to Bastogne. They weren't the only unit there, there were some other units there, and they were surrounded.

SPEAKER_01Um, and potentially they there was concern that they would uh be forced to surrender. However, as Patton is driving north to get to them to relieve them, uh 101st starts getting uh supplied by the air. The paratroopers were used to fighting while surrounded, they had been trained for that mission. That's nothing new to them, and they were actually on the offensive and pushing out their perimeter in some places when Patton's third army got to Bastone. So, of course, uh famously at the end of an episode in Band of Brothers, it says the men of the 101st that they never needed any saving.

SPEAKER_01Thank you very much. And uh I think I have to side with the men of the 101st on that side of the argument because um the 101st, if it had been a fought-out, just about to surrender unit, it would have been pulled back from the line. But instead, they were pushed forward for another two and a half, three weeks where they continued fighting in the Battle of the Bulge as the U.S. went over to the offensive. And so that seems to me to not be a unit that was uh fought out and about to surrender.

SPEAKER_01But Patton should get credit for reacting relatively quickly. He did not actually react as quickly as General Simpson of the Ninth Army, who transferred more units, got more units into the fight, into the battle than Patton's Third Army did faster, more units and faster than Patton's units did. But Patton deserves a lot of credit for what took place at Bastone. And if Patton had not relieved Bastone, even if the 101st didn't surrender, certainly many more men of the 101st would have been killed. So he did save a lot of their lives, even if they didn't need saving.

SPEAKER_01Thank you very much.

SPEAKER_00We see a glimpse of this after the war of Patton in Germany and the denazification program. And there's a lot of pushback again. He's he's he is arguing with his superiors on what he's doing, he's catching flack. What's Patton like as a post-war commander? It doesn't last long. Terrible.

SPEAKER_01Um, he really wanted to be sent off to uh the Pacific to fight against Japan, and he wanted to uh run big tank armies that were uh driving across the northern plains of China, killing Japanese. Um, because of course Japanese had conquered most of China at that time. Um Marshall and Eisenhower don't trust Pat anymore and don't think he's the right guy for the job. And they choose uh Courtney Hodges, the general in charge of the First Army, pull Hodges and his whole staff and send them to the Pacific uh to lead an army in the uh planned invasion of Japan.

SPEAKER_01And then they pull Alexander Patch, uh, the general of the and commander of the 7th Army out also uh southern Germany and send him back to Texas and he was going to run another army in the invasion, though Patch died of pneumonia. Um so Patton is left with a job he hates, which is military governor of Bavaria. He's been writing to his wife that without war, there's nothing for me left. He's writing to his brother uh-in-law, Frank Ayer, uh, saying, hey, you're gonna have to help me find a big estate where I can do a lot of hunting and fishing and sailing.

SPEAKER_01There's nothing left for me except death and my own immortality, of course. But Patton comes up with an idea well before the German surrender, which is how about another war? How about we start fighting the Red Army and push those darn Asiatics back to Moscow because they can't be trusted. And of course, he, you know, Patton was not a strategist. He had no idea that the Red Army was supposed to join us in the war against um Japan two months after the German surrender.

SPEAKER_01That was the deal made at Yalta between FDR and Stalin. So Patton begins treating the Germans very well because he thinks he needs to rearm the Germans to help him go on this uh crusade to uh march on Moscow. And to keep the Jews happy, I'm sorry, the Germans happy, he needs to be really bad to the Jews. And he there are a lot of Jews left uh emaciated, starved, uh dispirited who are displaced persons in these concentration camps, those who've not been killed by the end of the war.

SPEAKER_01And uh this really leads to a flowering of uh uh Patton's anti-Semitism. And he writes some of the worst things you could imagine about Jews, and he basically actually doesn't basically, he just writes they're not human, they're below humans. Um so his uh refusal to fire Nazis from uh positions in the civil government in Bavaria and his unwillingness to treat Jews well uh leads to a reprimand from Eisenhower, and then when Patton still refuses to follow those orders, and then says being a Nazi in Nazi Germany was kind of like being a Democrat or a Republican in the United States.

SPEAKER_01That's the final straw, even for Eisenhower, and Eisenhower finally relieves him of command. Um, and that's the end of Patton's military career.

SPEAKER_00I want to ask you a little bit, uh you know, historians we love to play with contingency in these ideas. So, you know, you've been you've name checked a lot of generals, a lot of people who I who I don't even know about. I remember reading some of these guys when I was start first started reading it, reading uh Rick Atkinson's trilogy uh some years ago. But I'm wondering, as you're studying through all of this and you're seeing Patton, you're seeing his contemporaries, are there guys that would have done a better job that could have possibly been placed in command where he was? You know, obviously Bradley gets get you know get gets a job at some point, but like are his could you know could could have other men done a better job than than George Patton?

SPEAKER_01Well, certainly many men have could have done a better job because um it's certainly in the area of diplomacy, comportment, um, insubordination. Um Pat was constantly uh disparaging Eisenhower uh to his staff and his troops and to the press, um, despite the fact that you know he was really biting the hand that was feeding him, despite the fact that Eisenhower was was the only thing he in many cases stayed between Patton and being relieved.

SPEAKER_01Um so I, you know, there were other US troops in other U.S. armies than the third and the seventh in World War II that shot prisoners. But I don't know of any other general commander of a field army in the U.S. that encouraged his men to um shoot prisoners. We didn't really talk too much about that friendly fire incident, but he patent was told by Matthew Ridgway, the head of the 82nd Airborne, don't do this drop. He was told by the his naval co the naval commander in the area, Admiral Hewitt, don't do this drop.

SPEAKER_01It's gonna then lead to friendly fire deaths. And Pat overruled them and did it anyway. I I don't know of any other general who led a field army in the US who ordered such uh an action that led to uh such a blue on blue event. Um Alexander Patch was an excellent field general, could have done, I think, just As well tactically as Patton. He was one of the heroes and effectively was the Corps commander that won the Battle of Guadalcanal, then took over the 7th Army, landed in the French Southern France, the French Riviera, and raced even faster than the Third Army had moved to get up to the German frontier.

SPEAKER_01General Eichelberger, who I already mentioned, who ended up running Eighth Army in the Pacific, also was a very aggressive commander in terms of uh quick slash and attack that Patton was known for, but without causing all these controversies and without acting in a way that was unbecoming, not just unbecoming to U.S. officer, but was actually criminal in nature. So my sh conclusion short answer is other men could have done what Patton did without all the warts and all that came along with General George S.

SPEAKER_01Patton Jr.

SPEAKER_00Patton dies unexpectedly in his 60s, young for a soldier, uh for a career soldier at least.

SPEAKER_01Actually, not in those days, not in those days. He was actually one of the oldest. And I was almost surprised that he was uh that that you know Marshall fired most of the older generals that would have been Patton's age. And so he was pretty old for that period. The only other field army general who was older was Kruger. And it was only because Kruger was just so good and because MacArthur demanded him as his army commander in the Pacific, his first army commander in the Pacific, that Kruger was not farmed out into a training role in the States.

SPEAKER_01And Kruger was surprised. He thought he would have been believed. So 60 in those days, in hard a lot of hard drinking, a lot of smoking, uh, a lot of red meat eating. Um, you know, men didn't last as long there. And you know, several of the U.S. field army generals didn't live that long after World War II. For example, Patches, I mentioned, who died soon after.

SPEAKER_00Um I'm kind of wondering, you know, I uh I fell asleep watching the documentary on Grant the other night because I have a real exciting life lately. Um but as historians, we love rankings, we love to talk about people. I think you know, one of the things about this book is that really just really just beats the snot out of the mythology of Patton here. But I'm wondering is you know, you've studied these other generals, MacArthur and so forth. When we start start to think about who the great American generals are, well, golly, I think Patton is no longer in contention here.

SPEAKER_00But do you have uh an informed opinion about who you like that you've studied and have come across, you know, who do you like as these American generals?

SPEAKER_01Uh absolutely. And I uh, you know, in this book, Patent Reconsider, I am certainly not just trying to uh take cheap shots at Patton. I'm trying to point out the Biscari massacre, the Jella-friendly fire incident, uh the slapping incident with all the uh the assaults that took place beforehand, the Hammelburg raid. These are all things we know about. Many of them didn't come out until after World War II, but they were all known and in the public domain before uh the 1970 movie Patton was made.

SPEAKER_01Um I also try and give Patton credit where credit is due, and I also try to very much point out that if we're going to say that Patton was a military genius, then we need to say that Bradley and Eichelberger and Patch and Hodges and Pike Simpson and Kruger, they were also military geniuses. And they I don't think they were all military geniuses, but Eichelberger was arguably the best U.S. field army commander in World War II. Patch, he fought in jungles, on beaches, uh in the French Riviera, in snow, snowy mountains on the uh French German frontier.

SPEAKER_01He won on the defensive, he won on the offensive. Uh, you know, he deserves to be much better known. And Courtney Hodges, partly because Pat didn't like him, and because Montgomery didn't like him. Almost nobody knows the name of Courtney Hodges, but his first army uh was the one that stopped the big German counterattack in Normandy. It was the army that uh liberated Paris, it was the army that got across the Rhine the first uh first, it fought more German units and better German units and moved even further, captured even more territory or went even further distance than Patton's third army did.

SPEAKER_01So if we are looking for heroes and great generals from World War II, they're there. And unfortunately, if we want to look at what Patton did, we need to look past the mythology and look at the actual facts. And as you mentioned, I think he slips down the list pretty significantly.

SPEAKER_00You know, to draw this back to the film itself, I asked you to say, hey, we're gonna watch this movie again. I said that was like this is a three-hour film. Great job, Jason. Um what are your thoughts on this, James? I'm assuming you know we you you've seen a lot of other other war films and so forth. Where does Patton rank when you start to think about these war films, these stories about World War II or even America writ large? How do you knowing what you know about Patton now, how do we conceptualize this film? How do we feel about this film?

SPEAKER_01You know, the film's a great piece of art, but it's it's a fiction. You know, I don't have time to go through, but there must be I I probably have a list of 50 historical inaccuracies that take place in the in the film. And many of them are unnecessary fabrications that Hollywood inserted. I don't know why. Um so you know, in terms of uh I don't understand why we are unable to um celebrate many of the actual great heroes of World War II, and the of course the real great heroes were the the guys in the front line rather than the generals.

SPEAKER_01And um, you know, unfortunately, patent stands out today still in a legacy that you know we have people who still say we need more patents today. And I think we we want exactly the opposite of patents. We don't want soldiers who are insubordinate, we don't want uh generals who are uh demeaning to their fellow officers, their subordinate officers, we don't want generals who physically assault uh uh uh enlisted men.

SPEAKER_01Um we you you know if generals have uh um opinions of other uh uh the opposite gender or other races or other ethnicities, you know, that that's fine, but they I would imagine need to keep it to themselves to run a uh multi-ethnic force that is the United States Army today. So I think we need to be very careful about demanding more patents because we may just get them if that's what we're asking for.

SPEAKER_00You know, you spent all this time talking about the past, spend you know, going back to World War II, going back to 1970 uh with this film. Um what's in your future? What what comes next? Are there other guys you're you're eyeing to uh to take a look at historically? Are you do you have the next project lined up? Are you are you taking a break? What happens for you now?

SPEAKER_01Uh a little bit of taking a break. I'm working on a couple of things, uh, and uh I I don't have a a new book contract or or book plan just yet, but I'll be working soon enough, I promise you.

SPEAKER_00Well, uh Jay's I'd have to first of all have to thank you, and I really gotta thank the people at your press for like reaching out to me because I don't get a chance to read World War II very often with my own work and stuff like that. And I started as I started to get into the book, I just couldn't stop being in the book. Um, I really enjoyed it. I really dug it. Um it was really fun to read this, think about this film that we know so well, uh, and really kind of have my thoughts. And this is what you love as history, right? It's like read to reconsider uh an event, a person, uh whatever, right?

SPEAKER_00It's a really cool read, man. I enjoyed it almost as much as stuff I could do today, dude. This was really, really fun, man. I really can't thank you enough for coming on. Jason, thanks again. I appreciate the time to chat today. And that's a wrap here at Reckoning with Jason Herbert. Thank you so very much to our guest, James Ellman, for coming on. You can find his book, Patent Reconsidered, General George S. Patton Jr. as a wartime commander in bookstores everywhere or online. Thank you to our producer, Fletcher Powell, for making this show run.

SPEAKER_00And of course, thank you to all of you for continuing to be here. Hey, we got a lot of shows coming up for you soon, so sit back and relax. Share these with your friends, keep tuning in. Thanks again. Ciao for now.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Episode 210: The Outlaw Josey Wales with Matthew Hulbert

    Nov 17, 20261 hr 25 minAudio

    Is The Outlaw Josey Wales a Western, a Civil War movie - or John Wick on horseback? Historian Matthew Hulbert joins Jason Herbert to revisit Clint Eastwood’s 1976 classic and explore the brutal history behind its tale...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Episode 209: My Life with Pandas with Dr. Brandie Smith

    Nov 10, 202648 minAudio

    Are giant pandas really bad at reproducing - or have humans been getting the story wrong? Dr. Brandie Smith, director of the Smithsonian’s National Zoo and Conservation Biology Institute, joins Jason Herbert for a...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Episode 207: Onondaga: The Central Fire of the Iroquois with Michael Oberg

    Oct 27, 20261 hr 26 minAudio

    “We’re still here.” Historian Michael Oberg joins Jason Herbert to explore the history of the Onondaga Nation, keepers of the central fire of the Haudenosaunee Confederacy, also known as the Iroquois Six Nations....

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Episode 206: Historians At The Movies: Battleship with Colin Colbourn and Trent Hone

    Oct 20, 20261 hr 44 minAudio

    Can you really drift a battleship? Which American admiral would you trust to fight an alien invasion - and which one would get us all killed? Naval historian Trent Hone and military historian Colin Colbourn join Jason...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Episode 205: Freedom's Ghosts: Ben Vereen & Amethyst Davis on The Grey House and the Meaning of Juneteenth

    Jun 19, 202657 minAudio

    Episode Description As America prepares to commemorate Juneteenth, Jason Herbert sits down with legendary actor Ben Vereen and breakout star Amethyst Davis for a powerful conversation about The Grey House - the Civil...

    Credit the people on this episode