Why John the Baptist Refused to Stay Silent - Matthew 14:1-12 (Session 28)
24 minAudio
John the Baptist faithfully prepared the way for Jesus, but Matthew 14 records an ending we might not expect for someone Jesus called a great prophet. Herod imprisoned John because John openly confronted his relationship with Herodias. Later, a reckless promise made at Herod’s birthday celebration resulted in John being beheaded. Glenn and Steve examine the contrast between John and Herod. Herod had wealth, political authority, luxury, and the ability to silence his critic, yet his conscience would not leave him alone. John had lost his freedom and eventually his life, but he knew he had faithfully completed the work God had given him. The discussion also explores why suffering does not necessarily mean someone is outside God’s will, why killing the messenger does not silence God’s message, how Christians should speak truth with both clarity and compassion, the danger of rash promises, and what Herod teaches us about weak leadership. Matthew 14:1-12 | The Book of Matthew - Session 28 Questions discussed in this session include: · Can bad things happen even if we are in God’s will? · Should Christians speak about the moral actions of political leaders? · What should we do if we need to give a difficult message to a powerful person in authority? · Does morality change over time? Support the show Thank you for listening!! Please give us a five-star rating to help your podcast provider's algorithm spread RTTB among their listeners. You can find free study and leader resources at the following link - Resource Page - Reasoning Through the Bible Please prayerfully consider supporting RTTB to help us to continue providing content and free resources. You can do that at this link - Support RTTB - Reasoning Through the Bible May God Bless you!! - Glenn and Steve
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_00Welcome to Reasoning Through the Bible. We're in the book of Matthew, chapter 14. We hope that you've been with us as we go through this wonderful book. It of course presents Jesus as King. We're at a section of the book where Jesus is transitioning the message. At the beginning of the book, he introduces the kingdom of heaven is at hand, and the Jewish leaders reject that message. So now Jesus is transitioning that message. Here in Matthew chapter 14, we're into a section about John the Baptist.
SPEAKER_00Of course, John the Baptist was the herald, the prophet that went before Jesus, and he has served his purpose from God. Now we have John that is going to be killed by Herod. That's where we have here at this section in Matthew 14. Steve, any comments about that before we just jump in?
SPEAKER_01I was just thinking that it's a little bit odd that here it is this person that heralded Jesus and that Jesus spoke so well of. He was a cousin of Jesus. He had a large gathering followers, and here he is. He's arrested, put in prison, and we're going to see here that he's going to lose his life for pettiness. He's an innocent man. So it's a little bit curious that here's somebody that's an actual relative of Jesus and he's losing his life.
SPEAKER_00So let's read about it here in Matthew chapter 14. We'll start at verse 1. At that time Herod the Tetrarch heard the news about Jesus and said to his servants, This is John the Baptist. He has risen from the dead, and that is why miraculous powers are at work in him. For when Herod had John arrested, he bound him and put him in prison because of Herodias, the wife of his brother Philip. For John had been saying to him, It is not lawful for you to have her. Although Herod wanted to put him to death, he feared the crowd, because they regarded John as a prophet.
SPEAKER_00But when Herod's birthday came, the daughter of Herodias danced before them and pleased Herod, so much that he promised with an oath to give her whatever she asked. Having been prompted by her mother, she said, Give me here on a platter the head of John the Baptist. Although he was grieved, the king commanded it to be given because of his oaths, and because of his dinner guests. He sent and had John beheaded in the prison, and his head was brought on a platter and given to the girl, and she brought it to her mother.
SPEAKER_00His disciples came and took away the body and buried it, and they went and reported it to Jesus. Here we have this gross story. It's very depraved. Steve, what's your opinion? Just hearing the story, what what do you think about these people?
SPEAKER_01Barbaric. I mean, it gives a picture of royalty. They can just give a command and have something done, have something carried out. There obviously wasn't any trial. Well, he had also been put in prison because he had offended Herod. And that's why he was he was in prison because Herod had just decreed that he be put in prison. And here it is as a birthday present, no less. He's killed. It's mind-boggling, but it does give a picture into how kingships worked, how they could be abused, and if you had the wrong king, there's an old saying, absolute power corrupts absolutely.
SPEAKER_00These people were indeed corrupted. So let's kind of walk through these passages. There's a lot here. So the first couple of verses, Herod seems to think that Jesus is John the Baptist that's come back to life. The irony here is that Herod wanted to get rid of John so that he could go on in his sexual sins and be at peace without John's bothering him and claiming that he shouldn't do that. Yet after he kills John, he's more uneasy than he was before. His conscience won't let him alone. So does Herod sound like someone who is mentally troubled with the knowledge that he killed an innocent man?
SPEAKER_01Yes. And also the fact that he didn't like that John was calling him out shows that he actually knew that he was doing something wrong in the first place.
SPEAKER_00When we do something wrong, will our conscience leave us alone?
SPEAKER_01No. Especially if you're a Christian and you have that Holy Spirit, if you're doing something wrong, you're going to be convicted of it.
SPEAKER_00Your conscience will not let you alone because the Spirit won't let you alone.
SPEAKER_01Who had a greater peace, Herod or John the Baptist? I think John the Baptist did. I mean, he was at peace in regards to knowing that what he was doing was the right thing. He was innocent. John was in the will of God and he knew he was in the will of God.
SPEAKER_00John knew he was doing God's will and following God's path. And what was John's basic purpose in life? To introduce the Messiah. Introduce the Messiah. And now the Messiah was introduced, and his role is now complete. So I'm sure John knew what his role was, and he was directly communicating with God because he was God's prophet.
SPEAKER_01It doesn't seem like that is the way, though, of a reward as being the prophet. Again, it's a twist in the story that's a little bit of an unexpected story, I think. If you were trying to make something up that was all flowers and roses, then you might have something here that says John escaped from prison or something else like that, or he led a rebellion, but no, here he is. He's taken, he's imprisoned, and he's beheaded. It just doesn't seem like it's something that should happen, but yet it has happened.
SPEAKER_00One of the stories I'm reminded of is Daniel in the lion's den. Remember that story? Daniel is in the bottom of the dungeon in a lion's den. And the king, remember the story? What happened that night? The king couldn't sleep.
SPEAKER_01Because he had reluctantly, again, he had signed a decree and put himself into a position where he had to follow through, kind of like what Herod is saying here. He said, Because of my oath that he made, he went through with it.
SPEAKER_00So the king was the king, and he had the softest bed and the finest foods, and yet he couldn't sleep and was uneasy and bothered. Whereas Daniel was in this filthy lion's den, but he was at peace because he knew he was following God's will and the angel of God was there with him.
SPEAKER_01One last comment is that on both of those stories, the king with Daniel was uneasy because he knew Daniel was innocent. And here we get a little bit of glimpse of that that Herod was uneasy. He didn't want to do it because John was considered a prophet to the people, but yet he went ahead and did it anyway. So even though there is a little bit of conscience there of that I'm doing the wrong thing, he goes ahead and does it anyway. Both of them went ahead and did it.
SPEAKER_00No, Herod went ahead and did it. And in verse one and two, he's uneasy. His conscience is bothering him, but he's not uneasy enough to do anything about it. He wasn't uneasy enough to stop the murder of an innocent man. And he's not uneasy enough to where he changes his ways. So he didn't show any sort of remorse for John's murder. He's just bothered by the idea. He's not really sorry, certainly not repenting. So John was killed, even though Jesus said John was the greatest prophet.
SPEAKER_00Remember back earlier in Matthew chapter 11, verse 11. Jesus said that John was the greatest of the prophets. He still gets killed. So if we are in a right relationship with God and we have all faith, can painful things still happen to us?
SPEAKER_01That's what this is showing us.
SPEAKER_00And that's exactly what this shows. John was right in the middle of the will of God, doing exactly what God had him to do, and yet here he gets thrown in prison and killed. So there are times where we are doing God's will, we are saying what God wants us to say, we are staying away from sin. We are doing exactly the role that God wants us to, but yet painful things happen.
SPEAKER_01It also shows that John's not being punished by God because he's doing what he's supposed to be doing. So again, it shows us that we've talked about before is that not every time that something bad happens should it be interpreted, oh, it's it's a consequence of something that I have disobeyed God. Bad things can happen even though you're in the will of God and doing what you're supposed to.
SPEAKER_00Now, Herod didn't like the message that he heard from John the Baptist, so he had him killed. If we kill the messenger, do we stop the message? If we kill God's messenger, do we then stop the word of God? No, no, by no means. Many a person, Herod's not the only one that's ever tried to do that. People turn off the TV, turn off the radio because they don't want to hear the word of God. But yet the word of God is still there and it's still quick and active and powerful. Just getting rid of the messenger doesn't stop the message, especially when it's God's message.
SPEAKER_00So in verse 4, what did John say that got him thrown into prison? What was it that John did that actually got him thrown into prison in the first time? Herod had married his brothers, or at least he was having relations with his brothers' wife. And John called him out on it. So John spoke against the moral actions of a political leader. John, who was the prophet of God, the greatest of the prophets, as Jesus said, was not afraid to speak against the leaders. John spoke against both immoral acts and false theological positions of leadership.
SPEAKER_00Remember back when John first spoke, he called the Pharisees that came out there a brood of vipers. John spoke very directly and very openly against false religious teaching. And in this case, here in Matthew 14, he spoke very plainly against the moral positions of political leaders.
SPEAKER_01Which keeps in line with the prophet. The prophets in the Old Testament did the same thing. They would call kings out and call them out for different things that they were doing as well.
SPEAKER_00Are Christians in our day able and should we speak against moral issues of public figures, or at least moral issues in the culture around us today?
SPEAKER_01Yes.
SPEAKER_00For some strange reason, there's many churches that don't and feel that we shouldn't speak against moral issues in public. Every example I see here of people following God in the scriptures, we are to speak against immoral issues and for moral issues of our leaders, of our culture. That's one of the reasons why we're here.
SPEAKER_01As we record this today, there recently has been a decision in regards to a very divisive moral issue in our country. Abortion. It's a moral issue. The reason why I mention it is because I have not heard any from the pulpits in regards to this decision. It's a watershed decision, and the pulpits have been silenced on it. You would think that they would say this is a good decision. Now we need to continue working within our states, but I really haven't heard any of the uh pastors speak in favor of it.
SPEAKER_00The first church I ever was a member of, the church I got saved in, was very active as far as social issues and community issues and issues with morality that were being involved with the government. That church had a letter writing committee that would write letters to our public officials. They had a social action committee. I just thought every Christian did that. As time goes on, I find there's much greater number of Christians that look for excuses not to get involved with moral issues and that happen with our political leaders.
SPEAKER_00And I submit to you, John the Baptist, he was doing exactly what God wanted him to do. And he spoke against an immoral act that was done by Herod, and this is exactly what God wanted him to do. Too many times I've seen Christian leaders say we shouldn't do that. I think we need to be careful and not get associated with any one political party. That's a problem. We shouldn't, whatever political party or even or even one particular politician. Or or even a particular politician, correct. But we should indeed speak up on moral issues.
SPEAKER_00If we don't, then what happens? The people that are immoral take over the circus, which is exactly what's happened in our country.
SPEAKER_01And if we don't speak up, how are we not salt and how are we not light? I mean, that's how it is. To be salt and light in the world, you have to speak up.
SPEAKER_00Twice in the New Testament, we are told, even commanded, if you will, to be good citizens. Romans 13 and 1 Peter 2. We are in those two passages commanded to be good citizens. And in most of the places where this podcast is heard, being a good citizen means being aware of the issues, voting, telling our elected officials what we think and how our country should be run, and taking up for the least advantaged and the people that are being taken advantage by the powerful.
SPEAKER_00There are moral issues that have to do with legislation that gets passed in our countries. We should speak about these things. We should speak about individual people that are in our leadership that do immoral things and others that are trying to lead our countries in the correct way. Jesus called John the greatest prophet, and John spoke about the morals of the leaders. The other thing here is he didn't soften the message because he was speaking to a leader, because he spoke to anybody. He would speak very plainly and directly.
SPEAKER_00What should we do if one of us needs to give a very difficult message to an important and powerful person? Whether it's like inside the church or outside the church.
SPEAKER_01I think it should be couched sometimes in regards to who you are speaking with, but the message should stay the same. And the message should be clear and it should be consistent. Whether it's somebody powerful or whether it's somebody that's not so powerful, just speak plainly and go to the point. Don't try and soften it up or beat around the bush. We should state it clearly.
SPEAKER_00We should not soften the truth when we speak to somebody. If we're speaking to a pastor or an elder or somebody that's in a position of respect, we should show respect for their position. And we should soften our tone, possibly. There's many times in scripture we're told to speak to people with compassion and love. 1 Peter 3.15 says speak with love. 1 Peter 3.8. There's many passages in the Bible that tells us to have our speech be compassionate and loving, but that doesn't mean soften the truth.
SPEAKER_00God is no respecter of person. There is no partiality with God, it says in Romans 2.11. We should always soften the tone, but not the message. So Herod's niece danced before his birthday party in verse 6. Because of that is partially why this problem happened. And I would point out that the lust of the eyes tends to disconnect the brain from having good sense. The lust of the eyes of watching this girl dance disconnected Herod's brain to get him to do something that he didn't want to do.
SPEAKER_01It said in the verses before that he wanted to put John to death, but he hadn't yet because he feared the crowds, because the crowds thought of him as a prophet. But now he's going to change his mind because of this dance.
SPEAKER_00In verse 7, Herod made a rash promise in front of his guest. And in verse 8, the sister-in-law, Herodias, had coached the niece to ask for John the Baptist's head on a platter. So the players here, who do we have? We have Herod, his brother Philip. We have Herodias, who's technically Philip's wife, but has been having relations with Herod. Then there's the daughter, and all four of them seem to be with no shame in sharing a bed between them. They do not seem to have any hangups.
SPEAKER_00They're not held back by any kind of old-fashioned morality. They're thoroughly modern, wouldn't you say, Steve?
SPEAKER_01It's a again a glimpse of that things really don't change. Immorality is immorality. These people were people just like us. So even though this took place a couple of thousand years ago or so, they're still human beings. Humanity doesn't change. We still have the five emotions, and the Satan attacks us the same today as he has attacked uh people in the past.
SPEAKER_00Morality does not change with the times. The same types of motivations happened way back then as happened today. Verse 9, Herod commands the execution of John because his guests had heard him make an oath to give the girl whatever she asked for. Was Herod more concerned with doing the right thing, or was he more concerned with his public image?
SPEAKER_01He was more concerned with his public image. And we also saw this a little bit back in Judges, whenever one of the judges made an off-the-cuff oath that he would kill the first thing that came out of his house. And we discussed that. Part of what we discussed was maybe we should think before we make oaths in such a grand fashion of whatever. And we should think about that.
SPEAKER_00And I would submit that even if afterwards we realize I promised to do something, and now I realize this is a wrong thing to do, then back off on it, ask forgiveness. We shouldn't follow through with a bad act just because I promised something. So verse 11, John's head was indeed brought to the girl and her mother on a platter. Now think of these people. These were very wealthy people. They wore the finest clothes, they ate the best food, they lived in a palace, they were the upper crust of the upper crust, but yet they showed human depravity at its worst.
SPEAKER_00I can't even think of something worse than this. Is to cut off somebody's head, especially an innocent man, and put it on a plate and serve it up as if it was some sort of a dish. This is just depravity at its worst. Moral depravity will always destroy a nation. It will always destroy a people.
SPEAKER_01Education doesn't keep you from depravity. Wealth doesn't keep you from depravity. Security in through that wealth of being having opulent residents and away from other people doesn't keep you from that depravity. I guess the point being is depravity can come across with anybody. It's not based on class, it's not based on wealth or anything else like that. Depravity is depravity.
SPEAKER_00Hey, Steve, what do you have if you put lipstick on a pig? You have a pig with lipstick. They got a pig. Just like you said, if you take a depraved person and educate them, what do you have?
SPEAKER_01They're still depraved. You've got an educated, depraved person. And so that moral compass that's in people, that's why the word of God is important. And that's why having the Holy Spirit, once you have faith, is important to give you that moral compass. I would say that people are that believe and are Christians and have the Holy Spirit, that that can change their life. And it does change people's lives.
SPEAKER_00If somebody is very intelligent, does that have anything to do with their morality or ability to run their family? How about if they're very, very, very wealthy, or maybe they're very talented as an actor or a singer? Does that have anything to do with their ability to be happy with their family and things like that? I said, no, there's many a person that are very wealthy that would give everything back if they could get their family back.
SPEAKER_01And the question is, where do they get their morality from? If they get their morality from society, well, what society says is moral today might be different and immoral 10 years from now. Or what society once said was immoral 20 years ago, they now today say is moral. So if a person gets their morality from society, it's always subject to change. The word of God doesn't change, and the morality is always the same.
SPEAKER_00Now, Herod here was a high government official. It uses the word tetrarch, which not a word we have today, but he was a high government official in charge of that region. But think of this little story here, who he was influenced by. There's three different passages in here, three different sentences that tell us that Herod was influenced by his sister-in-law, Herodias. In verse 5, he feared the multitude because they believed John was a prophet. Verse 9, he was influenced by his party guests.
SPEAKER_00So we don't see this Herod as standing up and saying, I'm gonna decide what happens here. No, he's influenced by all these other people, he's kind of blowing in the wind. Does Herod show any strong sense of leadership here? No, like you said, he's going with whatever the particular position is. If we find ourselves in a position of leadership, what should a good leader do? Good leadership. And sometimes we find ourselves in just that a position of leadership.
SPEAKER_00A good leader needs to lead. Good leader doesn't need to blow in the wind. People under us, if we're a leader, people under us, they don't need somebody that blows in the wind. They need somebody that knows the word of God, that knows what's right, and goes out and does it. I think of Nehemiah, I think of Daniel, I think of these heroes of the faith that knew what was right and they set their mind to it and they moved forward with it. And they were not blown about by the changing winds of the culture. So this woman, Herodias, asked for John's head because she was offended at John.
SPEAKER_00Well, think of that. So she wasn't any good person here either. She was just as depraved as everybody else in the story. Once John was beheaded, was Herodias victorious. She wanted John gone because she didn't like his message either. Did she not have to worry about anybody judging her morality anymore?
SPEAKER_01No, because she was still sleeping with her husband's brother.
SPEAKER_00Do you think she was at peace now that she got rid of John? She killed the messenger, but the message still gets through. I submit she wasn't any more at peace than she was before. If we silence our critics, it doesn't mean that we get rid of our conscience, doesn't mean we get rid of the moral code that falls on all people. In verse 12, the disciples came and buried the body. They didn't burn it. Christians have always buried our dead because we believe in resurrection. That's been the case for 2,000 years.
SPEAKER_00John's body was shown honor and respect. And God's people always show honor and respect to a body throughout the scriptures because we believe in the resurrection of the body. Now, here's the other thing I find interesting, Steve. This whole story here of Herod killing John the Baptist, it's also documented. There's a secular first century historian named Josephus. And he was a Jewish person that was hired by the Romans and was certainly not Christian, and certainly had no reason to be supporting Christian causes.
SPEAKER_00And he wrote a huge volume that was paid by the Romans to write a history of the Jews, and the name of it is The Antiquities of the Jews. Many of the things in the New Testament are supported by this secular Jewish historian, Josephus. And this story here of John the Baptist is found in that as well. It has the fact that Herod and Philip were sharing this woman. It has the fact that Herod was afraid of the people because of John the Baptist. So the way history works is the more corroboration you have, the more confidence you have in the account.
SPEAKER_00And so the reason I'm bringing this up here is because we have this secular source, an extra-biblical source, corroborating the history and the minute details of the New Testament, by the way. And there's many of those. Someday we'll do an entire session, possibly on the history of the New Testament, but we can trust our Bibles to be trustworthy as far as the history and what it's telling us. Probably a good point to stop. So we'll pull it to the curb for there today. But we hope you'll stop in next time as we go through the Bible and we're reasoning through where Jesus feeds the 5,000 and does a great miracle.
SPEAKER_00And you'll find that next time on Reasoning Through the Bible.
Can the New Testament really be trusted as history? Skeptics often dismiss the Bible as legend, religious fiction, or a collection of stories written long after the events they describe. In this topical study, Glenn...
Are Christians still required to keep the Mosaic Law? In this topical Bible study, Glenn and Steve examine a question that appears in Hebrew Roots movements, some Messianic groups, certain Sabbath-keeping traditions,...
What does the Bible actually say about hell? This topical Q&A study begins with a listener’s question about “eternal separation from God” and asks what that really means. Is hell eternal conscious misery? Is it simply...
How can we find peace when life becomes overwhelming? Psalms 3 and 4 provide practical biblical guidance for dealing with fear, discouragement, anxiety, and circumstances that seem beyond our control. In this...
What is the significance of Jesus rising from the dead? How did people react on resurrection morning? What is the most important piece of evidence about the resurrection? What did people do when they saw the resurrected...