What matters more to God - clean hands or a clean heart? In Matthew 15, Pharisees and scribes travel from Jerusalem to confront Jesus because His disciples do not follow the ceremonial handwashing traditions of the elders. But Jesus exposes a far greater problem: their traditions have become so important that they are actually undermining the Word of God. Glenn and Steve examine Jesus’ warning about religious traditions, the command to care for aging parents, hypocrisy that honors God with the lips while the heart remains far away, and why outward religious activity can never substitute for genuine love for God. Jesus then explains that what truly defiles a person does not come from food or unwashed hands. It comes from the heart. The study closes with a warning about spiritually blind leaders and an important question for every believer: are we following Scripture, or simply following religious habits we have never examined? Matthew 15:1-20 | The Book of Matthew - Session 30 Questions discussed in this session include: How important is taking care of our parents and family members? What does Jesus say about the condition of the human heart? What does the Bible teach about foods? Is it possible to be spiritually blind and not know it? Support the show Thank you for listening!! Please give us a five-star rating to help your podcast provider's algorithm spread RTTB among their listeners. You can find free study and leader resources at the following link - Resource Page - Reasoning Through the Bible Please prayerfully consider supporting RTTB to help us to continue providing content and free resources. You can do that at this link - Support RTTB - Reasoning Through the Bible May God Bless you!! - Glenn and Steve
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_01Welcome to Reasoning Through the Bible, a podcast where we do verse-by-verse Bible study through the Word of God. We're in the book of Matthew, chapter 15. I hope you've been following along with us. Just a little bit of review before we jump into Matthew 15. Of course, Matthew presents Jesus as king. He starts off with the very first verse in the book telling us that Jesus was the son of David. And David, of course, was the greatest king of Israel, where God made a promise to David that his throne would be held forever by an heir of his.
SPEAKER_01So Jesus is the fulfillment of a series of prophecies that Matthew brings up towards the beginning of the book. And then Jesus starts giving the kingdom ethic in the Sermon on the Mount, presenting the message that the kingdom of heaven is at hand. And at hand means it's right there. You could reach out and touch it. And the Jewish leaders have rejected Jesus, saying he was satanic. They have officially formally rejected Jesus as the king. So Jesus has been in the process in these last couple of chapters of changing his message.
SPEAKER_01First saying that the Gentiles will be included in the kingdom and some of the Jews removed, and then teaching in parables so that the kingdom could have some teaching around it to the people, but then the people that hated him, the Jewish leaders, would not have reasons to send him to trial because it wasn't his time yet. And he starts teaching that in these kingdom parables that we discussed, that the kingdom was going to have this future sense to it. So at the beginning of the book, he said the kingdom of heaven is at hand.
SPEAKER_01And then once the Jewish leaders had rejected him, he starts teaching these kingdom parables that introduce this future sense to the kingdom. So in chapter 14, John the Baptist is beheaded, Jesus has fed the 5,000, and Jesus walks on water. Then in this chapter, Jesus talks with the Jewish leaders about the traditions, he heals a Gentile woman's daughter, and he has a feeding of the 4,000. So Steve, if you could read the first two verses of Matthew 15.
SPEAKER_00Then some Pharisees and scribes came to Jesus from Jerusalem and said, Why do your disciples break the tradition of the elders, for they do not wash their hands when they eat bread?
SPEAKER_01So remember here that Jesus is in the northern part of Israel, up near the very north shore of the Sea of Galilee. He's a long way from Jerusalem, which is the capital city. It's where all the temple is, too. Where the temple is. So these Jewish leaders came all the way from Jerusalem. That's maybe a three-day walk.
SPEAKER_00It is. This is something that was so pressing that they had to come out there and investigate it. And it shows that a couple of things. One is that Jesus isn't breaking the Mosaic law. And here in the verse two, they asked him to say, Why do your disciples break their tradition of the elders? That's a little bit of a phrase that we've talked about that Jesus' main rub with the Pharisees and the Sadducees is they have this oral tradition known as the Mishnah, which are these extra set of rules that they came up with through the years to keep the original 613 commandments.
SPEAKER_00Jesus, he's rejecting that. And that's their main rub with him, is because he's rejecting it. So here they come up and they're challenging him, not on the mosaic law, they're challenging him on this tradition of the men. We're going to see Jesus address that.
SPEAKER_01They were looking for an opportunity to catch him on something that they could kill him. That's why they're out here. That's why they came all the way from Jerusalem. They're watching him, they're watching his disciples, they're trying to find an excuse to put him to death. These are the experts in the Mosaic Law, and all the many hundreds of commands, the one they come up with wasn't even in the Mosaic Law, it was in their traditions. So what does that tell you? He's been obeying the Mosaic Law. They didn't really have anything substantial to accuse him with because Jesus kept the law perfectly.
SPEAKER_01They're trying so hard to get an accusation against them. So the worst thing they come up with is this hand washing ritual. Now, were they really worried about germs or dirty fingernails?
SPEAKER_00No, this Mishnah law, the way they looked at it is that sometimes it even surpassed God's word, and that they saw it as having greater authority than scripture sometimes. Over in Mark, where there's parallel passages, it points out that they were forbidden to partake in the smallest seed until they first washed their hands. And the word used there for washing actually kind of indicates it is all the way up to the elbows and stuff. So again, it's a it's another indication that things that man comes up with is way over and above and oppressing to the people.
SPEAKER_01Now we'd never have traditions that we'd hold up against the word of God, would we? Well, we all do. I've been at churches where, oh, if you really just want to create controversy, then switch the order of the Sunday morning service. That'd really get everybody all upset. There's a natural human tendency to let these human traditions kind of creep in over time.
SPEAKER_00And to add, add extra things to scripture, which is not proper.
SPEAKER_01So all of us need to hold up the word of God as a mirror to ourselves and ask ourselves how much of what I'm doing and believing is really a tradition of man and how much of it's actually taught in the Word of God. And it's always a challenge. So the next passage, let me start at verse three, and we'll see what Jesus answers to them. And he answered them and said to them, Why do you yourselves transgress the commandments of God for the sake of your traditions? For God said, Honor your father and mother, and he who speaks evil of father and mother is to be put to death.
SPEAKER_01But you say, Whoever says to his father or mother, Whatever I have that would help you has been given to God. He is not to honor his father or his mother, and by this you invalidated the word of God for the sake of your tradition. You hypocrites, rightly did Isaiah prophesy of you, this people honors me with their lips, but their heart is far away from me. But in vain do they worship me, teaching his doctrines, the precepts of men. The religious leaders were concerned about Jesus' disciples not following this ceremonial cleansing before they eat.
SPEAKER_01But Jesus was concerned with what? He was concerned with a much greater issue, God's commands of taking care of one's parents. And in verse 5, Jesus accuses the Jews of saying that whatever I have that would help my parents has been given to God. What's he talking about there?
SPEAKER_00So they had come up with these extra biblical rules where they could give an oath for their possessions, and they would give this oath that they would give it to the temple or give it to the congregation, the assembly. And then they would say, Oh, I have vowed to give these items to the temple, therefore I can't provide them to my parents to take care of them. Honor your father and mother. We think of it today as in the Western world as just paying respect to me.
SPEAKER_00But what this actually meant was they were to take care of their parents as they got old. They had a commitment to take care of them. Now they're making these oaths to where they owed, I'm sorry, I can't provide anything for you because I've given this oath to them. But at the same time, at any point in time, they could take that back through the rules that they had set up and then take it back for themselves. So it was a bait and switch type of situation, and Jesus is calling them out on it.
SPEAKER_01And I would say even today, the Ten Commandments are not the 10 suggestions. Taking care of your parents made the top 10. So he very rightly, as you said, is concerned with taking care of your parents, not just leaving them and abandoning them. I've had family members that have worked for years at old folks' homes. It's kind of awful sometimes how older people are just forgotten. Sometimes the the nursing home directors are the ones that have to dispose of the personal effects, because after people die, the family doesn't even come in to take away their their uh their effects.
SPEAKER_01And so we really should still take care of our parents. And I'm sure it was a lot of work back then, just like it is today, which is kind of what they're talking about. And people would temporarily give to the temple, oh, the next six months worth of this resource I promised to give to the temple, so I can't give it to my parents.
SPEAKER_00We see also a little bit of a reversal here. So back in chapter five, when he's going through the Beatitudes and some of the others, the Sermon on the Mount, at the one point, I think in chapter six, he says, For you have heard it said, and he gives whatever it might have been, but I say, or God says, that it should be this way. First, he says, This is what you say, but this is what God says. Here it's a little bit of reversal, and I think it's just kind of interesting where he's saying, God says you're supposed to, but you say that you don't need to or that you can't do it.
SPEAKER_01They had come up with the traditions of the elders, and he contrasts those traditions with the what God says. I think we could conclude here what Jesus is also saying is that some people make religion a racket, and we shouldn't use religion as a way to keep our time and money from helping people. And again, people are guilty of this today. And our culture does not emphasize nearly the need to take care of our families as much as God does. Jesus is putting taking care of your family at a very high level. People should not get old and die sick and alone.
SPEAKER_01God does not approve of that, according to these passages. So, verse 7, Jesus calls them hypocrites. The word originally came from dramatic actors who would pretend to be something they're not in like in a play. We don't want to be a play actor or a pretender. Then in verse eight, Jesus says there are people who honor him with their lips, but their hearts are far from him. What do you think of, Steve, when you hear that? What I think of is we should never want to find ourselves in that position. If those Pharisees could have been guilty of that, then it's possible for me to be guilty of that as well.
SPEAKER_01I never wanted to be somebody who just honored God verbally with my lips, but my heart wasn't there.
SPEAKER_00Well, it's an indication too of outward versus inward. It's something that people are hearing, it's something that you're doing outwardly, but your heart is inward, where they can't really tell what your actual motives are or where your actual desire is. Saying something with your lips, giving lip service is something outwardly that is done, but inwardly they don't have any regard for God whatsoever.
SPEAKER_01Too many times people in our churches hide what's going on at home and hide what's going on in their heart, and they act very differently at church. That's being hypocritical. If our hearts are not right, our worship is in vain. And one of the accusations that non-believers have always made against church people is, oh, it's just a bunch of hypocrites. Well, mostly that's an excuse because they don't want to bleed. But most stereotypes have some basis, in fact, there are indeed a lot of hypocrites. When I hear that objection, and I always agree with them.
SPEAKER_01But we shouldn't let hypocrites get in between you and God. And the word of God tells us that we're all hypocrites. The only difference in the people in the church and the people outside the church is that the hypocrites inside the church are saved people, and the ones outside the church are not. So, what did Jesus say was the first and greatest commandment? To love God with all of our heart, soul, mind, and strength, and our neighbors ourselves. That's really what he's talking about here. So, Steve, next start at verse 10 and read through verse 20 of Matthew 15.
SPEAKER_00After Jesus called the crowd to him, he said to them, Hear and understand. It is not what enters into the mouth that defiles the man, but what proceeds out of the mouth that defiles the man. Then the disciples came and said to him, Do you know that the Pharisees were offended when they heard you this statement? But he answered and said, Every plant which my heavenly Father did not plant shall be uprooted. Let them alone. They are blind guides of the blind, and if a blind man guides a blind man, both will fall into a pit.
SPEAKER_00Peter said to him, Explain the parable to us. Jesus said, Are you still lacking in understanding also? Do you not understand that everything that goes into the mouth passes into the stomach and is eliminated? But the things that proceed out of the mouth come from the heart, and those defile the man. For out of the heart come evil thoughts, murders, adulteries, fornications, thefts, false witness, slanders. These are the things which defile the man. But to eat with unwashed hands does not defile the man.
SPEAKER_01So back in verse 11, he says, It is not that that goes into the mouth that defiles the man. So what is he teaching here about the Old Testament dietary laws? Can we be defiled by what we eat or drink? And I would submit that as far as righteousness goes, eating and drinking doesn't make you righteous or unrighteous. Eating bacon cheeseburgers does not make you a sinful person. So it's not the Old Testament dietary laws. There's so much teaching back in the Old Testament in Leviticus and other places on what to eat.
SPEAKER_01To the Jewish ear, this is a major teaching. Reason we bring this up is because there are still people today that disagree on these things. And this is one of the passages where Jesus quite clearly says, it is not what enters the mouth that defiles the man. There's other passages as well.
SPEAKER_00It's an indication as well that Jesus knows what is going to happen from the standpoint he knows his purpose. He knows that he is going to die for the sins of the world and be raised and resurrected and ascended. He knows all of that. This is an indication of later on, if you remember, when Peter is given the vision and he comes back and he goes, No, you can eat anything you want. And this is Jesus knowing, and he is giving that indication to him that afterwards those are not going to be needed anymore.
SPEAKER_01So the passages that I know of that deal with this in the New Testament, the Lord taught Peter that it was okay to eat all types of foods. Remember Acts 10, where Peter's on the rooftop and the sheep comes down, and the Lord says, Eat. And there was all types of animals. And initially Peter refused. He said, I've only I only eat clean things. God says, Nothing is unclean that I have cleansed. Paul says in Romans 14, verses 2 to 4, one person has faith that he may eat all things, but he who is weak eats vegetables only.
SPEAKER_01The one who eats is not to regard with contempt the one who does not eat. And the one who does not eat is not to judge the one who eats, for God has accepted him. And then in Colossians it says, Let no one judge you in food or drink, Colossians 2.16. Most of the book of Galatians is where Paul is confronting Peter because Peter was giving a hypocritical message to the Gentiles because he would keep kosher when the Jews were around. And then when the Jews left, he'd go off and eat all kinds of things with the Gentiles, and it just sent a wrong message to the Gentiles.
SPEAKER_01And Paul gets very emotional in the book of Galatians, spends a good part of the book talking about this.
SPEAKER_00And he not only was not just keeping kosher, but he was associating only with the Jews whenever the Jews would come around, backing away from the Gentiles.
SPEAKER_01There's a command: do not destroy the work of God for the sake of food, Romans 14, 20. And again in Romans, the kingdom of God is not eating or drinking, but righteousness and peace and joy in the Holy Spirit, Romans 14, 17. So with those, and this one here in Matthew 15, we contrast that with remember back in Matthew 5, Jesus repeated some of the laws, especially the Ten Commandments. He talked about adultery.
SPEAKER_01You have heard it said that don't commit adultery. You have heard it said, don't kill. And he reinforced those and even brought them up to a higher standard. So he's quite clear on the Old Testament things that should be continued. Here, he's also quite clear in saying that we are no longer held to the Old Testament dietary laws as far as righteousness before God. Now it might make sense not to eat some of those things. It might be a health thing. Very well, it could be a really good idea to follow the Old Testament dietary laws for health reasons.
SPEAKER_01But as far as righteousness before God, that's what we're really talking about. It is not make you unclean or sinful to eat the things that the Old Testament says is unclean.
SPEAKER_00And it also goes back to one of the themes of Matthew in regards to what he's recording with Jesus, in that Jesus is constantly what you referred to is expanding and giving them the proper meaning to it. The dietary laws and the things that were given to the Jewish people, that was to set them apart from the pagan world. That was to have them show that these are God's people and they have certain dietary things.
SPEAKER_00The point was for to show that they were worshiping Yahweh, the one true God, the creator. Now it had gotten to a point where they were just doing it out of not love for God and worship of God, but because they felt obligated that they had to do it and the oppression of the tradition had come. So once again, Jesus is expanding on it and basically saying, you're doing it because you've been told that it will defile you if you don't do it properly. But in actuality, it's what's in your heart is what defiles the man.
SPEAKER_00And I think we're going to get into that in a little bit.
SPEAKER_01So according to Jesus here in Matthew 15, what is the source of the things that come out of our mouth? It's our heart. What he's saying is what is in the heart determines what comes out of our mouth. And in verse 12, the disciples are worried that the Pharisees took offense. Why would the disciples care whether or not the Pharisees were offended?
SPEAKER_00These were the people that had interpreted the law.
SPEAKER_01Jesus said earlier said they hold the key to the power did the Pharisees have over the commoner in Israel.
SPEAKER_00They could declare a person outside the bounds of the law, and they could it could be a capital punishment.
SPEAKER_01And cutting people off. Sometimes in the Gospels, it talks about people being put out of the synagogue. Well, that was a major thing. Now you're cut off from your family, lose your job, shunned. They had a lot of power, and offending them to the average person is a significant event.
SPEAKER_00So that's what they were worried about. They were the arbitrators of who was keeping the law and who wasn't keeping the law.
SPEAKER_01Then in verse 13, it says, Every plant which my heavenly father did not plant will be uprooted. Of course, he's talking about people, not farming. This implies that all followers of God were planted by the Father, which is what he's strongly implying here.
SPEAKER_00I think he's even specifically talking about the Pharisees because the scribes and Pharisees, because they're those are the ones that are challenging them. And this is kind of the context, but he's saying these scribes and Pharisees, they are not of God. They don't love God. You think that they do because they're the interpreters of the law, they're the the ones who keep the law and as far as writing it down and the traditions, but they don't really truly love God. So they're not planted by God and they're going to be uprooted.
SPEAKER_01No. Contrast what you just said with we should get a picture of who these Pharisees are. These people wore the dress, they had the religious clothing on, they were full-time religious people. They had memorized the text of the Old Testament. They were going about doing religious things on a regular basis. Are you telling me, Steve, that they were not of God?
SPEAKER_00Yes, that's what Jesus is saying.
SPEAKER_01Just because they have religious trappings and do religious things doesn't mean that their hearts were in the right place. That's exactly what he's teaching here.
SPEAKER_00And I think that's something for us today. We should always examine ourselves in regards to what we're doing. And if we're doing things just to go through the motions, we need to check ourselves. We need to be doing things because we love God. And we need to be doing things that we want to build a relationship with God with Jesus. If we're just doing them because of obligation or we're doing them out of guilt, we need to check and make sure that that's not the case.
SPEAKER_01So in verse 19, what does Jesus say comes out of the human heart? He's got this horrible list: evil thoughts, murders, adulteries, fornications, thefts, lying, slander. So according to Jesus, what is in mankind?
SPEAKER_00Evilness or evil.
SPEAKER_01There's popular teachings today that, well, people are basically good. What does Jesus say comes out of our heart? The natural human heart, according to the Bible, is not inclined towards God. The heart is deceitful above all things and desperately wicked. Who can know it? It says in Jeremiah 17 9. Then the Lord saw that the wickedness of man was great in all the earth, and every intent of the thoughts of his heart were only evil continually, it says back in Genesis. Because we do not understand the high degree of holiness and purity in God, we hold ourselves up.
SPEAKER_01To be neutral or good, but in reality, our hearts are not inclined to anything good. We can think we're good because we measure ourselves against a guy down the street or our neighbor or somebody that we know that did an evil thing and we say, Well, I'm not as bad as them, so I'm okay. But we're not really understanding holiness. If we really understood God's holiness, then we would understand how far from God we really are. We would realize that Jesus is correct.
SPEAKER_01Out of our heart come all these evil things. Now we do have value because we are made in whose image?
SPEAKER_00God's image.
SPEAKER_01We are made in God's image. That gives us value. Verse 14, the blind follow the blind, they're both going to fall into a ditch. Kind of a funny, humorous thing that's easy to remember. The blind people that I've known have been pretty good at getting around, but Jesus gives this humorous illustration. So in the book of Revelation, Jesus tells the Laodicean church that they don't know that they're blind. Is it possible to be spiritually blind and not know it? I think so.
SPEAKER_00Absolutely.
SPEAKER_01Spiritually blind people lead spiritually blind churches, and the whole congregation can fall into a ditch. There are churches that are spiritually blind churches today, led by spiritually blind people that are very religious. These Pharisees, we get kind of a mental image of them that we don't really understand how they were. These people cared a lot about the religion. They cared a lot about the traditions. But what had happened is they'd gotten so legalistic at following the rules that they had lost their way and they didn't really care about people and they didn't really care about doing the things.
SPEAKER_01Remember when the man with the withered hand was healed? They were more concerned with Jesus healing on the Sabbath than they were about this man that could now have his hand back. So that is where they had gotten off.
SPEAKER_00That's an area where you're following rules blindly. Another area is in today's world and today's preaching are following things that are unscriptural and not checking what is being said by the pastors and being preached from the pulpit, whether or not it is scriptural and just blindly following those people. People follow these other people blindly because they believe that the people are in their heart that they actually love God.
SPEAKER_00But in essence, they're giving lip service to God. They're following this pastor and the things that they're teaching blindly. And they say, here's an inspiration cube that you can have in your house, and you can punch a button, and it'll give you some affirmations that will make you feel good and tell you who you are, and you can push another button and you can hear a sermon from this pastor. They're buying into things like the inspiration cube rather than actually studying the word of God.
SPEAKER_00That's to me is an activity of the blind following the blind.
SPEAKER_01You know, we have vending machines where you walk up and you put money in it and it spits out a product that you wanted. Well, God is not a vending machine. God is not a I put in this and I automatically get up. God is a person. What he wants is a personal loving relationship. And so God is not a list of rules that we should follow. Sure, there's things that we should do and not do, but if all you have is a list of rules, you're very far from God. The main point of this, to kind of summarize and wrap up this section, these Jewish leaders had come up and said, you're not following our religious traditions.
SPEAKER_01There's not anything necessarily wrong with religious traditions as long as they don't get in between us and God. And like what Jesus said here, they had used those traditions to actually violate a commandment against taking care of their families.
SPEAKER_00And the traditions have superseded actual scripture. That's how they viewed them. And that was that's absolutely wrong.
SPEAKER_01So what Jesus is saying here is that violating religious traditions is not a sin. He's saying that it is not a sin to violate human traditions. What is a sin is to take a human tradition and make it more important and the principles behind and the commandments of God. And that's what we should all remember.
SPEAKER_00He also expresses his disappointment in the disciples that they didn't understand the real issue of where defilement begins, that the defilement begins inwardly with the heart, not outwardly with the hands.
SPEAKER_01Remember what he says in another place. He says the Pharisees would clean the outside of the cup quite well. The inside was dirty. Same thing. They're more concerned with the outward arrangement and not what's in the heathen heart.
SPEAKER_00So I think that's kind of a good stopping point here in this chapter 15. We'll pick up with the last part of chapter 15 as we go into our next session of reasoning through the Bible.
Can the New Testament really be trusted as history? Skeptics often dismiss the Bible as legend, religious fiction, or a collection of stories written long after the events they describe. In this topical study, Glenn...
Are Christians still required to keep the Mosaic Law? In this topical Bible study, Glenn and Steve examine a question that appears in Hebrew Roots movements, some Messianic groups, certain Sabbath-keeping traditions,...
What does the Bible actually say about hell? This topical Q&A study begins with a listener’s question about “eternal separation from God” and asks what that really means. Is hell eternal conscious misery? Is it simply...
How can we find peace when life becomes overwhelming? Psalms 3 and 4 provide practical biblical guidance for dealing with fear, discouragement, anxiety, and circumstances that seem beyond our control. In this...
What is the significance of Jesus rising from the dead? How did people react on resurrection morning? What is the most important piece of evidence about the resurrection? What did people do when they saw the resurrected...