Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

ReadMultiplex.com Podcast.

ReadMultiplex.com Podcast. artwork

ReadMultiplex.com: A Review Of The Research Behind Shufflebrain: The Quest for the Hologramic Mind.

Aug 15, 202646 minAudio

Got something to say to this podcast? Send a voicemail, and you might hear yourself on the next episode! I first brushed against the idea of a holographic mind in the late 1970s, long before most people outside specialized circles had even heard the phrase. I was still young, still absorbing everything I could about lasers, interference patterns, and the strange ways light could store information across an entire surface rather than at single points. Somewhere in those years the notion that the brain might work the same way - encoding memory as distributed phase relationships rather than fixed addresses - lodged itself in me and refused to leave. It felt less like a theory and more like a recognition of something already half-known. When Paul Pietsch’s Shufflebrain appeared in 1981, I found it almost immediately. The book was new, the experiments still raw, and the claim that you could scramble a salamander’s brain and still keep its mind intact struck me with the force of a physical discovery. I tracked it down, read it cover to cover, and then read it again. The Texas Medical Center Library later became one of the places where I found a physical volume years afterward, when the library began clearing older titles from open display, I secured a copy that had already begun its quiet journey toward the discard pile. That particular volume still carries the marks of that earlier era. From that first encounter the research became a private through-line. I followed the older literature backward - Lashley’s failed hunt for the engram, Pribram’s holonomic proposals, the optical work of Gabor and Leith - and then forward into every new paper that seemed to touch distributed coding. The salamander experiments stayed with me not as curiosities but as existence proofs: anatomy could be rearranged, tissue could be exchanged, and coherent behavior still returned. That resilience suggested the code lived in relationships, not in the precise coordinates of cells. Read more at: ReadMultiplex.com Support this work by buying us a coffee: https://ko-fi.com/brianroemmele

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

You know, usually when we talk about a medical diagnosis, there's this like expectation of precision we treat the human body like a piece of mechanical engineering right like a car engine or something exactly you fall off your bike you break your arm and the x -ray shows that jagged white line on a black background and the doctor just points to the film and says well there it is yeah there's your problem it's super clean it is entirely clean it's binary and it gives us this profound sense of comfort you know we really like our problems to be visible and securely localized

in one physical spot. We want a broken part that we could just swap out. I mean, it makes the world feel tractable. But the moment you step out of orthopedics and into the world of neurodevelopment or trauma or even just basic memory, that whole x -ray machine metaphor completely shattered. Oh, absolutely. It completely falls apart. We are no longer looking at a clean, broken strut. We are looking at a diagnostic landscape that is incredibly murky. And that murky water, the absolute mystery of where a thought actually lives inside your head, well, that is what we

are swimming in today. It's a deep one today. It really is. Welcome to the ReadMultiplex .com podcast. This is a classic Brian Rommel deep dive into an almost unbelievable aspect of the physical brain. Unbelievable is definitely the right word for it. And a quick note to you listening before we get started. If you find this level of content useful, please support Brian and his work. Become a member of the site or at the very least, buy him a coffee. It takes immense effort to unearth these forgotten scientific threads. So keeping that support going makes deep dives

like this possible. Yeah, it's so important. So we're going to explore a stack of notes, original sources, and research centering around a very rare, largely forgotten 1981 book called Shuffle Brain. It's subtitled The Quest for the Hologramic Mind by Paul Peach. Such a great title. Right. And the core mission of our deep dive today sounds like pure science fiction. We are going to look at the physical mechanics of how you can take a living creature's brain, remove it, literally mince it up with scissors, put it back into the skull completely out of order, and watch. that

creature wake up with its memories and innate behaviors totally intact. Which is just, I mean, it challenges the single most fundamental assumption we hold in modern biology. It really does. Because we've all been conditioned to think of the brain as a complex computer hard drive, you know. We just assume that your memory of your 10th birthday party is stored in a specific fixed location, like a physical file sitting in a physical folder of neurons. Yeah, like a filing cabinet in your head. Exactly. But today, we are exploring the

evidence that the mind isn't a physical object locked in a specific cell at all. We are looking at the brain as a distributed phase relationship. Okay, let's unpack this. Because to really grasp how wild this paradigm shift is, we have to start chronologically with Brian Rommel's own discovery of this material. It connects to a historical scientific puzzle that frustrated an entire generation of scientists. Yeah, the context of the late 1970s is super crucial here. Right. So Brian had this absolute obsession with lasers at the time. He was spending his days diving into the

physics of interference pattern. Which was cutting edge back then. Very much so. He was specifically captivated by the strange ways that light could store information across an entire surface rather than at a single localized microscopic point. And while he was... Studying this optical physics, he started getting this nagging intuition that the human brain might actually work the exact same way. He hypothesized that memory might be encoded as distributed relationships across a wide area, not as fixed physical addresses. Yeah,

and in his notes, he mentions that this didn't feel like a brand new theory he was inventing. It felt more like recognizing something he already fundamentally knew. That intuition is what led him directly to Paul Peach's work. In 1981, Shufflebrain was published, and the surgical experiments detailed in that book were just raw. They hit Brian with the force of a physical revelation. Because the data was sitting right there in print, you could physically scramble a salamander's brain, and its mind, its behavioral programming, would remain perfectly intact. So he tracked the book down

and devoured it. He did. And there's great detail in our sources about the physical artifact itself. Years later, Brian actually found a volume of Shufflebrain at the Texas Medical Center Library. Oh, wow. A physical copy. Yeah. They were clearing out older titles from their open display shelves to make room, and he basically rescued a copy that was on its quiet, inevitable journey to the discard pile. That is so fitting. Right. He noted that the physical book still carries the library stamps and the wear of that earlier era. Rescuing a discarded book about a discarded

theory of the brain. I mean, it's incredibly poetic because I understand why a researcher like Peach was even doing these bizarre salamander experiments in the 1970s. We have to rewind another 50 years. Let's do it. We have to look at Carl Lashley and the great failed hunt for the Enneagram. Ah, the Enneagram. From the 1920s through the 1950s, Carl Lashley was effectively the biggest name in neuropsychology. He spent decades conducting these exhaustive lesion studies on rats. His entire career was built on hunting for that Enneagram,

which was the theoretical term for the physical trace of a single memory. And the methodology was pretty straightforward, right? He would teach a rat to run a complex maze until it had the route perfectly memorized. Then he would anesthetize the rat. open its skull, and systematically remove a tiny portion of its cerebral cortex. The prevailing logic being that eventually his scalpel would hit the exact cluster of cells where the memory of the maze was stored. Exactly. The assumption was when he cut that specific spot out, the rat

would wake up and completely forget how to run the maze. Because the localized storage theory... demanded that result. If you cut the wire, the signal dies. It's just basic mechanics. But the rats kept running the maze. Lashley would cut out completely different areas of the cortex in different rats. He would destroy the front, the back, the sides, and yet the rats would wake up, get dropped in the maze, and find their way to the cheese. That drove him crazy. Decades of this. Through all that, Lashley discovered two principles that completely baffled the scientific community of his era. He called them mass action

and equipotentiality. Which basically means the severity of a memory deficit only correlated with the total amount of brain tissue he removed, not its precise location. Right. If he removed 50 % of the cortex, the rat would be sluggish and clumsy, but it would still essentially know the maze. Lashley was so deeply flummoxed by his own life's work that he famously joked that Which is a hilarious concession from a top scientist.

Totally. I think we need a solid analogy to picture Lashley's intense frustration here. Imagine you were trying to find the exact microchip inside an old AM radio that physically contains the singer's voice. Oh, that's a great way to think about it. You take a pair of pliers and you snap out a wire here, pull a transistor there. The radio might get a little quieter. You might introduce some heavy static. But the singer's voice is still playing through the speaker. Right, because the voice isn't localized in one transistor. Exactly. After you've pulled half the parts out and you still haven't found the voice chip, you

eventually have to face a mind -bending reality. The voice isn't actually in the radio. The physical hardware is just a tuning mechanism for a distributed signal that exists outside the localized parts. That framing captures the early 20th century neuroscience dilemma perfectly. Lashley's decades of data practically proved that memory was distributed across the whole brain. But nobody had a physical, biological, or mathematical model for how a cluster of wet biological cells could store distributed

information. Because structural biology was just looking at cells under microscopes and drawing lines between them? Yeah, they had reached a dead end. They had undeniable evidence of a distributed system, but absolutely no mechanism to explain it. So they needed a completely different field of science to catch up and provide the math. They were basically waiting for optical physics to have a breakthrough. Specifically, they were waiting for Dennis Gabor. Right, in 1947 and 1948. Yeah, and Gabor wasn't studying the brain at all. He was a physicist trying to improve the resolution of electron microscopes. And in

the process of trying to clear up the images of atoms, he invented the underlying mathematical principles of holography. It was a brilliant theoretical leap. It was. But it remained mostly mathematical until the 1960s when Emmett Leith and Juracy Patniks combined Gabor's math with newly invented lasers to create practical visible holograms. Okay, let's establish the crucial difference between a normal photograph and a hologram because this distinction is the key to literally everything Paul Peach discovers later with his salamanders. Yeah, this is vital.

A standard photograph records intensity, which physicists call amplitude. So think of a camera taking... a picture of an apple. Right. A single point of light bounces off the top of the apple, enters the lens, and hits a single point on the chemical film at the back of the camera is a one -to -one localized map. The top of the apple lives on the top of the negative. Exactly. A hologram, however, doesn't record a picture at all. It records interference patterns. It preserves the relative phase of the light waves. Phase meaning how the waves interact? Yes. Phase is

relational. It's about how different waves interact with one another, amplifying or canceling each other out. So the holographic plate just looks like a bunch of concentric, messy ripples to the naked eye. The information is encoded in the complex mathematical wave relationships across the entire surface of the plate. And once that optical mathematics is proven in the lab, a neuroscientist named Carl Pribram enters the picture. Right, in the 1960s and 70s. And Pribram had actually worked with Lashley. He had felt that same crushing frustration of the missing Enneagram firsthand.

So Pribram looks at holography and develops the holonomic brain theory. He proposes that neural information isn't stored in single localized cells. Instead, it is encoded in the interference patterns of local field potentials. Meaning the electrical and chemical activity of the brain creates overlapping waves in the dendritic networks. Yes, the branching structures of neurons. He argued that the content of our memory is carried by the phase relationships of these overlapping waves rather than by the rigid physical firing

of a specific neuron at a fixed address. Wait, hold on. I need to jump in and ask for a breakdown on behalf of our listener. Sure. When we throw around terms like... local field potentials and say the brain is doing complex wave mathematics like Fourier transforms. Are we just using a poetic metaphor here? Are we saying there are literal lasers shooting around inside our heads? That is a critical distinction to make. We are absolutely not talking about literal light in the brain. Okay, good. If we connect this to the bigger picture, we are talking about the mathematics of wave -phase relationships. The

brain uses electrical impulses and chemical gradients to create waves, whereas holography uses light to create waves. So the medium is different. The medium is completely different. But the underlying mathematical equations, the transforms, they are identical. Think of a Fourier transform as the math used to break down a complex, messy signal into simple, regular sine waves. A biological brain doesn't sit down and write equations on a chalkboard. Its physical architecture naturally acts as a filter that performs this wave breakdown

automatically. Got it. So it's the math of wholeness. Explain the wholeness principle of a diffuse hologram, because this directly answers Carl Lashley's rat problem. Okay, so if you take a normal photograph of a face on a glass plate, and you drop it on the floor, it shatters. Right. If you pick up a tiny shard from the bottom left corner, you might only see a piece of the chin. The information is localized. Right, you just get the chin. But a diffuse holographic plate records the phase relationships of the entire object across every single point on the plate.

If you drop a diffuse hologram and shatter it into 100 shards, you can pick up any single tiny piece, shine a laser through it, and project the entire face. Oh, wow. So every broken shard contains the whole picture. Exactly. Every single piece. Now, the smaller the shard, the lower the resolution, and the fuzzier the image gets, but the entire scene is always there. The information is distributed relationally, so Prebram sees this and realizes this is exactly why Lashley couldn't find the maze memory in the rat's brain. Yep. You can cut out a piece of the rat's cortex,

but the remaining tissue still contains the whole memory, just at a slightly lower fidelity. Prebram had the elegant theory that perfectly bridged Lashley's data. And Gabor's physics. But a theory in neuroscience isn't enough, right? No, not at all. To prove this wild concept, they needed to go far beyond rats. Mammals are just too fragile. They needed a living subject that could survive having its biological plate truly shattered and rearranged. And that brings us to Paul Peach and the salamanders. I want to spend some time on Peach himself because his background really

informs why these experiments are so credible. Yeah, his story is fascinating. He wasn't some ivory tower academic chasing mystical theories. New York City and actually dropped out of high school in the 10th grade. Wow. I didn't realize it was 10th grade. Yeah. He joined the Army in 1946, served in Japan and Korea, got his GED while in the military, and then used the GI Bill to study zoology. That's incredible. He eventually earned a Ph .D. in anatomy from the University of Pennsylvania in 1960. He was a guy who worked with his hands, holding patents from his time

as a research scientist at Dow Chemical before becoming a professor at Indiana University. His blue -collar, highly practical background is vital to understand. because pete was at his core a strict structuralist meaning he believed that life And the mind, reduced entirely to the physical architecture of living parts. Like the brain is a biological clock and the neurons are the brass gears. Exactly. Early in his career, his specialty was studying limb regeneration in salamanders. He treated biological cells as

independent mathematical sets. He mapped them out like a mechanical blueprint. Right. So when he first encountered Karl Pripram's hologramic theory of the brain, Pichu was deeply offended by it. He hated it. He really did. He thought the idea that the brain wasn't a rigid, structured circuit board was mystical nonsense. He didn't set out to prove the hologramic theory. He designed his experiments specifically to destroy it. The best kind of scientific paradigm shift is the one forced upon a reluctant skeptic by his own undeniable data. Always. So let's look at his

subjects. He used larval salamanders of the genus Ambistoma, which includes the axolotl. And the reason he used salamanders is that they possess these almost supernatural regenerative capabilities. Yeah, they can survive horrific bodily trauma that would instantly send a mammal into fatal shock. They are the ultimate biological canvas to test the... physical resilience of memory and behavior. The surgical procedures detailed in the sources are astonishing. Pichich would place the salamanders in a bath of MS -222, which

is a potent amphibian anesthetic. Right. Working under a stereoscopic microscope, using incredibly fine forceps and tiny iridectomy scissors, he would literally slice open the skull cartilage and manipulate the brain tissue. And he didn't even use sutures to close them up. No. Amphibian tissue has such robust regenerative properties that he would just let the wound close naturally over a few days. He established his foundation with a baseline experiment that sounds incredibly brutal, but it was necessary to prove the biological

limits. OK. Yeah. Describe this baseline. So. He would completely remove the salamander's brain. He would scoop the entire organ out of the skull. The animal would instantly enter a vegetative stupor. It wouldn't eat. It wouldn't respond to light. It was just a living husk maintaining basic autonomic function. It's completely empty. Yes. Then he would take that exact same brain and simply put it back into the empty skull cavity. Just drop it back in. Over a few weeks, as the vascular and neural connections regenerated, the salamander would wake up. And not only would

it wake up, but it completely restored its normal, complex feeding behaviors. It went right back to aggressively hunting and eating live tube effects worms. That baseline alone severely wounds the structuralist argument. Think about the mechanical logic of that. If memory and behavior are dictated by a fixed, rigid circuit board, where microscopic wire A must connect perfectly to microscopic port B to trigger a feeding response, then unplugging the entire squishy mass of the brain and just dropping it back in shouldn't work. The microscopic

connections are severed. When they regrow, they do not line up perfectly with their original ports. Yet the salamander behaved normally. This proved that perfect structural continuity is not required for a behavioral program to run. But the structuralists could argue that on a macro level, the front of the brain was still in the front. And the back was still in the back. Oh, right. The macro wires found their general macro ports. Exactly. To truly destroy their argument, Peach knew he had to destroy the physical map entirely. He had to scramble the architecture

so severely that localized storage was a physical impossibility. This is the era of the shuffling experiments. This is how the book gets the title Shuffle Brain. Yeah, and he performed over 700 of these radical operations. We are just talking about shifting the brain slightly. He would open the skull. cut out the cerebral hemispheres, rotate them 180 degrees, and pack them back in. He flipped them entirely upside down. He interchanged the cerebrum and the deencephalon, literally swapping the front brain with the middle brain.

And in some cases, he resorted to mincing the tissue. Yes. Like, wait, he literally minced it. He sliced it up like you would prep garlic on a cutting board and packed the biological slurry back into the cranium. Oh, my gosh. That is insane. He created the most gross anatomical abnormalities imaginable. He was doing everything in his power to physically destroy the file folders where a localized memory could possibly be kept. And the result of these 700 surgeries, it was completely uniform. As long as he left a sufficient critical mass of tissue, and as long as the medulla,

which controls the basic life support systems, was left intact, the salamander's innate predatory feeding behavior always returned. The anatomy of the brain was a catastrophic, unrecognizable mess. It was completely reordered. But the behavioral program survived perfectly. You cannot reconcile those 700 recoveries with a strictly localized storage model. You just can't. No, because if the hunting behavior was located in a specific file at the front left of the brain and you move that physical file to the back right, turn it

upside down and severed all its original connecting pathways, the physical wiring diagram is utterly broken. The behavior should vanish. The fact that the behavior persisted. proves that the physical coordinates of the tissue do not dictate the information it holds. So Peach proves that you can scramble the brain and retain innate instinct. But instinct is hardwired. He wanted to see how this scrambled brain handled new incoming sensory information. And this leads us to the ectopic eye experiments. Yeah, he started fundamentally

altering their sensory architecture. He created what he called triclops larvae. He took normal salamanders with their two natural eyes, and he grafted a third fully functional eye directly onto the top of their heads, facing straight up toward the sky. which is wild. And he also created cyclops forms, where he entirely removed the two natural eyes and placed a single eye in that bizarre upward -facing dorsal position. Consider the biological friction here. You have a single eye sitting on the roof of the skull.

Its optic nerve has to grow downward through unfamiliar tissue, forging a completely unconventional trajectory, just trying to wire its way into a brain that might have already been shuffled or reversed. Okay, so Peach takes these structurally absurd animals and tests them on visual learning. He sets up a conditioning experiment where the animals have to learn to avoid a mild electric shock associated with a light stimulus. Right. The triclops animals, with their three eyes, learned the light shock avoidance response just as fast as the normal control salamanders. Which

is impressive in itself. But here's where it gets really interesting. The cyclops results are what truly break the old models. The cyclops animals, the ones relying entirely on a single, bizarrely placed eye glued to the top of their heads, actually learned the avoidance behavior faster and had higher success rates than the normal control group. It's just staggering. I have to play the skeptic here again because this sounds impossible. If the brain is a fixed wire map, Built by millions of years of evolution, how on earth does an optic nerve growing from

the top of the head instantly plug into a fear conditioning circuit? Evolution didn't pre -wire a port for an eye on the roof of the skull. It is entirely impossible under a structuralist model. The structuralist has absolutely no answer for the cyclops, but under a hologramic model, the mechanism makes perfect mathematical sense. Okay, explain that. Peach developed the concept of smart eyes and inverse transforms to explain this. In this view, the salamander's brain isn't passively waiting for a specific wire to plug into a specific socket. The brain operates as

a continuous phase frequency domain. It is processing wave relationships. So the eye isn't just a camera lens taking a picture, it's a transformer. Precisely. Let's use an analogy to explain how the sensory system generates a phase spectrum. Imagine a calm pond. You drop two stones into the water simultaneously. As the ripples spread out from each splash, they eventually collide. Where the peaks of the ripples meet, they amplify. Where a peak meets a trough, they cancel out. Creating a pattern on the water. Right. That complex pattern

of colliding water is an interference pattern. If you take a snapshot of that complex, messy, overlapping pattern on the surface of the pond, you can use mathematical equations, inverse transforms, to reverse engineer exactly where those two stones originally fell, how big they were, and how fast they hit. You can read the whole event just by looking at the resulting waves. Yes. The salamander's eye is dropping stones into the pond of the brain. The sensory system converts visual stimuli into complex phase spectra, basically chemical and

electrical ripples. Wow. Because the brain relies on reading these distributed relationships rather than looking at fixed coordinates, it is incredibly flexible. As soon as the regenerated optic pathways physically connect to the brain, it doesn't matter where they connect, they start dropping stones into the pond. And the brain just reads the ripples. Exactly. The brain's mathematical processing simply reads the resulting interference pattern and inverse transfer. forms those waves back into meaningful perception. The intelligence, the capacity to learn fear from a light, is entirely

in the wave manipulation. It has nothing to do with the physical XY coordinates of the cells. The meat is just the water that the wave travels through. Anatomy is indispensable because you need a physical medium to carry the signal, but the anatomy does not dictate the function. It completely dissolves the rigid line between structure and function. Okay. It is one thing to show that an animal can remember its own innate behaviors after you put its brain through a blender. And it's miraculous that it can learn new things with a scrambled anatomy. But Peach took this

line of inquiry to an entirely different, almost magical level. Oh yeah, he went much further. He showed that an animal can remember someone else's behaviors. The memory transfer experiments. This is the absolute frontier of his work. So Peach designed a classic associative learning paradigm. He would take a normal adult salamander and tap the rim. of its glass dish. Immediately after the tap, he would feed it a small piece of raw liver. Right. He did this repeatedly over days. Eventually, the salamander developed a strong anticipatory reflex. You just tap the

dish, and the salamander arches its back, lifts its head, and looks up, waiting for the liver to drop. Like Pavlov's dogs. Exactly. This looking up behavior was deeply ingrained, and it persisted for weeks, even if he stopped providing the meat reward. It is a highly specific, acquired memory. It is not an innate instinct like hunting worms. It is learned software. Then, Peach performs a physical transfer. He anesthetizes the trained donor salamander and he removes a portion of its brain, specifically the cerebrum or the midbrain.

He takes that highly trained tissue and transplants it into the skull of a naive, untrained larval host. He is putting trained tissue into a salamander that has never experienced the dish tapping, never eaten raw liver, and has never been subjected to any conditioning whatsoever. Host salamander heals from the surgery. Peach walks up to the dish and taps the rim. And the completely untrained host salamander arches its back and looks up anticipating the liver. It's wild. It exhibits the exact conditioned response of the donor.

The specific learned in memory was physically transferred via the tissue. The sources note that these transferred behaviors weren't fleeting either. They endured in the host for months and sometimes years. Wow. And to rule out the trauma of the surgery itself, he performed control transplants using tissue from naive, untrained donors, and those hosts produced absolutely no looking up response. The phase relationships encoding that specific memory were physically carried over in the dendritic networks of the transplanted tissue. But he didn't stop with same -species

transfers. He wanted to push the absolute boundaries of biological compatibility. This brings us to the cross -species composites, the Frankenbrains. Peach took brain tissue from a frog and grafted it into a salamander host. The salamander woke up. regained full consciousness and had normal motor function. It could swim and walk perfectly, but it exhibited a massive behavioral shift. It completely refused to eat meat. Right, because frogs have entirely different dietary drives. Exactly. Salamanders are naturally aggressive carnivores, but the composite animal lost its

host's carnivorous instinct and had to be force -fed to survive. He transferred an entirely different species behavioral operating system. And the experiment with the guppy brain? makes the mechanics of this even clearer. Oh yeah, the guppy. He took the cerebrum of a guppy, a tropical fish, and grafted it into the brain of a salamander host. Guppies, being tropical, have metabolisms intricately tied to water temperature. When the salamander woke up from the surgery, it adopted a highly specific guppy trait. It completely refused to feed if the ambient temperature dropped

below 18 degrees Celsius. If the water was cool, it acted like a tropical fish in distress. But as soon as you warmed the tank up, it resumed normal salamander feeding behavior. What's fascinating here is the mechanism of how this behavior manifests. It's the key to proving the hologramic theory. It's tempting to use a computer analogy here. You might say it's like taking a hard drive from a Mac and plugging it into a PC. But that analogy fails, right? Because in a computer, the new operating system usually overwrites or crashes the host system. Yeah, it would just brick the

computer. But in the Salamander, the new tissue introduces independent behavioral codes that peacefully coexist with the host's original programming. You're entirely right to reject the hard drive metaphor. A much better analogy is a symphony. This peaceful coexistence is the mathematical signature of a hologram, governed by what physicists call an independence principle. In optical holography, you can superimpose dozens of different holograms onto a single photographic plate. You just slightly change the angle of the reference laser for each

exposure. So they just stack on top of each other. Yes. The new information integrates into the complex interference pattern. It does not overwrite or erase the old information. They occupy the exact same physical space without mutual destruction. So applying the symphony analogy, it's not like deleting a file to make room for another. It's like adding a trumpet to a string quartet. The sound waves of the trumpet don't erase the sound waves of the violins. Their waves just merge in the air, creating a richer, more complex combined

interference pattern. You can still hear the violin and you can still hear the trumpet. Exactly. When Peach grafted the guppy brain into the salamander. The wave phase relationships of the guppies' temperature -dependent feeding were superimposed onto the salamander's existing neural hologram. They merged into a single, complex symphony. Wow. And this implies something profoundly unifying about biology. Under this theory, instinct, like a salamander's innate drive to eat worms, and acquired memory, like learning to look up when

a dish is tapped, are mathematically the exact same thing. They're both just phase spectra. Yes. They differ in their evolutionary origin, but mathematically, they're just different instruments playing in the same wave space. If these experiments are so meticulously documented, and if they literally rewrite our fundamental understanding of how memory learning and biology work, well, I know exactly what you were thinking as you listened to this. Why haven't I heard of Paul Peach? Exactly. Why isn't Shuffle Brain required reading in Biology

101? If he proved all this in 1981, why did the world seemingly ignore him? It is the glaring question hanging over all this research. Our source material refers to this as the lost thread. The short answer is that the technological and cultural winds of neuroscience shifted violently in the opposite direction. Right. In the 1980s, and especially the 1990s, which was famously dubbed the decade of the brain, the entire field of neuroscience took a hard pivot toward the micro. The grant money, the prestigious journal publications, and the technological advancements

all moved decisively toward cellular, synaptic, and molecular mechanisms. This was the era where we discovered long -term potentiation. We began mapping specific receptor cascades and isolating discrete neurotransmitters. We discovered place cells and grid cells in the hippocampus. We invented fMRI to track localized blood flow. It was the dawn of high -resolution connectomics, this obsession with mapping the physical wiring diagram of the brain. Yes. And alongside that biological shift, the computational models of the brain shifted.

The 1980s saw the massive boom of the personal computer age. Because silicon microprocessors were changing the world, researchers naturally fell in love with models of the brain that functioned like computers, discrete, addressable representations. A continuous, distributed wave phase code didn't fit the zeitgeist of the digital binary era. It just felt... antiquated. Plus, there was a massive practical barrier that prevented mainstream validation. The memory transfer and shuffling experiments simply couldn't be easily replicated in mammals. Oh, right, because of the trauma.

That was perhaps the fatal blow for Peach's momentum. Salamanders can survive having their brains minced and flipped because of their incredibly unique amphibian regenerative biology. If a researcher at Harvard tries to mince the cortex of a rat or a macaque monkey to replicate Peach's work, the animal simply suffers massive hemorrhaging and dies. Mainstream mammalian neuroscience couldn't operationalize Peach's work. Right. Because they couldn't recreate it in their own standard lab models, they ignored it. We also can't ignore

the cultural contamination that happened in the early 90s. The book. Yeah. A writer named Michael Talbot published a massively popular book called The Holographic Universe. He took these incredibly rigorous optical, mathematical and biological concepts from Gabor, Pribram and Peach, and he spun them into a sort of mystical new age pop psychology. He used the holographic theory to explain psychic phenomena, telepathy and quantum mysticism. Which is absolute poison to a nascent controversial scientific theory. Serious tenure

track scientists. sprinted in the other direction. They didn't want their grant proposals associated with crystal healing or telekinesis. No, they wanted hard, irrefutable data on serotonin uptake at the synaptic cleft. So playing the devil's advocate here, did the reductionists just win out because they were right? Is the hologram theory dead in the water because we successfully mapped the human genome, invented optogenetics, and can literally watch an engram cell light up in a mouse's brain? The theory was never refuted by the data. It was simply set aside because

it was too difficult to work with. The thread was dropped because mainstream science took the more tractable path. It's easier to get funding for the micro stuff. It is infinitely easier to get a million dollar grant to study a specific protein cascade at a single synapse than it is to devise an experiment measuring whole brain multidimensional phase interference patterns. The localization approach, mapping the microparts, yielded tremendous medical and pharmacological results. But mapping the parts still hasn't solved the core philosophical mystery. How does a unified,

distributed, continuous mind arise from billions of local, discrete parts? Exactly. The localization model tells us how the engine works, but the hologramic model is the only one that explains how the car actually drives. Which brings us to the profound implications of all this. The source material draws these historical experiments firmly into the present, offering a framework for how we should view the human mind today. These implications bridge the gap between abstract optical physics and our daily human experience.

Yeah, let's get into what this actually means for us. Let's explore how this theory completely changes the way we view brain damage. The first major implication is what we can call radical resilience. If human memory and intent are a distributed face code, then large -scale tissue loss, like the damage caused by a massive stroke, a tumor resection, or traumatic brain injury, shouldn't necessarily result in the permanent deletion of specific memories. The physical localized file wasn't destroyed because the file never existed. The residual healthy fragments of the

brain still contain the mathematical equations to reconstruct the usable content, just at a lower resolution or with more noise. This should radically change how we approach stroke rehabilitation. Right now, there is a tendency to mourn the lost specific loci of the brain. If the speech center is damaged, we assume speech is gone. But under the hologramic model, rehab shouldn't just be about building clumsy workarounds. It should focus on aggressively stimulating the remaining healthy tissue's latent capacity to reconstruct

those phase patterns. The symphony can still be played, we just need to teach the remaining instruments to play louder. The theory also fundamentally redefines how we view lifelong learning. It solves the problem of catastrophic interference. Which is what? Well, in early computer neural networks, if you train the network on task A and then train it on task B, the new weights would overwrite the old ones and the network would instantly forget task A. Okay. But humans don't do that. You can learn a new language at age 40 without it accidentally overwriting your ability to ride

a bicycle. The hologramic model explains this perfectly through the independence principle. Multiple wave spectra can coexist in the same tissue without destroying each other. One of the most beautiful implications in Brian's notes is how this theory collapses the distinction between perceiving the world and remembering the world. They are mathematically continuous processes. That is perhaps the most profound shift in perspective. Under this model, the distinction between sensing a live event and remembering a past event. Blurs into semantics. Wait, really?

Yeah. Recall is simply the brain internally generating an inverse transform to reconstruct an image from stored interference patterns. Yeah. Perception is the exact same mathematical process. The brain constructing an image from live sensory interference patterns generated by the eyes or ears. It's the same transform. Remembering is quite literally just perceiving inward. So when you visualize your childhood bedroom, your brain is executing the exact same wave math as if you were standing in the room looking at it. That's exactly. So what does this all mean? That naturally leads

us to the philosophical crux of this entire deep dive. It offers a framework for consciousness that is physicalist but completely non -reductive. It solves the great debate of what we actually are. Think about your own deepest memories. Think about the specific scent of pine needles or the exact timber of your best friend's laugh. Under the old structuralist theory, that precious memory is sitting as a physical trace inside one specific molecule or a handful of cells waiting to be permanently destroyed by a minor concussion or

a dying baron. Which is terrifying. It really is. But under the hologramic theory, your memory is not a physical object. It is a wave pattern singing continuously across the vast ocean of your brain. This theory beautifully sidesteps crude materialism, which says you are nothing but a sack of atomic years, and it sidesteps spiritual dualism, which says your mind is an unmeasurable ghost haunting the biological machine. Your mind is a physical pattern, strictly bound by the laws of physics, but it is carried by waves independent of any single fragile atom.

And that implies a continuum of mind across all biological life. The underlying physics of a simple larval salamander learning to avoid a bright light and human cognition debating the finer points of philosophy are formally the exact same thing. It is distributed phase coding. Humans just possess a thicker cortex, providing exponentially more complexity and higher dimensionality in our wave spectrum. Micromines and macromines exist on a single, unbroken continuum of physics. The salamander and the human are playing the

same game, just on different sized fields. This realization naturally bridges the gap from Peach's 1981 amphibian laboratory directly to Brian Rommel's modern technological work. Because the laboratory to test these theories has grown exponentially larger, we are finally moving from the biology of salamanders to the architecture of silicon. The modern manifestations of the hologramic theory are playing out in artificial intelligence right now. Let's talk about Brian's practical experiments. Remember Brian in his garage hacking those early consumer EEG headsets? Yeah, that's a great example.

He was spending hours training models on his own personal brainwave data. He was trying to correlate the raw theta and beta wave patterns, you know, the electrical storms moving across his scalp, with his own internal imagery and conscious intent. And his major breakthrough. was the realization that he didn't need to track single neurons to know what he was thinking. By simply listening to the distributed, noisy, overlapping electrical signals across the skull, he could extract a whole coherent intent. He

was tracking the whole wave, not the individual drops of water. He was doing exactly what the diffuse hologram does. He was reconstructing a clear image from a seemingly broken, noisy plate. The signals his EEG picked up were fragmentary, messy, and indirect. But the mathematical meaning buried in the phase relationships was entirely whole. And this wave -based approach connects to other modern technological trails Brian explored over the years. Photobiomodulation, which is the practice of shining specific frequencies of lasers on damaged tissue to stimulate healing

through wave resonance. Wave genetics. And the thermodynamic incentives that govern how autonomous systems self -organize. But the most urgent and timely application of this theory today is in the realm of artificial intelligence. Specifically, the debate between massive centralized data centers and local AI systems using multi -model consensus agents. This is where the salamander teaches the computer scientist. Think about modern localized AI architectures. You can design a swarm of smaller AI agents, a distributed network running across

multiple devices. And in that network, individual nodes can fail. A server can go down. A connection can be severed. And yet the overarching system survives, the task continues, and the consensus decision -making remains remarkably coherent. It behaves exactly like the minced brain of Peach's salamander. Both the local AI swarm and the salamander exhibit this incredible stubborn wholeness. There is no single centralized vulnerable store of the mind. This raises an important question, though. It serves as a stark warning and a blueprint

for technologists today. We are currently architecting the next generation of artificial minds. If we build these AI systems like a traditional hard drive, strictly localized, with highly addressable siloed information and centralized control, they will be inherently brittle. A single catastrophic failure point? A single severed wire? can crash the entire multibillion -dollar system. But if we build them like a hologram? If we architect them around distributed phase relationships where every part contains a low -resolution map of

the whole, they inherit the biological resilience of the amphibian. They survive disruption. They could be fragmented, minced, and disconnected, and still dynamically reconstruct their core intent. the underlying physics of resilience is mathematically identical whether the medium is wet neural tissue or dry silicon wafers it's an absolutely staggering journey we've been on today it really is Let's synthesize the ground we've covered. We started with Brian Rommel rescuing a physically discarded library book from a cart in Texas. That dusty book led us back to Carl

Ashley's intense frustration, cutting up rat brains for decades and failing to find a single memory. We looked to Dennis Gabor and the invention of optical holography to provide the math that biology lacked. We walked into Paul Peach's 1970s laboratory and watched him meticulously, brutally mince the brains of salamanders, only to watch them wake up and resume hunting worms. We saw third eyes glued to the top of skulls instantly wire themselves into a fear response through inverse wave transforms. We saw frog and guppy

minds seamlessly transplanted into salamander bodies, playing their distinct notes in a shared biological symphony. And through it all, we traced the slow, undeniable realization that consciousness, behavior, and memory operate less like a physical substance locked inside a vault of cells and more like a standing pattern of interference, a persistent wave that survives the violent scrambling of its physical medium. Which leaves us with a final... Deeply provocative thought pulled straight from Brian's notes. It's a philosophical challenge to leave you with. Right. The hologramic

theory of the mind does not promise immortality. If you take a hammer and completely smash the holographic plate into dust, the image is permanently gone. If the physical medium is utterly destroyed, the wave ceases to exist. But while it doesn't promise immortality, it does promise something equally profound. Reconstructability. And that concept single -handedly forces us to redefine the nature of identity. If your mind, your memories, your personality, your fears is essentially a mathematical wave pattern that can survive the

physical scrambling, mincing, and reordering of its biological medium, then what exactly is your mind? And taking it a step further, if a modern artificial intelligence system can be designed to reconstruct a complex pattern of intent from a fragmented, scrambled silicon medium, does it share the exact same kind of foundational mind as Peach's resilient salamander? If the mathematical pattern is the mind, does the wetness or dryness of the physical substrate even matter at all? It is the ultimate question we face as we enter the abundance in Eregnum. We are no

longer just building machines. We are learning the mathematical language to manipulate the waves of consciousness themselves. It really is the frontier. I want to thank you for joining us on this deep dive. Remember, the research behind this is vast. And to keep these deep dives coming, go support Brian at readmultiplex .com, become a member, buy him a coffee, and keep this kind of relentless historical exploration alive. There is always another lost thread waiting to be pulled. So true. And the next time you have to go to the doctor and you find yourself looking at an

x -ray of a broken bone, take a second to appreciate the clean, comforting, binary simplicity of that jagged white line. Because the mind reading that x -ray is anything but simple. Exactly. Because the moment you look away from that broken bone and start thinking about the incredibly complex wave -based mind that is actively perceiving it, that simple mechanical view of the world shatters. And the mind that endlessly rebuilds itself from those shattered pieces is vastly more resilient and infinitely more beautiful than a simple machine. Catch you on the next

deep dive. Welcome to the multiplex, where the future comes alive. Past, present, future tech, open up your eyes. Brian Romero leads the way with research deep and true. Technology and history, he connects them all for you. Brian Romero leads the way with research deep and true. Technology and history, he connects them all for you. Ancient sparks to modern code, he traces every thread, go exploration. But humanity moves on Love equation

for AI Zero human companies building from the start Thermodynamic wages earning the key Secrets we will read Experiment in publishing

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. ReadMultiplex.com: The Field That Heals: Why Pulsed Electromagnetic Fields May Have Profound Benefits.

    Nov 21, 202651 minAudio

    Got something to say to this podcast? Send a voicemail, and you might hear yourself on the next episode! Every cell in your body has lived its whole life inside a magnetic field. The Earth is a dynamo, and it has been...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. 78 RPM Record Hour: From Steel to Hillbilly

    Nov 19, 20261 hrAudio

    Got something to say to this podcast? Send a voicemail, and you might hear yourself on the next episode! The 78 RPM Record Hour, Episode 3: From Steel to Hillbilly (Early Country). From steel to hillbilly: Frank Ferera,...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. 78 RPM Record Hour: The Knife and the Steel

    Nov 19, 20261 hrAudio

    Got something to say to this podcast? Send a voicemail, and you might hear yourself on the next episode! The 78 RPM Record Hour, Episode 2: The Knife and the Steel (Hawaiian). The knife of the blues slide guitar and the...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. ReadMultiplex.com: How to Run Local AI on a Computer From 2017.

    Nov 18, 202635 minAudio

    Got something to say to this podcast? Send a voicemail, and you might hear yourself on the next episode! Somewhere in your house there is a computer you stopped thinking about. Maybe it is a 2017 laptop in a drawer, its...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. 78 RPM Record Hour: Blues (Pilot)

    Nov 18, 20261 hrAudio

    Got something to say to this podcast? Send a voicemail, and you might hear yourself on the next episode! The 78 RPM Record Hour, Episode 1 (Pilot): Blues. Fourteen original 78 RPM records from 1917 to 1925 that trace...

    Credit the people on this episode