In this episode, Israel and Brook respond to the Botkin sisters' apology video about their book So Much More. Does the Bible require a young woman to live under her father's authority until she marries? Is an adult daughter obligated to obey her parents forever? What does 1 Corinthians 7 say about the unmarried woman's freedom to serve the Lord? Israel and Brook address this controversial topic on today's episode. Biblical parenting is hard - but you don’t have to figure it out alone. Each week, Raising Them Up tackles real-life parenting questions with biblical wisdom, practical help, and gospel hope. From screen time and sibling conflict to discipleship, marriage, and homeschooling, hosts Israel and Brook Wayne bring decades of parenting experience and a deep love for God’s Word to your everyday challenges. Short, honest, and full of grace - this is Christian parenting help you can trust. Submit your question at raisingthemup.org or call 1-800-223-6567.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
unknownHey!
SPEAKER_01Welcome to another episode of Raising Them Up.
SPEAKER_00Our Christian Parenting QA podcast, and we're your hosts. I'm Israel Wayne. And I'm Brooke Wayne.
SPEAKER_01Hello, welcome to another episode of the Raising Them Up Parenting QA podcast, where we answer your parenting questions. And we would love to hear from you. If you have a question that you'd like to submit for a future episode, you can do that by going to the website for this podcast, raisingthemup.org. That's raisingthemup.org, or call 1-800-223-6567, leave a voicemail, and we will answer your question in a future episode. Well, we have a question that is kind of current for when we're recording this.
SPEAKER_01Uh, there's always a little bit of a delay between when it goes live, but recently a couple of young ladies who we respect, uh, who have been in the kind of Christian and homeschool space for a long time, uh, who had written a book 20 years ago on their views about daughters and their role as teenagers and young adults and what that should look like, uh, they've come out and um have basically written an apology and sort of a biblical exegesis on how they believe some of the teachings that they were promoting uh were not on point.
SPEAKER_01And uh I want to say at the outset that we um think that these young ladies were extremely well-meaning, that they had the right heart. Um they were trying to push back against the feminism of our age and the feminism of our culture, and kind of that view that says that we're uh completely independent from any kind of accountability and that uh we can just sort of live our lives the way that we want to. And they were calling young ladies to live in a way that pleases the Lord.
SPEAKER_01And so the heart was good, and uh there are many things that they wrote in their book that we would, I think, all as biblical Christians agree with uh the idea of young ladies uh pursuing the Lord and pursuing holiness and uh not buying into the false ideologies of the age. But there were a couple of dynamics that they uh talked about and promoted in the books that they're now pushing back on and saying that they think they missed it. And so we've had people contacting us and asking us for, you know, what is our view on that particular issue?
SPEAKER_01So the issue or the topic is uh young women living at home in their young adult years. So after they've finished high school, uh, should they go to college, should they get a job, should they go on mission trips, should they get their own apartment or their own house? What should their own career, what should that look like? And the general working thesis of these two young ladies, who I should say were 15 and 17 when they first started writing the book, and it was like two years later that the book actually was published.
SPEAKER_01So they were quite young, and uh sometimes we're as young people idealistic, and that we have viewpoints that we think you know, this is the way it should be. And then later you kind of get some exposure to life and maybe a little bit more hermeneutical and scriptural grounding, and see a little bit more of life happen. Yeah, and so they have have repudiated some of the things that they taught. And I think this is a fair representation of their thesis. It was that young women should be under the covering of their fathers and their spiritual protection and authority until such time as they marry, and then that transfers to their husband, and that there shouldn't be an interim where they're not living under the authority of a man.
SPEAKER_01And the view was that that's the godly order. Um, this was a view that was promoted by many people uh who talked in conservative fundamental Christian circles uh in the late 80s through probably the early 2000s. It was a fairly popular viewpoint. And uh you actually published a magazine for young women um when you were a teenager, and so it was kind of the dominant view, I would say, within the sphere in which you were operating, uh, because there were like dozens of these magazines written by young women and published by young women.
SPEAKER_01Right. And yours was one of the more popular ones at the time. And so um, these were things that I think a lot of us in that age group had to contend with, um, especially coming up in conservative fundamental circles and then the homeschooling culture. So we want to talk about that. What is the biblical view of this? And I think one of the dangers that we can get into is when we start to make laws and rules where God hasn't made laws and rules.
SPEAKER_01And so the idea of a young woman being uh wise and discerning and having accountability in her life and uh having discretion and all those things, uh, those are great ideals, and those are things that we should promote and we should encourage. Um, but when we say that a young woman should not work outside of the home because then she's under the authority of another man besides her husband, or in some cases, some of these uh teachers, not these two ladies in particular, but some of the teachers maybe that influenced them and that were popular at that time, said that a young woman should not uh even work for a woman, because they were saying that a woman should not have a business, even if it's inside of her home.
SPEAKER_01Um, and if she does, then it's really under the authority of her husband. So if this young lady is working for a woman who has a home-based business, she still is under the authority of some other man who's not her father. And so these were some of the arguments. Um, there was also the argument against them uh going to going into missions or college or you know, other things. And so um I think that what we've learned as we have had children and we have some young adult women now, um, is that there's a balance to all of this.
SPEAKER_01And that there is uh a need, I think, for us as parents to help our children to make wise decisions and to help them to uh be safe and to be discerning. But I mean, really, we feel that way about our sons and our daughters.
SPEAKER_00I know, right?
SPEAKER_01Not just our daughters.
SPEAKER_00I'm all for providing a place for our young men too to remain at home until that time um that they have some reason to leave the home, not just pushing them out. At 18 years old, you go make a living on your own, but just the accountability that's in the home for just the family relationships and and all that as well for our young men, not just our young women. But that doesn't mean uh it's a law.
SPEAKER_01So some people in that time period said that like women shouldn't go to college, for example. And uh I'll just tell you my bias. I think that none of us should presume that our children should go to college, uh, sons or daughters.
SPEAKER_00In this day and age in particular.
SPEAKER_01And so this is not a gender issue, in my view. It is a whole episode that we would need to do, probably like an hour or two webinar, honestly, on why we need to rethink college. I'm not saying that no one should ever go to college, but I don't think that should be our assumption and that we should start with a presupposition that young people need to go to college for a myriad of reasons. I think it should be the exception rather than the rule that someone goes to college.
SPEAKER_01And if they go to college, they are very focused on what it is that God's calling them to do with their life, and uh they have a very purposeful intent on what they're going there to do, and that they need the degree for the thing that God is calling them to do with their life, and that they choose their school wisely, and there's a whole bunch of factors, right? So the college issue is is huge. Um, but I would say that in terms of these young women, the the idea was that they would be under the protection and the covering of their father.
SPEAKER_01And I actually wrote an article for um my family published a national homeschool magazine back in those days, and somewhere 15 to 20 years ago, I wrote an article on that topic. And uh one of the things that I called out in that article was that the the view was that these young women were supposed to stay home and support their father's vision. And I think what was clear was that a lot of those men didn't have a vision, right? Like they didn't have a vision for their own lives, let alone a vision for their daughter's life.
SPEAKER_01And these young women are staying at home, folding laundry, making meals, and just wondering, well, when is Prince Charming going to show up? And because they had very little social life, some of them didn't get married. Yeah. And uh sometimes they had controlling fathers who actually were not helping them to be able to find a future for themselves. So what typically happened in a lot of those situations is there was a lot of trust that my dad is looking out for me in my best interest.
SPEAKER_01And quite often the dad was just busy with his life and he didn't really have a vision for his own life, let alone for his daughter's life and for her future. And so it really created a very difficult situation for many young women who didn't have a job, who didn't have an income, who weren't really involved in any service or ministry. And uh what I noticed just observationally was that a lot of these young ladies would hang in until about their middle 20s, they'd start getting restless.
SPEAKER_01Yep. And then if their Prince Charming hadn't come along by like, say, the age 28, 29, they would bail. And oftentimes um they would react in a really negative way. Oftentimes they would just go start hanging out at bars, shacking up with some guy. It was like they just threw off any hope that their dad's path was a path that was gonna get them where they wanted them to go. And obviously, I'm not talking about all of them. Uh, some certainly didn't react that dramatically, but many did.
SPEAKER_01And I think it was like they felt like I've been sold this narrative that this is the path to happiness and satisfaction and content.
SPEAKER_00This is gonna lead to, yeah, the happiness, but also maybe a marriage component. And if it didn't, then it was kind of like, okay, game's over.
SPEAKER_01So realizing that not everyone will be married and that some of these ladies will not have a husband, uh, what do you think are some suggestions for women who find themselves in those older teen years uh and into their adult years? And we should say that there's a whole biblical study that we don't have time to get into here about how the Bible delineates adulthood at about age 20. There's several benchmarks that are clearly lined out in the scripture that under 20 is child and and still considered to be under the authority of the parents.
SPEAKER_01Over 20 is considered to be an adult and responsible for themselves. Um military draft, the young people who are allowed to go into the promised land versus those who were not, uh other indications at age 20. And so, give or take, somewhere in there, uh obviously minors uh do need to obey their parents and to comply with the house rules. But once someone is an adult and in our country, at least 21, you know, there's a 18, you're legally allowed to do some things, 21, you're fully legally an adult.
SPEAKER_01Uh, but let's say at least by 21, um, there should be no question as to adulthood. Um, what are some ways in which a young woman can pursue a life that is meaningful, that may not end in marriage, without reacting against her parents and saying, I don't need you, and kind of disowning them and and being dismissive of their place in her life. But how can she be her own person and be an adult uh in that kind of a scenario?
SPEAKER_00I think a lot of it really goes to the surrender to the Lord first. And um, you know, in all of this mix, there's going to be that need to look to, okay, parents, do you have any advice for me in this area? Uh, because they may actually see a good path of this would be a great way to go. Uh, this we have some reservations about. There may be some practical factors.
SPEAKER_01So the parents are likely giving advice and counsel.
SPEAKER_00Right. And I think parents, that one's a tricky one because there may be unbelieving parents who would not have good counsel, you know, and that might be.
SPEAKER_01Unwise parents.
SPEAKER_00Just unwise parents. And so at that time, there should be uh kind of a greater community of of leadership, of, of understanding who are who are the elders in my church and getting to know them and being able to seek out wisdom from someone you respect who is godly, wise, who's further ahead down the road than you. And you know, there might be like some advice from friends that also know you well, but seeing someone who's a good generation above you, I think really has a lot of wisdom. And like in the issue, say, of marrying someone against a parent's uh blessing or confirmation, uh, that should come with great caution in the sense that your parents may know you really well.
SPEAKER_00And, you know, we're talking kind of within the homeschool community here. However, this could obviously relate just within the Christian community, that if you're going to be doing something like that, that's directly against what the parents wish, desire, have blessing for it, whatever the word is there, uh, it should be with great prayer. Um, I would say fasting and prayer on that situation, and then go into those who are wise, who are godly, and having their counsel in that.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. So I would say that a lot of these ideas came out of what is commonly referred to as the hyper-patriarchy movement. And that's a very difficult term to use because it assumes that there's some universal definition for patriarchy, which there's not, but uh basically the etymology of that term is father rule. So it's the rule of the father. And within that culture, there was a lot of emphasis on everything being father-led and father rule. And I remember one time we even went to a family integrated church that was called Fellowship of the Fathers with an S at the end.
SPEAKER_01And so, and at communion, the fathers would serve communion to their families, which I don't necessarily have a problem with. But in that particular case, I was very disgusted to see that there was a single mom and her children who were not given communion at that church service because there wasn't a father in the home. Right. And so so many of those patriarchal ideas were really taken to an extreme, and that the young woman is there to serve her father and so forth. And uh I think that this really misses the mark when we're thinking about it from a biblical framework, particularly when you're uh centering a church around male headship and male fatherhood and so forth.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, Christ is the head of the church. Men are not the head of the church. Christ is the head of the church. And so we want to have Christ-led homes, we want to have Christ-led marriages, uh, we want to have Christ-led parenting. And so when you exalt a human who is fallible and who is sinful, uh, you can get into error. And so I think that in this, you know, the young woman exists to serve her father mentality, it really misses the bigger point, which is what is the cause of Christ?
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_01And is Christ being exalted? And the goal should be that Christ is exalted through the life of this young woman in singlehood or in marriage. And so I think that got missed.
SPEAKER_00I think it did. And part of it, you know, maybe it was like again, like, oh, we could raise up our daughters to be helpmates to their future husbands. And they sort of did it as like, well, then you practice this by being a helpmeet of sorts to your father, or sometimes even brothers would get into the mix. And, you know, the Bible speaks very directly to the unmarried woman in 1 Corinthians 7, where it says the unmarried woman, young woman, uh, I think it just says unmarried woman is supposed to be free to serve the Lord. She is not entangled by the things, the regular things of life.
SPEAKER_00And then it says the married woman does have considerations about her family and very practical issues. And, you know, it's there's this motive there though, that the young woman is free to serve the Lord. She has none of these. And I feel like this daughters at home mindset, unlimited time frame kind of issue kind of creates a situation where she may not really be free to go and serve the Lord in her youth and in that season of singleness, whatever that looks like.
SPEAKER_00Maybe sometimes though, you know, we're we're thinking of these situations we know where the young woman never did get married. And so there's, you know, 20, 40 years maybe of of vitality and an ability to really go and do something in the world that um is maybe minimized where she's not free then to serve the Lord in that capacity.
SPEAKER_01So I want to be clear. We don't believe that it is intrinsically necessary that a young woman at the age of 20 or 25 or whatever that she has to move out of her parents' home. That may be a fine situation. It may be very amiable. It may be that everyone's happy with that kind of a situation. What we're talking about more is the idea that biblically she's not allowed to. And I think that goes beyond scripture. It goes beyond what the scripture teaches. And again, she should be wise about the choices that she makes.
SPEAKER_01But hopefully she has, as you said, a broader scope of counsel where she can draw from her church elders, because hopefully she's a member of a local church, uh, grandparents, if she has grandparents, especially if they're Christians, um, older friends. And what we used to do when we were in our early 20s and needed counsel is we would go to people who were our parents' age and older, because we felt like they probably wouldn't give us the advice that we wanted to hear. They'd give us the advice that we needed to hear.
SPEAKER_01So we had a group of people that we would go to and get advice and counsel from when we made major life decisions. And uh, as you said about the marriage issue, I've always said that if you go against your parents' blessing in terms of who you marry, you had better be more sure of that decision than you've ever been sure of anything in your life and be willing to live with the consequences if you're wrong. Because as Brooke said, there are blind spots that we don't see.
SPEAKER_01And so obviously, we want to push back against the culture of the world who says parents are unnecessary, that disrespects and dishonors parents. But the idea that an adult woman uh is supposed to be under the authority of her father and mother, um, I don't see as being substantiated in the scripture.
SPEAKER_00Yep. My mom really loved history. And I remember so many times on the whiteboard, and I, you know, I now wish I could go back and have photos of her little diagrams and everything, but she would often just show the pendulum swings that have happened through the generations. And so for her, uh being a boomer, there was that expectation that your value basically as a woman depends on your ability to get out there and create a career and prove yourself in this um in the area of the workplace and the marketplace.
SPEAKER_00And so as she kind of looked, went through that whole process, worked for many years, and grew tired of the four walls of her apartment, she desired uh family life. And I think that was the case for so many of in that era. It was this desire to wait, wait, there's more than just the career life for the woman. And so that opened up this idea of we want to help our daughters kind of see the value of investing in the family, of raising children, homeschooling them, uh, of doing some of these things that create more of a family unit of togetherness.
SPEAKER_00But that didn't help then for that next generation beyond that to really launch into knowing, okay, so where do we stop being we're the family, the for and no more kind of concept, and say we we release our children to go and do what they're created to do, even if that's an interim between um marriage. And I know I've heard a lot of folks say the ability to find usefulness of growth of um education, service in that time. Again, going back to 1 Corinthians 7, this is a season that singleness season of great opportunity for service in the Lord.
SPEAKER_00Some of that may project forward and eventually evolve in a family. And I think the desire should always be that giving to the family a future family is of high value, and uh that would be a great service opportunity. But it is also of a great service opportunity if the young woman were to remain single and to put her her heart and her mind into serving the Lord.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I think that there are people that we would have to scratch out of history, the Amy Carmichaels and the Gladys Howards, and so many of these women. Uh, I even had an aunt who was. A missionary as a single woman in Africa and uh taught in a school and was uh used by the Lord for many years. Um, if they are just supposed to stay home and support their father's vision, um, they aren't serving the Lord outside of a very, very limited capacity. And as I said, a lot of these men didn't really have a vision.
SPEAKER_00So that's kind of a tricky one because of course there could be blind sights that we young ladies would have, young people would have, and um knowing how to go about that conversation. I think that's where relationship needs to be both sides. You know, it's not just dependent on the parents in those older years, it is also dependent on the young people to say, honestly, here's how I'm feeling about it, and to go about those conversations in a way that will be just a good open, direct way for them to speak to each other, to understand each other's hearts and make a game plan going forward.
SPEAKER_01So let's just talk about our own family. So our oldest daughter um had health issues throughout her teen years, and so in her older teen years, she was limited in what she could do physically. But we encouraged her to get at least a part-time job. Um, and we were always careful with all of our children that we tried to get them into environments that we thought would be healthy, uh, good work environments. And so there was a lady in our church who had started a coffee shop in our town, and she was a very kind and gracious and merciful lady.
SPEAKER_01And so it was a perfect fit for our daughter who needed that kind of a boss. And so she worked there for a while. Two years, maybe? Yeah, maybe two years on you know, on a part-time basis, just because physically she wasn't up the full time. Um, but we felt like it gave her some drive and some focus and some determination, and I have to get myself ready and go to work, and then to be able to get new experiences, interacting with people that would give her some life skills that would be beneficial. She ended up um living with us until she was maybe 23.
SPEAKER_00Yes.
SPEAKER_01And so she married at that age and um, you know, had found the guy that she wanted to marry by about 21, so kind of knew what her path was going to be that she was pursuing marriage. But during that time in her early 20s, um, she worked for our business uh from home. And so again, um, you know, there was actually something for her to do uh at home. And then our second daughter, who is at the time of this recording about 19 years old, um, she wanted to get a job.
SPEAKER_01And uh so at 18 years old, she got a full-time job working in a local cleaning business. And she has been very successful at that and actually makes more money than her boys. Probably they won't be pleased if this gets put out on the air, but hey, um, she's doing really well and she's just very driven, very focused. And so for her, even at 18, the thought of just like sitting around the house post-high school, she has no ambition to go to college, and uh, she does want to be married, and in fact, um, knows who she wants to marry.
SPEAKER_01Uh, so that's in her future. She's very kind of goal and task oriented. Um, not totally sure, but I think she may have proposed. Um, but she's just one of these personalities that she's not a docile, quiet uh wallflower kind of girl. And so um the so one of the things, of course, that we've done is we've said with our children, well, let's just kind of watch the fruit, you know, let's see how this goes, let's see how you are able to handle it, you know. And if we were to see her start spiral spiraling in some unhealthy way, well, of course, we would try to, you know, talk with her about that.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. But but I here's the as we close this, here's I think the bottom line. Your children will follow you as parents if they firmly believe that you are for them. And if in the things that you've led them in and that you've instructed them in, and even when they were younger and the times when you had to tell them no, if they believe that it was in their best interests and that you really had their future and their best at heart, they'll follow you. But if they believe that the decisions that you're making that impact their life are for your good and for your best, they won't follow you.
SPEAKER_01They will eventually reject you, and it's gonna get ugly. So you have to be part of a team. And the team really needs to be about them and their future, not about you and your future. You've had your day in the sun. Uh, you need to release your children into the world to go and serve God and to be lights for him. You know, that as arrows in the hands of a warrior, so are the children of one's youth. Well, those arrows are not to sit in the quiver forever, they're to be launched into the world against the king of darkness and the kingdom of darkness to do great damage for the kingdom of light.
SPEAKER_01And so that's what our children are. That's how we're raising them. And so we don't want to just keep all of our children in the quiver forever. We're raising adults, we're not raising children. So we want to release them into the world, but to follow the Lord, not their own sinful pleasures and their own hedonistic, you know, goals. Uh, but it's not about their goals and it's not about our goals, it's really about what is God's will for their life. And we come alongside them as coaches and mentors and as cheerleaders to help them find that.
SPEAKER_01And if they believe that you're really all about that and that you're helping them to find God's will for their life and to fulfill God's purposes, they're gonna follow you. So that's our advice and counsel to you is to really encourage your sons and your daughters to think about what God wants them to do and how can they make an impact in this world for the kingdom of God. Well, we hope this has been helpful for you, and we would love for you to subscribe to our podcast, which is raisingthemup.org.
SPEAKER_01Tell your friends about it, like it, review it, all the things. Help us get the word out about this. And then our ministry is familyrenewal.org, familyrenewal.org. Lots of great parenting resources and family resources on there. And also, we would love for you to have us come speak at your event, family camp, church, whatever. Uh, go to israelwain.com. That's my name, israelwain.com. There's a contact form there where you can write to us, and we would love to connect with you and see how we can be part of an event that you're doing.
SPEAKER_01Also, connect with us on social media. You can look up Israel Wayne or Family Renewal anywhere you hang out in social media land. And then we would love for you to purchase our books. We have great resources, and you can find those at generations.org. They are the producers of this podcast. Generations.org, just go to the store and then look up my name, Israel Wayne. It'll pull up a list of all the books that I've written, and you can support our ministry and generations ministry by purchasing from their web store. So thank you guys.
SPEAKER_01We appreciate you, and we'll see you next time on the Raising Them Up podcast. This has been a production of the Generations Media Network. For more information, go to generations.org/slash media.
What do you do when your home feels like a war zone, with siblings tattling and parents yelling? Why does a 19-year-old keep saying she forgot? And how should a wife respond when her husband asks her to dress in a way...
Should you go against your parenting instincts to fit in at a co-op, especially when student government requires smartphones? What do you do when your 13-year-old daughter is harsh and disrespectful to you but sweet...
Is it ever okay to leave your church, even if the preaching is good? How do you get to know someone after you’re engaged? And what should you do when your son wants to join the military, but you're not on board? Listen...
What do you do when your teens act crude and say they don’t care what anyone thinks? How do you guide a daughter who talks all day without shutting her down? And how do you love and honor your parents when they keep...
Is a mom entitled to be upset when dad makes a decision without her? How should she communicate her hurt without trying to control her husband? And is it okay to use secular curriculum when it seems more academically...