Is debt a sin? Wes McAdams and Marcus Stenson explore Proverbs 22:7 - ”the borrower is slave to the lender” - to unpack the biblical wisdom around debt, lending, and financial stewardship. This episode examines how Proverbs offers general truths rather than absolute promises, distinguishing between wise financial decisions and sinful behavior. They discuss Old Testament laws against charging interest, the Year of Jubilee, and how consumer debt differs from predatory lending. Discover why the Bible focuses more on lenders than borrowers, how perpetual debt stifles spiritual fruit, and what sacrificial generosity looks like in Christian community. Whether you’re wrestling with credit cards, student loans, or mortgage decisions, this conversation challenges Western assumptions about debt and calls believers to cruciform living that prioritizes relationships over financial gain. Learn to navigate our economic system with biblical wisdom. Links and Resources: * Mere Christianity by C.S. Lewis * Ecclesiastes episode with Michael Whitworth * Freed-Hardeman University Certificate in Counseling for Church Leaders: fhu.edu/gradtheology Disclaimer: This post may contain affiliate links. If you make a purchase through these links, we may earn a small commission at no additional cost to you. This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit www.radicallychristian.com
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
A person that is crippled with debt is not likely to have peace in their life. They are more likely to act rashly or aggressively since you're probably just going
SPEAKER_00to be in a perpetual state of fight or flight. And this becomes difficult because kindness does not proceed from desperation. Desperation has all of our focus turned inward. So just being in debt perpetually is not the place where God wants his people to exist. It certainly would snuff out generosity. And that's one of the hallmarks of the presence of the spirit, presence of the spirit in someone's life.
SPEAKER_01Is debt a sin? Today we're going to look at Proverbs 22.7 on the Radically Christian podcast, where we have one goal, learn to love like Jesus. But before we get to that conversation, I want to share a word from the sponsor of today's episode. I've seen firsthand how church leaders face challenges that go beyond sermons and Bible studies. people come to them with struggles that need more than just good advice that's why friedhardeman university created the certificate in counseling for church leaders
it's fully online and designed to help ministers and elders respond wisely to issues like grief anxiety and addiction they especially encourage minister teams and elderships to consider going through this program together in cohorts as it
SPEAKER_01builds shared skills and strengthens the entire ministry team If you want to serve your congregation better and grow in practical skills that you can use immediately, check it out at fhu.edu slash gradtheology. Okay, now my conversation about debt with my co-host, Marcus Stinson. Hey, Marcus. How's this going, brother?
SPEAKER_00Doing good, man. Good to be back. Fantastic.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, we're surviving the ice and snow. How about y'all?
SPEAKER_00We're doing okay. Just a few hours south, but just as dicey down here, I think.
SPEAKER_01No doubt. No doubt. We're not used to this kind of thing in Texas, but we will make it through. We'll make it through. Let's talk about Proverbs 22, verse 7. How about that?
SPEAKER_00Let's do it.
SPEAKER_01Okay. So I'm just going to read it, and then we can jump into it. So it says, "...the rich rules over the poor, and the borrower is the slave of the lender." So the question that kind of comes with this and sort of revolves around this passage, I've heard this passage be quoted a lot, that the borrower is a slave to the lender. And a lot of people, I think, wonder, is it a sin to go into debt? Is debt a sin? And so let's talk about, is debt a sin? But maybe first,
SPEAKER_01like, how do we read this proverb in light of how do we read Proverbs in general? Let's talk about that for a second. How do we read Proverbs?
SPEAKER_00Proverbs, to me, one of my favorite books. Proverbs is about the development of wisdom. And wisdom only comes by practical application and experience, right? So Proverbs, to me, when we look at a proverb like this, of the best things that you can do is understand that in general a lot of times this is the way the world works but not in every instance and the difference between the way the world normally works in every instance is
that thing that only comes by that painful experience called wisdom right and so wise application of this proverb hopefully should give us a little bit of insight and a little bit of
SPEAKER_00clarity about a question like this which I think really touches all of us in a way, um, maybe more prevalently than we think about often. We all know the nagging feeling of bills piling up or responsibilities. emergencies happening, and we're not sure what to do with them. And you might read this proverb and say, is borrowing in this instance okay as a follower of Jesus? Is it a sin for me to participate in,
as this proverb seems to suggest on its face, putting myself in debt to someone or giving someone the ability to be a master over
SPEAKER_00me and becoming a slave to them. I've been thinking about it a lot lately, especially as we, you know, we're preparing to do this episode. Our entire world is really built on a system of leveraged debt. So this is an important question for us to talk about. It's an important thing for us to dig into. The world of credit cards and student loans and... charging interest it'll be good for us to kind of wrestle through this a little bit yeah let's let's talk for a second about just what you you brought out a second ago
about the idea of these being general truths and and and developing wisdom and i i think that so much of proverbs is about observation like like looking at the world
SPEAKER_01and saying like you said This is generally how things operate. A few weeks ago, we did an episode. You weren't with us that day, but we talked with Michael Whitworth about the idea of Ecclesiastes and how Ecclesiastes and Proverbs are kind of in conversation with each other. And Proverbs is more of a, you know, this is the way things work out well. Like if you do these things, things generally go well for you. If you do these things... You know, generally things will not go well for you. And then Ecclesiastes is sort of the other side of it to say,
well, actually, hold on a second.
SPEAKER_01Sometimes you do the right thing and things still go poorly. And sometimes you do the wrong thing and things seem to go pretty well for you. You know, like, so sometimes things, as you said earlier, don't necessarily work out this way. So the Proverbs are not necessarily like these universal truths that are always true in every situation, no matter what. I had a friend one time that said that he read the Proverbs like promises. And I thought, man, that's the wrong way to read the Proverbs.
SPEAKER_01They are not promises. The verse right before this says, if you train up a child in the way that he should go when he's old, he will not depart from it. Like generally that's true. But that doesn't necessarily mean that if a child is wayward, if a child doesn't do what they're supposed to do, that their parents must have done something wrong. It's the parents' fault. They messed up. If they had trained them in the way they were supposed to go, they would not have departed from it. That cannot be drawn from that. What you can say is generally...
SPEAKER_01When you train up a child in the way they should go, generally they will not depart from that path. They will stay on that path. But there are always exceptions to that. So we have to keep that in mind as we read any proverb. But I think especially this one here, for the sake of our conversation, we have to keep this in mind that nothing in this passage says debt is a sin. That's not what it says. It doesn't say it is a sin to go get a loan. That's not what it says. But there is wisdom in this passage.
SPEAKER_01And as you said, not just wisdom for the ancient world. There probably was a particular way of applying this to their world. But there is still a tremendous amount of relevant wisdom for our world. We still live in a world where debt is leveraged against people and where people do. find themselves buried under a tremendous amount of debt. We were talking earlier just about our own experiences with that and how we saw that in different times and different ways growing up and the
crushing nature that
SPEAKER_01debt can have on people. I know my family experienced that. I don't think my parents would mind too much me saying that they got in over their heads. We were underwater. They couldn't breathe. Yeah, we live in a world where debt certainly can make us slaves to the lender.
SPEAKER_00I agree with that so much. Similar experience growing up, I don't think my parents would be upset either. As a matter of fact, I hope they look back and they're proud of what they were able to accomplish. We didn't realize that we were not well off, my sisters and I, until we were in junior high, when those things become really difficult to hide. But they were constantly stretched and constantly pinched, and it gave me a certain worldview and approach to the world and an approach to debt, especially things like credit cards. uh instilled a really healthy fear in me of not allowing myself
to get behind in those situations and spaces um i love what you added to how we opened about
SPEAKER_00proverbs not always being the way the world goes um I think that's why the emphasis in Proverbs is so often on getting wisdom. Like, get wisdom, because that's what applies to the 90% of life situations where things are not black and white. Like, here is a template for order, the way that God has designed the world to work. And you can expect that when things are operating as they should, this is how it will go. So live by these and practice these. But you got to have the wisdom to know how to apply and
approach and navigate when
SPEAKER_00things are a little more ecclesiastical than they are proverbial. So I love that you drew that out.
SPEAKER_01Well, and don't you think that so often, and I think I trained myself, I think this way, I think in very black and white terms, like right and wrong, sin and righteousness. And sometimes that's not the right question. The right question isn't, is this wrong? The right question is more, is this wise? Like, am I sinning if I have a credit card? Maybe that might not be the best question to ask, because maybe the answer is no. You're not sinning. You're not in rebellion to the will of God by having a credit card,
SPEAKER_01simply by having a credit card. You maybe ought to be asking yourself, am I being wise? Am I operating in a wise way, in a way that promotes the health and well-being of myself and my family and my neighbors and my community and the world? Am I contributing to the overall well-being of myself and others by doing this, whatever this is? And so sometimes it's not a matter of, is God going to strike me dead? Am I going to go to hell if I do such and such?
SPEAKER_01But the question might be better phrased as, is this a wise thing to do? Is this leading in the right way? Is this the sort of thing that I ought to be doing? Is this going to have the kind of results that I'm looking for in life?
SPEAKER_00Am I borrowing for the right reasons? Am I borrowing out of a covetousness? Am I borrowing out of the spirit of consumerism because I'm not satisfied or content? Am I borrowing in a way that is gonna be ultimately injurious to me, where I'm willfully putting myself in a position where someone can take advantage of me and exact a lot more for me than they should? Am I borrowing in a way that puts people that I'm responsible for taking care of at risk? So now I'm bringing my debt upon them. Those are probably better questions than,
SPEAKER_00is it just a sin to borrow or to have any debt of any kind on its face? I think... If we nuance those a little bit, especially as they pertain to the long-term effects of my ability to be a good steward and a witness, and the long-term effects of the relationships that I'm responsible for, that gets us closer to being able to exercise and make those decisions with the wisdom that Proverbs is calling us to.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. And isn't it interesting that this proverb, like so many of them, is not necessarily a command. It's not necessarily instruction in the sense of do this, don't do this, here's what you ought to do. There is no ought to statement. It's simply an observation. It says that this is what happens. The rich rules over the poor. The borrower is slave of the lender. It's not saying, be rich, don't be poor. It's not what it's saying. It's saying, this is the way the world operates. As you look out in the world,
SPEAKER_01you see the rich ruling over the poor, and you see the borrower being slave to the lender. In fact, you could argue that I think this proverb is observation about how the world is, but... isn't how it should be like that's not the way the world was supposed to be with one human ruling over another human this is not the way the world is supposed to be but it is the way that it does operate in our fallen and broken world the rich are
SPEAKER_01ruling over the poor and the borrowers are slave to the lenders Now, it's interesting to me that when we read this in our consumer society, where we think of everything from the perspective of the consumer, we are asking, is debt a sin? And what we mean is, is it a sin to borrow money? Maybe the better question, or at least equally important question is, is it a sin to loan money? Like, why are we thinking about this from the perspective of the borrower instead of from
SPEAKER_01the perspective of the lender? Yeah. is it a sin to enslave people with debt maybe that is a question we ought to be tackling the bible has quite a lot to say about that actually yeah and has very very strong language about it um that's why i think it's really good that you bring
SPEAKER_00that up when god gave the law to the israelites in the old testament In all three, in three places, it's recited that to lend on interest like that is forbidden to put someone in your debt in a way that causes them to be oppressed or poverty stricken or is just, uh, It actually, within the people of Israel, any interest at all was forbidden in their legal code, in Exodus, in Deuteronomy, in Leviticus, all those places.
SPEAKER_00You are not permitted to take profit from a brother's distress. So the implication there is that sometimes people go into debt because bad things happen and life is unpredictable. There's no proclamation of them being in sin for being in that situation or sinning to have gotten in that situation, even though it's certainly possible for some of the reasons that we've already talked about. But God's word is to the lender that you are not to be involved in this. The focus is on treating people who've fallen on hard times as
family and not as a
SPEAKER_00means of financial growth for yourself, charging interest on survival loans. I remember we talked about not too long ago the loan sharks out there on the payday loans with the two-week terms that are really prevalent in our society right now. This is the kind of thing, among others, that was totally outlawed in ancient Israel. Um... you wanted to, I guess I would say that another's misfortune was not to be your opportunity for fortune.
SPEAKER_00And that's a, that's a question that becomes very hard, especially, or challenging, I should say, especially in the, in the, the makeup or the landscape of our modern economic system as, as a Christian who wants to live in accordance with what God's intention for us actually is, uh, I wonder what your thoughts are about how God's edicts in the Old Testament for what he wanted the community of his people to look like really kind of passed down to us now in a New Testament era as the people of God now.
How do you see those two things coming together, especially in our modern landscape?
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Let me just read to kind of to your point. Let me read the command in Exodus about this. This is from Exodus 22, starting verse 25. He says, if you lend money to any of my people with you who is poor, you shall not be like a money lender to him and you shall not exact interest from him. So in other words, if you loan, don't loan with the intention of getting interest from him. Give it to them. And then when they give it back to you, don't take any extra from them. If you ever take your neighbor's cloak in pledge,
SPEAKER_01you shall return it to him before the sun goes down, for that is his only covering, and it is his cloak for his body. In what else shall he sleep? And if he cries to me, I will hear him, for I am compassionate. I think the way that we ought to read the law of Moses as Christians is that Jesus is the one who perfectly embodies the law, and that by following Jesus, by following our Lord, we are fulfilling the law.
SPEAKER_01This is the way that Christians today fulfill the law of Moses. It isn't that we say, well, the law of Moses, that's for a different people, a different time, doesn't have any application to us whatsoever— No, no, no. We say, yes, we are also trying to fulfill the law of Moses, but the way that we fulfill it is by faith, by loyalty to our Lord. And by giving our loyalty to King Jesus and by walking in his footsteps, we are actually doing what the law required. And so what does it look like to fulfill the law? Well, it looks like love your neighbor as yourself.
SPEAKER_01Love one another as Jesus has loved you. That was the heart of this commandment, is do to him, your neighbor, who has fallen on hard times and who comes to you and says, Wes, Marcus, I need help. I can't feed my family today. Like, you don't say, okay, well, until you pay me back, give me your clothes, you know, give me your coat so that I can, you know, hold this in pledge. You know, I'm going to hold on to this for a week, and until you pay me back, I'm not giving you this back.
SPEAKER_01No, no, no. You don't take that from him. That's what he... That's the only way he's keeping warm. You do to him what you would want somebody else to do to you. Like you love him the way you would want to be loved. You take care of him the way you would want. You wouldn't want somebody to say, okay, but I'm going to charge you 120% interest. No, you'd want somebody to say, let me help you feed your family and don't worry about paying it back. Or you pay me back when you can. And no, of course, I'm not going to charge you interest. That's what you would do for someone else. So you do that for them. This is what the Sermon on the Mount is all about,
SPEAKER_01is this is what it looks like to really fulfill the law of Moses. It's not like, okay, well, it says I can't take his cloak and pledge, but it doesn't say I can't take his horse. It doesn't say, no, no, no. You do for him what you would want somebody else to do for you. It's not about following a legal code. It's about loyalty to the Lord who perfectly embodied the law. And when you follow Jesus, you are fulfilling the law of Moses. And so...
SPEAKER_01Very simply, it looks like loving your neighbor as yourself. And you wouldn't want someone giving you a predatory loan so you don't give a predatory loan to someone else. You don't steal from other people because you wouldn't want them to steal from you. And so you treat everybody like they're your sister, your brother, yourself. You treat them as you would want to be treating.
SPEAKER_00100%. And I, I, I cannot stress enough how strong the old Testament is on this. Um, Ezekiel brings up this sort of situation in Ezekiel 18. And it's a eye-opening passage for me because in the scope of Ezekiel 18... Actually, I'll pull it up and let's take a look at it really quick. In Ezekiel 18, we read a clause...
SPEAKER_00beginning in verse 5, it says, If a man is righteous and does what is right, if he does not eat upon the mountains or lift up his eyes to the idols of the house of Israel and does not defile his neighbor's wife or approach a woman in her time of menstrual impurity, does not oppress anyone, but restores the debtor his pledge, commits no robbery, gives his bread to the hungry, covers the naked with a garment, and in verse 8, does not lend at interest or take any profit,
SPEAKER_00withholds his hand from injustice, executes true justice between man and man, walks in my statutes and keeps my rules by acting faithfully. He is righteous and he shall surely live. But in verse 10, if he fathers a son who is a violent shedder of blood, all the exact same list, including in verse 13, lends it interest. He has done all these abominations and he shall surely die. His blood shall be upon himself. In verse 14, it says, suppose this man fathers a son who sees all the sins that his
father has done and
SPEAKER_00does not do likewise, but instead lives righteously or in a sense breaks that generational curse, which includes usury as it was called or lending it interest or taking advantage of his brother's misfortune, that the sins of his father will not come upon the sins of his son and that he shall surely live instead. really really strong language there from the prophet we would see the sort of sin of lending at interest as something that is minor in just the
way that the world works but to god and to ezekiel this was just as serious as adultery as oppressing
SPEAKER_00people not taking care of the poor being violent or stealing, which is what the prophets accuse Israel of again and again and again throughout the Old Testament. So the way that we choose to position ourselves in never wanting to take advantage of a brother's misfortune, never wanting to put someone in a place where their misfortune is going to be increased by their dealings with us out of desperation is something that is very near and close to the heart of God. and probably why there was such a thing as the sabbatical year
and the year of
SPEAKER_00Jubilee also put in place by God. We'd love to talk about that for a few minutes if we have some time today, too. I just find it fascinating.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. I mean, I'm so glad you brought that up because that's at the heart of the law of Moses. It's at the heart of Jesus. That's why Jesus did what he did to bring good news to the poor, to rescue those who are indebted and imprisoned, not just in a figurative way, but in a literal way. Like Jesus liberates us from By freeing not only the person who is enslaved, but also the enslaver. By changing our heart of greed and covetousness,
he shows us a better way so that we do what the law required and we liberate each
SPEAKER_01other and we say, I'm going to stop holding you in bondage. I mean, I watched several different versions of the Christmas Carol this year. I had seen a couple of them, but I was like, you know what, I'm going to compare them. So I watched the Jim Carrey version, and I watched the Muppet version, and I watched all of these different versions of A Christmas Carol.
SPEAKER_00The Muppet version has to be the best, by the way. Which one? The Muppet version.
SPEAKER_01Oh, yeah, it's fantastic. And it's amazing how accurate to the actual text it was. But it's so interesting because in that situation, I could absolutely say, to answer the question, is debt a sin? Well, Ebenezer Scrooge was absolutely sinning in the way he loaned and exacted interest from people. That is a sin. It's a sin to unjustly and cruelly—
take advantage of the poor by loaning them money just to rip the rug out from underneath them.
SPEAKER_01Like that is cruelty and it is sinful and wicked. And like you said, this is something God condemned over and over and over again. And what Jesus wants to do is not only like liberate us from sin. So yes, absolutely. As a metaphor, figuratively speaking, Jesus liberates us from that debt of sin. But also he changes the hearts of greedy, covetous people so that we say, I'm going to stop taking advantage of my neighbor and I'm going to let you go.
SPEAKER_01I'm going to liberate you. I'm going to free you. I'm going to forgive what you owe to me because that's what God did for me. That's what was behind the year of Jubilee was God liberated me. So now I'm going to liberate everyone who is in my debt. I'm going to do for them what God did for me. And there's not a law like the United States of America doesn't have a law that says every seven years or every 49 years. Here's what you have to do. You have to let everybody go.
SPEAKER_01But God has that law because God did that for us. We do that for each other. And we say, I want to forgive the people that owe me. I don't want to hold this over their head. I don't want to be their slave master. I want to do for them what God did for me.
SPEAKER_00Oh, man. Yeah, that's so good. For anybody who just heard, like, seven years or 49 years and year of Jubilee, there in Leviticus 25, there are two other edicts given by God in relation to lending and borrowing. Basically, every seven years, there were supposed to be sabbatical year, where they actually didn't harvest, but they were able to take from the crops just to eat and sustain themselves. Loans were all forgiven.
And any indentured servants who had been put into bondage because they could not
SPEAKER_00pay back debts, which is really how it worked in that ancient system, would be set free. Every seven years, it goes back. And there actually is language there that says, don't refuse to lend to your brother because you know next year is a sabbatical year and you're not going to get very much out of it, right? So even in the institution of those laws, God is attacking the heart and he's putting those fail-safes in place just the way that we will twist and turn and use things to our own benefit. The Jubilee year was...
SPEAKER_00a much larger scale every 49 years, every 50th year. And they would not only let the indentured servants go, but they were also commanded to let their land rest again. But they also were supposed to revert land that had been sold back to the original owner, which is wild. Now, here's the thing. I'm not aware that they ever actually did this. It was even a bridge too far for the people of God.
SPEAKER_00If they did or had done it, we probably wouldn't have to hear Ezekiel and other prophets rail against the situations that would become later in Israel. But I really just see God instituting a system of community that was designed to abolish generational poverty and the generational concentration of wealth through exacting debts and oppressing others. Debts that could never be repaid. So... that's...
SPEAKER_00To me, the Christian community, the church, spiritual Israel, is supposed to be living that out live and direct for the world to see a different way of doing life, a different way of embodying relationships together, a different way of doing business together and lending and forgiving and showing grace. Making it part of the law that every seven years or every 50th year, you literally have to give everything back, de-incentivizes our human predisposition to just collect and
amass and hoard and Ebenezer Scrooge ourself into things that we come to believe are ours because we
SPEAKER_00earned them. If you have to do a sabbatical year, That would start with a proclamation and a scripture reading, in a sense, reminding us that everything we have is from God anyway. And I have no right to punish and oppress my brother for something that God gave me. Super helpful for me to think about as a reminder and a conviction for a person or for a family or for our communities, even for a nation,
SPEAKER_00really, that we don't want to be ruled or enslaved by systems of debt that seem to be running everything else around us. So...
SPEAKER_01You know, somebody told me here recently that when our Hindu neighbors, our Indian neighbors, come move here, immigrate from India to here, that they have a tendency to be a very close-knit community within their Hindu neighborhood. When someone is just getting started, they will not take out like home loans to get started. They will not take out business loans. They will go to their community and their community of fellow
Indian immigrants
SPEAKER_01within the Hindu, within the temple community. will loan money to one another, and I assume interest-free, take care of one another. This was all in the context of if we're going to reach people with the gospel, if we're going to reach our Hindu neighbors who move here from India, if we're going to reach them, we better reach them quickly because they move here and after a while they feel a sense of indebtedness to the Hindu community because the Hindu community was the one
who loaned them
SPEAKER_01money and got them started. And they don't borrow money from the bank that's going to charge them all this interest. They borrow money from their neighbors. They borrow money from their Indian Hindu neighbors who take care of them, get them started, get the ball rolling, and then they can do for others what was done for them. Man, I listened to that and I thought, wow, why are Christians not doing that? Like, why are we not the ones to take care of one another's needs? And I think the reason is because we like the idea of being
individualistic. I don't want to have to go to Marcus and say, Marcus, I'm really in a bad way right now.
SPEAKER_01I've got all of these medical bills. Can you help me with some of this? Or go to the church community and say, hey, brothers and sisters, can you help me cover this? I'm going to help you cover it when you have this. So we don't want to go to them. It's much easier to say, I'm going to make it on my own. I'm going to pull myself up by my own bootstraps. And instead of being emotionally indebted to our church community, now I am financially indebted to my insurance company who is taking care of me. But I feel like I did it on my own because I'm not looking
anybody in the eye.
SPEAKER_01It's just this company, this company out there, this organization out there that's taking care of me. And we've done that with almost everything in our life. And so we borrow from a bank rather than taking care of each other's needs. And when we look at some of our immigrant neighbors, this is true of our Hindu Indian neighbors, but I'm sure it's true of our immigrant neighbors from other places, that they are not going into debt from the local bank. They are... Not going into debt necessarily, but they are taking care of one another and their sense of
indebtedness is to their
SPEAKER_01community rather than a financial obligation to an institution. We have financially obligated ourselves to institutions and thereby have enslaved ourselves to them rather than caring for each other in the community.
SPEAKER_00That is so deep. I mean, we would rather be fiscally in debt than socially indebted. That is the one right there, Wes. And that's convicting to me. I wonder how much of this comes from the fact that they have a different perspective. They did not grow up like many of us have grown up. If you grew up in this country, I know from the time that I grew up, I was told the way to be successful, the way to live a good life,
SPEAKER_00even the way to live an honorable life, was to build credit and at all costs exist in this ecosystem. So if they're coming from somewhere else where they have not been told from the time that they were able to even conceptualize money, you got to build your credit. the only way for you to be successful is for you to go into hundreds of thousands of dollars worth of student loan debt, and it's just a fact of life, right? If you haven't been told that, perhaps you have a little bit of a different perspective from which you can consider maybe some additional options.
SPEAKER_00I'm afraid that when people hear you share that story, they're going to think that, oh, this is a political statement that he's making. No, no, no, no. Far from that. Not in any way. And the second fear that people probably have is, well, if I lend without interest, I mean, wouldn't people take advantage of me? Wouldn't they just not pay it back if they knew it wasn't actually gonna cost them anything? Probably some people, but you know, just a little bit further on in Proverbs from the verse that we're studying today in Proverbs 31,
SPEAKER_00it says, the wicked borrows, but does not pay back, but the righteous is generous and gives. The implication is that if we are all accountable to each other to be doing life this way together, not only will it not be embarrassing for me to borrow from someone at zero interest. But what I will want to do is to pay it back above and beyond in return. And then to pay it forward to the next person who needs it. There's probably a little bit of that insidious pride word that
we run into and
SPEAKER_00bump into a lot in our American context that's at play here. I wonder if it might be helpful. I wrestled with... It seems like he comes up a lot in our conversation. C.S. Lewis has been popping up frequently the last couple weeks. But he wrestled with this too in Mere Christianity. I want to just share kind of a quote from that that talks about sort of our American system and the assumptions that we make. Not even American, but the Western system. He was... from the UK. He says, uh, in mere Christianity.
Now, another point, there's one bit of advice given to us by the ancient heathen Greeks. I always find it funny that that's what he refers to the Greek says and the Jews in
SPEAKER_00the old Testament. And by the great Christian teachers of the middle ages, which the modern economic system has completely disobeyed. All these people told us not to lend money at interest and lending money at interest. What we call investment is the basis of our whole system. Now it may not be apps may not absolutely follow that we are wrong, Some people say that when Moses or Aristotle and those Christian teachers agreed in forbidding interest, or usury as it's called, they could not have foreseen joint stock companies, and they were only thinking of the private money lender, and that, therefore,
SPEAKER_00we need not to bother about what they said. That's a question I cannot decide on. I'm not an economist, and I simply do not know whether the investment system is responsible for the state we are in or not. This is where we want the Christian economist. But I should not have been honest if I had not told you that three great civilizations had agreed in condemning the very thing on which we have based our entire life. Now, I wrestle with that because it puts into words a lot of the considerations that pop into my mind when I start thinking about my personal responsibilities and
SPEAKER_00relationship with debt. as compared to the macroeconomic system, which is all based on debt and leveraged income. It would also be irresponsible not to be honest and say that the types of markets that rule our economies today are responsible for helping a vast percentage of people out of poverty. So it's not a condemnation of the system itself. But I think we would do really well to very seriously consider how we're supposed to be navigating and operating within that system,
SPEAKER_00especially with how we treat other people, our neighbors, our brothers. I think it was you who said the goal was for us to be treating everyone as if they're family in relation to these things. But unfortunately, sometimes families have the most strict... when it comes to money and borrowing. We might all need a sabbatical year from time to time, I think. Romans 13,
SPEAKER_001 to 10, really, that whole passage comes up a lot in this conversation. Romans 13, where we find, And I don't want to bring that up to muddy the waters, but just to say, I think that actually is a really good verse that marries very well with what you just suggested a few minutes ago. That to owe no one, nothing, except the love that we're showing and how we deal with each
other is actually how
SPEAKER_00we fulfill the law by following Jesus. Cause that's exactly what he did for us.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Yeah. And that's really what it comes down to. I do think it's possible to loan someone money, even in our economy, in our system, even if there is interest attached. I think it's possible for a bank or an institution or an individual... to loan someone money in a merciful way, in a loving way. I think it's possible that this loan is being extended in a fair,
SPEAKER_01reasonable, merciful way that's actually going to be beneficial and helpful to that person. And I think it's possible to borrow money in a way that's wise. I think it's possible for individuals and companies and even churches to borrow money in in wise ways that helps them to navigate the system and everything that we need to operate in this particular place and time. I don't think every act of borrowing and every act of lending is predatory. I don't think it's all unjust and criminal as we've been describing it.
SPEAKER_01But sometimes it is. And we need to have the wisdom and the discernment to know the difference. There are a lot of people in the world, speaking of our immigrant neighbors, who are coming here because around the world to this day, there are people who are literally slaves and And a lot of the slavery that exists today is indentured servitude, like they owe a debt. And the way the system is built is that they will never,
ever pay off that debt. We had that same kind of sharecropping system that when slavery was made illegal in
SPEAKER_01this country, sharecroppers essentially enslaved their workers so that it technically wasn't slavery, but it was. They could never pay off the debt that they owed. Every year, the seed that they planted, the groceries that they bought from the store that belonged to the landowner, All of it just put them further and further into debt and they never were able to work their way out of it. That same sort of system exists around the world today. And I think we ought to be careful and thoughtful in what are we buying?
SPEAKER_01How are we supporting systems like that, not just here, but around the world, especially around the world? Are we supporting sweatshops? Are we supporting systems that are enslaving people where the rich are ruling over the poor and where the debtor is enslaved to the lender? Are we part of that? And is it possible for us to... separate ourselves, come out of Babylon and be separate from her in those kinds of instances. So yeah, this is a very nuanced conversation and we have to be very wise
in the way that
SPEAKER_01we're navigating it. It's not always a sin to have a credit card or to borrow money, but some of the ways that we have arranged our economies are unjust and sinful. I think that's such an important distinction that you're making right there.
SPEAKER_00I mean, I would want anyone who listens to this conversation to come away knowing that there is a distinction between what I would just call consumer debt and the financial instruments that in some cases are unavoidable if you're going to live in our current society. Common debate right now is buying a house we're renting what's actually advantageous what's actually wise and that might be different based on case to case and there are a lot of folks who have experienced and would be proponents of hey owning a home is the
way that you actually can start to have an asset that is actual wealth for you it's the greatest
SPEAKER_00predictor of being able to leave something for the next generation so I would never say that you're going to be sinning if you're gonna go get a mortgage. That's just a feature of the system right now. But we can definitively say that being unwise, being undisciplined, practicing bad stewardship with money, and other assets even, can be sinful. that brings others in your care into financial binds as well, certainly something like going into debt for gambling or just
keeping up with the
SPEAKER_00Joneses, as they used to say. Anything out of a covetous desire that doesn't come from contentment, I think would all fall under that banner, so to speak. Another consideration that I would just maybe think about, and this is something that I wrestle with too, just the constant status of being in debt. Um, I think it's important for us to consider how that constant state, if it's not managed well or with wisdom,
is something that can and does strangle the fruit of the spirit out of our lives. A person that is crippled with debt is not likely to have peace in their life. They are more likely to act rashly or aggressively since you're probably just gonna
SPEAKER_00be in a perpetual state of fight or flight. Kindness becomes difficult because kindness does not proceed from desperation. Desperation has all of our focus turned inward. So just being in debt perpetually is not the place where God wants His people to exist. It certainly would snuff out generosity. And that's one of the hallmarks of the presence of the Spirit in someone's life. So what I think is I would advocate for prayerful consideration to be made
in how we each individually are going to participate in this economic system,
SPEAKER_00prayerfully, because it will take us being humble enough to bring it back to God again and again and again. What you just said a few minutes ago probably creates some cognitive dissonance for folks. Are there certain jobs that a Christian should take pause before thinking about becoming involved in because they are predicated on sort of predatory economic instruments? Absolutely. And I would say the same thing to someone who's in music or someone who's an aspiring actor.
SPEAKER_00There are going to be roles. that you are going to have to pass on if you're gonna maintain your integrity, if you're gonna maintain your character. I don't think that's really any different. It's not really my place to tell you, certainly, which job you can and cannot take, but I would just say, think deeply and intently about the way God treats situations and prayerfully consider, can I reflect Jesus in this role or this state? if taking on this debt is going to inhibit my ability to be a witness,
SPEAKER_00then I should think twice about whether this is a wise decision to make. I hope that makes sense, if that's coming across pretty clearly.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, that's so well said, Marcus. It really comes back to being cruciform in the way that we live our lives, that yes, yes, there are inherent risks in being a disciple of Jesus. Like you said, if you listen to this you think well man if i follow that somebody might take advantage of me if i loan money without expecting you know to get extra back or maybe even not expecting to get what i loaned as jesus said it
lends without the expectation that it's ever going to be returned to you like that's a huge risk yeah
SPEAKER_01There are inherent risks with discipleship. Like, yes, you are risking. There may be some things you miss out on. There may be some times where you're taken advantage of. There may be times where you don't get to have the fun that you wanted to have or the fun that other people are having. That's what it is to follow Jesus sometimes, that there are sacrifices. But what we're saying is that with any aspect of discipleship, it's worth it. It's worth it to be wise. It's worth it to be kind, to create, as you were saying,
SPEAKER_01margin in our lives, where we have the margin, where we have the breathing room to be generous, that I'm not spending everything that I get and even spending more than I actually have and going deeper and deeper into debt because I don't want to miss out on anything else. I'm creating margins so that I have the breathing room to be generous when the opportunity arises. Yeah, there are going to be times where you have to sacrifice some things, where you have to give up some things, where you have to risk some things. But that's what it looks like sometimes to live a cruciform life,
SPEAKER_01to be a follower of Jesus, taking up our cross and following him. That word sacrifice really looms large in this conversation for me because I
SPEAKER_00When I look at everything that we've talked about today, when I look at what God was trying to set up in Leviticus with the people of Israel, when I look at what we're called to, even what Proverbs is advocating, God's trying to create a sacrificial generosity and charity. Yeah. And I think the larger point is that once you're making something from it, it's not charity anymore. It's an investment. And so that turns a good deed into nothing more than good business. And that means when the business isn't good anymore,
neither will the relationship be.
SPEAKER_00And that's what God cares about the most. So I think that's why Jesus says in Luke chapter six, don't lend expecting to get anything back. As a matter of fact, if you do that, you're doing it for the wrong reason. Um, so lend being completely comfortable that you're not receiving anything in return. And it's hard to feel taken advantage of when you operate this way within God's family. when we're on the receiving endeavor, payback fully, payback promptly.
SPEAKER_00And as Proverbs and Jesus is kind of leading us to, um, we're not supposed to be the people that are out to make a dollar off of anybody at every opportunity. And when nobody is trying to make a dollar off anybody, when nobody's trying to take advantage of each other, then it's truly to all of our advantage, I think. And that's the kind of radical generosity that is the hallmark of a community that Jesus has called us to be and that God has always had planned from the very beginning.
SPEAKER_01Amen. Amen. Thank you, brother. I think that this conversation, I know it's been helpful to me and I think it's going to be helpful to others. I really appreciate you engaging in it.
SPEAKER_00Absolutely, man. It's a good one. Thank you.
SPEAKER_01Appreciate you. I hope you enjoyed that episode of the Radically Christian Podcast. If you did, please take a second to like, share, subscribe, rate, or review the podcast. You can find the show on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, Substack, YouTube, or wherever you listen to podcasts. Thank you so much for listening. Thank you to my co-host, Marcus, and thank you to my McDermott Road Church family who helps make this podcast possible. Okay, now let's all go out and love like Jesus.
The Spirit is often the member of the Godhead we talk about least, and when we do, He can feel more like a doctrine to manage than a Person to know. In this conversation from the 412 Christian Podcast, Wes joins hosts...
What if the vocabulary you inherited for salvation has left you more anxious than assured? Justification, sanctification, saved: many believers learned these words as tidy categories, and many sincere Christians still...
What does it actually mean to be baptized in the Holy Spirit? For many who grew up in the Restoration Movement, the phrase meant a debate about water baptism or a defensive argument about miraculous gifts, and then the...
If we’re saved by grace through faith, why does baptism still matter? An elder in Tennessee wrote in with a question many Christians are asking. If love is the heart of everything, is baptism just a ritual tacked on, a...
Is gluttony only about what is on your plate? Most of us assume we know the answer, and most of us feel a little uncomfortable when the subject comes up. The Bible mentions gluttony far less than many Christians expect,...