Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Radically Christian

Radically Christian artwork

Digital Disciples: Is Online Church Working?

Sep 2, 202656 minAudio

How much of your spiritual life happens on a screen? Wes and Marcus turn the podcast on itself this week, asking hard questions about online worship, podcasts, and social media (the very tools they’re using to talk to you right now). Is live-streaming church a gift for the homebound and a front door for the curious, or a subtle invitation to become a spiritual consumer instead of a disciple? They dig into what happens when anyone can be a teacher with no elders holding them accountable, why comfort and discipleship rarely coexist, and what gets lost when friction and pushback disappear from our spiritual conversations. This isn’t a rulebook for what to do or not do online; it’s an honest look at what these platforms are forming us into, and whether that’s actually making us more like Jesus. Links and Resources * The Democratization of American Christianity by Nathan O. Hatch - Referenced as background on why the restoration movement’s anyone-can-preach spirit took hold in American evangelicalism. * The Gospel in a Pluralistic Society by Lesslie Newbigin - Cited for Newbigin’s insight on adapting the gospel’s presentation to different audiences and contexts. * Foolishness to the Greeks: The Gospel and Western Culture by Lesslie Newbigin - Cited alongside the above for Newbigin’s work on Paul’s strategy of contextualizing the gospel. * Extended Free Trial of Logos Bible Study Software * Books by Wes McAdams * VidAngel Special Offer This description contains affiliate links. If you purchase through these links, we may earn a small commission at no additional cost to you. We only recommend resources we genuinely believe in. This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit www.radicallychristian.com

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_00Welcome to the Radically Christian podcast. Here we have one goal, learn to love like Jesus. I'm Wes McAdams and I am here with Marcus Stinson. Marcus, good to see you, brother.

SPEAKER_01It is a good day, brother. Good to see you. We've got a fun conversation today. I'm excited to see where it goes. I feel that I will be convicted at some point, just like last time, but that'll be a good thing.

SPEAKER_00That's really the goal of this podcast, isn't it? Is that we don't come at this as the experts, but mere fellow students, not only of one another, but also of listeners, and we're all on this journey together. But this one is kind of meta, isn't it? Online church, online Bible study, online networking platforms, I guess is the word I'm looking for. So what do we do with all of that?

SPEAKER_00I think just as you said, I think it will be convicting for us. And so we're not coming at this as scolding anybody to say, hey, here's what you should and shouldn't do, but rather what lessons should we all learn as we navigate this new world?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, I just hope that this will be a conversation that will be received from a tone and disposition that I'm just thinking that this is something that we maybe haven't thought deeply enough about, often enough about, and because it... involves the technological mediums that are always improving, always increasing, and proliferating deeper and deeper through all segments of our society. Like, we just kind of adopt them and move into these spaces, and we see what happens, and we start to feel behind other people that are doing different things,

SPEAKER_01and we have to play catch-up to that. And I think a lot of our engagement online comes from a good place or a good intention, but sometimes it's really good to slow down and think about what we're doing and why. And how we carry ourselves in these spaces and what it really means in terms of a faith that is far more ancient than our now digitally connected world. So this will be good, man. I probably have a lot to say here. We'll try to keep it under time.

SPEAKER_00I love it. I love it. We may have to split this into two. I don't know.

SPEAKER_01Maybe.

SPEAKER_00But let's first, let's talk about the positives. There certainly are, I think, a lot of positives. Let's talk about, I want to talk about both online worship, like the worship service, live streaming, I want to start with the positives and talk about why

SPEAKER_00And what is good in what we have and the tools that are available and how we're using them. So let's talk about worship first. I'm curious, I don't even know the answer to this question. Do y'all at Falls Church, do you live stream? Are you live streaming your worship?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, yeah, we do. We live stream in a couple of places. The stream is always going to be on Facebook and it's going to be on YouTube and then it gets stored presently on the website through those links afterward. But ironically enough, we are in the process of upgrading and overhauling that whole situation. I mean, there's a real argument to be made, I think, from a couple of different directions for the benefit of online worship and online content that the church puts out into what I call the digital agora. And so, I mean,

SPEAKER_01the most apparent application is this is a great sort of temporary placeholder for someone who's unable to be at worship. It certainly is a blessing for folks who may be shut in or physically unable to attend. Beautiful for folks who have physical ailments that, you know, preclude them from being able to be there in person or sometimes when you're traveling. And you're stuck in an airport and there's nothing you can do because Delta's not playing nice that day. It's great to still be able to tap in. And so there's something positive for that.

SPEAKER_01But all of that, I think, springs out of a Real embodied connection that's preexistent. So I think it's great for someone who has that, to have that capability and that possibility. I also think the church actually has a responsibility to be on digital mediums. And I call it the digital agora because it is the place that is most like where the Apostle Paul did a lot of his ministry.

SPEAKER_00For those that aren't Greek people, why don't you explain what the Agora is or was?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, yeah. So you would probably, the most famous account involving the Greco-Roman Agora happens when Paul is in Athens and he spends time in the marketplace. That's what the Agora was. But the marketplace was the central hub for life. And so every day people went to the market to get provisions and food for the day. It's also where the town criers were and they were Telling the news of the day. They were heralding. It's also usually connected to the amphitheater. So entertainment happened right there near the Agora.

SPEAKER_01It's also where all the businesses were. So business was being conducted. News was being heard and told. People were connecting as friends and family and business constituents. And it was really the center of Greco-Roman life. This is where Paul went to spend time to see what people were concerned about, to find the holes in their worldview, to really get to learn them and know them. And to share the gospel, it's his time in that space that preceded his invitation to the Areopagus to share with the great thinkers of the day. And in my view,

SPEAKER_01there is one place that exists in our modern world where people are going for entertainment, they're going for news, they're going to catch up with friends and family and doing it all at the same time. And that's online. And so, there is a really good argument to be made that for the church, at large, not to be involved in that marketplace, so to speak, is really negligent, and it really betrays our mission to reach the world. Now, it can't be the be-all, end-all. And how we actually embody that space and inhabit that space well

SPEAKER_01and steward our platforms in this space is something that I don't think we've talked about enough. And so, A lot of us have just been winging it and trying to find our way for better or worse. And so I'm actually excited to kind of dig a little bit deep here today.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, no, that's really good. And that's exactly how I always framed it. Before I recognized the negatives, I think that this is where I started. And that is recognizing the positive, recognizing the potential, recognizing all of the benefits that might come from being in this There's a digital marketplace where we can join in the conversation. There is a conversation happening. And to your point, it would be negligent of the church to not be part of that conversation, not be part of this social fabric and saying, hey, here's what's important. Here's what's happening here.

SPEAKER_00Here's the story by which we're living our lives. If we believe that the gospel, the good news about Jesus and his kingship and his reign is the good news by which everyone ought to live their lives, then we have to be where the conversation is happening. And you're right, it's happening on social media. It's happening on Facebook. It's happening, I will say, I abandoned X a long time ago, back when it was Twitter. But these are the places where it's happening. It's happening on YouTube. And if we want to be part of the conversation,

SPEAKER_00And really, it's not really whether or not we want to be part of the conversation. We have an obligation as the church. That doesn't mean every individual. And I think we need to come back to this idea. Not every individual should be a teacher. Not every individual should be the storyteller online, so to speak. But as a whole, collectively, the church ought to be involved in the conversation and be where the conversation is happening. I think there is a distinction between... The worship service and the other conversations that are happening,

SPEAKER_00like this platform, like podcasts or like blogs or something like that, there is a difference between those two things. And I think an argument could be made for... The worship assembly is for the Christians. It is for Christians to come together, to encourage each other, to edify one another, to praise God, to break bread together, to share the cup together. And to your point, it is helpful that when you can't gather So I think one of the greatest benefits of having an online streaming service is as

SPEAKER_00a supplement. We stream our services, we have two services, an early and a later service, and any given Sunday, We might have a couple hundred people that are legitimately gone. They're not just choosing to be online, but they're either homebound, and they're always homebound, or they're, as you said, traveling, they've got a sick kid. For any number of legitimate reasons, they're not just choosing. Choosing not to assemble, but they can't be there. And so as a supplement, it is a wonderful thing, but it assumes that you would be here in person, embodied, if you could.

SPEAKER_00But because you can't, here's this that we recognize is a lesser alternative. Even when we were, to bring up a difficult time in all of our lives, when we were in the midst of COVID, It was a time where we couldn't get together in person for all kinds of reasons, agree, disagree, whatever, but we couldn't be together in person, and it was a great supplement. We all recognized, and we said from day one, this is not as good as being together. Right. Right. Right.

SPEAKER_00We're settling for good enough. And it is. On some times, on some occasions, it is good enough. And I'm thankful for it because when I was a kid, if there was an ice storm or if somebody was sick for three weeks or somebody was shut in for years, homebound, unable to come to the church building, they were kind of cut off from everyone. And now we have this wonderful way for people to stay plugged in. And it's not the greatest thing in the world, but it is better than nothing. And I think that ought to be said.

SPEAKER_01I think the word that you used is the best possible terminology we could assign to it, and that's a supplement. And I really risk going into another pathway here with my nerdish interest in the health and wellness space. It's the same way with your physical health. They are called supplements. Supplements for a reason. You should never take a supplement as a replacement for what you should be eating. You cannot do that. Supplements are best used to fill in the gaps, right?

SPEAKER_01They are to replace micronutrition for what your macros are not able to provide you in the course of eating daily. And so if my physical health is built out of bricks, the food that I eat, then the mortar between the bricks would be really good supplementation. And so my spiritual life, in much the same way, are built on spiritual disciplines, one of which is gathering with the assembly for a number of reasons. Then an online supplement when that isn't being actualized, when I'm not able to be there,

SPEAKER_01is a great way to sort of put some mortar between the bricks and hold the whole thing together. But I can't build my wall out of that. That's an inadequate foundation, I think. So I love that you use that terminology. It's a really good metaphor.

SPEAKER_00Well, and that's really helpful to think about it that way, about filling in the gaps. And one of the ways that I hear from people all the time that they... I don't like to say watch our online service. They're participating in our online service. One of the ways that people do that is on Sunday morning, again, our first service streams at eight o'clock central, not to get people to tune in necessarily, but it streams at eight o'clock. And a lot of people don't go to their assembly or to their Bible class until 9 or 9.30. And so they tune in and participate with us online first.

SPEAKER_00And it kind of helps them to get into the right headspace for them to be in a spiritual mindset. That before they gather with their local body, they worship with us first. And I love that. I think that's a fantastic way to use online service. It's not the primary reason we stream our services, but for them, it's great. Another thing is for those that are exploring For those that are exploring churches in their area, I mean, we live in an age where we do everything online.

SPEAKER_00I probably would have a hard time visiting a restaurant unless I saw pictures online. In fact, I'll tell this silly little story. I had dinner the other night at Grandma's Guatemalan restaurant, and it is in Sulphur Springs. So if you're ever passing through Sulphur Springs on the interstate, stop at Grandma's Guatemalan restaurant. Now, you might have the same reaction I'm sure a lot of people did. In fact, the locals that live there in Sulphur Springs had never heard of it before. And that's because it's in the back of a Shamrock gas station.

SPEAKER_00Now, I went to Grandma's because it had great reviews on Google and people had posted pictures of the restaurant. So I knew what to expect. I knew what the food was going to look like. I knew what the seating was going to look like. I knew when I pushed open that sketchy door in the back of the gas station that I probably was not going to be murdered and that it was going to be an enjoyable experience. And sure enough, The internet did not lie or disappoint. It was wonderful. It was fantastic. But I probably would have never pushed that door open unless I knew what was on the other side.

SPEAKER_00And that's what we're doing when we put our services online is we're saying, hey, We know you've never been here, but we would like for you to come. Here's everything that you're going to experience when you come. And what a tremendous opportunity that is. I have no idea how many times people have come to visit McDermott Road and have said to me, I've been watching online for the last few weeks, and I've decided to come and be here in person. And a lot of times they become members here or they become Christians here. Again, I'm not saying every church has to do this,

SPEAKER_00but man, I think we're missing a huge opportunity if we don't let people know this is what you're going to experience when you come and visit, and we would like for you to come and visit.

SPEAKER_01Oh man, totally agree. What is it about Texas that some of the best places to eat are attached to random gas stations? Like, that does not surprise me at all. I'll have to remember grandma's attached to a Shamrock gas station. One of my favorite places for Beria tacos is attached to a Shell gas station in Cedar Park in North Austin. So, uh, and my wife Maggie is a compulsive menu checker ahead of time. She loves to plan, plan, plan. So we're probably not going to a restaurant unless I surprise her,

SPEAKER_01unless she's already bedded it ahead of time. And you make such a good point that that's just the cultural moment that we're in now in terms of folks that are curious about spiritual things, curious about God, curious about church, curious about Jesus. They're going to be online trying to see what's there first. And so I like to say we kind of have a responsibility for them to be able to see themselves here before they find themselves here. And making sure that we're visible in the space where everyone is is just common sense to me. The church's online presentation,

SPEAKER_01whether they've got social media pumping or they're doing live streams for their services, it serves the same purpose. That's the purpose that a really catchy church sign did in the 80s. As people are driving through town, oh, there's a church there, there's a witty church sign. Or even older than that, what the church steeple used to be. Back in the day, you're driving through town or riding on horseback through town, You see this tall steeple and know, oh, there's a church there. And so us being in this digital space, that agora, so to speak, is really just doing that.

SPEAKER_01There's nothing new about it. It's just sort of a new medium. I want to riff off that just a little bit because I think the seeker or the curious is one of our responsibilities that The church is visible and that they're able to find us and that there is content that is God honoring and true to the scripture that is available as far as our capability extends. If they bump into us, they're going to get great biblically based teaching, right?

SPEAKER_01They're going to at least be exposed to that in our locus of influence. But the second thing is we're not alone out there. And if recent statistics are in any way accurate, that most people are spending upwards of eight hours a day on their phones or devices now, it really doesn't matter, Wes, how great my sermon is on Sunday. I'm not deceived, I'm not naive to believe that I could deliver a masterstroke sermon In 35 minutes,

SPEAKER_01I am not going to overcome the torrent of content that my family members here at our church are going to be consuming throughout the week. I got 35 minutes to give them something that'll challenge them and encourage them and encourage them to take a step towards Jesus, but they're going to be listening to hours and hours and hours and hours of content from who knows what other sources. And so I think the church, our The first and predominant responsibility in online platforms is providing content that can stem that a little bit, that can bridge that gap between the Sundays,

SPEAKER_01so that we can know that not just on Sunday morning are they going to get something valuable for spiritual formation that's related to the vision and mission that we're working towards together as a located, embodied people together. But that there is content there for them that they can continue to tap into and be dripped throughout the week so that it's not just a one shot into the abyss, you know? And so there's tons of good stuff out there. I would love it, like, if you guys who are here at Falls Church or anywhere that I've ever been,

SPEAKER_01if you want to warm up before I get going with Wes McAdams, that's a pretty good warm up, right? As a matter of fact, wait, listen to him after, because I don't want to follow Wes on a Sunday morning. Don't warm up with Wes. That's terrible advice. I should have never said that.

SPEAKER_00Well, and to that point, I mean, I get so much encouragement from teaching that I get online. Like, I need that teaching. I don't get the opportunity when I'm here. I'm the one preaching. I need to listen to somebody else preach. I need that encouragement. And what a blessing it is that we live in an age where you can be discipled, not just on Sundays and Wednesdays, you can be discipled all throughout the week, that it is everywhere. If you want a podcast, you can find a podcast. You can find multiple podcasts.

SPEAKER_00You can find all kinds of things. There's more content than you could possibly consume and it can help you be transformed. And as church leaders, as preachers and teachers and elders and Our goal is, to your point, is discipling people, is helping people become more like Jesus. We have to recognize that the world is certainly discipling people throughout the week. They don't just do one time a week and say, well, we did our job, check that off the list. They are discipling people as much and in many ways as they possibly can.

SPEAKER_00Why would we be any different? Why would we say, yeah, we're just gonna do the whole one hour a week thing, maybe two hours a week, maybe three hours a week, Sunday morning, Sunday night, Wednesday night, No, we need to be out there as the church discipling our people, much less the people that are seeking. We need to be discipling people as much, as often, and also in as many ways as we possibly can. For some people, that's the written word. For some people, it's animated videos on YouTube. For some people, it's a long-form podcast. Sadly, with the young people,

SPEAKER_00it's the vertical 60-second videos, and I'm like, How much, you know, formation is happening in that. But that's a whole other thing. We need to be where people are. Deformation, maybe, is happening there? Yeah, TikTok

SPEAKER_01is responsible. TikTok may be responsible for more deformation than formation.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, we need to talk about the negative. The negative sides of all of that. But yeah, I mean, we need to be where people are and be teaching people how to follow Jesus wherever they are. And these platforms and these tools are a great way to do that. Not the only way to do it, maybe not even the best way to do it, but a way to do it. And we need to have a presence there, I think.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. I appreciate so much also the... It's sort of a double-edged sword, actually. I should be a little bit more measured with this statement. Because the access is so ubiquitous online, you can find just about any perspective on any topic at any time. And on the one hand, that can be a really valuable thing and a really beneficial thing. On the other hand,

SPEAKER_01it raises one of the biggest red flags and questions that I think we have to wrestle with. Because I love that you're using the term discipled. What's really happening is people are being discipled by a lot of unqualified voices. They're being discipled by a lot of voices that are leading them astray. They're being discipled in bite-sized like tidbits that are not contextual. And they're being discipled by people that they have no real relationship with and therefore no real oversight,

SPEAKER_01accountability, And that is a recipe for disaster, if that's the main locus or basis for spiritual formation. And it requires very little of us. And depending on where you're at and whose well you're drinking from, you could end up in a world of hurt. And so maybe that's something we should kick around a little bit, but I think there is a danger to that in our current environment right now.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, and I'm so glad we're getting into the negative side of this because there are some very serious negatives. I mean, when I just talk about the negatives, it makes me want to abandon all of this. All of the positives that we said are still true, but one of the problems That's not really the way discipleship happens. It happens through being challenged, by being taught, by our ideas that we already have.

SPEAKER_00Again, challenged may be the best word I can think of right now, but being rebuked and being told we're wrong and we need to change. But the problem with being a consumer is I look for things that fulfill my appetite. I look for things I'm already hungry for. I look for answers that I already believe. And what people want a lot of times, what they want, whether we want to say it or not, what they want from a podcast is they want the podcast host to have their own words coming out of somebody else's mouth. That's what we want. When I listen to a podcast, I want them to say what I already think is true.

SPEAKER_00And we have to start approaching these tools differently. We have to start approaching podcasts and online service and all of these things differently. And not just asking, is this what I want? And again, even in person, I'll have people come up to me sometimes and say, well, I disagreed with what you said this morning. Good. Like, fantastic.

SPEAKER_00Like, it's possible I was wrong, but it's also possible you're wrong and you need to consider whether or not what I said was true, not whether or not you agree with it. Is it true? And if we're just going out And when we're out there finding preachers and teachers that we agree with, there's a serious problem with that because it becomes an echo chamber where we just have someone affirming what we already think is true rather than challenging what we think is true but is actually false.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, man, the idea of the consumer-oriented church is one that's a little bit buzzwordy now, but I think it's only buzzwordy because so many of us have become aware that this is sort of what we default into because it's our cultural paradigm. It's what we do. We consume, especially when we're uncomfortable. We consume to assuage that feeling. And so one thing that I would say is It is, when you are online, you are consuming by default, because there's no real relational interaction that can happen there.

SPEAKER_01You are consuming, okay? But when you are in person, you may be consuming, but if your heart and your mind is in the right place, you will be communing, and that is different than consuming. Consuming is usually comfortable. It is usually convenient. It is prone to us worshiping a projection of ourselves and not the God of the universe. That's the exact kind of thing that you were just talking about. Hey, if the God that I worship never disagrees with me,

SPEAKER_01then I'm not really worshiping the God of the Bible. I'm worshiping a God made in my own image, right? And I can shop around until I find a place that is just going to give me that or tell me what I want to hear. But community, we love the idea of community. We love the idea of relationship until it requires accountability from us, until it asks something of us, until there's a cost to pay, and then we run the other way. Sometimes community is really uncomfortable, and sometimes it's really inconvenient.

SPEAKER_01But the thing about real community is, and real embodied worship, it is ultimately the only way to a fulfilling relationship with Jesus. You might be able to learn some things online. I learn tons of things online. I binge so many podcasts, it's not even funny. But the reality is, there is always a cap on your growth without community. There's always a cap on growth without community. And what I'm afraid is that we live in a moment where we are furiously, like,

SPEAKER_01We are obsessively trying to remove all of the tension points from our lives in every single avenue of life. We're obsessed with that sort of comfort, removing discomfort, for the sake of efficiency, for the sake of being able to get more done. And we lose a lot in the process. And we lose a lot, especially if we allow that to be our framework for worship and what it means to be a part of the church and a part of God's family. It's really reductionistic, honestly.

SPEAKER_01Like, the things that actually grow us are the things that challenge us and are sometimes uncomfortable and force us to adapt and reconsider and humble ourselves and expand our perspective and be checked. And it's not like you just go to church so that people will do that to you. I think part of what we miss is, like, I'm not just there for me. That's the consumer mindset. I'm there for my brothers and sisters too. Like there's somebody that I'm supposed to encourage this Sunday. There's somebody that I'm supposed to help keep accountable with kindness

SPEAKER_01and grace seasoned with salt this Sunday, right? And I can't, I can't do that to a digital medium. I just can't. And so we lose a lot when we, we settle for that reductionistic approach, I think.

SPEAKER_00Man, I love that. That is so rich, Marcus. That's worth the price of admission right here is that tension and that friction. That's where the growth happens. And what we are doing when we move things online is we are reducing, if not eliminating, the friction and the tension. And that's true now. It's not only for the person consuming, but also for the content creator. It's true for us. Like in a lot of ways, it's so much easier to do a podcast than it is to do a Bible class because I don't have to deal with all those people. You know, like it's so easy. It's so easy for us to be on here,

SPEAKER_00and if we're not careful, we just agree with each other, and I say, well, Marcus is the smartest guy I know, and you agree with me, and I agree with you, and then we just go home, as opposed to in real life, in a Bible class setting, when we say something, We throw something out and somebody says, hey, I don't think that's true. What about this passage over here? And it creates friction. It creates tension. We have to deal with people where they are and what they understand. And maybe I'm wrong. And maybe I just taught something that's wrong. So it's hard to teach in community because we're all in different places.

SPEAKER_00We have different understandings and we get to push back on each other and we get that instant feedback. When I'm preaching even, even if it's not a back and forth type of conversation, I can see people's faces and I can see what I've said. I've said something that I stepped over a line. Maybe I shouldn't have said that and I didn't even think about this person. I have to deal with the person afterwards who comes up to me and says, hey, that was really offensive what you said. I have to deal with the fact that they're right, and I shouldn't have said that. Online, it's so much easier. I mean, I don't have to look at the comments.

SPEAKER_00I don't have to listen to the emails, and they have to be the one to email in, and I'm not seeing their faces. They're not seeing mine. So, again, I think you're exactly right that for the sake of efficiency, we are eliminating We're eliminating the tension. We're eliminating the friction. We're eliminating the pushback and the back and forth. And that's exactly where growth happens. And it's true for both the person in the pulpit and in the pew. It's true for both the consumer and the content creator. We have to stop eliminating those things from our life.

SPEAKER_00You used the word earlier, accountability. And that's what I'm really afraid happens a lot when anybody can be a content creator, anybody can be a teacher, anybody can be a preacher, anybody can be a teacher. Anybody can start a podcast. Anybody could just go online and start preaching and not have the oversight, not have the accountability of an eldership and a congregation to hold them accountable for what they're saying. And I think that's happening a lot. Again, you said it earlier, it's nothing new to some degree. In fact, this is why the Restoration Movement grew so rapidly in America,

SPEAKER_00in the United States, because of, there's a book called The Democratization of American Christianity, and we kind of lean into this entrepreneurial spirit that goes along with our unique American evangelicalism, where anybody can become a preacher, and everybody can go and preach and teach and whatever. Well, there's some benefit to that. There's some positive to that. There's no gatekeeper, so to speak, as there is in the denominational world. But at the same time, is that really how God designed it that anybody can teach

SPEAKER_00and nobody really gets held accountable to those in authority to say, this is wrong and this shouldn't be taught and this is toxic, especially in our culture now where people Anything that is outrageous gets clicks. It gets views. And the more outrageous a person is, the more hateful a person is, the more angry a person is, the more outraged that he inspires people to be, the more How popular he becomes. And that's kind of the environment that we're dealing with.

SPEAKER_00And people need accountability. Both students and teachers need to be held accountable. And the local church is where that's supposed to happen. But oftentimes, when everybody is able to go and start their own platform, that accountability is lacking.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, it's a symptom of the sort of weird... It's interesting to me that we know that the scripture will tell us, let not many of you become teachers. Strict warnings about this situation. But because of the advent of the mass social media society, for some reason, we haven't thought about the fact that when you step online, when you do something like we're doing today,

SPEAKER_01you actually are stewarding an incredible gift and responsibility. You're stepping into the seat of a teacher. Now, you might think, I'm just creating some content, but if people are listening with the intent to learn, you are putting yourself in the position of a teacher. And that should come with it a certain sobering mentality and posture. And we get really passionate about what we say online, but for some reason, there's a weird dichotomy where we don't act as if it's real.

SPEAKER_01And like, we get really upset, we get really enthused, we get really engrossed, and it really affects our day, but then we sequester it off as if it's not the real world. And so we... Abide by different rules here. And how we carry ourselves here can be different. And anonymity is okay here. And I can say things that are misleading just because, well, I'm just getting people into the conversation here. And I can stand up and teach here. I'm qualified because this is just what people do.

SPEAKER_01And I haven't taken a second thought to ask the question, is this wise? Is this helpful? One thing that I hope that we become much more mindful of collectively is the dichotomy that we're talking about here, Wes, that it is such a tremendous gift that we have the ability to jump online and everybody has a voice and everybody has a platform,

SPEAKER_01but is also an incredible danger if you don't actually wrestle with and reckon with what that actually means. I don't mean to derail the conversation in another direction, but as far as our involvement as Christians online, it's not just my wall. It's not. It's not just my profile. It's not just mine to do with whatever I want to do with it. I am a projection of the church, not just because I'm in ministry, but because I'm a Christian.

SPEAKER_01I'm wearing the name of Christ in that place. So, I'm never justified to say something like, if you don't like what I'm posting here, just unfollow me. Am I really willing over my opinion to lose every future opportunity to share the gospel or have a meaningful conversation with somebody? I'm just not willing to do that. I do not feel comfortable standing before Jesus someday saying that. We have to come to a place. Where our online behavior is taken just as seriously as our in-person behavior.

SPEAKER_01I think that's what I'm really trying to say. Because it has a far wider reach in so many instances and cases. And can have such a greater impact in so many instances and cases. So our witness is threatened when we don't think about these topics and how we inhabit these places, I think.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. I mean, that was so much of what Paul wrote to churches and to Christians in the first century, was you have to make sure that your life is above reproach. And the whole point of that is you are bringing negative attention And that was true in the ancient world, living in small community.

SPEAKER_00Much less today living online and having everything there for posterity forever. And we have to be very careful what we say. We have to recognize that, again, like you said, not just because we are in full-time ministry, but every Christian is accountable to their eldership. Whether you're a minister or not, whether you're in person or online, you are accountable. And I pray that every Christian has wise shepherds who will come to them and say, this is inappropriate. I don't care if you We need to recognize our accountability that we represent Jesus,

SPEAKER_00we represent the global church, but we also represent ourselves. Every one of us does. And there is accountability built into that that we all need. And we don't get to say, well, this part of my life, this part is immune to the accountability of the church. I'm not responsible. You have no authority over what I say online.

SPEAKER_00I mean, that's not true. In fact, like you said, it's even more impactful what we say online versus what we say in person. And for some reason, we think that this has no consequence. And that's a real problem. It's true, and I do want to talk specifically about preachers and teachers. I think it's right for us to be using these online tools, but again, we have to be very careful, and we have to recognize that sometimes we are talking to people that are in a very different context than our own, and something might be appropriate for me to preach in my congregation

SPEAKER_00to these people, not my congregation as if I own it, mine as in the congregation of which I'm a part, There might be something that is appropriate for me to preach with the people I'm doing life with, but maybe this is not exactly the message that somebody in a different part of the country, or for that matter, in a different part of the world needs to hear. And I need to recognize that some things are good for the local assembly or a local class that may not be the right thing for the online audience.

SPEAKER_01Oh, yeah, man. I think this actually is connected to what we began this conversation talking about because my connection to a localized pocket of God's family has or necessitates different interactions than what I'm going to be portraying to just the world at large. And that's not an inconsistency. That's not a lack of integrity. Sometimes I just think, like, we stand behind this big, you know,

SPEAKER_01braggadocious shield of, well, I'm the same everywhere, and you get what you get with me. And, well, hold on now. I'm looking at Paul, and I know, I know that he had a different message when he came to the synagogue than he does when he comes to the Areopagus. And there's a very good reason for that. Leslie Newbigin's fantastic. He's got a couple of good books, Gospel in a Pluralistic Society and Foolishness of the Greeks, where he talks about Paul's strategy of adapting the gospel to where he is in his context.

SPEAKER_01And you bring up such a good point because if I could be so bold as to say, honestly, man, a lot of the meaningful conversations that are worth having, the best place to have them is not online. I have to always stop and think my goal should always be to communicate in such a way that the person I'm communicating to has the best possible chance to understand me clearly so that we can maybe not reach an agreement,

SPEAKER_01but we can reach a genuine understanding of each other because that's what any future agreement will be built on. And the medium of social media in many cases does not do that, does not accomplish that goal. I'm much more fond of recognizing where a conversation needs to happen and taking it offline as fast as possible, or at minimum, taking it into a private context, maybe a private message where I want to ask someone about something or deepen the conversation. And that's because if you get it out of the public eye and off

SPEAKER_01of those public world-facing walls, Now you can get to something real. There doesn't have to be posturing. There doesn't have to be someone worried about what someone else is going to see or think of them for the position that they hold or what they're not upholding. I have a much better chance of really getting with somebody. And to me, that is incumbent upon me in being a good steward of the platform, so to speak.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. That's exactly right. And it is amazing. I'm so glad that you said that about just helping people save face so that they're not tempted to posture, not tempted to virtue signal to say, oh, yeah, well, I believe this because It's amazing to me how often I will take a conversation from being a public one to being a private one and people have this switch that gets flipped and they become a different person. They're so much more reasonable, so much more calm.

SPEAKER_00They have positions that aren't Just wildly dogmatic. And it's like, wow, why can't we be this person in public? And I think that's the key. And I hope that we're modeling that for people right now to say we need to... If we're going to be online, we have to be real with people. We have to be vulnerable with people. We cannot be this kind of boisterous, I'm gonna punch the other guy in the mouth because I'm winning one for the team.

SPEAKER_00I have to be kind. I have to manifest the fruit of the Spirit. If we're going to be in the agora, if we're going to be representing Jesus and his people in the public, we have to be especially here, be filled with love and joy and peace and patience and kindness and goodness. This is not the place for you to virtue signal. This is not the place for you to show people that you know how to own the other side. This is a place for you to model kindness and humility and understanding and listening.

SPEAKER_00So that's what I... And I say all that to say that's not how I began my online ministry. That's not how radicallychristian.com started. Like I wanted to be all the things that got clicks and got people outraged and got people on my side and got people all these things. And then it's like, no, that's not who I want to be. And that's not what I need to model. That's not what I find in the New Testament. If we want to talk about modeling New Testament Christianity, that's New Testament Christianity. Let's be humble.

SPEAKER_00Let's confess. Let's use podcasts like we've tried to do the last couple of weeks. Let's use this platform to confess our sins and our struggles and to be real with not just each other, but with the online audience.

SPEAKER_01Let's use these platforms to be nothing more than an extension and a projection of the real relationship and community that we actually share in the body of Christ. And I think that pulls the whole conversation together because it's really hard to fake that when you don't actually have it. It's really hard to promote that and project that if it's not something that you've experienced and it's not something that you're actually involved in on a daily, weekly basis.

SPEAKER_01Because when you're just out in the digital void and it's an echo chamber, Lots of voices are loud that aren't going to lead you in the right direction, and you have all kinds of incentives to step outside of grace. But if you're an embodied community, you are accountable to them. And we are accountable to the way that we represent ourselves. I think to the original question about online worship, is it good, is it not good? I think it is good. And I'm glad that we have the opportunity to reach so much more of the world.

SPEAKER_01But what I want to always keep in mind and what I hope that I can encourage others to keep in mind is that when it comes to my relational commitment to the body of Christ, Jesus said, go and find what this means to the disciples. He told them to go and dig into this together and tear it apart, tease it out, apply it, wrestle with it together. He did not say, go and find someone who agrees with you. And if we're not in community together, we are very susceptible to just being spoon-fed people that just agree with us.

SPEAKER_01And that's not great for our ultimate growth and what God actually wants for us. So, finding a community of people that you can go and find what this means with, even if they don't always agree with you and you don't always agree with them, but Even your disagreements are situations and occasions for the fruit of the Spirit to be on display is an incredibly healthy and fulfilling thing. That's a picture of what we see in Scripture.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. And I think we are. We're sort of in a moment that's a hybrid. You know, like for a while during 2020, during COVID, we were all online all the time. And I don't think that was long-term. It wasn't sustainable. It wasn't healthy. It wasn't good. And I don't think anybody I don't know if anybody ever thought that it was, but some people I think have gotten stuck there. I think some people have gotten stuck there, maybe just with their worship or maybe lots of areas of their life where they are perpetually online and they do need to unplug.

SPEAKER_00As the kids used to say, hang up and hang out. They need to find embodied community, be part of a church family. I hope that people listen to podcasts like this and they say, I want to hang out with Marcus. I want to hang out with Wes. I want to be in... I want to be in a place with people like that. I want to be having these kinds of conversations at a dinner table or a coffee table. I want to be having these kinds of conversations and living this kind of life that they see modeled and displayed rather than I want to be online modeled.

SPEAKER_00Like hopefully whatever it is you're consuming online is pushing you towards more embodied community. Again, I think there is a place and a purpose and a benefit to the online material that is created. And hopefully it is making us less consumers and more Christlike. That's the goal of all of this is discipleship is to become more like Jesus. And that not only needs to be the goal of those of us who have the audacity to sit behind a microphone Talk to people,

SPEAKER_00but it also needs to be the mindset of those who are listening and as we are consuming to say, is this helping me be more like Jesus? And whether you're talking about this podcast or Fox News or Facebook or Twitter or CNN or whatever it is you're consuming, if it's not helping you be more like Jesus, if you leave more angry and upset and hostile, turn it off. If this podcast ever makes you so angry that you can't see straight, Turn it off.

SPEAKER_00Go find someone and some place and something that's going to help you to be a better follower of Jesus. And we hope that this is that. But find things and people to put in your life that help you be better disciples.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, I just want to speak candidly to a population that I know is out there. I don't know if they're listening to this podcast or not, but I want to fairly represent. I know that there are folks out there Who, maybe it was through COVID or maybe through some other medium, have just felt that, you know what, it's healthier for me to not be around difficult hypocritical people. That's not spiritually healthy for me. And maybe they're like that in a lot of places in their life.

SPEAKER_01Maybe they're more introverted. Maybe they just don't like being around large groups, whatever that may be. I want to tell you that I see you and I get it. We are a mess. We really are a mess. But the beauty that comes from that mess, that Jesus works in redeeming it, is something that must be accounted for and cannot be replaced. If I'm thinking about online versus in-person engagement with the community of God,

SPEAKER_01and the goal is for me to be more like Jesus, I have to look at His example. The triune God, the Father, the Son, the Spirit, have been in relationship from before time, in community before time. The dance is what it's called, right? Perpetually edifying and venerating each other and loving one another. Actually, the only reason for him to ever even create us is community and family and what comes from that and the beauty that is there to share that. And I was convicted a couple of years ago and someone shared with me,

SPEAKER_01you realize that The less you want to be around people, the less like God you are. The less you want to be in relationship with people and community with people, the more like the enemy of your soul you become. Like the more jaded and cynical and convinced that I don't want relational attachments to anybody, the less like the God we're trying to become like we actually are. And that is proven, if by nothing else, that Jesus decided to come and be with us,

SPEAKER_01not from a distance, not just communicating the Word, not just giving us, you know, the Bible that we can study and come to know Him by, but He felt it was necessary to actually come and get in the dirt, get in the mud, get in relationships, be hurt, be betrayed, be lied to, to experience the beauty that actually comes out of that and the redemption that He was securing for all of us. It is a necessary cost of doing business in the kingdom to be around messed up, broken, flawed people. But I promise,

SPEAKER_01both anecdotally through experience and through scriptural precedent, it is always, always, always worth it. The loneliness epidemic in our country right now exists in part because we have been convinced by our devices that we don't need people. And it is robbing us of part of what it actually means to be human. There's something about that embodiment and relationship and community that you just can't deprogram out of us. And I think that of all places, God's family, the church, is the best place to be in community.

SPEAKER_01That's where you're going to get the best of it.

SPEAKER_00Oh, I'm so glad you said all that, Marcus. And I do think, to kind of go back to a word you used, there are environments that are unhealthy. And that's true online, and that's true in person. But there's a difference between unhealthy and uncomfortable. And we really have to stop and ask ourselves, does this community simply make me uncomfortable, or is it truly unhealthy? Like, not necessarily am I becoming a better follower of Jesus by being here,

SPEAKER_00but Is that what they're trying to accomplish? Like, is it possible to become a better follower of Jesus here? Because sometimes the reason I'm not becoming a better follower of Jesus is my fault, not my community's fault. And sometimes it's easy for me to blame them and say, well, y'all are just You are toxic. You are hard to get along with. You are all of these things. When really the problem is in me and I have to take the log out of my own eye and say, actually, you guys are just making me really uncomfortable right now and I need to surrender myself. As James would say, I need to Stop being so quick to hear.

SPEAKER_00I need to be slow or stop being so quick to get angry. I need to be slow to speak, slow to get angry. I need to receive the implanted word that's able to save my soul. I need to receive it with meekness. Like, that needs to be our attitude. And some places, the word is not being proclaimed. Like, a toxic, angry, wrathful, whatever message, legalistic message is being proclaimed, and it's not. That's not the gospel. And I'd say that probably isn't a healthy place.

SPEAKER_00But there are some places where the gospel is being proclaimed and it's making me really uncomfortable. And that's exactly where I need to be. And there are people that are also struggling to become followers of Jesus. That's why our lives are messy and they're not there yet and I'm not there yet. And sometimes we clash with each other and there's friction and there's tension, but it's exactly in those spaces where growth and discipleship transformation is really possible. I mean, you love going to the gym, like you love working out.

SPEAKER_00Can't say the same for myself. I should. But I mean, what would a gym be like if they advertised this the most comfortable place you've ever been? We will never make you sweat. It won't be hard. It won't be difficult. It'll be the easiest thing you've ever done. Like, what kind of a gym would that be? Like, you're not gonna accomplish anything. No growth is gonna happen there. Like, gyms, they pride themselves on, we're gonna, we're gonna, you know, put you through the wringer. No pain, no gain, man. You gotta, you gotta, you gotta sweat. You gotta cry. You gotta bleed. Like, you gotta go through the hard things because that's where growth is gonna happen.

SPEAKER_00And for some reason, we expect our churches to be easy and comfortable and not cause us to sweat or cry. And it's exactly in the sweat and the tears where real growth and transformation happens.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, man, I'm gonna show incredible restraint here and not speak out of turn on this online platform because there are some gems that are like that. And I have personal disdain for them. And I just don't want radicallychristian to get hit with a cease and desist or something like that because I am tempted to go on. But I will say that what you said is absolutely correct. There's a quote that's never left to me, and it goes like this.

SPEAKER_01For a seed to achieve its greatest expression, it must become completely undone. The shell cracks, the insides come out, everything changes, and to somebody who doesn't understand growth, it looks like complete destruction.

SPEAKER_00Yeah.

SPEAKER_01There is no growth without the kind of discomfort that's just necessary in the process. So I think you bring up a really good point there.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. Well, Marcus, this has been really helpful, and I really hope that it causes us to think about what we're putting online, what we're consuming online, and how much time we're spending online, and whether or not all of this stuff is helping us and other people become more like Jesus.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, I'm convicted by the time, because if I go and check right in my iPhone and look at the amount of time, the weekly time report, It will reveal to me that my lack of prayer and my lack of time in community with the saints is not for a lack of time. It's just not, right? But I hope that if you are a part of a local body, you think about it in a way of what you can bring to that body instead

SPEAKER_01of just what you can take from that body. And if you're not a part of a local body and you're listening, I would encourage you to really, really go on the search and dig in. Let it be a little bit messy. Let it be a little bit uncomfortable. If they are forming people more and more into the likeness of Christ, then it is a good place to be. And maybe you're in one of those places where there isn't a place like that. And I would say you got to find some people. Find some people that you can dig in with together and let God do something right there. Maybe even in your own house to riff off our episode last week.

SPEAKER_01But it's something that the value of which and the importance of which cannot be overstated.

SPEAKER_00Amen. Well, thanks, brother. This has been great.

SPEAKER_01All right. Thanks, Wes.

SPEAKER_00I hope you enjoyed that episode of the Radically Christian podcast. If you did, please take a second to like, share, subscribe, rate, or review the podcast. You can find the show on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, Substack, YouTube, or wherever you listen to podcasts. Thank you so much for listening. Thank you to my co-host Marcus, and thank you to my McDermott Road Church family who helps make this podcast possible. Okay, now let's all go out and love like Jesus.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. What Does the Bible Say About the Holy Spirit Today?

    Nov 11, 202656 minAudio

    The Spirit is often the member of the Godhead we talk about least, and when we do, He can feel more like a doctrine to manage than a Person to know. In this conversation from the 412 Christian Podcast, Wes joins hosts...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Salvation, Sanctification, and Justification

    Nov 4, 202649 minAudio

    What if the vocabulary you inherited for salvation has left you more anxious than assured? Justification, sanctification, saved: many believers learned these words as tidy categories, and many sincere Christians still...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. What is Baptism of the Holy Spirit?

    Oct 28, 202644 minAudio

    What does it actually mean to be baptized in the Holy Spirit? For many who grew up in the Restoration Movement, the phrase meant a debate about water baptism or a defensive argument about miraculous gifts, and then the...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Is Baptism a Work?

    Oct 21, 202654 minAudio

    If we’re saved by grace through faith, why does baptism still matter? An elder in Tennessee wrote in with a question many Christians are asking. If love is the heart of everything, is baptism just a ritual tacked on, a...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. What the Bible Says About Gluttony

    Oct 14, 202646 minAudio

    Is gluttony only about what is on your plate? Most of us assume we know the answer, and most of us feel a little uncomfortable when the subject comes up. The Bible mentions gluttony far less than many Christians expect,...

    Credit the people on this episode