This episode of the Radically Christian Bible Study Podcast continues the series on becoming a better Bible student. The conversation centers on how to ask better questions of Scripture and how cultural and generational trends affect biblical interpretation. The discussion highlights the importance of moving beyond a "what's in it for me?" mindset when reading Scripture. Garrett Best encourages humility in reading Scripture and emphasizes group Bible study for broader perspectives. Key concepts include the value of questioning, wrestling with the text, and seeking transformation rather than simply acquiring knowledge. Garrett Best, PhD, is an Associate Professor of Bible and Ministry and the Chair of the Department of Bible and Ministry at York University. Garrett has degrees from Freed-Hardeman University, Harding School of Theology (MDiv), and Asbury Theological Seminary (PhD Biblical Studies). He is passionate about helping students discover the depth and beauty of Scripture while fostering transformative learning experiences. Links and Resources: * Logos Bible Study Software (https://logos.com/radicallychristian) * The Anxious Generation by Jonathan Haidt (https://amzn.to/4gubWo3) * Strange and Sacred Scripture by Matthew Schlimm (https://amzn.to/3WO6a9P) Note: Some links may be affiliate links. Meaning, if you choose to buy something through these links, we receive a small commission at no extra cost to you. This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit www.radicallychristian.com
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
welcome to the radical christian bible study podcast i'm your host wes mcadams here we have one goal learn to love like jesus we're continuing our series on how to be a better bible student and today we're talking with garrett best phd chair of the
SPEAKER_01bible and ministry department at york university We're talking about how to ask better questions of the Bible. We'll get to that conversation in just a moment. But before we do, I want to keep encouraging you to sign up for an extended free trial of Logos Bible Study software. If you preach, teach, lead a small group Bible study, or you just want to get access to more resources, then consider signing up for this extended free trial. You can visit logos.com slash radicallychristian. That's logos, L-O-G-O-S,
dot com slash radically christian okay now my conversation with garrett best garrett best welcome back to the podcast brother thank you it's good to be back it's it's an honor to get invited twice well you did such a fantastic job last night we were talking about the fact that we had a great conversation about revelation we were talking about that before we hit record and i really appreciated a lot of your book recommendations and the way you think through that book and it
SPEAKER_00it really helped a lot of people well um you know i'll share with you um I had a lot of conversations outside of the podcast. So that means that you've got quite a few people listening and finding a lot of value in what you're doing. So thank you for the podcast and for having me on and looking forward to our conversation today.
SPEAKER_01Awesome. Well, thanks, brother. Well, before we get started, why don't you, you probably shared this last time you were on, but why don't you share a little bit about your work and what you do?
SPEAKER_00Yeah. So for the last three years, I have been here in York, Nebraska, in the middle of the cornfields, right now in the frozen tundra. And I serve as the chair of the Department of Bible and Ministry here. And so it's my honor, you know, awesome privilege to get to work with our students here at York. And so I think this is also a little bit of background for the conversation that we'll be having today. But here at York, every student takes six Bible classes.
And so there are four that the university mandates and then two upper level
SPEAKER_00electives and all students go through those. So I really get to see the vast majority of our students. I mean, it would be close to almost all of our students. I'll see at some point in a class because they have to have a Bible class while they're here. They have to six of them. And We don't have a huge faculty, so they'll probably have class with me at some point. So I get to see kind of all of our students, and these students come from all over the world. We have many international students. We have students from Texas, actually,
California, and then, of course, here in the Midwest. So we have students from all over, and they bring different experiences reading the Bible.
SPEAKER_00They bring limited experience reading the Bible in many cases. They've never engaged the Bible. And so I get to sit with them for, in many cases, six classes. It's an awesome privilege. And then we have Bible and ministry majors. And so these are students that love learning about the Bible and Scripture and ministry. So I kind of get the best of both worlds working with students, working with Bible and ministry majors, and then also helping students discover Scripture and and reading Scripture, and Jesus, and how to encounter God through Scripture,
SPEAKER_00get to do all of that. So that's my job. So that's, I don't know, I love my job. That's awesome.
SPEAKER_01Well, I think you bring a unique perspective to the table, especially to this conversation about becoming better Bible students, because number one, you are a great Bible student, and so you're modeling that. but also you're teaching Bible students, current and future Bible students. So I'm curious, what are some of the trends that you notice as you work with these young people? What are some of the trends, maybe the trends that encourage you and you think, man, it's so good that young people are thinking this way, but maybe also the trends that kind of concern you as well?
SPEAKER_00Sure. Sure. So as I answer this question, I'm not just going to answer just Bible and ministry majors. I'm just going to make some broad statements about the generation that I am working with right now, which is Gen Z. And we've already got to start talking about Gen Alpha, because they'll be coming right behind Gen Z. And so... It's not true for every student, but in general, I think there are some trends. And so I'll start with some things that are a little bit concerning. And these are not just related to how we read the Bible,
just generational trends.
SPEAKER_00One was when I first got here... two years ago, I was a little discouraged by the fact that, you know, I don't feel that old. I was in college not that long ago, but when I was in college, we would throw the Frisbee out on the lawn, and if there was anything fun happening, we went to it. We didn't miss anything, and we all ate in the cafeteria, and we were just out, you know, and when I got here, I Students prefer to be in their rooms on video games,
SPEAKER_00and when they go through the cafeteria line, they want a to-go box to go eat in their room, and they didn't turn out to fun things that were happening on campus, you know, and it was trying to process that. Then this year, there's just been a totally different vibe. The students are engaged and eating the calf and go to stuff and totally different feel on campus. And a lot of people have noticed this. We're trying to make sense of it. And someone pointed out to us that this is the first group to
be a student,
SPEAKER_00kind of an incoming class who were not in high school during COVID. And so just one trend to notice is I'm sure other institutions of higher learning would acknowledge us too, that I'm not sure we fully reckoned with how COVID affected entire generations of students. And so that's a concerning trend, but also an encouraging trend to see how this group that just came in this year is just having those years of quote unquote normal high school experience has changed the way that they interact on campus.
SPEAKER_00That's one thing. I would say other concerning trends, like in general, I don't know if you've referenced on your podcast or not, but Jonathan Haidt's work, Anxious Generation. I think if you want to understand this generation, that might be a good place to look. And as a social psychologist, he traces so much of the angst and anxiety in Gen Z back to the proliferation of smartphones and social media back around 2012. That's kind of where we saw. And so we just see a lot of that happening.
SPEAKER_00that angst, that anxiety, and mental health issues. We had someone come and do training with our faculty on this idea of purpose anxiety, that what's driving a lot of that anxiety is, what is my purpose? Why am I here? What am I supposed to be doing with my life? And so that is just a trend that is here. One of the things that that does is students are always on their screens,
SPEAKER_00on their phones, playing video games. A trend that's different from when I was growing up is if we wanted to listen to headphones all the time, we had to carry around a Walkman with us. Well, the AirPods make it so that many students literally never remove an AirPod from their ear from the moment they wake up till the time they go to bed. Even sitting in class, they have one in their ear. And so when you're plugged in like that, you can't actually be present for relationship with people. And so it's... Sad to me to actually talk to young men about what it's like to
date today.
SPEAKER_00It's very difficult for them to date, to approach a female and invite them to a date and then think about going to a restaurant and sitting down and having a dinner and a conversation. That is... It's actually easier for some of them to meet up for a mindless, meaningless sexual encounter than it is to think about a meaningful relationship. These are difficult trends. I think addiction to pornography, I just think we have to acknowledge these things are happening
with Gen Z. I will always say my first year teaching was the first year that ChatGPT came out.
SPEAKER_00And so the use of artificial intelligence. And as hard as I fight, you know, and try to convince them that we cannot farm out our critical thinking... We cannot farm out morality to chat GPT. It's just here to stay. And the temptation to use it, you know, to do all of the thinking and work for us is really high. And so that leads to lack of inability to read. I think a lack of desire to read, you know, to read a text and,
SPEAKER_00like, understand it and engage with it. I think that is more difficult for this generation that has all these challenges. And then the last thing that I would say is a concern is... Even students that come here from Christian households that love the Lord and are spiritual leaders on our campus and pray in class and speak in chapel, many of them don't see the church as a part of faith. as important to faith. And so there are people,
SPEAKER_00many of Gen Z, like, love Jesus, love the idea of Jesus, but they don't see why the church is a part of following Jesus. And so I feel like I spend a lot of my time trying to convince students that the church is beautiful and the church is where you can find Jesus, you know, and those sorts of things. So I don't know. Those are some of the concerning things. I don't know if you want to say something about any of those, but
SPEAKER_01No, that's really helpful. And I think that sometimes we don't always put those trends together with spirituality, you know, when we think about relationships and, you know, sort of this draw away from other people and how that affects the way that we read or don't read scripture, or as you've pointed out about ChatGPT. You know, I mean, I think there's a lot of people that are concerned, and I think probably rightfully so, and I'm sure you could speak to this as well, about cheating on papers and exams because of,
SPEAKER_01you know, using ChatGPT to cheat their way through school. And that concerns me, of course. But what you said really concerns me, the idea of critical thinking. And I mean, just honestly, from my own perspective, I use AI for some tasks, you know, for my podcast. I'll take the transcript from the podcast and I'll give it to ChatGPT and I'll say, hey, write me a summary for this. Kind of pull back the curtain, show people what I do. Um, but, but I, I don't want to overuse it because to your point,
SPEAKER_01I mean, it just sort of the way that calculators made it so that I can't do even basic math in my head anymore because I have the convenience of a calculator. And when we, I love the way you put that farm out our critical thinking to technology, um, then we're intellectually fat and lazy and we're incapable. When push comes to shove, we're incapable of thinking through difficult questions because we've forgotten how to think. Yeah, and the irony here, this happens all the time with students,
is I do a huge thing.
SPEAKER_00I just want you to read and reflect. Even if you write on there, I read it three times and I didn't get it, and here are just some things I saw. I'm going to give you full points for that because many of these students have never read the Bible. So I'm going to show a ton of grace. I just want you to try. What ends up happening when you catch students using the AI is they say, well, I didn't understand, so I used AI to help me understand. And what I always say back is, and you've ensured that you're never going to be able to understand. because you're not growing in your ability to read.
SPEAKER_00And I'm not asking you for right answers. I'm asking you for what you're seeing and observing in the text so that you can grow as a reader in the text. So AI, we go to it because the temptation's so strong, because it is a powerful tool. but then it shortcuts that ability to actually learn those skills ourselves.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, and that's so helpful, and I think that's something that has kind of risen to the top of this series that we're doing right now on being better Bible students, is our temptation towards, even before AI, our temptation towards trying to get the right answer is And sometimes that's all we ever cared about. Like, what's the right answer? What does the Bible say about X, Y, and Z? And before AI, we were using Google for that or YouTube for that. And we were like, what does the Bible say about this? And all we want is the right answer. And we're shortcutting the process.
SPEAKER_01And sometimes the process is the whole point. The point is to wrestle with the text, to wrestle with God and allow him to change us and shape us. And it's that interaction... in which we grow and that's what's really important that's where we become wise rather than just downloading all the right answers as if we could just plug a cord in our head and just download all the right answers i think a lot of people would be content with that but god would not be because he wants a relationship with us when a lot of students approach education that way let me do
what i need to do to get the a you know it's kind of a transactional thing and this is where we have to
SPEAKER_00shift from education being the dissemination of information to a transformative experience. And so that's what we try to communicate is that there's value in the transformative experience of learning to read.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, that's so good. I feel like I should say some positive things.
SPEAKER_00I just said negative things. First, I just want to say people can get really down on other generations, but I find these students to be kind and respectful, and they have hopes and dreams. Like, I love the students that we have here. They're wonderful to me and my family. They're always playing with my kids, you know, and it's like I love our students here at the university. The other things are that some of the positives grow out of some of those negatives.
So that mental health and purpose anxiety has created an openness for people to
SPEAKER_00hear conversations about faith. So in a class, if I say to you, you know, students are like on their computers and phones and checked out and all those sorts of things, but in any class, if I just said at any moment... How many of you feel purposeless and lost and hopeless and wonder what your future is and wish that you had a purpose? What if I said I had something that I think can help you? You could hear a cricket chirp in there. And so there's just this real openness, you know, that is here. And I think some of that is creating that mental health and
purpose anxiety.
SPEAKER_00I think it's also driving students towards a desire for mentoring. They are... They feel kind of lost a little bit. And so when they find somebody who's 15, 20 years up the road from them that they feel like can help them, they will meet with you. I have a student that comes to my house on Tuesday mornings at 6 a.m. for coffee. Does not miss. and we do mentoring on Tuesday mornings at 6 a.m. This is a college student. So hear me say there's a hunger for intergenerational mentoring
for this generation.
SPEAKER_00I think that's really encouraging. The other thing I would say is this generation does not have a filter. They have not inherited the taboos of things you're not supposed to talk about and things that you're not supposed to mention. So they come in my office and just, help me, I'm addicted to pornography. And other generations don't talk about their stuff. You hide that stuff. And this generation just comes in and lays it all out on the table. I think that's a positive trend.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. Confession is not a problem for Gen Z. They are willing to kind of lay it all out there for you. I do have a story just to tell you, just to maybe encourage you. So they want to talk about stuff, and there's no topics that are off the table for them. I think we should hear that in our churches too. because sometimes churches are a place where it doesn't feel like you can have certain conversations or talk about certain things. And so my first year here, we have a class where we don't actually give any tests in the class.
And we say that this is a class where we don't want you to feel like we're here to just...
SPEAKER_00unload information on you, but we want you to have a whole course for your soul work, for your heart. So they actually have to practice spiritual disciplines. They pick 10 over the semester, and they spend a whole week doing that one, and then they journal about it, and we talk about the Christian faith and let them ask questions, and we dialogue in the class, and We want them to have that transformative experience. Well, I know that they want to talk about sex, and so I built a class in, but I really chickened out. It was my first year teaching. That topic is so scary to talk about with Gen Z.
I didn't want the class to go off the rails because I know that we have students
SPEAKER_00from all over and all different backgrounds. So of all the classes that semester, I just showed a video that day. And it was from a great theologian who had great theology of sex, but I was just so insecure talking about that with them that I just punted and kind of showed a video. So at the end of class, I had eight students stay after class. It happens they were all females. They stayed after, and they said, we were already talking, and we would like to confront you. They said, why don't you show a video today?
SPEAKER_00He said, we want to talk about this, and we need to talk about this, and we have come to trust you, and if we don't hear it from you, who are we going to hear it from? And I think that story says a lot about our students and the students that are out there today, and I just remember being like, oh, you talk about a gut punch. I learned a lot that day, and I've been bolder since then, and I do build in sex talks into my classes, and they're open to having them, and they've all gone really well, actually, believe it or not.
SPEAKER_00And so I learned a lot through that, and that story encourages me. I carry that with me, actually, in every semester, that they need to hear these things from us, because if they're not hearing it from us and having those conversations with us, where will they be finding that information?
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Wow, that's really good. And I think in a way that helps us transition to this next idea about questions, and that we all have questions. And I think sometimes we're asking questions of the Bible when we study the Bible, whether we realize it or not. We may not be asking them explicitly, but implicitly we assume that we're going to find answers to whatever questions that we're asking. So what do you find are some of the default questions that we tend to ask? And Maybe why are those questions not the best questions that we
could be asking? So what are some of the default questions, not just with college students, but just in general?
SPEAKER_01What are the questions we tend to be asking when we go to the text?
SPEAKER_00Sure. Yeah, this is not just true for college students. I mean, I have 15 years of ministry experience too, so people of different ages in churches. I think it's more from reading the Bible in our Western consumerist, individualist, fast-paced... You know, if your food's not out to your table in a couple of minutes, you're upset. And we just demand like immediate payoff, you know. And so I think all the questions that people jump to first can kind of be summarized under this idea of what's in it for me.
You know, and that's the initial impulse that our culture kind of drives us towards.
SPEAKER_00And now, for particularly students here, there are some passages that do give you that immediate what's in it for me. You know, Jeremiah 29 11. If I had a quarter for every time someone quoted Jeremiah 29 11, I know the plans I have for you, says the Lord. Philippians 4 13, you know, and lines from the Psalms. Here at the university, I refer to those as tattoo passages. When I'm in a church, I call them crochet passages, the ones we crochet and hang up in our bathrooms,
SPEAKER_00but students don't even know what the word crochet means. These are the ones they get tattooed, you know what I mean? And for them, they read that passage and there's like this immediate payoff that like, God loves me and he has a plan for me. Now, let me go on a caveat here and say... I want to affirm these students that they're going to Scripture to hear a message from the Lord. And so when a student quotes Jeremiah 29 11 in chapel or whatever, I'm going to go up and say,
SPEAKER_00thank you so much for sharing your faith with our campus this morning. And I want to affirm that impulse to go to Scripture to hear a word from the Lord. they are doing the best they can with the ways that they are reading Scripture and thinking about Scripture, and I just think we ought to affirm that. And I think they have pretty good radars to know that you're judging them or the way that they're reading the Bible is wrong. And so I want to go up and just affirm that impulse. And then create the invitation in our classes and our interactions to say...
SPEAKER_00I love that you're trying to find meaning in Scripture, and you're trying to find it through the Lord. What if I could show you a way to even go deeper in how you're reading that in Scripture? And so instead of just Jeremiah 29 11, in fact, in our Story of Israel class, we spend a whole class on the context of Jeremiah 29. Because there's this beautiful message that comes through that text beyond just verse 11 about settling down and blessing the place in which you find yourself. And even if that's here at York or wherever that might be, there's a powerful message that comes through Jeremiah 29 11.
So let me even take you deeper into how you could hear from God and find purpose in
SPEAKER_00your encounter with Scripture. But in moving them deeper, we'd like to move beyond the question of what's in it for me to... what am I missing when I read the Bible and make it all about me? I don't know where I got this term. You know, we talk about exegesis, like drawing meaning out of the text, and eisegesis. And I don't know if somebody's ever shared this on your podcast. I don't know where I learned the term, but narsegesis. I don't know. I feel like I learned that from maybe Nije Gupta or something.
SPEAKER_01I love it. I love it. I've never heard that.
SPEAKER_00Narsegesis. You know, making it all about me. And we tend to do that, and so we try to shift then from doing that to asking... how would the original readers have understood this? And let's understand it as a message to them before we try to make it a message for us. I use a metaphor in a class that goes over pretty well. It's from a book by Matthew Schlimm called Strange and Sacred Scripture.
And he's talking specifically about the Old Testament and how we've kind of lost
SPEAKER_00the Old Testament. And he uses the metaphor of a person, a relationship. And he says, is the Old Testament for you a stranger, an enemy, or a friend? For like 99% of the students in class, they say stranger, even Christian students. No one knows the Old Testament. That's a problem in and of itself, but they say stranger. And so I say, if you had a stranger in your life or an international student comes from another culture, what kinds of things would you need to do to move them from the category of stranger to friend And the students know they have come up with a great list.
SPEAKER_00Like, you know, I would spend time with them. I would not judge their culture. I would listen. I would learn. I would be respectful. I would be patient. I would try new things even if they make me uncomfortable. You know, those sorts of, that sort of list. And that's why I think that metaphor is great for this conversation. Okay, well then how do we do that with Scripture? How do we treat Scripture that's another culture? How do we do that? And there is blessing to be found in moving someone from stranger to friendship. And so how do we look at Scripture as a friend who can walk with us in faith?
SPEAKER_01I love that. It reminds me of a conversation. I don't think I've shared this on the podcast, but I was having a conversation with my kids the other day. We were playing that game where you ask, you know, if you could have dinner with anyone living or dead, who would it be? And I said someone, a modern person, and my kids were surprised. And they said, well, I thought you would say somebody from the Bible. And I said, well, that's a good suggestion. But I said, are we assuming they would speak English? Yeah. And they never stopped to think about it. And I don't think we normally do stop and think about that. We think, well, I would love to have dinner with Paul.
SPEAKER_01And I'm like, well, I mean, it would be kind of a boring dinner unless I had a translator who could speak his language or Greek or Aramaic and have this... be a translator for me. But even if we could translate the language, there's still this huge cultural barrier. I'm not sure we could get past all of that over dinner. But we just assume that if I was hanging out with Jesus and the apostles, not only would I understand their culture and their language, that they would understand mine. And there is this huge cultural barrier between the two,
SPEAKER_01and especially when it comes to the Old Testament. And I think you're exactly right. If we approached these Old Testament writers this way, understanding that they live in this ancient hebrew culture and and trying to understand them and not i like what you said not judging their culture but but really just asking good questions and getting to know them sort of hanging out with them and and decentralizing ourselves then we could really make some progress and in learning and understanding
SPEAKER_00Yeah. I think that conversation would have to be like an Acts 2 Holy Spirit moment, where like you heard each other speaking in the same language or something, yeah.
SPEAKER_01Yes, absolutely. For sure. For sure. So most of the questions that we're asking that are sort of the wrong questions are... I love that narcissistic idea. Narcagesus.
SPEAKER_00Narcagesus. I love it.
SPEAKER_01Narcagesus. And so what do we miss? What are some of the things—you kind of touched on this already—but what are some of the things that we miss? What are some of the details that we're not seeing because we're going to the text asking, what's in it for me? How do I get saved? How do I do church right? Whatever the questions may be, even to go to the question that a lot of young people are asking right now, to your point, about purpose. And I think that's why Jeremiah 29, 11 resonates with them. They're looking for purpose.
SPEAKER_01And then this verse, you just take it, it's just one sentence, and it promises me that I have a purpose, God has plans for my life, and it seems to speak to the question that I was already asking. But what details are we missing when we practice narcegesis?
SPEAKER_00Yeah. I've tried to teach kind of a three-fold way to read Scripture. So first, whenever we read a text, and by the way, this is not even just for Scripture. I mean, if you're going to read the Constitution of the United States, there's a history there. It's embedded within a context. Now, can you read the Constitution or can you read any Bible verse and on a surface level, you know, have some understanding of what's happening? Of course. But as we know, there's ways to kind of deepen our understanding there.
SPEAKER_00So I teach this behind the text, in the text, in front of the text. So we have to ask those questions about what is happening in the world behind the text, right? So when we read the Gospel of Luke and it mentions Pharisees, you could read through that narrative and sort of understand that Jesus frequently finds himself in conflict with Pharisees, and you could understand that there's some conflict that happens there. But who were the Pharisees? What did they believe? And why were they frequently in conflict with Jesus?
I think that is a really interesting question that allows us to kind of get behind
SPEAKER_00the text and ask those. And the text... assumes, the text is written by ancient people for ancient people, assuming ancient things that we're so not familiar with today. So we do have to do some work to understand some of those dynamics behind the text. I mean, you mentioned one, and I don't think everybody is always expected to do this, but even the language itself, even the Greek text, the Hebrew text... there are things that are helpful to see there that English sometimes doesn't draw out the full significance of those things.
SPEAKER_00So behind the text. And then in the text, surprisingly, we are not great readers of dynamics that are happening within the text. I ask students, I say, when was the last time you read something that you didn't just completely scroll through, that you read every word of it? And our phones are making us people who can't actually read text closely as a whole. And so to actually bear into text and notice literary details and themes, and on a church level, I'm not faulting this because there's a certain pragmatics that
is involved here,
SPEAKER_00but somebody reads their Bible every day, we would pat them on the back and say, praise the Lord. But if they're doing that, they're probably just doing one chapter a day. And these documents were written to be read and encountered and heard in one sitting. And so even breaking up 28 chapters of Acts, even breaking that up over a month, by the time you get to chapter 28, you've forgotten chapter 1.
And what you miss there is there's actually an inclusio in Acts chapter 1 where
SPEAKER_00what Jesus is speaking to them about in chapter 1, the very first few verses, for 40 days is the kingdom of God. And then in the last two verses of Acts 28, 30, and 31, Paul is there speaking to them about the kingdom of God. And that's like a literary inclusio that tells you how to read everything in between it. It's all about the kingdom of God. Now, Does that mean you can't read Acts and get something from it? No, but it just means that we often miss actually literary devices and details that are happening in the text. So behind the text,
SPEAKER_00in the text, and then I think as we approach Scripture, it's designed by people of faith, for people of faith, to build up their faith. And so I think the way that sometimes Scripture's read at secular universities and institutions where you don't ever ask that faith question I don't think that's actually treating these texts in the way that they were designed either. So I think reading in a Christ-centered Christian university institution like ours, we have to attend to what the text is trying to do and the people who are sitting in front of it.
SPEAKER_00So that's kind of the threefold way. And then each one of those sections has all these questions. One of the exercises... I teach a course called Advanced Biblical Research, and we work on their skills of reading and noticing. We do a lot of exercises. I just have them read, and I say, I have to literally beat it out of them all semester, and it is the hardest thing to beat out of them. Do not ask, what does this mean for me yet? That's a second, third-order question. First, make observations and ask questions.
SPEAKER_00We do an exercise where we read a text, and I just pick a random text, and everybody in the room has to sit there and write out questions, and I challenge them, come up with more questions than me. And you win if you can come up with more questions than me. And in just three or four verses, five, six verses, however many we pick, I can come up with 25 questions. And so we practice that skill of asking questions. One of the biggest... one of the biggest issues, one of the biggest questions I think people struggle with is where do I find
SPEAKER_00answers to my questions? And the default is to Google it, and I try to tell students not to do that because Google is a mixed bag, and probably more times than not, you're going to find a wacko website, you know, that does not share credible information. And so we spend time in the library talking about different kinds of commentaries and sharing those sources, and so... Behind the text, in the text, in front of the text. And then how to find the answers to the questions that we actually have.
SPEAKER_00I think those would be just some things I would share there.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I love that. Garrett, let me ask you this. How do you know—and I love the exercise, and maybe this is the answer, but I love the exercise of coming up with more questions than you, because I think that a lot of people, especially if they're at least somewhat familiar with Scripture, and especially those that are super familiar with Scripture—maybe they've been a Christian for— 50 years, and they've been reading the Bible their whole life. Every year they read through the Bible, or whatever the case may be, even if it's just sitting in Bible classes and listening to sermons. And I think there's an assumption that I know what a Pharisee is.
SPEAKER_01You know, like, I don't need to research Pharisees. I know that Pharisees are this ultra-conservative, legalistic group of Jews that, you know, they didn't like Jesus. And they have this surface-level understanding of who the Pharisees were, and so they're not understanding the nuances of the text because they assume that they know the answer to these questions, but they ought to be asking, maybe again asking afresh, okay, do I really understand the Pharisees? Do I understand the Sadducees? Do I understand the dynamics between these different groups?
So how do you go about sort of probing and helping people to realize that they ought to be asking more questions and that maybe the questions that they think have
SPEAKER_01already been answered need to be answered again?
SPEAKER_00Sure. And let me answer this by prefacing it by saying, I don't think that what we also want to do to people is throw them into radical skepticism to you can never know anything about the text. And that's not what we want to do, you know, on the other side of that too. The best way that I would know to do this is I try to model it myself. Because I heard the saying once, and I don't know who it's attributed to, you know, Scripture is shallow enough for a child to play in and deep enough for an elephant to swim in. And I think if we...
SPEAKER_00if we have a view of Scripture that is living and active, if we have a view of God who is transcendent, then we should always approach it humbly, expecting that we will never know everything. You know, last podcast, Revelation. I will spend the rest of my life studying Revelation and never mind the depths. And so I think it really is an attitudinal issue here. If we're approaching it with this attitude that I already know everything...
SPEAKER_00but when we read it, if we read it from this, there's always something to learn, then when we approach it with this kind of humility and respect, then that question has got to always be there. Where might my knowledge kind of be faulty here, or where might there be areas for growth in what I know? So I think attitude is important, but then I think this leads into some other things we want to talk about here. I think another huge thing here is reading it with other people who read it differently than we do,
SPEAKER_00and who raise those questions, and reading books about Scripture that are pointing out things that maybe we hadn't thought about before, listening to teachers, reading in a group, particularly with people maybe that are different from you. I think those are some of the ways that we can sometimes notice certain things that are different in the text. yeah absolutely and i love that idea and i i think that you're it's really good that you pointed that out the idea that even a surface level understanding of scripture the lord is able to bring people to faith even even
with just a surface level uh understanding and we are saved by grace through faith you know we're saved because our faith is in jesus not because we know everything about the text and so
SPEAKER_01i think sometimes when people start to understand that maybe their understanding of scripture isn't as great as they thought it was they start to even question their salvation and it's like no you're saved because of what jesus has done for you and because your faith and confidence and loyalty is to him and and trying to understand scripture better isn't trying to be more saved It is simply trying to have a greater appreciation for who he is and what he's done. And so I love even going back to what you were saying about Jeremiah 29 11 and the way that people quote that.
SPEAKER_01Does God have a plan for your life? I hope so. I think so. You know, I don't know what that looks like. It may not be the health and wealth that you think that it is. But I'm glad that you are looking to Scripture, and I'm glad you're looking to the Lord. I'm glad you're trusting in Him. And that better understanding of what's happening in Jeremiah isn't hopefully going to diminish the idea that God loves them and has a purpose for them. It's going to deepen. that idea, and they're going to walk away not with this sort of defeated, oh man, I guess God doesn't have a plan for me.
SPEAKER_01They're going to be like, no, I'm part of this cosmic plan that God had for all of us to bring us into the family of God, which I think leads to our next idea of what you've already touched on, is this reading in groups, reading together. Talk to us about the importance of that, as opposed to reading the Bible solely on our own.
SPEAKER_00Sure. So all of us come to the Bible as people who have lived experiences, and... another way we might say that is all of us come to the Bible with particular social locations. To illustrate that, have you ever shared with your readers, or has anybody ever shared Mark Allen Powell's illustration of the prodigal son?
SPEAKER_01I don't think so.
SPEAKER_00Have you heard of this? No. I share this in all my classes, really fascinating. So we tend to be pretty familiar with the prodigal son parable. And so Mark Allen Powell shares this example of when he teaches in American context, he asks, you know... Why did the older son end up... desiring pig's food. And 99% of the time, I don't remember the exact number, but almost all the time they say, well, he squandered his parents' money. And that's a narrative that we know well.
SPEAKER_00Students, black sheep of the family, rebel against mom and dad, you know, take and do something stupid. You know, that's an arc of many of our movies even, right? And so we like the redemption story there. He tells about going and teaching the same parable in Russia, and he asks them, why did the son end up And their response is, because there was a famine in the land. And to be honest with you, as a boy growing up in Alabama, I never even noticed that in the text. But if you think about it, he would not have been wanting to eat pig's food if there
hadn't been a famine in
SPEAKER_00the land. And the reason a Russian would notice that detail is if you're in living memory of the war and events after the war, and grandma and grandpa grew up eating every speck of food they had because they experienced real famine and starvation, then that detail stands out to you because of your social location. And the third example is he says, I taught this in Africa, and... He says, almost all of them point out the detail in Luke 15, 16, that no one gave him anything.
SPEAKER_00And to be honest, I had read this story how many times? You know, heard this story preached how many times? I even had to open my Bible to make sure that line was in there. Because in their reading, yes, there was a famine in the land, and yes, he squandered his parents' money, but he wouldn't have wanted to eat that pig's food if someone else in his community had have given him some food or provisions. And Africans are reading this from a communal culture, where even if you find yourself on hard times, you help each other out. And that's a detail that as someone from an individualist culture,
I had never even noticed.
SPEAKER_00We have a student here from Zimbabwe who is a Bible and ministry major, and the day we talked about this in class, he was like, oh yeah, let me tell you what life is like in the village, and if a student from, you know, a son from my village, an older son did this to his dad, let me tell you what my village would do to him. He chose to write his research paper on this, and he made some observations from the text from his location from a communal culture where he said... You know, if the son's going to the dad and asking for his inheritance, he's essentially wishing his dad dead as he's still alive,
SPEAKER_00because that's something you get upon the death of the dad. And let me just tell you what that would be like in a Zimbabwean culture in my village if a son shamed his father like this, you know, in public. Those are dynamics that we will never know, because it's actually...we have no shame in our culture. And this is a common narrative for kids to rebel against their parents, you know what I mean? And so... reading the text with this incredible student from Zimbabwe who's noticing these things, that's incredibly helpful to the way that we see this. So I tell students,
I say, social locations are neither inherently good or bad.
SPEAKER_00They don't make your reading inferior or superior inherently, but they do impact the way that you're reading the text and the things that you're seeing in the text. And here's what I say, they can either be blind spots or So for me, that line in Luke 15, 16, no one helped him, that was a blind spot for me because I'm an individualist from an individualist culture. Never even noticed that. But they can also be magnifying glasses in the way that that was for this particular student. You know, I'm teaching a class now called Women in the Bible.
And females come to the Bible in different ways and with different questions for
SPEAKER_00many of the stories in the Bible than males do. I had a student last semester, she chose to write her paper, her research paper, like pick this of all the topics in the Old Testament. She wanted to know why the period for ritual impurity for women was twice as long in Leviticus 12 when they have a baby girl as opposed to when they have a baby boy. Now, that's not to say that's an unimportant question for me, but I can guarantee you as a student, I never wrote a paper on that. But for her as a female, that's a question that really stands out for her that she wants
to wrestle with. And so our social locations can be magnifying glasses to things happening in the text.
SPEAKER_00So again, this is not to say there's not absolute truth, but I like to think about the truth in Scripture as like a diamond and And if it's living and active, we can hold that and we can shine the light and we can turn it and we can see. And what sometimes our brothers and sisters do from their various experiences is they help shine the light on another particular facet that helps Scripture stand out. And reading in that way might say, I've never considered that before or seen that before, but that's actually really incredibly helpful.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. And it occurs to me how this is the way Scripture was always intended to be understood and wrestled with, that the original audiences, whether we're talking Old Testament, New Testament, these audiences were probably, a lot of them were illiterate. They were rich. They were poor. They were slaves. They were free people. They were men. They were women. And it was being read to them And probably depending on the section of Scripture, maybe being memorized by them when they were young,
but they were dealing with it together in community within their church family or
SPEAKER_01within the synagogue, and they were wrestling with this together. And I mean, it's a wonderful thing that we live in a time where so many of us have—I mean, I've got dozens and dozens of Bibles on my bookshelf. I've got access to hundreds of Bibles on every device that I own. So that's a wonderful thing. But we have taken Bible reading and Bible study and Bible questions out of the realm of— together communal activity and made it a solo activity.
SPEAKER_01And like you said, it's not that you're going to necessarily come to the wrong conclusions, but you're going to miss things because we all have blind spots. And so somebody from a communal culture needs to hear the individualist perspective about the prodigal son and say, oh, yeah. I guess he does bear responsibility for the fact, but also nobody was helping him. And there were circumstances like the famine that was outside of his control. And the way we all come together, all of God's people, and share our own perspectives and our social location,
SPEAKER_01it helps us to come to such better conclusions. Yeah. I've got one other example that might be interesting to you and your listeners.
SPEAKER_00So the first class everybody takes here is Story of Jesus. We study the Gospel of Luke. And again, many students have never read the Bible. And there's one particular student who... that the story is about, who, if I remember correctly, has no faith backgrounds, not read the Bible, and was actually not particularly excited about this course, but did wonderful work, like participated, read, spoke in class, wonderful experience. I don't think we have to be afraid of Gen Z, which is wonderful,
wonderful.
SPEAKER_00So... We read through the Gospel of Luke, and of course Zacchaeus. Zacchaeus was a wee little, you know, great, great story. And so ask him to read that outside of class and reflect on it. And so we come back, and the question is, how is Zacchaeus portrayed in this story? And... Of course, people say, well, he was a tax collector, and we've seen them a lot in Luke, so students usually say, probably a bad guy, probably there's a money thing, he's stealing from people, you know, those kinds of reflections. And one of the students, this particular student,
SPEAKER_00who, again, I don't think has read the Bible, you know, on at least a regular basis, not a church background, says, I think he's portrayed like a child, right? And you got this little person who's climbing trees. And my mind in class was like starting to race. So I go back to my office and I start looking in commentaries because I know something that he's not necessarily thinking about. Just the chapter before, he says, unless you become like a little child.
you know, in Luke 18, and I'm looking at commentaries, and I'm not seeing many commentaries.
SPEAKER_00I comment on this, so I start searching. I did find one article that had been written. I want to say it was by Stephen Fowle, but I didn't look that up before it came on here. But on how the whole narrative is constructed to show you, you have Jesus welcome the children and say, unless you become like a little child. And by the way, that word little is the same word that's used to describe Zacchaeus. In Greek. And so it's like there's a link there already, by the way. And then the first story is the rich young ruler who acts a
whole lot like an adult and is too burdened by adult things like bill paying and those sorts of things,
SPEAKER_00money and stuff and the stuff of the world. But then the next story is the story of the blind beggar near Jericho who won't stop screaming even though the other people in the story are telling him to stop screaming. Right. And you start thinking about it and you think, Luke has constructed this thing to show you what childlike faith does not look like and what it looks like. It does not look like the rich young ruler. It does look like people who will not stop screaming out loud their faith in Jesus, even though people around them are telling them to be quiet.
SPEAKER_00That sounds a lot like my kids, actually. Who would climb a tree? You know, a little person climbs a tree to see Jesus. Who climbs trees with abandon? You know, my kids. And so Luke's actually, I think, constructed this. I had never noticed that. I had never thought about that. I hadn't seen that in commentaries. And it came from a student observation, someone who's not even read the text. So these are the kinds of epiphanies that you have. And there's other things connecting those texts when you look at it. So the rich young ruler, after that story,
If this is how hard it is to be in the kingdom of God, then who can be saved?
SPEAKER_00Well, the blind beggar, Jesus says, your faith has saved you. And then Zacchaeus, today salvation has come to this house. That's childlike faith. So all that to say, it was not a brilliant observation that I made. It came from an observation from a student who's actually not read the Bible before. Incredible things can happen when we read the Bible with people, I think.
SPEAKER_01Wow, that is a phenomenal story, because as soon as you said that, I was like, wow, how have I never seen that before? But that's exactly the kind of thing that happens when we read the Bible together in community and give people the opportunity to share their observations and ask questions, because I think so often, again, going back to how we began this conversation, when we're so concerned about having the right answers and we impress that upon people, then they feel like, well, I'd I don't know the Bible, I'm not sophisticated,
SPEAKER_01I don't have all this learning, so I'm not going to say that he sounds like a kid, because I might be embarrassed, because that might be the wrong answer. And it's like, no, we need that, we need that perspective, we need you to share that with us, because that's going to help all of us.
SPEAKER_00And I think for Christians in particular, that's why I love the opportunity to read with people who have not read the Bible before, because when we read with Christians, sometimes our familiarity... dulls our ability to see things. We assume that we know this story, like the prodigal son, so we would never notice that detail in Luke 15, 16. And so sometimes what we really need to do as Christians is defamiliarize ourselves, as hard as that is to do, you know, and really impossible to do, but we need to try to read with fresh eyes to the extent that we can.
SPEAKER_00And sometimes that's where reading in community can help us do that.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, absolutely. Garrett, I've been asking everybody that comes on during this series, what's one piece of advice you'd give to somebody who... I think we all want to be better Bible students, so if somebody said, hey, I want to be a better student of Scripture, what piece of advice would you give them?
SPEAKER_00This is an interesting question, because I've had two people reach out and ask this question this week, and so it's easy to answer, because I'll just tell you what I said to them, and this may be a strange answer coming from a Bible professor and a preacher. Um... I think we put too much pressure on ourselves to read the Bible by ourselves. Now, if someone wants to read the Bible every day by themselves, do their devotional, praise the Lord, that's awesome. But as you mentioned, the average early Christian did not have personal copies of the text,
SPEAKER_00and they experienced them in community. A text that I love to share with students all the time when they ask me this is I said, let's go read Acts 8. And when Philip walks up to that eunuch, he says, eunuch's doing his best to read that on his own. He says, do you understand what you are reading? And he says, how can I unless someone guides me? I had an experience the other day a student came, she was in tears because she's not really been living kind of a
Christian life.
SPEAKER_00Nominally, she might refer to herself as a Christian, but not actively. And some things have been happening in her life, and she felt like God was doing some stuff, like showing up and calling her. And so she was trying to embrace that. And so we talked about things like prayer and encountering God in Scripture and in the church and all those stuff. And she said, well, I don't understand the Bible. And honestly, I think it's boring. And that goes back to that vulnerability of this generation. Like, I appreciate the honesty there, and I can understand that.
SPEAKER_00And I said, can we look at Acts 8 together? And the look on her face when she read those verses, do you understand what you're reading? How can I unless... She looked up and she said, this is in the Bible? I said, it is. I think the Bible's affirming you right now. This is okay to feel that way. And actually, I think God's given the church teachers as a gift for a reason. I think that's so freeing for people. I think reading in a group, like forming a group together, gives you accountability,
SPEAKER_00gives you encouragement, gives you the insights of the group, and we now live in a world where you have access to books and teachers, and I mean, I do not teach a course that I don't highly use Bible Project, you know, resources like that, this podcast, books... commentaries. There are so many incredible resources, and so I think my advice would just be, let's lower the pressure on trying to sit down and hammer all this out ourselves. It can be difficult. It is difficult. Not every text is exciting,
SPEAKER_00and so I think reading it in a group, reading it with the church, not only the church currently, locally, but even historically and globally is a good way to give us accountability and new insights and to help us in our reading.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Well, and I love that, because not only do we gain those insights when we read it together, but it also, to go back to the idea of narcegesis, you know, I would so much rather, and it's better that we ask questions about the original audience and what's going on with them, but I would rather people are asking, what does this mean for us then what does this mean for me personally? Sure. Both have their place, but it's so much better that we're thinking through, you know, how does this impact Garrett and what Garrett's going through right now?
SPEAKER_01And if I'm reading it in a community and I know that, you know, Sarah over there, she just lost her mom. And I know what she's going through. She's grieving. And so we're thinking through our community and what's happening with one another. And that gives us a more humble, a more empathetic, sympathetic way of reading scripture. And I think it's helpful.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, completely agree.
SPEAKER_01Well, Garrett, thank you. Thank you for making time for this conversation, brother. Thank you for your work there at York. And thank you for all that you do.
SPEAKER_00Thank you so much. This was great. Thank you so much for listening to the Radically Christian Bible Study Podcast.
SPEAKER_01If you enjoyed this episode, I want to encourage you to make sure you're subscribed and also take a moment to rate and review the podcast wherever you're listening. It really does help more people find this content. I also want to thank my guests who join me each week and my McDermott Road Church family who helps make this podcast possible. You can find out more about Radically Christian at radicallychristian.com. I love you. God loves you. Now, let's all go out and love like Jesus.
The Spirit is often the member of the Godhead we talk about least, and when we do, He can feel more like a doctrine to manage than a Person to know. In this conversation from the 412 Christian Podcast, Wes joins hosts...
What if the vocabulary you inherited for salvation has left you more anxious than assured? Justification, sanctification, saved: many believers learned these words as tidy categories, and many sincere Christians still...
What does it actually mean to be baptized in the Holy Spirit? For many who grew up in the Restoration Movement, the phrase meant a debate about water baptism or a defensive argument about miraculous gifts, and then the...
If we’re saved by grace through faith, why does baptism still matter? An elder in Tennessee wrote in with a question many Christians are asking. If love is the heart of everything, is baptism just a ritual tacked on, a...
Is gluttony only about what is on your plate? Most of us assume we know the answer, and most of us feel a little uncomfortable when the subject comes up. The Bible mentions gluttony far less than many Christians expect,...