In this episode, Wes McAdams and Jared Saltz explore the significance of authorial intent in biblical interpretation. They discuss whether the meaning of a biblical passage is limited to what the human author originally intended or if the Holy Spirit inspired meanings beyond the author’s understanding. They also consider how modern readers can responsibly interpret Scripture without imposing personal biases. The conversation highlights the balance between respecting an author's intent and recognizing the fuller meaning that is the result of divine inspiration. They examine scriptural examples where biblical authors, prophets, and apostles interpreted past writings in ways that pointed to Jesus. They emphasize that while context and historical understanding are crucial, Scripture’s ultimate meaning unfolds through Christ and the broader story of God’s covenant people. Jared Saltz is the preacher at the Smoky Hill Church of Christ in Denver, Colorado. Previously, he was a bi-vocational minister and a Bible teacher at a Christian college. Jared has the unique ability to approach biblical studies from the perspective of an academic and a minister, making biblical interpretation accessible to everyday believers. Resources Mentioned * Logos Bible Software (https://www.logos.com/radicallychristian) * How to Read the Bible for All Its Worth by Gordon Fee and Douglas Stuart Note: Some links may be affiliate links. Meaning, if you choose to buy something through these links, we receive a small commission at no extra cost to you. This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit www.radicallychristian.com
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_00Welcome to the Radically Christian Bible Study Podcast. I'm your host, Wes McAdams. Here we have one goal, learn to love like Jesus. Today we're continuing our series on how to be a better Bible student, and we're talking with Jared Salts about what the biblical authors were intending to say and whether or not there is meaning beyond their intentions. We'll get to that conversation in just a moment. But before we do, I want to keep encouraging you to sign up for an extended free trial of Logos Bible study software.
SPEAKER_00If you preach, teach, lead a small group Bible study, or you just want to get access to more resources, consider signing up for this extended free trial. You can visit logos.com slash radically Christian. That's logos.com slash radically Christian. Okay, now my conversation with Jared Saltz. Jared Salt, welcome back to the podcast, brother.
SPEAKER_01Thanks for having me, Wes. Really excited to get to chat about it. Something that's really fun for both of us.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, no doubt. I'm excited about this conversation. Sometimes we have conversations that I'm genuinely curious about this. I really want to have a conversation about this, and I'm not even sure where the conversation will go, but I'm excited to have it. I'm excited to be here. When you asked me to do this and you're like, I don't know if this is too weird of a topic.
SPEAKER_01I was like, no, no, no. I'm excited to talk about this if you're excited to talk about it. Very cool.
SPEAKER_00Very cool. Well, before we get into that, why don't you share where you are and what you're doing is a little bit different than the last time we talked. It's been several years. So why don't you tell people about the work you're doing? Yeah, so I am preaching at the Smokey Hill Church of Christ in Denver, Colorado.
SPEAKER_01This is a new stop for me. I've been here getting close to 18 months. I'm really enjoying working with the group here. They've been wonderful. And it's been a lot of fun for me moving into difficult, moving into exclusively full-time preaching as opposed to what I've sort of been doing for the past... seven plus years, which was being via vocational for preaching and also teaching Bible at a Christian college. So that's been fun getting to kind of dive into those things,
SPEAKER_01have more time to spend on those areas, a little bit of a learning curve as well. But excited to be here, love the people, enjoying Denver immensely. So everything's been going really well. That's awesome.
SPEAKER_00Well, that's actually one of the things that I really appreciate about you is that you have that mind of an academic and that you understand the Bible at that academic level, but then you're able to bring it to people and help them to understand Scripture and apply it to their lives and help meet them where they are in the real world. So I really appreciate that about you, and I think that that will help us as we navigate this conversation today. So let's talk about this idea of authorial intent. the intention of the author, the train of thought of the author.
SPEAKER_00As we're talking about how to be better Bible students, anytime we read any sort of book on hermeneutics, on interpreting and understanding Scripture, this is something that's going to come up, is you've got to understand what the author's intention was as he's writing this text. And so why don't you explain a little bit about what authorial intent is and why that's an important topic?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I mean, if we think about reading or interacting with a text, and a text here can be something like the Bible, or it could be something that's purely the product of humans. This is a big question, like deciding about what the Constitution means. But it's also true of other documents or media. It's true of movies. It's true of book series. And when you think about this, there's really three parts to interpreting or reading or watching any sort of text or movie.
SPEAKER_01And that is what the author has done. So what the author intends to do, that's the author. Then you've got the text or the movie itself on its own. And then you've got the people... who interact with it. There's this question of, you know, if a tree falls in the forest does it make a sound? If a text just lies there, if your Bible just sits there and you never read it, then does it do anything? There's all these pieces that play out there. And in conversations about determining meaning, which is really what hermeneutics is,
SPEAKER_01we have to kind of play with those different things. And different people have emphasized different parts of that equation. So for us, we're probably most used to authorial intent. And here we mean specifically the human. You know, if we say, hey, what did Paul mean? That's what it means for us. Other people, you know, people like T.S. Eliot, a lot of the new criticism and poets, they argue that, well, you can't ever know what the author intended. What we have to deal with is just what we have on its own, the text itself. And then, you know, you move forward another hundred years and people say,
SPEAKER_01well, it doesn't mean anything unless I read it, until I interact with it. So we actually has to do with what we do. And so it's this big conversation and it's a fascinating conversation that has a lot of implications in all of our lives. And that's why I think it's so fun to talk about. I think a lot about this recently in questions of determining canon for fictional events. What counts as Star Wars canon? Are we really accepting the sequels? Are we willing to admit that? We know that the company in control of that
SPEAKER_01has said this is what's canon, they've gotten rid of like Thrawn, you know, some of the Extended Universe stuff. But we watch it and we say, I don't know about that. Or how do we feel about J.K. Rowling sort of retroactively changing major aspects of the Harry Potter franchise? We say, no, no, no. I know you're the author and I know you said you meant this all along, but I don't buy it. This is now in the public domain. This text exists on its own. I reject your authorial intent. And those can be fun conversations, but when we come to the Bible, well, now that's a whole other process,
SPEAKER_01whole other business, and has a lot more implications, and that we can sort of need to at least have some sort of basis of agreement to move forward.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. Yeah, I think about a text that comes to mind because it's come up several times in this series is Jeremiah 29, 11, one of the most well-quoted verses. And I think a lot of people today would say, well, what this verse means to me is that God has plans for my life. God has a direct, a very specific plan laid out for my life, and he's going to prosper me and he's not going to harm me. And so they would say what it means for me or what it means to me. And somebody else might argue that,
SPEAKER_00well, we need to we need to stop and ask ourselves, well, what did Jeremiah mean when he wrote these words? It's not really so much about what it means to you as much as what did Jeremiah intend? And I think that, you know, as you I appreciate you applying this to other texts and to other ways of communicating, because I think that we would all expect people to respect ourselves. our authorial intent like if i wrote something down if i wrote a note to my son for
instance if i wrote a note to one of my boys and i said here's what i need you to do and here's all these things and then he said well i interpreted that to mean x y and z and i said no no that's not what i intended that's not what i meant here's
SPEAKER_00what i meant he said i don't care what you meant The way I took it was this, and I'm the audience, and so I get to interpret it however I want to. So does that play into that idea of authorial intent and why we need to respect what the author is trying to say?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, absolutely. And I'm not trying to, and you'll see as we go, I think authorial intent is incredibly important. I just don't think it's the only thing. We've all had conversations, you know, maybe with a spouse, if this happens to be. I had a conversation recently with a really good friend of mine where I hurt their feelings and I did not intend to, but I did. And we've all been part of that conversation. And it's not that it didn't happen. Those words existed. I didn't mean them in that way. But like, if you look at it, you can interpret it either way.
SPEAKER_01Like it was unclear enough that I You can read it according to my intent to not hurt them. And you can read it in order to their intent that they were hurt. And you're like, well, we have this breach then of how these things play out. And I think that it's a little bit complicated. There's a famous sort of introductory hermeneutics book by Gordon Fee and Douglas Stewart called How to Interpret the Bible for All of Its Worth. You may have read it. And there's a paragraph there. I'm not going to quote the whole paragraph. But he's going through and saying there's a lot of confusing things.
SPEAKER_01about hermeneutics, but he says, and this is a quote, but on this one statement, however, there must surely be agreement. A text cannot mean what it could never have meant for its original readers and hearers. That sounds great. I don't think that's true when it comes to the Bible. And because I think we have a lot of examples in the Bible where that isn't true. And although there is part of that that is, I think we're actually cutting off a lot of not only meaning,
but actually denying the authority and meaning of the Scriptures in some ways if we
SPEAKER_01exclusively deal with that.
SPEAKER_00That's interesting. And I really want to get to this second layer of it because, and you've already sort of hinted at this already in saying when we're talking about authorial intent, we're talking about the human authorial intent, implying that there is another author and there's another intention involved here. So we have not only what was the author intending, but we also believe, as Christians, we believe that Scripture is inspired, that the Holy Spirit is active and involved in in the writing of all of these texts that these prophets were
carried along by the
SPEAKER_00Holy Spirit as they wrote, whatever that means exactly. But we believe that God is involved in there. So speak to that for a moment and how that should play into the way that we understand and interpret.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, absolutely. I think that what we see clearly, and this is, I think, most clear in the New Testament, but present even in the Old Testament, is that the human authors are being brought along by the Holy Spirit. And there is a meaning of what they say and what they do that is the human authorial intent. And it is, and we can, and we should ask the question as a first step, what would this audience have heard? Because if the Holy Spirit's inspiration means that they're
providing good communication,
SPEAKER_01then when the human author says, you know, if we kind of pull it into our modern conception, hey, I was driving through Texas and I went through the Big D, if they mean Denton and not Dallas, they need to say that. Because that's not what the original audience is going to hear. But there are times, a lot of times, where the authors are communicating truthfully and we need to read more than what they intended. And that's because the Holy Spirit is not like us.
SPEAKER_01And the audience is not only the original audience, but it's us as well. When Paul writes Philippians, it's not written to us. Neither of us lives in Philippi, neither of us lived 2,000 years ago, neither of us, you know, speak Greek, but it's written for us. And this is what Paul talks about all the time. These are written for your benefit. These are written for your examples, like he says in 1 Corinthians chapter 10. But in that same description, he says, hey, that rock that followed them in the wilderness, that was Jesus.
And I don't know of anybody who reading through Numbers and reading the story about
SPEAKER_01Moses striking the rock without 1 Corinthians would have been like, you know, that's Jesus. That's what Moses intended. He intended us to read this story as about Jesus. But that's clearly what the Holy Spirit intended. Maybe even more clearly is when we read the story in Galatians 3 and 4 about these two women and we read through Genesis. We read Genesis a lot. And most people that I know, when they're teaching through a Genesis class and they're teaching the story of Sarah and Hagar, Don't say, hey, by the way, these aren't really women.
SPEAKER_01These are covenants. One's representative of slavery. The other's representative of freedom. They're really two mountains. And that's what Moses intended when he wrote this story. But it's what God intended. And we have to sort of use our spiritual eyes or to do what Paul says, read allegorically, which is the word he uses there in Galatians there, 424. And that is distinct from what the human author means.
And we have to, I think, not only ask, what does Moses or Paul or Peter or Luke or John mean?
SPEAKER_01We should also ask, but what does the Spirit mean? What does God mean? How are we supposed to read this for ourselves?
SPEAKER_00Yeah. So here's my big question, and I don't know that I gave you a heads up on this specifically, but as you're talking, it really, it's kind of coming to the surface for me to say, okay, well, what are the guardrails then? And I think that I'm good, I'm comfortable saying that this text could be, the metaphor that's coming to my brain is pregnant. This text is pregnant with meaning. And it only is born out when we see Jesus.
SPEAKER_00And then when we see Jesus, we say, oh, that was the seed that was there all along, that this verse, this idea was pregnant with this meaning, and only in Christ does it come to fruition. But I'm afraid that sometimes we actually make our own interpretation inspired. And what we're saying is, well, nobody said that this particular text means X, Y, and Z. There's no proof that the author actually meant for it to mean X, Y, and Z. No proof. no apostle,
SPEAKER_00Jesus himself, did not say that it meant X, Y, and Z. But I think it means X, Y, and Z. And it doesn't really matter whether the author meant that or not, because I'm sure God meant that. And so we take our own understanding, our own interpretation as being inspired, and we read that into the text. And then by doing so, we dismiss not only authorial intent from the author, but we suppose that there is inspired authorial intent, even if we don't have evidence of that.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, absolutely. And we have to be careful about this because, you know, the whole argument about that, you know, Catholicism has dealt with Protestantism. It's like by getting rid of the pope, they've made every person their own pope. Yes, exactly. And we need to be very cautious of that because there can be when we reject some sort of guardrails. And that's what really Fee and Stewart are dealing with is that authorial intent is a guardrail. And that is a guardrail that I think is important and exclusive. I mean, I have studied ancient history and ancient literature a lot so that I can
SPEAKER_01understand authorial intent. That's dedicated enormous amounts of time in there. And a lot of times when we say, well, this is what God meant, what we really mean is that's what I mean. Yeah. And that is a problem. But on the other side, isn't... that what we do when we do application at the end of our sermons? You know, we're like, okay, this is what this means, but here's what I say that it means. And this is, of course, my issue.
SPEAKER_01I was talking to my elders recently and they're like, you know, you need more application in your sermons. And I was like, I don't like application that much in sermons because it feels like I'm imposing my meaning and raising it to the level of scripture that other people are doing. But that's something that we're okay with as long as it's well done. And I think that the answer to some degree is not to do it or not to do it, but to try to do it well. I think a lot about the story in 2 Kings chapter 6.
SPEAKER_01That's the story where Elisha, the prophet, has been kind of annoying the king of Syria by telling everybody where he's at. And the king of Syria is like, oh, well, we're going to go capture Elisha, the prophet. Surely he won't know where we're at. And they get surrounded, and this prophet Gehazi is freaking out because there's all these chariots and horsemen of Syria, and he thinks they're going to die. And Elisha has to say... Those who are with us are more than with those who are with them. And he opens Gehazi's eyes to see that the mountain was covered
with chariots and
SPEAKER_01horsemen of fire. And this idea that there's more going on than we can see with our human eyes is, I think, the same that we can see that there is more going on with scripture than just human authorial intent. When Jesus is speaking after his resurrection on the road to Emmaus, He says he opens their eyes and they can see now and explain to all of Scripture as being about him. Paul says that all Scripture is breathed out by God,
SPEAKER_01you know, profitable for teaching proof and correction and teaching salvation in Jesus, which means that when you're reading Leviticus, And we're reading all these picayune little things that to us feel very sort of nonsensical or trivial. They're teaching salvation. Now, you're not going to get that literally. And I'm not certain that Moses, when he's writing down cleanliness laws, is like, this is about salvation in Jesus. Any more that when he's writing about the flood, he's like,
this is about baptism. Or when he's writing about them going through the Red Sea, he's saying, this is about baptism.
SPEAKER_01But the Spirit did. And we need to read not only according to what the human writer meant and what that audience dealt with, but what God meant and what that means for the church as seen through Jesus and what that means for us as a community, not just as an individual.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. I'm going to read from 1 Peter 1, because this is a text that keeps coming to my mind as I've thought through this, as I've even taught authorial intent. And then I think about what Peter says. He says, searched and inquired carefully, inquiring what person or time the Spirit of Christ in them was indicating when he predicted the sufferings of Christ and the subsequent glories. It was revealed to them, to the prophets, that they were serving not themselves,
but you in the things that have now been announced to you through those who preach
SPEAKER_00the good news to you by the Holy Spirit sent from... by the holy spirit sent from heaven things into which angels long to look so how does that that sort of play into this to me as i read that i think about multiple things i think you know one he doesn't necessarily say that the prophets don't that they don't have any idea what they're talking about. It's totally beyond their comprehension. He's not, I don't think, saying that the Holy Spirit, that the Spirit of Christ sort of robotically controlled them
to write these things down,
SPEAKER_00that there seems to be some intentionality, some authorial intentionality to search these things out, but they can't see all the way to the end of the road. And so there are some things about Jesus, about the Christ, that they are saying that is even beyond their understanding. You know, and as much as I like to emphasize, and I think rightfully so, that Isaiah had a message for the people of his day,
Peter also says that they were serving the people of Peter's day hundreds and
SPEAKER_00hundreds of years down the road. So how does this play into the way that we read Scripture?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, absolutely. And I think that's such an important question because, and there's a lot of reasons why this is such an important question these days. And it's typically an unsurprising little bit of a historical reason. And that is, in the early church, when we're kind of moving into like the third and fourth centuries after Jesus, some church fathers were sort of trying to have this supersessionist idea or this taking over of Judaism, taking over the Old Testament and saying, this is really ours, not yours. And so they go through and say that's not actually what they meant,
SPEAKER_01it's actually and only about Jesus. And so this is going on, and this has a long history and fruit leading almost inevitably, as all things do, into anti-Semitism in the Holocaust, where German academics were saying this isn't what's going on. And after that, and after the Holocaust, and there is the sort of counter-reaction from conservatives who don't let that happen again, that then now emphasizes authorial intent itself. So there are a lot of academics,
SPEAKER_01even Christian ones, and even ones who believe in old inspiration, that will go back to the Old Testament and say, this isn't at all about Jesus. You know, it's not really about a messianic psalm. You know, this is just about the king. It's just what the author meant at that moment. And I appreciate their attempts to sort of push back against anti-Semitism. For those who don't know, I grew up Jewish. I attended the Hebrew Union College Jewish Institute of Religion for my PhD. I think that's a good thing to do. But I think that they've pushed too far.
I think that as Christian readers of Scripture, we should be seeing Jesus and things.
SPEAKER_01When Hosea says, out of Egypt I called my son... He's not talking about a prophecy at all. He's giving a history lesson about what happened to Israel. But Matthew is also right to say, this is about Jesus. And we as Christians who believe in inspiration, who believe in Jesus, should be seeing Jesus more than we do and in more ways than we do. And we should be open to reading typologically or
Christologically or allegorically
SPEAKER_01But we do have to be careful to do it well, and that is more difficult. We're really, really good at sort of book chapter verse reading. That's our training, that's our history, that's our tradition, and that is an enormous benefit. But I think that we need to sort of not see everything as a nail just because we only have a hammer in our toolbox. And asking, even asking the question, does the Spirit mean something else? How does this relate to the church? How does this relate to Jesus is a really good thing,
SPEAKER_01because we have apostolic example of doing that. When the earliest church is being, you know, persecuted, they look to the Psalms and they say, why do the nations rage? Why do the peoples plot in vain? And they don't say, well, this David meant about himself. They say, this is what God meant for us. And I think that opening that up says that all of the Bible is for us, if not written to us, and it's all applicable to our lives. Sometimes we just have to do a little bit more work to figure out how.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. Would you say that we need to—context is a word I always use, and I think that what people mean by context usually is very limited to, you know, what's the verse before and what's the verse after it—but do you think that even our application needs to be kept in context? And what I mean by that is within the context of the story of Jesus, within the story of God and his covenant people— I think so often the reason we need and want to put these guardrails up about authorial intent is because people are trying to apply the text
of the Scripture
SPEAKER_00out of context. So they're trying to make application to this football game, or this job that I'm doing, or my career, or being healthy and wealthy and wise, all of these things. They're applying it to something that is outside of the context of the story of God and his covenant people, if we keep it within that larger context, well, then there is all kinds of meaning and layers of meaning and application for our lives. Absolutely.
SPEAKER_01I think of one that I heard when I was very young, I'd just become a Christian, and it was just the exact thing that you're talking about in sort of this misapplication. He was reading in Proverbs and it says, from him flow the issues of life. And his application from what that meant was, God cares about your problems. Because he had misunderstood that issues of life meant wellsprings and waters of life. And he read issues and said, see, this scripture is about God caring about your problems.
SPEAKER_01And I'm like, that is not what that's about. Now, the point that he talks about is true. God does care about your problems. That is in line with the overall context of scripture. That's the wrong place to go for that. And the same way, on the other hand, it's like when you see therefore, you have to ask what it's there for, so you back up a verse, and that's too limited. We need to kind of maybe see something in between that. I like how you said that if we understand the sort of story about God's covenant and its people, that all of the Bible is about God's desire to dwell with His
people in unity,
SPEAKER_01using the salvific work of Jesus Christ, His Son, to conquer our sins and bring us to Him. then we have a broader context that we need to understand. And we need to sort of be able to move between what does this verse mean in this context? What does it mean within the chapter? What does it mean within the book? What does it mean within the story of God and the scriptures as a whole? And if we see our context in those ways as this, you know, you throw a rock into a still pond and these ripples that go out and the ripples
SPEAKER_01become smaller and less distinct as they go. And we should be more careful the farther that we travel from that initial burst. I don't think that God's Word is limited in the ways that sometimes we think that it is. I think that it is, you know, sharper than any two-edged sword. And that means it can do more than sometimes we allow it to do. And I am concerned sometimes that our restriction, not using it as guardrails,
SPEAKER_01but setting sort of a hard boundary there, is kind of making us act in the same way the Christians did there in Galilee, where Jesus comes to heal them, and he can't because they're not willing to listen. They have so little faith. They're not willing to sort of apply his words to their life. And I think we do need to be equally cautious of that. We don't want to bind what God has inbound, and we don't want to loose what God hasn't loosed. Either one of those.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. So just to kind of catch people up, maybe this might be a totally new subject for a lot of people and they've never really thought about this. So on one end, and you and I know this, you more than me, because I don't swim in those academic circles, but the academic writing and at all layers really dismisses the inspiration piece of it. or that it could be connected to the story of jesus and so if
you're reading isaiah it's simply what did this author mean or authors depending on who you're reading but what did isaiah mean when he's talking to his original audience and really put on very tight guard rails around or boundaries restrictions on what could have
SPEAKER_00isaiah meant On the other end of the spectrum, I'm afraid that there is such a loose interpretation that it becomes whatever you want it to mean, and that the beauty or the meaning is in the eye of the beholder. And then maybe somewhere in the middle is, I think, what we're trying to navigate this path where we're saying, yes, God meant more than Isaiah even realized, that everything Isaiah said, because he was being carried along by the Holy Spirit, was pregnant with meaning that really only came...
SPEAKER_00came to be revealed in the person and the work of Jesus, and that this is where the story was always headed. And kind of keeping everything in that context helps us to understand, yes, it's important to understand what Isaiah meant, but it's also important to understand how all of this was with God's intention leading to Jesus. So with that in mind, you know, and this is the way I try to navigate it. I want to feel free to tell me I'm wrong. But, you know, when I'm reading a passage like Isaiah 53 about the suffering servant,
SPEAKER_00you know, if you read modern scholars, they'll say, well, you know, Isaiah is obviously just talking about Israel and about Israel's suffering and that Israel is the servant of God who is suffering and through that suffering is God is going to bring about redemption. Now, if you read a lot of Christians, They would say, well, obviously this is a prediction about Jesus, and Isaiah is just predicting Jesus. This couldn't have meant anything to them because they didn't even know what a cross was or crucifixion was.
SPEAKER_00And obviously Jesus is being predicted here in this text. And I want to say, well... you're sort of both wrong and you're both right. You know, is he talking about Israel? Yes. And is he talking about the Messiah? Yes. It's really both of those meanings are found in there, you know, and Jesus is the fulfillment of that. So is that sort of the way we would tackle a lot of what we find in the Old Testament?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, absolutely. And I think that we have to recognize that God can mean more than one thing at once. Yeah. And this is sort of a difficulty because in our tradition there have been some pretty influential books about prophecy that are trying to use prophecy in an apologetic sense primarily to say this has to mean about Jesus and this idea that prophecy only ever has one fulfillment. So we might think of Isaiah 714, which is, in our texts, a virgin will give birth to a son,
SPEAKER_01if you're reading like the New American Standard, or a young woman will give birth to a son, we'll call him Emmanuel. And there was an enormous warfare over how to translate this verse. If you go back and look at the history of translations, like this is why we have the New Revised Standard versus the New American Standard, was because of this one verse. And when you read that story, it seems very clear that Isaiah is talking about someone who's about to be born, and that's going to resolve the, you know, Syro-Ephramite War.
And so if you don't believe inspiration, you're like, it's only ever talking about that kid. But if you are sort of concerned that prophecy is the way that you prove Jesus's existence,
SPEAKER_01then it has to only be about Jesus. This is the same thing you're talking about. Why not both? When we're reading through the story of Daniel and the coming of the kingdoms or the destruction, you know, in Daniel 7, it's like that's talking about the Maccabean revolt. It's also talking about Rome and God's ambiguity there is purposeful. There is a reason that Alma in Hebrew can mean virgin or can mean young woman.
SPEAKER_01That is not an accident. God has chosen this in a way that it can be more things than once. Now it would be a wrong application for some to say, see Isaiah 714, that's about me. I definitely didn't fool around and that's why I'm pregnant. That's not what it's saying. That would be an incorrect application. But we don't want to cut down or destroy or eliminate the full meaning of Scripture, which is that very clearly what God and the Spirit meant for Isaiah was, and Isaiah meant, is this particular human birth,
SPEAKER_01but what the Spirit and God also meant, and what Isaiah maybe glimpsed a little bit, had an inkling, could see, you know, through a keel dimly. or in a mirror dimly, I guess, mixing metaphors there, is that maybe this is about something else that's coming on. You know, John the Baptist knows who Jesus is. He sees the Spirit descend on him, but he still doesn't understand everything about that. And that's why he sends his disciples to say, hey, are you really the Messiah or should we look for someone else? You know, Mary, we're out of season for this,
SPEAKER_01but Mary did know something about Jesus, but she also doesn't know everything about it. These are things prophets and even angels longed to look. And God knows what he's doing. And sometimes we might have hope of that, even if we can't see it clearly.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, yeah, absolutely. I think that's really beautifully said. And I think that once you know the story that you're a part of, And I like to use the phrase or the framework of a cruciform way of reading Scripture, you know, reading through the cross, that once you know that this is the story we're a part of, that this is the way God operates, this is who God is, this is the sort of thing that God does to rescue his people— and you read everything through that lens,
then you read back through the Old Testament.
SPEAKER_00It's hard not to see echoes of the cross, pre-echoes of the cross in everything, in Joseph, even in Samson. You read all of these things, and you're like, oh, well, even when you don't have the apostles saying, hey, this is a fulfillment of this, this is a fulfillment of that, and I don't know that When Matthew says fulfillment of, I don't know that he means it was a prediction and Jesus fulfilled that prediction. He's just saying this is the fullness of that. This is what it looks like when the truth of this really comes to bear.
And so I like to tell people all the time when you're reading Isaiah 7, this is a sign.
SPEAKER_00It was a sign to Ahaz that God is with you. Emmanuel, God is with you and you're going to win. You're not going to lose. This isn't going to defeat you. And that was a sign that God is with you. And then Matthew says, yeah, that was a sign that God was with them. But now God is with us. And look at this even more full, full fulfillment of these words that now a virgin literally has conceived and is giving birth to a son. And this really is God with us.
SPEAKER_00I like to talk in terms of limited and ultimate fulfillment. This is true in a limited sense, but Jesus is this come to fruition in the fullest sense, in the ultimate sense. And I just don't know how you don't see those echoes or those foreshadowing. Yeah.
SPEAKER_01in the Old Testament Scriptures. Well, and I think we can push it even further because I don't think that the virgin birth of Jesus on earth is even the ultimate fulfillment of that. I think that we see this idea of God with us. Well, God was with them then, and God was with them in Jesus, but it's looking forward to another birth. You know, if we look forward to Revelation and this woman as the church giving birth to us, and God will be with them in the new heavens and the new earth, that's the ultimate fulfillment. is what is still yet to come. We are still like that woman groaning,
SPEAKER_01waiting for childbirth, waiting for the things yet to come. And as wonderful and amazing that we have now with the Spirit in us and the church and the kingdom which has come, there still lies a kingdom to come, a further fulfillment of God with us, a further fulfillment of this promise that those powers that are arrayed against us, that were arrayed against Ahaz, that were arrayed against the other church, that are still arrayed against us, they'll be defeated. And that sort of, if we want to say it, then that triple fulfillment of this fulfillment in the past,
SPEAKER_01this fulfillment in Jesus, is looking forward to and still applies to us because there is more to come. God's story isn't done. He's written the ending. But we haven't gotten there yet. And so all of these are still relevant and applicable to us because they're all still looking forward to something more of Emmanuel, something more of God with us that, you know, there will be no sun because God is their light and he will shine on them. And so there's still more.
SPEAKER_00There's still more that we can read this through God's Spirit. You know, one of the phrases that scholars use a lot now is already but not yet. And I love that phrase. And I think that that's a fantastic way to read the New Testament. But it wasn't until this conversation just now, as you were saying those things, that I thought, you know, that that's true of so much of Scripture, that as you're reading Isaiah or you're reading Jeremiah or you're reading whatever, there's the already but not yet. Like, you Yes. Does this does this apply? Does this prophecy apply to the exiles going back to Jerusalem?
SPEAKER_00Yes. Yes. And so there is an already fulfillment of that, but not yet, because Jesus hasn't yet come. And that is an ultimate fulfillment, but not even, as you said, not even the ultimate fulfillment. And so there is an already fulfillment. Maybe it's the return from exile. Maybe it's, you know, whatever. And then the not yet that is Jesus. But even in that, there's an already the church, what we're experiencing right now, salvation and redemption, and even in a sense, glorification. Mm-hmm. But there's a not yet to that.
SPEAKER_00So there's layers to everything that God says. And so when the prophets say, God has plans for you, like, yes, that has fulfillment in the exiles going back to Jerusalem, but it has an even greater fulfillment in the plans that God had for the Jewish people in the coming of the Messiah. And it has fulfillment in you and me coming as a Jew and a Gentile, part of this kingdom. And then there's the not yet of the age to come that we're all
still waiting for. And so I think you're right that we so often limit what Scripture can mean to one thing when really there's all of these layers of ultimate and even more ultimate meaning.
SPEAKER_01Right, and I think that almost everything is like that. I can't say everything, you know, I'm hesitant to use always, never, sort of language. And you see that same sort of thing, like if you're talking even again just for that, like how does Peter refer to us but as exiles? So we are still in exile waiting for the consummation. You know, Hebrews says there remains a land of rest for us. We're still wandering in the wilderness, you know, and it's like, well, but also we're not. There's a reason that for Paul salvation is present and for
Peter salvation is
SPEAKER_01future because it is already and not yet. And I think that is true of enormous elements because Jesus coming as a human in flesh, fully human, fully divine, is not the end of the story. And God has always intended us to be part of this story. And we know the ending and we're trying to get there. We're doing everything we can. And so God does have plans for you. Maybe that doesn't mean that his plan for you was that,
SPEAKER_01you know, you may get to this job interview so he turned that red light green or he gave you that parking spot. Maybe he did. He can, right? And I'm not going to say he couldn't or he didn't. But those plans are so much more eschatological for us, just as they were for the Israelites, just as they were for the church. His plans are bigger than we are, and we want to find ourselves as a part of that plan. So is that verse about them? Yeah. Is it about us? Yeah. Is it about Jesus?
SPEAKER_01Yeah. So our application and our sort of hermeneutic shouldn't just be, well, it can't be about us because that's not what the author intended, but it should instead be, what does that mean for me if God has plans for me? Like, what do I do with it? What did they do with that? Maybe what they did with it can be a guide for us of what we should do with it ourselves.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. Man, I love that, Jared. I'm almost hesitant to bring up this next subject because I like where we are right now. I like this because this is about Jesus. And you've even used the word eschatological. I mean, the eschatology of it, the kingdom that is and that is yet to come. And so I think that is where we need to live when we think about both the author's intention and God's sort of concealed intention. But I think sometimes, and you use the phrase apologetics,
and sometimes we're so desperate to sort of prove the truthfulness of Scripture,
SPEAKER_00the reliability of Scripture, that we use it and we say, well, see, like these authors had this, even though they didn't know that they had scientific foreknowledge or this understanding about science and the way the world works. And so there's this tendency to interpret Scripture. In fact, I was reading on a website this morning, and they were talking about the water of purification. And this author of this apologetic website said, "...the recipe for the water of purification stands today as a
wonderful example of
SPEAKER_00the Bible's brilliance, since the recipe is nothing less than a procedure to produce an antibacterial soap." So there's this tendency to read the Bible and say, you know, see, this is how we know that it's inspired, because all of these things are scientifically accurate, and they've proven even thousands of years before we discovered them scientifically that the Bible is reliable— But I think that that tends to be like a pick and choose of what verses we want to
SPEAKER_00read that way and what verses we don't want to read that way. So is there a problem with that? Is authorial intent a way to guard against that sort of reading of Scripture, or should we guard against that reading of Scripture? I would say that authorial intent is a very useful way to guard against that. But I think that instead of using authorial intent to invalidate that entirely,
SPEAKER_01just say those are bad readings of Scripture. Well motivated. understandable, good people doing them, but they don't read scripture as its broader entire context. So we'll say, well, God hung earth on a string that is scientific foreknowledge that the earth is floating. Well, I say, well, first of all, that's poetry and you know it because you don't think God's literally hanging the world on a string. So we're already being a little loosey-goosey with our interpretation, but also the Bible says he founded it on pillars.
SPEAKER_01And so contextual reading, whether authorial intent or the broad scope of Scripture, which is recognizing that God does not intend the Scripture to be a scientific textbook, but the story of his desire to save us, to live with us, that'll guard against that. And that doesn't require authorial intent. That just requires careful reading. But there's a lot of these places. You mentioned a few of them. You know, think about that antibacterial soap. One of my favorites is people, this happens a lot with Leviticus because we don't know how to read law. We don't know how to read it about salvation,
so we have to read about practicum. They'll say, well, the laws against eating pork are to guard against criconella.
SPEAKER_01We say salmonella, but I had a virologist very stringently tell me it's criconella, not salmonella. And I say, okay, does that make sense in the scope of Scripture? Does God simply not care about his people after Acts 10 and Acts 15 and Romans 14? It's like, well, you all have been dunked now. You can die of cricketing all you want, you know. Well, no, they had discovered refrigeration. They don't know germ theory by the time of Acts. So that better, broader reading of the context of Scripture should help us realize maybe the authors mean something else here.
SPEAKER_01Maybe there's something else going on. People will talk about, you know, and this also guards us against the tax on Christianity. When people, a most common sort of thing is like, yeah, I know the Bible says this or this or that about homosexuality, but it also doesn't like polyester. So we can just throw the whole thing out. Well, I don't think God's description about not mixing two types of seed is about the dangers of microplastics, but is instead trying to reflect the created order where everything is according to its kind.
SPEAKER_01That theological reading, reading it about the Spirit's work and not purely as the authorial intent, helps us guard against not only our own mistakes, who has not been on the Daniel diet, throw the first stone, whoever's not bought a loaf of Ezekiel bread, which I'm convinced is not authentic recipe, not typically cooked over poop, is not doing that, but it also defends us against attacks from outside. We can say this isn't about polyester, this isn't about George Washington Carver's seed theory and
getting the best
SPEAKER_01agricultural product, it's about reflecting the order of creation in our daily lives. And so once we move outside of authorial intent, once we move outside of trying to use the Bible and apologetics, which is a defense and should be a shield, but we like to use it as a sword to kind of prove something, then we're not only sort of aligning ourselves more with the Scripture, but we're aligning ourselves more with God. And like what you were talking about,
SPEAKER_01you're like, oh, wow, I hadn't thought about it this way, that's already not yet still applying to us. Well, now all of a sudden Leviticus applies to us. And wow, what an enormous gift that is. Because how many people read through the law, read through Leviticus, read through so many parts of the Old Testament and think, well, this is nailed to the cross. It doesn't have anything to do with me. We're trying to reclaim the fullness of scripture because God wants us to be part of that story. It does apply to us. And that means we have to learn how to read it better. And that is not purely through authorial intent.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. Oh, that's really good, Jared. Thank you. Let me ask you this final question. This is what I'm asking all of the people that are part of this series. If you could give Christians one piece of advice, or even non-Christians, if you could give people one piece of advice on how to become a better Bible student, what advice would you give them?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, this was both very simple, but also difficult to do. And that is, ask when you're reading Scripture, what if I'm wrong? What if I'm wrong? I'm teaching through Matthew here at Smokey Hill, and one of the things that constantly surprises me and terrifies me a little bit about the Gospels is everybody thinks that they know what Jesus is saying. The apostles think they know what Jesus is saying. And because they are so certain that they are right about an ethnic Jewish kingdom, they are so certain they're right about a conquering, glorified,
SPEAKER_01warlike, earthly messiah, and they're so certain that that means that they should be worldly power, sitting, you know, at Jesus' right and left hand, they don't ever actually hear what he's saying. which is speaking about a crucified, conquered Messiah, speaking about a multi-ethnic kingdom that is spiritual, and speaking about disciples who follow Jesus to a cross and not to a crown, at least not yet. Ask yourself, what if I'm wrong?
SPEAKER_01That doesn't mean you are. It doesn't mean that you have to be. It doesn't mean we should reject what we have been given as part of our tradition or part of our church family or part of our prior reading or our parents or anything else. But we should ask and be willing to ask and be willing to consider, what if I'm wrong? Because it'll be amazing what you will see when you say, can I read this a different way? Even if you return to how you had it the first time.
SPEAKER_00Well, that's good. Jared, thank you for this conversation. It was so good to reconnect with you. I appreciate your spirit. I appreciate your generosity with your time and your work in the kingdom, brother. Thank you so much, Wes. I've always enjoyed chatting with you. It's been great. Thank you so much for listening to the Radically Christian Bible Study podcast. If you have just a moment, we would love for you to rate and review this podcast on iTunes or wherever you're listening. It really does help more people discover this content. I also want to thank the guests who join me each week,
SPEAKER_00Beth Tabor, who volunteers her time to transcribe the podcast, and our whole McDermott Road Church family who make it possible for us to provide this Bible study for you. Now, let's all go out and love like Jesus.
The Spirit is often the member of the Godhead we talk about least, and when we do, He can feel more like a doctrine to manage than a Person to know. In this conversation from the 412 Christian Podcast, Wes joins hosts...
What if the vocabulary you inherited for salvation has left you more anxious than assured? Justification, sanctification, saved: many believers learned these words as tidy categories, and many sincere Christians still...
What does it actually mean to be baptized in the Holy Spirit? For many who grew up in the Restoration Movement, the phrase meant a debate about water baptism or a defensive argument about miraculous gifts, and then the...
If we’re saved by grace through faith, why does baptism still matter? An elder in Tennessee wrote in with a question many Christians are asking. If love is the heart of everything, is baptism just a ritual tacked on, a...
Is gluttony only about what is on your plate? Most of us assume we know the answer, and most of us feel a little uncomfortable when the subject comes up. The Bible mentions gluttony far less than many Christians expect,...