Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Radically Christian

Radically Christian artwork

Cognitive Dissonance and Discipleship

Oct 23, 202457 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Do you ever find yourself clinging to ideas or behaviors that don't match your faith? In this episode of the Radically Christian Bible Study Podcast, Wes McAdams and Brandon Britton discuss cognitive dissonance - why we often feel uncomfortable, or even angry, when we learn something that contradicts what we already believe, or when our actions don’t align with what we claim to believe. How does this internal struggle affect our spiritual journey and how can we overcome these mental barriers as we seek to follow Jesus more faithfully? Throughout the episode, Wes and Brandon explore biblical concepts related to discipleship and the importance of being willing to change. We dig into Scripture to see how biblical characters - like Jesus' own disciples - struggled with new ideas that challenged their preconceived notions about the Messiah and God’s plan. We also discuss how embracing humility and letting go of our biases can lead us toward deeper spiritual growth and alignment with Christ's teachings. This episode features Brandon Britton, who has been a guest on the podcast several times before. Brandon brings years of experience in ministry and a deep love for exploring how Christian disciplines shape us into the image of Jesus. His insights on how our minds and hearts wrestle with change will leave you reflecting on your own journey as a disciple of Christ. Links and Resources: * Freed-Hardeman University (fhu.edu/radicallychristian) * Benefit of the Doubt by Greg Boyd (https://amzn.to/3NA4VG8) * The Righteous Mind by Jonathan Haidt (https://amzn.to/4eZsGn5) * Logos Bible Software - 30 Day Free Trial (https://logos.sjv.io/GmAdQk) * VidAngel - Free Trial (https://vidangel.pxf.io/DKPWPy) Note: Some links are affiliate links. Meaning, if you choose to buy something through these links, we receive a small commission at no extra cost to you. This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit www.radicallychristian.com

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_00Welcome to the Radically Christian Bible Study Podcast. I'm your host, Wes McAdams. Here we have one goal, learn to love like Jesus. Have you ever wondered why we feel so uncomfortable, even angry, when we hear something that contradicts what we believe? How about when someone points out that our own behaviors are inconsistent with what we say we believe? Why do we feel the way we do? Why do we react the way we do when we hear these kinds of things? Could it be that we're experiencing cognitive dissonance?

SPEAKER_00Today I'm joined by my friend Brandon Britton, who's been on the podcast several times before, and we're continuing our series on discipleship by talking about cognitive dissonance and how that sometimes impacts our efforts to be disciples of Jesus. But before we get to that conversation, I want to share a brief message from our sponsor, Freed Hardeman University. If you're an avid listener to this podcast, then you probably know that we've been promoting a free webinar hosted by the Fried Hardeman University Graduate School of Theology entitled Merging Ministry with

SPEAKER_00Mental Health. That webinar has already happened, but if you're a minister and you're looking to better address the mental health needs of your congregation, then look no further than Fried Hardeman University's Master of Arts in Pastoral Care and Counseling program. This 100% online program provides you with the tools to address mental health challenges within a Christian context, blending theology with practical counseling skills. With live web conference classes, you can deepen your ministry without leaving your current role.

SPEAKER_00And with scholarships available, you don't have to break the bank to better yourself. Elevate your ministry today with Freed Hardeman University's Master's in Pastoral Care and Counseling. To learn more, simply go to fhu.edu slash radicallychristian. That's fhu.edu slash radicallychristian. And now my conversation with Brandon Britton. Brandon Britton, welcome back to the podcast, brother. Well, thank you. I'm glad to be back, Wes. I always love being with you. Yeah, I always love having you.

SPEAKER_00You're one of my favorite people that has been on the podcast several times. And I just love the way that you think and the way that you challenge me. And I know that this conversation that we're going to have right now is going to be no different. I know that it's going to be challenging for me and for those that are listening and hopefully give us some, you used the word before we started recording, you used the word language. I hope that what this does is give us some language to understand what we sometimes experience and what other people sometimes may be experiencing as well. But before we even get into that,

SPEAKER_00I really want to start with this conversation about discipleship, because that's the series that we're doing right now. And I'm asking everybody that's coming on as a part of this series to define discipleship in their own words. So what would you say? How would you phrase what it means to be a disciple?

SPEAKER_01Okay, so for me, I think I tend to focus on the discipline aspect of the word, you know, that you kind of see in the word disciple. And so in that context, I think of it as like the disciplines that we have to practice in order to learn to become like Jesus. And what I would put in that category of disciplines would be things like prayer, fasting, worship, study, benevolence, service, being a part of a community.

SPEAKER_01Those are things that I think that we have to actively engage in regularly today. To help mold and shape us to be like Jesus. And that's what the goal of discipleship is, obviously, is to become like Jesus. So I think I kind of focus on the discipline part of it because it's not just something that's going to happen. It's something that has to be pursued. And there are avenues of things that we can do. that help us to shape those muscles, if you will, those spiritual muscles to become like Jesus.

SPEAKER_01So I think of it very much about the disciplines of doing the things that Jesus did regularly that made him who he was and can help us become more like him as we practice those.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, I love that. I love that. That's so good. I think we may come back to some of that later. But let's talk about this idea of cognitive dissonance, what that is. That might be a new term for people. Maybe people have heard that term thrown around before and not really understood what it was, or maybe people are really familiar with the term. I don't know. But what is cognitive dissonance, and then how does it relate to discipleship and being disciples of Jesus? OK,

SPEAKER_01well, one thing I wanted to give is kind of a disclaimer right up front, and that is I don't have any degrees or formal training in psychology or anything like that. So what I'm talking about, I'm not speaking about it from like an expert perspective. I'm just a regular person who has brushed up against these things and learned from them. And I found them very valuable in my own discipleship. So I wanted to share those. And I've tried to do that in the congregations I've worked with is share those things with other people, because once we understand them, I think it gives us some tools to deal with difficult things that become obstacles.

SPEAKER_01of being a disciple, things that naturally get in our way and how we can kind of dismantle those. So I just kind of wanted to start with that up front. Now, that being said, I'll just give you the simplest way. Probably the easiest thing to do is just Google it. You'll get a lot of different definitions. And psychology today, this is the way they would define it, cognitive dissonance. It's the discomfort that you feel when you try to hold two opposing opinions in your mind.

SPEAKER_01And it could be two conflicting ideas, or it could be an idea that you hold, maybe a core value that you hold, but what is in conflict with that is maybe your lifestyle or your behavior, your beliefs and your actions aren't lined up. Or it could also just refer to two beliefs that you're trying to wrestle with in your mind. And it creates this discomfort, this dissatisfaction in us. We become kind of mentally unstable in that, well, wait a minute.

SPEAKER_01If this, then how about that? And so the whole idea is that discomfort motivates us to try to reduce the discomfort. And if you don't mind, I want to introduce another phrase here that kind of, tags along with the cognitive dissonance. And that's this phrase confirmation bias. And these things often work hand in hand. So you would experience confirmation bias. You have something that you genuinely strongly believe and hold to be true.

SPEAKER_01And then someone presents to you or some scenario happens that contradicts something that you hold strongly to be true. And it makes you very uncomfortable, uneasy. And sometimes what we then do to try to deal with that, try to reduce that discomfort is where confirmation bias comes in. Confirmation bias is our tendency to seek out information that will reaffirm what we already believe and discredit this new information that is causing this discomfort.

SPEAKER_01So rather than doing the difficult task of changing our contradictory beliefs or the contradiction between our beliefs and our actions, sometimes what we do is we seek to confirm what we already believe, and that's lethal to our discipleship efforts. Because to be a disciple means when I encounter things in my life, whether it's things I believe or actions that are in conflict with the teachings of Jesus,

SPEAKER_01then I'm going to have to change. I'm going to have to let some things go or adopt some new things. And confirmation bias can work for us or against us. It can motivate us to change, or it can become something that prevents us from being willing to consider new information. So I know that's maybe a little bit of a muddy way of describing it, But everybody's experienced it's when you believe something strongly and then

SPEAKER_01someone shows you something that contradicts it and your brain just kind of goes like that. You don't really know what to do with it. Now, let me throw this in. Something that I learned I thought was interesting. It seems that the part of the brain that is responsible for this, this is going to sound really weird in a Bible podcast because we're kind of like, okay, now we're talking about biology. But we have a part of our brain that it's the part of the brain that usually gets called the lizard brain or the reptile brain. And People usually mean by that it's mostly just pure instinct.

SPEAKER_01It's not logic and reason. It's just action. It's the amygdala. And it's the part where the fight or flight mechanism comes from. So you get this information that is contradictory to this strongly held belief. And so your body immediately responds by releasing cortisol into your bloodstream and you get into that fight or flight pose. And that's a natural instinct. I mean, it's not bad. God designed it. It has its benefits. But it can be an impediment to our discipleship if we can't move past that fight or

SPEAKER_01flight impulse and get into the realm of like the prefrontal cortex part where you're thinking, where your logic and your reason comes in and you begin to work through and kind of solve some things. That's where the tricky part comes in, in trying to deal with this and be a disciple. You're having to kind of fight against your biological impulses a little bit in order to get to a point where you can reason and think and not let your emotion or

SPEAKER_01your reaction just kind of cloud your thinking.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, that's so good. I was thinking about something that I heard. I think it was Jonathan Haidt that brought this out, that when we are trying to quote unquote research something and it's something that we want to believe, we ask ourselves the question, can I believe this? And we will search for information that that even if it's just a tiny little bit of information, and we found one other guy that lives in Podunk, USA, and he says the same thing as me,

SPEAKER_00and it's like, oh, see, I'm not the only one, therefore I can believe this. And then on the other hand, if we don't want to believe something, we hear something we don't want to believe, then we'll do, quote unquote, our research on it. And the question that we're asking is, must I believe this? Do I have to believe that this is true? And if we find anything, again, it's some guy sitting in his basement or his parents' basement, and he's put on the internet that that's not true. Well, I don't have to believe it because that guy says that it's not true. And so, again, back to your point about confirmation bias.

SPEAKER_00And I think this happens It happens with me. I mean, I do this. I know that I do this. I will have a strongly held belief. I will preach on it. And then I will hear some pushback to that. I'll hear somebody say, well, that actually isn't true or this other thing is true. I'll be reading a commentary, some brilliant theologian, and they'll say, well, actually, this is the way things are. And I think, well, wait a second. You know, was I wrong? And then I don't want to think I was wrong. And so I will go and try to find something that someone said somewhere that agrees

SPEAKER_00with me and is like, see, I don't have to believe that this guy knows what he's talking about, because me and Joe Schmo over here, we believe that this other thing is the way that it is. And so that is it is a strong motivation to confirm what we already believe and to dismiss anything that we don't believe.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. And I think it's important to say when we're talking about this, this is not about being a good person, a bad person, an honest person. This is just about being a person. This happens to us as human beings. It's part of our God designed us this way. It has benefits. But most I mean, there are a lot of natural impulses that God has given us. that we have to make a choice. We can either obey them mindlessly and become slaves to them, or we can learn how to use them in the way that God intended them. And I'm thinking about things like hunger, thirst, sexual desire, sleep, being tired.

SPEAKER_01These are all natural impulses that God created us with. But if you give yourself over to be a slave to those impulses, it will destroy your life. You have to learn how to navigate those things in a way that is proper and healthy and within the framework that God created them to serve a purpose. And I would put this in that same category. Every one of us instinctively push back when we hear something that contradicts

SPEAKER_01something that we strongly believe. All of us do it. You're not going to get around that. And it has a purpose, but you can't become enslaved to it either because then you're letting you're letting the impulse be in the driver's seat rather than being kind of an aid that God has given you to kind of to navigate and guide difficult things in life. So I think that's really important for us to understand, because I think people I think that if we don't make it clear that this is not about being a good person or an honest person.

SPEAKER_01People will assume, well, wait a minute, I'm a good person. I wouldn't do that. No, good people do this. Again, it's an involuntary response that your body, that your mind produces. And that's OK. We just have to be aware of it because our feelings don't dictate truth. Our feelings don't determine whether or not something is right or wrong. And I always reflect back to the story when Jacob was presented with the evidence

SPEAKER_01that Joseph had been been killed, perhaps by a wild animal. Here's here's the bloody shredded coat. His assumption, his instinct, everything within him told him that his son had been killed. He'd never see his son again. All his emotions, his grief, the pain, all of that, all of that was real, but none of it was true. And of course, it took quite a bit for him to believe otherwise. You know, he had to even when his sons come back and tell him, no, Joseph's alive.

SPEAKER_01You know, it was hard for him to accept that. And of course, he eventually gets to see his son. And it's kind of hard to deny at that point. But this is just something that we do. It's not indicative of whether or not we're good or honest or anything like that. It's just something that we need to be aware of so that because we're trying to be good and honest people. We don't allow these natural impulses to derail our discipleship efforts. Because ultimately the goal is to go where Jesus goes. To follow where Scripture leads.

SPEAKER_01That's the goal. Knowing that I do it imperfectly, though sincerely. And if I'm aware of this... This natural impulse that I'm going to have to push back, which, by the way, is not a bad thing because it prevents us from being tossed to and fro with every wind of doctrine. So it has a value, but we also have to be careful that we don't allow it to become an obstacle. that causes us to kind of dig our feet into the trenches here and refuse to budge,

SPEAKER_01even when presented with overwhelming evidence to the contrary. We don't want to remain blinded. And we don't want to just seek to confirm what we already believe. Like you said, in the information age or the disinformation age, you don't have to go very far. You can find somebody to reinforce practically anything that you believe. um but that's not our goal our goal is to know what is god saying what is god

SPEAKER_01directing what is god wanting and how do i align with that not who can i find you know to back me up because we can all find that if that's if that's what our goal is yeah

SPEAKER_00I think about one of the phrases that you find in scripture oftentimes. And in fact, it was the idea that prompted our conversation was the idea of being self-deceived. Don't deceive yourselves. And how easy that is to deceive ourselves. And I think that's exactly the sort of thing that we now call cognitive dissonance is that we deceive, we're uncomfortable or rather confirmation bias. We're uncomfortable with the fact that I'm being presented with information that convicts me, it challenges me, it hurts me.

SPEAKER_00And so I'm being confronted with this information. And what would be easiest is to just dismiss that information as not true. What would be easiest is just find a way that I can reconcile or I can alleviate that pain that I'm experiencing. experiencing. And I think about what James says in the beginning of his letter. He says to be quick to listen, slow to speak and slow to become angry. And then he goes on to talk about the implanted word, which is able to save your souls. And I think I think that's the type of anger he's talking about is the anger that

SPEAKER_00is produced when we hear something that challenges us, that contradicts something that we believe or contradicts something that we're doing. And our tendency is going to be to stick our fingers in our ear and say, I'm not listening to that. And to come up with a reason and state a reason, speak why we don't have to believe that and get mad at the person who told us. And James encourages people, don't do that. Be quick to listen, slow to speak, slow to become angry and receive the implanted word, which is able to save your souls.

SPEAKER_01And Wes, I really think that it's especially powerful, this vulnerability is especially powerful in communities where being right is tantamount to being saved. If I believe that my standing with God is contingent upon my, quote, rightness on something I believe, not just something I believe really with everything. If I believe that my standing with God is contingent upon me being right and about everything that I believe,

SPEAKER_01it's nearly impossible for me to even entertain conflicting information. Because to entertain conflicting information is to flirt with the idea that maybe I'm wrong about something. And in that mindset, to be wrong is to be lost. to say that i believe this and i was wrong is to say well i believe something that wasn't true and and i was lost because of that which brings in the new added fear

SPEAKER_01of well what else might i be wrong about and if i'm wrong about that am i now lost because i'm wrong about that so in how There's a great book out there Greg Boyd wrote called Benefit of the Doubt. I know you mentioned Jonathan Haidt a moment ago. I think you were probably referencing The Righteous Mind. That book really helped me from the, I guess you would say, scientific aspect of understanding this topic. But Greg Boyd's benefit of the doubt helped me to understand it from the I guess

SPEAKER_01you'd say the theological aspect of it. He also grew up in what would be kind of considered that some would consider maybe this terminology they would use as fundamentalist type of beliefs. And that if you're wrong about something, then then you're wrong with God. And I know that none of us would speak so, you know, crassly as like to believe, well, you've got to be right about everything all the time or you're lost.

SPEAKER_01I know nobody really believes that, but sometimes we we almost do. And so that mindset and he portrays his own struggles in that of how it it becomes almost impossible to. To learn anything new, because to learn something new is to accept that you were wrong, and to accept that you were wrong is to flirt with, well, I was not right with God or I was lost. And you want to talk about somebody putting up a fight for accepting new information,

SPEAKER_01let them think that it has to do with whether or not they're going to be right with God. And suddenly we're dealing more than just cognitive dissonance here. I mean, you're in a fight for your soul, so to speak. And just to kind of illustrate how powerful and dangerous that can become, I don't think we have to look any further than just the New Testament when Jesus comes on the scene. There was a very clear picture in the first century of what Messiah was going to look like.

SPEAKER_01And he was going to be, of course, you know, the son of David. And the assumptions then, of course, were he's going to be a warrior king just like David. He's going to drive out the enemies just like David. Of course, you bring in the messianic picture from the Maccabean period where you have the Maccabees who are fighting and driving out the enemies of the Israelites. And when Jesus shows up on the scene, everybody knows what Messiah is going to do. He's going to be a warrior and he's going to kill the Romans and he's going to run the Herods off the throne and he's going to reclaim Israel.

SPEAKER_01And he's, you know, that's what he's going to do. And then you have this Jesus guy show up and he's saying things like, love your enemies and do good to them that hate you. Turn the other cheek, go the extra mile. And that, I mean, right there, cognitive dissonance right there. We know what Messiah is going to be like. And then Jesus is saying, no, this is what Messiah is like. And he would even show them from their own scriptures. He would go back and pull from Isaiah and these images of what the king was going to be like.

SPEAKER_01But they were so in conflict with what was the commonly held belief about what the Messiah was going to be and what the Messiah was going to do that they had no choice but I don't mean that in the literal sense. I'm talking about in their cognitive dissonance. They had no choice but to reject him because they could not make these two things line up. The pieces didn't fit. This is what Messiah is. And yet this one who is claiming to be Messiah is none of those things.

SPEAKER_01And they rejected him and they couldn't see that he was literally the embodiment of their scriptures. He was the fulfillment of all of these things. But they couldn't see it to the point that they were willing to murder him even though he was tried and found innocent of no crimes. So if you want a picture of how powerful cognitive dissonance can be and how dangerous it potentially can be,

SPEAKER_01you know, look no further than the way that he came into his own and his own received him not. That to me is the ultimate picture of why this is important for a disciple today. And if I can go a step further, even his own disciples even wrestled with this. I preached through the book of Mark a couple of years back and. I don't know if I'd never noticed this, and it just kind of blew me away.

SPEAKER_01In the book of Mark, Jesus literally, on three separate occasions, directly tells his disciples face to face. Now, I'm talking about the 12 here. That I'm going to be betrayed by one of you. I'm going to be arrested. I'm going to be killed. But I'll be raised again. He tells them this three straight times. And they never hear it. Just, they can't hear it. In fact, on one occasion, they're debating with each other, like, what is he talking about?

SPEAKER_01You know, how much more plainly can he say that? And I found myself as I was reading this text, I'm like, you literally can't say it any more plainly than he just said it. And yet they still couldn't hear it. And now I understand why. Cognitive dissonance. In their mind, there was no way. that the Messiah was going to come and be betrayed by one of his own and be arrested and killed. That goes against everything they believe about the Messiah. So even those who embraced Jesus had a hard time accepting who Jesus was,

SPEAKER_01what he came to do, what was going to happen, even when he told them just plain as day that it was going to happen. Now add to that, and this is the even, if you really want to see how hard it is to overcome this, After the resurrection, you get the women come and testify that Jesus was resurrected. Thomas is literally looking at the resurrected Christ and still doesn't believe.

SPEAKER_01and and then you have the the two who are on the road to emmaus who are with him and don't realize it's him and then when they come back and tell the the others that they've been with him they don't believe it so they're they're denying their closest inner circle who has actually seen jesus they're still denying that he's raised from the dead despite that testimony despite that power of testimony so That portrays how hard it can be to even consider anything that contradicts

SPEAKER_01something that you strongly believe. So that's what we're up against sometimes when we're talking about how to overcome this in our pursuit of being disciples of Jesus. Well,

SPEAKER_00I watched a video earlier on cognitive dissonance because, you know, it's the internet and you can find whatever information that you want. And this video, for whatever value that it has, I thought it was interesting. It says that when we experience this discomfort because of two conflicting beliefs or behaviors, we can resolve that in several different ways. One way that we try to resolve that is by changing. Obviously, we could change one of the beliefs that contradicts. So if we have two conflicting ideas, we say, okay, well, I guess I need to change my mind.

SPEAKER_00And that would be the healthy way, I think, to deal with consciousness is when we experience this and we realize, hey, this new information is true. And what I used to hold to be true is not true. And I need to reject one and take the other. We could also change our behavior because sometimes it's our behavior that's getting in the way. The third way was that we add thoughts. And this is a lot of what we've been talking about. We add thoughts to sort of rationalize what it is that we believe. And so we still try sometimes, I think, to hold two contradicting ideas in our head at the same time.

SPEAKER_00And we say, yes, this is true. And yeah, that's also true. And we're like, well, don't those conflict with each other? And and we will try to add information to try to rationalize, well, it's only because of this, and there's extenuating circumstances there, and we add information to try to fix the dissonance. And then the fourth one is to completely trivialize the inconsistency and to just say, yes, it's inconsistent. I know it's inconsistent. I don't care that it's inconsistent. It's not a big deal. Yes, I say I believe X, and I also do Y, and I know that doesn't make sense, but

SPEAKER_00I'm okay with it. And we just kind of leave it at that. So we've kind of been dancing around this, Brandon, a little bit. And I would love for us to talk about some specific ways that we have this going on and maybe we don't recognize that we have going on. How have you seen this specifically in your own life or in the life of Christians that you know? Where do you think cognitive dissonance affects us specifically?

SPEAKER_01OK, I'll give you just an example with me because I can maybe be an expert on my own experiences. What I began to encounter were things that I had. I think all of us probably bring into our discipleship inherited beliefs, probably from our parents, from our church community, even geographically where we live, you know, whatever parts of the country you live in. There are certain things that are just kind of unspoken. They're just unsaid. This is just kind of how we think, how we see the world.

SPEAKER_01And so we all bring some of these things in. And if you're serious about your faith, there are going to be times when those are going to bump up against teachings or behaviors of Jesus. And you're going to find those things in conflicts like, well, this is what we do here. This is what we believe. But this is what Jesus says. And you get uncomfortable because you're like, wait a minute. So does that mean and that's when you kind of start going. So I think if you really want to know whether or not cognitive dissonance is

SPEAKER_01engaged in you, if you hear yourself saying, so are you telling me and then fill in the blank with whatever comes next? You know, that's kind of like I think it tips me off. So what you're saying is and then because now we're trying to rationalize. And we're trying to find, you know, OK, well, this can't be true because of this. For me, where I started encountering it, I grew up, I guess what you, you know, the term that you would use is pro-life. That would be the term that people would say, pro-life. And what that really meant,

SPEAKER_01I didn't know it at the time, but what it really meant was just anti-abortion. And that's the culture that I come from. And I would still say that I am as adamant in my pro-life position as I ever was, maybe even more than I was historically. Where I started running into some difficulties is in recognizing that pro-life was much bigger than just the abortion issue. That certainly is a compartment of that topic.

SPEAKER_01But there were other things that I believe very strongly that definitely could not be described under the label of pro-life. Some of them had to do with violence, war, the death penalty, other things like that. And I began to see that there were some of the things that Jesus was saying about the sacredness of human life and the willingness to protect human life and

SPEAKER_01actually the willingness to lay down your life that I found started being in conflict with some of the ways that I was raised. And I don't say any of this is to label judgment. I'm just telling you the journey that I went on. I grew up very much of, you know, you got a gun, you keep it in your house. Maybe you carry a gun on you and somebody tries to hurt you. You do what you got to do to stop them or protect them or whatever, protect yourself or whatever. I started having some trouble with that stuff because what I encountered was how

SPEAKER_01can I love my enemy and kill him at the same time? That was one of the first wars going on in my mind because everything within me was saying, oh, wait a minute. It's common sense. Everybody knows you've got a right to protect yourself. I mean, I don't even need my Bible to tell me that. Everybody knows that. But then I'm hearing Jesus say certain things. And more than hearing him say certain things, I'm seeing Jesus do certain things.

SPEAKER_01And Jesus' disciples do certain things. And then I start to read some of the church history and church fathers, and I realized that really for the first 300 years of Christianity, this wasn't even a discussion. I mean, there wasn't even debate here. It was just, it was a given. Christians don't kill people, period, for any reason at all. They don't do it. Even if it means dying. Well, that's not how I was raised. And that's not, I guess, what you would say is instinctive and natural to me.

SPEAKER_01Um, so there was a big, big, you know, you talk about cognitive dissonance and this feeling of discomfort of strongly held belief, conflicting information. What do I do with that? I don't know that I've resolved that. But I know that my horizons for what it means to truly be pro-life have begun to broaden because I'm trying my best to stick with Jesus and Scripture and where that leads.

SPEAKER_01And now, have I read all the counter arguments? Yeah, I've read them all. I've read both sides. I can argue both sides if I need to. now I'm trying to navigate with a pure heart of what I think Jesus did and would do and what he said. And so that's kind of one of the areas in my own life, just me personally. Now, that's just one. I could give you a dozen of things that I encountered that just,

SPEAKER_01this is just the world I grew up in, the air I breathe. But I started going, if I'm going to stick with what I'm seeing in Jesus, There's some stuff in my culture, in my upbringing that can't go along, can't be in harmony with this. So now the choice is what am I going to do? Am I going to ignore it? And I did that for a long time, just try to push it down, ignore it. That just leaves the discomfort. Then it's am I just going to find people that agree with me that can make me go, see, it's okay to believe this.

SPEAKER_01And that didn't take the discomfort away either because I still got those lingering other arguments in the back of my mind that were valid and made good points. And so at some point I started having to go, I've got to start – Maybe not letting those things go completely, but I've definitely had to hold them with an open hand, if that makes any sense. I'm not gripping. It's more like I'm opening myself up to what I'm seeing in Scripture. And if that means that I've got to let go of some of the things that were

SPEAKER_01instinctive in my culture, then so be it. And that's the journey, I guess I'd say, I still am on.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. Well, I appreciate that, Brendan. I think that we share so much in common with our theology and our journey of discipleship. And I think that's what the journey of discipleship is all about. It's all about allowing Jesus through the scriptures and through the spirit to convict us of the places where we are not in harmony with his will for our life. And if we're going to say, Jesus, you can change everything. this part of my life, you can change these beliefs, you can change these behaviors,

SPEAKER_00but these over here, I'm just going to assume these are okay. These are off limits. I'm not going to allow Jesus to change these things. Then we're not actually living out our baptism. Our baptism, we believe that we immerse a person completely. There's not an aspect of our life that we hold up out of the water and say, well, this part of my life doesn't belong to Jesus. We believe that in baptism we surrender our entire self to Jesus, and that means our politics, and that means how we protect our family, and that means our finances,

SPEAKER_00and that means our whatever. And it's interesting to me how I have felt myself bump up against this, and I felt other Christians bump up against this. I know you and I have talked a lot about politics, and I don't want to go too far down that rabbit hole, but It's interesting to me how we can preach, Jesus says, love your enemies. Jesus says, love your neighbors. Jesus says, love your brothers and sisters. And that has a lot of application to how we engage or if we engage or what way we engage with political issues and the way that we engage with our neighbors and the

SPEAKER_00people around us. And I see Christian people that if you ask them, should you love your enemies? They would say, yes, Jesus says, love your enemies. And then you say, is it okay to post rude, unkind, unloving memes and articles and pictures online about your political opponents? They would say, yes, we need to own the left or we need to own these people. We need to put them in their place. We got to stand up for what's right. And even if we have to talk ugly and be rude, we have to do that.

SPEAKER_00And And not seeing the conflict of those two things, like you can't you can't legitimately hold both of those positions at the same time. Either you love your enemies and pray for those, even those that persecute you, or you engage in this kind of rhetoric and this kind of behavior. But you can't hold both of those at the same time.

SPEAKER_01I don't know who to credit with this. I wish I did. But there's a great quote that I carry with me that we oftentimes step over the way of Jesus in order to get to the truth of Jesus. And that's what I see happening in those areas. We want to stand for what is true and right. And oftentimes maybe we are in the the application of this is what Scripture says and this is right or this is wrong. But sometimes we want to do that in a in a fleshly, non-spirit led way that takes the good and taints it,

SPEAKER_01you know. And that's an area absolutely where you often see that is, you know, you may be right on the answer or the topic. But the means by which is just as important as well, not just used to pick at my son. My son was naturally just bringing it math and he could he could do a lot of stuff in his head. And we used to have to try to tell him, listen, in order for a math problem to be right, you have to get the right answer and you have to show how you got there. It's not enough to get the right answer.

SPEAKER_01And I think we need to be reminded of that. It's not enough just to hold the right, quote unquote, moral positions. it's important that we get there the right way as well in getting those points across. And if we sacrifice that, if we let that go, then oftentimes the, quote, right point gets lost because of the way that we got there. And for some reason, again, you know, this is the cognitive dissonance thing, our emotions get involved.

SPEAKER_01That fight or flight gets kicked in. The adrenaline gets going, you know. And we can go to that kind of, you know, a verbal death match very, very quickly in the same way that an animal would be ready to fight to the death. Verbally, we're almost ready to fight to the death because we are capable of saying some pretty horrific things about each other. And sometimes we're not even talking about like the quote enemy. We're talking about sometimes we say them about brothers. I can remember an occasion. I preached a sermon kind of sharing some of my thoughts that I had learned about

SPEAKER_01about violence and things like that. And maybe some things we need to reconsider. And I got tickled that afterwards, a brother very angrily shouted and called me a pacifist. And he he meant that as a derogatory. It was it wasn't it wasn't a description. He was he was calling me that because he was angry at me. And, you know, you're just a pacifist. And which I thought was very weird, but it's just that's what can happen if if we don't keep this stuff in check,

SPEAKER_01you know, that lizard brain engages. And, you know, we start to act like a reptile rather than like a image bearer, you know, created to glorify God. And that's part of the human condition. I understand. But that's why we have these conversations. The better we understand how we operate. the better we can be equipped to navigate these things with a Christ-like spirit. Again, these impulses are not wrong.

SPEAKER_01God gave them to us. But what do we do with them? And I don't know, maybe this is best compared to like the sexual impulse. God gave that to human beings for a purpose. But we've all seen how ugly and damaging it is when people allow that to go unchecked and unrestrained. And so we have to be able to go, okay, what is the purpose? Is it God? Why did God create this thing that we have where we react like this to conflicting information?

SPEAKER_01And I think it's probably to help us to stay grounded where we don't just believe every single thing that comes along. And every time somebody, you know, I used to when I was doing Bible studies with people, I liked it when people wanted to argue because it meant they cared about it. And if I could just come in and, you know, say a few scriptures and you go, OK, and then I'm right there with you, then I figure somebody else will come along after me and say something else. And, you know, there go off that way now. So there's value in this. It makes us kind of have to do a little bit of work and to sift through,

SPEAKER_01but we can't become enslaved by it where we refuse to entertain information that contradicts something that we already believe. or we have to accept i'm right about everything already and you know if if someone has that level of of arrogance i don't know that anything but god can can break through that um hopefully people don't have that mentality so if i'm not that

SPEAKER_01arrogant to think that i'm right about everything Then I need to just go ahead and operate from the perspective of, I know there's some things I've got wrong and it's okay for me to learn those. And it's actually good because I'm pursuing truth and everything I learned that maybe contradicts what I already believe, but turns out to be true, is this making me a better disciple? So it's ultimately for my good and helps me achieve my goals.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. Well, there's so much that you've said that I wish we had time to go back to and flesh out a little bit more. But I want to go back just for a second to what you said about the fact that when we... tie everything that we believe to our salvation so that we're not allowed to question what we believe or what we're currently doing, because then it makes us question whether or not we're saved. That's why I say to people all the time that every conversation has to be

SPEAKER_00undergirded with the foundation of grace, that we are saved by grace through faith. We are saved not because we're right about everything, but because God is right. Not because we're good, but because he is. Not because we're strong, but because he is. And so when it comes back to that and when we know, hey, I have messed up, I have beliefs that are messed up, I have behaviors that the Lord has not yet sanctified, I have all kinds of things in my life that I am still a work in progress, but I am saved because God is gracious and God is merciful and God is slow to anger

SPEAKER_00and abounding in steadfast love, then we can engage in these conversations and you can say, Wes, You know, you're wrong about this. And I can say, oh, wow, Brandon, I didn't realize I was wrong. Let me study that out. And if you're right, I will change what I was believing or what I was doing because it doesn't challenge my identity. It doesn't challenge my salvation. I am still saved by grace through faith. even though I've discovered I was wrong about something. In fact, it makes me even more grateful for my salvation.

SPEAKER_00So kind of with that in mind, what can we do and what can the Lord do to help us become more aware of the fact that we're holding contradictory ideas or we're doing things that are in conflict with what we say we believe? And how can the church and the Lord help us to resolve some of that cognitive dissonance?

SPEAKER_01I think we have to be intentional, and I'm choosing that word on purpose. We have to be intentional, meaning that it doesn't just happen. We have to seek it. We have to be intentional in cultivating a community that can challenge us And it also needs to be a community that we can trust the people who are challenging us. So that's, I think, imperative and number one. And when healthy, that's what the church's role is.

SPEAKER_01It's a place where we do get our views challenged. And we can we know that we can trust the people who are challenges because we know of their purity of their motives, the sincerity of their heart, their pursuit in following the spirit led life and that collective wisdom. So there's a there's there's a community where we can be challenged and we can, you know, to use the term the iron sharpens iron. Now, however. In an unhealthy church, you wind up with an echo chamber and just our biases just get reinforced.

SPEAKER_01I recall a brother saying to me on one occasion, he described his particular situation. He said, we call it Bible class, but it's really creed rehearsal. And what he meant was there's no room for discussion, debate, disagreement. It's just, here's what we believe. reinforce it, don't question it. And if you do, you'll probably be expelled from the community because you're going to be viewed as a troublemaker or a threat or divisive or a false teacher,

SPEAKER_01you know, any number of labels that get put on. So it's really important that we cultivate in our churches a healthy environment that This is where we do the work. This is where we have the conversations. This is where we sit together and we pull these things apart and see what we find, see what doesn't fit, and then put it back together the right way. And what a blessing it is to be in a community where you do have collective wisdom. and collective experience because sometimes it's not even about wisdom it's about

SPEAKER_01perspectives different people can see the same thing differently and it's not necessarily even an issue of this is right and this is wrong it's just this is a different perspective that you're not even considering but this is affected by it one of the things that we have got to embrace is that most topics that we disagree on are not simple black and white issues if they were We probably wouldn't have a lot of disagreement. There's nuance to these things.

SPEAKER_01And when we fail, often what we want is we just want that binary yes or no, right or wrong, black or white, do or don't. And there are things that fall in that category. Of course there are. But there's an awful lot of stuff that are way more complicated than that. It's just not that simple. And so those things have to be taken into account from various perspectives and circumstances. We see it in scripture. I mean, we all know it's pretty plain. The only people that could eat the showbread were the priest, except when David and his men ate it.

SPEAKER_01And then suddenly it was okay. And Jesus even references that. So there's an example there of saying, look, there's some nuance here. There is a greater law that came into effect, and that was the love your neighbor law and the fact that these guys were on the run and didn't have anything to eat. Now, if David just decided one night, hey, you know, I'd like a snack. I'm going to go down to the tabernacle and grab some bread. I don't think God would have been pleased with that, but that's a different circumstance. So there's gotta be nuance in these things and understanding that in a healthy community,

SPEAKER_01We can listen to various perspectives, not to prove them wrong, but to try to better understand maybe this is something I haven't considered. The second thing is we have to cultivate a heart that is willing and able and seeking to be corrected. And that's not easy. And that's why I think following Jesus is always referred to as a death or taking up a cross, a crucifixion, because it's hard.

SPEAKER_01to open up your heart to the possibility that maybe I'm wrong and someone knows better than me whether something I'm not considering. So what does that look like? I think that looks like intentionally seeking out information and sources that don't agree with your position. Listen to what the other side has to say and don't do it for the purpose of just disproving and critiquing it. Do it for the purpose of seeing, is there valid information?

SPEAKER_01Be humble. Humility enables us to admit that we're wrong and change when we're presented with evidence that shows us to be wrong. So be humble and be open to the other side and honestly consider it. Don't just listen for, okay, well, here's where I can attack them. Here's where I can get them. But what about, you know, have honest conversation where you say, OK, I hear what you're saying, but here's where I'm struggling because I'm thinking of this verse and this verse

SPEAKER_01and this verse. And it sounds like that's the opposite of what you're saying. So help me how you can know those passages, but come to a different conclusion than I'm coming to because I don't see how you get there. Because chances are, this is what's funny to me is sometimes if you have a conversation with somebody and they immediately quote a verse and say, well, you know, the Bible says they quote a verse. And my response usually is, do you really think that I've never read that verse? That I've, you know, I've never heard that verse before, that I've never considered that.

SPEAKER_01Or do you think I know that it says that and I just don't care? I mean, is that the spirit that you've seen in me? Somebody who goes, I don't care what scripture says. So I probably know that verse and I probably wrestled with that verse and I've still come to this conclusion. So why don't you ask me instead? So what are the reasons? How do you bridge that gap there? Because to me, it's a bridge too far. Those are things that we can do that can help us actually invite challenges to our own beliefs, um,

SPEAKER_01that show respect to other people, that show respect to the argument and can help you to actually be challenged and go, you know what? At the end of it, I don't agree with you. I still think what I think, but I understand how you got there. And that's going to help us get rid of this idea of, well, you just don't love the truth or you just don't care what the scriptures say or you just want to please people. I think that is such a careless and, frankly, a lazy dismissal of people who disagree with us.

SPEAKER_01Because most of the people that I disagree with, I do not question their devotion and love to the Lord at all. I've seen the fruit of it too much. And in many cases, I think that they're brilliant people who are devout and sincere in their study of Scripture. But I might just come to a different conclusion. But I'm not questioning whether or not they love the Lord and they love the truth. And that's where I think we can start to close that gap. And we both benefit.

SPEAKER_01Remember, tension builds strength and provides stability. And Scripture is filled with tensions. And we shouldn't run from them. We should embrace them and wrestle with them because that's where we grow stronger and that's where we find that stability. Well, on the one hand, it says, you know, okay, this passage says, you know, love your enemy. And this passage says, well, you know, they'll bear the sword in hand. Okay, let those things exist together. Wrestle with them. There's tension there. Strength and stability come from tension. So don't run from it. That's the cognitive dissonance.

SPEAKER_01I don't want it. Don't go with the confirmation bias. I just want to hear the guy that can refute that. Put yourself in that tension. Be humble. Be in a community where you can lovingly discuss these things together and then make peace with each other moving forward. Brother, I just don't agree with you on this, but I understand why you do. And I love you. And let's keep seeking. You know, let's keep seeking God together.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. Yeah. And what I love about what you just said, Brandon, is that is it possible that the person, as somebody is listening to this, you know, maybe they're thinking about a particular person or a group of people with whom they disagree. Is it possible? that all of those people with whom you disagree are evil, wicked people that hate God and want nothing to do with anything good? Yes, I suppose it's possible. That's true. But is it also possible that you have found it easier to dismiss their arguments

SPEAKER_00and dismiss them as Christians or as people and to dismiss everything that they're saying? It's easier to dismiss them as evil and wicked and they just don't love God. And the truth is probably, as you said, that they probably are sincere people. And at the end of the day, you may still disagree with them, but don't take the easy road out by simply dismissing them and saying that they're evil, wicked people who don't love God, because that is the cognitive dissonance that is...

SPEAKER_00causing us to take the path of least resistance. And the path of least resistance is simply to dismiss those other people. It could be that they have information that you need to know. And the reason you are so tempted to dismiss them and call them evil and wicked is because what they're saying makes you uncomfortable because there's at least a part of you that is acknowledging maybe there's some truth to that. And you don't want to accept that. And so it's easier just to dismiss them.

SPEAKER_00And so I love what you're challenging us to do. I love what Jesus is challenging us to do, to live in the church community where there are people who have different beliefs. Romans 14, who have different opinions, who have different perspectives and who have come to different conclusions without dismissing people, without arguing, without writing people off, loving one another and living in that tension because it's good for us. It's good for us to learn and grow.

SPEAKER_00And it's good for us to just wrestle with those different ideas, even if at the end of the day, we still come to the same conclusions.

SPEAKER_01Right. And if we don't, like we mentioned earlier, if we don't do that, it leads to ugly places like in Scripture where people looked God in the face and told God that he was a blasphemer. Well, Brandon, thank you so much for your time today. And more than anything, thank you for your work in the kingdom, brother. My pleasure being with you. Thank you for this conversation. And it's helped me in my faith journey. I hope somebody else can take another step in theirs because of it.

SPEAKER_00Let's all go out and love like Jesus.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. What Does the Bible Say About the Holy Spirit Today?

    Nov 11, 202656 minAudio

    The Spirit is often the member of the Godhead we talk about least, and when we do, He can feel more like a doctrine to manage than a Person to know. In this conversation from the 412 Christian Podcast, Wes joins hosts...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Salvation, Sanctification, and Justification

    Nov 4, 202649 minAudio

    What if the vocabulary you inherited for salvation has left you more anxious than assured? Justification, sanctification, saved: many believers learned these words as tidy categories, and many sincere Christians still...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. What is Baptism of the Holy Spirit?

    Oct 28, 202644 minAudio

    What does it actually mean to be baptized in the Holy Spirit? For many who grew up in the Restoration Movement, the phrase meant a debate about water baptism or a defensive argument about miraculous gifts, and then the...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Is Baptism a Work?

    Oct 21, 202654 minAudio

    If we’re saved by grace through faith, why does baptism still matter? An elder in Tennessee wrote in with a question many Christians are asking. If love is the heart of everything, is baptism just a ritual tacked on, a...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. What the Bible Says About Gluttony

    Oct 14, 202646 minAudio

    Is gluttony only about what is on your plate? Most of us assume we know the answer, and most of us feel a little uncomfortable when the subject comes up. The Bible mentions gluttony far less than many Christians expect,...

    Credit the people on this episode