In this episode of the Radically Christian Bible Study Podcast, Wes McAdams engages in a thoughtful conversation with Marcus Stenson about the complex topics of race, ethnicity, and how these factors influence the way we read and interpret Scripture. They explore the historical and societal constructs of race, emphasizing how the idea of race as a biological reality has been debunked, and how ethnicity relates more to shared cultural experiences. The conversation highlights how societal perceptions shape our understanding of Scripture and why it's essential to acknowledge and embrace diverse perspectives. Marcus shares his personal experiences, detailing how his ethnic identity has shaped his worldview and his approach to Scripture. He emphasizes the importance of recognizing biases and cultural influences when engaging with biblical texts. Both Wes and Marcus discuss the concept of reading Scripture through one's ethnic lens and argue that understanding these perspectives can enrich and deepen biblical interpretation. They also emphasize the importance of diversity within the church, asserting that unity doesn't mean uniformity but rather a celebration of varied experiences within the body of Christ. Marcus Stenson serves as the preaching minister at the Leander Church of Christ. Beyond his local ministry, he is actively involved in kingdom-focused nonprofits, including initiatives in Kenya and leadership development programs in the United States. His passion lies in fostering disciple-making cultures and advancing conversations about biblical understanding and unity within the church. Links and Resources: * Logos Bible Study Software (https://logos.com/radicallychristian) * Reading While Black by Esau McCaulley * Leander Church of Christ (https://leanderchurch.org) This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit www.radicallychristian.com
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
welcome to the radically christian bible study podcast i'm your host wes mcadams here we have one goal learn to love like jesus today i'll be talking with marcus
SPEAKER_00stinson about how the issues of race and ethnicity factor into biblical understanding and application this is all part of our how to be a better bible student series we'll get to that conversation in just a moment but before we do a word about logos bible study software I use logos every single day on my laptop, iPad, smartphone. I have access to dozens of Bible translations and my entire theological library. One of the coolest features is their search functionality that
uses AI and your logos library.
SPEAKER_00If you would like to try logos, you can do it for free. They're even offering an extended free trial for those who listen to this podcast. So just go to logos.com slash radically Christian. That's logos, L-O-G-O-S dot com slash radically Christian. Okay, now my conversation with Marcus Stinson. Marcus Stinson, welcome back to the podcast, brother.
SPEAKER_01Thank you so much. It is always a joy. It's an honor to be here.
SPEAKER_00It is fantastic to have you. Well, for those that don't know you yet, why don't you tell us a little bit about your life and the ministry you're doing right now?
SPEAKER_01Yeah. I mean, that's a, that's a long story, but, uh, my wife, uh, Maggie and I live just north of Austin, Texas right now. I'm serving as the preaching minister at the Landry Church of Christ here. Um, and I partner in some other endeavors to a few kingdom facing nonprofits that do some work in Kenya and Africa and, uh, some work here stateside and leadership development and disciple making culture as well. So, uh, it's a beautiful blur and a beautiful full plate. Uh, but, uh, God has blessed me tremendously.
SPEAKER_00That's awesome. That's awesome. Well, for those that don't know, Marcus and I, we were working together at one point. I was going to say we were co-workers, but we're still co-workers. And we're working together in the kingdom, even if we don't get to see each other every day. I miss seeing you every day. I miss working with you side by side. But I'm so thankful for the work that you're doing, brother.
SPEAKER_01Thank you so much. Thank you.
SPEAKER_00Well, this conversation that we're going to have, and obviously we're going to be sensitive about it because it is kind of a sensitive topic, but we're going to talk about race and ethnicity and how those things play into biblical understanding and biblical application. But let's define those terms, because I think so often they get used synonymously, and they're not synonymous terms, race and ethnicity. Let's define those just a little bit, and then we'll talk about how that has even affected your reading and understanding of Scripture. So how would you define,
how would you help people to think about those terms properly?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I think this is where you have to start the conversation. And I also just want to say, no matter where we go today, I think one of the things that is the most important when you are talking about something that can be sensitive like this, that is often difficult... there has to be a grace that exists between us as brothers and sisters, and so, first and foremost, you gotta give each other permission to not say things perfectly every time if you're gonna come to an understanding. And so, uh, I'll ask for that for the audience,
SPEAKER_01but I know that that exists between you and I, Wes, and I think that's a really good starting place as we have conversations like this. When it comes to race and ethnicity, you're hard-pressed to maybe find a more loaded topic in our culture and society today. I will say that those two things sound identical. They're not identical. They are related but distinct concepts. If I was going to break it down as cleanly as I could, I would say that Your ethnicity refers to your cultural identity,
SPEAKER_01a shared heritage, language, traditions, behaviors, culture. Race, though, is a construct that is a broad societal categorization that is based on physical traits like skin color. It does a lot to oversimplify what ethnicity really means. I think maybe the interesting point for a lot of folks, if this is the first time you're thinking about this concept or a question like this, is prior to the 17th century, we really didn't have the idea of a race.
SPEAKER_01We were all one race. Now, there were always ethnic groups. There was always ethnicity. But prior to really colonial expansion and the need to create a justification for subjugating different groups of people, there wasn't such a thing as race, at least not organized by things like skin color before. Um, unfortunately, that idea, um, widely adopted, um, and was used to marginalize entire populations. And so that's become kind of the dominant framework for
understanding human
SPEAKER_01diversity is to talk about race, But I'm convinced that most people, even when they say race today, are actually referring to ethnicity. They're really talking about a shared culture or a shared life experience. And I would just warn, you know, the more we lean on that broad categorization or generalization of race, the more you oversimplify and ignore really, really rich diversity that can exist within ethnic groups. and the more we kind of subconsciously reinforce racial
stereotypes that even persist to today. So race, think of it as an overgeneralization used to create a social hierarchy.
SPEAKER_01And race, Really unfortunate result of that is it renders groups of people as monolithic, whereas ethnicity, no ethnicity, is a monolith. Black people are not monolithic. I can't speak on behalf of all black people or biracial people. White people are not monolithic. There's a tremendous amount of diversity in every ethnicity. So that would be my first crack at trying to break down those two concepts.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. And it's amazing how the concept of race as a biological reality has been sort of debunked over the years and how most anthropologists, I would say all anthropologists, all serious scientists, would now say there really is no truth to the idea that we belong to distinct biological categories. In fact, the children's song that we sometimes sing about Jesus loving people, and we even echoed the racial categories that were invented,
SPEAKER_00red, yellow, black, white. And I think that's unfortunate because that concept, as you said, as people were seeking to expand colonialism, as they were seeking to justify slavery— They were saying, why is it okay for us to own certain people? Well, because they belong to this distinct biological group. They are black people. They are yellow people. They are red people. And we are white people.
SPEAKER_00And so they are a different kind of human being than us. They are distinct biologically. They're biologically different. They're not capable of the same kinds of things. They don't think the same way. They don't act the same way. They're barbaric. They're all of these things. And those stereotypes were used, as you said, to justify the idea of enslaving people, of owning people as if they are just one step above animals or something like that. And over the years, we have gotten rid of the idea that people are
SPEAKER_00biologically distinct. We understand that all human beings, I think most people understand that all human beings are equally capable of all kinds of wonderful, beautiful things because we're all human beings. We all belong to the human race. But that construct is It did. It divided us and it created an idea that there are black people, white people, that there are these distinct groups and we still use that kind of language today.
SPEAKER_00So I have been trying to sort of de-racialize my language. And it is a very different thing to think of myself as an American who is of European descent, specifically, like I am of British descent, you know, when I check my DNA records, you know. That that's where I come from. And that has shaped who I am and how I think and those kinds of things. The construct of whiteness,
the construct of being a white man like that probably has shaped how I think,
SPEAKER_00whether I want it to or not. You know, that's the interesting thing, even if we reject the idea of racial categories. it still continues to sort of shape us, whether we want it to or not. And so we sort of have to acknowledge, even though we don't belong to biologically distinct groups, there are social groups that have been created by the ideology of race and racism. And even if we try to get rid of that, we still have to deal with the effects of that.
SPEAKER_00So With all of that said, Marcus, let's get a little bit more specific. As we talk about Scripture and just living life as a follower of Jesus, how has your own ethnic identity or your own ethnicity shaped how you navigate the world and how you read Scripture?
SPEAKER_01It's a deep one. I love what you just said about us not being able to escape sort of the reality that's been created for us, and the dichotomy that's been created for us, and the way that people groups have been divided over this long span of time. It's weird, we're talking just a few minutes ago. You can almost view the creation of race and that construct as a religion in that it became,
SPEAKER_01over time, the first and main way that people identified with each other. One of the beautiful things about attending a church anywhere in the world is that when you walk in for worship or you're in a gathering of the saints, you automatically have a communion and a fellowship and an attachment to those people because of what you share. And it's interesting how this idea of race really became that for us too. And I think you would have that to some extent when you're just talking about your
SPEAKER_01heritage and ethnicity as well. I don't think that's escapable. But you're right in that when you open up the door and step out into the world, it is going to perceive things based on this dynamic and this paradigm. That's how the world is going to see you and respond to you. And you do kind of have to make peace with it, even if you reject the reality of it. And that's... kind of the place that we are right now. And I think that the church has a responsibility and a great opportunity to speak to this in a very different light, in a very different way.
But as for how it's affected me, it's hard for me as I sit and think back in time I don't think a moment exists when I haven't been affected by just being a person
SPEAKER_01of color in America. I'm under no delusion that there haven't been so many more folks that have had a different experience, a more severe experience, a worse experience than I am, but... or that I had, but, you know, one of my earliest memories, formative memory, core memory, was, you know, I'm four, five years old, and our next-door neighbor was not happy about the fact that he shared the street with a family of Black people.
and one of my earliest memories is my mom rushing me upstairs tucking me under the windowsill telling me to cover my sisters they were a year or younger at the time and telling me not to look out the window of course five-year-old marcus did and seeing a guy uh with a shotgun take two shots at dad right there in the street and not really knowing what that meant and watching dad run and the panic and crying
SPEAKER_01and The conversations that came after that of explaining why this was the case that I couldn't really understand or formulate at the time just will shape the way that you step into the world and the way that you see the world and what you expect from the world. And so I don't think I've ever really had a time where I wasn't affected in some way. Even later growing up in church, I remember lots of experiences that don't scare me as much as that experience did, but still impacted me deeply. I remember... Um, walking into a drug store,
SPEAKER_01uh, at one point and having a little girl look up at me and say, hey, mommy, why doesn't that man wash his hands? I just realized she was just referring to my skin color. It was the most innocent thing, and the mom was mortified, but, you know, some experiences aren't that innocent. I remember mom coming home just distraught because her best friend at the time, who was a member of our church, had let slip in conversation that the reason why she moved to teach the school she was teaching at was so her kids didn't have to attend school in town with the black kids, and mom was crushed because her kids are the black kids.
SPEAKER_01I remember... I remember not being able to date certain people because their parents, even in the late nineties and early two thousands were beholden to the idea that interracial relationships were outlawed by scripture because of not yoking light with darkness. And so, um, some of those experiences sent me on a tailspin almost, um, because it seemed to clash with the God of the Bible that I was learning about at church and that was being preached to me.
And so when I began to really dig into the Scripture for myself and really started
SPEAKER_01to grow, it was never without the question if these things were true. Is this really how God is? Like, does God really make an allowance for this? Um, and I found that he wasn't, and then there was a new problem and a new question that I had to ask, well, is this who we in the church are? Is this who we're called to be? Is this how we're supposed to be? Is this what it's supposed to look like? And there are lots of other instances through my life and school and things that people said that really kind of probably affected the way that
I saw myself and the way that I approached my relationship with God and who I was supposed to be.
SPEAKER_01When you get to junior high and high school, things change because the innocence of children leaves and now they're aware that the world says that there is such a thing as red and yellow, black and white, and you're supposed to have this tension between each other and you're supposed to expect certain things of each other. Um, I started to hear really weird things, Wes, like I would hear, man, you're the whitest black guy I know. And every time I heard that, I was like, man, what, that hurt. Like, am I supposed to, do I have to defend my heritage? Like, am I not, am I not black enough for this person?
SPEAKER_01Like, what does that even mean? This was all in, like, deep tension in me. There came a day where I just responded by asking, you know, what does that mean? Is it because I'm articulate and I speak well? Is it because I'm still in school? Is it because I'm nonviolent? So it is fair to say that in my life there's been a constant wrestling with... racial or ethnic tensions in our culture and even in the arena of the church. Um, it's touched every part of my life. It doesn't really matter how I saw myself.
Kind of like you said a few minutes ago when I stepped into the world, this is what people saw.
SPEAKER_01They had a certain expectation of me. Um... And so over time, I think probably two things really developed. Number one, I really developed a like, as it were, flipped it on its head. I started to relish the opportunity to subvert stereotypes. I felt like that's something that God was calling me to. And also the way that I approached scripture changed. And it grew from, I think, a lot of what I inherited, which... was to approach Scripture as if people are a monolith,
and that all valid applications in Scripture are basically just kind of the right
SPEAKER_01rules to follow and my personal salvation, as well as some prescriptions for corporate worship. And I think those things are there, but the word became much deeper for me in that when I began to go find out who the God of the Bible really is. What does he have to say about what I'm experiencing? What does he have to say about how we relate to one another? What does he have to say about us collectively as image bearers? what does the Bible have to say about the character of this God? Because we're supposed to be ambassadors of His on this earth.
SPEAKER_01And so I needed to know, what does God really say about all of this? Does He say anything about this? Is there something for me here? Not individualistically, but I mean, for people like me. And what does that really mean? So it's been a lifelong pursuit. I'm actually really thankful for it. God has worked some incredible... incredible things over the course of my life. And so it's been a journey, that's for sure.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. Well, thank you for sharing that, the good, the bad, and the ugly of all of those experiences. I appreciate you being vulnerable and sharing those with us, Marcus. I can't help but anticipate that there are people, because I think I was at this point, at some point in my life, to think that the only way to read scripture rightly is Yeah.
SPEAKER_00And so they would say, well, when you read the Bible, you just have to read it as if you're not coming at it from any sort of background, any sort of perspective, any sort of bias, and lay all of that stuff aside and read Scripture with sort of this clear lens. Well, let's talk about that for a minute. Is that possible? Is that good? Is that the goal? Are people fooling themselves when they think that they can read Scripture? Are we fooling ourselves when we think that we can read Scripture without a perspective,
SPEAKER_00without a bias, without a sort of our own background? Can we just lay those things aside and read Scripture without that perspective, or should we?
SPEAKER_01I love this question. I have heard it. I've heard this statement multiple times, many, many times over the years. Usually when someone makes that statement, I ask a follow-up question because sometimes they're not trying to communicate what it actually communicates. And by that, I mean, I think... I think this statement sometimes can be made with the best of intentions. Um, I think often because discussions of race and ethnicity and the things that have traditionally been so incendiary for us and divisive, our hope and our assumption is the best way to heal those
wounds or the divide is
SPEAKER_01to just kind of stop talking about it. Um, and that we almost try to convey, uh, I'm not what those people were back then, I'm actually colorblind. Um, everyone is the same to me, so let's just go with that. And I'm actually thankful for that intent, I'm thankful for the heart that desperately wants that, because I think that is the ideal. but it's not that easy. I do think we delude ourselves. I do think we fool ourselves a little bit. It's not easy because unity does not mean uniformity.
SPEAKER_01I think I think that we all come to the text with our culture, history, lived experiences, the things that come with being a part of our ethnicity or race, and it's impossible to divorce ourselves from those things, even if we try. And having an awareness that I do, in fact, come to the Bible with a certain lens already can help me to see outside of that, and it can give me a richer, deeper understanding and perspective
SPEAKER_01Um, but it is a mistake to believe that my experience and approach is the only experience and approach that is valid or effectual. Um, so I'm thankful for the intent of that question. Um, uh, I think to say that we can just approach the text without any of that baggage misunderstands what unity means. Saying that we're colorblind, or that we need to lay aside all ethnic attributes in matters of fellowship, theology,
SPEAKER_01life, is to assume that unity is uniformity. And that idea affirms the fears that have always surrounded the uncomfortable prospect of us all truly being one in Christ. And that is that somehow someone is going to lose something that makes them them. And I don't think that the scripture bears that out. I don't think that's how God does unity. I don't think that's how Jesus does unity in his kingdom or his church. So the reality that's impossible for any of us to come to each other or to come to the scripture without bringing our perspective and paradigm to it,
SPEAKER_01um, that is absolutely made of all the elements of our lived experience. We come to the scripture with societal, socioeconomic frameworks. We come with cultural frameworks. We come with familial frameworks and what we learned and picked up from our families and those indefinitely undergird the theological frameworks that we use as well. So even I'll go so far as to say whether we're talking about, you know, white America or black America, we all come to the text with a Western post enlightenment perspective.
SPEAKER_01not just, you know, our ethnic perspectives. And that affects how we approach the scripture, what we see in scripture, how we study scripture, how we apply scripture. So it's impossible to avoid it. And as much as we hate to admit it, we push against this from the time that we're young. As soon as we reach the teenage years, we start saying, I'm not going to be like my parents. I'm not going to be like my parents. And you wake up one day in your mid thirties and you're like, man, I sound a lot like dad. And we are much more product of our environment and our time than we ever really want to admit, a product of our families and our memories. So ignoring that,
I think, is to feign a type of omniscience that we don't have.
SPEAKER_01So I'm with you on that. I think God actually designed it this way. I don't think it's a bad thing. I think it's a powerful thing. When we have the self-awareness to acknowledge it and embrace it, it gives us a necessary spirit of humility. And instead of always having to be in the posture of the authority, it allows us to take the posture of a learner. And I see that in Jesus. If Jesus himself grew in knowledge and wisdom and favor with God and man, and if Jesus himself learned even obedience unto death, then I should never reach a place in my life where I'm not in
the posture of a learner. So admitting that I don't have the market cornered on perspective and approach is a
SPEAKER_01really good reminder for me to have consistently, continually of that reality.
SPEAKER_00Man, that's beautiful. I didn't want to forget that phrase that you used, feign and omniscience that we don't have. That is so true. And I think that's exactly what ends up happening when we assume that we can or we're capable of coming to the text with this sort of omniscient perspective of of being able to approach it without our own bias. I mean, that is to ignore a key part of ethnicity. A key part of ethnicity is language. I cannot read the Bible without reading it as an English speaker.
SPEAKER_00Even if I learned Spanish, I would still be reading it. Even if I could learn Spanish... and I read the Bible in Spanish, I would still be reading it in Spanish as a native English speaker. It's part of my perspective. As you said, that Western post-Enlightenment perspective is part of how I think. I cannot think about the world without having a background in Western ideology. I can't think about Scripture without having a background in democracy and capitalism and all of these things that have shaped my thinking.
SPEAKER_00And so to assume that I could is a denial of reality. And so I think sometimes when we talk about—and that's what happens, I think, when we talk about race and ethnicity in such a myopic way, where we're just thinking about someone's skin color, that's not all that goes into our ethnic identity. And so part of what it means to read the Scripture through an ethnic lens is that you're reading it as— a native speaker of some language whatever your native language
is whatever you grew up speaking at home and then along with that is culture and it's it's all kinds of different things that you're most of us i will say are unaware of especially people that come from a majority culture and so if as as english speakers if we have only ever been around english speakers then we think well this
SPEAKER_00is just the normal way of talking Every other way of speaking is just the strange way of talking. That's abnormal. That's where the idea of being a barbarian came from, that idea of just saying, bar, bar, bar, bar, bar. That's how people thought of people that spoke another language. They're just barbaric. They don't speak the normal tongue. They don't speak the normal language. They don't speak Greek in this case. So the Persians speak a barbaric language. They don't speak Greek. And we tend to think the same way.
When you come from a majority culture and where you've only ever known your own culture,
SPEAKER_00then you just think, well, this is the normal way of thinking. This is the normal way of speaking. This is the normal culture. Everything else is abnormal. And so we think we can read the text without any sort of lens because we come from a majority culture. But if you have the blessing of knowing people who come from a minority culture, who are used to living in a world, navigating a world where people don't look like them or talk like them or think like them, then they understand that they have a unique take on things.
SPEAKER_00And we all need to understand that. We all have an ethnicity. It used to bother me. I think they've changed this now. But when you would go to the grocery store, they would have certain kinds of foods labeled ethnic food. It just cracked me up as if all the other food in the store wasn't ethnic food. All food is ethnic food. It just depends on what ethnicity it comes from. All food comes from some sort of ethnic background. It has an ethnic heritage to it. And it is the height of arrogance to think,
well, I don't have an ethnicity.
SPEAKER_00It's all of those other ethnic people out there saying, no, no, no. We all have an ethnicity. We all have a language. We all have a culture. We all have a background. And so being a white American descended from Europeans, living in the 21st century, speaking English, all of that affects my perspective. And I have to, like you said, be honest and humble about that. That doesn't mean my perspective is wrong because I'm white. It doesn't mean my perspective is wrong because I'm American.
SPEAKER_00It doesn't mean my perspective... It just means it's unique. It's different than someone with a different ethnic background will have when they come to the text. And so the idea isn't to abandon our ethnicity when we read Scripture. It is to come together with our unique ethnic perspectives and read Scripture together, I think.
SPEAKER_01Oh, 100%. Culture is a powerful force for good when it is shared. Culture is dangerous when you assume you don't have it. And what I mean by that is other people have culture, but I just have the right way to see this and I have the right way of doing this. And it's fine if you practice your cultural things over there, but when you're in this culture, this is how you're supposed to do things, and truly, this is superior. It's really subversive. It can get down into us. Um,
I don't think I've seen an ethnic aisle in a grocery store in quite some time. And I will tell you that we have remixed the classic song from Red and Yellow,
SPEAKER_01Black and White, to It Doesn't Matter What You're Like. And so, we're making some progress in VBSs across the country, I think.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. And I think that sometimes people don't understand why those sorts of changes are necessary. I mean, sometimes I get it. You know, there's a lot of stuff that is changing in our culture. And especially those who come from a majority culture background don't understand why those things. They think, well, you're just being politically correct or you're being overly sensitive or you're being whatever. Right. But again, that's a sort of a denial of the history of what we've gone through and a denial of
SPEAKER_00where we're trying to get to, where I think when it's done well, we're trying to get to the point where we have an appreciation for people with different language, different culture, different background, different ethnicity, and recognize and appreciate what everyone can bring to the table, as opposed to saying, you Do it like me or don't do it at all. You know, we don't need anything different because, again, it's that sort of that hubris of believing that my way is the right way.
SPEAKER_00My way is the vanilla way. You know, my way is just the normal, ordinary way. not realizing that no no you added vanilla to that it's not plain it's not it's not untouched you know like you you do have a perspective and you're bringing that to the background and you're assuming that everything should have this sort of base layer and and that's not the way to appreciate what what your brothers and sisters and neighbors are bringing to the table and so I understand that people sort of get whiplash with sort of the
way things change in
SPEAKER_00our culture, but I think there's some things to kind of sit back and appreciate about where it can be going, where we can take this and appreciate if we have the right perspective.
SPEAKER_01I agree with that so much. I think there's a fear that has a tendency to sneak up whenever change is suggested. And I don't even think it's necessarily a sinful impulse. I think that that fear sometimes just comes from when God is trying to pull you along to something new, there is comfort and safety in what you already know. As I was talking about earlier, I think one of the biggest issues with this is whenever we talk about appreciating
SPEAKER_01culture that someone else brings to the table, the assumption is that I'm going to lose part of my culture if I make space to do that. And that's really just not the case. It's not the way that the kingdom functions. We can kind of jump into this if you like, but it is not assimilation in the kingdom of God. Assimilation would imply that Everyone compromises, someone loses big and now you become something else. But the picture that's painted of the kingdom in the scripture is very different. It's a situation where all of those distinctives get pulled
together in unity, but not erasure.
SPEAKER_01And so everybody benefits from what everybody brings to the table. I remember they used to talk about the great melting pot of the United States of America and how the stew was better because of all the different ingredients that were a part of it, and it wouldn't be the same without every ingredient. That's really a more accurate metaphor for how the kingdom of God is supposed to be. this is all of the different experiences this is all of the different cultures this is all of the different traditions and all of the different languages all of those things coming together and being accentuated highlighted lifted
up celebrated without being destroyed or erased because they're approaching each other in the humility of the shadow of the cross and they are doing so with respect to and with
SPEAKER_01the love of the other based on the example of jesus and That fear that sneaks up inside of us is ignoring how Jesus is going to ask us to do this. The way that the world does unity is by assimilation. You capitulate, right? You get coerced or you coerce. It's a power dynamic. But the way Jesus set up his kingdom is totally different. And so I don't think we have anything to fear about doing this better and continuing to chase this down and pursue it. I think we have everything to gain, really.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, and I think that's exactly right. I'm so glad that you highlighted that, that there is a big difference between the way the world does diversity, the way the world does unity, and the way the church ought to be doing that. And we have this tendency to see everything on this left-right path. liberal conservative spectrum. And it's like, that's not even what we're talking about. We're talking about this earthly versus heavenly spectrum. We're talking about a vertical spectrum, not a horizontal one. And so what we're trying to accomplish here is to appreciate
every language and nation and tribe coming around the throne of God and appreciating the different
SPEAKER_00perspectives that everyone brings, including people from a majority culture. Paul, whether he was talking to a majority Jewish culture or a majority Gentile culture, or he was talking to a majority Greek culture or majority Roman culture, he wasn't saying, hey, if you're Greek, if you're Roman, if you're Jewish, then you just need to shut up and listen to your minority neighbors. He was saying, no, no, no. You're all going to have different perspectives, and you all are valued in the kingdom of God.
And so he says, when I'm with those that are under the law, I become like one under the law. When I'm with those that are not under the law, I become like one that's not under the law.
SPEAKER_00And so he talks about his willingness to appreciate. And live with and eat with, you know, his brothers and sisters and neighbors from every culture because he has an appreciation for the unique perspective that they have and the unique things that they bring to the table. So kind of with that in mind, Marcus, there's a book and this conversation kind of started with our conversation around this book. It's called Reading While Black. And I'm sure that even that title would be provocative to a lot
of people.
SPEAKER_00And there's all different kinds of ways that we could frame that. Esau Macaulay framed it that way, reading while Black. We could say reading while African American. We could say reading while white. We could say reading while European American. We could say reading while Native American. We could say reading while Latin American. We could say all kinds of things. But let's talk specifically about the Black perspective and What is it that you think that the church as a whole can learn,
SPEAKER_00and how can we benefit from a uniquely Black perspective on Scripture? What is it that being an African American, an American of African descent, can help other Christians to see and to know and to understand about being a Christ follower that maybe they wouldn't understand if they didn't have that African American perspective?
SPEAKER_01Great question. And I love Esau's work in this book. I would recommend it to anybody who's interested in wrestling with this a little bit or digging a little bit deeper. I would say that one of the things that he does really well in this book and that I would echo is that one of the offerings coming out of a black theology, a black American theology, is the unity of all peoples in Christ. that actually creates a new humanity,
that that is the goal, a new way of being human. It's interesting to me that there are some contemporary scholars now from different backgrounds and persuasions that are picking up on this theology as they've widened
SPEAKER_01their scope a little bit. But it's an inescapable theme in Scripture, that it was always God's mission from the Old Testament and his dealings with the family of Abraham that they would be a light to the nations, and thereby all nations would flock to the mountain of the house of the Lord, the God of Jacob, and that that is what the kingdom is here to do. And so, In the book of Acts, we really start to see this being borne out with a great wrestling in the New Testament church. Acts chapter 10, 15,
SPEAKER_0116, the Jerusalem council, Peter's interactions with Cornelius, Peter and Paul's interactions in the New Testament. We see that God's mission to bring... God's mission to bring Jew and Gentile, or ethnos, all ethnicities into the family, becomes real, even despite the hesitance of many and the opposition of some. And so we see a model for a thriving multi-ethnic church in Antioch, later in the Book of Acts, the engine that powers the proliferation of the Gospel through the whole world. We see it at its fruition in the innumerable host of every people, nation, and tribe, and tongue together around the throne.
SPEAKER_01And so... When it comes to offerings that everyone needs to hear, I would say that I would look at some of the ways that some iconic passages are read and listened to. If you just take a basic, maybe we'll just call it a post-Enlightenment interpretation, you look at the New Testament and you're liable to come out with a focus on spiritual salvation, which is there.
But a black biblical interpretation would see salvation as both spiritual and social.
SPEAKER_01There's a social justice element to it. The traditional post-enlightenment readings and interpretations are going to lean towards individualistic readings, personal faiths, personal relationships, private morality. Um, but the black interpretation is going to be different. It's going to hit at a communal level, God's justice for whole people groups. Um, that is what you're going to find, uh, someone like Esau Macaulay or others are going to point to when they're dealing with texts, say in Isaiah or specifically the Exodus as well is going to be
a huge theme. Post-Enlightenment interpretation might actually downplay some of the political
SPEAKER_01implications of some texts, but a Black biblical interpretation is going to see a justification for the right kind of resistance to corrupt political structures and power structures. So, there's a lot that's going to be involved if you're gonna look at that perspective with a little bit more depth. I personally believe that the white church in America needs the black perspective, just as the black church in America needs the white perspective because it's the only solution to our blind spots.
The more homogenous we are in our churches and in our theology and our social lives,
SPEAKER_01the more blind spots we have. And those blind spots will not only limit our ability to reach the world around us, which we say is our biggest goal, but they're also a breeding ground for pride and for fear. And I think we're all actually in danger of this. The world of the kingdom opens up so much when you resist the urge to believe that we have arrived and pretty much have it all figured out. That's the most dangerous place that we can be. And I think we need the Black interpretation because I think we're far too comfortable in our segregation.
We sort of deceived ourselves into thinking there's nothing wrong in living these...
SPEAKER_01homogeneous lives, people living in segregated communities, worshiping in segregated churches, attending functionally segregated schools. We imagine in our minds that it's actually okay for Christians, even though the scriptures refute this. And I don't think we see, Wes, how cancerous this subconscious agreement that we've made is and how much it prevents us from being the kind of counterculture that God calls us to be. We don't see how much power and influence we're forfeiting to the world around us by acquiescing to this.
And so I think that all ethnic witnesses are valuable and needed and necessary. But I do think it probably begins with the bridging of the gap between the two most
SPEAKER_01apparent with whom there is the most continuing tension and strife. That is between those of a white heritage and a black American heritage as well. so yeah yeah that's really powerful brother and i really appreciate you especially touching on the idea of segregation and even the idea of like different ways of reading like exodus the there there was this way of of reading so much of the scriptures that so many of us inherited that was just passed down and it becomes
our default way of reading scripture that is what i would call kind of gnostic
SPEAKER_00Because we have over-spiritualized Scripture. And we said, well, you know, Jesus is—he's not really a real king. He's just a spiritual king. You know, the kingdom of God isn't a real kingdom. It's just a spiritual kingdom. He's not talking about real liberation, real freedom. He's just talking about spiritual freedom. And we have over-spiritualized things. And we said, well, this only applies to your religious life, your spiritual life. And that way of thinking was developed in order to justify, once again,
SPEAKER_00justify slavery to say, well, yes, I own this guy over here. I own these people over here. And yes, they're free in Jesus. Like, they're free because Jesus has set them free, but just spiritually. Like, I don't actually have to liberate them physically. I don't have to take the chains off of their hands and feet. But when African descendants that were enslaved read Scripture and listened to the things that God says to his people about freedom,
starting all the way back in Exodus and following through to Philemon and to the
SPEAKER_00New Testament— they saw not only spiritual freedom, not only liberation from sin, but also liberation from these chains, from this bondage, and that this God is a God who sets people free, and that if we are going to belong to this God, then the right thing to do would be to free one another, to set one another free, not just from guilt and shame, but also from the literal bondage that we are experiencing. And so... It was two very different ways of reading Scripture and
listening to one another
SPEAKER_00and loving one another. And as you said, healing those blind spots so that we can see beyond this inherited lens, this inherited hermeneutic that we have received. And so it's so important. But like you said, it's not just... African-American theology and ways of reading Scripture, or white ways of reading Scripture, there are so many different backgrounds and perspectives. That's true of whole people groups and individuals.
SPEAKER_00Marcus Stinson brings something to the text that Wes McAdams needs, and Wes McAdams brings something to the text that Marcus needs. And so we are better for having read Scripture together. But that's also true of communities and backgrounds and ethnic groups and different languages. And we're going to see things in a unique and beautiful ways that is going to help one another when we come to the text.
SPEAKER_01I agree with that so much. It's not an either-or, and that is the paradigm that we've been handed down. We started this conversation talking about essentially what does it mean to be black or white, and how does that affect your approach to the text? Really, look, you need both. You know, fundamentally, you know, Black American theology is not just about a God that can get you to heaven, but that is important, right? It is also about a God who's a liberator and a breaker of chains, and that's just as important that he's a God that interferes
and judges unjust
SPEAKER_01power structures. So I think maybe the way that I might add to what you said about over-spiritualizing, there's a really strong current in Black American theology about a present God who is... um, physically effectual. Not necessarily political, but he is manifesting his kingdom here and now. He's using his mighty arm to bring the wicked low, uh, he's bringing the powerful to nothing, he cares for the poor,
SPEAKER_01he frees the captives, he takes care of widows, and all those actions, a Black interpretation would see the coming of the kingdom on Earth as it is in Heaven. not just a spiritual salvation of souls, but also these accompany the kingdom of heaven too, is probably the best way to put it. Um, and also a God that calls upon his people at times to be the right kind of subversive resistance, uh, to corrupt systems. Um, I use this quote a lot because I think it's applicable on so many different levels.
SPEAKER_01Um, I think that the church is the only place, the only, the only entity capable of taking all of us, all ethnicities in with our different experiences and offerings. It's the only place where incorporation will not equal uniformity. I think that's something only the church can offer the world. And if you believe the Bible, I think we're meant to. And, uh, an old quote by CS Lewis, I think speaks to this, um, C.S. Lewis said after the passing of...
SPEAKER_01of his good friend Ron, he said, uh, in each of my friends, I see something that is... that only some other friend can fully bring out. By myself, I'm not large enough to call the whole man into activity. I want other lights other than my own to show all his facets. Now that Charles is dead, I shall never see Ronald. That's Tolkien's reaction to a specifically Charles joke. far from having more of ronald by having him to myself now that charles is away i have less of ronald in this friendship exhibits a glorious nearness by resemblance to heaven itself where the very multitude of the blessed which
no man can number increases the fruition with eat which each of us has of god for every soul seeing him in her own way doubtless communicates that unique vision to all the rest
SPEAKER_01That, says the old author, is why the Seraphim and Isaiah's vision cry holy, holy, holy to one another. The more thus we share in the heavenly bread between us, the more we shall have. And I love that because what Lewis is saying is that if it takes the presence of multiple people to unlock all the dimensions of a person, to see them clearly and to know them fully, then how much more is that true of Jesus? How much more is that true of God? When the church upholds the vision of the kingdom in Scripture
and crosses ethnic walls,
SPEAKER_01each and every participant is the recipient of incredible blessings, insights, edifications, experiences that they can only have by the humble engagement of our differences together. And it is something that is worthy of being pursued, in my estimation, with much more intentionality and urgency than we've been willing to thus far.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. Oh, that's beautiful. You have such a unique way of saying things, Marcus. It's just poetic and beautiful. Going back to this idea about sort of liberation theology, the unique Black perspective, and I will say, I think this is exactly why these kinds of conversations are so important. I think you would agree with this, that I think that if that gets taken too far, and that is the only perspective that then I think that we might go so far as to only accept the
already and not the not
SPEAKER_00yet of the kingdom of God, and we could empower governments of this world, kingdoms of this world, to try to bring about the utopia of the kingdom of God and say, well, okay, if God wants to set people free right now, then that means we need to empower this government or that government to to set everybody free. We need to endow them, anoint them, appoint them with the power of God to liberate everyone. Ignoring the idea, I think, that this freedom happens when you and I—I mean,
SPEAKER_00Again, Philemon is a beautiful book that I think speaks exactly to this, that it isn't in the Roman authority. It isn't because of Rome's power in order to set the captive free. It is within Philemon's power as he has been empowered by the Holy Spirit. to liberate Onesimus from his slavery and treat him as a brother, treat him as he would the Apostle Paul with the same kind of love and care that he
would give in the same kind of respect that he would give to the Apostle Paul
SPEAKER_00because he's been transformed by the Holy Spirit. That's what happens when the kingdom of God is the already, and we still acknowledge the not yet of the kingdom of God in that all of this is only going to happen when Jesus comes. But when Jesus comes— He better find us getting a head start on liberating one another, of loving one another, of being the kingdom of God on earth as it is in heaven. And so that's where I think that both perspectives are needed. Is the kingdom of God spiritual?
Well, if by spiritual you mean empowered by the Holy Spirit in order to bring about salvation,
SPEAKER_00the will of God on earth as it is in heaven, then yes, it's spiritual. It's spiritual in the fact that we're still waiting for Jesus to appear, who is now in the unseen places, and we're waiting for him to come, but it is already, and it is also physical, and it can be seen in the way that we, empowered by the Holy Spirit, you know, free one another. And there were Christians. That's not to say there weren't white Christians in the 1800s, in the 1700s, that got this and that were freeing their slaves because they
became Christians.
SPEAKER_00And the Spirit filled them and convicted them of their sin, of abusing and enslaving their brothers and sisters and neighbors. And they freed their—that's the kingdom of God coming to bear— On earth as it is in heaven, it's not about making the United States government the kingdom of God. It will never be the kingdom of God. It was never supposed to be the kingdom of God. This is lived out when the church, like you said, acts like the church. And that can only be seen,
those blind spots can only be seen when we listen to each other.
SPEAKER_01Mm-hmm. I don't know if I could agree with what you're saying anymore. I think specifically in the instance of Philemon and Onesimus, you see a picture of how the Spirit does this, and that is... a phrase that I think Tom Wright has coined recently, that the church is to be the small working model of the kingdom
that is not yet.
SPEAKER_01Like, we are supposed to be personally a small working model. This is what a human that has been reborn is supposed to look like and function like and move like through the world. And these family units that are laid out in the book of Ephesians, this is what a family in the kingdom is supposed to look like. This is what the counterculture of the family looks like. And a church body, this is how they function together. And so, all the way down the line, it's not that you don't critique unjust power structures,
it's that the way that you go about changing them is by being the working model of
SPEAKER_01the kingdom here and now, until it reaches its fulfillment in Christ. I love that you said, we better be about being the kingdom. And I think that that is a great bridge between the either all political approach that you're, you know, putting forward here in the last few minutes or the all spiritual approach, which would essentially say, well, the main thing is that their soul gets to heaven and everything else, you know, this is just kind of the created order and the way that it's supposed to go. or even so far as to say more modernly, like, we don't really have to be concerned about these issues because
when it's all said
SPEAKER_01and done, this whole thing's burning up and we're gonna be in heaven anyway. The picture in scripture is very different. Like, no, you, as a city on a hill, as a light in the darkness, are supposed to be showing the world around you what this new humanity looks like. Church, you are supposed to be showing the world around you, and not to our credit, because we haven't done this well, you're supposed to be showing the world around you what this multi-ethnic kingdom looks like. You're supposed to be showing them how this can be, how this works. You're supposed to be showing them the beauty of that.
You're supposed to be an influence on the world around you by bringing these
SPEAKER_01elements together, validating the benefits and value that they each bring, and showing them something different. I still maintain that I don't believe that we as the family of God could ever expect that the secular world has gotten this ethnicity and racial tension thing figured out and healed when we as the people of God have just been far too comfortable to let it be as it is. If we just decided it's not worth...
SPEAKER_01it's not worth the discomfort, it's not worth the awkwardness, we're pretty much fine the way that we are, I don't know why we would ever expect that, uh, you know, our society and our world and culture around us would be any different. We haven't shown them that that's even possible. So, um, I really like that terminology, the small working model of the kingdom here on Earth. I think that's what we should strive for.
SPEAKER_00I love it. I want to read a quote. It's kind of a long quote from Esau McCauley's book, Reading While Black. He said, if we all read the biblical text, assuming that God is able to speak a coherent word to us through it, then we can discuss the meanings our varied cultures have gleaned from the scriptures. What I have in mind then is a unified mission in which our varied cultures turn to the text and dialogue with one another to discern the mind of Christ. That means in the providence of God,
I need Ugandan biblical interpretation because the experiences of Ugandans mean
SPEAKER_00that they are able to bring their unique insights to the conversation. African-American exegesis then precisely because it is informed by the black experience that has the potential to be universal when added to the chorus of believers through time and across cultures thoughts on that quote that that is a bar right there that that is a wonderful summation i think and it occurs relatively
early in the book he does a really good job encapsulating of all the stuff that he's going to unpack
SPEAKER_01from there um man uh adding to the chorus is important to key in on. He's not arguing that it should be the only chorus or that it should replace any music that is already playing, but that there is value to adding all of these different perspectives to the chorus. I think that the quote speaks to me that it's a reality or that
the reality is that
SPEAKER_01it's an allusion to assume that the Bible read through my particular experience, whether that's ethnic, academic, cultural, familiar, socioeconomic, or otherwise, is the only and complete experience that there is. Again, being willing to be in the humble posture of a learner and be asking, what could I gain from being willing to sit and listen and learn is so valuable.
I think just that spirit of self-awareness and humility will take us a long way
SPEAKER_01down this road if we're not afraid of it anymore. That is, I would say. Love that quote. It's probably one of my favorites from the whole book.
SPEAKER_00You know, something just occurred to me as we're talking, and it's a passage, an idea that comes up in my mind a lot, is the Beatitudes and how different Jesus' way of thinking of blessedness was from our, especially, again, Western context— You know, we tend to think, blessed are the rich, blessed are the powerful, blessed are those who, you know, are not persecuted, blessed are those who live a comfortable life. I mean, we say it all the time. We say, I am so blessed to live here, to have this, to have that.
SPEAKER_00And that's not at all how Jesus talked. Jesus never talked like that. He never said, blessed are the rich. He never said, blessed are the comfortable, blessed are the unpersecuted. In fact, he said the exact opposite. He said, blessed are the poor. Blessed are those who are persecuted for righteousness sake. Blessed are those who hunger and thirst. And in Luke's account, we don't even have the sort of nuance of blessed are those who hunger and thirst for righteousness, you know, or blessed are those. But even that is blessed are those who hunger and thirst for the justice of God,
SPEAKER_00who are hungry for God's justice. And again, if we read that in an over-spiritualized way, we think, oh, well, that just means, you know, blessed are those who are hungry and thirsty to be forgiven. Well, yes, that's true. But it's probably more like those Jewish people who are sitting there persecuted by the Roman overlords for year after year after year, decade after decade after decade, waiting for God's justice. And they are hungry for the justice of God.
I can't even really understand that text because I have never truly myself
SPEAKER_00personally hungered and thirsted for justice. I've never been in a situation where I've had to be hungry and thirsty for God's justice because man's justice had failed me over and over and over again, and I need the justice of God. And so, I need to listen to the people that Jesus says are the blessed ones. Come, you who are hungry and thirsty for justice, teach me about the kingdom of God. Come, you who are poor, teach me about God's riches.
SPEAKER_00You who are persecuted for righteousness' sake, come, teach me about God and how the prophets were persecuted in like fashion. So, I benefit as a wealthy European descendant, as somebody who has lived a comfortable life, who belongs to a family for the most part, have lived a relatively, by world standards, comfortable life. I need the perspective of my brothers and sisters around the world, in my own neighborhood and around the world,
SPEAKER_00who come from different perspectives that Jesus says are blessed today. And I need to listen to them because there are things that they know by experience that I can only know secondhand, but I need to know.
SPEAKER_01Amen. That is beautiful. I couldn't help by thinking while you were, you were talking and enumerating the things that we don't experience being from relatively well-off, you know, middle-class America. Um, yeah. Anybody who's been on a real mission trip probably has gotten a taste of this from a different angle. I remember being blown away by my friends that I made in Kenya
and the way that
SPEAKER_01they saw the world. and their generosity and pit that against our penny-pinching here and our anxiety and our worry here. People that I perceived didn't have anything had way more than I had. And you'll often hear this opinion, and I learn more from them than they probably have learned from me. And I come teaching doctrine, you know? But I've learned so much from them about what it means to be brothers and sisters in the kingdom and striving together.
And I don't think that's just because they're an exceptional group of people that I
SPEAKER_01got to, you know, meet with and do kingdom work with. Now they are, but I think that's because it's a fundamental principle in our life experience. Yeah, I think it's something that we experience every time we open ourselves up and get outside of the walls that we build to protect ourselves. We find that those walls weren't really protecting us. They were confining us. They were keeping us limited. Who knows what God will do?
SPEAKER_00But let me ask you one last question, the question I like to ask at the end of this series to everybody who's been a guest. If you could give people one piece of advice to be a better student of Scripture, what would it be?
SPEAKER_01Oh, man, that's tough. Well, we're a few episodes into this series now, so a lot of really good answers have been taken. So... I might give you a 1A and a 1B if I could. And 1A is don't be afraid to ask really difficult questions. And it's been my experience that in Scripture when something
rubs me the wrong way
SPEAKER_01or I don't understand something, our gut instinct is to try and subdue it or dissolve it or solve the problem immediately. But we're meant to wrestle with this book. We're meant to wrestle with this text. We're meant to wrestle because that's what gets us out of our limited perspective. And so I would say, please don't be afraid to ask really difficult questions. Underneath of those difficult questions is always, always a treasure. And God is not afraid of your questions.
SPEAKER_01He is welcoming them. And so 1B alongside of that would be, Take the opportunity to study the Bible with someone from a different ethnic background. If you really want to see how this can be effectual and beneficial, I'm confident it'll only take one or two times sitting down across the table from someone or, you know, in your living room and just breaking open a passage and really just chewing on it together, that you are going to see that there's a whole world of insight and Spirit-led growth and development that hasn't been available to you before
because you've been
SPEAKER_01confined to your own individualistic approach to the Scripture. Just... Take my word for it and sit down with someone from a totally different background from you. It will be a beautiful, challenging, enriching experience.
SPEAKER_00Amen. Marcus, you bless me every time we get to hang out and spend time together. I look forward to spending some time face-to-face with you, but thank you for making time for this conversation, and thank you for your work in the kingdom, brother.
SPEAKER_01Thank you, brother. I appreciate it so much, and that is a two-way street. I love you, and I'm very thankful for you and all you do.
SPEAKER_00Thanks, brother. Thank you so much for listening to the Radically Christian Bible Study Podcast. I hope you found this conversation to be encouraging. And if you did, would you mind taking a moment to rate and review this podcast on Apple Podcasts or Spotify or wherever you're listening, or even taking a moment to share this episode on social media? We want as many people as possible to find the same encouragement that you found. Before we close, I want to take a moment to thank my McDermott Road Church family who helps make this podcast possible. If you live in or you're traveling through the Dallas area,
we would love for you to worship with us at the Church of Christ on McDermott Road
SPEAKER_00in Plano, Texas. Now, let's all go out and love like Jesus.
The Spirit is often the member of the Godhead we talk about least, and when we do, He can feel more like a doctrine to manage than a Person to know. In this conversation from the 412 Christian Podcast, Wes joins hosts...
What if the vocabulary you inherited for salvation has left you more anxious than assured? Justification, sanctification, saved: many believers learned these words as tidy categories, and many sincere Christians still...
What does it actually mean to be baptized in the Holy Spirit? For many who grew up in the Restoration Movement, the phrase meant a debate about water baptism or a defensive argument about miraculous gifts, and then the...
If we’re saved by grace through faith, why does baptism still matter? An elder in Tennessee wrote in with a question many Christians are asking. If love is the heart of everything, is baptism just a ritual tacked on, a...
Is gluttony only about what is on your plate? Most of us assume we know the answer, and most of us feel a little uncomfortable when the subject comes up. The Bible mentions gluttony far less than many Christians expect,...