Why do we struggle so much to remain united? On this episode, Wes and Marcus dig into why division spreads so easily inside the church. Underneath the arguments over politics, worship styles, and personal convictions, there is often something more personal: fear, cultural blind spots, and the belief that being right is what keeps us safe with God. Is unity the same thing as agreement? What’s the difference between a conviction worth defending and one we’ve quietly turned into a test of fellowship? Marcus even introduces a memorable way of sorting theological issues (borrowed from his wife) that might just change how you think about your own dividing lines and what it really means to walk in unity with people who see things differently. Links and Resources: * Extended Free Trial of Logos Bible Study Software * Books by Wes McAdams * VidAngel Special Offer This description contains affiliate links. If you purchase through these links, we may earn a small commission at no additional cost to you. We only recommend resources we genuinely believe in. This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit www.radicallychristian.com
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_01Welcome to the Radically Christian Podcast. Here we have one goal, learn to love like Jesus. Today I am with my co-host as always, Marcus Stinson. Marcus, good to hang out with you, brother.
SPEAKER_00It's a good day, man. Happy to be here with you. We are getting into the weeds today. I have to say, get into the weeds.
SPEAKER_01We asked for people to submit things that they wanted us to talk about. And one of the things that was the most popular response or the most popular question that people wanted us to address is this idea of division. So let's talk about division. We'll talk about unity. Obviously the opposite of division is unity and oneness. But let's start with the problem first and talk about division. And first, how do you see, where do you see division happening in the church?
SPEAKER_00Man, I see division happening everywhere in the church. That's really not an understatement, and that's because, I mean, I think that the church, for what we are as a community of people, of God's people, sometimes we try to insulate ourselves away from the issues of life, and we come through those doors, and we show up to worship, and we smile, shake a hand, say, I'm fine. But all of the stresses, all of the baggage come through the doors with us. And unfortunately, sometimes it's not until those really hot temperature moments
SPEAKER_00where we see how divided we actually are. But we live in a divided world. We live in a world that runs on division and just never gets enough of it, just hungry for division. And so all of the political divisions have weaseled their way. Bled their way into congregational life. There's doctrinal division inside of the church. There's division between different people groups and ethnicities and cultural strata.
SPEAKER_00And even just like at a joking level, there's a certain expectation For people from the South, or from the Bible Belt community, or from the Pacific Northwest, or from the Northeast, and what they're supposed to be like, and how they act, and what they find most important, and what is better about Southern hospitality than those cold-shouldered folks up in the North. Like, there's division about almost any and everything, and our churches, Are not immune, and unfortunately, in too many cases, we seem to lead the way for people that are supposed to be defined by our unity.
SPEAKER_00And I hope that's not too broad of an answer for you, Wes, but I see it in almost every facet.
SPEAKER_01It's so true, and I'm glad you brought out so many of those things, because nobody would ever say, look, I don't like these people, or I don't like people like this because they're from the North, or I don't like them because they're from the South, or I don't like them because of their ethnicity, or whatever. And if anyone would ever say that out loud, what they would say is, I have a problem with the way they do X, Y, and Z, which is exactly what was happening in the first century. It wasn't like the Jewish Christians were saying, I don't like them because they're Gentile. So it was seen as being a doctrinal issue or a practice issue, but it really came down
SPEAKER_01And we'll get more into this later, but it came down to opinions and conclusions. It came down to culture. And I think so often there are cultural differences between individuals, between congregations, between people in different regions and different ethnicities. And we chalk it up to saying, well, they're wrong about X, Y, and Z. I don't dislike them because of their ethnicity. I don't dislike them because of their region. I dislike what they're doing. I dislike these practices. When we don't realize that we're actually viewing our own And there's a lot of that
SPEAKER_01that plays into the way that we look at our own practices and the way that we look at other people's practices. Everything from the way we eat to what we eat to how we worship to where we worship. And I assume that my way is right and their way is weird and wrong.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, man, that's a good point for us to kind of kick around here at the very beginning, because I think what gets us in trouble, like, we really come honestly by it, um, we're not very culturally aware. Which sounds weird, because there's so much emphasis on culture, and we're talking about it all the time. But just by and large, no matter who you are, you come to the table with sort of a cultural paradigm and you don't think about the fact that you come to the table with a cultural paradigm. It is just the right way of doing things. And that is something that comes to us all naturally because we grew up in
SPEAKER_00that paradigm and we learned how to do things, quote, unquote, the right way within that framework and those rules for life. And it's just almost a reflex, without even thinking, that we project that onto other people and we project those expectations onto other people. And it happens with more than culture, too. Just our cultural, you know, idiosyncrasies that come out. And I think that's part of the root for some of our division, is just not being aware of that. I think some of it goes deeper.
SPEAKER_00I think that inside each and every one of us, one of the things that the gospel has to heal is this sort of fear-based default setting. And I think that any time the chief motivation underneath of our behavior and the way that we think about things is something that we're afraid of, we run the risk of being divided in all sorts of ways instead of being united because we're always on the That we never feel safe. That is something that Jesus offers us, that the gospel offers us, complete and total security. But if we're not thinking about that and we're not focused on that,
SPEAKER_00enter in opportunities for divisions to come through all the different cracks that fear creates in our life.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Oh, man, that's so good. I want to come back to that when we talk more about unity in just a second. Because imagine how at peace we could be with one another if we were at peace with God and at peace within ourselves. But when we're afraid, when we're fearful, we are anxious. And when we're anxious, we treat each other poorly, especially when we're afraid of the other person or we're afraid of what they're doing. We use arguments all the time like, well, that's a slippery slope and I don't necessarily agree.
SPEAKER_01I don't necessarily think what they're doing is wrong, but it's going to lead to this and it's going to lead to that and it's going to lead to this. And we start panicking about where things might be going if we let them have their foot in the door. I mean, When we started this conversation, we were talking about the history of division before we hit record. We were talking about the history of division within the Restoration Movement, within Churches of Christ. But it goes back long before the Campbells, long before Stone. It goes back all the way to the first century. The first century churches were divided. And I want to think for just a second about that Jewish-Gentile relationship,
SPEAKER_01because that's one of the first real divisions within the Church that Paul and others preached against that sort of division. And I empathize with my Jewish brothers and sisters because these people were deeply religious, and they came to a faith in Jesus as the Messiah as a continuation, not as a departure from their faith of their childhood. This is a continuation of our faith, and this is just the next chapter in the story of Abraham and his descendants.
SPEAKER_01And they saw what they were doing as being faithful to the God of their forefathers. But then, all of a sudden, now these Gentiles get grafted into the family, and you're telling me that I have to sit across from these pig-eating people? Are you kidding me? These dirty, nasty Gentiles? They don't even care about our history. They don't care about our culture. I can't even imagine what's going to happen in 10 years or 20 years or 30 years if we just keep letting these Gentiles come into our family and wreck all
SPEAKER_01of our traditions and just disregard the law of Moses. I really empathize with that position. And I probably would have felt exactly the same way to say, we are standing up for what's right here. We're holding the line from what was passed down to us, not just from our forefathers, but from God himself. And just because we believe They were so afraid that they ended up not loving one another. They ended up being divided from one another, and that was the real thing.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, you can continue to circumcise your children, you can continue to keep the Sabbath, you can continue to eat kosher food, but not accepting your brothers and sisters in Christ is not an option. If you want to continue in the faith, if you want to continue in the family, you can't be divided from one another.
SPEAKER_00Man, there's no better place to start our conversation, really, than with that New Testament church because what you just drew out, I think, applies to us more than we realize. And what I would really like to just think about for a few seconds is that sort of situation that the Jewish brothers and sisters found themselves in where their entire, you know, life Was wrapped up in this way of life that has come down from the God of us all.
SPEAKER_00It's ancient, it's unmoving, it's unchanging. And they've been living in what really amounts to a hostile world for most of their entire history. And the one thing that they always had to hold on to was their tradition and their heritage. This is what makes us different. This is what makes us special. This is what gives us value. We have the temple. We have the promises. We have the ordinances. We have the sacrifices. We have the law. And if not for that, we're just like everybody else.
SPEAKER_00And so the fear, the great fear that shows up in the New Testament is that if we let go of this, who are we really?
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_00The fear of being assimilated into something that doesn't offer you the same familiar, safe confines that you have been reaching for your entire life and straining for your entire life would be terrifying to anybody. So I want to give some grace for the situation that they're in. As a people that was constantly under threat of being assimilated and even had to assimilate in some ways into other cultures, holding on to their heritage, their tradition, It was something that I actually empathize with quite a bit.
SPEAKER_00Now, the real caveat, or I guess the real paradox is that unity in Christ means that assimilation doesn't happen when you come into the community of God. Actually, your distinctives just get explored and enriched at an exponential level where the entire community benefits from the heritage and the tradition that you bring and the culture that you bring to the table. But that wasn't quite yet understood in those early days. I think about Peter. Who in one breath could preach to Cornelius and then go back and defend his actions
SPEAKER_00in front of the Jerusalem council and say, look, God is doing the same thing among the Gentiles that he's doing with us. Yes, I went in this house. Yes, I ate with him. Yes, I would do it again and you should too. And then at the same time, not quite fully grasping the full implication of what that means in practice by the time he shows up. And Paul has to call him out to his face in Antioch. So there are levels to this, starting at an intellectual recognition down to the implications that it means in my heart, and then functionally how I live this every single day.
SPEAKER_00And every single one of those levels is a place where fear and division can sneak in. So, yes, let's give grace to those early Christians. Let's give a little bit of grace to ourselves, but let's strive continually to be more and more aware of how these divisions happen and why they don't have to, right?
SPEAKER_01So well said. I also want to think about, just for a second, Corinth and this primarily Gentile church and how they were divided, not over the same sorts of things that churches in Galatia were dividing over or in Rome were dividing over, they were more divided over the Because they allowed the way of thinking of the world to seep into the church, they were still doing things the way they did on the streets in Corinth, and that is they rallied around a philosopher,
SPEAKER_01a teacher, a leader, somebody who was strong And they said, I'm of this person. And then they vilified and demonized everybody who wasn't part of that group. And then they did that exact same thing in the church. And they were rallying around different teachers, different leaders and saying, well, this guy, he's really smart. And Paul says, this is not okay. This is not the game. We don't play that game in the church. But I think about the way we are doing things now, and we've done exactly the same thing. And I always ask Christians, if it's wrong for the church to be divided over...
SPEAKER_01Secular or over religious leaders and saying, I'm of Marcus, I'm of Wes, I follow this teacher, I follow that teacher. If that's wrong for us to be divided over religious leaders, how much worse would it be for Christians to be divided over secular leaders to say, I'm of this politician, I'm of that politician, I belong to this party, I belong to that faction. And if you're not part of my faction, if you're not part of my party, if you don't follow the same leader, you're dead to me. Man, if it's wrong for me to rally around a preacher,
SPEAKER_01how much worse is it for me to rally around a politician? But yet we think, that's okay. Again, because we compartmentalize our life, and we think, well, that has nothing to do with my And I'm afraid it's exactly what's happening in the church today.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, man. Astute observation there. And I would just add to it by saying that, for me, I've recognized that the places where this happens are the places where I secretly or deep down don't trust Jesus as sufficient.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Yeah, that's so good.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, it's convicting to me. The things that I'm extraordinarily defensive about to an order of magnitude great enough that I would be divisive about it, it's because I haven't given something fully to Jesus in that way. A second, you know, way that I recognize that in my own heart is when I'm incapable of criticizing something or receiving criticism about something. If it's above criticism in my mind, then it's on a throne that only God should actually sit on. That which I cannot criticize, I worship.
SPEAKER_00And that who I cannot criticize owns me. And I'm supposed to be owned by only one person.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_00The only one that actually paid for me. And so, when I think about it that way, it's usually a good sort of sieve or a filter for me when I get a little bit out of pocket and start holding too tightly, sort of in that Corinthian style that you're talking about. Something from the world has caught my attention or roused my fear or my discomfort. Something that I'm insecure about often is the way that this takes place. And that's where I become rife for the same type of division that we see in the scriptures. Not to my credit,
SPEAKER_01Yeah, that's so good. And I'm so glad you keep bringing that back to fear and how unity, let's start talking more about unity, how unity really is founded in and based in and rooted in. Built upon a foundation of salvation by grace through faith. This is Paul's, I think Paul's game, not game, but this is Paul's strategy with the book of Romans. Like he's writing this to churches in Rome that are incredibly divided
SPEAKER_01and they're divided along ethnic lines between Jewish congregations and Gentile congregations meeting in different house churches and they are divided from one another. And so he spends the first half of the book All about how we are saved by the grace of God. We have all sinned and fallen short of God's glory. Everybody has. Yes, you're right. You Jewish believers, you're right in saying that the Romans and the Greeks and all of these nasty Gentiles, they've all fallen short of God's glory. Because they stopped worshiping the Creator and started worshiping the creation.
SPEAKER_01You're right. And they've fallen short of God's glory. But how about you, Jews? And he turns the table and he says, you have too. We have too. We have also sinned. We had the law and we didn't do what the law required us to do. We've all sinned and fallen short of God's glory. And the only way for us to be reconciled to God, to be justified in God's sight, is for us to accept this gift that he's given us. And it's not by works. And we cannot boast. That has to undergird everything that we're talking about. Because I think sometimes we believe that we are saved,
SPEAKER_01we are in a right relationship with God, and we can only be in a right relationship with each other. If I'm right about everything and you're right about everything, well then we can have a relationship. But if you're wrong about something, Marcus, I can't be in a relationship with you because my relationship with you, just like my relationship with God, is based on being right about everything. That's not the gospel. In fact, that's heresy, and we need to repent of that. And the only way that we can be in a right relationship with God, and therefore the basis of our relationship with each other,
SPEAKER_01must be on the basis of God's free gift of grace.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, man. You're threatening to get to some touchy territory here, but let's dig a little bit. What you just said. One level beyond me only being able to be in a right relationship with God if I'm right about everything and a right relationship with you if you agree with everything that I think that I'm right about, really gets exposed, I think, because somewhere down the line, the question gets asked, like, if I have to bear with this brother who disagrees with me on XYZ topic,
SPEAKER_00And my right stance or my conception, my evaluation, my understanding of my relationship with God and my salvation status is rooted in my belief that I'm right about everything. It creates cognitive dissonance for me if Wes has a different opinion. Therefore, if he doesn't agree, either I'm not as safe as I feel like I want to be, because clearly it's a possibility that I'm not right about everything, or He's just wrong and intentionally mishandling the word of God
SPEAKER_00and therefore he should be cast out. So this type of approach that you just outlined actually creates fertile soil for division over every conceivable topic. And I mean everything. Because if I think that the reason that I'm okay with God is because I have everything right, I would love to say that we'd be really good at drawing the distinction that I have everything right according to scripture on what I would call essential doctrines or spine issues.
SPEAKER_00Maybe I'll share a little bit more about that metaphor that I stole from my wife here in a little bit. But it extends to everything because of the fear that we were just talking about. If you grow up in that ethos, the only reason that I'm safe is because I attend here And we do everything the right way and any deviation from that is not the right way. Then even a conversation over whether we should have pews or chairs is not a conversation over whether pews or chairs would be the best option
SPEAKER_00for this particular community of God's people based on what we want to do with the building and what we're going to use it for to glorify God. It is an attack on my personal salvation. It will be received as an attack on my right standing with God if I have to give up the ground that the way that I've done everything for so long, believing that this is the only way that it's going to be okay, now gets shaken. Even if I get to a place where I'm willing to admit, well, maybe I don't need to be as dogmatic about that,
SPEAKER_00another layer of this enters because you will start to ask the question, well, Does that mean that the people that I love and revere and have looked up to and have taught me for so many years were also wrong? And if they were wrong in this one point, what of their eternal destiny? And so just starting from that assumption creates a veritable spiritual minefield that it's really hard to escape from without kind of reframing the way we think
SPEAKER_00about Our relationship with God and what that means and how it calls us to relate to one another and what role grace actually plays in this thing. And unless we get to the Roman-style approach, we'll always be trapped by that minefield and division will continue.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. And you mentioned Romans, and I think we have to talk about Romans 14. I've come to the conclusion, we might talk about a definition of unity. I've come to the conclusion that unity is about alignment, not necessarily agreement. There's a difference between alignment and agreement. I can be aligned with someone even when I don't agree with them. My wife and I, for instance, are always aligned, but sometimes not in agreement. And that's okay. We are aligned.
SPEAKER_01We can be aligned because we know who we are. We know what we're committed to. We know where we're headed. We know why we're headed there. And so we can be aligned. We can be headed in the same direction and committed to going to that place together. We don't always agree along the way. You can be on a journey with someone as long as you're aligned with them even if you don't agree with them on everything. You can be in the same car and have a disagreement but as long as you are aligned about where you're going and what it is that you're doing,
SPEAKER_01you can continue to travel together. And that's what Paul is encouraging in Romans. He's saying there is a difference between those who have faith and those who don't have faith You're not part of the same family. In order to be part of the same family, you have to give yourself to Jesus in faith. And if you give yourself to Jesus in faith, if you hear the Word and you have faith in Him, faith comes by hearing, and hearing by the Word of Christ, and you come to that saving faith in Him, you pledge your allegiance to Him in baptism, You die with him in the waters.
SPEAKER_01You're raised to live in newness of life. Then you are family. But you're not always going to agree. And he says in Romans chapter 14, when you have brothers and sisters with whom you have differences of opinion, Welcome each other. Now we hear opinion and we think of something trivial. Like we think, wow, yeah, Marcus, you're exactly right. Pews and chairs, that's a trivial opinion. And we shouldn't be divided over trivial opinions like that. Paul is not talking about trivial opinions. He is talking about deeply held convictions.
SPEAKER_01And for some people, pews might be a deeply held conviction. But if you think that's trivial, then don't think about that example. Think about an example of something you hold deeply because you have still And you have come to this conclusion. And you admit, Scripture doesn't explicitly say this, but I've studied this out, and here's the conclusion I've come to. I could talk about my conviction of not using instruments and singing with our voices. That's a deeply held religious conviction that I have.
SPEAKER_01The Jewish Christians in the first century had come to some deeply held convictions about the holidays that they celebrated, about the holidays they didn't celebrate, about the food that they eat, the food that they don't eat. And the Romans didn't share those same convictions. The Gentiles didn't share those same convictions. And Paul says, here's what you do. You welcome each other as brothers and sisters in Christ. Why? Because Christ welcomed you. And so our accepting of one another is on the same basis of Christ's accepting of us.
SPEAKER_01He accepted us even while we were his enemies. He accepted us on the basis, not that we got everything figured out, not that we're right about everything, but that we have put our faith in Jesus as the King. And if you're following Jesus and I'm following Jesus, then we are aligned. And if we are aligned on those core fundamental things, on the seven ones that Paul lays out in Ephesians, if we have the same Lord and the same faith and the same baptism, then we are family. And there are going to be a lot of things on which we are dealing We're in disagreement, and that's okay.
SPEAKER_01But we love each other. We don't have to be divided just because we disagree.
SPEAKER_00Oh, man. I love the phrase that you kicked that off with in saying that unity is about alignment, not agreement. Now, certainly, there will be more agreement than not, but it's about our alignment. What are we actually loyal to? What is our allegiance in? That's sort of a concept that we talk about a lot here on RC. You know what really helps me? There's a metaphor that Maggie actually gave me, and I just have a tendency to run with metaphors. That's kind of my thing, Marcus's metaphors, I guess. But when I think through conversations like this,
SPEAKER_00I'm thinking about unity and I'm thinking about the issues that surround these divisions. She once said during one of our conversations, actually pretty early on, we're studying the scripture together. And we were talking about some of the differences in the tradition that she grew up in versus, you know, where we're at here in the Churches of Christ and the Restoration Movement. And she said, oh, so these are like rib and spine issues. I was like, what is that? And she's like, well, you know, like a rib and a spine. Spine issues are issues that are crippling, horribly disfiguring, and ultimately they're fatal if they're broken, just like your back.
SPEAKER_00If your spine is out of whack, you cannot move together, right? But then there's rib issues, right? And rib issues are not necessarily fatal. They can be extraordinarily painful, but they're not sustainable because they can worsen and deteriorate if they're not addressed or cared for. But they're not really matters of life and death. There's no reason you can't go on with, like, a broken rib. I thought this was brilliant, because I started to think about some of the divisions, some of the usual suspects that we have,
SPEAKER_00and I started to ask, which of these are spine issues? Which of these are rib issues? Which of these are rib issues that we have made into spine issues? Right? And then, because I couldn't stop there, I just decided I was gonna add another one. I added the pinky toe designation to this. So I got rib, spine, and pinky toe designations. Why? Because there's nothing more painful, yet not fatal, than stoving your toe on the corner of a table. And when I stove my foot on the corner of a table, it's actually my fault. I've incurred this injury because of something of my doing,
SPEAKER_00my lack of perspective, my lack of awareness, and I have no one to blame but myself. Even though I will probably blame whoever put the table there, the fault is really my own, even though it was accidental. I have to own it. And when I stove my foot on a table, It's an even louder volume decibel increase than there would be from stepping on a Lego, which is the second most terrible non-lethal pain that you can experience. And everybody is gonna hear about the fact that I stowed my toe in the house, right? Everyone knows.
SPEAKER_00It's not fatal. It's not anyone else's fault. And it'll cause you to walk funny, but ultimately this is a small thing. And I think there are a lot of theological issues that have a remarkable and uncanny way of fitting this metaphor. There are for sure definite spine issues. They are essential. They are essential to the faith. They are clearly outlined in the scripture that they are essential to your eternal destiny and your standing with God. They are the non-negotiables. There are rib issues which are important, sort of secondary elements that are important in the Bible for someone
SPEAKER_00who is striving with all their might to be faithful to Jesus and walk as he walked and be a community of people that are operating in the world and making an impact on the world the way that we're intended to. And then there are a lot of toe issues that are personal. And these are things that God leaves for us to decide as personal preferences or truths. There's a lack of a decisive statement or command or even evidence or example either way. And it's just up to my conscience and me dwelling with my brother knowing
SPEAKER_00that he's got his own toe issues too. Now, if I go about forcing all of my toe issues that I find painful to be spine issues in the body in which I'm a part, I am now causing division. Because I lack the discernment to know the difference between those three, if that makes sense. So think of concentric circles, right, with the essential doctrines of the faith in the center, important doctrines for formational or spiritual formation and discipleship,
SPEAKER_00even worship on the outer ring. And then outside of that, the stuff that I just feel really strongly about. And we might not agree, Wes, on those toe issues, but if I keep stowing my toe and my brotherhood with you about it, that's actually my fault, because I know the table is there. I should let you be received by the Lord the same way I've been received by the Lord, knowing that He's going to sort it out, and you'll give a count, and I'll give a count, like Paul says there in Romans 14.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, yeah. In fact, what is the verb that you say about when you hit your toe on something? What's that word you're saying?
SPEAKER_00The verb that I say when I hit my toe? I don't think that's appropriate for the podcast.
SPEAKER_01No, no, you said, what do you do to your toe when you hit it? What's that word you use? It starts with an S. Stove
SPEAKER_00it or stub it?
SPEAKER_01Stove it. See, I say stub it. And so, you know, there's a difference of opinion right there.
SPEAKER_00That might be regional. That might be like Coke, Pop, and Fizz. By the way, if you say Fizz, never listen to this podcast ever again. I'm just kidding. But... It's unacceptable in 2026 now. But yeah, that might be one of those cultural bands that you're talking about, I'm sure. There you go.
SPEAKER_01So I accept you. I love you. I embrace you as my brother, even though you say stove and I say stub. So I'm not sure which came from which or which one's right or wrong, but I'm going to stick with mine, but I'm going to love you anyway. That's a great example.
SPEAKER_00You know what? It might be like a phalange-specific conversation because I will stove a finger but stub a toe. Is that? Oh, interesting. Does that sound official? Maybe. I don't know. Someone hit us up in the comments and let me know if I'm just crazy. I could be.
SPEAKER_01I don't know. No, but I love this distinction. And we have to make this distinction between things that are a matter of opinion or a matter of faith or a spine issue, a rib issue, whatever, however you want to frame that. But Paul lays these things out, too. Some One thing I think we have to hit on, though, is when Paul lists out things that are unacceptable, like you cannot do these things and be part of the family, you cannot do these things, you cannot hold these positions,
SPEAKER_01you cannot be this kind of a person and expect to inherit the kingdom of God, amongst lots of other things, including things like sexual immorality and, of course, disbelief and unfaithfulness, all of these things— Amongst those lists almost every time is divisiveness. Like being divisive is something you will lose your soul over. Like this is a matter of doctrine. Unity is a matter of doctrine. Love is a matter of doctrine. In fact, these are chief doctrines.
SPEAKER_01And so sometimes we get all caught up in our pet projects, our pet doctrines, our pet ideas, our rib issues, our pinky toe issues. We get so caught up in these things that we forget that a spine issue Paul warns people, Titus chapter 3, he tells this preacher, warn a divisive person once, and then warn him a second time, and after that have nothing to do with him because he's warped, he's sinful, he's self-condemned.
SPEAKER_01And I think we also have to acknowledge that addressing divisiveness, calling people out for their divisiveness, warning people, you can't be like that, you can't act that way, is not itself divisive. It's not being divisive To call people out for dividing the body of Christ. We need to be able to do that. And I think sometimes the most loving, joyful, peaceful, patient, kind people are avoiding conflict. I mean, who likes conflict? I don't like conflict. None of us like conflict.
SPEAKER_01But it's not causing conflict to deal with it because that divisive person is doing real harm to the body of Christ. And that cancer of divisiveness needs to be cut out. And we cannot just tolerate it and say, well, you know, that's just the kind of the way this person is. He's pretty divisive. He's pretty abrasive. He's pretty dogmatic. He just calls it like he sees it. That's not okay. And sometimes we give a pass to those kinds of people because we think,
SPEAKER_01well, they're more, quote-unquote, conservative than I am. Well, that's not conservative. Like, that's not conserving the doctrine and the way of Christ by being dogmatic and abrasive and divisive. That is unacceptable behavior that is not aligned with the truth, with the doctrine of the body of Christ.
SPEAKER_00Man, it's wild to me that you use the metaphor there for cancer, because as you were speaking, I was thinking, it's like cancer. If it is not dealt with, all it will do is it will grow. It will grow and it will spread, and before you know it, you have a full-blown division on your hands because it wasn't nipped in the bud when it was first detected. And that's an uncomfortable position to be in. It's never comfortable to go under the knife, so to speak, but it is absolutely necessary in some instances. I like to think of it this way. I'm guilty of both errors of omission and errors of commission.
SPEAKER_00And what I am more likely to address and what I'm more likely to take action against are errors of commission. Those are the things that I do, and I want to do them correctly, right? I do not want to do them wrong. And I think we're pretty good at this, especially in our fellowship. I think we're pretty good at making sure that we are wanting to do things the right way. But errors of omission are almost always twice as bad. Almost always. And it's like an error of omission is when you don't do something that you ought to do.
SPEAKER_00And the void that is created by that is always catastrophic and tragic. When we don't confront divisiveness, when we don't exhume or excise the cancer, when you don't swing on the third strike, it's always twice as bad than if you at least went down swinging, you know? Maybe you approach a brother in love and you have a conversation with them. And you explain to them, I understand that you feel really strongly about this, but we are bordering on some divisiveness now, and I think we should adjust our perspective here,
SPEAKER_00at least our approach in how we're trying to be heard. And maybe he doesn't hear you, but at least you took the swing. At least, like Ezekiel would say, the blood isn't on your hands as the watchman who let this thing continue to grow and blow up an entire community. And I think it's way more important than we think about, because going back to what we first started talking about, Wes, We have accepted the idea that our rightness is the defining characteristic and quality about us spiritually and relationally, our rightness.
SPEAKER_00But I would push back on that because even Jesus himself, when he talks about our purpose, our mission in the world, what he wants us to be and do, told the disciples before he went to the cross in that high priestly prayer that it is going to be their unity that will let the world know that I have been sent by you. The world will know that you sent me. Because they are one. Because they're unified. So every time we are divided,
SPEAKER_00every time we allow divisiveness to continue and run amok unchecked, then we are betraying the actual witness that Jesus has entrusted to us. That's why it's a spine issue. That's why it's a salvation issue. And I'm just thankful that you termed it that way.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, it's so true. It's so true. And we have to recognize that this is a difficult conversation because it's the Spirit. It's the Spirit who creates unity. It's the Spirit who marks us out as belonging to God. Like you said, Jesus said, they will know that you're my disciples by the love that you have for one another. And he prays, Father, make them one so that the world will know that you sent me. Paul says in Galatians 5, The mark, the fruit of the Spirit, that's what marks you as belonging to God.
SPEAKER_01It's the love and the joy and the peace and the patience and the kindness and goodness. That's what is the indicator. Oh, you're one of God's people. You bear the family resemblance. I see your Father in you because of your love and your joy and your peace and your patience. That's what marks people out. Not, they agree with me on everything, therefore they must be okay. And we typically go by the things that we can measure and say, well,
SPEAKER_01they do this right and they do that right and they teach the right thing on this. And what we mean is they do things the way I like. They hold the line that I like. If a congregation is not known And we need to start recognizing that if a congregation is abrasive and cruel
SPEAKER_01and divisive and they're always talking about everybody else and how everybody's doing everything wrong and they're known for what they're against and not what they're for, that is not a healthy, sound church. Fruit-filled congregation. The Spirit of God is not—they're not at least embracing and walking in the Spirit as long as they have that spirit of envy and rivalry and dissension and division. That is not of Christ. James would say that's wisdom from below. That's earthly.
SPEAKER_01It's unspiritual. It's demonic-type wisdom rather than the wisdom that's from above.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, man. That's heavy, what you just laid down right there. I almost hesitate to even add anything to that right there because... I struggle sometimes. I really do. I think we all do to some extent. I read Jesus and his repeated affirmations that it is gonna be by their fruit that you know them. Yeah. And then... I think what we can do is we can often swap what fruits we're willing to accept.
SPEAKER_00There are some of us who only will eat apples. And if it's not an apple, I don't want it. I'll just cast it out. And we will discard a whole lot of other fruit that is being produced. And there are some of us who aren't producing any fruit at all. And yet, we would be really critical of others that And I would just say, with no dogmatic or critical spirit about anyone's eternal status in regard to those two situations that I just brought out, just please,
SPEAKER_00can we take pause before we sit in God's chair and start adjudicating and legislating without taking into account the fruit that is being produced? And if our fruit is consistently division, Then we have some self-inventory to do, and we have some serious corrections to make. And might I say, we have some planks to deal with before we go about plucking splinters from somebody else. Yeah.
SPEAKER_01It's exhausting, isn't it? And I know. I'm not pointing my finger at anybody or looking down my nose at anybody. I'm saying this from personal experience. It's exhausting trying to do God's job. Let God be God. Let God be the judge. And that's exactly what Paul lays out in Romans 14 and 15. Who are you to stand in judgment of your brother? Yeah, you have this conviction and I'm not asking you to compromise your conviction. I'm not asking you to change your conviction. I'm not asking you to do something that you think is wrong.
SPEAKER_01But what I am asking you to do Stop standing in God's place. Stop trying to be God. Stop trying to judge your brother or sister. Before his own master he will stand and he is able to make him stand. It's not your job to try to be the judge of everyone. Wouldn't it be so relieving? Wouldn't it lift a huge burden off of our shoulders? And again, it goes back to peace. It goes back to an assurance that we are in a right relationship with God because He's given us a gift and He's given other people,
SPEAKER_01even people we disagree with, the same gift. And we can embrace one another and love one another and live at peace with God and at peace inside of ourselves and at peace with one another because of the grace of God. And I And that just, it changes everything. And we don't have to live in fear. We don't have to live with that constant anxiety. What if I'm wrong about this? Or what if I'm in fellowship with somebody else who is wrong about this other thing? Rather, we have this peace that passes understanding.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I... I sound like a broken record. And like I'm kicking a dead horse, proverbially speaking. With what I brought up at the very beginning about the fear. I would just say, while we're talking about fruit of the Spirit, fear is not one of them.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, that's right.
SPEAKER_00If that's the fuel that all of my activity and all of my judgment and all of my greater sensibilities as it regards my brothers and sisters and the faith and what I ought to be doing and ought not be doing, if fear is what is underneath of all of that, then I have the wrong motivation. Then there's so much more that the gospel has for me, so much more that Jesus has for me. And I'm not in any way saying that a fearful, you know, even awful reverence of the Lord is not necessary. I believe that you have to have that to understand the gospel. I'm not saying we dispense with that at all.
SPEAKER_00I'm just saying that, man, there's a reason that God calls Himself our Heavenly Father. And there comes a place where If you really, really have the spirit, you will one day wake up much like you maybe did with your mother or your father, and you're no longer afraid of them and the punishment that they're going to rain down on you if you do something wrong. What you're really afraid of is disappointing them because you know how much they've given for you and how much they love you. And that motivation Will take your life in such a greater direction on so many levels.
SPEAKER_00You will accomplish more out of reciprocating that love and sharing that love than you ever will out of an iron-fisted fear. And if our relationship with our Father in Heaven is not like that, we are going to project that iron fist on everyone around us. And what I want so much is for every single disciple, every single brother and sister to be able to rest in that peace that we're all promised, to rest in that joy that we're all promised. It doesn't make light of the commandments of God at all.
SPEAKER_00It doesn't make light of who we're called to be and how we're called to practice at all. But it makes so much more of the unity that we're called to. And it makes it so much more attainable when I look at my relationship with God through that light. I can look at my relationship with my brother through that light as well.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Yeah. That's a good word. I think that's exactly where we should end, brother. I mean, again, it's not being dismissive of obedience. Yeah, absolutely. We should obey. And the chief commands to obey. Love the Lord your God with all your heart, soul, mind, and strength. Love your neighbor as yourself. Love is the chief doctrine. And we do have to obey that. And if we're more concerned about following our scruples, our personal scruples and conclusions that we've come to, than we are about obeying the chief commands of God and of His Son,
SPEAKER_01Jesus, then we are not walking in the Spirit. And we have to check ourselves and say, am I walking in the Spirit? And you'll know you're walking in the Spirit, not because of a warm, fuzzy feeling you have in your heart. You may have that. But you'll know you're walking in the Spirit if the Spirit is producing this kind of fruit in your life. And you'll know where your brothers and sisters are by the fruit you see in their life.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. So, like, take a self-inventory regularly. Like, is my day consistently racked with anxiety and fear? When I think about God, like, what was the... Was it Chesterton? I don't know if it was Chesterton. What we think about when we think about God is the most important thing about us. Some great theologian said that. I think it's so true. But examine the fruit that's being produced by my thought life. Examine the fruit that's being produced by my interaction, my relationships with my brothers and sisters.
SPEAKER_00Examine the fruit that's produced when I consider what other brothers and sisters maybe in other congregations are doing, that maybe we're not doing, and should they do that, and should we do that? Examine what the real result of all that is, and then take an inventory. Is this love? Is this joy? Is this peace? Is this putting me more and more in fellowship and striving for unity and alignment with the fact that we serve the same Lord, the same Lord died for us, and the same Lord is coming back to get us? Or is this causing more and more division? That's... That's where I would start.
SPEAKER_01That's a good word. That's a good word. Marcus, thank you for this incredibly encouraging conversation. I appreciate it, brother.
SPEAKER_00Man, you've been pushing me lately, Wes. But thank you so much. This has been a good one.
SPEAKER_01Thanks, brother. I hope you enjoyed that episode of the Radically Christian Podcast. If you did, please take a second to like, share, subscribe, rate, or review the podcast. You can find this show on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, Substack, YouTube, or wherever you listen to podcasts. Thank you so much for listening. Thank you also to my co-host, Marcus, and thank you to my McDermott Road Church family who helps make this podcast possible. Okay, now let's all go out and love like Jesus.
The Spirit is often the member of the Godhead we talk about least, and when we do, He can feel more like a doctrine to manage than a Person to know. In this conversation from the 412 Christian Podcast, Wes joins hosts...
What if the vocabulary you inherited for salvation has left you more anxious than assured? Justification, sanctification, saved: many believers learned these words as tidy categories, and many sincere Christians still...
What does it actually mean to be baptized in the Holy Spirit? For many who grew up in the Restoration Movement, the phrase meant a debate about water baptism or a defensive argument about miraculous gifts, and then the...
If we’re saved by grace through faith, why does baptism still matter? An elder in Tennessee wrote in with a question many Christians are asking. If love is the heart of everything, is baptism just a ritual tacked on, a...
Is gluttony only about what is on your plate? Most of us assume we know the answer, and most of us feel a little uncomfortable when the subject comes up. The Bible mentions gluttony far less than many Christians expect,...