Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Radically Christian

Radically Christian artwork

Baptism, What Does the Bible Actually Teach?

Oct 29, 20251 hr 2 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Baptism according to Scripture is more than a ritual - it is an expression of faith in Jesus for the forgiveness of sins. In this episode of the Radically Christian Podcast, Wes McAdams talks with Dr. Bobby Harrington, founder of Discipleship.org and Renew.org, about what the Bible truly teaches about baptism and why Christians must understand its connection to the gospel. Dr. Harrington, author of Baptism According to Scripture: A Clear, Short, and Unfiltered Guide, explains why immersion in the name of Jesus Christ is the New Testament pattern (Acts 2:38), how baptism expresses loyalty and allegiance to King Jesus, and why it is wrong to separate baptism from faith in Christ. Together, Wes and Bobby explore the restoration movement perspective, early church history, and common misunderstandings in evangelical circles. This conversation will help you: * Understand baptism as an expression of saving faith * See why passages like Acts 2:38 and 1 Peter 3:21 are central to this teaching * Learn how the early church viewed baptism * Grasp what it means for baptism to be “normative” If this episode encourages you, like, subscribe, and share your thoughts in the comments. Let’s continue to help others understand Scripture and love like Jesus! Links and Resources: * Baptism According to Scripture: A Clear, Short, and Unfiltered Guide by Bobby Harrington * DiscipleShift by Jim Putman and Bobby Harrington * Baptism in the Early Church by Everett Ferguson * Gospel Allegiance by Matthew Bates * Renew.org and Discipleship.org websites for further study and resources Some links may be affiliate links. This means if you choose to purchase through these links, we may receive a small commission at no additional cost to you. This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit www.radicallychristian.com

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

I'm going to add something that isn't in the book, but it's just for your audience, okay?

SPEAKER_00So, I believe that the Bible teaches that immersion as an expression of faith and commitment to King Jesus or Jesus Christ is for the forgiveness of sins. I'll state it the way we stated in the book. I wanted to use immersion so that I'm clear about that. But baptism is an expression of faith in Jesus for the forgiveness of sins.

SPEAKER_00Now, if I can, I'd like to state why articulating it is important. I believe that that definition or that description is what the Bible teaches. It's what the church for the first 500 years held. And it is the best of the restoration movement.

SPEAKER_01Welcome to the Radically Christian podcast. I'm your host, Wes McAdams. Here we have one goal, learn to love like Jesus. My guest today is Dr. Bobby Harrington. He's the founder and point leader of discipleship.org and renew.org. He's also the author of a new booklet on baptism, baptism according to scripture, a clear, short and unfiltered guide. Bobby is the lead minister at Harpeth Christian Church in the Nashville area. And for those who don't know, Christian churches and churches of Christ are both part of the

restoration

SPEAKER_01movement, which we talk about quite a bit in this episode. And both believe that baptism is how a person should express repentant faith in Jesus for the forgiveness of their sins. bobby's book is short but it does a good job emphasizing that everyone needs to be baptized but also encouraging people to put their faith in jesus not in the act of baptism itself of course baptism apart from faith in jesus does nothing But baptism as an expression of saving faith is a fundamental

Christian doctrine

SPEAKER_01that unfortunately is being downplayed and even dismissed, even by some in the restoration movement, but especially by those in the evangelical world. I hope this conversation and Bobby's book help us to share the truth about baptism with others in a kind and loving way. So here's my conversation with Dr. Bobby Harrington. Dr. Bobby Harrington, welcome to the podcast, brother. Great to be with you, Wes. I'm actually looking forward to our conversation.

SPEAKER_01Me too. Me too. Thank you for making time for this. For those that aren't familiar with your work and your life, why don't you spend just a couple of minutes introducing yourself and telling us about what you do? Okay.

SPEAKER_00So I'm going to give, I'm going to explain my life in four quarters. How's that?

SPEAKER_01Love it.

SPEAKER_00So from zero to 20, I grew up in Calgary, Alberta, Canada. It's my hometown. For those of you who are thinking geographically where that is, it's above Montana. In fact, until I was 20, the furthest south I'd ever been was Kalispell, Montana. So that's where I lived. I grew up in a home where we didn't, you know, go to church regularly or anything. And then at the University of Calgary, after sort of trying to figure out the world the year before,

SPEAKER_00I was a political science major. So I'd gone to the Soviet Union right to Russia or Moscow itself to figure out what I believe. I'd come back. And at the University of Calgary, I'd made a decision to find out more about the Bible. So my second semester, I was that was my French professor. I ended up having to take a course with him. I didn't know anything about him and all that well.

SPEAKER_00He was from Abilene Christian University. It was actually back then, I think, probably Abilene Christian College. Anyway, he became my French professor and he discipled me. He was a phenomenal human being and I was baptized. And so that's that's that's quarter number one. So when I was 20, I was baptized on my 20th birthday and then went to Harding

University that summer. I decided that I wanted to study the Bible and I could thought I could master it in a year.

SPEAKER_00And then I moved back to Calgary and You know, get my law degree and so forth. Anyway. God got a hold of me at Harding University and met the lady who became my wife. She's from Memphis, Tennessee. If anybody knows back in the day, Thomas B. Warren, he was her preacher, if you can imagine that. So I went to Harding, finished my bachelor's in Bible with minor in Greek.

SPEAKER_00And then since Cindy was from Memphis, we moved to Memphis. And I completed an MA at Harding Graduate School. Your audience may know I just did an MA, but Mike Cope graduated same time as me with his MDiv. So Mike Cope's wife and my wife had been roommates at Harding University. Just to give a little context, everybody, Mike and I probably don't see things the same anymore. But but that's my rootedness.

SPEAKER_00So I moved back to Calgary, helped my dad run his trucking company, and then became the senior minister of the Calgary Church of Christ in 1987 and served there till 1994, where a church in Nashville, Tennessee, called the Otter Creek Church, recruited me. I became the senior minister there, served there for... about three years, and then really felt like I wanted to focus on reaching lost

people.

SPEAKER_00So we planted, coming out of the Otter Creek Church of Christ, Harpeth Christian Church when I reached 40. So first 20 years, non-Christian, 20 to 40, very much involved in a cappella churches of Christ and then planted Harpeth Christian Church when I became 40. And so from then until I was 60, I worked with a group called Stadia, trained

I guess 200 church planting teams helped them create a national church planting networks. And then in 2011, I left and helped Jim Putman create the Relational Discipleship Network.

SPEAKER_00Jim and I published a book on disciple making that was really popular. It was called Disciple Shift. shifting your church to disciple me. I may be giving you more than you wanted, Wes. Sorry. I love it. I love it. Anyway, so in that time, after I turned 40, I completed my doctor of ministry at Southern Baptist Theological Seminary under Tom Rainer, was my mentor in my program. And then I

SPEAKER_00Ian, after helping Jim create the Relational Discipleship Network, we started discipleship.org in 2014 with Todd Wilson, the founder of the Exponential Network, and led that, learned a lot. about disciple making. I still lead it to this day, discipleship.org. But my real heart is Renew.org, which we created when I was 59. Renew.org in 2017, fall of 2017.

SPEAKER_00We really started January of 2018. And Renew.org takes what we hope is the best of the restoration movement, and the best of disciple-making focused on engaging our culture. So it's the intersection of, hopefully, only God knows, but the best of the Restoration Movement theology, the best of disciple-making in our current cultural context in

North America.

SPEAKER_00So for the last eight years, I have tried to straddle the fence between being a lead minister of the church I planted just about 28 years ago. Discipleship.org and Renew.org. And if you ask me, how do I do it? I don't know how, only by God's grace. But I'm trying to change that so that my only focus is Renew.org. So how's that for you? I have a wife, wonderful wife, and two children who are my daughter's 42.

SPEAKER_00My son's about to be 40. And yeah, they're wonderful people. And we have six grandchildren.

SPEAKER_01Fantastic, fantastic. Well, thanks for sharing all that with us, brother. I really appreciate it. And let's get into this topic of baptism. But I think first, I don't know, we were talking about who the audience is, and there's no telling who's listening today. And when people hear the word baptize or baptism, what comes to their mind might be something different than we mean. And so let's just start with simple definitions. When people think about baptism, some people go to the idea of baptism of the Holy Spirit and

they don't even think about water and others think about infant baptism and others think about adult

SPEAKER_01immersion. And so what do you mean when you talk about baptism and maybe why?

SPEAKER_00I'm going to give you a very precise definition. I'm going to add something that isn't in the book, but it's just for your audience. OK, so I believe that the Bible teaches that immersion as an expression of faith and commitment to King Jesus or Jesus Christ is for the forgiveness of sins. I'll state it the way we stated in the book.

SPEAKER_00I wanted to use immersion so that I'm clear about that. But baptism is an expression of faith in Jesus for the forgiveness of sins. Now, if I can, I'd like to state why articulating it is important. I believe that that definition or that description is what the Bible teaches. It's what the church for the first 500 years held.

SPEAKER_00And it is the best of the restoration movement expression. What I did not say, I want to be careful. I did not say that baptism is for the remission of sins. And I did not say that because that's what John the Baptist taught, according to Luke 3, 3. John the Baptist had a baptism for the forgiveness of sins. And we know that in Acts 19, those who were baptized by John the Baptist's baptism had to be

rebaptized in the

SPEAKER_00name of Jesus because they did not have the Holy Spirit. Or as they said, we've not even heard about the Holy Spirit. I do think sometimes in the restoration movement, people have championed baptism for the remission of sins. And the problem with that is it communicates two things that I don't think people want to communicate. Number one, it communicates to a lot of people that if you're not baptized for the remission of sins,

SPEAKER_00you can't have your sins forgiven. And number two, more importantly, it cuts off baptism. from the gospel and cross and atoning sacrifice of Jesus. So it's very important that we say baptism as an expression of faith in Jesus is for the forgiveness of sins. So baptism is the method of expressing faith

SPEAKER_00And the ground or the basis of our forgiveness is Jesus Christ, his gospel, and his atoning sacrifice. So I'll pause there and you can... That's really good, Bobby. I didn't realize we would get into sort of controversial territory this quickly,

SPEAKER_01but I'm glad that you expressed that the way that you did. And I don't know that I picked up on that sort of that distinction that you're making right there. And I think it's really well articulated what you just said. As I was reading the book, we'll get to some of the stuff that you put in the latter part of the book. Wait, wait, tell them I wrote a book on this, Ruth.

SPEAKER_00Yes, yes, exactly.

SPEAKER_01I don't think we've said that. I do want to talk about that, but I anticipate that as people were listening to your definition there, that they're going to say, well, Acts 238, Acts 238. Is what you are saying different from, or I'm sure that you believe it's aligned with, but why is that more closely aligned to what Peter is saying in Acts 2 than what John was saying when he was saying about baptism? Let's go through three passages that in the Restoration Movement we have championed.

SPEAKER_00We'll start with Acts 2.38. And by the way, I make the argument in the booklet that anchoring our doctrine in Acts 2.38 is right-minded. It's right-minded because of the way it's positioned in the book of Acts. It's right-minded because what Acts 2.39 says is And it's right-minded because in the early church, the Nicene Creed actually uses Acts 2.38. You know, we believe in one baptism for the forgiveness of sins.

SPEAKER_00So let me start there. And we can walk through as many passages as you want on this, but I'm going to show you that the passages actually teach us to focus on Jesus when we do baptism. So Acts 2.38, repent and be baptized every one of you in the name of Jesus Christ for the forgiveness of your sins and you will receive the gift of the Holy Spirit. He then goes on and says,

SPEAKER_00this promises for you, for your children and for all who are far off, all whom the Lord our God will call. So verse 39 tells us it's gonna be normative. OK, what does 238 says? So repentance, which is expressing sort of the the renunciation side of faith, repentance and baptism in the name of Jesus, literally in the Greek text, epionomata, literally like we get the word epicenter for the epicenter of

an earthquake.

SPEAKER_00So repent and be baptized on the name of Jesus Christ. for the forgiveness of your sins, and you will receive the gift of the Holy Spirit. So Acts 2.38, baptism has to be an expression of reliance upon and commitment to allegiance to King Jesus. Acts 22.16, Ananias tells Paul, what are you waiting for? You guys know this text. Arise, be baptized, wash away your sins, calling on his name.

SPEAKER_00Oh, baptism is calling on his name. Or 1 Peter 3, 21. Baptism now saves you also, not the removal of dirt from the body, but the pledge of a good conscience toward God. It saves you by the resurrection of Jesus Christ. So just in those three examples, and and I think we could we could go through all of them. But what happened to me, Wes,

SPEAKER_00on this is in the early years, you know, when I was baptized, when I got out of harding and lots of conversations, too often it was this baptism was disconnected from Jesus's sacrifice of atonement or from his gospel. I'll give you one example. A friend of mine told me of a guy who got baptized in the church and he got baptized and then he called my buddy a week later. So he was baptized for the remission of sins.

Called my buddy a week later and said, will you tell me why did Jesus die on the cross now? So the guy was baptized for the forgiveness of sins and did not connect it with

SPEAKER_00Jesus on the cross. And so that forced me to really look into the text. And when you look in the text, as I've said, in just those three key examples, there's an emphasis that it's the atoning sacrifice of Jesus. So Ephesians 2, 8 is right. It is by grace we have been saved through faith. Baptism is the way we express faith. in Jesus and access the grace that he offers by his gospel.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, that's so rich, and I love the way that both in this conversation you've already articulated the idea of allegiance and loyalty, and you did that throughout the book as well, that faith, and Matthew Bates, his work has been really helpful to me on seeing that connection, that we've always said in restoration movements that faith is more than just mental assent, but I love that way of expressing it, that it is loyalty and allegiance to King Jesus, And that what we're doing in baptism is that we are declaring,

SPEAKER_01we are pledging our loyalty and allegiance to him, that we will follow him, we will become his disciples. But to remove it from that, to remove it from obedience to the gospel that Jesus is king and that he has died for the forgiveness of our sins, to disconnect it as if just the act of getting wet, as if that is what is for the forgiveness of sins, is really to miss what the New Testament teaches.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, you know, Wes, I don't know if you know this, but when we started Renew in the fall of 2017, I had read, you know, Matthew Bates about him and that I called him and ended up having a long conversation. I connected him to a buddy of mine, Bill Hull, who was leading the Bonhoeffer project. And then Matthew became very involved at Renew. And the reason that we connected is because I felt like his

description of faith

SPEAKER_00was very consistent with the best of the Restoration Movement. His view on baptism was very similar. One of the things that I do when people are taking a leadership position at Renew is we ask them to go through our faith statement. to see if it represents where they're at. And when I got to the part with him on baptism, this is before he published Gospel Allegiance, which, by the way, is a renewed book. You might notice before he published that, I asked him about baptism. And he said, he says, I know, I know, I know.

SPEAKER_00I read Everett Ferguson's book, Baptism of the First Five Centuries. He says, I'm on board. Uh, so, uh, I encouraged him to join a Christian church there in Quincy, Illinois, which he did do. Uh, he's subsequent to that. He's become a professor at, uh, is it Northeastern seminary? Am I saying that right? Uh, just outside Chicago. So I'm not sure if his family still goes to the Christian church in Quincy, Illinois, but, uh, yeah. So he's tied in with our roots now.

SPEAKER_01I knew that he was. I was really impressed to see his material on Yale's website because I've really been a big fan of what he's doing. Well, let's talk about your book. And I was pointed towards your book by a mutual friend, Jordan Arnold, who's been on the podcast before. And I loved the book and it lays out baptism so well. And the subtitle of it is a clear, short and unfiltered guide. And I think that's a perfect description of what it is. So why did you write the book and why specifically did you

write a condensed guide?

SPEAKER_01Why a short book like this?

SPEAKER_00Yeah. So let me just back up. I want to clarify because I have another book on baptism that we published with David Young from the North Boulevard Church of Christ and Tony Twist, who's a Christian church scholar who leads TCM, Training Christians for Mission. They have a seminary in Vienna, Austria, and then also one in Indianapolis, just so you know. So this book is a different one than that. It's about half the size. It's called Baptism According to Scripture.

SPEAKER_00Clear. What is it? Give the subtitle again. I don't have a clear, short and unfiltered guide. Yeah. So here's what happened. I started noticing watering down on baptism in like. Some significant names in churches of Christ. that I could tell you about, but I'm not going to right now, just because I want to honor the fact they're not here to defend themselves. On their websites,

SPEAKER_00they're like watering down what baptism is, sounding very Baptistic or, you know, it's a different theology. It's just a different theology that others have. And then in Christian churches, it was really getting bad too. In a lot of megachurches, They're kind of afraid to articulate it. So they end up doing this thing of you say a prayer and ask Jesus into your heart and then go ahead and get baptized later. And it's like,

wait, that that's not the roots of the restoration movement.

SPEAKER_00So in in Christian churches, there's a guy named Jack Cottrell and his stuff was very influential. But that was like 30 years ago. So there's nothing really in Christian churches that they're accessing. And then I think the best scholar on this stuff is Everett Ferguson, who taught for many years at Abilene and did the spade work, not just in the New Testament text, but in the second, third. And in his book, he goes up to the, you know, I think to 500 AD.

SPEAKER_00Well, he's not accessible. So I just felt really convicted by God about it. And so. I and I I in my life, this has been. It's probably the most painful doctrine that I've had to uphold. Here's why. The guy who discipled me when I was baptized, so I went off to Harding, and then Harding Graduate School,

SPEAKER_00and then Cindy and I moved back to Calgary. We got back, and two weeks later, he was disfellowshipped by the church. And here's why they disfellowshipped him. Because he came to the belief that God would still save people who were not properly baptized. Like he still upheld it, that it's normative. He didn't use that language back then. But he said, I believe people can be saved who aren't baptized. Well, they just fellowshiped him.

And so I'd got my family going to church and in the morning they disfellowshipped him.

SPEAKER_00My mom had some relatives coming to church and it was a disaster. And my wife grew up staunch Church Christ and I still hadn't worked out some of my own stuff. It was extremely painful for me and my wife and my family and the church. And it took about a year. to work through that thing. I was threatened by the elders. If I didn't get in line, they're going to disfellowship me. Some of this stuff sounds ridiculous now,

but I just want I just want to identify with the fundamentalistic roots of some

SPEAKER_00acapella churches of Christ. And it was extremely painful. So I worked through that. Five years later, they asked me to become their senior minister. So that's interesting. That's a longer story for another day. So then I kept trying to persuade people around baptism. Had lots of conversations with lots of people and lots of contacts. Kind of at one point, somebody hinted at me. They asked me to join the faculty of the Southern Baptist Seminary,

SPEAKER_00which I said, nope, because of baptism. When I did my doctoral project, Tom Rainer gave me permission in my project to articulate the view of baptism that's in this booklet. And he forgot to tell the other guys. So defending my dissertation, one of the guys started picking a fight with me around baptism. And he said, that's not right. What you write, that's not right.

SPEAKER_00And I said, well, yeah, it is. And he said, no, it's just Church of Christ stuff. And I said, no, it's not. It's the view of the early church for the first, I probably said back then, 400 years. And he said, that's not true. And I said, yes, it is. And I was about to quote some of the early church fathers. And Rainer intervenes and said, Dr. Cox is not defending his dissertation. You're defending yours. Let's take a break.

SPEAKER_00And then we took a break and it was very awful. And then he came back in and he said, I forgot to tell them I gave you permission to hold your view as long as you acknowledged it wasn't the Southern Baptist Theological Seminary view. So anyway, that was an awful thing. And then when we planted the church, because most of our people do not have a restoration movement background, I have had a gazillion conversations about on this topic. And then by God's grace,

we've been able to win over people to renew on this position.

SPEAKER_00Bill Hull is kind of like the father of modern disciple making. He's written more on disciple making than anybody else. I had very long conversations with Bill and then he came around. And he says, I agree with you. So he became a part of Renew. Ralph Moore started the Hope Chapel movement. Ralph Moore has come around. And here's the thing about it. When you walk people through what I try to do in the book, that this was the normative method in the New Testament,

SPEAKER_00and you explain the Christ-centered focus of it, And then you allow that it's normative, but that God can make exceptions. I just find most people I'm able, over time, to win them over with the text on that. If they think you're saying, you're lost and going to hell if you didn't do it this way. Once you show it differently, I find generally people are very receptive to it.

SPEAKER_00Yeah.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. Well, that's great. That's wonderful. And there really are. There are a lot of people, some people that are, I'm sure, shocked and surprised when we take a position that says you need to be baptized. I was on a Moody Bible radio interview one time. I was talking with Julie Roy. She was interviewing me and a guy that believed in infant baptism. And we were having this conversation, and at one point she said, to clarify, because I think she could tell where my conversation was going, she said, sort of to clarify,

SPEAKER_01she said, well, but I'm sure, you know, even if you believe in adult baptism and you believe in infant baptism, we all agree that you don't have to be baptized. It's not necessary to be baptized. And I said, well, I don't agree with that. And I said what I believe. And they both were absolutely shocked. It seemed to be the first time they had ever even heard that someone took a position that this is the point of conversion of when we express our faith in Jesus through baptism. And so... Let's walk through maybe some of the common misunderstandings

that people have in

SPEAKER_01the religious world. There's a lot of people that they love Jesus, they read their Bible, they go to church, but they misunderstand what Scripture teaches about baptism. So where do some of those misunderstandings lie?

SPEAKER_00So here's the thing when you press into it at a deep level. Evangelical Christianity in North America largely has a foundation in Calvinism. And even though the average preacher may not say he's a Calvinist, the theological systems and framing has been developed with that by the scholars.

SPEAKER_00I can give you more detail on that. But in fact, let me recommend to your readers a booklet It's actually a book they might want to read. It's called Baptism, Zwingli or the Bible by Jack Cottrell. Now, it came out after Jack died, but it really pushes you to see that sort of the philosophical foundations, which I have found to be true. Let me just describe it succinctly, Wes. So in Calvinism,

before God ever creates the world, he predetermines who will be saved.

SPEAKER_00OK, so he elects them before they're ever born. Then here's the order of salvation. He picks them then at some point in their life. And this is a mystery. He awakens and regenerates them. so that they believe in Jesus, okay? So in that system, you have election, then you have regeneration and awakening. So baptism can only be a sign or a seal of salvation already received.

SPEAKER_00A sign or seal, or people will say a public demonstration, which by the way, those are not, you can't find that language in the Bible. My friend Jim Putman leads a church of like, I don't know, 9000 in Idaho, and they've planted a bunch of churches. And we we worked on the relational discipleship network years ago. And Jim and I are very close friends. So Jim and I, we've gone round and round on this because,

SPEAKER_00you know, he would say it's a public demonstration of your faith. And I go, Jim, just give me one verse in the Bible that says that. And anyway, the good news is on this book, when it came out on Amazon, Jim gave me a stellar review, which I was so grateful for. And he's going to use it in his church. So anyway, back to the short answer is you have this rejection of religion. the Roman Catholic or Eastern Orthodox view,

SPEAKER_00which is baptismal regeneration, that you are saved by the act of baptism as a baby, apart from faith. That's their doctrine. So in history, Luther and Calvin and Zwingli, they all rejected that, okay? Now what you've got is they, in rejecting that, came up with this alternative model and it's just dominated.

SPEAKER_00And then to be transparent with you, sometimes Church of Christ guys or Christian church guys fit into that when they say, You know, I believe you're saved by baptism. I believe, you know, baptism is for the remission of sins without connecting it to Jesus, his sacrifice of atonement and our faith in him. So they act like and sometimes I've even heard people say, which is bad, that they believe in baptismal regeneration.

SPEAKER_00No, you don't. And if you do, repent because it's a false doctrine.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, that's really good. And I really appreciate how the book does deal with sort of both of those extremes, sort of the extreme that says that we're saved apart from baptism or that baptism has nothing to do with salvation or the idea that we're saved by baptism apart from faith. And neither of those things is true, that we are saved when we express our faith in Jesus through being baptized. And that is the way that it was done in the New Testament. And we continue to do that today. and it really is it it should be such a beautiful unifying

thing in fact i preached on baptism not too long ago here at mcdermott and and one of the the main points that i focused on was that baptism is and you you mentioned something similar in your book that baptism is one of seven things that every christian in the world who has ever lived every christian has this in common this is one of the seven things

SPEAKER_01We have one God, we have one faith, we have one Lord, and we have one baptism, we have one church. There's a lot of things that we have differences on, and there's a beautiful diversity within the unity of the body of Christ. But one of the things that we have to have in common is baptism. We all have been through the water. We have all pledged our allegiance. and our loyalty to King Jesus. And so it really should be a subject on which we're unified. And unfortunately, there is so much division and contention.

SPEAKER_01I shared a post on Facebook after that sermon, and it was really interesting to see the people that kind of came out of the woodwork to attack the congregation or attack the message because they were very much in that Calvinistic camp.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. Yeah, so we have found that as well at Renew. And part of the thing at Renew is we're bringing in church leaders and churches who don't have roots in the restoration movement. Like 95% have roots in the restoration movement. So what we ended up doing, like there's a church planting network in North Carolina that wanted to become a part of Renew. Now, they ended up becoming a part of Renew, but they had more Baptist roots.

SPEAKER_00So this was a big question for them. So if you you go to Renew.org and you look at our faith statement, you read the faith statement on baptism where it express what you and I have been talking about. There's a hyperlink. where we have a one pager summarizing, you know, you don't want we don't believe in baptismal regeneration. That's the Roman Catholic doctrine. Here's what it is. And kind of walking people through that. And I think I think people have been set up in the broad

evangelical culture. that there's such an emphasis we're saved by grace through faith and it sounds like oftentimes baptism is against that and so you have to carefully with nuance explain this doctrine and that's what i i tried to do in the book so i was telling you i felt led by god to do it if i can let me go back to that just for a second wes so i went away uh in we have some friends who have a cabin and i went away to write it

SPEAKER_00And I want you to know I have written another book on it. The booklet that Renew has or the booklet. It's also a free download, by the way. Biblical Baptism, What Do the Scriptures Teach? Like that was our church's position paper when we started. And we just modified that. I brought on David Young and Tony Twist to add some stories. But I knew that wasn't covering what I needed to do. So I went away, and this is the hardest book I've ever written.

SPEAKER_00I've written 20 book books and more than 20 e-books. But this was the hardest one. It wasn't like I didn't know, you know, what I believed, but it was to say it right. Because I wanted a book that churches would use. I wanted a book so that when we have people who are saying, what do you guys teach about baptism? That sounds weird that we could give it to him because most of

the people coming to

SPEAKER_00the church where I'm the I'm one of the elders, some lead pastor. Most of the people who come there don't have restoration movement background. So we got to work through this with them. I wanted a book I could hand to them that they could read it in 40 to 45 minutes. We can talk more about this if you want. It's written for people's minds who have been discipled to read A.I. summaries. Like, I believe moving forward more and more, we're going to have to write books that are in step with A.I.

summaries because we're training everybody to want that and what they're reading.

SPEAKER_00But I wanted it to have the gravitas that when I said stuff, there's references at the back if you want to know. But for the average serious layman, they could read that or elders. And I wanted it to be used in churches because I think right now I care very much about the restoration movement. And I think that there's major drifting. So what I did is when I was done, I sent it to College Press. So I can publish books through renew.org.

SPEAKER_00I'm the CEO. I could do that. But I didn't want to do that because I wanted it to have a broad influence. So I contacted Carl Halverson. He read it and right away said, yeah, we want to publish it. I said, well, just wait. And then I reached out to E2 Elders. They work with 500 elders in the Christian church. And Gary Johnson read it and said, yeah, we need this because elders are confused about this topic today. So he said, we'll co-publish it. I said, well, just wait.

SPEAKER_00So I contacted Christian Standard, Christian Standard, kind of the mainstream publisher, historically, going back to 1865 in the Restoration Movement. Now, they don't publish books now, but Jerry Harris read it and said, yeah, we want to co-publish it with you. So four of us co-published it. And then my my intuition of the Holy Spirit's leading was confirmed when New Day asked for copies and gave it to 400 ministers in a gathering

they had in Lebanon

SPEAKER_00and then Christian churches, the Spire Conference. They wanted to give a copy to the 2000 ministers and pastors who attended their gathering in September. And then Orpheus Hayward and the African-American churches at the Nehemiah Summit. They're also giving a copy to everybody who attends there. So I'm getting stories of churches using it. As a little missionary, the way I thought it would be, like Jimmy Adcox just sent me a text yesterday.

He's with the Church of Christ in Jonesborough, I think Northwest maybe is what it's called. So Adam, the lead pastor there, his dad used it with somebody and they were baptized on Sunday. And I'm getting lots of stories like that in Christian churches and churches of Christ.

SPEAKER_00And You know, guys like John Mark Hicks have endorsed it. And I think what I was hoping it would feel like, and I'm only doing this because I felt like God was leading me, is it would feel like a restoration movement statement on how we look at baptisms.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, yeah. Yeah, I really appreciate the way that you've laid it out. And, you know, as people are listening to this, I'm sure that they can already tell that there are differences between the different groups in the restoration movement. There are differences between Christian churches and churches of Christ and in our ecclesiology, sort of how we organize leadership and in our worship styles and those kinds of things. And that's not to dismiss any of those things, but we all believe, obviously our faith is in Jesus, and we also believe in the significance and the importance and

the necessity of

SPEAKER_01baptism. And so this is absolutely an area where we need to be able to come together and say, let's articulate this in a way so that we can share the good news about Jesus with the world and help them to understand that this is how you pledge your allegiance, your loyalty to King Jesus. Let's kind of talk about sort of the exceptions. And you touched on this earlier that you've used this word normative. And I thought this was a really interesting way to do this. It might be an area where some of my listeners might feel a

little bit like,

SPEAKER_01oh, wait, wait, what is being said here? because i think that we've we've gone back and forth with our with our neighbors about um about this idea of the necessity of baptism because people like to use stories like cornelius or the the samaritans and say well look this is this is the way that it happened um there's exceptions to that and so you don't have to be baptized it's not necessary so in the book you said baptism is the normative time of conversion in scripture But then you also deal with sort of the deviations from the norm.

SPEAKER_01Do those deviations destroy our argument that baptism is necessary? One of the things you said, here's a quote from the book, it says, there were circumstances where God worked things out differently when it came to the gospel coming to the gospel coming to two non-Jewish groups for the first time, the Samaritans and In Acts 8, the Holy Spirit was given after baptism. And Cornelius and his household in Acts 10 and Acts 11, the Holy Spirit came upon them before baptism. So do these stories destroy our argument?

And why was it necessary and important for you to include this sort of caveat in the discussion?

SPEAKER_00Yeah. So the first thing is that I think it's important to clarify, according to the New Testament, in places like Romans 8, verse 9, the thing that distinguishes the saved from the lost, the thing that shows you're saved is that the Holy Spirit dwells within you. Again, Romans 8, verse 9, Ephesians chapter 1, 13 and 14. And I would encourage anybody who's not sure about this. Read Acts 19 verses one through five or one through six.

SPEAKER_00And you'll you'll note the role of the of the Holy Spirit, which, of course, is promised in Acts two thirty eight. Like we just recently baptized a lady who felt like she had the Holy Spirit. But, you know, there's a question about it. And like when you follow Acts 238, you can have scriptural assurance that you have the Holy Spirit. So that's the first thing. The second thing is that if you lead with this posture that

it's normative,

SPEAKER_00but not absolutely essential, that your opinion is that God can and does have some special circumstances. If you lead with that, it might undermine your position. That's why when I wrote the booklet, the first eight points are laying out the biblical pattern. By the way, Everett Ferguson, I didn't know this, so we came up with normative,

SPEAKER_00before I knew this. By the way, it applies to other circumstances, like Shadonke Johnson became a part of Renew. And he said, I believe what you do about baptism. This is a guy who's probably led, his movement has probably led I'll take the lower number. Hundreds of thousands of Muslims to Christ. In this movement, a guy started in Sierra Leone. Okay.

SPEAKER_00Hundreds of thousands of Muslims. And he said, Bobby, I agree that it's the norm. But sometimes when Muslims convert... we have to wait a little bit and be careful because if they're baptized just impulsively right away, they may be put to death. And so sometimes we help them to wait, you know, a week or two. It's like, okay, yeah, I can see why you do that, Shanonke. And he said, the other thing with normativeness is I believe in male

leadership like you do at

SPEAKER_00Renew. But sometimes when the gospel's gone to a village, And there are no men. We would sooner have the church gather, even if it has to be women temporarily. But we want to get to the norm where it's male leadership, because that's biblical and ultimately also best in that culture. So I wanted to say that about the language of norm. Now, Everett Ferguson, I reread his book like... I guess it was two months ago.

SPEAKER_00And I found he used that language in there, too. It's normative from Acts 2, 38 and 39. So some people will take it that you're sort of you've opened Pandora's box. I think if you don't allow for that, you've got more problems. By the way, since people are listening, again, you can get the book on Amazon.com if you want to buy bulk.

A lot of churches are buying them in bulk now to do what we do at our church,

SPEAKER_00and that's pass them out to people. Go to College Press because there are $6 on Amazon, and I think if you buy bulk, You know, I think it goes down. The price goes down depending on how many you buy to like four dollars and fifty cents a copy on College Press's website. Let me let me give the the qualifiers. So I first scripture not experience should be our authority on this. So you got to be careful with the whole experience thing.

SPEAKER_00I want to go by scripture. Baptismal regeneration and the whole concept on that, that's not biblical. Number three, God gives salvation and the spirit as he sees fit. You don't get to decide and I don't get to decide. if God is going to look at the heart and give the Holy Spirit. Okay? And on that point, there are people that I can't not believe that God didn't give

them the Holy

SPEAKER_00Spirit. That's a bunch of negatives. There are people, I believe, by the fruit of their lives and their ministries, that even though they weren't properly baptized, they still had the Holy Spirit. and that they committed themselves, they didn't learn about baptism, and I think God looked at the heart. I'll give you a couple examples. How about Tim Keller? Do you think Tim Keller didn't have the Holy Spirit? How about C.S. Lewis? How about Martin Luther? Like, you know, and I can go on. I can't believe those guys didn't have the Holy Spirit.

SPEAKER_00Now, I'm not to judge. God is. OK, but I'm comfortable saying this is the normative way. But I'm going to I'm going to look at like in Acts 15, see the verse eight or nine talking about Cornelius, who got the Holy Spirit before he was baptized. In recounting that to the council in Jerusalem, Peter says, God who looks at the heart gave them the Holy Spirit just as he

did to us.

SPEAKER_00Now, they needed to be baptized because the two should go together. That's what happens in Acts 10 and 11. But that's where I land to on that. Here's our expression that we use. And this is, by the way, a classic Christian church expression that I found helpful. And it's an early church expression. God is not bound by baptism, but we are bound to uphold it as our norms. And then even if you believe the spirit, you've received the spirit apart from baptism,

SPEAKER_00because I meet lots of people. You do, too. I still think you need to be baptized. It's like like look at Cornelius. He still had to be baptized. And this is like you said, Ephesians chapter four. It's one of the seven unity platforms in the Bible. So in our congregation and anybody I coach and recommend, you know, you got to make sure that they get that right before they're considered a member in your church, because I think it's upholding biblical norms.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, and I think that's such a great point about Cornelius is that that's the first thing that Peter said when they received the Holy Spirit. The first thing that he said was, you know, that they need to be baptized. And so I think that this is such an interesting way. And I want to be really clear for everybody that's listening, because we've told a lot of stories and we've gone to a lot of places in this conversation. It's been really rich. But the idea is that we absolutely preach the necessity of baptism, that this is the...

SPEAKER_01Again, I like that word normative. This is the normal way of doing things. As you were describing things in Sierra Leone, it made me think about the fact that there are so many churches across America that don't have men who are qualified to serve as elders. And so they... They make exceptions. They do whatever they need to do to kind of make it until they have men that they can appoint as elders. Now, that doesn't mean that they don't believe in the necessity of elders. They believe that it's necessary that churches have elders. The Book of Acts says that they appointed men in every city.

SPEAKER_01They appointed elders in every city. so we believe in the necessity of elders that's the normative way of doing church is having a group of older men who oversee and and shepherd that congregation that's the normative way of doing it it's the necessary way of doing it we need to move towards that but we also recognize that god can work in extraordinary or exceptional types of situations And so I think that what you're acknowledging is that salvation isn't a machine. It's not a,

you push this button, then you push this button, and then this happens.

SPEAKER_01What we're saying is that salvation is always about trusting in Jesus. It's about committing ourselves to him. And God is, God does what God wants to do. The Holy Spirit does what the Holy Spirit wants to do. And we acknowledge that, but we still uphold the necessity, the importance, the normativeness of baptism in all of our conversations. So I appreciate the nuance there.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, Wes, you know, this was Alexander Campbell's view. He didn't articulate it this way, but he ends up at the same place. And in the early restoration movement, like this view was, was the way people understood it it's only after the civil war and uh there's sociological reasons why sectarian mindset develops uh you know the south was impoverished uh after the civil war there was a lot of

resentment to northerners

SPEAKER_00there was a lot of desire to kind of find a sectarian righteousness that delineated them from those northerners, that if we're honest and thorough, we'll recognize that some of the streams of the Restoration Movement had too much of a sectarian impulse that influenced how we framed some of these things, right? Yeah. Including like Austin McGarry there in the South in the late

1800s and early 1900s. By the way, Lipscomb tried to delineate his position on baptism from that more sectarian one.

SPEAKER_00Yeah.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, I said on a podcast one time, and it got some pushback, and I understand the pushback, but I said one time that I don't have any confidence in my baptism. I have confidence in Jesus. There were a million things I did not know when I was baptized. There were a million things that I did not understand, but I know for a fact that I was putting my faith in Jesus to save me, to rescue me. that's what baptism is it is a confession that i can't save myself i can't rescue

myself and the king can and he gave his life to rescue me and so we're not if if baptism has become to someone this idea of checking a box and doing it in such a precise way that we we feel like we're we're saving ourselves then the accusation

SPEAKER_01that our our friends in the evangelical world are hurling at us about baptism or regeneration. They're right to say that if that's what we think baptism is, that this is an act of precision by which I'm saving myself, then it's not what the New Testament teaches. It is, as you said, an expression of faith in Jesus.

SPEAKER_00And I think if we can really champion that, Like we lead with that. Hey, baptism is an expression of faith in Jesus. We could say even an expression of saving faith in Jesus for the forgiveness of sins. I guess that's a, you know, saying it two ways. But if we can champion the connection of baptism, baptism to A, the cross, B, to our death to self, C, to our allegiance to King Jesus. Like I'm seeing with Gen Z on these college campuses and all that.

SPEAKER_00The desire, you know, to get baptized. It's like they don't fully see it like biblically and all that. And sometimes it's not fully articulated. But what we're seeing, and I find this true, by the way, all over the place, unchurched people. I never personally have had a problem with unchurched people on baptism. OK, like, oh, the Bible says that. OK, I'm going to do that. That's for me. You know, and they look at it as the time they were saved and everything. The people have a problem with it or people have been discipled

by other church traditions. And so I hope that the booklet is effective with both those without a background.

SPEAKER_00Like we've had people read it and say, hey, I want to be baptized. But then people from other church traditions, I think it can be really effective as well.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, absolutely. Well, Bobby, thank you for this conversation. Thank you for your work. I'm really thankful for this conversation about baptism, but I'm also thankful for whatever bridges that we can build between our different

SPEAKER_00fellowships. We have learning communities renewed us for senior ministers. 450 senior ministers are regularly involved. Some of the guys you might know, Jonathan Stormont, Eric Gentry, Jordan Arnold, they're involved from Churches of Christ. Of the 450, probably 200 are from Churches of Christ. 425 would be Christian churches and 25 would be,

SPEAKER_00you know, people who, you know, they agree with us. They've come to believe in us from other traditions. So I hope it's OK to mention this. And if anybody's interested, reach out to us at info at Renew dot org. That's info at Renew dot org. Because, Wes, one of the goals I have, I felt like God had for me, which we I can explain that with Renew, is that we would bring together uh three groups uh christian churches churches of christ and

then other people who just come to believe from looking at the bible that they believe like we believe and they care about the intersection of um good biblical theology uh disciple

SPEAKER_00making and engaging in our culture I'll add this. I guess I'm making a commercial here, so forgive me. When we were led to start Renew, It was myself, David Young, and Rick Oster from Harding School of Theology with a Church Christ background. It was Brett Andrews, a church planting guy with New Life Christian Church and

Exponential. Tony Twist from Christian Churches, super respected scholarly guy from Christian Churches. And then a couple of guys who had roots in International Churches of Christ. And we felt led to do it that what we were doing is recasting the best of the

SPEAKER_00restoration movement. And that we needed to do that because so many were drifting to progressivism to the left or falling back to legalism to the right. And we wanted to champion, again, the best of. Now, I'll tell you this one last thing. A major motivation was to provide a theology that would undergird long-term disciple-making.

SPEAKER_00So before he died, Dallas Willard discipled my friend Bill Hull. And he persuaded Bill of the following. The gospel you preach will determine the disciple you get. Now, we've added to that a little clarifying. The Jesus you uphold, the gospel you preach, and the faith you coach will determine the disciple you get.

And we realized that the restoration movement, at its best, already had that theology.

SPEAKER_00So we just reclaimed it. And that's what we're trying to do at Renew.

SPEAKER_01That's awesome. That's awesome. Well, I really would encourage people to check out the resources that you have at Renew, including this book on baptism. And I think they'll find a lot of value in all the things that you have to offer.

SPEAKER_00By the way, the book itself, since it's primarily published by College Press, the best way to get it is actually not to go to Renew's website. Go to Amazon.com or CollegePress.com.

SPEAKER_01Awesome. Awesome. Well, Bobby, thank you so much for this conversation and for your work in the kingdom, brother. Thank you, Wes. Thank you so much for listening to the Radically Christian podcast. If you have just a moment, I would really appreciate if you would rate and review the podcast on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you're listening. It really does help more people discover this content. Thank you again for listening. And I also want to thank the guests who join me each week and my McDermott Road Church family who helps make this podcast possible. Okay, now let's all go out and love like Jesus.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. What Does the Bible Say About the Holy Spirit Today?

    Nov 11, 202656 minAudio

    The Spirit is often the member of the Godhead we talk about least, and when we do, He can feel more like a doctrine to manage than a Person to know. In this conversation from the 412 Christian Podcast, Wes joins hosts...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Salvation, Sanctification, and Justification

    Nov 4, 202649 minAudio

    What if the vocabulary you inherited for salvation has left you more anxious than assured? Justification, sanctification, saved: many believers learned these words as tidy categories, and many sincere Christians still...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. What is Baptism of the Holy Spirit?

    Oct 28, 202644 minAudio

    What does it actually mean to be baptized in the Holy Spirit? For many who grew up in the Restoration Movement, the phrase meant a debate about water baptism or a defensive argument about miraculous gifts, and then the...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Is Baptism a Work?

    Oct 21, 202654 minAudio

    If we’re saved by grace through faith, why does baptism still matter? An elder in Tennessee wrote in with a question many Christians are asking. If love is the heart of everything, is baptism just a ritual tacked on, a...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. What the Bible Says About Gluttony

    Oct 14, 202646 minAudio

    Is gluttony only about what is on your plate? Most of us assume we know the answer, and most of us feel a little uncomfortable when the subject comes up. The Bible mentions gluttony far less than many Christians expect,...

    Credit the people on this episode