Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Radical Truth

Radical Truth artwork

Reimagining Economics for a Just Future with Robert Johnson

Nov 4, 20251 hr 7 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Get full access to TBLI Radical Truth at tbli.substack.com/subscribe

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_02Good afternoon, and thank you so much. I'm really honored today we have the brilliant Robert Johnson, who is the president and the founder of the Institute for New Economic Thinking. I'm really excited about this conversation because he's definitely one of my superheroes. Robert, for those that are listening to this, that are not familiar with the work that you've done with the Institute,

SPEAKER_02Explain to us what was the idea behind it, how you got it started, and what were you trying to do? And going forward, does it have to change direction or change its role?

SPEAKER_00Okay, great. Well, thank you for bringing me. onto your platform and exploring. I admire your work tremendously as well. And I always say the Robert Johnson that's the genius is the blues singer. But we all have a hellhound on our trail today, so we can synchronize with him. At any rate, going back to the origins of INET, what I will call the traumatic birth experience by way of background.

SPEAKER_00I had been in both parties. I had been a senior economist on the United States Senate Budget Committee under Pete Domenici, and in 86, when they lost control of the Senate, I moved to be chief economist of the Senate Banking Committee through 87 stock market crash, savings and loan bailout, and other things. Then I worked in the private sector, first at Bankers Trust and then at Soros Fund Management. And so I would guess after I left all of that, I was working in music and film and things.

But the great financial crisis, starting with the Bear Stearns, was very stressful.

SPEAKER_00I sat on the board of a number of places, Campaign for America's Future, Economic Policy Institute and others. And they were starting to bring me together. with key legislators, people like Nancy Pelosi and Dodd and Frank, and I had former colleagues that were on the staff of the House and Senate Banking Committee. So when the Bear Stearns thing happened, I warned many of them that this was not over. This was a kickoff, and they were coming up to an election year.

SPEAKER_00And this was 1988, and they were very frightened about the ominousness of what was unfolding. And of course, when Lehman happened, they had to go to essentially emergency and a bailout, the so-called TARP plan. And when that was implemented, I was in conversation with a man who was a very dear friend, Robert Duggar, who was my predecessor as the banking chief economist of the Senate.

SPEAKER_00And before that, he had been the banking chief economist on the House. And he and I went in to help everybody with the suggestion of some of the leaders. And we could see that the TARP bailout was not going to distribute the burden and the responsibility and the public funding properly. And Rob Duggar and I had lunch with Joseph Stiglitz.

SPEAKER_00We had lunch with Paul Krugman. We had lunch with all these different people who just kind of kicked the tires.

SPEAKER_02Wow.

SPEAKER_00But when we had lunch with, or had dinner actually, with George Soros, George, we thought this was really going to be dangerous. Obama had been elected. but hadn't come into office. And it was a very, very, how do I say, like, what in the world can we do? And we decided to form something called the Institute for New

Economic Thinking, which started in January of 2009 with me traveling around the world and meeting

SPEAKER_00with major economists. And we brought 30 of them. And these are Nobel laureates and famous financial manager from different countries, different regions. And we brought them all to a home that George Soros had in the suburbs of New York. And we basically did three days of conversation. People like George Akerlof and Joe Stiglitz and Jim Heckman from University of Chicago all were saying, what did they think was going on?

SPEAKER_00And I was reporting, what did I think had gone on? when I talked to people all over the world. People like Willem Boider, who used to be a LSE professor and then worked in the private sector with Citibank. All of these people were involved. And at the end of this two or three day meeting, Duggar and myself and Soros kind of had a post-mortal, we discussed it and said, we've got to build something. We've got to build something

SPEAKER_00to change the nature of finance and financial understanding. And we were thinking our marketplace was academia. Create Trojan horses, little projects inside of all the major places and go convince people that what you might call rational expectations and a financial system that didn't have side effects was a fantasy.

And if we could convince the experts to change the nature of how we saw finance,

SPEAKER_00we could take it back to governance. And so that was where we set off with that kind of vision in mind. And I had, how would I say, both experience as a speculator and in government and in the structure of what you might call the cross currents and pressures in government. So then we started to implement it by holding conferences at Cambridge University and held it at King's College, which was where Hayek and Keynes had debated in the years past.

We held one in Bretton Woods, one in Hong Kong, one in Paris, one in Berlin.

SPEAKER_00So we traveled around and we then formed something, which I'm very happy to report to you, called the Young Scholars Initiative. which was people who were in the economics or whether graduate students, postdocs or undergraduate, who didn't think that the curriculum was okay. And you have things going on like Occupy Wall Street and so forth, and everybody's complaining.

And I said to people in the news, it's not a Harvard or a Princeton professor's job.

SPEAKER_00to deviate. It's INET's job to create a supplemental library so that everybody, whether they're professors or students, can see the alternative ways of thinking. Not necessarily what's right and wrong. We're not the judge and jury. But to create the portfolio of what you might call engaged curiosity in light of the traumas that we were going through. We then moved on into things related to climate, people like Gustaf

SPEAKER_00Gus Beth was a person who had worked in climate issues in the, excuse me, Jimmy Carter administration and was very, very in touch. Herman Daly, people like that. We worked on issues. I'm from Detroit, Michigan. So we worked on issues related to transformation in light of automation, machine learning, globalization, NAFTA, and how that intermingled. with racial inequality and the echoes of what you might call

slavery and the

SPEAKER_00attempts in the United States to work on things. I also really, really focused on US-China. And that was because when I was at Bankers Trust and at Soros Fund Management, I was very involved. My former wife had been the head of Japan analysis at the Federal Reserve under Paul Volcker and Alan Greenspan. I had a lot of proximity to Japan and then later to China and worked with

fantastic colleagues, like a man named William Overholt, who passed away this last September.

SPEAKER_00But I really could engage at Beida, Tsinghua University and other things by, what you might say, going to them rather than trying to do things behind their back. Embrace their government, meeting with people through the World Economic Forum. I had known some people, including former prime ministers and things. So INET started holding convenings and conferences. And in the old days, we all used Skype meetings where like at 11 o'clock on Saturday night,

SPEAKER_00I'd meet with Chinese students on Sunday morning. And we would try to enlarge the community. People like Wang Hui, and Yu Yong Ding, who are famous people who started writing for Project Syndicate. And we tried to grow a global awareness, lots of brilliant people like Adair Turner in Great Britain, many, many German economists, French economists. And we just,

how do I say, try to, how do I say, be supple, go to the different issues.

SPEAKER_00through time, look at what was happening, look at what wasn't happening, or what alternatives we should perhaps illuminate, and try to enlarge and invigorate the debate. We also did something related to my work with Alex Gibney on documentary film, which was we started, we hired a video team, a man named Matt Kovecki is the captain of it, to make things like, for instance, Michael Sandel's

did a sabbatical with us and the famous Harvard philosopher wrote a book called

SPEAKER_00what money can't buy morals and markets. They made a full on course movie, multiple episodes. And it showed to millions of people all over the world. What we were basically saying was working papers are important, but if you're trying to increase awareness on scale, watching movies, uh, might project the issues into a much bigger audience. So we ended up working in film. My research director,

SPEAKER_00Tom Ferguson, who was a mentor to me going back to my undergraduate days at MIT. And Tom had written a book called Right Turned. And then another book called The Hidden Election. And the third one called The Golden Rule, He Who Has the Gold Rules. And Tom was a specialist in understanding what I will call the plutocratic refraction of the policymaking process, what in Washington they called the K Street lobbies.

SPEAKER_00But this wasn't confined to America. This was, I mean, Tom's original work was based on America going back to the time of JP Morgan and through the new deal and depression and beyond. But this consciousness about how do we support the development of electric cars in Europe? What famous people in the, how I say Cambridge world, like Luigi Passanetti had to say about distributional adjustment and the advent of globalization.

SPEAKER_00and how the ERM had blown up during unification, what kind of stress it was under as China was invigorating Germany and Germany was creating very, very profound volume of capital goods being sold to China while China was stressing out as it was growing, labor-intensive, low-skill markets all over the world. But that included places like Portugal, and it included places like Spain.

SPEAKER_00So what happened to their real estate markets? What happened to their employment rates? What happened to the integrity of the EU with everybody now on the euro currency? All of those kind of distributional adjustment things became a big part of the work. So that's kind of a, how do you say, a run through history.

SPEAKER_02But you did all of this outreach and information collection, listening. you know, almost continuous listening to other thought leaders, which probably filled up a massive amount of research data, massive data of research, a report, and that went on for how long?

SPEAKER_00Oh, well, at the outset, before we launched, in other words, from TARP to the day of launching, was... we'll say we got the full launch on by, uh, April of 2010. And we started these meetings that Robert Duggar and Soros and I had in January of 2009. Uh, another man who I knew who, by the way, was at that head table in the beginning was Anatole Kolesky, the former journalist with DFT who now has a investment

advisory strategy company

SPEAKER_00called Govkill. And, uh, But we did that, the kind of what I'll call prelude research was really rolling by the time we got to the April 2010 conference at Cambridge University. And we were soliciting grants to see what people wanted to do. We were driving themes and looking for the people who would write about them.

SPEAKER_00I had an interesting window just because of my history. My grandfather was Scottish and my mother was born in Scotland. And so seeing the history of Scotland, there's a wonderful author, James Buchan, who's written about this, wrote a book called The Authentic Adam Smith. And it was driven by, my mother was very involved in the Presbyterian church as well.

SPEAKER_00My father was an atheist, so I felt the tension going on about that, and I studied very intensely what created the Protestant Reformation, and then with the Protestant Reformation, how Great Britain, and particularly Scotland, went secular, meaning they started to say the landed aristocracy of the agricultural era have captured all the churches,

and they're not working for the common good. And I've got documents and debates, or not debates, but conversations, explorations,

SPEAKER_00Between David Hume and Adam Smith, after he wrote the theory of moral sentiments about, we've got to get to this, but not talk about morals and values. We got to talk like scientists because people don't trust the churches anymore. And we've now seen a whole lot of people thinking that people who talk like scientists are subordinates to this power structure. And we've got to go back to morals. But anyway, watching that history in Scotland led me to work as an adjunct

professor at the

SPEAKER_00Union Theological Seminary. Some people I knew from my time in music, particularly a man named James Cohen, brought me in during Occupy Wall Street to sort of say, what should economics do now? And how all of these moral issues had been cast aside or simplified, ignored in deference to power. And so that plays a role in my approach and curiosity in every realm.

SPEAKER_00It's not a, how would I say, just a history of Scotland thing. It's seeing what Scotland did, seeing how the secularization, and then the kind of scientific governance, the growth of central banks and finance ministries. But then you go to socialism and they had a certain romance about government. And then you see what's happened in China, what's happened in Russia,

SPEAKER_00Lenin, Stalin, and the despondency about what you want to call cruelty and control that took place in socialist nations. So I always say, I'm going to write a book someday called Taking Off the Mask and Facing the Future. And it's going to be challenging the romantic love of markets and challenging the romantic love of socialist governance. Because I don't see either one as a balanced, dynamic, improvisational.

SPEAKER_00what you might call credible leader for the common good.

SPEAKER_02So you did this for a little over a year.

SPEAKER_00And we've been at it now for 16 years.

SPEAKER_02Okay. So it's, But did it, how did it transition or did it transition from engaging with various academics, thought leaders, governments, professors, students, entrepreneurs, investors, and then as a reaction from the financial crisis, but did it influence the TARP rollout or did you say, no, we have to go a different direction?

SPEAKER_00What I felt like was during the so-called Dodd-Frank discussions, people like the new Nobel Prize winner, Simon Johnson. He was given the Nobel Prize along with others this last year. He's at MIT. But there were a number of people. There's a woman who was at Stanford University. It was extraordinary. All of these people got involved in MIT. the question of the bailouts and the Dodd-Frank and the what to do.

SPEAKER_00And Joe Stiglitz wrote a book called Free Fall, even though he wasn't His forte, what you might call his centerpiece of genius was not the financial sector. I worked with him on that book quite a bit. And he chaired the UN Commission called the Stiglitz Commission. It brought all kinds of people that I was one of the commissioners on. But there were some really great financial people and people from all over the world. But... It started to evolve away from just finance or what I would

call in addition to finance.

SPEAKER_00But we were, I will say without any question, quite uncomfortable with the bailouts and the, what am I call non-distribution? of the burdens and how many of the mortgage holders underwater got no help. There were a group called the Democracy Alliance that worked on Southern California, San Bernardino, how to restructure mortgages. It was like they took care of the banks as somebody,

SPEAKER_00Joe Stiglitz, I believe, said they paid the polluters. And so there was a deep dissatisfaction that brought Tom Ferguson onto center stage about why would they do this when these people made this error? And it had a lot to do with the money politics of the Democratic Party coalition surviving, but they were taking care of their donors from the financial sector,

SPEAKER_00not the general population. And so it got to be very Very contentious, but it was sort of like contentious underground. And we went to a Republican House, a Republican Senate, Donald Trump. And I think it was very, very, I'll say inside of INET, its board and its leading scholars could see this coming.

SPEAKER_00Famous, no longer with us, but Axel Lehenhofer. had tremendous insight and was engaging people all over the world. He's originally from Sweden. He had been at UCLA. He got along well with the University of Chicago. The Young Scholars Initiative enlisted James Heckman to do empirical studies of what gets you tenure, what subjects are addressed to be in the five star journals that get you the kind

of record. So you get government grants in some countries and you get tenure at major universities. And so we explored the structure of incentives in that intellectual world.

SPEAKER_00And what you might call the aversion of development departments at major universities of taking on issues that offended deep pocket people in sectors that were part of the controversy led to silences that we shouldn't have had. Angus Deaton was very much part of this. He's recently written a book, which I think you'd find very interesting. But he talked about how in the peer-reviewed journals, there are five, what are called five-star journals,

SPEAKER_00in their entire history, there's only been 56 articles written about climate change. And the Quarterly Journal of Economics, according to Angus's book, which came out a year or so ago, and that's the journal that's centered at Harvard and MIT, my alma mater. MIT's my alma mater. And they basically showed that they had no articles on climate change. Only one person... has gotten a Nobel Prize in economics related to climate issues.

SPEAKER_00And that was William Nordhaus at Yale, who was essentially saying, well, with the discount rates so high, you don't have to really deal with it. It's 20 years off and we'll get there. Whereas people like Nicholas Stern, we're not given a Nobel Prize for doing extraordinary work about what you might call the dangers on the horizon.

SPEAKER_02But you, so you created this institute and you were able to convince funders to support it, but support it not just for a couple of weeks, but for a long period of time.

SPEAKER_00Well, George Soros gave us a very substantial baseline grant, a man named James Balsillie, who was part of the research in motion program. The Blackberry company in Toronto gave us a very significant amount of money. And William Janeway, I call them the co-founders along with me. Those three people gave us essentially, you know, 10 to 15 years worth of money.

SPEAKER_02Wow.

SPEAKER_00To really dig down deep, not be afraid, go for it. And, uh, and these people were, were very sophisticated. Soros in the realm of philosophy. Jim Basile was extremely interesting about globalization technology and the protection or not of intellectual property rights. What kind of designs do you get if, say, America protects Silicon Valley

but research in motion is not protected by multilateral global agreements.

SPEAKER_00And then you had William Janeway, who's worked in venture capital, worked in finance, and he's really an extraordinary, deep thinker. So I felt like some of the greatest minds were my donors in addition to my scholars, but that also invigorated the courage of the Institute And it set examples for scholars, because these were powerful men.

SPEAKER_02And what were you, I mean, when you get money, there's an ask, and they expect something back, you know, something, whether it's an article, a sign on a building, or what did they expect you to do? Or what were you offering what this institute will do?

SPEAKER_00Well, what I felt was, number one, We did our first conference at Cambridge University. That's Bill Janeway's alma mater. He had gone to Princeton. He was a valedictorian at Princeton. I went there for graduate school. We did things there with various different centers in the Woodrow Wilson School and the Economics Department. George Soros had a Central European University founded in

Hungary by himself,

SPEAKER_00and we did some joint things there. Uh, I acknowledged all of these people on the website that I, we acknowledged and included them in all of the major conferences. We did conferences pretty much every year until the onset of the pandemic that were in person during the pandemic. We did virtual stuff, but you know, we'd have five, 600 people coming. We founded this young scholars initiative, which is now about 24,600 members, uh,

How would I say I promise to and continue to listen to them about what thematic

SPEAKER_00areas we should implement. We built the amplification system. Like I mentioned to you earlier on the video side, we started creating movies with people who took sabbaticals like Michael Sandel or people like Michael Spence and Joe Stiglitz co-chaired a global commission on economic transformation. Um, Adair Turner did presentations on climate change all over. We got very involved in India, the famous Nobel laureate Amartya Sen,

SPEAKER_00and his wife used to help me engage there. And then again, more recently, one of my board members who's from India, who really understands how technology and a digital emerging market economy work together because there were great tensions because so many times the economic development model always involved low wages and export-led growth from manual labor as the way you

dug out of the ditch

SPEAKER_00with a balance of payments surplus. But now with automation, machine learning and so forth, that doesn't work anymore. So, for instance, looking at the global south, huge population growth in Africa, needs education infrastructure, subsistence farming near the equator is in danger. What do we do? What do we do to facilitate that? People in Europe have been very concerned about

a migration into Italy, France, Spain, and what have you, out of Africa and the Middle East.

SPEAKER_00But when you look at what's on the horizon, the lady who ran the International Office of Migration before it merged with the UN, her name is Tolu Olubumi from Nigeria. He's a friend of mine. She helped me create an understanding of these scenarios. And as she said, what you see going on now causes stress, but it's a spit in the bucket compared to a tsunami on the horizon. We've got to deal with things in Africa.

SPEAKER_00And so it's just, it keeps moving around. We've had donors that are project specific. We've had donors that are general support, but want to understand what we're doing and how we're doing it. And how would I say? And I try to be constructive about what to do, not just a critic of what not to do. I don't want to be despair and despondency.

SPEAKER_02I never hear you say to someone, your children are ugly. You know, you're not, you know, you don't, you try to find ways to communicate and educate on many, understanding where the person is coming from. But Do you feel that you've been able to change the mindset of the people that matter, that need to get things back on track? The reason why I ask that is because I used to teach at the

Rotterdam School of Management.

SPEAKER_02on sustainable investing. They asked me to teach. I was the beekeeping course. Nobody was going to release it. So I did that for a few years, and I was very disappointed because none of the students pursued their heart and pursued that space. They all went to AT Kearney and McKinsey, and they were all unhappy, but they were worried about student loans. And the most shocking part of that was I was asked to join the curriculum committee. And I joined the curriculum and then I never realized that the

rankings of business

SPEAKER_02school was not based on education. It was based on the salary you earned when you left. So this particular business school would reflect to come to this at the Rodham School of Management to be a student there because they didn't have a big, it wasn't like they had thousands of students because they were afraid it would bring down their rankings. If you said you were going to go work at a non-profit or I'm going to work at Robert Johnson's institute,

SPEAKER_02they would not let you in because you'll bring down the rankings. So I said, oh, wow, I didn't realize that that's the system we're dealing with. So you did all of this research, had all of these engagements, lots, mountains, tsunamis of knowledge. Were you able to kind of get through, whether it's politicians or central bankers or entrepreneurs or billionaires or whatever, What were you trying to get?

After you got that information and it's still going on, what's the next step?

SPEAKER_00Well, I think at this juncture, the distress of what the scholar Gary Gerstle calls the rise and decline of the neoliberal order is what I'll call fomenting despair. If you are in denial, but you still think you're moving forward, you can be calm. But if you're shocked, like people seem to be all over the world right now,

SPEAKER_00and then, how would I say, the urgency to do something and the fear of doing something are both much higher than they were Maybe in 2009 and 10, people were amazed at what had happened in the financial system. I think the tension that people feel right now, if you're saying what's on the horizon, I think the breakdown of the,

SPEAKER_00what I'll call, United States-led order, the rise of the BRICS group, Brazil, Russia, India, China, South Africa was where the acronym BRICS came from. And the question of the dollars, international reserve currency status, the question of whether the United States will participate in multilateral agreements.

And all of these questions related to climate change and the ramifications of not doing something what I'll call that is global and inclusive together.

SPEAKER_00This is causing a great deal of distress right now. So you're seeing brilliant people like the former head of the Office of Management Budget, David Stockman, talking about the dynamics of the sustainability of American budgets particularly if the appetite for U.S. Treasury bills as the store of value all over the world is diminished, whether oil continues to be denominated in dollars, which augments the strength of that currency.

SPEAKER_00You have a whole lot of people. My former neighbor and the very famous Ray Dalio. Oh, yeah. He's writing books about coping with a broken system, looking at the parallel to when empires broke down over history and trying to envision what's happening. It's a book that's in progress right now, and he's read a few of the chapters. So you have what I will call some very courageous,

brilliant leaders trying to step forward and identify what the problems are and how

SPEAKER_00you might address them. They're trying to give guidance. My sense is there are people, you know, I used to run the Humphrey Hawkins seminar every, the United States Senate had a, what do you call it, scrutiny of the Federal Reserve. They reported to the government. And when I worked with the banking committee and I've stayed connected with many of the governors there and so forth, and I think they're quite thoughtful and quite soulful. I don't think they're,

SPEAKER_00crunch down in fear and behind the curve. I think they feel a sense of responsibility. There are serious officials at the World Bank. They seem to be the ones I talk to, very frustrated because you can't implement what they need to do because you can't get the money. But they do have an extraordinary design. I see lots of people, I've just been to Hong Kong,

and I see lots of people trying to envision how to create an ethical and strong intra-Asian,

SPEAKER_00what they call the ASEAN country system, again. So I don't... I don't think we don't have clues, and I don't think we don't have courageous intellectuals and leaders, but this overwhelming process of money and politics in the United States, but pervasive in many parts of the world,

SPEAKER_00is really quite daunting. In other words, will you do things that turbocharge the risk of nuclear war so that people in Silicon Valley who are building the guidance and control systems with AI get a lot more money when they're already billionaires. A lot of people are very afraid of war, but they're afraid of that. My understanding, I don't know him, but he's passed away, but Henry Kissinger's last article

SPEAKER_00in the Council on Foreign Relations, Journal of Foreign Affairs, was about, we did nuclear agreements and now we need AI-related global agreements on what not to do with this powerful new tool in order to maintain safety. So I think there's a lot of consciousness, but I think there's a big agenda on the horizon.

SPEAKER_02When the financial crisis hit, I was most surprised because what basically happened, kind of translating it into Brooklynese, where I'm from, is that somebody came to your house, they burnt it down, but then they said to me, don't worry, I'm going to lend you new money to build up your house again. And nobody got upset. I mean, nobody. The outrage was not there.

SPEAKER_02It was very little mass outrage.

SPEAKER_00At the moment. Yeah. Well, to be fair, let's be fair to people who work. If I say I'm going to just sit back and watch all the banks melt down and take the economy into a depression, that's not the best choice. What you need to do is a combination of a bailout which stabilizes the system. So what you might call the adverse side effects don't burn everyone's house down or everyone's job get torn away. But at the same time, you have to understand why you're there and create reforms so

you don't repeat the performance. The so-called SVB problem that occurred in the United States last year, 23 and 24,

SPEAKER_00haunted an awful lot of people because they're saying, oh my God, we're going back to the same place. The people from SVB were on the board of the San Francisco District Federal Reserve and they didn't discipline SVB. They didn't bring them around and are we going to make the same mistakes again? In other words, what happened into the great financial crisis happened.

SPEAKER_00But once it happened, you needed to bail it out, and then you needed to repair the system so you didn't go back there. And it's that latter part that might have been inadequate. That's why people like George Soros stepped up to support INET, because when we saw the TARP legislation and we saw the Dodd-Frank Diwali, they didn't think there was enough reform. And as Joe Stiglitz, who's very good with parables and metaphors, said, we've got the mother of all moral hazards.

What he meant was when they take risk, if they make money, they get magic bonuses.

SPEAKER_00If they lose money, we bail them out. And because the world knows we'll bail them out, the too-big-to-fail banks all have a lower cost of funding because there's no risk premium associated with their funding costs for default. So they then have an advantage relative to other banks to take even more risk. So you're turbocharging concentrated wealth playing too aggressive where the

SPEAKER_00downside is picked up by the federal budget, meaning the population at large.

SPEAKER_02I remember there was a Senate hearing. I forgot, he was from, I think he was from Michigan or Illinois, the senator. And he was interviewing Goldman Sachs, three guys from Goldman Sachs. And he said to them, we have all of the emails you were sending and you knew you were making these CDOs that were junk. And you were bragging about it, that I sold another, you know, CDO and it was junk.

SPEAKER_02But not only did you know that it was bad and it would fail, you insured, you took out an insurance policy that it would fail. So basically you sold a car with no brakes, ensuring that it would crash. And he asked them specifically, don't you have a problem with that? And they said, I mean, they answered him not to get into legal trouble. They said, we're market makers. But the issue about values,

SPEAKER_02morality, you know, just decent behavior never came up, at least in their eyes, because they were chasing that bonus. How did we break that?

SPEAKER_00Well, I've often said to friends of mine in that realm, using the parable from my childhood. When you go to St. Peter's Gate and you want entrance, what are you going to tell them you did? In other words, how would I put it? There's so many different agendas. Lots of people now, I have a very good friend who's a brilliant young man. And he said to me, I went to Harvard and I wanted to study Dante and Homer and Shakespeare.

But I ended up doing accounting and business administration because I knew someday

SPEAKER_00I'd get married and have children. I got to be able to take care of them. I need a credential, not an education was this way of saying it. And so I sense that. Some of the emotional distress that people feel in the advanced economies now is you're supposed to do wealth extraction to take care of yourself and your family and be prestigious and be referred to positively and be on the board of universities or whatever.

SPEAKER_00But are you really doing good? A lot of people feel very hollow when they retire. because they don't feel like they did anything. They're happy they protected their children, but some of their children are saying, why did you spend your life like this? What I'll call the moral dilemmas are conscious among smart children. And so the question I think is how do we create an alignment

SPEAKER_00between social good and the system. So you can deploy your brilliance, your energy, your consciousness, the wealth you've made in the past to create a better world. And I think we're underserving that mission, which metaphorically, I call St. Peter's Gate.

SPEAKER_02I was once asked to speak at a tech conference in Oslo, and they asked me to talk about how tech is going to fix everything. I said, I don't believe in that. I don't believe in tech fix. No, no, we want a different opinion. So they had these climate tech guys who are saying how they're going to get you know, beat the market and get their unicorns and 10x and all of this and how it's going to fix everything.

SPEAKER_02And I said to them, I looked up the figures of the number of people actually working in high tech industry. And then I looked at the number of the people working in small-scale agriculture. You know, it's like 1.4, 1.3, 1.4 billion people work in small-scale agriculture and maybe 30 or 40 million work in, you know, in high tech. And I said, the billion youth unemployment coming up in Africa and Latin America, are they all going to get jobs as coders in AI?

SPEAKER_02Yeah. And they felt kind of taken aback because it was like, what are you talking about? Dying rich as quickly as possible, getting the unicorns. And I've, because I chose, maybe I chose the wrong sector. I chose the financial sector to try to change the mindset and create an economy based on wellbeing. But it's very hard because most of the people in the financial sector are totally extractive in nature.

SPEAKER_02Almost all conversations is, what can I get out of Robert? I don't have to put anything back, but what can I get out? So as soon as they get out what they have or what they want, they think, I don't need him anymore. How do you, you know...

SPEAKER_00Well, this is how I say these are serious questions. I have talked to people at financial institutions about ESG related issues. And one of them said to me, and I admire this, I'll maintain his name in secret. But he said to me, I run a big trading floor. And if we do things that are good for the environment and get a lower rate of return, All my best traders will leave and go to other firms. Yeah, that's true.

SPEAKER_00I can't just do social good and keep my super team. No. And so how do we create through governance the incentives where what is profitable for the common good is profitable as an investment? and the best people align the flow of capital with what the world needs. That's the right way to put it.

SPEAKER_02That's totally true because There's no, it's like shouting loudly in Mandarin to someone who speaks German. Trying to get through. And you think, if I speak louder, I'm going to get through to that person. And I discovered that a long time ago. No, you have to shout, speak in their language and show them the three things, self-interest, opportunity, money flows, and show that over and over again. But you have to align with their interests. If they hit the moral imperative...

SPEAKER_02but they don't hit their benchmark. They're fired. He's right. They're fired. That's their job.

SPEAKER_00What I said to a young man who said to me, he would like to work with me and then be my successor. What was my punchline for him? And I said, what you have to do is understand dilemmas. You can't just be righteous about outcomes. or you're going to be, how do I call it, twisting in the wind. If you understand dilemmas, if you understand the kind of things you just said about how people have

SPEAKER_00resistances to things. One of my favorite books is by a woman named Muriel Rukeyser, who was a great both poet and social critique. And she wrote a book called The Life of Poetry. And part one was called The Resistances, and chapter one was called The Fear of Poetry. And she was basically saying, based on an experience she'd had around bombing in World War II when she was in Norway,

SPEAKER_00that when people are really afraid, and you teach them something that isn't familiar, right? they shut it down, they get anxious, they run away from it. So understanding how to address constructively the emotional place where people are and try to help them move towards that vision of the common good involves not just persuading them, it involves creating social structures where that,

SPEAKER_00what you might call, fear is diminished in the dilemma. and possibility of achieving self-gratification and compensation is enhanced. What economists call externalities are very pervasive. I'll recommend a book to your audience, man from Northern California named Peter Barnes. He wrote a book called Ours, O-U-R-S. And what he told me when I made a podcast with him at INET, is that he wanted to talk to my Young Scholars Initiative

because his dad had been

SPEAKER_00a PhD economist. And he believes that the under emphasis in the economics profession of the common good has been detrimental to where we are going. And, you know, a lot of people in the tech sector are working on strategies for universal basic income and so forth. In other words, we're going to displace you. It's a dynamic thing, and we've got to go with this. We've got to make the rising tide raise all boats,

SPEAKER_00and we've got to give everybody a life jacket. I mean, it seems in many cases so overwhelming, the challenges going forward.

SPEAKER_02And you know better than anyone, you've collected so much information and knowledge and books and understanding of the present problem and the present course. At the same time, a friend of mine, we don't share the same politics, but he was the most successful lobbyist in the United States, only one that went to prison, the only one. And he said, the absolutely best investment you can make is lobbying.

invest in lobbying because the amount of money you spend for the upside is so huge

SPEAKER_02in a relatively short, you write the laws in that. It seems almost insurmountable, that system and also with Citizen United past, you know, unlimited funding and you keep coming back to the money in politics. Is there any hope Or does the system have to completely collapse and then we start again?

SPEAKER_00Well, I think the system, as my friend David Sirota, who built this 11-hour podcast called The Master Plan, said, we are essentially swimming against the tide in trying to do good in light of that. I went to a famous, what I'll call former Wall Street strategist who talks about political economy. His name is Porter Stansberry.

SPEAKER_00And Porter gave a talk last year before the election that I attended. And he essentially said he thought there were three things that kept America from being truly great. K Street lobbyists, the military industrial complex, and the Federal Reserve. And I talked with him because of my experience with the Federal Reserve that I didn't think they were, they weren't the whole downside. But he was saying, but they conform with, you bail out with the public money and they don't impose any new rules.

SPEAKER_00A little bit what we talked about earlier. But when you see very sophisticated Wall Street people essentially acknowledging when they're at an investment conference, the power of lobbying. The military industrial complex is related to lobbying as well. But he's basically saying they're making the world more dangerous to get more money for themselves. That's why it's not just getting more money for themselves. It has adverse effects of the risk of war.

SPEAKER_00But I think it's very hard for me to envision right now that we're going to emerge from this. But I think what we need, my dad was a doctor, so I'm speaking from there. You need a diagnosis before you can have a remedy. And I think the more people who will stand up with a diagnosis, say that echoes with Porter Stansberry or with the kind of work you do or the kind of work INET tries to do,

SPEAKER_00the chance in the crisis of having a constructive resolution or addressing aspects of the dilemmas that move us forward. I'm not going to put probabilities on it, but I'm saying that that's a noble agenda that I hope more and more people will engage in. And a whole lot of people, I want to mention a book that really haunts me because it's so magnificent. There's a professor at NYU named Douglas Rushkoff.

SPEAKER_00He wrote a book called Survival of the Richest. Oh, okay. And it was all about how even the wealthy, the super wealthy, don't feel they can change the system. So they're investing in bomb shelters and undergrounds and so forth to get out of harm's way in the event that things disintegrate. And I found that very, very haunting to read because it... How would I say?

SPEAKER_00I've lived years in Greenwich, Connecticut, and my Wall Street years, I've been around a lot of wealthy people. I don't know many people who think they can bring about the change, even if they identify what to do, how to implement it now. And that's what many people find very scary, who are sophisticated.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, I was, people would also ask me, because most of our work is trying to change the mindset of investors. And they always would say, I always tell them, I never really found it very difficult to get through or change that mindset. I mean, because I always find if you ask any asset owner, any wealthy individual, do you want a financial return and a social and environmental added value? I've never had anyone say to me,

SPEAKER_02no, I want all my money to make life miserable for everyone, and I'm working at that 24-7. For me, I always found it's been an educational issue that when they fully understand what we're talking about, and then long-term, it's also in their interest, and it's about resilience, not about sacrifice that you can get through. This has been an absolutely brilliant conversation. What can we do to help you? those that will listen.

SPEAKER_00Well, I guess if you can help me find more people to give us financial support and more people to challenge us to continue to enlarge our imagination or understand the dilemmas, I would be grateful for that. I also think it's very important now to understand The power structure of the United States and the risk it has, not because I'm an American citizen, but because everyone in the world will be affected by the side

effects of American dysfunction,

SPEAKER_00given the role that it is played. And I would very much want to continue to work with people on creating what you might call a stabilization of the anxiety and polarity between the United States and China. I once met with a very powerful leader in China, right at about six months after Donald Trump was elected in 2016. And he said, there were 40, how did he say,

the per capita income in America was 40 times what it was in China when we started

SPEAKER_00to integrate. And We have a population four times the size of America. So there were going to be adjustment difficulties. But what we saw was American multinational corporations came and built things in our country. And as everybody said, free trade can make everybody better off and nobody worse off. But you have to do adjustment assistance and things.

SPEAKER_00And America didn't do that. And now they're blaming us. And then he said, big companies like Walmart, like Home Depot, like Apple. He gave me a list of about 18. It's not like there's one demon or something. He said, all of these people pay donations to senators so that they don't demand an appreciation

SPEAKER_00of the Chinese renminbi because that would reduce their profits. And the American people suffer from that. I'm from Michigan. Automation, machine learning, NAFTA all played a stressful role in Detroit. But what he was saying to me as a Chinese, you're an economist, Rob. There was a way you could have made everybody better off and nobody worse off. And the stress was going to be big because at the outset, we were big and much lower income.

SPEAKER_00How come America didn't respond to this with balance? And I just use that as an example of a parable. How do we create balance? How do we create that understanding of the adverse side effects of change? People, like you mentioned in an earlier part of this conversation, talk about AI. Or they talk about climate change. There are people who are afraid of ending fossil fuels.

And what people are afraid of is adjustments that put them under greater stress.

SPEAKER_00Just like Chinese labor did in an integrated global system. How do we get to the place where we understand the dynamics of needed adjustment and we compensate people as opposed to watching them burn, and then experiencing rage. I have a very good friend who was once a Princeton professor named David Abraham, and he wrote a book, which I would recommend to all your readers,

SPEAKER_00The Collapse of the Weimar Republic. And what one sees as the simple parable in that book, but it's worth going into detail, is distress creates fear and it makes people amenable to authoritarian false resolution. Our brilliant writer at the Financial Times, Martin Wolf, wrote a book that I helped him by giving him feedback on during

the 2020-2021 kind

SPEAKER_00of window of time. What was it? I'm missing... blanking on the title right now, but it's called The Crisis of Capitalist Democracy. Martin is a beautiful spirit whose family had left Vienna. In other words, his mother and father didn't know each other yet,

SPEAKER_00but they went to London, met there and had two kids. And Martin said to me, many of the other members of my family tree were killed by the Nazis. And David Abraham and Mark Wolf both describe the, what you might call amplification of that dysfunctional process that leads to dictatorship and leads to war. And I think we've got to dive deep into understanding how

distress and dysfunction

SPEAKER_00is cultivated in order to what you might call, address it and not fall victim to it.

SPEAKER_02How do you stay sane?

SPEAKER_00Well, I don't know. I'm a big fan of music. You know, I'm from Detroit. So Diana Ross sings, do you know where you're going to? Do your life, the things that life is showing you. But then she also sings, reach out and touch somebody's hand, make this world a better place if you can. And then Marvin Gaye sings, what's going on?

SPEAKER_01Yeah.

SPEAKER_00My mom worked for the Detroit Symphony. My dad was a jazz pianist. Oh, wow. The famous Motown people were patients of his medical practice. Wow. So Detroit was in stress. When I grew up, 67 riots after Dr. Miller was murdered in 68 and all that stress. 2.1 million people was the city of Detroit when I was a little boy. It's now 700,000. Whoa. Look at the arts. Wow. that came out of Detroit stress. And that's, that's my sugar cookie.

SPEAKER_00That's what I, how would I say, that's how I cope. Trying to understand how to invigorate emotional resilience within yourself is a key part of all of this because they're not handing us what you might call gold medals easily in this world. This is, this is a tough game. But I think it's the right game. And every time I look at my daughters, I have four children, but two here still at home who are 12,

SPEAKER_0013, 13 next week and 15, be 16. Every time I look at them, my sense of purpose is making their world a better place. And I don't know, you know, it may be that people say if you had $2 billion, you could hide them on a... SpaceX capsule in Mars and you'd be better off I don't know but I feel like I just this is a critical time and I admire the work that you do

that's why I wanted to join with you today and well how would I say we need brothers and sisters yeah that's true we all need to stick together but I I go I dip into the arts of Detroit

SPEAKER_00or work on film projects. Eugene Jarecki's famous film, Why We Fight, about Eisenhower, a former general, being the president and being concerned about the K Street influence of the military industrial complex. There are ways that help us with diagnosis, and there are ways that help us with healing ourselves so we maintain the stamina to continue to address the challenge.

SPEAKER_02Robert, this has been a joy. Thank you so much for doing this conversation, but also for keeping the faith and you rolling the stone up the hill despite of everything and doing the heavy lifting. And I'm sure that your kids would much prefer to hang out with you than being on a rocket of SpaceX or from Jeff... Thank you so, so much. And we'll process this and I'll let you know when we publish it.

SPEAKER_02We'll push it out either next week or the following week. Just have to make an intro for that. So thank you again.

SPEAKER_00We got to listen to Bob Dylan, too, because he said, how does it feel to be on your own with no direction home like a Rolling Stone?

SPEAKER_02Yeah, that is so beautiful.

SPEAKER_00A complete unknown.

SPEAKER_02I'm going to just turn off the record. I want to ask you something. Thank you. Thank you again.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Netzero 2050

    Nov 15, 20261 minAudio

    Do you know who sets a target for 2050? People who will not be there in 2050. The CEO will be retired. The board will be on a golf course, or under one. The analyst who built the model will be running a vineyard in...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. New York, I Barely Recognize You And I Mean That as the Highest Compliment

    Jun 11, 20266 minAudio

    New York, I Barely Recognize You And I Mean That as the Highest Compliment Get full access to TBLI Radical Truth at tbli.substack.com/subscribe

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. High-Fructose Leadership: Sweet, Addictive, and Nutritionally Worthless Robert Rubinstein

    Jun 5, 202611 minAudio

    Get full access to TBLI Radical Truth at tbli.substack.com/subscribe

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. The $91 Million Math Problem: Why Finance Funds "Future Forests" While Real Ones Burn

    May 22, 202613 minAudio

    Grassroots Over Big Capital: Lessons from an Upset Election Victory Get full access to TBLI Radical Truth at tbli.substack.com/subscribe

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Niceness is Killing the Planet: ESG, Greenwashing, and Radical Truth

    May 21, 202612 minAudio

    Niceness is Killing the Planet: ESG, Greenwashing, and Radical Truth Get full access to TBLI Radical Truth at tbli.substack.com/subscribe

    Credit the people on this episode