Listen in to a fascinating conversation between GALA Choruses' Executive Director John D. Carrion and Dr. Hsien Chew, the Network Lead of the Proud Voices LGBT Choir Networks. Throughout the course of the interview, Hsien talks about his start with the Pink Singers in London, how the Proud Voices network began in the UK & Ireland and spread to Asia, and the journey of Asia's Hand in Hand Festival, first hosted in 2015 in Taipei and most recently in Singapore in 2025.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
I'm John Carrion and welcome to Season 2 of Queer Voices, the official podcast of GALA Choruses. We are the membership association representing over 15 ,000 singers in the Americas. We are also the producer of the GALA Festival, the largest LGBTQIA plus choral event in the world. You can learn more about GALA Choruses at www dot GALA Choruses dot org. Also follow us on Instagram and Facebook at GALA Choruses. Recently, I sat down with Dr.
Hsien Chew, Network Lead for Proud Voices LGBT Choir Networks. In particular, we talked about his journey with the Hand in Hand Festival in Singapore last summer. Well, hello! How are you? I'm doing really well, thank you. Great, thank you so much for being here today. I'm really excited to talk to you. You've done such incredible work. in this field, so why don't you tell the people who you are, where you're from, all the good things. I know they'll have lots of questions,
so let's go. Gosh, where do I even start? My name is Hsien. That's a good place. I was born in Singapore. I lived there for five years, then moved to Australia for a while. I did most of my primary education there, then came back to Singapore for secondary education, did my national service, and then came to the UK for university, which is largely where I've been based since. I am a member of the Pink Singers, which is the
choir that I first joined in 2002. They're an LGBT choir based in London. And I also set up my own LGBTQ barbershop group called The Barber Fellas, that was in 2010. I helped to establish the UK and Ireland LGBT choir network called Proud Voices UK and Ireland in 2011 and the Asian LGBT choir network in the same year. And then we had our first festivals in 2014 and 2015.
And I've generally been involved in lots of different aspects of the LGBTQ choral community around the world in lots of different sort of capacities ever since. So currently I'm on the board of a group called- I'm on the board of the network of European LGBTQ choirs called Legato. I continue to run Proud Voices Asia and I also coordinate Proud Voices UK and Ireland. Okay, so we have lots to talk about it sounds like. Sorry! No this is wonderful! No need to apologize, I mean first
of all, just thank you so much for all the work you're doing all over the world, right? This is incredible. I think this is one of the reasons I really wanted to have a chance to speak with you today because I know that a lot of people might not understand that a lot of the work is coming actually from the same person, right? And so all these incredible opportunities that we're= that you're providing around the world, you know, and people just won't know about it, I guess is what I'm trying to say. So, you know, I guess what maybe... your entry point, right, was the Pink Singers is what I'm hearing, right? Yeah. So could you tell us a little bit about
the Pink Singers, right? I mean, I've been fortunate enough to see you all perform many, many times, but tell us about the Pink Singers and tell us about, you know, how you got involved and go from there. Ah, Pink Singers is kind of like my second home. Where do I even start again? I would say Pink Singers is one of the oldest LGBTQ choirs in Europe. It was formed in 1983, really after one of the founding members went over to New York, saw the New York Gay Men's
Chorus and came back to London and said, well, you know, we need to have a choir of our own in the UK. He put out an ad in the Pink Paper and that first group of people met in April of that year. And it's basically grown ever since. It's a mixed LGBTQ chorus and justifiably proud of that. We've had, really, trans members since the beginning. There was a period when we had
fewer women members, but I would say they were probably really balanced at the moment and I don't think we've ever been more diverse as a group as we are now. I joined in 2002 and that was quite accidental because I had just finished my university studies, I'd come down to London to start working and one of my colleagues at work who was also gay came up to me and said, look, you know, we need to meet more gay people.
Let's go join this LGBTQ choir. At the time, it was a gay and lesbian choir. And so one Sunday afternoon, we went down to the Drill Hall, which is off Goodge Street in London, for those of you who know London. And I went to this tiny room where there were 40 people sitting in a space where the windows were closed, so it smelled really fruity. Uh, and I was asked, uh, what my voice part was. And then I sat down, uh, next
to, um, a couple of members who, uh, one of whom is actually still a member of the Pink Singers now. Uh, they made me feel very welcome and we, we learned how to sing, um, Colors of the Wind from Pocahontas, uh, which was absolutely dreadful actually. Um, I- I'd sung in choirs before, so it wasn't, um, a new experience. but my experience of singing in choirs had always been at the point where we were quite serious about it and we often
took any song learning quite competitively. And so there was a lot of things to finesse, including, you know, the usual kinds of things with choirs like, you know, vowel matching, breathing, where to place consonants. And it was all really great technically, but it wasn't very fun. And the Pink Singers was simpler music, but it was genuinely fun. And after that first rehearsal, I was completely hooked. I have to add that my friend who introduced
me to The Pink Singers, who saw the advert in the paper about it and dragged me down there, didn't actually get through the voice check because... I mean, he's lovely. He comes to our concerts all the time, but he's really... I've never met anyone more tone deaf in my entire life. Hopefully he's listening and can hear that assessment. Yeah, yeah, yeah an absolute f*** you, thank you. Oh, amazing. So, okay, so thinking through when The Pink Singers was founded, right? So it's
an offshoot in a sense, right, of the New York City Gay Men's Chorus, but... the founder didn't start another gay men's chorus, right? That's really interesting. So what do you think that difference here, what happened there? That's a good question. I mean, I can't sort of say. In 1983, I was a sprightly 11 -year -old who barely knew anything about anything. Sure. I mean, I'm much older than that now and I barely know anything about anything, so I hear you. I mean, if I were to conjecture I would say that, uh, the LGBTQ or the gay and lesbian scene in
London at the time was much more, um, uh, I don't know whether you could say cohesive in some ways. Um, I think at the time the- it wasn't that easy to be out. Um, I think, uh, decriminalization had happened but organization was still something that was quite new. And society wasn't really that prepared for the gay and lesbian visibility
in the way that it had been, that it is now. The first Pride in the UK happened in 1972, I think. Which meant that it had only been a decade since that had happened. And I know that Mark Bannon, who is the first musical director of The Pink Singers, what he found most surprising about that initial crop of, uh, singers was that there were people in like tweed jackets and and aran sweaters, so people who were- were not on the front line of,
uh, activism, you know. Not the people who would stand on the Trafalgar Square carrying banners and kissing each other. These are people who were, um, exploring, I suppose, the- the boundaries of of what was comfortable to them but also the boundaries of what was comfortable to wider society. And I think that that number of people certainly in London wasn't that great, and therefore it had to be inclusive from the outset if we wanted to have an important, I guess, momentum to that
movement and particularly to that choir. In fact, at that initial rehearsal I think there were only about a dozen people who came, and after that first rehearsal the number sort of maybe went down to two -thirds of that, but it did build up gradually after that. And what's interesting about the Pink Singers as well is you've done some incredible work obviously around London, but also around the world. Maybe you could talk a little bit about that. I went to your 30th anniversary presentation. I've seen that you've been to India, all these sorts of wonderful things.
I think people would love to hear more about that. I guess, well, there's a lot to say there really. The Pink Singers has had a really long tradition of working with other choirs and having that experience of traveling across borders. I think being in Europe means that visiting another country isn't as great a geographical ordeal as it is in other places of the world. So you can just, you know, hop across the Channel or travel a short flight away. But it's quite amazing
how much even at that short distance brings up different language, different culture, and a different experience of being queer. And so really, even since the early days of the Pink Singers, the Pink Singers started to make contact with other choirs in Europe. And we participated in the early festivals, European gay and lesbian choir festivals, which served eventually as Legato,
which is the European LGBT choir network. We went to the early festival in Stockholm; I think that was 1986, I believe. And so the idea of traveling, visiting other people, singing together is not a new one at all. I suppose what became very bit more adventurous for us, and definitely adventure for me personally, was the ability to go and travel to other places, other countries beyond Europe, where there was indeed a quite
a significant cultural difference. The visit to India took place in 2015, I want to say. No, maybe 2016. Gosh, I really need to check that. 2016 or 2017? I'm going to say both and then you can check it. What happened is, by 2011, as I said, I had set up the Asian LGBT choir network. And this was a group that was principally East
Asia and a little bit Southeast Asia focus, mainly East Asia. So most of the choirs were in Japan and in China. But I had a persistent search going on and I widened the search at the time from just being in English and Chinese to include other languages: Korean, Japanese, and other Indian languages including Tamil and Hindi. And one of the searches turned up a new choir in Mumbai called Rainbow Voices Mumbai. And so they were
on Twitter, I got in touch with them that way. And I said, hey, you know, welcome to the local LGBT choir network. We hear you exist. Would you like to join us? And the person who I got in touch with, Vinod, said, yeah, absolutely. And they didn't realize that such a thing existed. So from there, it was simply a question of deciding whether the possibility could happen that their choir could come and visit us here in London
or we could go visit them over in India. It was very exciting because I'd never been to India myself. And most of the choir had never been to India either, and I think we all came at it with lots of preconceptions about what the queer life in India was and also, you know, what our personal safety and things like hygiene and all those kinds of things that we think about when we travel anywhere else. And I think it was very
important that the choir, both our choirs, but I think the Pink Singers in particular, prepared itself for this trip to go there without sort of preconceptions and to try to perhaps dismantle some of the prejudices we may have had about going to visiting another country. Yeah, so it was quite an arduous process. We took probably the better part of a year and a half from the conception of the trip to actually going to India.
But it was a good time, well spent, with a lot of educational programs on both sides. So we met virtually. This was the very early days of video conferencing. Well, not very early days, but early enough, pre-pandemic video conferencing, which is not as advanced as it is today. We also organized for educational programs to take place both in the UK and in India. So for instance, over here we had academics working in queer Indian
research to come to talk to us about what life on the ground was actually like for queer men in India and particularly about the intersectional experiences. Because I guess we didn't really have a sense of what pre-existing Indian culture was like and how that intersects and has an impact upon the queer experience over there. And when all of that sort of came together, we then sorted
out things like how to fly over there, when we were going to have a concert, how they were going to be hosting us, and then- and the return journey as well. So there was an awful lot that happened before, that had to be put together, before we actually went to India. But it was an amazing experience. I don't think I've ever made such good friends in such a short time. I would say that when- before we went, there was a lot of
concern that, ah, we would be going there with our, as I said, preconceptions, and that, you know, there was an argument that we shouldn't go there as, you know, the- with the white savior syndrome. I'm using white savior syndrome- you probably can't see me do this, but I'm using air quotes. I can see you. Good, good I mean, it's that situation where particularly if a choir- a group from the West goes to somewhere such as India, there's that perception
from the visitor that we are there to rescue or save the people from a very dire situation. If anything, it was quite the opposite. I think we learned so much about ourselves in that trip and about what queer diversity could look like, even in a country which had inherited our own laws that criminalize homosexuality. So I guess our visit to India actually came at a very fortuitous
time because we in the UK were at that point celebrating 50 years since the partial decriminalization of homosexuality. And that was obviously a really great thing, but we also realize- and- and that the sense of jubilation was also tempered by the knowledge that that law that we'd got rid of in the UK 50 years ago continued to exist in something called the Indian Penal Code and was actively implemented not just in India,
but also across many of the former colonies. And so that law had initially been decriminalized by the local courts. This was overturned by the Supreme Court. And so when we visited India, it was still in place and we used our visit to India to help to amplify the voice of our host choir, Rainbow Voices Mumbai, to ask the Supreme
Court for decriminalization. A lot of our performances, our marching at Pride in Mumbai, all of that helped to add to the tidal wave of indignation against the criminalization of homosexuality there. And that law, Section 377, was eventually finally removed by the Supreme Court in 2019, a couple of years after we left India. So yeah, it was a- it was a very interesting experience
and I would say that ever since then we have continued to remain in touch. As I said, they've become really good friends. Having never been to India before then, I probably go to India at least once a year now just to meet with and sing with my friends over there. It's really fascinating. I think, you know, everyone says travel broadens your mind, but it absolutely does, particularly when you are sharing this experience with other people. Yeah, I mean, this is wonderful. I think,
you know, I've been fortunate enough to go to India twice, and it's just an incredible country. So I'm actually quite envious of the experience that you were able to have there. I'd love to do something like that one day. You know, I think it's really interesting as well, this kind of idea, this- the legacy of empire, right, that we have. So you can celebrate what's happening in the UK of a partial decriminalization in 1967, but then when you go to a former colony, you still have the legacy of empire in the legal structures, right? So this is a really, there's a nuance I kind of hadn't appreciated until you had just mentioned it right now. So if you think
of your sort of your work in India, right, obviously, this correlates directly with your work with Proud Voices Asia, right? Now, by this point, you had already had your first Hand in Hand Festival, right, by the time you had been to India the first time. Yes. Right, okay, um, can you tell us a little bit about how you set up Proud Voices Asia- kind of the thinking there and a little bit about the first Hand in Hand Festival? Okay, let me think this through. Another long story there. No, that's what we're here for. Um, so, uh, in, I
guess, about 2010 -ish or so, the Pink Singers went to Bristol to sing with the local LGBTQ choir there called Sing Out Bristol. And, as usual, when you have these little choir exchanges, they're just over a weekend, but they're really good fun. You usually arrive on the Friday night, head to a pub, get to meet each other, do the rehearsals and texts, and then sing on the Saturday, and then go out to party that Saturday night. Sunday is usually a day of rest and recuperation, you're having a brunch together. And I was chatting
to some of the guys there saying, you know, we really should do this more often, you know, we should get together. Because some of the questions they were asking about our choir and some of the questions that our choir was asking of them were things that come up all the time. And so why don't we just, you know, find other choirs and leverage that kind of that gap. And once again, this is the early days of Twitter. And I think at that point in time, maybe seven or eight choirs were online. And so we started a little group and we started a little chat and
we decided, hey, you know, Proud Voices should be formed. And so I helped to set it up together with members of the- of Gay Abandon, which is the Leeds Choir; Manchester Lesbian and Gay Chorus, that was what was called at the time, it's now called Manchester Proud Chorus; and Sing Out Bristol. And Proud Voices UK and Ireland then eventually went on in 2013 to help to set up the UK and
Ireland LGBT Choir Festival, which is called Hand in Hand. And that was partly due to the Pink Singers also celebrating their 30th anniversary, and it was a way of Pink Singers saying, look, you know, we have this history. We want to create something that has legacy value. Let's create a festival that will bring all of these choirs together. And really in that short time, the number of choirs that had been members of Proud Voices went from that eight to... 16. So it had
really grown even in those few years. And I have to say that now Proud Voices is about 74 choirs at last count, so it's a very large number of choirs in the UK and Ireland. So there clearly was mileage in all of that. And while all of this was happening, I was still traveling back to Singapore regularly. And I'm thinking, gosh, you know, this- all this activity is going on where I am, I decided that I would try and find a queer choir in Singapore. Obviously, the political
environment is very different and it also had Section 377 or a variant of Section 377, so homosexuality was criminalized in Singapore and that meant that most queer activities were underground. So you could only find these places if you knew someone who was already in there, and details were shared by word of mouth. But I did manage to find a choir there, and I got in touch to say, you know, there's this whole thing that's happening over in the UK. Are there other LGBT choirs in
Asia, in this region, which you might want to sing with? Like most choirs who have been contacted for the first time from the outside, they go, oh, I don't really know. I didn't even know there were other LGBT choirs in Asia. And so I probably started to search for this. As I said, it was easier to do this in English and Chinese. And that actually rapidly turned up the choirs in Beijing, in China. It was called Shining Jazzy Chorus (三棱减一合唱团). And in Taipei, in Taiwan, called G-Major Chorus, G大調男聲合唱團, and the Singapore choir. and they became the
core of Proud Voices Asia. And we were having this conversation about the possibility of getting together. And in 2014, Dublin was organizing Various Voices, which is the European LGBT Choir Festival. Sorry, there's so many names and places. I know Ian, who is the festival director, really well. And I said, look, you know, I could really do with something that would bring these people together face-to-face so that we're not just emailing each other. And he said well, why
don't you bring a bring them over here to the to the festival and I'll create a slot for you. So I thought well, what can I do to- to make this happen? And so we had our first ever Proud Voices from Scratch Choir attend Various Voices in Dublin. And this was made up of choirs from Proud Voices UK and Ireland and Proud Voices Asia. And it was an incredible experience because we sang songs in multiple languages. We got together-
we hadn't met each other before the festival, we arrived at the festival and we had like two rehearsals together and then we hit the stage. It was a fantastic experience for me, but it was also a massive experience for the choirs from Asia who had never seen anything like it before. You know what festivals are like, they're incredibly loud, they're chaotic, but they're also such liberating spaces. And they're a place where you can meet and connect and experience
degrees of freedom that you might not otherwise experience in your day to day. And I remember sitting in the theater and there was one of those special evening concerts; it was a Eurovision theme concert. So lots of people dressed in ABBA outfits, you know, silver boots and wigs. You had me at Eurovision, don't worry, you're fine. Good. I just need to contextualize it for those people who haven't heard about it before. Of course, of course, of course. It's basically gay Christmas.
Yeah. If you don't know Eurovision, definitely worth the Google and many YouTube searches. Good luck in being lost down that rabbit hole, everyone. Yeah, so the choir from Taipei. their musical director, I think, the Peking Gay Men's Chorus, was performing an ABBA medley, you know, dressed like Agnetha. And he was just sitting there watching this happening on stage and I could see his jaw was completely dropped, his eyes were completely wide open. He was just so stunned by it. And there was almost like a
tear rolling down his cheek from the sheer joy, but also the sheer freedom of it. And so after that concert, he came up to me and said, look, we have to make this happen in Asia. And we want Taipei to be the host for this first festival in 2015. And so I said, oh, wow, yes, absolutely. And so we got in touch with all the other choirs, the other choirs that hadn't made it all the way to Dublin, and said, let's do it. We'll meet in
Taipei in 2015. And that first festival in Taipei had about eight choirs: nations like China, Japan, Taiwan, Hong Kong, Singapore, mixed choirs, South Korea as well. A great experience. And I know that I was sitting there in the front row watching, I think, the Korean lesbian choir, Unnie (아는언니들). They
were singing Korean songs and playing drums on stage. And I remember thinking, goodness, I can't believe that this has happened. This is just incredible. And I was there with my mouth, you know, dropped, my eyes wide open, and that tear rolling down my cheek because it was such an emotional and cathartic experience. I mean, it was so wonderful, you know, that- I was not that one, but I was that the one this year; gosh, it was just this year. We'll talk about that. It's interesting because I also was able to go
to South Korea this summer and I was able to attend a rehearsal from G_Voice (지보이스). And it was just so wonderful. I was welcomed like I was family, right? And that's, I think, what's really incredible about this community and this movement, right? Is that we welcome each other like family from all over the world, right, you know? And so thank you for being part of that in this sense, right, in creating this opportunity to connect choirs with whom we might not otherwise have been able to do so, right? And it's because of your work that this exists. Thank you. You know,
I would put a couple of caveats on that. You know, Asia is a part of the world which has really seen massive wars until- until very recently. I think I was I was born in a time of peace and I've only ever known peace in Asia, but even recently there continued to be lots of sort of border scuffles and there was a major world war which tore the country apart. There were many civil wars in individual countries and so there's
a long history of enmity between different cultures in Asia. At the very first festival, the Japanese choir sang a song called Sakura, which is a very traditional Japanese folk song about the falling sakura, which is cherry blossoms in springtime. Beautiful song. When I was in Singapore as a child, it was one of the songs that we had to learn in- in multiple different languages so that we got used to hearing what other languages sound
like. And so I thought nothing of it, but after the Japanese choir performed it one of the Korean choirs came up and said look, you know, this song was also sung by kamikaze pilots prior to their final flights. So I hadn't realized that I had a major sort of diplomatic incident on my hands. But I think in some ways, you're right, you know. We- we as queer people, whichever country you're
from, have experienced marginalization. And so we understand what it is like to be marginalized and to marginalize others in some ways. And so there was a tone of empathy and the Koreans came at it saying look, we need you to know this, but they didn't come at it saying we need you to make them stop or punish them or anything along those lines. And so it was very easy to bring the Japanese choir and the Korean choir together
and say look, you know, this is the situation and obviously on the part of the Japanese choir, they were not malicious about it at all. In fact, they were quite mortified that they'd caused any offense, right? But I think it's- it gave us quite an important learning point that yes, there is a lot of commonality that we have and we should be there to celebrate that commonality. But we still also have to acknowledge that there are differences, uh, there is diversity. And we love
diversity but sometimes that diversity butts up against other people's sense of self and how do we- how do we manage that especially in that international context when, yeah, culture is also very important Yeah, I mean, this is a really great point. I think it's very easy often for Western cultures to think of Asia, quote unquote, as a monolith. And I think you make a really good point here of how they're different. And I guess that's in many ways, and please correct
me, but that's kind of the whole point of Hand in Hand, of showing those differences and celebrating them while obviously using the commonality as the thread by which we will convene. Yeah, absolutely. Absolutely. I guess there's a question that I've always been thinking about or that I've been thinking about more frequently, particularly as our own societies start to feel like they're unraveling. How do we focus on the commonalities,
acknowledge their differences, but also bridge them to allow us to move forward together? That's I think the question of our times, really. For sure. So could you tell us a little bit also about now the trajectory of the Hand in Hand Festival in Asia? Because you first went to Taipei and obviously leading up to 2025 when we had it in Singapore, I would love to hear a little bit more about that. So after the Taipei Festival,
the Korean choirs decided that they would pick up the mantle. Uh, they were in no way coerced and I will, um, I will die on that hill. Maybe we should ask them, huh? Don't get in touch with them. Okay, okay, I'm sorry, I'm sorry, sorry, sorry. Uh, so the next one was two years later in 2017 in Seoul. Um, I think the festival became a bit more refined so rather than just, uh, a- an opportunity to get together and sing there was much more development
of the social aspect and also of the learning aspect of it, particularly the intercultural learning aspect of it. We kind of recognized that these festivals were useful ways of building community. All choirs build community and I'm sure you've had many of your other previous interviews talk about how choirs do that. But for people who try to bring choirs together particularly across national borders, it becomes a greater
challenge to try to create a sense of commonality. And so they can't just be left to circumstance, everything has to be planned and engineered in such a way to enable that to happen. And the South Korean choirs did a really amazing job. They- the choir in Seoul- that's G_Voice (지보이스) which you mentioned earlier- they had just done a film about them.
One of their members had a really good friend who was a filmmaker and so they created a film called Weekends (2016), which I strongly recommend you watch, about being in their choir. And so they did a private screening for members of the, or participating members of the festival, and we had a Q and A after that. It was really amazing because it enabled us to get a deeper insight into the choir, into Korean patriarchal systems,
and how the choir was itself trying to overcome that, and the importance of solidarity with other marginalized causes in Korea. And also, because it featured people who we had been singing with, gave us a real deep insight into individuals as well, which was such a privilege. The female lesbian choir called Unnie (아는언니들), they had a women's night over in their LGBT Center where they brought
women and they did had a very similar type of event to really learn much more about what feminism meant in Korea, once again about how patriarchal the systems were in Korea, and what was being done to try to overcome it. So it was really interesting; it was an opportunity for people to socialize but also to really learn much more about their hosts. And we took that template and continued to expand on it for the subsequent
festivals. So the one after Seoul in 2017 was Tokyo in 2019. And then pandemic hit, obviously. We were going to have it in Hong Kong in 2021, but that never really happened and then became really difficult to put together. So we ended up having a virtual festival, which is still on YouTube, but if you want to go watch some of the choirs performing- and that was in 2022- it's just, search for Proud Voices Asia Hand in
Hand Festival, Hong Kong. And then the most recent one, which is the one that you went to 2025 in Singapore. Right. Okay. So could you tell us then? So 2025, obviously here, we had the festival in Singapore. I'm assuming this was the biggest festival you've had to date. Is that right? It's the same size as the one in Tokyo. Got it. Okay. And this was my first time attending Hand in Hand in Asia. And I mean, for me, it was just absolutely incredible, right, just to hear the
different choirs performing, to meet all the incredible people and, you know, and to recognize as you rightly mentioned, right, both the commonality and the differences and to celebrate both of those. Singapore obviously is your home, right, and so could you tell us a little bit about what that experience was like in creating a festival in Singapore? It was very exciting and yeah, I guess it was really, really moving for me to be able to put
a festival like this together in Singapore, a place that I had grown up in, where I felt that this kind of festival would never happen. So there was something incredibly satisfying, edifying and relieving about that. And the fact that it even happened was just wonderful. We began the process of planning the Singapore Festival really shortly after the Hong Kong Festival. We thought, well, we needed to have something in person.
In some ways, Singapore was my trump card because I knew that I could make the Singapore choir volunteer to host the festival, if I absolutely needed to. And we felt that this was the time. And to be honest, it was also the 10th anniversary of Hand in Hand, so it felt like things were right. When we started talking about it, Singapore was actually going through that period where
they were starting to discuss decriminalization of homosexuality as well. So that law eventually got removed in 2022. So it was a cause of celebration. But that also fed into the many opportunities because the LGBT community was not, say, completely unfettered, but communities could start to get together. They weren't going to be criminalized for meeting, for organizing. And so we could then
make contact more easily with other community groups, and that includes things like other arts groups, other advocacy groups, even places like Proud Spaces, which is the LGBT community center in Singapore that started up very soon after decriminalization. And so we developed these collaborative projects with them to say, look, you know, how can we work together to make this event happen? There are two ways that I can go
down, two paths I can go down at the moment. But I want to talk about, first of all, the idea of queerness in Asia and the importance of decolonizing queerness in Asia. I think when we talk about queerness we view it from very Western terms, very Western academic terms in fact, and a lot of the language that is used, because it is using English, already comes with a lot of implicit understanding of what things mean. What does gay mean,
what does lesbian mean, what does trans, what is non binary, all of these things come loaded with very specific, I guess, typologies of behavior. And these things aren't often quite so well defined, or defined in different ways in Asia. Even the idea of coming out isn't always necessarily- the way things are done in many Asian countries, the focus is more on a kind of communality rather
than individualism. And so there's a kind of a really passive way of coming out rather than a big sort of grand emergence from the closet in many places in Asia. I mean, once again, this is not a hard and fast rule. The borders are fuzzy. And I think it is also important to know that Asia is not a monolith. So there are lots of different places where there are different levels of influences. And there's a real sort of hybridity to queer identity across Asia. What
the festival I see doing, particularly in Singapore, was bringing together many of these other ideas of what queerness means. And certainly for countries like Singapore and Hong Kong, which are very English-speaking, or countries like Taiwan, which have a big American influence, much of the language used does refer back to existing Anglo-American ideas of queerness. But there's
so much more. There's an emergence of a new ideas of this ever since decriminalization in Singapore. So this was particularly from an Asian perspective and I can sort of see that being explored really in the last few years and really at the festival itself. So that's one of the things that I really wanted to see happen in Singapore. The other thing is that even if you remove a law, society
doesn't immediately change. And the law was decriminalization. It was not about equality. It was not about equal rights. It was not about protection against discrimination. So, you know, you might not be illegal, but can still be discriminated against. Right, right. We applied to- we applied to lots of different venues to host our festival. And from the very start, we wanted to be absolutely transparent that this was an LGBTQ festival. And so we were very aware that we would be limiting our opportunities
if we were very upfront about it. But we didn't want to have to sort of tell a lie. And we didn't want to have the venues, say, cancel on us if they suddenly decided that we were deceiving them from the start. And, uh, it did mean that I encountered the full brunt of very narrow-minded administrators of theaters, of food caterers, of printers, you
know, all the people who provide the ancillary services to make a festival like this happen, who were- who objected to the fact that it was a queer event. And it was really disappointing. The venues were a particular challenge. But I'm really glad that we did find a partner with whom we could work in a really positive way to make the festival come to fruition. I mean, that's
incredible. And I think it's something that people might not have a full appreciation for that nuance and that difficulty. So I guess thinking through- what's next for Hand in Hand? What's the plan? Can I ask that question? What's the next one going to be like? What are you thinking about? So Hand in Hand festivals also happen in the UK and Ireland, and I love them very much. But two Hand in Hand festivals in a year is... too
much for me. And they were coincident since 2014, 2015 when the first festival happened. So- I know- so it was- it was a lot of work. So the next UK and Ireland festival is actually in 2027. And ordinarily, the next Asian festival would also be in the same year. But I decided no, I need a break. We're going to have a festival in 2028. Okay. So, yes, so our next festival will be in that year. We are in the process of negotiating
the next venue. It's a bit of an open secret at the moment. It's probably going to be in Fukuoka in Japan. Wow. Which will be interesting. There's a real- the conversation is really different there because it's- I think queerness particularly in Japan is really sort of hitting the mainstream. And there's an opportunity there for- as in, say, countries like- as in the West, really, where festivals
often are supported by tourism boards because they understand that it brings a financial input into their own cities, Fukuoka is one of those places which has recognized that we have a kind of an economic impact by being there. And so this is the start of that new journey, I suppose? Yay, capitalism, to some extent? But- Yay! So we were exploring that. And then 2030
isn't locked at all in but we are also started conversations for the 2030 event. Now, I wish there was an organization like GALA Choruses, who had helped to organize our festivals. But I think in Asia in particular, there is a real importance on understanding the local systems and local networks and local contacts. We really do want the events to be localized as possible
and that means connecting with local choirs, connecting local LGBT organizations, and- and trying to make sure that when we- as I said, when we run the festival there are many opportunities to learn about what the LGBT community is like in these specific places and how that may differ or be the same as those of our visiting delegates. So because of that, because of the language problems, because of the different laws, that- that hyper locality
is really key. And that means that we are often dependent upon local groups to organize these events, obviously, with- with guidance from from Proud Voices, but it's still- it's still a constant challenge. And so it's a model which we are still examining and re-examining to try to streamline as much as possible. Right, okay. And I guess, you know, thinking through the last question
I want to ask you about is, you know, for our GALA members or anybody listening, is there anything you think we all should know, or could do to help and participate and support this incredible initiative? I would say that I think our festival is growing and we would love to have wider participation in the future from people from other parts of the world at our festival. This does come with
a caveat, in that please do come with an open mind and learn about where you're going before you arrive. And, you know, follow us on the usual socials, you know, Proud Voices Asia, and look for opportunities to support the individual choirs as they embark on different journeys. If you are traveling to these places, why not get in touch with the individual choirs and ask
to come along to a rehearsal? This helps to broaden, I guess, the- your own experience when you are going as- so you're not just a tourist, so you get to meet locals who will take you to local places, but it also enables the choirs themselves to realize that the world is a much bigger place and that we have so much more in common with each other than we have differences. And the more
communication we can have with each other, the more that we can help break down these barriers. I was saying earlier that I think that the biggest challenge to society today seems to be that polarization of world perspectives and one of the ways that we can help to challenge that is to meet and talk to each other and realize that we're all human beings, that we share so much in common with each other, and that we would never want
to hurt each other. Right. Well, yeah, I mean, let's definitely, you know, stay in touch about 2028 in particular, right? Obviously, the GALA Festival is that same year. So let's try not to have the dates clash, at least, so I can definitely get over to Japan. Because I would love to be there again. Thank you so much for- for being with us today, I think. you know, I certainly learned a lot from your experiences. And you know, as I've been saying throughout, just thank you for all the work that you're doing in the choral movement around the world, you know. You're- you're such a key part of this, and I'm
just so grateful to know you. Thank you very much, John, I'm grateful to know you. You know, I still remember when we actually first met face to face, you were working at the, I think, embassy, were you, in just? Gosh, no, I think it was it was then that area of London, was in the Royal College of Psychiatrists, actually. Oh, OK. OK. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. We met for a coffee there because this was in 2016 or 2015. Quite a long time ago. I think even earlier than that. Yeah. We were doing the bid for Gay Games London. That was
what I was talking to you about. It was a long time ago. There was- there was a 2018 bid which we didn't win. So we must have done that probably 2013, 2014. Right. Yeah. Yeah. Gosh. Yeah. So in 2013, 20- yeah, I was working at the Royal. Yeah, I was working at the Royal College of Psychiatrists and- or, not everybody cares where I worked. But yes, in the UK. But yeah, wow, that is a long time ago. A lifetime ago, I was 16 years old. But
yeah, I mean, gosh, yeah. And it's funny to think of all this time later, you know, getting to hang out in Singapore, for example, right? What an incredible opportunity. Yeah, it was so fun. You know, and it was it was just for me, it was, you know, experience of a lifetime. So just thank you for allowing me to personally experience that, but way more important than that is what you've provided to the communities around the world. Thank you. Thank you so much. This has been Queer Voices, the official podcast of GALA Choruses. We do not receive funding to produce this podcast, and now more than ever, it is essential that our stories be told. If you are able, please consider a donation via our website at www dot GALA choruses dot org. I would also like to thank our membership
and communications manager, Reese Schmid, who is also the editor extraordinaire of all of our episodes. If you are enjoying this podcast, please rate and review wherever you listen to podcasts. Please also share far and wide. Thanks for listening and thanks for supporting Queer Stories. Until next time.
Listen to a fascinating conversation between GALA Choruses' Executive Director John D. Carrion and Bill Thieleman from Seattle Men's Chorus, Robert Rufo from San Francisco Gay Men's Chorus, Bebe Magee from Calliope...
Join Queer Voices host and GALA Choruses' Executive Director John D. Carrion for a conversation with the founders of the Transcendent Choir of Philadelphia, Executive Director Celena Spain-Frank and Artistic Director...
Listen to a fascinating conversation between GALA Choruses' Executive Director John D. Carrion and Anjali Murthy, a singer at the Gay Men's Chorus of Washington, DC and alum of GenOUT Youth Chorus, and Matthew Pyles,...
Join Queer Voices host and GALA Choruses' Executive Director John D. Carrion for a conversation with the leaders of the Coro Gay Ciudad de México LGBTIQPA+, Executive Director Oscar Urtusástegui and Artistic Director...
Listen to a fascinating conversation about GALA Choruses' latest commission, "Sincerely Yours: Pauli Murray," centered on a noteworthy yet little known lawyer, activist, scholar and priest. GALA Choruses' Executive...