Listen in to a fascinating conversation between GALA Choruses' Executive Director John D. Carrion and two longstanding GALA Choruses members now working with the Portland Sage Singers: Dr. Tim Seelig, Artistic Director, and Michael McDonald, Board Chair. Throughout the course of the interview, Tim and Michael talk about the idea behind the Sage Singers movement; how to provide a welcoming community for the Q+ elders and allies in our choruses; balancing music and mission; and more.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
I'm John Carrion and welcome to Season 2 of Queer Voices, the official podcast of GALA Choruses. We are the membership association representing over 15 ,000 singers in the Americas. We are also the producer of the GALA Festival, the largest LGBTQIA plus choral event in the world. You can learn more about GALA Choruses at www dot GALA Choruses dot org. Also follow us on Instagram and Facebook at GALA Choruses. For this episode, I spoke with
two GALA Choruses veterans, Dr. Tim Seelig and Michael McDonald, both from the Portland Sage Singers. We talked through the importance of choirs for older members in our community and about expanding the Sage Singers movement. I hope you enjoy. Okay. Well, hello, we've got two really special guests here today. So I'm going to let them introduce themselves in just a second. But first, just so you know, we have Dr. Tim Seelig and we have Michael McDonald. So Dr. Tim Seelig, would you go first and tell us a little bit about yourself? Oh, my goodness.
How long do you have? Just kidding. Well, we're here to talk about the Portland Sage Singers. That's what we're here to talk about. But it is my fifth GALA chorus that- I never intended that to happen but it did. It started in 1987 with the Turtle Creek Chorale and stayed there 20 years and two years later co-founded the Women's Chorus of Dallas and stayed with them about 12 years simultaneous to the Turtle Creek Chorale. And then I started a mixed chorus called Resounding Harmony that was also a GALA chorus.
Then I moved to San Francisco to be the artistic director of the San Francisco Gay Men's Chorus, which lasted 11 and a half years, which is a strange tenure, but something happened in there called COVID. So what I intended as a tenure, lasted 11 and a half. And then I moved to Portland to retire forever in a recliner by the river. And poof, this opportunity came up to help found a brand new chorus for people like me, meaning
old. And so that's what happened. So here I am. This, you know, the path has led me to five GALA choruses. Wow. Wow. And we're going to get back to your definition of old, because I'm not sure that I agree with that use of that word here. But tell me now, you've written some books before as well, right? You've got more of a pedigree than just that. I strangely was invited by the then Shawnee Press to write a book on warmups
for voice for choir. And that started out as The Perfect Blend. And then subsequently wrote five more books, including DVDs that are all about choral technique. And then when I approached the age of 70, having lived a full life at 70, published my- I didn't publish it, my memoir was published in the year of 2020 okay and what's that memoir called- oh it's a good one, John- the
book is called Tale of Two Tims: Big Ol' Gay, Big Ol' Baptist. I remember it. I want to make sure everybody got to hear that incredible title. That tells the whole thing. Okay. End of podcast. Thanks so much for coming. Thank you. Thank you so much for everybody. Okay. Well, I know there's a lot more in that story there, so we'll come back to that. But I want to head over to Michael McDonald- if you could tell us a little bit about yourself. Sure. So I'm here today because I am
the board chair of Portland Sage Singers. I started out in my first GALA chorus, I think it was probably right around 1990. And I found and joined the Lesbian Gay Chorus of San Francisco. I was living in San Francisco at the time and had an amazing run with them for maybe five years or so before I needed to move south to San Jose for job purposes.
But it was incredible because I got to experience my first GALA Festival with the Lesbian Gay Chorus of San Francisco in 1992 in Denver. And that was, as many people have said, it was a life -changing experience. Seeing and experiencing all that goes on at a Festival just opened my eyes to the possibility of what it was like to
be in an environment of more or less unconditional love in a way where you're not being judged, you're being accepted. And it was amazing. So I was hooked. Once I moved to San Jose, then I wound up joining a chorus that's also a GALA chorus, the Choral Project. And I had to run with them for 16 years. And for a period of time,
I was on their board as well and served as their board chair as well for a few of those years, then moved to Portland and joined the Portland Gay Men's Chorus. And that was wonderful. And that's what got me interested in GALA even more, because I started to be exposed to people, two people in particular, Becky Porter and Bob Menzel. who were on the GALA board. And through my interactions
with them, I became interested in joining the GALA board. So I had a stint on the GALA board, which I just completed. I was on the board for eight years. And so, yeah, that's what brought me to that. And then, of course, through all these years getting older and feeling like what it was like to grow older in these choruses. And that's what was one of the things that caused us to start thinking about forming a new chorus just for people like us. Right, okay. So before
we get to the Portland Sage Singers, I mean, I just also want to acknowledge your eight years. So thank you so much for being on the board for eight years and having most recently served as secretary. So I mean, your service is incredible. And so I just want to publicly thank you for that, certainly. Um, okay, so, you know thinking be sort of between the two of you, you know, you have almost 40 years of- of GALA experience each of you, right? I mean that that's that's a significant amount of time. That's- that's really incredible. What- what sort of keeps you in in the GALA world? Um, you know, why do you stay?
What's- what's so special about it? Michael? I mean, it's family. It's- it's, you know, uh, I think- and I'm just gonna speak for myself- you know, there's the families that we are born into that very often as people who don't identify with the quote unquote norms of the way society is, we- sometimes, being that odd person out, you wind
up feeling separated. And when you find an environment where you feel like you belong... it really has so much to do with a feeling of belonging and the feeling of being okay to be exactly who we are. And it's in that environment. And not only do you get to be with people like that, but then you get to create with them and make music with them, which is such a binding force. And you wind up being... that space of creation is magical, I think, for that. So that's what it's like for
me is, I can't not do it. I have to. I- I do this out of deep, deep gratitude. Um, I, this is the funniest thing ever. I gave the wrong title to my book. The book is titled Tale of Two Tim's: Big Ol' Baptist, Big Ol' Gay, because I spent 45 years as a Southern Baptist, working in the Southern Baptist Church, teaching at Baptist
universities. I was all in it, with a wife and two kids when I came out. And I was completely devastated. And I was one of the many. many who considered the world would be a better place if I were not in it. And I did not know there was such a thing as a GALA chorus. That was 1986. And so in 1987, when I found out there was one in Dallas and I auditioned, there is absolutely no question that
a GALA Chorus- the Turtle Creek Chorale- saved my life. I was on a path of despair, and I walked in and it changed my life. So everything beyond that is simply gravy and gratitude. When I retired to Portland in 2022, I was done. It was great. Portland Gay Men's Chorus is gangbusters. Portland
Lesbian Choir is amazing. There's a youth choir. They're good. They don't need me to wave my arms at any gays. Then, when this started, I will tell you that, for me, one of the most emotional things that I can say to describe this is, as a young, new gay, my life was saved by GALA Choruses. As an old gay, now 75, GALA Choruses, I see it every week. I saw it yesterday. I saw
people's lives being not saved, but... elongated. There is such joy. When I first joined the Turtle Creek Chorale and came face to face with my first person with AIDS, full-blown KS, I was so, what- does he do- why is he at rehearsal? And I was told well, you need to learn some things, but he's here because it's keeping him alive. I told the Sage Singers yesterday, they have the best attendance of any choir I've ever conducted because they're
hanging on, this is- this is what they do, they're gonna be there, and you can imagine that with- uh, I'll just, I'll just say it. Um, you have to be 55 and over. Our average age is about 70 and right now we have 100 singers which is insane, just insane. And they show up, so all you young gays and lesbians and people binary, all you people out there, show up for rehearsal. It's so funny. I think sometimes when it's an accessory
for people, when singing in a choir is an accessory, they can take it or leave it. When it is the reason you're able to live another week, you show up. And that's what I'm experiencing with Sage Singers. I mean, this is a fascinating idea, right? So first of all, thank you for sharing that deeply personal moment of yours, I really appreciate that, and I'm sorry that you had to go through that. And I think it's worth saying certainly to the listeners, right, if anyone's out there questioning their identity and or sexuality... the world is better with you in it, always. And
certainly GALA Choruses is here to to help you along that, please reach out to us if we can help connect you with a chorus. It's interesting to hear you talk about the different experiences about your different choirs, both of you, right? And so, Michael, could you tell us if you think, how would you sort of describe your different experiences among the choirs? Or how has that been and how has it been the same? How has it been different and how has it been the same? Well, I think one difference is I've been in
choirs that are mixed and I've been in choirs that are... When I say mixed, what I mean is like all the way from soprano to bass, the whole range of parts, the way things are voiced. And I've also been in basically the TTBB type of environment. So musically, there's a difference there. And I think there also is a difference... it's really
interesting to think about this question because it makes me think a little bit longer about the fact of how things have evolved over the years as well. It used to be a certain kind of environment in the choruses and I think that naturally and wonderfully that environment in the choruses is evolving over time. What am I getting at? I'm getting at the fact that I think my experience is that the acceptance of gender fluidity in
our choruses has evolved. And so it's interesting that my experience in each chorus has changed over those years in sort of in parallel with the way that our way of looking at gender and dealing with gender and accepting and being around people completely in the whole spectrum of gender, it's so much different now. So I'm not sure why
I'm going down this direction, except that has been such a change that I've seen over the years, which also then asks, I then turn it inwards and start talking to myself about how am I gender -wise and things like that. And I'm so grateful to have been in the environment where I could do that. I don't know if I'm answering your question, but. Absolutely. I mean, I mean, I guess I just want to follow up, you know, because I know that you sing outside of GALA choruses as well.
And my question is going to be, you know, how do you see a difference, if any, between GALA choruses and any choir in which you sing that is not a GALA chorus? Yeah, the way I look at it, honestly, speaking from my perspective, is that when I sing outside of a GALA chorus, I'm singing with the primary reason for being there being the music and being to create the music. When I'm singing in a GALA chorus, the primary reason I'm there is for community and
music is part of that. But- but I think the community comes first. Right. In that kind of environment. Does that make sense? John, I said for years that I have twins. I don't actually have twins, but I have twins and they are music and mission. They're my twins. Or art and activism, but we'll use music and mission. And I have to feed them and nurture them every day. And I think where
some choruses go awry is when they say, well, we're just here for the mission and the music slips. And I will tell you that when the music slips, the audience slips as well. And there are others that put music first, and the mission is second. And they're just a different genre altogether. But when you feed those both every day, when you get up as an artistic director and say, I'm going to feed both, I'm going to work on music, but I'm also going to work on
the community, I think that is one of the keys to success in a GALA chorus. I can also tell you from now having done this for 39 years, um, the Sage Singers thing is the most nonjudgmental group I've ever been in. I mean, I grew up a Southern Baptist. That is the most regimental, but I got... I used to say after about a year with the gays, I'm like, I'm going back to the Baptists.
This is- you all people, way too high maintenance for me. And, um, but I found- I find that when we are in our 55s and ups, I mean, we've been there. And we've been- we've judged and we've... and people, it's amazing. So when- when people across the spectrum from soprano to bass show up, they get to show up however they want to and sing whatever they want to. And everybody
is OK, all right, and it's amazing. We haven't gotten to the crux of this whole thing yet. I know, I'm teasing it. I'm teasing it. We did not start Sage Singers. Denver started Sage Singers. That's right. And so, Michael, you want to talk about how that happened? Yeah, yeah. I mean, I didn't even know about Denver Sage Singers until Festival 2024. And then it kind of opened
my eyes and come to find out I was not the only one who left Festival 2024 thinking, wow, what an amazing idea to have a choir of queers and allies who are- who are elders, because then there's yet another thing to bind us together and to create community, because we understand our issues on another level. And so, yeah, so what happened
was a wonderful person I know named Cin Bowman posted on Facebook the idea of perhaps we should in Portland create such a choir. I saw it and my eyes flew open because I was thinking the same thing, of course. And so I responded saying, oh my gosh, yes, let's do this. And we set a meeting. We got together. My idea for the meeting was, well, we're going to decide whether or not
we want to do it. Of course, Cin showed up going, oh no, we're doing this. I've made a list and I have a chart. Michael and Cin decided they would meet in Michael's house and each of them invited a person. I was Michael's plus one for the meeting and Erik Gulliickson, who was a conductor of Bridging Voices, was Cin's plus one. So the- there were two or more gathered. The two became four. And so our initial meeting had four people,
strangely enough, two conductors, which of course could spell trouble, except it did not. As it turns out, it was fantastic. Right. Well, okay. So, I mean, this is amazing. So could you tell us a little bit about actually that process of starting the organization? What did that involve? What was the thinking? Even some of the nitty -gritty, right? Because you had to set up a 501c3. And what was that whole process like? Well, even before you get to the point of applying for a
501c3, you have to do a bunch of other things. Because I think that in order to apply for that, you have to have some things in place first. So I think what we did is we kind of made a list of all the things we felt like we had to do, that list got modified over time as we learned new things. But we just set our sights on achieving it and brought in people as we began the process, brought in people who could help us do that.
One of the things that I felt was really important for this organization is to have somebody who was a financially minded person, you know, and so that's why I knew my friend Mark Clift and took him to dinner one night and said, I need you to think about joining us. So Michael, I'm going to butt in right there, real quick. For anybody out there listening to this that thinks they might want a Sage Singers in their community, here's
what has happened that is so amazing. All the people that are involved in the building of this process are retired. So we got a retired CPA, we got a retired attorney, we got a retired marketing person, and we can have meetings during the day because everybody's retired. We don't have to have it at night. But the interesting thing is that when you are building a younger chorus, everybody's busy. I'm too busy, I've got that,
and, you know, now it's like hey, would you be on our board or be on a committee for our first GALA coming up and they're like well, I might have to move my canasta game for it, but... or our- my assistant who wasn't here this weekend because they were- they were off at a knitting convention, literally at a meeting. So I just wanted to butt in, Michael, and say- and talk about a level of expertise when you're talking about
people who are done with their career and they can invest in Sage Singers. It's magic. And one of the things I knew, for example, getting back to Mark for one second, is I knew that he had helped Bridging Voices get their 501c3. So I knew he had been through the process before, and so that's why he was a prime candidate in my mind. So, you know, working through the list and thinking who can help us achieve these things. That was a big thing. Right. Yeah. And so it
went really fast. So part of it is that Michael and Cin are both driven and focused. And Eric and I float around somewhere. And so literally I think that meeting was in August and I believe that all of those steps were complete by November. The 501c3, our bylaws, a board, a job description for an artistic director. In three months, basically.
It was a land speed record. And considering that many of us use walkers and canes, that is quite something. Now, let me hurry on, having said that, to say one of the beauties of a safe place in GALA Choruses is that we can be self-effacing, we can call ourselves all the things that people might call ourselves out the world and we'd be offended. We have more fun being old. It is the
funniest thing, it's just delightful, and when we get in that safe space where nobody is under 55 and most people are retired, it's a blast. I had a dream that we would have a dance troupe that danced with walkers, and they were called the Sage Singer Walkettes. It took me... well, we're one year old. And the Sage Singers Walkettes
had their debut at our holiday concert, 12 of them, Michael being one of them. So interestingly, none of them actually use walkers, but it was quite a hit for our audience in the fall. We've done two concerts. We did one last June and then December. And now we're preparing for the third concert of our entire lives. And it's- it's just amazing. I can remember the first time that Tim
brought up the idea of having the Walkettes. It was actually last spring, and he proposed that we might have it at our June concert. And we all sat there looking at him in rehearsal going, what? So nobody signed up. You wanted to do what? Yeah, like three people signed up. And I told them that, you know, I was experiencing just a little heartbreak because of this huge disappointment here at the end of my career, and perhaps my
life, that no one had signed up to be a Walkette. And so in the fall, I think when they trusted me a little more, when we had signups for Walkettes we had 18 people sign up. It was rough auditions, I will tell you. Our choreographer put them through their paces, so to speak. That's not true. You're looking at me like, Oh my gosh. No, no, no, no, no. So I will, uh, I will tell you the premise
upon which Sage Singers in Portland are built. Okay. As opposed to the choruses that many of these people come from- less memorization. Boy, is that a key, as our core- and our choruses should memorize, except not when you get to our age memory. Who are you? Who are you? What was your name? Oh, John. Yeah. Memory. Memory. Oh boy. Number two is less choreography. And our choruses
are doing more and more choreography and it's leaving the elders behind. Those two things. Memorizing a two hour concert or for some people two and a half. Don't do that, you youngsters. And choreographing 10 songs out of the sixteen. So it's less memory, less choreography, and no drama. Those are the three things that we're built on. Of course, we have our mission statement and all that stuff. That's not really- those things are not written down. They're just agreed upon.
So like most choruses, you know, we're doing fifteen, fourteen songs average, and we're memorizing three and we have choreographed choreography. Look, we do one jazz hand, just one. We don't do two, holding their music with the other. So it is, um, it's, it is so much fun. If anybody is listening to this, start a Sage Singers. It's
pure joy. That's right. Um, I want to underscore that part, uh, and If you go to Portland Sage Singers dot org, okay, I had to plug that. You can find our mission statement on our landing page. And one of the key words in our mission statement is celebrate, to celebrate being who we are as elders. And so that's part of the self-effacing. It's making fun of... it's a celebration. Look,
this is what it is. Might as well laugh about it. Early on, I called... well, before we had even started rehearsals, I called Holly Near, who's been a long, long time friend, certainly of the San Francisco Gay Men's Chorus, as well as a personal friend. And I said, yo, Holly, we're starting this old people choir. And of course we're going to sing Singing For Our Lives because since 1978, when she wrote that song, I guess every- every GALA chorus in the world has sung
it, along with many others. And I said, I would like to change the words, which she had done for me before and added things that were not there in 1978. She had added cis and trans to the song. And I said, I'd like to change it from singing for our lives to singing for the rest of our lives. And she was like, okay, that's gonna make me cry. She was like, of course you can change the words, not in the music, but our motto is singing for the rest of our lives. And
I think we're gonna do that. It's really lovely to hear this kind of trajectory, right? So we were thinking, just to kind of summarize, August 2024. You sort of start the process. November 2024, you become incorporated. Then you start rehearsals, I believe in February 2025, if I remember correctly. And then your first concert's in June, right? This is, from inception to concert, is less than one year. That's incredible, right? That's really, really incredible. And everything you're describing, it kind of reminds me of the
entire ethos of GALA Choruses, right? GALA Choruses for everyone, and so we can make space for everyone. And, you know, and with different needs, right? And so if we're thinking about a group of elders as you've called it, right, who- with less memorization, with less choreography, but just as much heart, just as much love, just as much community, just as much music as... we're just doing it in a different way. And I think that's spectacular, so thank you for doing that. Of course. I think one of the things that- that we all brought back from Denver- sorry
I just get stuck in Denver- from Minneapolis was that everyone cried to see, look at that. I can sing for the rest of my life, right, if I have that. Elders- when you reach a certain point, many elders, drop out of the choruses they're in. And that's GALA choruses and non- GALA choruses. The voice doesn't do what it used to do. It causes,
I will tell you, some deep insecurity and pain for people who've sung for years and all of a sudden, just like the... the rest of the muscles in their body start to atrophy and and they don't work the way... and when they come to a group where everybody is struggling with the same thing, it's- it's wonderful. It's like wow, I get to sing here, I get to sing again period. And so that's one of the things that in- in Minneapolis, people not
only cried but they cheered and laughed because the... in Minneapolis, the Denver Portland singers sing a song called Old People and it's hilarious. David Maddox wrote it and it's like, what am I- who are these people, who- these old people I'm singing with, well, they're the same age as me. And it's just adorable. So I think the- well they connected immediately, the Denver Sage Singers, and so we're buddies, um, the- the two choruses,
the Portland and the Denver Sage Singers. They have a new conductor, which is amazing, and they're doing great. We co-commissioned. piece. We did already. Wow. Wow. It's true, by the ever wonderful Dave Volpe. And if we have time later in the podcast, I'll tell you about what it was. Uh, it was a funny song. Of course, it's Dave Volpe and Tim Seelig. What's going to happen? And, um, so I want to give props, huge props to the
Denver Sage Singers because they started this movement and, um, now we're all just... um, 17, I believe, or 18 members of Denver Sage Singers came to our first concert in Portland. That's incredible. Yeah. I love that. I love that. Actually, when we have time to tell us about that song, I think it's important for here. Oh, good heavens. Oh, John, seriously? My mama- my mom, big Texas singer woman, she was not healthy in her last many years.
It's what the Baptist calls shut-in. She was a shut-in, and we never knew. We prayed for the shut-ins. We just didn't know who had shut them in. But she was basically bedridden, and I would call her. And being a musician herself, we would sit, and she would go, oh, my back is just, it's not good today, honey. And then she would stop, and she would go, oh, baby, I am so sorry. I know that no one really likes an organ recital, meaning the double entendre of an organ recital and her going through her organs.
So our commissioned piece is called Organ Recital. It includes every -itis, arthritis, all the -itis'es in the song and it's a hoot. So it's just all about all the pains and aches that we as old people share right. Yeah, that's amazing, that's amazing. I love that you've commissioned something. I mean, brand new music right from a brand new group, it's... I mean, exactly what we want. Yeah. So when
you think about kind of, you know, next steps for for Sage Singers, you know? What- what does that look like for you? You know, so it's- obviously your third concert's coming up and, you know, how do you consider the future uh of the group? Michael, you want to say that? Um, sure. I mean, we have come further in this year than I ever anticipated we would come. So when you talk about the future, I start thinking, well, I'm still trying to grasp where we are now. Because I was thinking the
first year, maybe we'll have 50 singers, maybe we'll have a little tiny budget. 35. Yeah, a little tiny budget, meekly rehearse and have our little party, but that's not what happened. There were several milestones along the way that increasingly showed us how much this was gonna really take off. We created this space, the small group of us, and then made the very smart, but
very challenging decision of hiring Dr. Tim Seelig as our artistic director which meant, oh boy, hang on, here we go. Our first rehearsal, we didn't know how many people were going to show up. We did a job trying to recruit, wound up having about, what was it, 65 -ish, something like that. Maybe 70 showed up, which was way more than we expected. Then we came to our- then,
but we're still like going, I don't know, is this going to succeed? And then we wound up having our first show. We were bold enough to decide that we were going to book one of the very nice sort of professional style venues here in the Portland area. And we wound up selling out four weeks before the show. I mean, that was mind- blowing because we- we just didn't expect that kind of success. So hold on a minute, Michael, because you're a big part of that. You know, Stepping
Out In Faith is- it's a song that a lot of GALA choruses are singing from Sing for the Cure and we stepped out in faith and we're like, okay, we could do this at a church. We could do our first concert or we can rent- Michael's understatement of a very nice performance venue, it is stunningly beautiful. It has 550 seats. Wow. And Michael went out and got our first sponsor for that concert, which relieved- it actually paid for the venue.
And our first sponsor was the AARP. Wow. I know. How perfect is that? Perfect. Yeah. That was just really something. And before anybody thinks, oh, wow, they're just rolling in money, we haven't had a sponsor since. So like most GALA choruses we, yeah, we're- we still struggle trying to find that- that thing. So then, uh, we went through the summer and we started up in the fall again with 80 singers and the attrition in this chorus
is way less, interestingly enough, than any of the choruses I conducted or know of. You know, the GALA choruses, when we start, we- a 10% percent is, 20 % by the time you start a concert, by the time you give it. And these folks are just hanging in. So we decided to go back to that beautiful venue. It fits us perfectly with 550 seats. And we did our holiday concert and we sold it out six weeks early. It's- it's lovely. But then people
can't get tickets and they're not happy. I mean, they don't even have an opportunity to get tickets. So we did live stream at the last minute and that was lovely. We are doubling our concerts this June. So we're doing two- two days and scaring us to death with a thousand seats. And we're only one year old. So one of the things that we're doing that you say what's next for- for Sage Singers, is to solve these problems that we've created for ourselves in that, how do we
manage the success in a way? Sure. The success creates problems that you need to work through. So one of those problems I think we recently addressed, we wound up hiring an assistant for Tim, um, a musical assistant. So that is going to greatly help because, you know, if you have a hundred singers, I mean, as an artistic director to have that many singers under you, I mean, the work just goes up. Right. So it's just not
possible. I don't know if I mentioned, but I'm retired. I heard that. Yeah. I don't know if I said that or not, but I want to make sure. So, you know, the part about, um, being our artistic director for a hundred voice chorus is a full -time job and I wasn't looking for a full -time job. So the board is like, okay, this is good. We can- we have a fantastic board, Michael leads an amazing board and they take care of, really, all the administrative functions. Yeah, so hiring
an administrator at this point was- didn't feel like the best- the best move for us. I want to say this to folks out there in radio land, we're talking big numbers. We're talking meteoric growth. We're talking... guess what? You can do this, it can happen in your community. If you look around at your own situation and look at the many people
you know who used to sing... oh my gosh, I hear this all the time, and I will say that GALA Choruses has not been able to plug into the alumni thing. I know many are trying to get the alumni involved, but it's not like a college fraternity, it's... people love the choruses they used to sing in, but when they go away, they go away. And so in your community, if you look around and look at the people that,
you know, who are no longer singing, look at elder communities, which are everywhere now, living communities, as well as local organizations that are serving elders, queer elders. They are there. Oh boy, as they say, the field is ripe unto harvest, as they say where I grew up. It's there. You- your job is just to to create this structure for people to move into and they will and, so that's my- if
you're sitting around listening to this going oh, well that could never happen to- oh, yes, it can. It absolutely can. I'm glad you said that because that was going to be one of the questions I was going to ask you if you had any advice. One question I do want to get your opinion on is, what do you think makes the group so popular to sort of the general audience? Why are people buying so many tickets in this really lovely way? What do you think makes the group so popular? Yeah, it's unprecedented in my time that anything like a brand new chorus would have that. But
I get all preachy when you ask that question because... Do we honor our elders appropriately in our community? No, we don't. We are invisible and we go off and we are islands to ourselves, and when we get to this age we think nobody really wants what I have to offer anymore. When you come together and people go holy moly, let's go-
let's go hear those old people sing, part of it is curiosity to see if we can actually get on the risers and then part of it is what are they going to sing. And it doesn't matter because for every one of those people that buy a ticket, they're buying a ticket to support an elder in their life. Maybe they haven't done that before, maybe they have, but they want to. They want to be a part of this amazing thing that's happening. I can't- I cannot let you finish this thing without
telling you... we're singing around, you know, as choruses do. And this last fall, I said to them in a rehearsal on a Sunday okay, this is not- we're not political. He coughs. I mean, you know, the long held- anytime a GALA chorus takes the stage, it's a political statement? I love that so much. But- and you all know out there in the
world that last fall, Portland was burning down. It wasn't. Portland was at war or a stage war. It wasn't. But I said to them, but it was a mess. The ICE detention center was the focus before Minneapolis. And I said to them, all right. If I said to you all we're gonna sing at the ICE facility how many of you would go. They all raise their hands. I haven't asked the board yet but uh, it means you overwhelmingly want to do it.
And so we went on a kind of rainy afternoon, uh, while it's still light so we didn't have to drive home in the dark, and gathered at the ICE detention center. 45 singers showed up and we sang all the the standard protest songs and had an amazing time. We didn't know that The Oregonian, the paper was filming it. I mean, because there were lots of cameras around, we didn't know they were there. Sure. And by the next- by the next couple
of days, we had 250,000 views of our singing at the ICE Detention Center. But it brought up all those things, John, all the things, should we be doing this? Is that appropriate use? I'm going to say hell yes. As it turns out, the ones who went were so empowered. Look, we are doing a little thing. Those who didn't get to go want to do it some more. I mean, now the detention center is going to shut down, which is fantastic.
But it was one of the things that sort of solidified the activist part of this choir. Well, it's interesting that you said that because this weekend, we just had our- our leadership symposium in Columbus, Ohio. And in my remarks, I said three main points, right? And so it kind of resonates to what you're saying. The first one I said, authenticity is a form of protest, right? And I think it's a check mark there. Number two, art is always political, right? And number three, 2026 is an election
year. So these are things that, you know, I said to the group and I think it's key in, to... you know, the work that you're doing at an ICE detention facility. So thank you for that. I think it's just it's incredible. It's incredibly brave and it's necessary work. And it kind of also leads me to think... to you, Michael, you know, I am not asking Tim this question because I think it's too easy. But it's the question is sort of is there a particular piece of music that you think sort of resonates the most in this group, you know, that that you feel is sort of exemplifies
the organization and what you're trying to do? Well, I mean, I'm just gonna speak for myself, and I know there are at least a handful of others who would agree with me. We sang a song at our first concert, In Whatever Time We Have that, well, I just think about it now when I start to almost tear up, you know because it's so much of what we are trying to do here, is to savor and enjoy and make the most of whatever time we have. And
I think that, for me, resonates so much. And it's such a beautiful song, so that doesn't hurt either. Yeah. We started with Sondheim's Our Time. It's our time, it's our time. We followed that with In Whatever Time We Have. We finished the show with Andrew Lippes' We Are Survivors and brought the house down because- we are survivors. Look at what all we've survived, and yeah, so music selection is a key. It's key, but it's also pretty
easy for- for this- for this choir and, uh, let me just say as well that, umm, we've had- we have had vaccine clinics at rehearsal where our members, our singing members can get both flu and COVID vaccine. So we brought the medical facilities in to do vaccine. We've had a food bank. One of our members runs a food bank and our singers have been bringing in food. It's an LGBTQ food
bank. So we're all up in it. We're just doing this thing. You know, the future, the future's now, for us. The future is now for all of us. We don't know what tomorrow will bring in our country, in our lives, and while we're making plans, which we all do, they're in pencil. Nothing is written in stone, and they follow the basic
path of a GALA chorus. Whether we do a swap-out concert with the Denver Sage Singers or, certainly Festival is on the radar. But there's just, as all the choruses know, there is work to be done. There is so much work to be done right now in our communities. As you said, there's an election. So looking far down the road doesn't resonate
as much with our singers as I think an average GALA chorus because we're hanging on for right now. And we want- we are singing Bob Dylan's Forever Young. And interestingly enough, the solo is being sung by one of our members whose seven- -year-old granddaughter is going to come down and sit on his lap while he sings to her. May you grow up to be courageous. May you be... and
then the chorus sings. And then anyone in the chorus who has a grandchild or a niece or a nephew, they're gonna come down at the end and sit with their grandparent or grand uncle. And so it'll be, yeah, no tears barred on that one. But we get to look back at that, the generational thing, and honor the fact that we have some. We have children or grandchildren or we've adopted nieces
and nephews and we have- we have these children. And I don't know if you've heard the song The Children Are Our Future but boy is it ever true. So that's the richness of what we get to do and we- we adopted Q plus elders and allies. That's Sage Singers, Q plus elders and allies. That's what we got. It's just, that's kind of hard to decide how you're going to say that. And I think
Michael one day in a meeting was like, well, what's wrong with Q plus? We're like, okay, we love you. And this is wonderful. Struggling with queer people... our age of our demographic don't like queer. I like queer, but our age, it was queer. That's what we were called, homo. In Texas, it was homo. If you had to draw that out, you'd be homo or queer. Then the next generation doesn't
like fag. Each of us grew up with different slurs being thrown. I think Q + Elders and Allies, just wraps it up beautifully. I love that. I really do. Yeah, it's interesting the nomenclature we choose to use between generations. And I think what's really kind of resonating to me is this group is a group of leaders who led the movement for a long time. And you continue to do that in a new way and charting uncharted territory,
I suppose, which I think is amazing. And so you continue to set a blueprint that generations that follow will be able to emulate. So I think it's wonderful. You know, something you also said that I wanted to come back to earlier is this idea of twins. I've been thinking about it a lot as you've been talking and, you know, kind of feeding both music and mission. And obviously, you've mentioned lots in kind of in story form. I just wonder if you had sort of a way to encapsulate your philosophy of how you marry music and mission.
It's been a long haul these 39 years. I- I fell into it in 1987 as I said, and The Turtle Creek Chorale at that point was was a music first and a mission second and we grew into- we grew into it because we had no choice in 1987. Because we had members who were dying, right, and then- and so we, we became caregivers and all that thing
just as all the GALA choruses that were around at that time. And when we started the Women's Chorus of Dallas they became our caregivers as well. When we thought- I think every year of my time in GALA at either a leadership conference we used to call them or a symposium or... the question arises every single year and many times during the year, are we still relevant? That is, it's been the topic of conversation forever. We are
more relevant today than we were my 39 years ago. And we have been relevant every day, sometimes more, sometimes less. In the Obama years, we thought, oh my goodness. How will we remain relevant now that being gay or lesbian or trans is just so accepted and then we got slapped in the face. And so I think the thing about music and mission
is so obvious but also hidden, because we don't know where we're going and what we're gonna do. Our mission has changed from gay rights, to marriage, to health, to, oh wait, equal rights. Okay, it just keeps going. Today, we are finding ourselves put in that position where mission is critical,
but we can't forget the music. As I said earlier, when we go out and sing on the street corner... I can't say it was beautiful singing at ICE detention because it was kind of rainy and we had raincoats and I don't know that it was beautiful, but boy was it ever heartfelt. And the people knew that. But keeping the quality in the music- I think people who know me know that's always been foremost in my mind, is if we don't keep the music at its
very highest form, then people disregard us and go, oh, I've heard this before. I won't tell you where. Could have been on the Chorus America board, maybe. And you can cut that out if you have to. No, it's okay. We're big fans of Chorus America. I was on the board for six years and I struggled, it was a long time ago, with, well, you gay choirs don't care about good music. A quote in a board meeting. And I will just say that Alice Parker stood up and scolded the person
who said that. We struggle with that of being disregarded because we're not serious. We are serious. We were very serious about singing Organ Recital. Very serious. We did it really well. Again, I'm going to say what Michael said. I'm not sure that I answered your question. It has to be at the forefront, both of those things. And when I forget, somebody will remind me of
the twins. They'll mention about it. Um, Judith Nelson.... Carol White received the Legacy Award at Festival because she started more musical organizations than most people, I think John Sims being the only one who started more choruses, including the San Francisco Gay Men's Chorus. But Carol White started the Denver Women's Chorus. She started Harmony. And as it came around to Sage
Singers, she was like, I'm not starting another choir. So her wife, Judith Nelson, said, fine, I'll start it. So Judith started Denver Sage Singers only because Carol White was too tired. And they are all up in it. And the both of them, they're now in their 80s. Both of them came to our concert and they're huge supporters, obviously,
of the Denver Sage Singers. And- and they're just doing great. So we've had that connection with Judith and Carol, who started Sage Singers in Denver. Yeah, when we were just getting off the ground, Tim and I had a Zoom call with Judith and Carol, and they were so incredibly helpful. This is before we ever- we were months away from our first rehearsal. And I would actually say that if, for anyone out there who's listening, who's thinking about starting a chorus and you
want to have a Zoom call to talk about whatever you're going through, I'm sure that Tim and I would be more than happy to lend a hand in that way. Just reach out. And you can find us through Portland Sage Singers dot org. See, I plugged that again. Oh, no, I'm laughing because I've written down notes as one of the questions I was about to ask you is how to contact you and then what advice you would give to people wanting to start a chorus. So that's perfect. I mean, you're reading my mind. So the sort of last two questions I'm going to ask you, the first being which- this is one for both of you. If there was a message
you wanted to have both for- for elders and for the generations coming up, you know, two separate messages and or the same message, what would you want them to sort of know most about Sage Singers and kind of this time of life? Well, I'll speak first, since you didn't jump in, Tim, this time. I think the most important thing for me is- we've already touched on a little bit, and that is that you don't have to withdraw from
this community as you age. In fact, there is a place for you. There can be a place for you and a place where it doesn't matter if your voice doesn't function as well as it did, or if you have trouble getting around. We're all about making sure that we provide all the support we can possibly provide for people to be able to participate regardless of what issues they may be going through related to age or not. So that is, I think, the
most important message I would like to see get out there. One of the things people are going to be asking about is what's the audition process? Is there an audition process? Because oh boy, when you get our age, to think you're going to have to do a solo audition is a barrier. That is putting it mildly. I have always invited, in my whole career, we've always had an open rehearsal for potential new members to come and sit in
a real rehearsal, see what it's like, make sure that they're a fit. Then we have auditions. At that open rehearsal, we rehearse three short sections, SATB, and they're- they're told, this is what you're going to audition on these three sections. We send them a little rehearsal track for those three and the music well in advance. And so we actually, the first time around, we auditioned in octets. So it was great. And we could hear, you can hear when somebody's singing
an octet. This time we used our four music section reps and they rehearsed in quartets with our music reps, and then at some point I would have the four music reps drop out so I could hear them in a quartet, but it's very supportive and yeah, I think that's a really important note to get out to folks that if you think you're going to do solo auditions, you will have half as many people show up, maybe less than you would with a really sort of embracing kind of feel. We know
you're seen, we see you, and we're about to hear you, and that's even scarier than being seen. So that's how we did auditions. We even struggled with the word audition as to whether or not we should call it an audition, but eventually we did land there, because just that word in itself has a little bit of baggage to it, with lots of information surrounding that. When I see people, and I will tell you that it's constant in the
chorus, when I hear from people, this chorus may not as I said earlier, may not be saving my life, but it may be saving my life. But it is the thing I look forward to most in my entire week. Yeah, wow. And they come and they hug each other and they yak and yak and... it's not a place interestingly enough, I thought it might be a place where people would just want to talk about
their ailments because, you know, I need somebody to listen to me about my arthritis and my tendinitis, all the -itis'es. It's not that. It's just super uplifting. And they do share with each other, of course. And we try to keep tabs on it as best we can. And it's, yeah, it's mission work at its best. That's great. Thank you so much for
having such strong shoulders for us to continue to stand on as you build out the community even more. And then the last question I have for you is a simple one, I hope. Maybe, maybe not. We'll see. Is there anything I didn't ask you that you wish I had? It might be interesting. We started out with two hour rehearsals on Sunday afternoon. It became apparent that we couldn't get done what we wanted to do in a two hour rehearsal. And so I was like, how y 'all feel about two and a half hours? And they're like, yeah. I mean, they would like to hang out. They would like
to sing. And part of that is because it's so important to them. Right. They don't care. And we have, we have refreshments- not in the middle. We don't have that break in the middle. Like many GALA choruses, we have it at the end and we can't get them out of the room. Y'all- y'all gotta go now, it's almost Monday. Uh, works out great, and for the first time we're having sectionals, uh, coming up during the day. It's hilarious. It's like wow, in the world- and there are some people
still working but with enough notice they're like yeah, we can get off, so we're having sectionals during the day. It's fantastic, um, I think the- I think the best thing I could say is for those of you forming a Sage Singers who come from the GALA world throw all that out and start over with your your perceptions and the things that you think should be this way. Build on it, build a structure and then when that structure is filled
with these people let it go whichever direction it goes, and it will go in different directions and they're delicious. The things that these folks come up with are just amazing. Yep. Absolutely. I- sometimes based on all of the experience I had previously, I sometimes fall into this trap of feeling like I need to plan out everything and I need to have it all mapped out in a clear
road to the future and everything like that. And what I found with this group is that I need to let go a little bit because it's gonna naturally evolve the direction it needs to go, so. It's really interesting to observe that, and I love that and that ties into what you were saying to him. That's beautiful. Thank you both so much. And so it's- so- okay. I know you plugged it a couple of times. So what- what's your website again, Portland Sage Singers org? Okay, and do you have any social media? We are on Facebook. We are on Instagram.
I will admit to you that we could do a better job with those things but you know, that's the- the thing when you have a new organization that's run by volunteers, you often, you know, you get by being scrappy and maybe not. Sure. So that- you talk about future plans There's- there's some of my- my future things I'd love to do better at. I'll plug Denver and- because they they started, not having, not thinking that it was gonna be a movement, right, their website is Sage
Singers org So leave out the Portland, go to Sage Singers org. If you live anywhere near Denver look them up, go to their concerts, support them give them money, Sage Singers org, and they will be grateful for it. And then we can't wait till our third sibling pops up in a city near you. Absolutely. Well, you know, I mean, kind of one of the reasons I really want to have this conversation today is, you know, I'm thinking about how we can kind of proliferate this model across the
GALA network, right? And I think it's a beautiful model. And I think, you know, I'll be talking to our friends in Denver again soon. I want to create more of these as many as possible, as many as are needed, because I think it's not just a want, it's a need, right? And I think we can help that as kind of the umbrella organization. So I'm excited to sort of be part of that work. And again, I just thank you both so much for making this happen and for being here today. Thank you, John. Thank you. This has been Queer Voices, the official podcast of GALA Choruses. We do not receive funding to produce this podcast and now, more than ever, it is essential that
our stories be told. If you are able, please consider a donation via our website at www dot GALA Choruses dot org. I would also like to thank Reese Schmid, our membership and communications manager, who is also the editor extraordinaire of all of our episodes. If you are enjoying this podcast, please rate and review wherever you listen to podcasts. Please also share far and wide. Thanks for listening and thanks for supporting Queer Stories. Until next time.
Listen to a fascinating conversation between GALA Choruses' Executive Director John D. Carrion and Bill Thieleman from Seattle Men's Chorus, Robert Rufo from San Francisco Gay Men's Chorus, Bebe Magee from Calliope...
Join Queer Voices host and GALA Choruses' Executive Director John D. Carrion for a conversation with the founders of the Transcendent Choir of Philadelphia, Executive Director Celena Spain-Frank and Artistic Director...
Listen to a fascinating conversation between GALA Choruses' Executive Director John D. Carrion and Anjali Murthy, a singer at the Gay Men's Chorus of Washington, DC and alum of GenOUT Youth Chorus, and Matthew Pyles,...
Listen to a fascinating conversation about GALA Choruses' latest commission, "Sincerely Yours: Pauli Murray," centered on a noteworthy yet little known lawyer, activist, scholar and priest. GALA Choruses' Executive...