Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Quantum Bombs

Quantum Bombs artwork

Our Plan To Erase 600 Million People β€” Nuclear War, Annie Jacobsen πŸ’₯

Nov 10, 202621 minAudio

In 1960, inside an Omaha bunker, America's top generals were shown a plan to kill 600 million people - one in five humans alive - and almost nobody said a word. Beth sets that meeting next to Wannsee and asks which one was more evil, and what happens to men who set out to stop evil. It comes from Annie Jacobsen's Nuclear War, told through the one man who stayed silent for 48 years.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show.

Quantum Bombs Welcome to Quantum Bombs, a commentary show on the human condition through metaphysics and freedom. The 20th century, some of our greatest minds, we all came together to build a bomb to stop evil. But can you stop evil without becoming it? That's the philosophical question of today's show. Today's story is about two meetings. The one on the left happened in January 1942 at a villa on a lake in Wonsey, Germany, just outside Berlin. Fifteen Nazi officials sat down for about 90 minutes and planned the murder of every Jew in Europe. Eleven million people were on that list. They went on to murder roughly six million. Now the meeting on the right happened in December 1960 in an underground bunker in Omaha, Nebraska. America's top generals sat down and were shown a plan that would kill 600 million people. At that time, that is one out of every five people on earth. Now everybody knows about the meeting on the left and 99% of us have never heard about the one on the right. Today's story is about the second meeting. Which meeting was more evil? The one that murdered 6 million or the one that calmly planned to murder 600 million? How did the country that stopped Hitler end up 15 years later sitting in that room? That is what the story is about. What happens to men when they set out to stop evil? Something I'm about to tell you about that meeting in the bunker comes from a man named John Rubel. He was a business executive and became a top Pentagon official in the defense research. He said nothing that day and he said nothing for 48 years, along with everyone else in that meeting. Now, in 2008, in his late 80s, getting ready to die, he wrote a short memoir and told the whole story. I got this story from the book, Nuclear War by Annie Jacobson, which I plan to start sharing more about it on the show. The philosopher Frederick Niche wrote this in 1886, he who fights with monsters should be careful lest he thereby become a monster. And if you gaze long into the abyss, the abyss will also gaze into you. Now we built the atomic bomb to stop a monster. In August 1945, we dropped two bombs on Japan and the war was over. Four years later, the Soviet Union set off a bomb of its own. So America started building. A year after the war, we had nine bombs and by 1960, we had 18,638. By then, the Army, the Navy, and the Air Force each had their own nuclear plan with their own targets. So the Defense Secretary ordered one master plan for nuclear war and 1,300 people were put on a staff in Omaha and their only job was to build the master plan for nuclear war. Nobody in that building thought they were evil. They were protecting their country, they've got lost in their work, and they kept going. December 1960, Strategic Air Command had quarters under the Ofut Air Force Base outside Omaha. This is where we would run our nuclear war. The room is massive. The walls were 150 feet long and several stories high with a glass balcony up top. One whole wall is covered in a map of the Soviet Union and China. The men sit in rows of old wooden folding chairs, four-star generals on the front row and one-star generals in the back. Our guy, Rubel, is in the second row. Now in that room are the Secretary of Defense, Thomas Gates, and the head of the Army, Navy, Air Force, and Marines, so all the big boys. And running the show is General Thomas Power, the commander of the Strategic Air Command. Alright, and just to put into perspective, who is General Powers? Fifteen years earlier, about 300 American B-29 bombers dropped napalm fire bombs on Tokyo, which is a city built mainly with wood. Power's planes circled above it for 90 minutes while map makers on board charted how the fire spread. So he watched around 100,000 people burn to death in one night. He said it left a tremendous and lasting impression on him. Now, nothing says he enjoyed it, but the man running this meeting had watched a city burn, so he knows exactly what the black marks coming up on these maps mean. Power gives the signal, the show begins. A briefer walks to the front, one aide sets up an easel of charts and another holds a pointer. But they're not the men to watch. Two airmen walk to the opposite ends of that long 150-foot wall of maps, each carrying a step ladder. They climbed at the exact same speed to reach the top of the step ladder. Each one unties a red ribbon, and a giant clear plastic overlay rolls down over the map. Wush. On the overlays are hundreds of small, tiny marks. Each mark is a nuclear explosion, and most of them are on Moscow. The briefer walks them through the attack. The first wave is fighter jets taking off from aircraft carriers near Okinawa, Japan. Then, wave after wave of B-52 bombers, every time he describes a new wave, the airmen untie another pair of ribbons, and another sheet comes whooshing down, and Moscow disappears in little, tiny black marks. Now, in Moscow alone, the plan drops 40 megatons. That's 4,000 times the bomb we dropped on Hiroshima. So here we are, openly talking about a plan to drop a bomb on a major city, not one, not ten, not a hundred, or two hundred numbers that we can grasp, but 4,000 times more than the one that we dropped on Hiroshima. 4,000 times stronger, more brisons, etc. And our guy Rubel sits in the second row and says nothing. Now, the numbers is what we're all here for. That's what makes this meeting so profound. The numbers come in. Now, this is a first strike where America hits first. Russia has done nothing to provoke this. The plan figures around 275 million people dead in the first hour, then at least 325 more over the next six months or so from the radioactive fallout. So that's 600 million people. In 1960, there were 3 billion people on Earth, so that's one in five. About half of those deaths are in countries that we aren't even at war with. They just happen to be downwind of Russia. Those countries will be Russia, Chinese, Poles, Czechs, Austrians, Yugoslavians, Hungarians, Romanians, Albanians, Bulgarians, Latvians, Estonians, Lithuanians, Finns, Swedes, Indians, Afghans, and Japanese, all dead. And that 600 million doesn't even account for the mutually assured destruction in nuclear war. It's assumed that if you fire, your enemy fires back. So if Russia fired back, about 100 million Americans could be dead, plus another 100 million across the North and South America from the fallout. So by this point in time, we have casually floated the idea to kill up to 800 million, not including the untold numbers of people who would starve to death from the nuclear winter to follow on Earth, like a volcano. And if that wasn't enough, a second briefer gets up with a second plan. This one is for China. Same ladders, same plastic sheets roll down. At the end, he points to a chart. Deaths from the fallout alone are 300 million, half the population of China at that time. No one says anything, and the meeting is adjourned. Now, the next morning, there's another meeting, but this one's smaller. And our guy Rubel is there, along with the Secretary of Defense and the heads of every branch. The chairman of the Joint Chiefs, General Lyman Limnitzer, tells everyone, oh guys, you did a very fine job and a very difficult job, and that you should be commended. And the Army Chief says the same thing, and so does the Navy Chief. And the Admiral Arleigh Burke takes his pipe out of his mouth and says, oh yeah, the same thing, basically. Hard job, well done, boys. The Air Force Chief, General Thomas White, also says it too. So nobody objects to killing 600 million people, not the Joint Chiefs, not the Secretary of Defense, and not our guy, John Rubel. Then, finally, one man does, General David Shoup, the head of the Marine Corps and Medal of Honor winner from World War II. Rubel said he was a short man with rimless glasses who could have passed for a school teacher. In a calm, level voice, Shoup said this. All I can say is any plan that murders 300 million Chinese when it might not even be their war is not a good plan, and that this isn't the American way. Rubel went on to write, nobody moved a muscle, nobody backed him up, nobody said anything. In fact, everyone just looked the other way. So this point right here, good job, men, has a similar crossover to the Nazi meeting we showed in the beginning. I think his name's Himmler, said it's a terrible duty, men. He's going to turn you into hard men, but basically, job well done. And you could say that the Nazis were working from hate, but really all human emotion traces back to fear and love. So the hate was really just coming from fear. And Shoup here in this situation had the courage to speak up. But what made him want to speak up in that moment as a human? It came from love. So Rubel had kept quiet that morning and decades later, he wrote down what went through his head. He said that he felt remorse for being part of a plan called part of darkness. And he called it a mass extermination. He was thinking about Wanzi, the villa on the lake in Germany, the meeting on the left side of the screen. So that comparison I opened with isn't actually mine. I'm not that brilliant. It's his. It came from a man sitting in the second row. He wrote, I felt as if I were witnessing a comparable descent into the deep heart of darkness, a twilight underworld governed by discipline, meticulous, and energetically mindless group think, aimed at wiping out half the people living nearly one third of the Earth's surface. Group think is a perfect word for it. A room full of people going along because everyone else in the room is going along. How many times in life can you think of a crowd or a group of people doing dumb things? While I know humans can be amazing people, I've always thought about how dangerous we are in crowds. To prevent further group think, I wanted to make a shame list of everyone that was at the meeting that day and put it on screen for you. All right, so let's look into some of our presidents about this. While this was being baked, President Eisenhower, who led us indeed a helped us beat and defeat Hitler himself, sent his science advisor to dig in on how they're doing. In November, 25th, 1960, the advisor came back and told him what was in it. Afterwards, Eisenhower's naval aid passed on what the president had said. And he said, I'm hearing some things about this Omaha deal that really frighten the devil out of me. He was frightened and he didn't stop it, coming from a general himself. A month after that meeting, in his farewell speech to the nation, Eisenhower warned. In the councils of government, we must guard against the acquisition of unwarranted influence, whether sought or unsought, by the military industrial complex. That is the speech where the military industrial complex entered our language. A few earlier uses turned up, but that's what made it famous. So then we fast forward to John F. Kennedy. He became the president next, and the plan became his. In July 1961, he sat through a briefing on what a nuclear war would do. With his secretary of state, Dean Russ Kennedy said, and we call ourselves the human race. Now, the Nazi plan was carried out. Six million people were murdered. Our plan was never carried out. Nobody died from it, at least not yet, because it never went away. The plan had a name, the single integrated operational plan, the SIOP. It's been renamed and updated over and over. Today, it's called OPLAN 8010-12, and it's aimed at four countries, Russia, China, North Korea, and Iran. Till this day, America still has 1,770 nuclear weapons deployed, most of them ready to launch, and more than 5,000 in total. OK, so again, how can we prevent evil without becoming it? I want to really jump into the human condition of this. Four closing thoughts here. First is, how do you get so involved and wrapped up and evil? You've got horse blinders on, and you're lost in your work. And I want to say, the first part of the work, I picture Oppenheimer, the film, right? It's sexy. It's nuclear war. I myself am working on a three-part documentary series, which is why I'm familiar with the book, on just trying to understand the unknown substance of Equals MC Squared. Is that the same substance that is behind the Big Bang and God and all that is that's in that? It's fascinating. I'm glad that we got caught up in that. That's meant at their best, kind of, right? Because we know that we're also building a bomb that, at its heat propensity, is five times hotter than the center of our sun. And then you go to the paper pushers, the 1,300 people that our government hired to make this plan. I think they probably had more smaller-scale scope of what they were doing. They were weather experts. They were experts on the Metro of Russia, et cetera, and so forth. So people come together, and there's nothing better than having a group project with good cohesion forward for the goal. But I guess along the way, no one stopped to really ask, why is this our goal? Which leads me to my second next point. Is that we projected our own fear onto Russia. We were the ones that built the bomb first. We were the ones that got the bomb. Have we ever looked at this from Russia's perspective? How dare they build a bomb like us? So we were so worried. In 1961, right after this happened, we used a satellite to check on Russia's supply of ICBMs. Turns out they had 10 and we had 57, along with thousands of other bombs and Russia themselves. So the fear is projected. I believe it's the human condition to take what is our worst and see it in others. And then, I guess, in this situation, I think of communication. Like, we all know that 90% of all problems on planet Earth are communication. And I think if you ever just somehow could force people to sit in a room, you'd realize that your goals are likely almost the same and be talked out. Anyway, I'm sorry. I'm thinking of now the Ukraine and the Russia war today, how Zelensky refuses to talk to Putin. Third is, the bigger our government grows, the more room for group think, corruption and evil. Because the bigger the group is, the harder it is to stand up and say, this is a crap idea. This makes no sense. This is too aggressive. And by then, yeah, it's simply that. I really do. I think a lot of people are cowards and no one wants to sit up and be like, why are we doing this in the first place and everybody wants a job and everybody needs money and the bigger the call, the more bureaucracy, the more rot, which brings me to my last point. I don't think a lot of people understand this and I, such a big point. I want to make a podcast about it with my friend on the same show, same topic. Our founding fathers never intended for us to have a large standing military. What they did to limit that was they said that you would need to fund a standing army. You would have to write and approve the financing of it every two years. So they made it annoying enough for us that if we wanted to have a standing military, we would need to finance and fund it and look at those every two years. And then the second amendment said, you shall keep the people. We, the people, a well-regulated militia. So many people misunderstand what that means and what that means is, we should drive through the community part and see a hundred bros dressed up in their military best, doing push-ups, taking firing shots, practicing gun rounds, regulated. The whole point was the people should have more military might than our government ever would and can. And we are so far past that. It reminds me of when Joe Biden threatened our own people with F-15s when he was making the point that you can't beat us, you the people, Texas folks with your guns, when we have F-15 fighters. It goes to show you how bizarre and how far away he got from what our founders intended. Now, let's fast forward to 1945, which is exactly the era we're talking about post-World War II. We came out of that war and we're like, holy crap. Up until that time, we had never kept a large standing military. We would always disband in peacetime and keep a few on hand and maybe send some off to go fight some pirates somewhere. After World War II, we're like, crap, that was really industrious. That was like military industrial complex. Cha-ching, baby. And you see that we were the aggressors. We created the atomic bomb. So it's just like, it's hard to kind of rewind from post-World War II to a point of peace on Earth. It is kind of interesting. I always try to think about, let's just say we wanted to disband our military. What if we went today, hey, everybody, we're a libertarian now, Ron Paul, part two has been elected. We're no longer going to be the police chief of the whole planet Earth. We're just bowing out. Well, we got a huge target on our back now, right? I would say 50% of that is propaganda that they want to feed you so they keep printing money. But we probably still have a big target on our back because we've been the aggressor on the block since then. Now, some may argue, well, thank goodness we're the Western, Western righteous. We've got to keep the peace. But what would it look like if we weren't always the aggressor? And you can't really answer that honestly. I guess that's the point of today's show is how much can you be aggressive to fight evil without becoming it yourself? I hope you enjoyed this show. It's a little bit different than my normal style. So let me know if you liked it or not because I plan to do more whether you do or you don't. But yeah, this is always a big interest of mine and I hope you enjoy it too. All right, stay human, stay free, and may we not chase evil. Bye-bye. The Founding Fathers didn't leave us up Poops Creek without a paddle. They actually gave us a way out, Article 5, State Convention. It basically allows we the people to rewrite our Constitution. Our Congress has rewritten it 27 times, some for good, some for ill. But to get out the corruption, get out the term limits, get the money out, reverse the income tax, et cetera, could all be done at the will of the people with Article 5. But unfortunately, they want you stuck, so they keep telling you to vote. When voting isn't the solution, Article 5 is and no one's talking about it. So please look into that. I would love that to become the main narrative.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. The Power Dynamics Of An Apology β€” What Makes A Good Apology like Jensen Huang’s πŸ’₯

    Nov 13, 202627 minAudio

    Jensen Huang's apology to Nvidia - full ownership, no excuses, no hedging - is the letter Beth has been waiting her whole life to hear from a powerful man. She scores it against what an apology actually has to do, then...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. When You Die on Impact, Does Your Soul Become a Ghost? | Learjet Crash πŸ’₯

    Nov 5, 202633 minAudio

    Beth asks what actually happens to the soul when you die on impact - a Learjet at 700 miles an hour, a C4 blast 26 times faster. Walking the three bodies that encase the soul, the reasons a soul lingers as a ghost, and...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. "Rest in Peace" Origins β€” How the Bible Kept Changing Where Your Soul Goes πŸͺ¦

    Nov 2, 202629 minAudio

    Beth takes on β€œrest in peace” - the goodbye we all type and can’t bring ourselves to send because, believer or atheist, it makes zero sense. She marches through the five times in history we changed what we think happens...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Why Voting Furthers Corruption & Wastes Our Time β€” Founding Fathers Left Us a Way Out πŸ’₯

    Oct 28, 202631 minAudio

    Beth makes the case that voting just fills the seat labeled "corruption" - we keep choosing who sits there, never the rules the seat gets to play by. Then she opens the two peaceful exits the founding fathers wrote into...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. We Are Superhuman & Science Proves It β€” The Sixth Sense, Intuition ✨

    Oct 23, 202633 minAudio

    Beth asks whether what we call 'supernatural' is just natural - a sixth sense we stopped using. From a hunter who talked a Siberian tiger into walking away to blindfolded kids reading cards and blind people seeing...

    Credit the people on this episode