Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Prospect One

Prospect One artwork

Episode 418 - James Anderson of Rotowire

Jun 3, 202654 minAudio

New Prospect One Podcast is BACK 🎙️ @RealJRAnderson of @RotoWire ➡️ Trust the Ethan Salas current run ➡️ How Aidan Miller's injury could affect value ➡️ Eric Hartman surging ➡️ Is Karson Milbrandt a top 5 prospect SP Join up to be a member of the army and support your boys to create more and more unique fantasy baseball content. Top 500 prospects for fantasy, top 400 dynasty, FYPD, GroupMe access, collectors groups and tons more. Go to inthisleague.com and sign up today. Find Welsh on Twitter @IsItTheWelsh and on Instagram @IsItTheWelsh

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Speaker 1In this league podcast that work presents Prospect one Look Fantasy Prospect Podcast Prospect one with your host Chris Welch.

Speaker 2This is the Fantasy Baseball prospect podcast. Yes, this is Prospect one. Hello friends, I'm your host Chris Welsh, who you can find on Twitter, Instagram, at is it the Welsh and of course at in this league dot com that is the Patreon. The podcast has been on a hiatus, but the patreon never is in this league dot Com. Access to the Top five hundred Prospect update, which is updated every month, Top Dynasty four hundred plus. We've got some of the MLB Draft prospects that have been continuously

Speaker 2added per update P one eighty p stuff which we hopefully will get one of those going here soon. And just all the data that we've got at Prospect one Plus. We've got the group me rooms, access to the Prospect one group me room where people are talking about dynasty, fantasy, all that type of stuff, and a ton more in this league dot com. Sign up today in this league dot Com. That's a big important thing to this as well. Because I'm back. I love you all. I appreciate holding through. It was actually very funny. You can tell it was

Speaker 2time to get back to it. When all of a sudden there was like a flood of people reaching out about it. You know, like in the very early onset of taking this little hiatus, which you know, to be fair, I did not give any big warning for I didn't really hear anything, and then I think it started to compound and people are like, hey, need more Prospect one. So I very much appreciate all the people that reached out that wanted to know what was going on. When a new episode was coming back this year definitely required. That's I think I've mentioned this before. Toughest thing about

Speaker 2this podcast is there's really no off period, Unlike like a Fantasy Baseball one. There kind of isn't as well, but you know, you can have like a two month grace period. Then you kind of jump back in and you start doing some pre draft things. And the Prospect said, that kind of really isn't. You're in season, then as soon as you're out of season, you're in the AFL, and then off of the AFL you're already talking about dynasty drafts. So after a couple of years, I needed a little bit of a break in kind of getting everything else established and maybe even figuring out the next

Speaker 2edition of like how I'm going to do some of these. So all that to be said is Prospect one is back. I'm kind of establishing a normal scene, maybe making the episodes a tiny bit shorter booking out so we can kind of assure that it's there. But another thing I would remind is, if you want to make sure that I can continue doing Prospect one, that we can have more episodes, that more stuff can be done, please consider going to end this League dot Com. That is the thing that pushes everything around and makes it go round, so I can even think about doing more. The seasons

Speaker 2kind of continuously get weird. Of course, when we do baseball in season, people can kind of drop, But consider signing up today in this League dot Com. It very very much helps in the ability to do this show, and the more that we can kind of dive into there, the more that I think I can put more of a focus on Prospect one. But regardless of all those points, the show is back. No more need to get into any of those things today on the episode, I've got James Anderson a good way to kind of jump back into things. My dear friend from Ertal Wire, James Anderson

Speaker 2is here where we're going to be talking about a handful of prospects that have absolutely risen up ranks. I mean, there are clearly the mades and the divreeses to talk about, and you know, the Seth Hernandez of the world, but there are some prospects that have made some absolute gigantic jumps in ranks. Many of those are shown in James's rank. Many of those, maybe not to the same degree, are shown in my ranks as well. A few guys at

Speaker 2James likes more than me, and then we're also going to get a who does he think he is higher on and lower on than kind of a consensus. So a nice, good conversation to get back into the flow of things and keep it nice and solid as well. Not going through a good jillion players or anything like that, but some good conversation pieces and also some there's some hooju rathers that are tied into there, so I think you guys will enjoy this, get some thoughts into James's thought process as he put his ranks together, and even put a few players to a test here as well. Obviously,

Speaker 2there's so much going on in the Prospect World not necessarily going to hit all of it. The one thing I am going to touch in this episode with James News that came down today, which probably is the most impactful of like the top twenty five to thirty guys, is I don't know if you guys saw this, but Aiden Miller is undergoing a back surgery. We have not seen aid. We didn't see him in the AFL due to an injury, which I don't think was a back by the way, I could be wrong. I mean that would make sense that it was. Didn't play in the AFL,

Speaker 2didn't see him in spring training, didn't see him at the start of the season, and now hander went a back surgery that he's going to miss a proposed six to eight weeks, which you know timeline would be like, let's just call it August. There is no greater candidate. I'm gonna just say it right now, Aiden Miller, AFL, just lock it up. He was supposed to go last year and then that injury they kind of took him off. He is going to miss, if not the entirety of this season. He is going to come back for about

Speaker 2a month of the season. And that's a huge marker, especially for a value standpoint, And that's kind of what I'm going to talk about with James a little bit comparing to another prospect, because you know, like my ranks are the relative, especially the top twenty five, like you don't see like insane movements. I do have one guy that I did jump that wasn't inside my top twenty five in a last update that has jumped up in but there's not really like a ton of those guys, even with graduations. But Aiden Miller is one of those really weird ones where you're like, man in phenomenal season

Speaker 2last year, it was like a top twelve guy this year insane out of position statistics. He's still suiting regardless of this, he's still super young, but it's like you got a lost season with weird injuries. How do you value that? I think that's like an ultimate test because out of sight, out of mind is one of either the worst offenders or greatest opportunities for dynasty people. You get these great talented players, when they become out of sight, out of mind, they become more valuable because well, to

Speaker 2you the buyer, if the owner of that guy is just like I don't know and then you maybe start to get here's the other thing. Rankers people like decimating a player because you're not going to see them this year. And that's kind of the test that I'm going to put James up against with the prospect that he had really high of Like, how do we account for that? I think that's a really tough question, especially for the elite, elite guys, you know, it's one I think a Mayin Rodriguez is another one of those examples, though he has played this year, he just I mean, he is allergic

Speaker 2to staying healthy. But you know when there's a guy that's like a outside the top seventy five and this happens, Okay, that's one thing you'll say, Persinio, that's maybe a really good example of that. Like Perscenio is exciting. You know, he hits for contact, there's good power and stuff like that. But we haven't seen Persinio at all this season. And this is coming off of a season at you know whatever, twenty years old he hit twenty homers with a two sixty average. I think it's one thing to look at a guy like Perscine like, let's say, Persinio, we're to miss the rest of the season. It'd be one thing

Speaker 2to look at a guy like that who was ranked theoretically outside the top fifty, say he's going to miss the year, and then you're like, well, it doesn't steal bases and it's not average, and then maybe you want to kind of I don't want to say decimate his value, but you want to push him outside like the top you know, one hundred or something like that. It's another thing when you're looking at like a top ten or fifteen prospect and you say they're going to miss the season, but they're still young, you know, Okay, whatever, it's just a lost year that I think I want to push back against it. But I think there's a lot of like rankers out there that could make some drastic moves

Speaker 2on it. There's owners that could be frustrated, oh, I'm not getting the value this year and he could be a bye. So I'm just kind of throwing that out there. But that's big news. And also, you know, in my little world of loving the Arizona Fall League, like I literally couldn't give you a bigger name of a prospect that I am all but assured is going to go to the Arizona Fall League. The only thing I think that would keep him back would be if the injury gets worse, you know, or like he has to have another surgery, Like if it is six to eight weeks, then he has to ramp back up. That is probably

Speaker 2him just ramping up to maybe going and playing in Triple A in a little bit of September and does not make the Majors and is going to the Arizona Fall League. So if you guys cared about that, that would be one of those players. Speaking of the ranks, we will have an update coming up this month. The most current one is two or three weeks old. There's a couple graduation there the rank. Prior to this there was like a big list of graduations that happened. This one is going to have a couple. I suspect I think Ryan Waldschmidt might. Like most recent, we just had

Speaker 2like Treya Savage come off. This will probably be next week that the rank update comes up, so you might have like Waldschmidt come off. I don't think you'd have Emerson. Actually might not be that many that actually come off of this list, maybe h ewing two or three inside the top one hundred that I currently have, but I'm going through this process where the next update is going to have a pretty dramatic change because now the sample sizes are bigger. I'm also going to be diving into a lot of draft content. I think my most recent update,

Speaker 2I believe I had top twenty from the draft as far as like where I think, you know, for fantasy, and I also put like a relative rank range that I think they're going to end up going into. So this next update I will probably have at least thirty. Maybe we'll go as high as fifty. I'm not one hundred percent sure, but I am planning this month to have at least one draft episode in the middle, probably one at the end, and we'll cover a lot of draft stuff, so the comfort levels are make sure if

Speaker 2you had unsubscribed or whatever that you're back. These episodes are going to be back. And I am also shooting for Wednesday releases. I used to put them on Fridays. I think maybe a Wednesday release would be better for the podcast in general, so I'm shooting for Wednesday releases. They're probably going to be a little bit shorter than they were before from a management standpoint, and I am also going to be working on potentially doing at least one mail bag episode a month. I think that'll be good. Interacting with Patreon, and we may do some of those live streams. So again, I can't reiterate enough if you

Speaker 2enjoy Prospect one, you appreciate the stuff that I do. Going over to this league dot com is like an absolute, huge, huge help in signing up there, getting access to the ranks and staying that is a big, big help for me this month. But otherwise, make sure you're following on all the socials. And I did this episode with James in a way that will be very easily clippable on YouTube, So I will let you know by terms of social and stuff if I do end up starting to clip these, I think that might be beneficial if I can do

Speaker 2the individual episode or the individual like topics of conversation.

Speaker 3But all that.

Speaker 2Aside, Friends, we're going to get into the episode, but before we do, I want to remind you of my friend Dennis Sidler. We appreciate Dennis Sidler's support always with the podcast. Go over to sids graphs. You can find them online, find them on eBay the eBay storage sids graphs, and you can find them on the socials a lot going on, and got to give a hat tip because guess what, Sids Graphs doesn't have the plethora of prospects currently that he's doing because they're all in the majors. He recently assigned Pedro Ramirez. I've always I've said this

Speaker 2for a long time, pay attention to who sids Grafs has signed, because if you're not super familiar with their game, you're probably going to be soon. Sids Grafs with aj Ewing at the beginning of the year in the majors, Pedro Ramirez with the Cubs, who's had a phenomenal run boom to the majors. You should go and check out the eBay store because you will see the litany of guys that they've got inventory on, the guys that they're doing current signings with, and there are some major leaguers that are coming up. How about Chris Sale? How about

Speaker 2future Hall of Famer Chris Sale, which he's actually doing. It's usually not out there, but a public signing ascend an opportunity with Chris Sale that's happening. By the time you listen to this, it's probably gonna be a little too late to do that, but you can check out all the crazy, awesome stuff. And a little birdie told me there might be a little Chandler Simpson coming up here in the very near future, So go and check everything that Sidgrass has got going on. You can get amazing unique things and as autographed as well as the things you expect, bats, baseballs, and a full slate of

Speaker 2trading cards that are out there. So go and check out all the awesome inventory. And we will try to be doing a giveaway actually as well this month, so be on the lookout for that over on the Patreon if you sign up, I want to do a giveaway of well, probably we might do a I don't know, I'm not one hundred percent tre you. We got a look, maybe we're gonna have a Chanela Simpson. Probably have to be for next month, but I'll probably check it out in the next week. But go to Sisgrafts check him out today. All right, let's get to the episode. It's James Anderson from Rode Wire. We've got six big prospects to talk about, and then as well a couple that

Speaker 2James wanted to hit. So don't go anywhere. James Anderson on the return of Prospect one say I like you. I like you so much, I'm gonna make you my partner. All he has to do is find the gold and I'll share it with you.

Speaker 1Fifty to fifty Prospect.

Speaker 4What he is?

Speaker 2James Anderson from Rodal Wire. You know him, you love him, You got the dynasty and the prospect ranked out there, and he's one of my dear friends in the industry for very, very long. And that is nifty wrote a Wire polo. You got there going on? James Anderson? What's U buddy, haven't talk to you a bit?

Speaker 4Hey man, Good to be back on the show. Yeah, fresh wag too.

Speaker 2Pretty slick man, brother, I love it. We are gonna be talking through five or six prospects that I really want to get your take on. Obviously, you and I have been in the depths of like you know, just big rank changes, and in those rank changes there's just some like severely big jumps that end up happening. I think these are just I don't even call them polarizing, but these are some really fascinating prospects to talk about. Most of them I think also show up very highly in your newest Prospect rank update. And then we're going

Speaker 2to take a look at least from your words on a player that you think you're lower than consensus on, in a player that you think you might be a bit higher than the majority. So if you are ready, mister James Anderson will jump into it. And I think one of the most fascinating guys out because he was kind of done in so many people's minds, is Ethan Solace and that's who I wanted to start us with Ethan Salas making the jump. It's so funny had he just not had that bad run early on in his career and we just jumped in and we're like, wow, hey, there's a twenty year old that's in double A. He's

Speaker 2hitting three to ZHO nine, he's got seven homers, ten stolen bases. I'd kind of be through the roof. But he lives in this kind of post hype sleeper world where it was one of the youngest to get moved. His bat completely fell apart, and I've had a really difficult time with him, I think as everybody has had. As far as like ranks go, I don't think I ever really pushed him outside of like a top one fifty, But I know he has left some ranks before, and I think more importantly than maybe want to talk about it outside of I want your take on this new

Speaker 2refound Ethan Solace is that I think you've made a pretty aggressive jump back. If I remember correctly, for your newest rank up day, James, you've got him like a little bit outside the top twenty five. Correct me obviously if I'm wrong on this, But what do you think about the changes in the production of who Ethan Solace is this year? How much you believe it, and that being relative to your prospect ranks?

Speaker 4Yeah, I guess I just don't really see any reason not to believe it when you factor in the age, in the level, in the stats, seventeen percent strikeout rate, He's one of the four youngest hitters at double A. The other three are Leo Debris, Jesus Made Franklin. Arius has already goten the bump to triple A. But Arius was one of the four youngest before he hit the bump, So he's among you know, elite company there just from

Speaker 4his age to level, but not really showing any flaws at the plate, and something that really pushed me to move him up into that range is just the fact that he's a potential five category fantasy catcher ten for twelve on stolen base attempts in forty five games, And it's more about the attempts, like just the fact that he wants to run that much and views stealing bases as that much a part of his game. You know,

Speaker 4one eighty eight ISO for a twenty year old plus plus defensive catcher at double A. I think it's pretty easy to envision twenty five plus homers from Salas, especially with his big body. So it just he spent two years kind of in the wilderness, but you know, the age really makes it easy to buy in. I guess it'd be more it'd be more complicated, I think if he was doing this at like single A or even high A. But the fact that he just kept this

Speaker 4aggressive assignment thing going and then had the breakout against this level competition, I feel pretty good about it.

Speaker 2Yeah, the wilderness thing is interesting because because like I would almost put like, you know, he was sent out camping with people for one year as a super young guy, and then he was sent out alone and that's last year where he suffered that shoulder injury. I remember I caught him like the day after he was sent down a complex after the shoulder injury. He looked okay. He actually was like taking hacks in the cages at the padres and he said he was going to be there for the majority of the summer. They would come back.

Speaker 2That didn't happen. Then he was listed to go out to the AFL, and I caught him the day before the or right at the AFL was like starting up, and him and the staff and everything decided he was just going to take a break. And so that's like the wilderness part. It's like a guy that was supposed to be out for two months ended up being out for the season eight months and not having any production. I was going to ask you if you had to put your finger on what you think the change is, because like statistic, I think it's statistically easy to look at Ethan Solas and be like wow, years old. You know,

Speaker 2like I said before, statistically this looks really great. Like what's the change I would like in it to. I do feel like there's a simplification that happened, and I think I'm actually impressed with that he had all this miss time and he was able to come back, and he does look like a different player. I think his swing looks more simplified, It looks easier. I don't know what happened in the six to eight months whatever, where it looks like pitch selection. Maybe the game slowed down for him. That just I feel like that doesn't typically

Speaker 2happen for a player that misses all of that time. Especially you could argue a nineteen year old regardless of the aggressive assignment, but your second year in the miners or what it like, it was a pretty critical time. It was a really critical time and instead of there being a backtrack, he was able to move forward. So like I would probably liken it too. I think his swing looks easier than ever before. Is there anything for you outside of statistically that you think like makes you feel more comfortable about jumping back in on solas?

Speaker 4Yeah, I mean I think the stats and like the contact right and everything is what gives me the comfort level. The thing I guess I noticed that is a little different is that he's just he's using the whole field more. He's kind of less less addicted to the sort of airpull approach, and interesting, maybe that's just better for him, Like maybe he just kind of unlocks his natural hitting ability and he can still get to that power, but without kind of trying to sell out for it. But yeah,

Speaker 4I guess it's tough to sort of compare like what he's doing this year to what he did at like prior stops, because you know, he only played ten games at double A last year. He was at high A in twenty twenty four. That almost just feels like too long ago to even compare it to now, like when you're.

Speaker 3Talking about like an eighteen year old versus a twenty year old.

Speaker 4So I'm almost basically evaluating him solely on what he's doing this year, and I think the age gives us the ability to do that.

Speaker 2I think that's that's a good way to say that. I like that because I think a lot of people are gonna hold the accounting abil buddies will hold like prior ranks, you know, throughout a couple of years. But he might be an interesting case of a player where you do throw it all out and you just say, like, we can't we can't look at what was before. We have to just be a focal point of what is now, and what is now is a plus defender who is stealing bases at a rate that I think none of us would have thought. And his swing looks better than it's ever done. He's hitting homers, he looks comfortable. He

Speaker 2now looks like he can realize to be the guy that could be a twenty one year old in the majors. So I'm with you. I think catchers are hard in fantasy kind of just as like a general statement. But I think and I don't think he's a guy that's gonna come off of catcher anytime soon, because I think defensively he's just too good. But like, what if he's Drake Baldwin, you know, like what if that's the path of him being like a Drake Baldwin type of guy, or the remember that good version of Augustin Ramirez where he was stealing bases, hitting the ball hard, Like that's where it could be. So yeah, I'm I'm kind of with you. I don't think i've put in where is

Speaker 2the rank? Was I right? Is he just outside your top twenty five?

Speaker 3Uh? He's at twenty four?

Speaker 2Okay, oh ogain to the run, He's right inside of it. I just missed that. So top twenty five Ethan Solas. He's back, can appreciate that. I think one of the biggest pop up names from this year. Definitely some people in preseason that had brought him up and your your new ranks definitely represent the high, high aggressive side of this player, and it is Eric Hartman with the Atlanta Braves. Hartman has had a ridiculously phenomenal season. Nineteen year old at high A. Thirteen homers, twenty stolen bases, two ninety

Speaker 2eight average, nine forty nine ohps just looks ridiculous. I think probably many of us are very, very excited to see him get pushed. You want to get him to double A at this point, but that double A would be similar what we talked about with Sawas like that would be an aggressive assignment. So one of the things that you stare at with Eric Hartman here is that this is very age appropriate, if not a way above age appropriate. He's absolutely dominating across the board, counting on himself, and I believe you have I'm just forgetting what it is is the top fifteen, top ten. I mean like

Speaker 2you are heavily, heavily aggressive on Eric Cartman, and I think he's an easy top one hundred for everybody, if not top fifty across the board. It's just he's done in such a short time span that people are having to, you know, really kind of come to terms with it. But talk to me about your rank and your feelings on Eric Cartman the rest of the season.

Speaker 3Yeah, it's just it's really all about the upside.

Speaker 4I may, like, if I were doing the ranks today, maybe he's down five ten spots.

Speaker 3Where is he?

Speaker 2Where do you have him right now? Is it top fifteen?

Speaker 4Just like around twenty Oh? Okay, okay, But he, like, you know, he's got superstar upside. The the plate discipline stuff. It's it's slipped a little over the past couple of weeks, but still just a twenty two percent strikeout rate and he's still nineteen. He's at high A. He's getting all this power. He's at least a seventy grade runner. He's a really good defender. So he just kind of checks

Speaker 4all the sort of prerequisite physical boxes for how high.

Speaker 3The ceiling can be. And it's going to come down to.

Speaker 4How the the swing decisions and the bat ball translated at double A and triple A. But you know, I also think his origin story kind of makes the pop up aspect a bit more believable, just because he came from such a lightly scouted part of North America and just was a great scouting find. Obviously, Like, I think we can overlook the lack of significant pedigree coming in,

Speaker 4especially when you know, like Chris Blessing saw him live and came on my show right before that update went live, and you know, he couldn't couldn't be higher on on Hartman, and that just kind of gave me the added confidence to push him way up there.

Speaker 2Yeah, especially when you see when like someone you know and trust has seen someone in person and they can kind of like attest to it. I think it does definitely say a lot. Let me ask you, who'd you rather hear Eric Hartman again? I loosely am going to use like the pop up stuff. I don't I don't want to get to hampered with it. Incredible season checking off so many boxes Versus how about an Aydon Miller. Eydon Miller, we just got word that, like I think he's gonna have like another surgery. He is absolutely destined

Speaker 2to play in the Arizona Fall League this year because he is going to miss the majority of the minor league season. I don't think they said it's out. I got to probably need to look or I've probably said it in the beginning of the show what it was, because I think it's an eight week timetable. He is having diagnosed with dysogenic pain and facet inflammation in his lumbar spine. But you know, it was like a top fifteen guy kind of all around. Who would you rather be invested in for the long term, not just of this season and Aidan Miller, who we do know is

Speaker 2on the precipice but is going to miss the majority of this season and all the talent in the world, or a guy like Eric Hartman who's in their breakout.

Speaker 3Yeah, I had him like right next to each other on the update.

Speaker 2The injury makes it really tough for Aiden MILLI You're like, oh, he's just like not coming back this season, but that doesn't mean he's done. He's a young player, fifty plus stolen bases on the corner infield. Alec Boholme is, you know, going to be a free agent likely, Like there's a spot for him for him to be in the majors next year. So I think the like the near term definitely would feel like an Eric Hartman, But like I loosely would say, like, if if you had Eric Hartman offered Aiden Miller and you're thinking long term here neither helping you this year, what side would you go on?

Speaker 3Well?

Speaker 4And I ranked Miller knowing that this was certainly a possibility and not and kind of ranking him as like, no matter what happens with the back, there's just not going to be enough time for him to get healthy and like help this year. So I was definitely mostly factoring this this in, and so I I think.

Speaker 3I'd probably take Miller back surgery.

Speaker 4It's just we're kind of guessing where, you know, we're obviously no idea if he's going to make a full recovery.

Speaker 3I think we kind of have to sort of.

Speaker 4Think he will, but he might not, And the running aspect of his game, like that could be affected by like if he doesn't get back to one hundred percent with the back, that's going to affect his running. But like we're we just need him to get back to one hundred percent. He would have been a top three prospect if he was healthy. He would have potentially even graduated if he was healthy. So I think it's it's enough of a enough of a discount to take Miller,

Speaker 4But I mean it could really evolve throughout the season. Like if Hartman gets promoted to double A like in.

Speaker 2July and dominates Double.

Speaker 3A dominates, then you'll probably regret it.

Speaker 4But if he gets promoted to double A and the strike out rate gets up to like twenty eight percent, maybe maybe you don't regret it.

Speaker 3Maybe you end up looking pretty good. That's a that's a good one.

Speaker 2One more. Who do you think and again is not going to hold you to the fire or anything feed to the fire, but by the end of the season, kind of playing some of this path, Eric Cartman goes to double A, maybe he's successful. Who do you think is going to be ranked higher for you, Eric Cartman or an Edward Florentino. I know Florentino is ranked higher right now. I think he's you know, he's he's seen some some struggles, not the very early parts of the season. But if just got here and Florentino's not a wrong answer because I know you have him higher. But if you had to take a guess, who do you think will be higher by the end of the season, And this is a This is assuming Hartman is at least

Speaker 2pseudo successful when he gets a Double A promotion.

Speaker 3Yeah, I'm assuming it's Florentino.

Speaker 4I I just think he's getting adjusted to to HIA also been a little unlucky. But I think he's gonna really heat up and in uh confirm everyone's belief in him as the summer gets going here. But that's that's a that's a good one because Florentino will, like I think if he just kind of keeps going the way he's going, I think the numbers are gonna be there. So maybe a by low on Florentino just based on

Speaker 4the surface deats at HIA. But he is only he is only like five months younger than Hartman.

Speaker 2Which is that's what I'm kind of like getting at. Like if Hartman goes out and has like a successful run at Double A, like that's where I'm gonna like start to have that conversation. I think Florentino was tooled up, but you know, like maybe it's more about Eric Hartman's ceiling than it is the lack of ceiling or floor with a Florentino if that ends up happening, like I wouldn't be shocked if that ends up happening. Another guy that you have a very very aggressive rank on and he is having a phenomenal season and maybe it's a

Speaker 2triple A. Another young guy twenty one years old all the way up to triple A is ralphie Velaskaz two ninety three seven homers, great OBP. There's a big power, slugging guy that's in his future. Strikeouts not a big major problem. He walks, He kind of does a little bit of everything you would want from a floor perspective and a ceiling perspective on a corner infielder. And I know you are really really high on ralphie Velaskas, so love to get your take on the season to be and what that fantasy value looks like for you know, a corner infielder that maybe you could question if there is elite power,

Speaker 2there's no stolen base output like those corner infielder guys you're gonna want, like you're definitely gonna want them to be a huge run producer. But what do you think about Ralphi Velaskaz? And like I said, I think again, I hate even speculating here. I don't I wanted to say he was like right near the top twenty five again, but you can correct me where you have Ralphie.

Speaker 3Yeah, I had Ralphie top ten.

Speaker 4I just love him as a as a pure hitter, the like in my mailbag article, someone was asking for like an absolute ceiling comp on Velaskaz and the name I threw out was Freddy Freeman, which is sort of like the type of what you were talking about, like the power aspect, like that kind of gets back to that, like, I just think this guy is a plus hitter at

Speaker 4least when it's all said and done, and then there's just gonna be a ton of seasons where he's somewhere in the twenty plus homer range, maybe some twenty eight homer years, maybe some twenty two homer years, but just a guy that is hitting like third in a good Big league line up, a ton of runs, a ton of RBI, no speed, and no platoon for Ralphie Velasquez. So I it's maybe a floor over ceiling play, but obviously,

Speaker 4like you know, if he ends up being anywhere close to Freddie Freeman, there's there's plenty of ceiling there too. So I think that one was maybe more of like I'm just I've just got a big crush on like the Alaskaz is bat and I saw enough flaws with with some of these other guys, whether it was Eta or just you know, maybe questions about like how much power they're going to get to. I don't really have any questions with the Alaskaz, But he also doesn't really

Speaker 4have that blue chip type of ceiling.

Speaker 2Yeah. Interesting. What I was gonna say is, so I brought up like his prospect savant page, and this is just going to have triple A context, which is like thirty four at batch. You know this, it's very very small sample size. It's not overwhelming. You know, nineteh percentile ev looks good. It's right under one oh five. He's not really barreling, he's not hitting the ball hard. But what I was going to kind of say is I do think sometimes, especially in the prospecting world for fantasy, that floor just gets underrated. And I think that's like

Speaker 2a typically underrated thing where everyone gets hyper hyper focused on ceiling and just kind of forgets about floor. And I think even though I don't think this savant page is screaming necessarily like floor or anything like that, I do think I agree with you that Ralphie has he has a really solid floor in that he's going to be a higher batting average guy. He's not gonna exemplify a bunch of like crazy strikeout issues. Maybe he's like old school Josh Naylor, you know. And it's funny the comp because Naylor was with the Guardians where it's like,

Speaker 2could he be a twenty twenty five home run a hitter with high batting average if he's sitting in the middle of the lineup, he's got a lot of RBIs. I don't know if he develops that stolen bases, but I think I don't have him top ten, But I understand the like the floorness of like this is a guy that's going to be in the majors. He's going to succeed. He's better first base prospect than what they've got out there right now. And like common Zardo, who's becoming like a DH only guy, and uh yeah, at the end of the day, I just think like the prospecting side underrates floor dramatically. I don't know if you

Speaker 2have any thoughts on like floor ratings. Everybody's just like I need the upside, I need the upside, and I totally get it. But you know, there are some guys that are really worthwhile just holding on to or acquiring because you know you are going to get solid growth out of them year over year.

Speaker 3Yeah.

Speaker 4No, I definitely agree. And when you combine like a high floor with youth, I think that that's even more compelling because then it can be like a sneaky ceiling and so like Alaska's just turned twenty one, So I just think it's when you start showing that type of floor. And obviously, like I ranked him based on what he did at at double A, I don't even think he was at triple A when I when I ranked him, but uh, you know, he was just in complete control

Speaker 4as a twenty year old at double A. And that high floor is what kind of leads to those surprising breakouts from guys that you're not you're not expecting someone to hit twenty five homers, but then they they do it because of how good the hit tool us.

Speaker 2This is just a random aside one here because because because I don't want to get in like disagreement range, because like all it is is like I just don't have Ralphie as the top, like necessarily twenty guy, and maybe I should more because of proximity. I think there's a little bit of like stolen baseness. I'm really curious about this you have. And this is a just according to like the latest, it's a public post because I don't want to give James ranks away. You should go and sign up and rote a wire and support him and the work that he does. But you have your public post and you have like your top twenty or something. You've got Ralphie at seven on that list, and you've

Speaker 2got like a guy like Louis Hernandez at eleven, which, by the way, Louis Hernandez, that's a nice aggressive rank. Where do you think, like from a valuation standpoint when you if you're sitting here talking about, you know, floor around Ralphie Velaskaz, do you think Louis Hernandez is like a high upside like you have Ralphie ranked ahead. But if it is a straight one for one, and let's say you're a rebuilding team, do you think there's a case to value a guy like Louis Hernandez who is also creating, by the way, a really good like floor

Speaker 2as a seventeen year old and has this great power upside, Like where would you go on that stance?

Speaker 4Yeah, I mean I've got him in the same tier, so I, you know, splitting hairs to me, I had Velaska's ahead, so I'll save Alaska's.

Speaker 3But they're in the same tier.

Speaker 2I'm done with that. I love being some Louis Hernandez Like, he has been one of the more exciting young guys that I've got to see out in complex and like quite some time. And it's weird because he's just like this, you know, like five foot ten, Like he's just this like smaller guy that just has like ridiculous like plate skills. Like, but I just don't know what the rest is going to look like. Another guy that I got to watch for a little bit of time before he got traded, and it's sad that he has, but he has been tremendously ridiculous this season. Another one of those guys that

Speaker 2has gone from you know, maybe he was like outside the top one fifty to looking like a top fifty guy is Devin Fitzgerald, former ranger now with the Washington Nationals. Shortstop is over at high a twenty years old, twelve homers, eleven stolen bases, a two eighty six average and almost four hundred OBP nine to seventy ops. He is he's lived up beyond the expectations because when he was like here in complex, you're like, oh, this is a guy that can really hit. He can steal some basses. I did not see the power output. But he has really

Speaker 2developed into his first pro season. So talk to me about Devin Fitzgerald. Where you have him ranked and are you buying this like crazy early productive season that he can be an elite fantasy prospect.

Speaker 4I think you have to be open to that possibility just given what he's done so far this season. I have no idea where the numbers are going to be at the end of the year. Like I think even people highest on him would be surprised by the counting stats, the home runs in the stone bases. But I think it's he's just kind of opening everyone's eyes to the possibilities and.

Speaker 3I couldn't.

Speaker 4I kept comparing him to other players at the same position or the same level, and I just had.

Speaker 3To keep moving him up.

Speaker 4I think the like compared Devin Fitzgerald to like Caleb Bonhamer, and they're both at the same level bottom like eight months older, and I just couldn't. I just couldn't justify having Bonhomer ahead of Fitzgerald given the like it's like half the k rate.

Speaker 2Basically, I look about to say the strike rate is probably the thing that you stare at you just like how.

Speaker 1Do we do that?

Speaker 4Like, I know Bonomber has got more raw power and he's going to hit for more power, but like, I think Fitzgerald clearly gets the edge in the other like batting average or OBP and stolen bases and who knows where the power goes. Like I think Fitzgerald is that exact kind of high floor guy, like where if you were buying into him, like I was too low on him before the season, but if you were high on him before the season, you were buying into that high

Speaker 4floor and then he just that high floor led to a surprisingly high ceiling. And like, I don't think he's going to be this like twenty five twenty five guy in the big leagues, but he'll be good at enough things that he's going to be pretty valuable.

Speaker 3You know.

Speaker 2And one thing to think about and it not might just be the player focus. I guess how am I trying to say this. I don't know if it's player development or they have their eyes on the right guys, but like the Nationals seem to be doing stuff with guys where it's like, obviously you know cj. Abrams has developed, like how he has developed since he's become a National has been ridiculous. James Wood like clearly out there. But you know, even guys like Curtis Mead, who they picked up off the wire, like they're finding guys that are able to barrel. And again, I don't know if it's

Speaker 2like players that they are identifying feats that meet certain metrics, or it is players that they think if they can attune them, they can unlock. But maybe in the player development department they're doing something right. An interesting thing that popped in my mind with Devin Fitzgerald, which might make compending where he's being ranked by people, which might make him a really interesting buy. Actually think from just me personally seeing both of them, there's this path where like Devin Fitzgerald and Louis Hernandez might be a very similar player,

Speaker 2Like Devin Mizgerald's not the biggest guy on the planet, makes a ton of contact the powers I think the biggest question. But I think he is going to have better stolen base potential than I got, like Louis Hernandez, who I think body wise is going to kind of cap himself out and stuff. But like what you're betting on with a Louis Hernandez when we talk about him as a top ten guy and let's say Fitzgerald is outside the top fifty for people if you're talking about trades, like, there's a legitimate path where Devin Fitzgerald is like a twenty twenty guy. And I think like you would be extremely excited if Louis Hernandez is that. And I do

Speaker 2think there people are starting to dream Hernandez could be a three hundred hitter thirty plus homer guy, and maybe that's the path, but I don't know. I think Devin Fitzgerald might be a better alternative if, like Louis Hernandez is untradable for in some leagues.

Speaker 4Sure, yeah, I mean I think that they both strike me as sort of I think about their floors before I think of their ceilings, and then I definitely see the ceiling. But I could see how you would compare those guys for sure.

Speaker 2Yeah, So and just I guess it is me seeing them before as well. The last guy that we're going to talk about and pull this up here as far as players that I want to get your takes on, and then we're going to just get a couple of high lows for you. This will be the first pitcher we'll finally bring up, and it is Carson Milbrandt. Carson Milbrandt with the Marlins was actually in the Arizona Fall League this past year. Don't really jump off the table or anything. If phenomenal Double A moved up to Triple A. He's got a one three four ERA on the season through nine starts, seventy strikeouts over forty seven innings. An

Speaker 2organization too that has just had like so many promised white Nobel Meyer was a guy at some point, and Carson Milbrandt seems to be making that jump. Is not just one of the most exciting Marlins pitching prospects, but has jumped inside as like a top one hundred guys so Triple A twenty two years old, insanely phenomenal results. Your thoughts and feelings on Carson Milbrandt and where do you rank him among like you can give relative among like pitching prospects.

Speaker 3Yeah, I was pretty high on Millbrand coming into the year.

Speaker 4I had him just outside my top one hundred, and I got to see him. I got to see Hi when he was at High A shut down that Brewers high A lineup. I think he had ten k's against Made and Fisher and Payanya and Adam Schevski and all those guys. Late last year. He was excellent after getting the bumped to double A late last year and then he's just kind of peak of his powers right now,

Speaker 4just got the bump to triple A, and I don't think he needs much more than like a month at triple A before he'll be up in the majors, as long as he can stay healthy. And I mean the two big things are just the stouts and walks and then the ground balls like fifty seven ground ball rate plus all those k's and uh, you know, walks are going to be a thing. That is sort of the one potential weakness with Milbrand as he gets to triple

Speaker 4A and gets adjusted to things there. But I just see such a high ceiling here, and it's they've dealt with the injuries with a lot of those guys that you listed off, but I think this is definitely a team that knows what to do with pitchers. And Milbrand just turned twenty two as well, so it's a it's a pretty weak pitching crap to me after the after seth Fernandez and Kate Anderson, and so I just didn't

Speaker 4see any reason to not push him up into my top five among oh pitching prospects.

Speaker 2You just, well, you just killed the next segment I was going to do. But let let's to do a couple of it because that I love. I mean, I love the aggressiveness of it, because I was going to ask you some who'd you rather, So you're actually going to change the scope of who I'm going to ask. So I think we know where the answers are going to go. But let's just do it anyways, if you'll humor me. Carson Milbrandt or Jamie Arnold mil Brand Carson Milbrandt or Gage Wood mil Brandt, Carson Milbrandt or Jack Winninger.

Speaker 3Milbrand But I've got them back to back.

Speaker 2So I know Ryan Sloan is probably above him.

Speaker 4Correct, I've got Sloan behind milbrand by I think, so I've got Milbrand three Wenninger four, Doyle five, Sloan six.

Speaker 2Okay, So that's because I was thinking I was putting Milbrandt at five there, and I was thinking Sloan would be above, So I was trying to find out who the fourth was. But he is your third in the pitching prospect range. So that is a full full buy in then, And what is the overall like top? I know he's three at picture, does that make him top twenty five?

Speaker 4No, he's forty one. I don't have a single picture ranked from I mean, yes, Savage is graduated, but I don't have a single picture from six to forty.

Speaker 2Always, you know, it's always my favorite thing. I love it.

Speaker 4I've got Hernandez three, Anderson five, and then not a single picture until mil brand at forty.

Speaker 2I love that. I mean, that's a very very big testament to Carson Milbritton, what he's done. All Right, last two things here I've got for you is the player you are down on versus consensus, and the player that might be ranked low for others but you are into, so essentially the guy that you might be more into on versus consensus. So let's start with a player that in consensus by the way is a very like moot turn into you know, Pipeline me Baseball America air Cross, you know, like it's the general consensus. So you're just

Speaker 2taking a stab at it. Who's a player that you think everybody's into that you are just not that into.

Speaker 4Yeah, so I think Felon and Celestine of the Mariners, it has to be the guy just because I got I got a bunch of questions about him. I have him, I think outside my top two hundred, but I mean it's pretty open down there. So it's like, I'm not saying that you should cut Felon in Celestine and like pick up the guy I've got ranked right ahead of him, Keith Law. I think just ranked him in his top twenty five. So you should obviously try to trade Celestin

Speaker 4if you believe in my analysis, you shouldn't just drop him.

Speaker 3But I just there.

Speaker 4Really isn't that much special happening under the hood. His exit velossites are basically average, and all his home runs have come at Everett. He's got a three eighty six bab it. He's repeating a level that he finished the last season at, and I had really high expectations for him. Coming into the year, and I just I think he's really just eating up on the home cooking at Everett right now, and there's just a ton of name value,

Speaker 4Like I said, like Keith Law's got him top twenty five. So I just I think Selestin would really struggle if he got to bump a double A. I don't think he will anytime soon. But I think the slash line eventually is just going to get like less and less impressive as the season goes on. And you know, the the approach is the one thing to point to and say like that.

Speaker 3This is why you're wrong. But yeah, I just I think like.

Speaker 2High walk, you mean like high walk, low strikeout the high content.

Speaker 3Yeah, yeah, like it.

Speaker 4Yeah, you could say, like if you just really like sel Ustin, I think the argument is just that he's controlling the zone and he's eventually going to get to more of that power.

Speaker 3But I just think he's overrated.

Speaker 2Yeah, I am surprised that you sell him outside or right around the two hundred, even after this run. But I mean your analysis tells a story of why I've always been a little hampered because like watching him in rookie ball, I was at this game where as a switch hitter, he hit two bombs and he just absolutely destroyed them. But I don't know if he has an understanding for like really good angles, you know, and barreling the ball. So I do kind of worry he maybe ends up being one of those guys that's just kind of like emptier counting stats and hits in the lower lineups,

Speaker 2and like even if you know, let's say his production right now, says he's like a top fifty guy, but he ends up being outside the top one hundred. Like, just because he's good right now doesn't mean you have to do that, especially if you're not into the approach. He's a really he's kind of a weird guy. But hey, James Anderson says, this might be a really good sell opportunity right now for Felman Selston. All right, so now this is going to be the verse a player that you think you were higher on the consensus that you're very excited about Vily not you know, the ralphies and stuff.

Speaker 3That we've already talked about. Yeah, and this player you might you might be able to trade Sellaston for John Heel straight up. In some leagues, John Heell, Atlanta's high a shortstop.

Speaker 1And.

Speaker 3Like, I don't, I think he's just really good. Uh. He finished last year at at A.

Speaker 4Once he got healthy, he just was a completely different player. And I just I wasn't one hundred percent sure if that was just him beating up on bad pitching late in the season, but for him to get the bump to Hi A and basically be the exact same player he was to close the year at single A last year, three seventy eight ovp, eight homers, twenty seven steals in fifty games may not stick at shortstop, but I think

Speaker 4he'll at least add value somewhere on the dirt. And Atlanta is a system that had been pretty starved for exciting hitting prospects. But now they've got Eric Hartman, they've got John Heel, they've got Tate southa scene who has been justly impressive to me. So I think it's things are trending up in Atlanta.

Speaker 2Where do you have he what range?

Speaker 3The top right around fifty?

Speaker 2Oh okay, all right, there you go, top fifty so by John Heel, Sell Felman, Selston and lots of other good talkabouts of some very interesting prospects that have had crazy seasons. He is James Anderson from Rodal Wire. James, what's going on? I think I just saw you post. You've got your big Dynasty update that's coming up on Rotal World here shortly that's going to be updated. What else is going on in your world?

Speaker 4Yeah, I mean it's basically just uh, it's just that Dynasty rankings update that should be live Friday, and then it's going to be kind of all draft from there for me.

Speaker 2Oh yeah, I know. I'm like I'm ready to start diving into heavy, heavy sides of the draft. A very interesting draft and the fantasy implications are out there, so make sure you go check him out over at Rodo Wire. He is James Anderson on the Socials Real Jr. Anderson. Appreciate your brother for taking the time and hanging with me, and we'll talk to you next time.

Speaker 3Of course. Thank you for having me there you go.

Speaker 2Thank you again to James Anderson for taking the time out in the episode talking about some great dudes that I think you guys are probably dealing with, probably from a high valuation standpoint. I think like really competitive leagues, like nobody is really able to go out and get Eric Hartman for you know, a penny or anything like that, but just know that the evaluations are like heavily changing and some unique perspectives. The idea of Felman being post two hundred still with what he's doing is a really interesting conversation. Continue the conversation over at in this League

Speaker 2dot com on our patreon in the prospect one room. Love to see what your guys' takes are from this episode. Be on the lookout YouTube dot com slash in this League for any of the clips of this episode if that's something that you like to do. And I got some player pages up as well, and just excited to set my return and I'm hyper focused on just the June schedule, getting the June schedule of episodes out and covering whatever we can for you guys. Rank updates should be right around next week possibility with the Dynasty and

Speaker 2the Redraft, and of course, like I'm going to have some rookie ball takes, I've been catching some rookie ball and we're gonna have Bridge League with the MLB Draft. So I got you all around, my friends. You can also find me over on Fantasy pros where that is where I work, and I've got the Prospecting segment we do every Tuesday that has not stopped. We do a short on it as well that's a little bit more Redraft centric, and sometimes I do some Dynasty on there. So make sure you're checking out leading off Monday through Friday Live and you can check out the Prospecting segment on Tuesday. Thank you guys so much for all the

Speaker 2people that are still around and hanging out. Love you all. Make sure you're subscribe and we will talk to you next time right here on Prospect one. My friends,

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Episode 425 - Arizona Fall League Week 1 Report

    Oct 12, 20261 hr 4 minAudio

    New Prospect One Podcast 🎙️ Arizona Fall League Week 1 Report ➡️ Kilby has all the tools ➡️ Flewelling might be best all-round prospect ➡️ Jarlin Susana hits 103.8 ➡️ More from around the AFL Join up to be a member of...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Episode 424 - Arizona Fall League Roster Breakdowns

    Sep 18, 20261 hr 32 minAudio

    New Prospect One Podcast 🎙️ Arizona Fall League Prediction Show ➡️ Rainer, Hope and Quintero lead the big names ➡️ Review the predictions ➡️ Glendale and Scottdale's stacked teams ➡️ MVP, Best pitcher, sleepers and...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Episode 423 - Arizona Fall League Prediction Show

    Sep 10, 20261 hr 29 minAudio

    New Prospect One Podcast 🎙️ Arizona Fall League Prediction Show ➡️ Bonemer, Nimmala, and Cristanes confirmed ➡️ One team has already released its entire list ➡️ Could we see 3 Top-10 prospects ➡️ All 6 team breakdowns...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Episode 422 - MLB Trade Deadline Prospect Breakdown with TIm Kanak of Prospect Warehouse

    Aug 6, 20261 hr 1 minAudio

    New Prospect One Podcast 🎙️ MLB Trade Deadline Prospect Breakdown with TIm Kanak of Prospect Warehouse ➡️ Zyhir Hope to DET ➡️ Was Eyanson to BAL the biggest get at the deadline ➡️ How did MLW trade Frias and Ragsdale...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Episode 421 - Prospect Risers with Lucas Morel of ProspectsLive

    Jul 25, 20261 hr 26 minAudio

    New Prospect One Podcast 🎙️ Prospect Risers with Lucas Morel of ProspectsLive ➡️ Sebastian Walcott's big return ➡️ Should we have any concerns about Joshua Baez ➡️ Tate Southsiene's rise ➡️ Luke Adams love Join up to...

    Credit the people on this episode