Send us Fan Mail I tear down the real books of a $1.3M painting business that turned off its Meta ads, shrank 14%, and lost $50K in cash - and the recovery plan to reach $2M. Work with us https://profitablepaintercpa.com/vsl Free Book - Profitable Painter https://profitablepaintercpa.com/book In this episode, I open the real financial statements of a swamp-stage painting business (owner anonymized - we'll call him Ethan). Ethan runs a painting business in South Carolina doing about $1.3M a year. 8 months ago he stopped running Meta ads - since then, leads slumped, revenue shrank 14%, and the business lost about $50,000 in cash. Now he's hired a marketing agency and wants to hit $2 million. But more leads won't fix weak job profits or oversized overhead. I walked through his statement of cash flows to find where the $50K actually went, the deposit policy mistake, the overhead team costing nearly double the benchmark, and the exact plan to rebuild profitability. Compare these numbers to your own business as we go. I'm Daniel Honan, CPA and former painting business owner. Since 2016, my firm, Profitable Painter CPA, has helped 529+ painting contractors with bookkeeping, taxes, payroll, automations, and financial strategy. WHAT YOU'LL LEARN - What happens to a $1.3M painting business 8 months after turning off outbound ads - How to read a statement of cash flows to find where cash is actually leaking - Why owner distributions during a downturn quietly drain the business - The zero-deposit mistake - and why deposits matter most heading into winter - Inbound vs outbound marketing costs, and why outbound demands a higher gross profit target - The 7% benchmark for admin + production manager overhead (and what 12% does to net profit) - How to renegotiate a production manager to ⅔ base + ⅓ bonus tied to volume, reviews, and gross profit - The roles-based method for owner pay: why this owner should earn 26% of revenue, not 1% 🎯 Want this kind of teardown on YOUR numbers? That's what we do - we are a Painter‑only CPA firm. Book a free call: https://profitablepaintercpa.com/vsl WHO I AM My name is Daniel Honan. I'm a CPA, a former painting business owner, and the founder of Profitable Painter CPA - an accounting firm that works exclusively with painting contractors. I make these podcasts to help painters keep more of what they earn and build more profitable businesses. Subscribe for weekly podcasts on taxes, bookkeeping, accounting, and financial strategy for painting businesses. Keywords: painting business, painting contractors, financial teardown, real business financials, statement of cash flows, cash flow problems small business, meta ads for contractors, stopping ads consequences, deposit policy contractors, GP to CAC ratio, customer acquisition cost, gross profit margin painting, overhead costs benchmark, production manager compensation, admin costs small business, owner distributions, owner pay small business, Profitable Painter This episode was originally recorded as a video for YouTube. If you hear me say things like “in this video” or reference visuals, don’t worry - the content still works perfectly in audio form. And if you ever want to watch the video version, you can find it on the Profitable Painter YouTube channel. https://www.youtube.com/@BookkeepingForPainters
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_00In this video, I'm tearing down the real financial statements of a painting business doing$1.3 million a year. The owner stopped running meta ads eight months ago. Lead slowed down, profit fell, and the business lost$50,000 in cash. Now he has hired a marketing company and wants to grow to$2 million in revenue. Will more leads rebuild his cash? Or do the numbers show a deeper problem? Let's find out. If you clicked on this video, you may want the answer to three questions. Did the lead slump cause the$50,000 drop? Is this business reaching its 50% gross profit goal?
SPEAKER_00Can new marketing help it reach its$2 million goal without burning through more cash? We'll use the company's real financial numbers to answer these questions. By the end, you can compare this business with your own. If we haven't met, I'm Daniel Honan. I'm a CPA and former painting business owner. I've helped over 500 painting businesses from startup to 20 million in sales, know their numbers and save big in tax. This is another video in my painting business financial teardown series. I break painting businesses into four financial stages startup, build, the swamp, and sellable asset. In each video, I open the books of a real painting business from one of these stages.
SPEAKER_00For this teardown, we're looking at another business in the swamp. That means this business makes between$1 million and$3 million a year. Alex Remozzi coined the term the swamp, and at this stage, the business has many moving parts. It needs good people, it needs strong systems, and a steady flow of leads, but it may not make enough profit to pay for everything it needs. A drop in sales can hit hard because the business still has bills to pay. The goal is to not just bring in more leads, the business must turn those leads into profit and cash.
SPEAKER_00All right, so let's meet the owner. Let's call this owner Ethan. Ethan runs a painting business out of South Carolina. I removed his real name and any details that could show who he actually is. Ethan's business did about 1.3 million over the last 12 months. He wants to grow to 2 million in the next 12 months. Ethan aims for a 50% gross profit margin. At 50% gross profit, the business should keep 50 cents from each sales dollar after paying for direct costs of each job. About eight months ago, Ethan stopped running outbound meta ads. These are paid ads on sites like Facebook and Instagram.
SPEAKER_00Since then, his business has hit a slump in leads. During the same time, profit and cash have suffered. The company's cash balance has dropped about$50,000. Ethan now has hired a marketing company. The company will restart their meta ads and work towards his$2 million goal he has set. More leads may help, but more leads will not fix weak job profits or high overhead. Before Ethan spends more money to grow, we need to know why his cash fell. These facts give us the right questions to ask. Is Ethan reaching his 50% gross profit goal?
SPEAKER_00Did the business lose cash because sales slowed? Are overhead costs too high for its current size? How much can Ethan afford to spend on marketing? And can he reach$2 million while rebuilding his cash? Let's open the financial statements and find out. All right, when I first look at financials, the first thing I want to do is identify the constraint of the business. So what I first look at is their cash balance. How much cash do they have in the form of overhead costs when I compare to overhead costs? So let's take a look at the cash balance here on the balance sheet.
SPEAKER_00We have$135,000 in cash. Now I want to compare that to what they have in terms of overhead. So if we scroll down here on the profit and loss and look at total expenses, we can see that over the last eight months, they have about$356,000 in total overhead costs. So$356 divided by eight is$44,000. So two months of overhead costs would be$80,000 or$89,000. So when we compare$89,000 as the minimum cash they should have, they're at$135,000. So they have more than two months of overhead costs as cash in the bank.
SPEAKER_00That's a good sign. However, we then want to look at the statement of cash flows because the statement of cash flow shows us where's the money actually coming from. Is it coming from profits from the business or is it coming from something like debt, which would not be a good sign? All right, so statement of cash flow starts with the profit margin here at the top and then it adjusts it for cash. And so we see the net cash by operating activities, which is the main operations of the business. It is cash flow positive, even though the income is negative for the first eight months. So bottom line, the business is generating a little bit of cash, not a lot though.
SPEAKER_00Then on top of that, we notice that the shareholder, or the owner in this case, Ethan, is taking out about$47,000 in cash. So basically, the business is not really generating much profit during cash, but the owner is taking out a lot of distributions. So this is what's causing the cash balance to go down significantly. So net cash increase for the period is actually negative. So they lost about$50,000 in cash. And so that is not a good sign. So over the last eight months, which is supposed to be the busiest season through the summer, we're actually losing cash. So this is obviously not sustainable.
SPEAKER_00So even though the cash balance has two months of overhead cost as cash in a bank, we have a downward trend going on right now. And so that is a red flag from a cash perspective. So my first recommendation for Ethan is to increase his deposit. Right now, Ethan actually does not take a deposit at all. He only requires full payment upon completion. So this has worked okay in the past. However, right now, because of the slowdown in leads and the profit margins have shrank, which we'll take a look at the second, he's really going into the slowest part of the year, which is the winner, with not an ideal position in cash.
SPEAKER_00So I want him to start taking a deposit so that he can get money paid up front more quickly. And that should increase his cash balance, at least in the short term. And that will buy us some more time to fix the underlying profit issues, which we'll cover here next. All right, let's take a look at his profit and loss. So here we are the first eight months, January 1 through August 31st, we're at$724,000 compared to the same time last year. We were at$842,000. So this business has actually shrank by about 14%. Now, if we look at the gross profit, so far this year, the gross profit's at 47% gross profit, which is a decent gross profit.
SPEAKER_00So they're shooting for 50%, they're hitting 47%. So they're doing a decent job. That tells me that their pricing is probably about on target and they're pretty efficient with their job side. Now, I I never want to just look at gross profit alone. I always want to pair it up with something called customer acquisition costs. So customer acquisition costs is basically what it costs for you to close the deal. So when we look at the profit and loss to determine what customer acquisition costs are, we first look at advertising and marketing. So for this business, we're at 4.8%. And then we want to look at the salesperson. But right now, the salesperson is actually the owner.
SPEAKER_00So we don't actually see it here on the profit and loss, but what we can do is use a plug number of 8%, because 8% is typically what we would pay a salesperson of what they close. So 8% of what they close. So we take the 4.8% and we add on eight to get the total customer acquisition cost of 12.8. And then we also have some marketing wages here, which is about 3% here as well. So we add that 3.12. Right now we have our customer acquisition cost of 15.92. So again, this is everything we need to pay to close the deal. So this is marketing and sales.
SPEAKER_00So that's what we have to pay to close the deal. And when we do this, we get a gross profit back of 47%. So if we take 47.31 divided by 15.92, we get a 2.97 to 1 GP to CAC ratio, meaning that when we spend$1 of customer acquisition, we get$2.97 back in the form of gross profit. And so this ratio is low. We want a minimum of three to one. So right now, this is concerning for me, especially since we're now just trying to add on a lot of outbound marketing again with hiring the new marketing agency.
SPEAKER_00So we're gonna be paying this new marketing agency and we're gonna be adding in this outbound type marketing, which outbound marketing is usually a lot more expensive than inbound type marketing. And inbound type marketing is repeat and referral work, people finding you on Google. Those sorts of marketing efforts are usually a lot lower in cost. Where outbound marketing, like Facebook, door-to-door, direct mail to people you don't know or pay per lead, those types are a lot more expensive. And so when we haven't even really been hitting that outbound marketing that hard, because we've been relying mostly on inbound, but we still have a low GP to CAC ratio, that's a little concerning.
SPEAKER_00And so the main thing that I want to do here is to recommend that we start shooting for a higher gross profit than 50%. I think we're gonna have to shoot for at least 55% gross profit, really to make the GP to CAC ratio over three to one. So can we actually do this? Let's take a look at the close rate for this business. If we take a look at their CRM, we'll notice that the win rate, aka the close rate is 54%. So I would say they have a little bit of room to increase prices without substantially tanking their close rate. Usually you want to keep a close rate somewhere between 30 and 40% close rate.
SPEAKER_00So they're at 54. So that's a pretty solid close rate. I think we could probably increase pricing by at least two to five percent. We want to start low and then test and monitor the close rate to see where it lands. So like I said, we want to keep the close rate between 30 and 40%. So I think we can do that without really changing much just by increasing the pricing. Now, if we wanted to protect our close rate from going down further, what we could do is add in a risk reversal guarantee that basically says, hey, customer, we actually guarantee our services. If we don't follow through on XYZ guarantee, we'll actually give you a portion of the job back in the form of a refund.
SPEAKER_00And so that's a risk reversal guarantee that you can add something like an on-time, on budget guarantee. So that could be a consideration as well for Ethan here. But bottom line, we want to get this gross profit closer to 55%. And if we have a 55% divided by the current customer acquisition cost, that'll put us about 3.4 to 1 GP to CAP ratio. Remember, the minimum is three to one. However, we know that we just hired a marketing agency, so customer acquisition costs will probably go up. So when we try to do outbound marketing, it usually goes up. So we might even see this GP to CAC not even be 3.4.
SPEAKER_00We might see it just stay around three to one, which is okay. That's the minimum. But ideally, the higher the better. All right, the other items here, the overhead costs are relatively inexpensive. We're not paying too much for most of these things. The thing that really jumps out though is what we're paying for our overhead team. So we have admin, and then we have contractors also doing admin, then we have marketing wages as well, and then a production manager. So when we add up all of the production and admin, it's pushing 12%. So that's not a good sign here.
SPEAKER_00Basically, what after talking with Ethan, he kept his team and he was shooting for 2 million. He was expecting 2 million revenue, but they ended up falling a lot short of that. And he had all these salaries that he still needed to pay. So he basically didn't want to fire his team because he still wanted to grow to 2 million, but he didn't have the lead flow to actually do that. And so this caused his overhead team to be a lot higher in overhead than what was planned. Now, ideally, we would want to have your admin team plus your production manager to be about 7% of revenue. And right now we're at like 12%. So there's a couple of things that we could do.
SPEAKER_00One, we could reduce hours or fire somebody, let somebody go so that we can cut our overhead team. Or the other thing we could do is to increase revenue as quick as possible, which he's trying to do that by hiring this marketing agency to get revenue up. So it makes sense to have these folks. The other option is to renegotiate the salaries, especially the production manager, since this is the biggest one. We could renegotiate this production manager's salary so that we're paying a two-thirds base and a one-third bonus opportunity. So it might look something like this, where we have a$65,000 base salary, and then they can get bonuses of up to$100,000 if they hit production volume, customer satisfaction, and they're hitting their gross profit targets.
SPEAKER_00If they hit those three things, then each month they could get a bonus. And if they hit their bonus each month, they could get up to$35,000 in pay for the year, plus a$65,000 base. So they would hit$100,000 in total compensation. But again, they got to hit production volume, customer reviews or Google reviews, and gross profit to hit those bonuses. That way, it's a win-win. It's a win for the company and it's a win for that production manager. Now for the admin team, I would maybe look at reducing hours, something that we can maybe cut down, at least in the meantime, while revenue is still a little bit lower than where we want it, so that admin costs are not so high.
SPEAKER_00Because right now we're pushing 6% for admin costs, which again, an admin should be about two to four percent for admin costs. Training and education is a little high, but that is discretionary. Ethan's trying to improve himself, so I don't have a big concern about that. And so when we look at the net profit here, we're at negative two percent. And then we also have officer salary here of three percent. So essentially, Ethan's netting about one percent. Obviously, that's not an ideal profit margin. Based off the roles that he plays, I would want him closer to somewhere around 25% of revenue. The way I got that is basically a passive business owner should make about 15% of revenue.
SPEAKER_00If they're completely passive, sitting on the beach, sipping a corona while their team runs the entire operation, they should be making 15%. Now, Ethan is not passive, he is actively working as a salesperson. So that should get him another 8%. Because what, like we said, a salesperson should get paid 8% of what they close. Gets us up to 23%. Then on top of that, he's leaving the company. So a CEO of a painting business should get around 3% of the revenue. So that gets us to 26%. So 26% discretionary earnings or cash flow that owners are recommendation on what he should be making.
SPEAKER_00Now he's only hitting about 1%. So he has a bit of room to improve. And most of the room, again, is in the gross profit. We need to get this higher at least 55% gross profit. And then on top of that, we need to make sure that the production manager and the admin team is closer to 7% of revenue instead of where it is now, is about 12%. So with those two changes, if we can get to 55% and get the overhead positions down closer to seven, that should get us about at least at a minimum 10 percentage points closer. Once we do those two big moves, we can reassess and see where else we can make those gains.
SPEAKER_00All right, so that's for profitability. Next one is liquidity insolvency, which is going back to the balance sheet. And so as we said before, we do have enough cash in the bank. We have over two months of cash, we have over two months of overhead costs as cash in the bank. And now let's compare their current assets here 137,000 to their current liabilities. So current liabilities is 75,000 and they have 137,000 of current assets. So they have that over one-to-one ratio. So they're pretty solid on liquidity right now. But like I said, my big concern for them right now is since they keep losing cash over the last year, that we really need to make sure the cash flow policies are dialed in going into the winner, since we'll likely have a downturn in terms of lead flow.
SPEAKER_00So we want to make sure we're taking a decent deposit so that we're not all of a sudden super low in cash. Now for solvency, we have about$98,000 in total liabilities, and 23% of that is long-term liability. So only$23,000 in long-term liabilities, and we have positive equity in this business. So solvency is still good. So our ability to pay debt in the long term is good. So overall, we just need to fix this profitability issue. Our liquidity and solvency are still okay, completely decent, but our profitability just needs to get up.
SPEAKER_00And if we again, if we look at that GP to CAC ratio, get it above three to one, and then we take a look at our production manager compensation and our admin team compensation, trying to keep that at about 7% of revenue. And then as a final note, again, since cash has decreased so much over the last year, really looking at ways we can improve cash flow, which the whole game with cash flow is to get paid faster and slow down payments to others. So I think an easy lever we could pull is basically just increase our deposit. All right, so that concludes the video for Ethan's business. Currently in the swamp, he has some options on increasing that profitability and that cash flow.
SPEAKER_00And with that, I will see you next video.
Send us Fan Mail Your painting business can be booked out for weeks and still be short on cash. Bigger sales don’t always mean more money in your pocket. In this episode, I break down why busy painting contractors still...
Send us Fan Mail If I had to grow a painting business from $4M to $10M today, here's what I'd do. Brandon Pierpont from Painter Marketing Pros and I walk through the money side and the marketing side of the stage where...
Send us Fan Mail Grow your painting business so fast in 2027 it feels illegal. Learn the exact checks I use to fix pricing, job margins, lead response and cash flow before you spend more on leads. Know Your Numbers &...
Send us Fan Mail Painting contractors can raise prices 5-10% with a guarantee and keep their close rate about the same. Randy Hurtado of the Good Contractors List and I show how. If you want to raise prices in your...
Send us Fan Mail If I had to grow a painting business from $1.5M to $4M today, here's what I'd do. Brandon Pierpont from Painter Marketing Pros and I walk through the money side and the marketing side of the stage we...