Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Profitable Painter Podcast

Profitable Painter Podcast artwork

Can This $850K Painting Business Really Hit $2M in 12 Months?

Sep 10, 202618 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Send us Fan Mail I tear down the real books of an $850K painting business that wants to hit $2M in 12 months: the GP-to-CAC ratio blocking it, the $3,800/month agency math, and the hiring plan that gets him there. Work with us https://profitablepaintercpa.com/vsl Free Book - Profitable Painter https://profitablepaintercpa.com/book In this episode, I open the real financial statements of a build-stage painting business (owner anonymized - we'll call him Bill). Bill runs a painting business in Oklahoma doing about $850K a year, pays two marketing agencies $3,800/month, and wants to grow to $2 million in the next 12 months. His cash position is excellent, but one ratio in his numbers says he can't afford to buy that growth yet. I walked through his P&L, his CRM funnel math, the exact production manager comp plan I'd use, and what has to change before he hits the gas. Compare these numbers to your own business as we go. I'm Daniel Honan, CPA and former painting business owner. Since 2016, my firm, Profitable Painter CPA, has helped 529+ painting contractors with bookkeeping, taxes, payroll, automations, and financial strategy. WHAT YOU'LL LEARN - How to tell which constraint is limiting a painting business - cash, team, or customers - The GP-to-CAC ratio: why 3-to-1 is the minimum - When a $3,800/month marketing agency is too expensive - and why the fix is growing, not cutting - Real funnel math: cost per lead → set rate → close rate → ad spend per closed job - The set rate benchmark for Meta ads and what a low one costs you - A complete production manager compensation plan: base, bonus, and the 3 metrics to tie it to - How much a painting business owner should pay themselves based on the hats they wear (the 15% + roles method) - The risk-reversal guarantee that lets you raise prices without losing close rate 🎯 Want this kind of teardown on YOUR numbers? That's what we do - we are a Painter‑only CPA firm. Book a free call: https://profitablepaintercpa.com/vsl WHO I AM My name is Daniel Honan. I'm a CPA, a former painting business owner, and the founder of Profitable Painter CPA - an accounting firm that works exclusively with painting contractors. I make these podcasts to help painters keep more of what they earn and build more profitable businesses. Subscribe for weekly podcasts on taxes, bookkeeping, accounting, and financial strategy for painting businesses. Keywords: painting business, painting contractors, financial teardown, real business financials, grow a painting business, GP to CAC ratio, customer acquisition cost, marketing agency cost small business, meta ads for contractors, cost per lead painting, set rate close rate, production manager compensation, production manager bonus plan, hiring for painting business, gross profit margin painting, owner compensation small business, risk reversal guarantee, Profitable Painter This episode was originally recorded as a video for YouTube. If you hear me say things like “in this video” or reference visuals, don’t worry - the content still works perfectly in audio form. And if you ever want to watch the video version, you can find it on the Profitable Painter YouTube channel. https://www.youtube.com/@BookkeepingForPainters

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_00In this video, I'm tearing down the real financial statements of a painting business doing about$850,000 a year. The owner wants to grow to$2 million in revenue in the next 12 months. He is already booked out for three weeks, but a full schedule does not mean the business is ready to more than double. I'll show you what looks good, what could slow down his growth, and what I would fix next. If you clicked on this video, you may want the answer to these three questions. Is this business reaching its 50% gross profit goal? Is it$3,800 monthly marketing spend producing enough growth?

SPEAKER_00Can the owner reach$2 million while he still runs sales and production? We'll use the company's real numbers to answer these questions. By the end, you can compare this business to your own. If we haven't met, I'm Daniel Honan. I'm a CPA and former painting business owner. I've helped over 500 painting businesses from startup to 20 million in sales, know their numbers, and save big in tax. And this is the second video in my painting business financial teardown series. I break down painting businesses into four financial stages startup, build, the swamp, and sellable asset.

SPEAKER_00In each video, I open the books of a real painting business from each stage. For this teardown, we're looking at the build stage. That means this business makes between$350,000 and$1 million a year. At this stage, the owner must start taking off hats. The business needs help with sales, production, and office work. It also needs a steady way to bring in new leagues, but growth costs money. The business must make enough profit and cash to pay for that growth. Let's call this owner Bill. Bill runs a painting business in Oklahoma.

SPEAKER_00I removed his real name and any details I could show who he is. Bill's business does about$850,000 a year. He wants to grow to$2 million in the next 12 months. Bill is booked out for three weeks, and that means he has plenty of work on the schedule right now. Bill pays two marketing agencies. Together they cost about$3,800 per month. They help him run his meta ads, Google Local Service Ads, and SEO. Bill also has a part-time admin. The admin helps him respond to new leads fast. But Bill still wears several big hats. He handles sales, he runs production, he also handles some of the office work.

SPEAKER_00Bill aims for a 50% gross profit margin. At 50% gross profit, he should keep about 50 cents for each sales dollar after paying for direct costs of each job. These facts give us the right questions to ask. Is Bill reaching his 50% goal? Is he getting enough value from his marketing spend? And can his current team handle$2 million worth of work? Does the business have enough profit and cash to fund that growth? And is Bill ready to give up some of his current work? Let's open the financial statements and find out. All right, when I'm looking at financial statements, the first thing I want to do is identify the constraint in the business.

SPEAKER_00What is holding the business from growing to the next level? And right off the bat, I can tell that this business has solid cash in the bank,$281,000 based off of that, comparing it to its overhead expenses. This business has multiple months of overhead costs as cash in the bank. So this business likely does not have a policy or behavior constraint. It has either a supply constraint where it needs more of a team, or they need more customers, really. So to answer that question, I know talking to Bill that they're booked out about three weeks.

SPEAKER_00Bill is doing production, managing production, and doing all the sales at this time. He does have an admin person that's helping him out. Right now, he could get to a little bit above a million on his own without any additional support. However, to hit his two million dollar goal, he will eventually need to hire a production manager, a full-time office person, and maybe even start looking at hiring on a salesperson as well. But to at least break a million dollars in revenue, he can probably get away with doing production and sales and just getting some office support. So let's take a look at his financials. When we look at his financials here on the profit and loss, over the course of the last eight months from January 1 to August 31st, he's at$536,000 in revenue compared to this time last year, just a slight bit of growth, about 5%.

SPEAKER_00And then looking at gross profit, about the same as last year, and we're sitting at about a 48% gross profit margin. So he's shooting for 50%, he's hitting 48%. That's pretty typical. You shoot for 50%, you hit 48%, things go wrong. So that makes sense and is expected. Now, the thing that I'm really like to hone in on is the gross profit to customer acquisition cost ratio. If we compare this gross profit of 48% compared to his customer acquisition cost, which again, customer acquisition is basically marketing spend plus what he's paying for a salesperson.

SPEAKER_00Now he's not paying for a salesperson at this time, he's actually doing all the sales. So we're going to use 8% as a plug number because the 8% is what you usually pay a salesperson as a percentage of what they close. Okay, let's determine his customer acquisition cost. So we look at his marketing line, he's at 12.7% for marketing. And then we add in that 8% for a salesperson. He's the salesperson, so we don't see it on the profit and loss, but we would typically pay a salesperson about 8% of what they close. So we get a total customer acquisition cost of 20.7%. So basically that we want to compare this customer acquisition cost to his gross profit.

SPEAKER_00And his gross profit is 48%, 48.33 divided by 20.7. So we're looking at a 2.33 to 1 ratio of gross profit compared to customer acquisition costs. Said another way, if we put a dollar into customer acquisition, we're getting$2.33 back out in the form of gross profit. This is a little weak. We typically want to see a bare minimum of three to one GP to CAC ratio. And he is aggressively trying to grow the business at this time. And so this is one of the reasons why we're seeing this. So my big concern of him trying to grow to two million is this GP to CAC ratio.

SPEAKER_00So let's see what we can do to figure out how to solve this. So when we look at his advertising, his marketing, it's at 12.7%. So it's a little hot. And when we dig into the details, we find out that he's paying about$3,800 per month on agencies, specifically agencies to help him with SEO, Google Local Service Ads, and Meta advertising. And so that's fine. But the problem is really is his revenue at this moment. So because that$3,800 is such a large percentage for his revenue level, he's basically in a weird position where he needs the help, but the fixed cost of the agencies is a huge percentage of his overall revenue.

SPEAKER_00So he's right now that$536,000 of revenue over the last eight months, on average, he's hitting about$67,000 in revenue per month. Now we're spending$3,800 divided by$67,000. So we're spending over 5% of revenue on just the marketing agencies. So that's a big fixed cost. And so this is a weird situation where the actual solution is to actually grow out of this situation where we don't want to necessarily cut the agencies unless they're not performing well. In this case, we're gonna validate that they're performing well before we make this decision.

SPEAKER_00But usually the problem that I see is when you bring on a marketing agency and you're doing four, five, six, seven hundred thousand dollars in revenue, it can be a huge burden on your fixed costs. And so usually the solution is to grow out of it and hit one million dollars plus so that the fixed agency cost is a smaller percentage of your revenue. Okay, so let's keep that in mind and let's actually dive into the marketing numbers to make sure it's not a problem with the agency or with the sales process. So this is a snapshot of their CRM, and we can see uh so far this year, sales is at 612,000.

SPEAKER_00And so his revenue is at 536, his sales is at 612 because he is does have some work that he hasn't produced yet, which makes sense. And then we also see his average job size, 9400, really strong average job size. His closing ratio is 43%, and set rate is 36%. So those are decent numbers. The one thing that jumps out to me is the set rate is a little low. So typically when you're doing meta ads, you want to shoot for around a 50% set rate. So we'll keep that in mind as we continue to look at where is his leads actually coming from.

SPEAKER_00And we can see that most of the leads are coming from some Facebook ads, basically. So the first two here are Facebook ads, and then we have another one on the fifth and sixth one as well. So a lot of his leads are basically coming from Facebook, a little bit from Google LSA and his website. Then we if we look at his set rate by source, Facebook has a 30% set rate here, 17% here, again, indicating that meta set rates are a little low. We typically want to shoot for a 50% set rate on meta had leads coming in. And then if we scroll down further, we can see that most of the sales are coming from Facebook, and then also his close rates are pretty decent across the board.

SPEAKER_00Basically 53% for Facebook here, and then 44%. So close rate is pretty strong. Usually a close rate between 30 and 40% is a pretty decent close rate. So no concerns there. So my biggest thing is the set rate looks a little low. So let's do some funnel math to make sure that the numbers work for this channel of meta advertising, because this is where most of the money is being spent on ad spend. Uh, we mentioned he's paying$33,000 to agencies this year, but he's actually spent$27,000 on ad spend. So a little less has been spent on the actual ads.

SPEAKER_00And so let's take a look at the funnel math. So looking at all the money that he's closed, all the work that he has booked with Facebook and dividing that into his how much he's spent on Facebook ads, his average cost per lead is about$85 per lead. So we take that$85 per lead and we divide it by his set rate, which is about 36%. And so this gives us$236. So basically, he has to pay Meta$236 in ad spend to set one estimate. Now let's take his close rate of 43% and divide that by 0.43.

SPEAKER_00And so he's paying about$550 of ad spend to close one deal on Facebook. And with an average job size of$9,400, that's a pretty good deal. So his ad spend is only about 6% of his average job size. Now, even if his average job size was a little bit lower than that, let's say if it was$6,000, we're still in good shape. Ad spends are about 9% of the average job size. So we're looking in good shape given the fact that he has a low set rate, but he's making it up for with his higher close rate.

SPEAKER_00And his cost per lead is not too bad either. So the funnel math is working out. So it does appear that even though we look at his financials and his marketing line is 12.7%, kind of on the higher side, the math still works. So I wouldn't say to turn down ads, I would actually say let's turn up the ads and let's get the marketing agencies a smaller percentage of revenue and grow out of this. Because if we double our revenue, instead of the agencies being 5% of revenue, they're going to drop down to 2.5%. And that will get the marketing and advertising to about 10% of revenue down from 12.7%.

SPEAKER_00Now, if we're at that point, let's say we're doubling revenue, we're at 10% for marketing, 8% for sales, that puts us at 18% customer acquisition. If we multiply that by three, we still need a 54% gross profit. Because remember, we want to have a GP to CAC ratio of three to one at a minimum. And so we still need to do some work on the gross profit, is the bottom line here. So 50% gross profit works in the beginning, but often if you want to grow quickly and spend a lot to acquire customers, you got to be willing to continually improve your gross profit. So with him, he has a really strong close rate.

SPEAKER_00I would challenge him to look at ways he could improve his pricing, increase his prices while maintaining the same close rate. And so there's two ways you can do this. You can either one, improve your sales process, where you just have a better presentation process on the things you say, the things that you do during the sales presentation to get more yeses, to close more deals. Improve your sales process is the first thing you can do. The second thing you can do is improve the offer. So what are you actually offering to the customer to make it desirable to sign up with you? And so one thing that I see a lot with painting businesses is that they have a typical offer where they're a professional painting company.

SPEAKER_00So they have insurance, general liability, workers comp. They may have a warranty, like a five-year warranty. They guarantee that they background check all of their workers. They use high quality paints from Cheryl Williams or Benjamin Moore. So that's a pretty standard offer. And so what I usually challenge painting business owners to do is to improve that offer with a guarantee and a risk reversal guarantee specifically, where you have a certain guarantee, like, hey, we're gonna do XYZ. If we don't, if we fail to do that, you're gonna get a portion of the job price refunded to you. And so you can do something like an on-time, on budget guarantee where you say, hey, if we don't complete the job on time and on budget with some conditions, you know, we can't control the weather, we need access to the property, that sort of thing, we're gonna actually refund 10% of your job if we fail to do that.

SPEAKER_00And so that risk reversal can often boost your close rate and then allow you to increase prices and keep about the same close rate. So that's what I would look at doing to increase gross profit while maintaining a very similar close rate is to look at the sales process. How can we improve that? And then look at the offer. If we can target a 55% gross profit instead of a 50% gross profit, that will leave more room for customer acquisition costs and maintain that three to one ratio that we're looking for. Now, let's take a look at the other overhead costs. The one thing that we're really missing here is we don't have a production manager, we don't have a salesperson.

SPEAKER_00We already identified, if we want to double, we're gonna need to hire those folks on. But looking at all the other overhead costs, everything else is pretty low. There's no costs that are really jumping out as really expensive. Everything is below benchmark. The one thing I would say here is for his office wages, he hasn't really spent that much on office staff wages. I would get more help. So that'd free up his ability to do more speed to lead and get more of that admin help and maybe help with some production tasks. That would be my first hire to look at. And usually in admin, you want to pay around two to four percent of revenue depending on their responsibilities.

SPEAKER_00So with a million dollar business, we're looking at somewhere between$20,000 and$40,000. A lot of painting businesses, they'll either hire a part-time person or maybe they'll go and hire a VA overseas that will assist them remotely. So there's a couple different options there. Once you have that admin in place, I would recommend for Bill to take a look at getting a production manager and paying them two-thirds base, one-third bonus. And the two-thirds base would be something like$60,000 base and then one-third bonus, somewhere around$30,000 to$40,000 in bonuses. And the bonuses should be tied to revenue produced, Google reviews captured, and gross profit.

SPEAKER_00If he's hitting those three metrics of volume produced, Google review coverage, and also he's hitting the gross profit for projects, he can get an additional bonus each month. And so what would that look like? Let's say you're doing a$65,000 base and you do$35,000 of bonuses. So he has an opportunity to make$100,000 per year. Now, a production manager typically, depending on their scope of the roles and responsibilities, they can usually produce somewhere around$1.5 million, but as high as$2.5 million and as low as a million, depending on again what their roles and responsibilities are. Since we're going to have an admin in place, this production manager should be able to produce at least$1.5 million.

SPEAKER_00And so if we base the production off of$1.5 million, the production manager can get a bonus if they hit$125,000 in a month, right? So that qualifies them to get that bonus. Then let's say they got to have 50% Google review coverage on all the jobs finished that month. And then additionally, they have to have an overall gross profit of at least 55%, because that's our target gross profit now. If they hit all those three things, then they get that bonus. And if we're doing$35,000 a year, we divide that by 12, they can get a bonus up to$2,900 per month. So that's a compensation plan that I'd set up for a production manager.

SPEAKER_00Again, you want to tie it to production volume, Google reviews, and gross profit. All right, let's take a look at the net profit here. We're at 21% plus his officer salary, is at about 5%. So we're looking at total discretionary earnings of about 26.45%, which is pretty strong. Where I like him to be, given all the roles that he's playing, would be closer to 30 to 33%. But how did I come up with that number? Basically, if you're a passive business owner where you're just not even working in the business at all, you're sipping corona on the beach and you have a team running the painting business, you should be making 15% of revenue.

SPEAKER_00But obviously, Bill is not passive, right? He's doing multiple roles, he's doing sales. And we already said sales should be making 8%. So that we add that 15 and 8 together, that's 23%. But he's also doing production management. So from there, a production manager usually gets somewhere around four to seven percent, depending on the scope of the responsibilities. So we add that onto the 23%. Now we're up to 30%. And additionally, Bill's also doing some of the admin as well. Two to four percent is what we usually pay in admin. So we'll add another three there. So I would like Bill to be somewhere closer to 33%, given the roles that he has.

SPEAKER_00So the main area for improvement here again is to get gross profit up closer to 55%. Also keep hammering the ads, the ad spend, monitor your CAC ratio so that we're maintaining at least a three to one ratio. And we need to outgrow our marketing agency spend because right now it's very high as a percentage of revenue because our revenue is a little bit too low. So we got to outgrow our marketing agencies. And then lastly, we need to be prepared to bring on an admin to help us with production tasks and speed to lead, and then maybe eventually a production manager as well. All right, let's take a look at the balance sheet.

SPEAKER_00We looked at profitability. Now let's take a look at liquidity. So liquidity is basically our ability to pay debt in the short term. So we look at bank accounts here, 281,000 and current assets of 284,000. And we can compare that to current liabilities of 35,000, about 36,000. So very strong liquidity. This business has the ability to cover its current liabilities several times over. So no concerns with liquidity here. This business is doing a great job of keeping enough cash in the business and keeping debt relatively low. And then lastly, we look at solvency. So not much long-term debt, and the business has plenty of equity, positive equity in the business.

SPEAKER_00So no concerns with solvency, which is the ability for the business to pay debt in the long term. So overall, profitability is decent. We just need to make a few tweaks to improve that GP to CAC ratio. And then we also need to grow the revenue. So marketing agencies are a smaller percentage of revenue. And then liquidity and solvency are very strong. So I think this business is well suited to grow to the next level. We just need to hit the gas on the marketing and then monitor our GP to CAC ratio. All right, that does it for our build financial teardown. Hopefully, this was helpful. Take a look at your numbers, see how it compares to our financial teardown for today.

SPEAKER_00And with that, I will see you in the next video.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Busy But Broke? How to Fix Cash Flow in Your Painting Business (2027)

    Nov 20, 202632 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail Your painting business can be booked out for weeks and still be short on cash. Bigger sales don’t always mean more money in your pocket. In this episode, I break down why busy painting contractors still...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. How to Scale a Painting Business From $4M to $10M

    Nov 17, 202615 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail If I had to grow a painting business from $4M to $10M today, here's what I'd do. Brandon Pierpont from Painter Marketing Pros and I walk through the money side and the marketing side of the stage where...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. How to Grow Your Painting Business SO Fast in 2027 It Feels ILLEGAL

    Nov 16, 202615 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail Grow your painting business so fast in 2027 it feels illegal. Learn the exact checks I use to fix pricing, job margins, lead response and cash flow before you spend more on leads. Know Your Numbers &...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. How a $50M Contractor Wins Jobs Without Being the Cheapest

    Nov 12, 202630 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail Painting contractors can raise prices 5-10% with a guarantee and keep their close rate about the same. Randy Hurtado of the Good Contractors List and I show how. If you want to raise prices in your...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Why Painting Businesses Get Stuck at $1.5M (And How to Reach $4M)

    Nov 11, 202652 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail If I had to grow a painting business from $1.5M to $4M today, here's what I'd do. Brandon Pierpont from Painter Marketing Pros and I walk through the money side and the marketing side of the stage we...

    Credit the people on this episode