Send us Fan Mail After my first year running a painting business, I was worse off than when I started. Over the last 10 years, I’ve worked with more than 600 painting businesses, and I keep seeing owners make the same mistakes I made. In this episode, I share 7 lessons I’d want you to know before you spend another year growing, from pricing and taxes to hiring, cash flow, and building your team. Know Your Numbers & Save Big in Taxes, Daniel Honan, CPA Every episode is made for painting business owners. Follow the show so the next one downloads automatically. WANT ME TO LOOK AT YOUR NUMBERS? Join 600+ painting contractors who know exactly where their money goes, keep more of what they earn, and scale without tax surprises. Book a free Profit Checkup here → profitablepaintercpa.com/vsl FREE BOOK FOR PAINTING CONTRACTORS FREE! Just cover shipping. Get your copy here → profitablepaintercpa.com/book Prefer video? Watch this episode on YouTube 📌 What We Discuss: 00:00 Seven Lessons for Building a More Profitable Painting Business 00:48 Pricing Labor and Materials for 50% Gross Profit 03:39 Keeping Up With Taxes, Payroll, and Records 05:16 Making Sure You Can Afford Your Next Hire 07:15 Hiring and Paying Salespeople Based on Profitable Work 08:48 Managing Cash Flow and Getting Paid on Time 10:37 Building a Two-Month Cash Reserve 11:10 Measuring Gross Profit Against Customer Acquisition Costs 13:02 Knowing When to Increase or Cut Marketing Spend 14:09 Building a Team That Can Take Ownership 16:13 Budgeting for Recruiting and Finding Better Employees 17:38 Planning Taxes Before the Year Ends 19:04 When to Consider an S Corp Election About us - Profitable Painter CPA: We helping painting business owners understand their numbers, reduce taxes, and build sustainable wealth. Check us out → profitablepaintercpa.com This episode was originally recorded as a video for YouTube. If you hear me say things like “in this video” or reference visuals, don’t worry - the content still works perfectly in audio form. And if you ever want to watch the video version, you can find it on the Profitable Painter YouTube channel. https://www.youtube.com/@BookkeepingForPainters
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_00After my first year running a painting business, I was worse off than when I started. When I started, I didn't have any money, but at least I didn't owe anyone. A year later, I still had no money, and now I had credit card debt too, all because I didn't understand my numbers. I grew up painting in my dad's business and I ran my own painting business while I was in college studying accounting. Later, I opened my own accounting firm that only works with painters. And over the last 10 years, I've worked with over 600 painting businesses, and I keep seeing owners make the same mistakes I made. I've seen an owner who thought he was making 50% on his jobs to find out he was really at 38%.
SPEAKER_00I've seen owners end up owing$200,000 or$300,000 in back taxes. I've also learned a lot from owners who are getting it right. So in this video, I'm going to share seven lessons I'd want you to know before you spend another year growing a business that leaves you with less money or more stress. Let's start with that owner who was sure his pricing was right. Lesson one, price the labor and the materials. So I worked with an owner doing around$500,000 in revenue. And I asked him what gross profit he was shooting for. And he said 50%.
SPEAKER_00Then we opened his profit and loss, and he was only at 38%. And just so we're out on the same page, gross profit is what's left over after you pay for the direct costs of doing the work, which means your painters and your materials. Out of that money, you still have to cover sales, marketing, and overhead, like your office and admin costs before you get to net profit. For residential repaint, when you're repainting an existing home, 50% is the starting target I usually recommend. If you're working with general contractors or GCs, around 35% can be a starting point. And that's because once you've got an ongoing relationship with a GC, it usually costs you less to get work from them than it does to find a brand new homeowner for every job.
SPEAKER_00You still have to account for your sales costs though. And those targets need to fit how your business gets customers. Now, on this owner's jobs, a small miss could have come from things going wrong during production. If you're aiming for 50% and coming in at 45 or 47%, you need to understand why. But 38% gross profit was 12 percentage points below his target. So we needed to check his pricing and whether his crews were going over their budgeted hours. He was using production rates to estimate how many painter hours a job would take, which was good. The problem showed up when he turned those hours into a price.
SPEAKER_00He was using about$30 an hour as his fully loaded labor cost, which includes payroll taxes and workers' comp. And he was charging$60 an hour. And that's 100% markup on his cost, which gives him a 50% gross profit margin on the labor. But then he'd add the cost of paint without marking it up at all. So he was aiming for 50% on labor and making no gross profit on the materials. Once you put two together, the margin on the whole job came down significantly. And here's how the mask would work: if your total direct cost on a job is$1,000 and you want a 50% gross profit margin, your price needs to be$2,000.
SPEAKER_00That way, the thousand dollars left over is half of what you sold it for. Just make sure that the calculation includes every direct cost you're putting into the job. When this owner fixed his pricing, his close rate dropped. He'd been closing around 60 to 65% on his estimates, mostly from warm inbound leads. And after the change, he was still closing around 50%. And that's why I always look at the close rate next to margin. With warmer inbound leads, around 40% is a benchmark I use. With colder outbound leads, it's closer to 30%.
SPEAKER_00And if you've got a mix, you're probably sitting somewhere in between. A high close rate tells me to look at the pricing, but we still need to check your costs and the kind of leads you're getting. So start with the gross margin you're trying to hit. Compare it with your actual numbers and walk through one estimate step by step. And that's how we found out this owner's missing material markup. And checking your numbers like that helps you catch a pricing problem early. You need that same habit with taxes because what you owe can keep piling up while you're busy doing the work. Lesson two, keep up with taxes, payroll, and records.
SPEAKER_00I've worked with owners who ended up owing$200,000 or$300,000 in back taxes because they didn't file and pay their income taxes or deal with what they owe in that state. And I've also seen payroll tax problems that ran into tens of thousands of dollars. Those were separate situations. And some of them, the missed returns also led to penalties and tax liens. So the owner had years of problems to deal with all this at once. You know when you haven't dealt with it. Every time you check the mailbox, you're dreading that envelope from the IRS. You might be doing good painting work, but you're carrying that stress around while you're trying to run your business.
SPEAKER_00I've seen state audits too in places like Washington and New Mexico. The rules are different from state to state. Washington can require retail sales tax on painting work while New Mexico has gross receipts tax. You need to know what applies to the work you're doing and take care of it as you go. That starts with a basic set of accurate books, filing your returns and paying what you owe. If you've got employees, run payroll the right way. If you use subcontractors, get their W9 information and file the information returns that are required. Their classification and the reporting rules need to be right for your situation.
SPEAKER_00And just so you know, what I'm sharing here is general business and tax education. Work with a qualified professional on what's required for your business and your state. Make sure it's clear who's keeping the books, who's filing the returns, and when the payments are due. That way, someone's responsible for each one, and then you've got a way to check that it actually got done. Those taxes need a spot in your budget, and so does your next hire. And a salary can look affordable when you're comparing it to revenue you haven't actually brought in yet. Lesson three, make sure you can afford your next hire. I see this mistake a lot with businesses under$1 million in revenue.
SPEAKER_00The owner wants help, so they bring on a production manager on a flat salary and figure the business will grow enough to pay for it. Let's say you're producing$700,000 a year and you hire a manager for$70,000. That's 10% as a percentage of revenue. You're hoping to get to$1 million next year. And at that point, that same salary would be 7%. But if production stays at$700,000, you still have to pay that salary. And for that role, I usually work from a range of four to seven percent of the production they're responsible for.
SPEAKER_00Where they fall in that range depends on what they're actually doing. If your admin handles onboarding and customer communication and your crew leads handle the final walkthrough and collecting payment, that production manager has a smaller job. And that can put them closer to four percent of what they produce. But if the production manager is ordering paint, talking to customers, managing the crews, collecting payment, and following up for Google reviews, they're doing a lot more and the budget moves closer to 7%. So first figure out what you're hiring them to do. Then compare their total pay with the production they'll be overseeing.
SPEAKER_00The structure I like is about two-thirds of their pay coming from a base salary and one-thirds from performance bonuses. Tie the bonus to production volume, gross profit on completed jobs, and customer satisfaction. Build the pay plan within the wage rules that apply for each role. The bonus still has to fit the numbers. If someone can earn$75,000 with bonuses, your business needs enough profitable production to support the full amount. At a 7% budget, that's roughly$1,070,000 in production.
SPEAKER_00Set your bonus target so that higher pay comes with the profitable work needed to pay for it. You might also be hiring the wrong position first. An admin can take customer calls, help with onboarding and invoicing, and give you time back while you keep selling and managing production. I've seen owners get close to a million with an admin and their crews. The right hiring order depends on what you're good at and which jobs are stretching you too thin. When you bring on a salesperson, start with the same question: What work are you paying them to do? A residential salesperson is usually a hunter.
SPEAKER_00They're doing several estimates a day and closing new work all the time. So I usually like a commission heavy pay for that role. Someone building ongoing relationships with GCs is more of a farmer. They go longer between sales, so base plus commission might be a better fit. Either way, tie their incentives to profitable work. If a salesperson can discount a job to get it signed and still get paid the same, your pay plan is rewarding them for giving away the margin that you need. One way that I set that up is to pay an initial commission on the next payroll after the job sells, then pay an extra amount once the job's finished and we've checked its actual labor and material costs.
SPEAKER_00For example, start with a 4% commission on the sale. If the job hits 50% gross profit, add an additional percentage point. So the total commission is 5%. At 53% gross profit, add two points. So it's six percent commission. And then set the tiers around your own margin target and put the payment terms in the pay plan. That gives your salesperson a reason to sell work at a price the business can actually afford to produce. You're also checking the result after the job's done when you know what it really costs. Even when a hire fits your margins, you still need cash in the bank when payday comes around.
SPEAKER_00And that's where a profitable painting business can still get into trouble. Lesson four get paid before cash gets tight. Cash is like oxygen for your business. If you run out, you can't keep operating. I've seen owners who were profitable on paper and still struggling to cover the next payroll just because of when the money came in and when it went out. One owner I worked with was an excellent painter. When a customer signed, he'd buy the paint right away with his business debit card and store it in his garage until the job started.
SPEAKER_00He didn't take a deposit or any progress payment. He paid his painters every week and he only collected from the customer at the very end. So he was paying for the job long before he got paid for it. He also wasn't using payment terms with his paint supplier. So buying those materials right away pulled cash straight out of his checking account. To fix that timing, start with how you collect. Take a deposit where it's allowed, agree on the progress payments for longer jobs, and have a process for collecting the final balance quickly.
SPEAKER_00I like a 50% deposit where it's legal. Some states limit deposits though, so your contract and your payment schedule have to follow the local rules. You can't just assume that what another painter does is allowed where you work. Next, look at your payment terms on materials. If your paint supplier gives you time to pay, understand those terms and plan the payment before it's due. That can keep you from sending cash out weeks before the job even starts. A business credit card can also help with timing as long as you pay the balance in full and avoid any interest.
SPEAKER_00It needs to fit a payment plan you can actually afford. Your payroll and subcontractor payments still have to follow the rules and agreements that apply. So focused on the parts of the timing you can legally control. I also want owners to keep at least two months of overhead costs as cash in the bank as a starting reserve. That gives you some breathing room when work slows down or the truck needs a repair. It won't cover every problem, but it gives you more time to deal with one. Be disciplined about what you can take out for yourself while building that reserve.
SPEAKER_00Your business should support you and your family. And to keep doing that, it needs enough cash left inside it. And that cash gives you room to grow. But before you put more of it into marketing, you need to know what it costs you to turn a new customer into gross profit. And this is the lesson that changed how I looked at a painting business. Lesson five compare gross profit with sales and marketing costs. When I first started working with painting businesses, I look at gross profit and decide if that was good or bad. Over time, I learned that I needed more context than that to make a call.
SPEAKER_00A business doing work for repeat general contractors might run a lower gross profit and spend very little on marketing. A residential repaint company could have a higher gross profit margin and still spend so much getting each customer that there's not enough left over. And that's why I look at gross profit compared to customer acquisition cost or GP to CAC. Your customer acquisition costs include your marketing and sales costs. What we want to know is how much gross profit those costs are bringing in.
SPEAKER_00One business I work with had a 50% gross profit margin. On its own, that looked like a good starting point. But marketing was 12% of revenue, and the salesperson was paid 8% of what they closed, 20% of revenue was going to getting customers. Divide 50 by 20 and you get 2.5. So for every dollar they spent getting customers, the business was bringing in$2.50 in gross profit. And that's before paying the rest of the overhead. The minimum I usually want to see is three to one with some room above that before you spend more on growth.
SPEAKER_00Somewhere between 4.5 to 1 and 6 to 1 gives you more room, depending on your business and where your customers come from. Use those as starting benchmarks. Then check whether the gross profit left after sales and marketing covers your overhead and still leaves room for profit. Here's why that room matters. When you spend more money on marketing, the next customers can cost more to get. If you're barely hitting the minimum, that extra cost can drop you below it. That's why I want to buffer before you hit the gas.
SPEAKER_00For the business at 2.5 to 1, we looked at its pricing and its sales process. Could it charge more? Was it getting back to leads quickly? Was the offer helping the salesperson close? Which marketing channels were bringing in enough gross profit to be worth what they cost? You need to check each channel separately too, because a good overall average can hide one channel that's costing you way too much. And that helps you decide which channels deserve more of your budget and which ones to cut back on or drop. And if you're doing the selling yourself, factor in what it would cost you to replace you when you're figuring out if the business can grow beyond you.
SPEAKER_00That change in how I read the numbers was a big one for me. A gross profit target gives you a place to start. Putting it next to acquisition costs is what helps you decide if you can afford the growth you're actually planning. And if you're looking at your own numbers and you're not sure whether it's your pricing, your sales costs, or your overhead causing the problem, my team offers a free painter profit review. We'll look at your situation, point out the biggest opportunities, and tell you whether we can help. I'll put the link in the description. Once you know your numbers can support growth, you might find the next thing holding you back is your team.
SPEAKER_00At that point, trying to keep every salary as low as possible can keep you stuck doing all the managing yourself. Lesson six spend enough to build the team you need. Earlier, we talked about paying too much for a role your business couldn't support. Now, later on, I see owners make the opposite mistake. They're at$2 million or$3 million in revenue and still trying to get capable managers to work for too little. I call that stage the swamp. It's often somewhere around$1.5 to$4 million in revenue. You've stopped painting, you've stopped selling and managing every job yourself, but you're still managing everyone who does these jobs.
SPEAKER_00So every decision keeps coming back to you. To get past that, you need people who can take responsibility for results. A production leader needs to manage the project managers and the crews. A sales leader needs to manage the salespeople. Depending on your business, you might need a marketing manager to oversee how you get customers or a controller to take charge of the finances. Once you've got those people, you can ask your production leader whether finished jobs are hitting gross profit target or ask your sales leader about the team's close rate. If they're missing a target, you ask what they're going to do to fix it.
SPEAKER_00They take responsibility for running their area and bringing you a plan, and that takes some of the day-to-day decisions off your plate. Some of those roles might need$150,000 to$250,000 in pay, depending on the responsibilities and the size of the business. And that's a big commitment. It has to fit your budget and you need someone who can actually do the job you're paying for. There's a thought experiment I like from Brad Jacobs' book, How to Make a Few Billion Dollars. Imagine if someone on your team walks in and tells you they're quitting. How do you react? If you're relieved because you're already thinking about letting them go, that's probably a C player.
SPEAKER_00If you're disappointed and it's going to be really inconvenient for the next month or two, but you think you can find someone just as good, that's probably a B player. If you're panicking because you know how much that person contributes, that's someone you want to keep. That's an A player. And that's how I like to think about A players. You've got to be willing to pay for those people properly. You also have to spend money to find them. And that recruiting problem can show up at any stage. Tara Riley has a rule of three that I really like: respond to a lead within three minutes, get out to an estimate within three days, and produce work within three weeks.
SPEAKER_00She used to lead Fresh Go Painters and now she works at the Academy for Professional Painting Contractors. So if you're booked out four, five, six weeks, look into whether you need more painters. If it's taking you too long to get out to do an estimate, you might need another salesperson. If leads are sitting there with no answer, you might need someone who handles the phone. Those delays show up where your team needs more capacity, though your season and the kind of work you do affect what's realistic. An owner asked me recently how much you should be willing to spend on recruiting.
SPEAKER_00I work from about 5% to 10% of gross profit that person is expected to bring on while they're with you. Let's say a painter stays with you for a year on average and produces$100,000 of work at 50% gross profit. That's$50,000 in gross profit. 5% to 10% of that gives you a recruiting budget of$2,500 to$5,000. Use your own numbers for how much your painters produce and how long they usually stay. The one year example is just there to show you the math. That budget could go towards recruiting ads or platform like Indeed or LinkedIn, a referral bonus for an employee who brings you someone good.
SPEAKER_00If a shortage of people is what's stopping you from getting the work done, spending nothing on recruiting just leaves that problem sitting there. As those people help your business grow beyond you, you can start building more wealth. One owner I worked with had gotten to that point, and planning his taxes became a big part of protecting what he'd built. Lesson seven, plan taxes before the year's over. This owner was doing around three to four million dollars in revenue, and a lot of his wealth was tied up in the painting business. He wanted to diversify into real estate.
SPEAKER_00We helped him plan a short-term rental strategy, and his spouse managed the rentals. We also used something called a cost segregation study, which can let you take certain tax deductions on parts of the property's costs sooner. Those deductions can create paper losses on your tax return. In his case, the rental losses could offset income from his painting business. Across multiple properties over a couple of years, that strategy saved him around six figures in taxes. Now, whether rental losses can offset your business income depends on how the rental is used, how involved you are in it, and other tax limit.
SPEAKER_00Your spouse's involvement can count, but the setup still has to qualify. So sit down with your tax professional and figure out whether you can use those deductions and win before you commit to the plan. The point is that you have choices to look at before the year's over. If you only file a tax return after everything's already happened, you've got fewer decisions you can still make for that year. You can start planning a lot earlier than the$3 million stage too. For an owner doing$500,000 to a million dollars in revenue, I'd want to talk about whether an S-corp election makes sense, what reasonable pay looks like for the work that you do, and whether business expenses you've paid personally are being reimbursed the right way.
SPEAKER_00Around$70,000 in net profit is one point where I often start the S-Corp conversation. We compare the possible tax benefit with the payroll, admin, and other costs before deciding if the election makes sense for that business. If you're working in your S-Corp, it has to pay you a reasonable compensation for that work before you take any profit as distributions. Your salary needs to match with the work you're actually doing for the company. An accountable plan can also help you get reimbursed for qualifying business expenses that you've paid for personally, like the business use of your vehicle or your phone.
SPEAKER_00When those reimbursements are handled the right way under the plan, they avoid payroll taxes. The expenses need a business purpose and documentation, and any extra reimbursement has to be paid back. Your accountant should help you figure out which expenses qualify and how to record them. Spending a few hours during the year going over these decisions with a qualified professional can be well worth it. That way you can make a plan while you still have time to act on it using the profit and cash your business is producing. You don't have to fix all seven of these at once.
SPEAKER_00Start with the problem that's holding your business back right now, whether that's getting customers, having enough people to do the work, or a policy that's hurting your profit and cash. In this video right here, I walk through how to find that bottleneck so you can put your money and time toward fixing it. Watch that one next.
Send us Fan Mail Your painting business can be booked out for weeks and still be short on cash. Bigger sales don’t always mean more money in your pocket. In this episode, I break down why busy painting contractors still...
Send us Fan Mail If I had to grow a painting business from $4M to $10M today, here's what I'd do. Brandon Pierpont from Painter Marketing Pros and I walk through the money side and the marketing side of the stage where...
Send us Fan Mail Grow your painting business so fast in 2027 it feels illegal. Learn the exact checks I use to fix pricing, job margins, lead response and cash flow before you spend more on leads. Know Your Numbers &...
Send us Fan Mail Painting contractors can raise prices 5-10% with a guarantee and keep their close rate about the same. Randy Hurtado of the Good Contractors List and I show how. If you want to raise prices in your...
Send us Fan Mail If I had to grow a painting business from $1.5M to $4M today, here's what I'd do. Brandon Pierpont from Painter Marketing Pros and I walk through the money side and the marketing side of the stage we...