Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Profitable Painter Podcast

Profitable Painter Podcast artwork

Helping a $700K Painting Business Fix Its Overhead and Pricing

Aug 14, 202625 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Send us Fan Mail Daniel helps the owner of a $700K painting company who has been badly undercharging for overhead - marking up 10% when his real numbers call for far more. Daniel walks through a complete job-pricing model (fully-loaded labor + materials, an overhead multiplier built from the last 12 months, and a 15% net-profit target) and shows why the company's oversized team is inflating quotes to a 56% gross profit that's too high to win work. They also cover the margins needed to win general-contractor vs. residential jobs, the hidden cash-flow traps of GC work, and a bonus structure that ties team pay to profit and production. Work with us https://profitablepaintercpa.com/vsl Free Book - Profitable Painter https://profitablepaintercpa.com/book Keywords: how to price painting jobs, painting business overhead markup, painting contractor pricing strategy, painting business profit margins, general contractor painting margins, painter fully loaded labor cost, painting company gross profit target, growing a painting business to profitability, painting business owner compensation, residential repaint pricing rule of thumb This episode was originally recorded as a video for YouTube. If you hear me say things like “in this video” or reference visuals, don’t worry - the content still works perfectly in audio form. And if you ever want to watch the video version, you can find it on the Profitable Painter YouTube channel. https://www.youtube.com/@BookkeepingForPainters For being a loyal listener, I want to send you a copy of my new book Profitable Painter. Inside, I’ll show you the exact frameworks that have helped painting businesses save big on taxes, increase profits, and scale with confidence Head over to profitablepaintercpa.com/book and grab your copy today. Don’t wait - this is my gift to you for being part of the Profitable Painter community.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_00uh we having a big problem uh in the company and uh like we did a course like uh we took a class with the pca with bob and uh we was using the wrong overhair for the business so basically like for 10 years over i was not charging enough for overhair right and uh i was only charges uh the profit and the uh the overhair is the profit yep so uh my question for you it is how we can be better with that gotcha okay cool i think that's a that's a great question let me uh pull out a calculator here so basically you went through bob's estimating course where you're doing product production rate estimating where you you figure out how much labor costs fully loaded labor with the the hourly rate plus the payroll taxes workers comp and then you add in the material and you get your actual costs there and then once you have your actual costs then you want to calculate your overhead percentage and you do that based off of looking at your financials and seeing what your aver your overhead is compared to your to your lab so uh just to to go through the first couple steps i it sounds like from your question you you understand production rate estimating like how to measure the surfaces get the budgeted hours multiply that by the the hourly rate and and add up the materials that's all pretty straightforward right you you understand that piece yes okay let's just take an example let's say you had um you did some math all the surfaces measured all the surfaces multiply them into your production rates and you've and and multiplied your fully loaded labor rate which is your hourly rate plus your markup I'm sorry plus your uh payroll taxes and workers comp which is usually another another 30% on top of like your um your base rate that you're gonna pay your your painter and you you multiply that by how many budget hours and you get$5,000 of labor costs full fully loaded labor from there you add in your materials and say it's a thousand bucks of materials so from here we're gonna we're up to six thousand dollars in costs of labor and materials now from here the piece that your question is about is like how do I add in the overhead piece and then the last step would be adding in the the profit piece so that you're properly charging your customers so you're covering your overhead covering your profit am I getting this right so far?

SPEAKER_00Yeah okay cool so what you want to do for your overhead how to calculate what to charge for your overhead is to look at the last year of your overhead costs and compare that to your last year of labor costs. So I went ahead and pulled those numbers for you ahead of time looking at the last 12 months you're around 355 of overhead costs. So overhead costs we're talking about marketing we're talking about your production manager salesperson your officer salary insurance like general liability insurance account legal all that stuff is overhead so 355 over the last 12 months we take that number and then we divide it by your total labor fully loaded which is your painter employee painters subcontractors your payroll taxes for those painters and workers comp.

SPEAKER_00And so that was around 3240 over the last 12 months and so we divide those two together and we get a ratio of 1.1 rounded so basically your overhead of the last 12 months is a little higher than your labor. So it's 110% of labor to say it another way. So to go back to our example we said uh$5,000 of labor costs and$1,000 of materials so to get how much to to add on for material um for overhead we said 1.1 is the the multiplier here so we take the$5,000 of labor cost for this example estimate that we just made up multiply that by 1.1 and so that gives us the overhead piece of what we should add in for this project based off of your historical overhead costs for the last year.

SPEAKER_00So now we have the overhead piece of five$5500 plus the labor piece of 5000 plus the materials of 1000. So right now we're at$11,500. And so now we get into the final step which is adding in the profit. So most folks they typically and I may I have the same recommendation of hitting at least 15% profit that's netting after everything all the job site costs all the overhead costs paying your officer salary to include that everything once you take everything out what's left over usually want around 15% you could shoot for more and so we take this$11,500 and we divide it by one minus our target net profit which is 15% in this case or otherwise stated as 0.15.

SPEAKER_00So one minus 0.15 is 0.85 so uh so that gives us our final price of 13529 and so um just to kind of break out the numbers a little bit here our total price to charge the customer to cover 15% profit and our overhead costs and our direct costs we got to charge$13,529. And if we hit the budget that we we were shooting for so we said five thousand dollars in labor costs plus one thousand in material that's six thousand dollars in direct cost if we hit that budget and we charge thirteen five twenty nine that means that we are actually shooting for a basically a 56% gross profit.

SPEAKER_00And so that probably seems pretty high but that is based off your overhead over the last 12 months yeah so now we can get into the why the overhead is a little bit higher. It's usually it's your overhead is a little bit higher than what we would typically see for for where you're at we can talk about that. But before we get into that does the math that I just went through does that make sense to you yes this is how we do it this is how we do it.

SPEAKER_01We are charging one uh 110% for the over here we charge you that and we are the pain of the bigger the job we are between 10 and 20 for profit but here where we are no one giving job to us like that.

SPEAKER_00Yeah yeah it's and this is our you're using this for residential repaint and uh so yeah so 50 50 56% gross profit on a GC job is yeah that's super high usually to win jobs consistently you need to be somewhere around 35% gross profit 3540 maybe yes I would agree that 56% gross profit is is pretty high. However what I would say looking at your your cost structure in your business over the last 12 months you're you have a lot of the biggest thing in your overhead is basically your overhead team so your production manager sales team and your ad with the amount of revenue that you're doing over the last 12 months it's it's you you have a large team.

SPEAKER_00You have a team that probably could help you produce 1.5 maybe two million with the team that you have at least how it looks on the profit and loss I don't haven't been with them but when I look at your your overhead costs you look like a company that should be doing 1.5 million in revenue and so uh in in that that over basically almost half of your revenue is going to those overhead positions I think it's I think it's about half. So really at a business your size I would typically see maybe an admin and maybe some help with sales or production management one of the two not both that I think is the main cost to look at is if we're going to stay at the revenue range that you're at now, do we actually need all of all this whole team here?

SPEAKER_00Or if we if we if you have aggressive growth goals we need to get those growth goals quick and you're we we need to grow the business. So the the the drawback to this methodology that uh Bob has which is a good methodology it is that it's gonna you're kind of locked your overhead in uh assuming your overhead's going to stay the same as you grow. Since your overhead is so high I'm assuming you probably don't need to bring people on to get to one million and one point five million you do you think you could stay with the same team and produce that much?

SPEAKER_01Because uh last year I was with the same team and we get like we get closer to 1.4.

SPEAKER_001.4 yes yeah so the answer is yes so um with that we if we look let me do some other math here we said 358 is your overhead costs and if you're at 1.4 let's say that means your overhead would be more like oops let's see it which is more of what I would typically expect for for over for overhead as a percentage of revenue and so uh to use the so so to to recalculate that overhead markup that instead of it being 1.1 or 110% let's recalculate it using 1.4 as the revenue so basically your 1.4 million let's say the labor uh because I think typically your labor has been running around 40% ish so that means 560,000 uh for labor and then 358 divided by 560 so that means our ratio is gonna be way different here so it's really 64% instead of 1.1 so to go back to our example if we're at 0.64 instead of 1.1 that$5,000 of labor cost in our original example multiply it by 0.64 then we're at$3200 for overhead and so$3200 plus the$0000 for labor plus the$1,000 for materials.

SPEAKER_00So we're at$9200 for the total cost of labor materials and overhead using the 0.64 multiple and then we add in the profit divided by 0.85 a 15% profit and so now the price is now instead of 13500 it's 10800 so a big difference and that and basically it's you your team has the capacity to the capacity to do 1.4 we know that and so I assuming you're trying to get back to that 1.4 that you were at we need to probably calibrate the overhead in a way that it makes sense for that growth uh so so in this example instead of it being a 56% gross profit that you have to shoot for it's uh 6,000 divided by 10823 it's a 45% gross profit.

SPEAKER_00Now it makes sense yeah and so in and with yeah so that that would be a lot more I think reasonable and you probably would win more bids with that type of pricing. But you just the key is you need to get that revenue up or downsize your team one of the two things get your revenue up as quick as possible or downsize your team in the in the short term so that uh you just have less overhead.

SPEAKER_01Yeah yeah I was I was planning for that was uh like not having like an inside estimator in like me go back and just do an old estimate myself is going to be a lot again and uh the thing is uh we're not getting a lot of jobs for the GC because of that that's one of the one that's the main point so they come back we offer it to us let's say let's just one sample we send the the bid for 45 thousand dollars and they come back to us okay I have 34 00 to you do the job but when we see because we know the number we know how much we need to get we not take the job we've been rejected let's say$7000 just this year in job$700,000 yeah that's that's a good exchange yeah because uh when we see the number when we see the number we're not going to cover anything for the overhead so I just spoke with Amari he's he wants a closing job he wants to close but I just get back to him and say hey if we're not getting any money for the overhead anyway all the all the profit is going to be over here we're not making no money doesn't make sense to get the job right for sure just just to be working it's not make sense correct yeah you don't you don't want to just get work to be busy but then not make any money you you take on too much risk as a business owner to not have profit it's not about being greedy it's really about protecting the business because the business needs cash to stay alive so for so everyone not just you but everyone the business employees the painters production manager sales per people they all depend on the business and in order for the business to continue to survive it needs that profit and that cash to protect itself because things go wrong sometimes you might be sued all these things it's a lot of risk and so we I you're totally right that when you take on work you you have to make sure that profit margin is there.

SPEAKER_00Otherwise you're putting the the business at risk and also everyone's job that's tied to it. Yeah a hundred percent and also the the big problem that you know that we have with GC is they they take too long to pay so we need uh we do we we do a lot of um prevailing we need to put all the money up front like payroll and all the materials and then wait when they want to pay us let's say between 30 60 and 90 days that's a lot that's a lot of it is yeah you you're basically acting as a financing company for those general contractors where you're fronting all the materials and the labor putting all the work in and not getting paid for several months in a lot of cases.

SPEAKER_00And then on top of that with prevailing wage you have to pay really high wages to your team to to meet those those thresholds so it can eat away at the profit very quickly. So it's slim oftentimes slim margin work and then high risk for cash flow because of the long time to get paid uh and so it just increases the risk a lot to to these jobs that that's the those are the downsides. The benefit of GC work is that you basically have almost zero customer acquisition costs your marketing spend is going to be basically zero.

SPEAKER_00You might have to pay some money for the for sales to calculate how much to charge folks but even the sales piece is pretty minimal it's just really about the relationships that you have. So the that's the the upside of GC work is that it's very low customer acquisition costs assuming you have good relationships with the the GCs that you're you're working with. So it's a bit of a trade-off so usually folks will have a lower gross profit margin somewhere like we were saying somewhere between 30 and 40% typically because they don't have to worry about customer acquisition costs.

SPEAKER_00Whereas residential repaint on the other hand they're they have a lot of customer acquisition costs for marketing and salespeople so their margins have to be a lot higher at least 40% of the very bottom and usually but the most successful ones are hitting 50 55 and sometimes even 60 or 65% gross profit. So I it's I'm in a I'm in a big trouble because uh win like I say it it is a lot about thank god that I I get to that point and I know what my overhead is supposed to be that because to be honest with you we all we always charge you 10% you always charge that the 110% no 20% just 20% we what we was doing the bit before was 30% profit margin 20% profit and we assuming 10% for the for the overhead oh gotcha okay yeah just 30% gotcha it was a mix right yeah sometimes to finish a job we was putting money from my pocket to finish the job yes yeah that uh the most painting businesses their overhead somewhere around 20 to 30 percent overhead and then say again 30 percent is that the overhead for for most painting businesses it ranges from roughly 20 to 30 for overhead and then you add in around 10 to 20 percent for profit so you're looking at overall for profit and for overhead together somewhere around 40 to 50 percent to to cover so that's why the tip often a for residential repaint a typical rule of thumb is just to basically take your labor costs and your material costs and double it because that will make it 50 for 50% for cost of doing the job and then 50% allocated for profit and overhead.

SPEAKER_00That that usually works as a a good rule of thumb for residential repaint for GC work because you have basically very low customer acquisition cost you can you can go below 50% a bit but it it still needs to be somewhere somewhere around 35% usually to to be profitable. So for a GC specific painting business usually what we see is somewhere around 20% for 20% for overhead and about 15% for profit profit is a is an ideal situation.

SPEAKER_00And so that leaves that that means you can have a 35% gross profit that covers you know 20% for the overhead and 15% for the profit. Okay what do you think if I take the chance and lowers my overhead 910 and we do like 60% and take the chance for that so we can close job so yeah using the 60.64 um multiple for overhead instead of the 1.1 what you're currently using I think I think you could do that uh you would just need to really make sure you're either one you're gonna hit that revenue of around 1.4 million to get get that spun up fast and like get a lot of jobs to line lined up on that 0.64 multiple or you'll have to downsize your your current team so that you you're just you have a smaller overhead so you can work at a smaller revenue level in the meantime.

SPEAKER_00Or a third option would be if you keep your current team is you can set up a compensation structure so that their pay scales with the business for example if you have a project manager let's say they would have a base rate of let's say around$65,000 salary and then you can give them bonuses up to 30$3500 if certain production is met per per month if they produce a certain amount of production per month if they're on track to if you if you and your team are on track to hit$1.4 million they could get paid up to$100,000 in salary but if if you're not gonna hit anywhere near$1.4 million you and you're like on whatever$700,000$8000 then they're they don't get any bonuses and they stay at their base rate.

SPEAKER_00So usually the best way to kind of structure this is you have your your base rate of whatever$6065000 and then you establish certain production volume per month and you tier it out like if you hit X amount y amount z amount you get uh ABC bonuses for that product that level of production but you have to be hitting your customer satisfaction targets like passing inspector and you have to be hitting gross profit on those jobs to to access those bonuses for each month.

SPEAKER_00And so that way you can um keep your same team but lower their pay so that it's there they have a lower base rate but they have a lot of upside with bonuses if the business grows.

SPEAKER_01That's a good idea that one is uh that one is a good idea and I we I can also do that with the estimate I I will use the same the same formula for that.

SPEAKER_00Yes yeah and so if you need to you just have a uh hard conversation with those folks the production manager and the salesperson and say hey we have to change what we're doing because right now the business isn't making money if the business goes out of business you lose a job and we all we all lose a job and so we have to starting on this date like let's say 30 days from now we're gonna or maybe 30 or 60 days and the reason why you give the time is that if they change their mind you have time to react and and get somebody else in place or have a plan in place.

SPEAKER_00But say hey 30 or 60 days from now we're gonna change your compensation to this you know it's gonna be a lower base rate however you're gonna have bonus opportunities tied to production volume or to sales volume and customer satisfaction and gross profit. And if you hit those targets each month we'll evaluate it you'll you can get these bonuses uh assuming that you're we're hitting that production volume or that sales volume and that way it's a win-win you're the business is growing and then you're taking part of that uh success with those additional bonuses but if the business doesn't grow I can't support you know that higher salary that you're currently on um and so we'll we'll have to keep it at this lower salary but that way we're all moving in the same direction we all want to grow the business we all want to make customers happy and we all want to do it in a profitable way.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Busy But Broke? How to Fix Cash Flow in Your Painting Business (2027)

    Nov 20, 202632 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail Your painting business can be booked out for weeks and still be short on cash. Bigger sales don’t always mean more money in your pocket. In this episode, I break down why busy painting contractors still...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. How to Scale a Painting Business From $4M to $10M

    Nov 17, 202615 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail If I had to grow a painting business from $4M to $10M today, here's what I'd do. Brandon Pierpont from Painter Marketing Pros and I walk through the money side and the marketing side of the stage where...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. How to Grow Your Painting Business SO Fast in 2027 It Feels ILLEGAL

    Nov 16, 202615 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail Grow your painting business so fast in 2027 it feels illegal. Learn the exact checks I use to fix pricing, job margins, lead response and cash flow before you spend more on leads. Know Your Numbers &...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. How a $50M Contractor Wins Jobs Without Being the Cheapest

    Nov 12, 202630 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail Painting contractors can raise prices 5-10% with a guarantee and keep their close rate about the same. Randy Hurtado of the Good Contractors List and I show how. If you want to raise prices in your...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Why Painting Businesses Get Stuck at $1.5M (And How to Reach $4M)

    Nov 11, 202652 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail If I had to grow a painting business from $1.5M to $4M today, here's what I'd do. Brandon Pierpont from Painter Marketing Pros and I walk through the money side and the marketing side of the stage we...

    Credit the people on this episode