This Painting Business Owner's 10% Discount Is Quietly Killing His $1.7M Business
20 minAudio
Send us Fan Mail I tear down the real books of a $1.7M painting business that doubled its revenue, while a 10% discount quietly dragged his gross profit. Work with us https://profitablepaintercpa.com/vsl Free Book - Profitable Painter https://profitablepaintercpa.com/book In this episode, I open the real financial statements of a swamp-stage painting business (owner anonymized - we'll call him Tony). Tony runs a painting business in Illinois doing about $1.7M a year, and he's aiming for $2.5M in the next 12 months. The impressive part: he's nearly doubled revenue year over year, takes a 50% deposit, and his cash flow is genuinely strong. The problem: a 10% sign-on-the-spot discount has been quietly eating his margin. I'll walk through his cash flow statement, the discount math, the exact salesperson commission plan that protects gross profit, and what has to happen in the next 3-6 months before he scales. Compare these numbers to your own business as we go. I'm Daniel Honan, CPA and former painting business owner. Since 2016, my firm, Profitable Painter CPA, has helped 529+ painting contractors with bookkeeping, taxes, payroll, automations, and financial strategy. WHAT YOU'LL LEARN - How a small "sign today" discount can quietly compound into a double-digit gross profit gap - Why doubling your revenue can hide a ratio that makes growth unaffordable - The deposit and unearned revenue setup keeping this business cash-strong despite thin margins - A salesperson commission structure that rewards profitable jobs, not just closed ones - Why straight commission quietly trains salespeople to discount, and what to do instead - A way to raise prices that most customers never notice - The two balance sheet numbers that reveal trouble even when the bank account looks fine - The test I use to decide if a business is ready to scale and how long it takes to pass 🎯 Want this kind of teardown on YOUR numbers? That's what we do - we are a Painter‑only CPA firm. Book a free call: https://profitablepaintercpa.com/vsl WHO I AM My name is Daniel Honan. I'm a CPA, a former painting business owner, and the founder of Profitable Painter CPA - an accounting firm that works exclusively with painting contractors. I make these podcasts to help painters keep more of what they earn and build more profitable businesses. Subscribe for weekly podcasts on taxes, bookkeeping, accounting, and financial strategy for painting businesses. Keywords: painting business, painting contractors, financial teardown, real business financials, painting business discount, sign today discount, gross profit margin painting, markup vs margin, GP to CAC ratio, customer acquisition cost, salesperson commission structure, sales commission tied to gross profit, salesperson compensation plan, hiring a salesperson, unearned revenue deposits, current ratio small business, negative equity small business, Profitable Painter This episode was originally recorded as a video for YouTube. If you hear me say things like “in this video” or reference visuals, don’t worry - the content still works perfectly in audio form. And if you ever want to watch the video version, you can find it on the Profitable Painter YouTube channel. https://www.youtube.com/@BookkeepingForPainters
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_00In this video, I'm tearing down the real financial statements of a painting business doing about$1.7 million a year in revenue. The owner wants to grow to$2.5 million in the next 12 months. He hired a production manager. He also tried to hire a salesperson, but it did not work out. And he has struggled with gross profit in the past. So is this business ready to grow? Or will more sales pull it deeper into the swamp? Let's look at the numbers. If you clicked on this video, you may want answer to these three questions. Is this business reaching its new 50% gross profit goal?
SPEAKER_00Does it make enough profit to pay the managers it actually needs? Can the owner reach$2.5 million without doing too much himself? We'll use the company's real numbers to answer these questions. By the end, you can compare this business to your own. If we haven't met, I'm Daniel Honan. I'm a CPA and former painting business owner. I've helped over 500 painting businesses from startup to 20 million in sales, know their numbers, and save big in tax. I break down businesses into four financial stages: startup, build, the swamp, and sellable asset.
SPEAKER_00In each video, I open the books of a real painting business from one stage. For this teardown, we're looking at the swamp. That means the business makes between$1 million and$3 million a year. Alex Ramosi coined the term the swamp, and the business now has a lot of moving parts. It needs good sales and operations managers. But it may not make enough profit to pay for great people. That leaves the owner stuck in the middle. The owner must lead the company. But they may still need to sell jobs, manage work, and solve daily problems. The goal at this stage is not to just get more sales.
SPEAKER_00The business needs enough profit to build a strong team. Let's call this owner Tony. Tony runs a painting business in Illinois. I removed his real name and any details that could show who he actually is. Tony's business does about$1.7 million a year. He wants to grow to$2.5 million in the next 12 months. Tony leads the company. He also handles some of the sales. And a few months ago, Tony hired a production manager. And last month he tried to hire a salesperson. However, that hire did not work out. Tony also has an overseas admin who helps with office work.
SPEAKER_00Tony has struggled with gross profit in the past, but now he has committed to reaching a 50% gross profit margin. At 50% gross profit, the business keeps 50 cents from each sales dollar after paying for direct costs on the job. That gross profit must pay for project manager, admin, salesperson, and all the other overhead. You must also leave a profit for Tony. And this is what makes this stage so hard. Tony needs more help to grow, but the business needs strong gross profit to pay for that help. These facts give us the right questions to ask.
SPEAKER_00Has Tony started to fix his gross profit? Can the business afford its current team? Can it afford another salesperson? Is this company making enough cash to fund its growth? And will growing to 2.5 million make Tony's life easier or create more problems? Let's open the financial statements and find out. All right, when I'm first looking at the financials, I first want to identify what is the constraint of the business. And this is using the theory of constraints developed by Mr. Goldrat in the 1980s. Basically, the business is going to grow till it hits a certain constraint, and then the business will flatline in revenue until you fix that constraint.
SPEAKER_00So there's one thing holding this business back at this time. So that's why I first want to identify. So first I always go to the bank balance. As I say, cash is king. We want to make sure we have enough cash in the business to continue operations in a safe manner. So right now, this business has$107,000 in the bank. And what I do is compare that to its overhead costs. So if we go down to total expenses, our total expenses, aka overhead was$347,000 for the first eight months of the year from January 1 to August 30th.
SPEAKER_00We divide that by eight. And so we have an average overhead spend of$43,000 per month. And we want to have two months of overhead cost as cash in the bank. So if we multiply that by two, we get$86,000. So this is the cash minimum we want at any point in time. And so right now they do have that cash minimum of$107,000. So we're good from that perspective. I just want to do one more check to make sure that they have decent cash flow. And so I'll look at this statement of cash flows here for the first eight months, same time period.
SPEAKER_00And basically the statement of cash flows looks at where the cash went. So if you ever have a question like, I'm making all this profit, but I don't have much cash in the bank, the statement of cash flows can tell you where the cash went. So it starts off with the net income and then it increases or reduces based off of the actual cash coming in and out. The big thing that jumps out to me here is the 127,000 increase from unearned revenue. So Tony has his books on the modified accrual approach, meaning that when he receives a deposit for work to be completed, he doesn't automatically include that deposit as revenue.
SPEAKER_00He includes it as unearned revenue. And then when the job is done, he'll record all of the revenue at that point. So he has$127,000 worth of deposits or unearned revenue. And that has really helped him maintain a positive cash position. So net cash from operating activities is the main number I'm looking at here. And his business is generating cash,$205,000 in the first eight months based off of$80,000 of net income. And a lot of that is thanks to the fact that he's taking a really strong deposit. He's taking 50% deposit.
SPEAKER_00So kudos to Tony for taking that higher deposit and maintaining solid cash flow. Then the next section here is financing activities. The thing that I really take a look at is how much is business owner actually taking out? And at this point, he's only taking out about$70,000 based off of net income. He's actually taking less out of the business than what the business is profiting. So he is good to go from my perspective. If he was taking out a lot more in cash, that would be a little bit concerning because one, he might be hit with a 357 gain on his taxes and actually have paid capital gains on that excess distribution. And then two, he might not be leaving enough money in the business for the business to operate.
SPEAKER_00So overall, his statement of cash flows looks pretty solid. So he has over two months of cash in the bank, and the business is generating cash from operating activities, mainly due to the fact he's taking a higher deposit and things look good to go there. So his constraint is not a cash constraint. He does not have a policy or behavior constraint. So we can eliminate that as a constraint of the business. The next piece that we look at is his supply constraint. Does he have enough of a team to produce the work? And so I know after talking to him and also looking at the unarmed revenue that they're booked out about four weeks, which is borderline too far out.
SPEAKER_00But you know, three to four weeks is kind of the sweet spot of where you want to stay in terms of being booked out. So we look good there. He also has an admin that's doing speed to lead, so he's able to answer or get back to leads within three minutes. And then the last piece is sales. So right now he is doing all of the sales at this moment. He has tried to hire a salesperson in the past, but that didn't work out. So now he's doing all the sales and they're on track to do 1.7 million. Well, they've done 1.7 million on the rolling 12, but they could do as high as 2 million this year if they fix a constraint as soon as possible.
SPEAKER_00And their constraint is really the owner is doing all the sales, and he's having a hard time getting out to the job site within three days when someone requests an estimate. So that is the main constraint of this business right now. All right, so now that we know the constraint, let's dive into the financials. So looking at the first eight months here, January 1 through August 31st, compared to the first eight months of the previous year, they have done an amazing job of growing very quickly. So we're at just under 1.3 million in revenue compared to last year at the same time. They're at 672,000. They've nearly doubled their revenue this year compared to last.
SPEAKER_00So that's amazing growth. The next piece I look at is gross profit. So gross profit has actually grown faster than revenue. Gross profit has grown 155%. So not only have they almost doubled in revenue, but they've grown gross profit even faster. So that tells me that they are actually getting more efficient, more profitable year over year. And so their gross profit is at 33%. So not as high as I'd like it to be for a residential repaint company, but they still are moving in the right direction.
SPEAKER_00So that gives me really good feeling for them. Plus, they've doubled. So they're doing something right. So when we look at gross profit, we always want to put that gross profit number in context with their second highest cost, which the first highest cost is the cost of goods sold, right? Producing the actual work is usually the biggest cost of the business. The second biggest cost is usually customer acquisition costs. And this is the cost that has to acquire a new customer. So this is marketing and sales. So if we look at first marketing here, we can see that marketing spent is about just under 11% of revenue.
SPEAKER_00And then if we scroll down, we can see that he also has tried to pay a salesperson for a bit of time, but it's only 0.5%. So he's been doing most of the sales for most of the year. So we're gonna still use a plug number of 8% because we want to capture the full amount of what you would pay a full-time salesperson through an entire year, which is typically around 8% of what they close. So we're gonna use a plug number of 8% for the salesperson since he's been doing it and we don't see it on the profit and loss here. To calculate the cost to acquire customers, we take the marketing spend, which is 10.97, plus the plug number of 8% for a salesperson since he's mostly been doing it for the year, and we get customer acquisition costs of 18.97.
SPEAKER_00Now we want to compare customer acquisition costs to gross profit. So we take the 33.02 divided by 18.97 and get a 1.74 to 1 ratio. So basically, we put$1 into customer acquisition and we're getting$1.74 out in the form of gross profit. And this is low. This is something we definitely want to fix before trying to scale too hard because that's not a very good ratio. That's not leaving a lot of room to cover other overhead and profit.
SPEAKER_00And if we go down to the net operating line here, we can see that net operating income is only about 6%. So not as high as we'd like it to be. Right now, this painting business owner is taking a salary of 1.25. So they're only netting about seven and a half percent going to them, what we call discretionary earnings, cash flow to owner. Based off of his roles, we would really want him to be 15% if he was completely passive on the beach, sipping a corona. His team is running the entire business, he'd have to do anything, he should be getting 15%. Then he's also doing sales, so that's another 8%, like we said.
SPEAKER_00And then on top of that, usually the leader of the organization gets somewhere around 3% or so. So we would really want him to be about 26% going to him as the owner. So we're about 20 percentage points off of that target. So there's a lot of work to be done. And most of the work that needs to be done is really on improving gross profit. He's done some improvement to gross profit over the past year, but it still needs to get a bit better. I'd like to see him closer to 50%. That'd really be my target is 50%. So ensuring that he is doubling labor and materials to get a proper markup, 100% markup, so that he's shooting for that 50% gross profit.
SPEAKER_00Now, after speaking with him, one of the things that we identified that was kind of holding him back was he was doing the proper markup, but he was doing a discounting. So he would often offer a 10% discount if the customers signed up right then and there, and sometimes even carry that over if they signed up the next week. So that's 10% right off the top, which significantly impacted his gross profit, as we can see. So he's committed to adjusting his pricing so that one, he's not offering those discounts as much, but then two, if he does offer a discount, that he actually increases the markup a bit so it can absorb that discount.
SPEAKER_00So this is really the biggest thing that I want Tony to focus on is getting gross profit closer to 50%. Because if we're at 50% and we have 18% for customer acquisition, that gets us closer to that three to one GP to cap ratio that we really want to maintain. It's actually a little bit under it still. We really need to be at 54% to have that three to one ratio. However, what I'm thinking is going to happen is if he shoots for that 50%, his revenue is going to go up as a proportion to customer acquisition cost. So customer acquisition costs will actually go down a bit.
SPEAKER_00So I think he'll end up landing somewhere around 16% for customer acquisition. And so he should be attaining that three to one ratio because he'll probably land about 48% for gross profit and 16% for customer acquisition. All right, so that's the number one issue that I'm seeing with the financials. Let's take a look at the other pieces here. So we also have recruiting, it's under 1%. He's been recruiting hard to hire a project manager, which he got in place, but he's also looking for a salesperson. So we'll talk about how to compensate a salesperson at this stage. Uh looking at the other costs here, auto expenses are under 2%, which we usually see 2% to 3% for auto expenses.
SPEAKER_00So that doesn't look too bad. Then we look at merchant service fees are at 2.6%. So it's a little on the higher end. He's taking a lot of credit cards, processing a lot of credit cards. And so one of the things that he I recommended that he actually do is to pass that fee along to his customers. And that's a way to increase prices without really increasing prices. You're basically saying, hey, you can pay with a credit card, it's just a three and a half percent convenience fee. And make sure you check your state laws because that does matter state by state to make sure you're not breaking that law.
SPEAKER_00All right, so let's take a look at the rest here. If we go down to wages for overhead positions, we have salesperson that didn't make it, and then the production manager, which who is relatively new, has only been with the company for a few months, is at 1.17. And then off the office person has been with them for a few months as well, is under 1%. So no real concerns with overcompensation here. We really the big concern is actually just getting Tony some help so he actually can do his job and focus on what he needs to do. All right, and then all the other costs here are relatively low.
SPEAKER_00So let's talk about compensating a salesperson since that's the big thing that's really constraining the business at this point. So, usually, like I said earlier, you want to keep compensation to a salesperson around 8% of what they close. However, I typically don't like doing straight commission because it could incentivize discounting, which we've seen with Tony's business already that discounting has been an issue because he's been shooting for 50%, but then he's doing a 10% discount if they sign up on the spot, which is really eating into his margins. So we don't want to incentivize discounting by just paying a commission off of what they close.
SPEAKER_00Ideally, we want to tie the commission to gross profit. That way, the salesperson is motivated to close not only jobs, just close jobs, but actually close profitable jobs. So, one way you can do this is do a split between straight commission and a bonus based off of where the job lands in terms of gross profit. So, usually what works is do a three to three and a half percent straight commission. So if they book a$10,000 job right off the bat in the next payroll cycle, they'll get three and a half percent of$10,000, so$350.
SPEAKER_00Then you do job costing, so you job cost each job, tracking how much materials were spent, how much labor was spent on the job, and subtract that from that$10,000 to see where the gross profit landed. Now, since we're shooting for a 50% gross profit margin, we want to give a bonus if the salesperson sells a profitable job that actually hits that 50% target. And so if he does hit that 50% target, we will give him an additional 1% commission off the total sales price. So instead of 3.5% commission, he will now be at 4.5%.
SPEAKER_00So 4.5% commission if he hits at or above 50% gross profit. But we don't want to stop there, we want to put some stretch goals in there. So also add a commission bonus for a 55% gross profit, and that's an additional percentage point as well. So if the job comes in at 55% or higher, then we're gonna give another percentage point, which will get the salesperson up to five and a half percent commission. And then finally, we'll do a third one for 60% gross profit. So if the job comes in at 60% gross profit, we'll give another commission point to get to six and a half percent commission.
SPEAKER_00And so the salesperson can make up to six and a half percent commission. And this structure protects the owner, Tony, from the salesperson just selling jobs and then discounting heavily and really hurting the gross profit because he's really incentivized to get those additional bonus points for some profitable jobs. All right, so just to sum up profitability here, the big takeaway is the GP to CAC ratio is 1.7 to one, and that needs to be a minimum of three to one. So we won't really want to start aiming for at least 50% and make sure that the salesperson pay compensation is tied to that goal and that we're bonusing based off of gross profit.
SPEAKER_00Those are the two things I want to focus on for from a profitability. Now let's take a look at liquidity. So liquidity is your ability to pay debt in the short term. So looking at the balance sheet here, have$107,000 in cash, which again is more than two months of overhead cost as cash in the bank, which is great. Then they do have some accounts receivable. Total current assets are at$181,000. Now let's compare that to total current liabilities. Current liabilities include the liabilities for accounts payable, the business credit card, some payroll liabilities, and unearned revenue.
SPEAKER_00Remember, we talked about unearned revenue, is basically the deposits that he has down that haven't been produced yet. So those deposits for the work that we haven't produced yet. And then total liabilities is about$228,000 compared to our current assets of$181. So we have below a one-to-one ratio. So even though cash is in a decent place, we're still a little weak on our current ratio, which is current liabilities compared to current assets. Because the whole idea with this ratio, the current ratio, is that we should be able to liquidate our assets, our current assets, and pay off our current liabilities.
SPEAKER_00And so we want at least a one-to-one ratio. We're a little bit below that. So liquidity is okay. It's not great, it's not terrible. It's okay. I'd really like to see a little bit more cash so we could pay down some of those current liabilities and get that one-to-one ratio. The next piece we look at is solvency. So solvency is long-term debt. How much long-term debt do we have? Or what are the chances that we can pay off that long-term debt and be squared away from a solvency perspective? So when we take a look at long-term debt, we have total long-term liabilities of about$12,000, which is not too bad.
SPEAKER_00But the big thing here is that equity is a bit negative. So basically, we have more liabilities than we have assets. So that's a little concerning. So solvency is not in a great place right now. But the basic solution is to increase profitability, increase cash, use some of that cash to pay down some liabilities. So no change to what we really need to do, what we really need to focus on, which again is get that three to one GP to CAC ratio going. Bring on a salesperson that has compensation tied to gross profit.
SPEAKER_00All right, to sum it up, I think what Tony really needs to focus on before striving for that$2.5 million goal is to get that GP to CAC ratio, improve the pricing, and ensure that we're hitting about 50% gross profit. So we can see a three to one ratio between gross profit and customer acquisition costs. And then once we can establish that we're doing that consistently over the next three to six months, then we can start hitting the gas and scaling to 2.5 million. The secondary piece is we also need to get a new salesperson in so that Tony actually has time to do all the things that he needs to do.
SPEAKER_00Because right now, the business growth is constrained on the fact that he can't be everywhere at once, right? So we need to hire that salesperson, but make sure when we compensate that salesperson, it's tied to gross profit. So we're not just incentivizing that salesperson to discount and close deals. Hopefully, this video was helpful in understanding what it looks like in a painting business that's in the swamp that's between$1 million and$3 million in revenue. In the next video, I'm going through a painting business's financials that's in the next stage, which is the sellable asset stage. So I'll see you next video.
Send us Fan Mail Your painting business can be booked out for weeks and still be short on cash. Bigger sales don’t always mean more money in your pocket. In this episode, I break down why busy painting contractors still...
Send us Fan Mail If I had to grow a painting business from $4M to $10M today, here's what I'd do. Brandon Pierpont from Painter Marketing Pros and I walk through the money side and the marketing side of the stage where...
Send us Fan Mail Grow your painting business so fast in 2027 it feels illegal. Learn the exact checks I use to fix pricing, job margins, lead response and cash flow before you spend more on leads. Know Your Numbers &...
Send us Fan Mail Painting contractors can raise prices 5-10% with a guarantee and keep their close rate about the same. Randy Hurtado of the Good Contractors List and I show how. If you want to raise prices in your...
Send us Fan Mail If I had to grow a painting business from $1.5M to $4M today, here's what I'd do. Brandon Pierpont from Painter Marketing Pros and I walk through the money side and the marketing side of the stage we...