Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Professional Learnings NSWPPA Educational Leadership

Professional Learnings NSWPPA Educational Leadership artwork

A Continuum, Not a Label: Rethinking Growth Mindset for Leaders (The Lead Learner, Part 3 of 4, with James Anderson)

Nov 18, 202637 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Is a student fixed mindset or growth mindset? In this episode of The Lead Learner, educational leadership author James Anderson argues that is the wrong question. Speaking with NSWPPA's Drew Janetzki, James reframes mindset as a continuum, not a label, and shows school leaders why where a learner is matters far more than who a label says they are. James unpacks the difference between challenge and adversity (the only difference is the source), why a fixed mindset can turn students into victims of their circumstances while a growth mindset says "I cannot do this yet, but I can become the person who can", and how agency sits at the centre of it all. In this conversation you will hear: Why "are they fixed or growth?" is a label that stops development, and what to ask instead. Challenge versus adversity, and why both push a learner into the same growth zone. "It is where you are, not who you are": mindset as a position on a continuum you can move along. What this means for how leaders talk about students, and about themselves. Guest: James Anderson, speaker and author on learnership and growth mindset. His book, Learnership: Raising the Status of Learning from an Act to an Art in Your School, is at https://www.jamesanderson.com.au/product/learnership/ More on his work, including a free Learner Agency masterclass and resources, at https://www.jamesanderson.com.au About the show: The Lead Learner is produced by the NSW Primary Principals' Association as part of our Professional Learning suite. Find out more at https://www.nswppa.org.au/professional-learning Links and References: To view our Professional Learning Offerings, visit: https://www.nswppa.org.au/professional-learning To view our latest offerings, visit: https://www.nswppa.org.au/catalogue

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Drew Janetzki (host)Welcome to Professional Learnings for Educational Leaders from the New South Wales Primary Principals Association. This is part three of The Lead Learner with James Anderson. Last time, James made the case that learning is a skill and asked who in your school is actually developing it. Today we turn to mindset, and James argues that asking whether a student is fixed or growth is the wrong question. Mindset, he says, is a continuum, not a label.

Drew Janetzki (host)Here is James. Okay, and welcome back to episode three. Welcome back, James.

SPEAKER_01Oh thanks, Drew. It has been so much fun having these other podcasts with you. I'm looking forward to this one about mindset.

Drew Janetzki (host)So am I, yes. You beat me to it. Mindset, and let's go to what actually is mindset. I'll preface with a question, and we when we think of mindset, uh, there's so many way ways to in which we could we could go in this. A lot of the work of Carol Dweck comes to mind with with growth mindset, and but most people know Carol Dreck's work, and she talks about fixed mindset versus growth mindset.

Drew Janetzki (host)Most people, James, most people know Carol Dreck's work as fixed versus a growth mindset mindset. How is your work different?

SPEAKER_01Look, uh, I think when we a lot of a lot of you listeners will hear that we're talking about mindset and we'll be reaching for the let's skip this episode because we've done mindset, we know all about it. And I'd ask them to pause just for a minute because what we did 10, 15 years ago, 20 years ago now, when Carol Dweck first sort of let the world know about mindset, was that she had done lots of research. Let's be really clear about this. This is not, you know, positive thinking stuff. She had lots of research that showed that people with a fixed mindset, and these are the people that would sort of look at themselves and say, This is me, get used to it.

SPEAKER_01Person I am today is going to be the person I am in five years' time. When you see yourself like that, your fundamental abilities are fixed, um, they tended not to grow as much. They tended to protect themselves, they tended to, you know, dislike mistakes, all those sort of things. Whereas people with a growth mindset, people who said, This is me today, but I change. I become the person I want or need to be in the world, they tended to uh grow more and have more success in the world. And she published her work as fixed versus growth.

SPEAKER_01And it was important work and it was groundbreaking work, and there's no doubt that we've got big, big, big data sets that says it makes a difference to student learning outcomes. What it did though is schools picked it up and said, Oh, this is obviously important, and we did what is the most natural thing in the world for teachers to do. And we taught it. We told kids this is fixed, this is growth, do this. Like we put the poster up on the wall.

Drew Janetzki (host)Again, with good intentions throughout our series, all of these educational paradigms to be put onto it is trying to actually yes, let's let's enhance this great work. Yeah, absolutely. It makes sense. It does.

SPEAKER_01But the problem was that what Carol Dreck was talking about were belief systems that people had built up over years and years and years of their life. And you don't change them by putting a poster on the wall and saying, start loving mistakes, start thinking if it's a good thing. And so the mistake we made to start with was to say that you know there were two to start with, and to say we could adopt one. We can't adopt a growth mindset. So what we needed to do was rather than teach about mindsets, was we needed to work out how to teach for mindsets.

SPEAKER_01And Carol Dweck's recognised this in the last five years or so, where she said that there's no doubt that the work's important, but we never realize the complexity of implementation. And the key difference, and one of the things that I bring to it, is to recognize that we need to not tell kids about mindsets. In fact, I suggest to the schools I work with, don't mention the term mindset. Like you don't need to tell kids what fixed and growth mindset are. There's some research that says that helps. But if you ban it, if you say to your teachers, I want you to develop a growth mindset in your students without ever mentioning the term, it means they've got to do it in a way that's not teaching about it, it's teaching for it.

Drew Janetzki (host)That makes sense. And and going back to her work, it seems like you're either in the you're either the growth mindset person, which is the irony here, is that's a fixed state, but anyway, you're a growth mindset person or you're a fixed mindset. And that seemed to be what can't be there's no in-between here of that work. So I'm curious in terms of the four, as you mentioned, in terms of what that actually could or should look like. Yeah. Yeah.

SPEAKER_01So and then that was the other part about the work. When Carol Dweck introduced it to the world, she rightly simplified it. She rightly said, you know, this is what it's all about. And she described the fixed and the growth mindset. All her research, though, doesn't define people as two camps. She defines them along a continuum. But to introduce the world to it, she talked about the ends of the continuum to make the point, which is really good for understanding mindsets. But for changing mindsets, you need a continuum.

SPEAKER_01You need to recognize the middle ground. Because no one, no one in the world has a fixed mindset. There's no one in the world going, this is me, I never changed, I've never learned anything, everything came pre-installed. Like there's no one like that. And there's no one going, I can achieve anything. Like I can, you know, be infinitely flexible. No one's doing that. We all think we have some limitation, there's points where we give up and all the rest of it. So the question is not do you have a fixed or growth mindset? The question is to ask, how growth-oriented am I? And that changes the work we do in schools because when you realize that your success with growth mindsets isn't going to be measured by the number of kids with a growth mindset.

SPEAKER_01It's going to be measured by how much more growth-oriented they become. Then it changes the nature of the work. And the other impact that this sort of fixed growth thing had is that we told teachers it was two. And you know, fixed mindset teachers, oh, they're they're they're a problem, you know. Those those fixed mindset teachers, they'll judge their kids, they'll categorize them, they'll label them, you know, they're they're they're terrible. Growth mindset teachers, they're awesome. They're the other, you know, and then we said to teachers, which one have you got? And every teacher rightly said, Well, I haven't got a fixed mindset.

SPEAKER_01And if I haven't got a fixed mindset, if there's only one option, I must have a growth. And what that did is it meant that good teachers, well-intentioned teachers, went into their classrooms with an unexamined mindset. And this produced what Carol Dweck and her colleague Susan Mackey, who's in Melbourne, describe as a false mindset. And what happened is that, you know, strategies like praise effort turned into praise struggling students for effort.

SPEAKER_01And what actually happened in a classroom is that, you know, I'd come up to you and go, hey Drew, keep up the hard work. You're good to see you. Here's some formative feedback. Keep going. It's good to see you working so hard. Exactly the sort of thing you'd want. But then I'd turn to Michelle next to you and say, Well done, Michelle, that's beautiful work and move on. And what I just said to both of you was that hard work was necessary for some, but what I really valued was performance. And we're actually pushing kids towards the fixed end of the continuum with that.

SPEAKER_01So when we look talk about mindset today, I think it's important to recognize that the the fix and growth was important for understanding the what. The continuum was important for understanding the how. And our goal is about moving students towards an increasingly growth-oriented mindset.

Drew Janetzki (host)Yeah. And it's important to have that preface and again acknowledging the work of Carol Tweck that many of our listeners would know. And Lawrence, it's around the implementation, though, James, and how going forward, what would you like our listeners to really take away from our discussion to in today's podcast on mindset?

SPEAKER_01I think the key is to recognize that your mindset is the sum total of all these messages that you accumulate through your life. Some of them send you towards the fixed end of the continuum where you're told, you know, some people are just different. Yeah, some people are like that. And some push you towards the growth end of the continuum. So where you can always build new abilities, you can always grow. And our schools, our classrooms, our communities are full of these messages. And what we need to do is to make sure in the environment we control as school leaders, we fill our schools, we fill our classrooms with the growth-oriented messages.

SPEAKER_01So more and more of these messages push kids towards the growth end.

Drew Janetzki (host)So I'm listening now as a principal, and I'm curious to what you've said and agree with what you have said. Where do I go now listening as a as a principal, curious about this topic we're talking about in mindset?

SPEAKER_01Well, you could pick up the book learnership and the the second section talks all about uh mindset there. Um look the problem we have when we start as leaders looking for it is we see the world through our own mindset, all right, through our own biases. And that that's not a negative thing. You know, we were talking pre-show, Drew, about um uh Carol Dweck's work and uh you know Carol Dweck's work is founded on stereotype bias and how stereotypes you know build certain expectations and so forth.

SPEAKER_01And as a as a child, look, yeah, I'll tell you my story. I mean, you know, where do your beliefs come from? This is what you've got to do. You've got to look at your current mindset, honestly, and go, well, actually, I'm a little bit fixed. Maybe not a lot fixed, but a little bit fixed. And so, well, why do I think that? Why do I think that some people are like this and other people couldn't do that? And look, you know, I grew up in a family where um, you know, we all had our own identities. Um I'll tell a story. Yeah, the the messages we get from school. Some of your listeners have perhaps heard me uh tell this story before, but it'll be new to many of them.

SPEAKER_01And and it speaks to where we get our mindsets from. I was uh year seven student, yeah, new school, independent boys' school, short haircut, all the rest of it.

Drew Janetzki (host)And uh Were you a good student, James? I can imagine you oh you you I've interjected. Let's see. Let's see what type of if I'm doing a bit of a a mindset myself, aren't I? Yeah. So let's let's go back to year seven.

SPEAKER_01Well, I was trying to work out how it all worked, because secondary school was different, like you know, and I'd been to the maths classroom and the maths classroom was row upon row upon tables with a blackboard up the front, and yes, you some of you listeners won't know what a blackboard is, but it's like a whiteboard on to dark mode. Um with chalk and everything. Yeah, chalk and everything. Um but then I went to the English lesson, and it was a bit the same, row upon row upon tables, but with English and language and stuff around the classroom. And I went to my first ever music lesson, and I never had a music lesson in primary school, like with a music teacher in a music room.

SPEAKER_01It wasn't something we'd had. So I didn't know quite what to expect. And I rocked up to this class, and the first thing we had to go like across the road. Like it was an entirely different building, so obviously something very different. And uh I got there, and uh the teacher who had a ponytail, that was a whole other story.

Drew Janetzki (host)Um Mindset C coming through. There you go.

SPEAKER_01Believe uh we walked through the door, and the first thing I noticed, not row upon row up on tables, we had three drum kits in the middle of the room, waiting for kids to use them. One row of tables sideways down the side of the classroom, and on the other side of the classroom, all these bongos. I'm sort of looking around going, what is this? Within five minutes of the class starting, you know, the three kids that are rushed to the drum kits are going boom, ch boom, ch boom, chuck this. The kids on the bongo are going bang, bang, bang, bang, bang, bang, bang, bang.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, and what do 11-year-old boys do when they're given drumsticks? Like they're smacking each other on their head and going on. It was noisy, it was energetic. It was an 11-year-old boy heaven. Like, I was fantastic. I did say halfway through this class, I'm going, this is me. Like, I I I I don't need to be a musician, I can be a drummer. Like, this is my future in front of me. This is, you know, I am switched on, I'm engaged, I'm exactly the student every teacher wants in their classroom. Like, I'm give me more, give me more, give me more. Don't talk to me, I want to listen to the teacher.

SPEAKER_01Like, yeah, I'm I'm all there. And uh I I can't stress enough just how switched on to this classroom I was. Anyway, we got to the end of the lesson, and the teacher goes, Boys, before you go, I just want to see who can do this. Now, I'll pause there for a second. He could have said, I want to see who's learnt enough by now to be able to do this and who's got more to learn, but he didn't. He said, I want to see who can. It's a test.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. Anyway, do you remember the ta-tar t tee's?

Drew Janetzki (host)Yes, I do.

SPEAKER_01He put up these rhythms on the board. He said, Right, on your left hand, I want you to go ta ta t. Ta ta t tee on the table. I'm clapping. On your right hand, I want you to do the opposite. I want you to go t tee ta ta. T T. He said, I'll count you in. And he goes, one, two, three, four. And 30 years, seven boys went and there's bam, snapping all around. No one could do it. We had a laugh and we went. Anyway, I wouldn't be frustrated.

SPEAKER_01I thought, I don't want to be able to do this. So I went home and I flipped out the computer paper on the kitchen bench.

Drew Janetzki (host)You were wow, you were really motivated.

SPEAKER_01I was like, I went home to work it out. And you know, I I marked the the line down the middle of the paper, top of the paper was for my left hand, the bottom paper was the right hand, like it was all the rest of it. Worked out, there had to be a pattern. Like, oh no, pattern, what's the pattern here? Spent ages, made mistakes, had to work out how to do it. Eventually worked it out. I saw the teacher in the yard the next day, day after, and and I rushed after him and said, Sir, sir, sir, is this what you asked us to do? And I'm not sure if the mic's gonna pick this up, but we'll give it a crack. Okay, go for it. Um I said, Sir, is this what the way it works?

SPEAKER_01And I Okay, James is clicking. No, no, I'm gonna do it with my legs. Okay. One, two, three, four. He goes, You can applaud me, Drew.

Drew Janetzki (host)Oh, that is one. That is so for those listeners, if we haven't picked up, he was doing ta ta chi chi ta ta chi chi. He was doing the actual rhythm. And and what was the response from the teacher? I'm hoping there was a lot of praise.

SPEAKER_01The the teacher, like he said, I slid up. He said, James, that's amazing. Not many people, that's a fantastic, well done. How did you do it? And I told him about going home, and I told him about the paper, and I told him about the time, and I told him about the mistakes, and he went, Oh. So you can't really do it then. Oh, ouch. Yeah. See, in his mind, there were people who could just do it, and other people who had to work hard instead. That did that? Yeah. People with natural ability, people who could fake it, but you know, work hard instead.

SPEAKER_01I was very quickly put in the category of had to work hard. Where do you reckon I sat in the next c next uh lesson?

Drew Janetzki (host)Yeah, you weren't you your motivation would have completely It's gone. Yeah.

SPEAKER_01There was no point in me trying. So the teacher worked really hard to make it interesting and exciting and engaging and all the rest of it. And what did I do? Stuffed around.

Drew Janetzki (host)Because you he uh invalidated your and the and he could have gone in so many so that is the learning moment there of and the mat Now you know this, obviously f speaking as a as a mature adult from that perspective, but that that perspective, I mean, you didn't know what was literally happening and it totally demotivated your uh experience and what happened with music in your world?

Drew Janetzki (host)Did it drop off or did you still have a aspirations in music or where did where did it go?

SPEAKER_01Well it's interesting because what happened next? I I was still trying to work out you know how school worked, like what was this what was life about, what was it going to become, all that sort of stuff. And what happened next is it's important to realise that the story's dramatized a little bit, but that didn't happen in a moment. Other messages added up to help that moment land. Because when I went back to the next lesson, maths lesson, um, the teacher was reading through the role and he goes, James Anderson? James Anderson, are you Canonine's brother?

SPEAKER_01Yeah. He said, Oh, another mathematician in the family, fantastic. I went, Oh, okay, so that's what I am. And so there's the same message. And some of your listeners will be going, Well, that'll never happen at my school. Happens at your school, it happens at your school all the time. Every time, you know, one of the kids turns around and goes, Oh, you're just so good at English, but I'm better at maths. Yeah, and every time a mum leans in and says, Don't worry, sweetheart, your father and I weren't very good at that either.

unknownYeah.

SPEAKER_01Every time, you know, when they're growing up, the you know, have you got your kids through? I don't know. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Yeah. If you try to encourage a three-year-old to do something they didn't want to do, and and you probably said to them, Come on, sweetheart, give it a go. And then you've reached for something to motivate them and you've said, you never know. You might be good at it. And there's this little message that there are things in the world, just like my music teacher, just like the two students sitting next to each other, things in the world that you don't have to put effort into.

SPEAKER_01And now we do it as adults. You know, how many of us as leaders in schools at some point in our you know leadership journey have been the victim of a personality test? Yeah, someone's come and someone's come along with the bubble chart and said, Oh, you're a red L MPT, fantastic. You'll be good at, you're suited to, you're cut out for. And you've said, but I'd really like to be a and they've gone, oh, doesn't line up. Yeah, people like you will find that really deep. People like you. So there's all these messages, and you you see it when you know where to look, you see it all the time.

SPEAKER_01And this is what I was saying that our job as leaders is to fill our school environment with more growth-oriented messages. Because the consequence for me, the question you asked a moment ago, was that you know, my school, independent boys school, we had music programs, we had drama programs, we had school productions, we had bands, we had all that stuff. How many of them did I take advantage of?

Drew Janetzki (host)I'm guessing from that end part of how you spoke about it was zero nothing. There was no the moment passed through and you felt judged and you responded accordingly based on your environment.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. And it wasn't that a spite, it was a logical decision. Like just those choices that the school offered for bands and for musicals and performances and the rest of it, they weren't choices I could make. It's not that I chose not to take them. It's not like I I could do it, but I don't want to. It's that they're not choices that are open to me. And you know, I was having a conversation with a a secondary principal last year, and she was saying that, you know, we we work really hard to offer all these pathways for the kids, and we've invested thousands and thousands of dollars in producing all these new subjects and blah, blah, blah.

SPEAKER_01But the kids are still choosing just these ones. Why? We try to make them interesting, we try to make them engaging, and so that's not the problem. Yeah. It's not that they're not interested, they just don't think the the those options apply to them. And this is the the tragedy of the mindset stuff that when students start the feeling that this is all I can be, their world gets small. And this when we started talking about agency in the episode two, two episodes ago, uh this is how it impacts your agency.

SPEAKER_01That it's not that you don't choose things, it's you think those choices don't apply to you. And I'm I'm all for you know giving kids choice and all the rest of it. But there's a big difference between not getting better at something because you don't want to and not getting better at something because you don't believe you can. Now my music teacher could have said, you know, I want to see who's learned enough to do this and who's got more learning to do before they will be able to do it. I could have said to my daughter, you know, you can be good at anything, but it's not free.

SPEAKER_01So choose whether you want to get good at this or good at something else. That's a choice you've got. But I didn't, because these messages flow out of us from our default. And so when, you know, I I I've spoken about Carl Allen at um Glenview a few times. You know, when I was working around walking around the school with him, and he said, you know, that that's Bob, that's our school motto, be our best. He thought that was a great thing. I said, just think about that for a minute. Do you want kids to be their best?

SPEAKER_01Do you want to define like potential as a fixed amount? Do you want teachers to go around and say look, Drew's Drew's not done really well, but that that's probably the best he can do. That's his best. Do you want to be about bettering your best, about growth and about change?

Drew Janetzki (host)And what you did there is you f reframed that thinking because he was in, you know, that example, Carl was in a fixed mindset because he thought that was a limitation, similar to the discussion we had in a previous podcast where you talked about anti-fragile with uh taking that to a that's actually a really good thing, how you've unpacked that and what that could look like for as a learner.

SPEAKER_01But you know, Carl doesn't have a fixed mindset. But what he was repeating was the patterns that he'd always like he'd heard be your best billion times in his life. And so it was a speech pattern that just came out, and he'd be the first person to say, No, no, no, no, no, that's not what I meant, that's not what I meant. Kids don't hear what you mean, they hear what you say. Yeah. And so, like the differentiation question. Like we know, as particularly as primary teachers, that you know, when we put those kids in that group and those kids in that group and those kids in that group, we're not saying smart kids, average kids, dumb kids.

SPEAKER_01But how many students hear that? All right. One of the messages about um from a growth mindset perspective is that we we don't have ability groupings. All right, we don't in the sense that you know they're the smart kids, they're the average kids and the other kids. We we group students according to where they are at the moment. Yeah, it's a re it's an interesting conversation. I sometimes talk about it.

Drew Janetzki (host)That is a really interesting space because many schools do, and guilty, Your Honor, in that space where we do I can think of uh spelling groups, for example, in my career with you know the the them and the mindset was for the best interest of the learner, so let's segue it into spelling groups. It was a particular time frame, it lasted for 55 minutes, still remember it to this day. And it was a specific program, and everyone is grouped according to ability. And now a sudden and not suddenly, but I reflect on that with this conversation and go, wow, what was that doing for the learner?

SPEAKER_01And and I think this is where the strategies of a moving kids come in, that because we have these inherited patterns, just these defaults that we you know leak out of us every day, but we don't mean it. Like we know we want all the kids to grow. Our kids are in primary school, of course they're gonna get better. You know, no one we don't have any adults out there with grade one spelling. Well, not many, but you know, you know, they're all going to improve. And so what we need to do is we need these little reminders, and I call them nudges. And through learnership, I've got these little QR codes that let you go and explore each of them.

SPEAKER_01And one of the really powerful ones that's so easy to adopt is to attach timestamps to performance. And what that means is that whenever you talk about a standard or a struggle or things like that, you attach it to a moment in time, not to the student. So for example, uh, you don't struggle with maths. You're struggling with maths right now. You don't have high ability groups, you have groups with students at this standard right now, this standard at the moment, and this standard at the moment.

SPEAKER_01But you're all going to improve through your standards. You know, one of the other big ones I tell um schools, and it sort of uh stops a few leaders in their tracks when we say it, is I say, I ask them, you know, do you have high achieving students at your school? And every principal goes, yeah, of course we do. So stop that. I don't want you to have high achieving students at your school. I want you to have students who are achieving highly. Make it about what they do, not who they are. Make it about their actions, not about their identity.

SPEAKER_01And this is what I talk about when I say, look, you know, how do we change students' mindset? And we do that as leaders by filling the environment with more and more of these growth messages and try and have fewer and fewer of the fixed messages. And as they add up over time, students don't suddenly impress challenge and love effort, but they take on a bit more of a challenge. They put in a bit more effort before they say, Oh, not my no worth not worth me doing any more of that.

SPEAKER_01And we nudge, we nourish, we nurture an increasingly growth-oriented mindset in our school. And can I tell you before you ask your next question? You know, I I often, when I visit schools, I I look at the the school's improvement plan, I look at their websites and these sort of things. You would be amazed at the number of fixed messages that are emblazoned in schools' mottos and uh yeah, help every student reach their potential.

SPEAKER_01For Drew, it's a short journey. Um, but you know.

Drew Janetzki (host)But that's it's a fascinating space in terms of what you've just done unpack. And if we go, yes, you you could tell I was leaning into a another question about I guess the work that you unpacked, James, which is so authentic. You you built a growth mindset style to change teachers' messaging. What would a leader's version of that look like? Yeah, look, it's it's the same process.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, I often talk about uh a school's culture is their default way of doing things. In the last episode we talked about, you know, walk through your school and ask how's learning getting done around here. Yeah. Your mindset is your default way of doing things. And so when as a leader, as you're looking for how you're influencing the student's mindset, like the story of Carl we've talked about before, look for your defaults. Look for your, you know, what do you do without having to think about it?

SPEAKER_01And ask hard questions. Yeah, you'll find yourself, I've worked with leaders who go, Well, you know, I'm I'm investing in this person because they've got potential. I'm not investing in James because, you know, there's no potential there. Well, what makes you think that?

Drew Janetzki (host)Yeah, fix again a mindset.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. And you do it with good intent. All right. And look, the I'm conscious of time too, but you know, one of the big things, I'll tell you the the big mindset mover. You know, we project, we influence people around us and that influence their mindset by our beliefs. And our beliefs have been built up by a whole lot of messages. And when we say I'm investing in Drew because he's got lots of potential and not in James because you know he probably doesn't, there's probably an element of truth in there.

SPEAKER_01There's something we've experienced in our life that says, you know, that that's accurate. What I'd encourage you to do is look to the backstories. When I talk about in the book about how we develop a more growth-oriented mindset, is the big mindset mover is to understand the backstory, the development of challenge, the development, sorry, of talents and abilities. And Anders Ericsson wrote the story about this, and it was popularized in books like um Malcolm Gladwell's Outlier and things like that.

SPEAKER_01That you know, that that feel, that body of work basically asked two questions. They said, There are extraordinary people in the world. There's no doubt about it. You look at people and they're they're so talented, they're so amazing, so incredible, they can do things other people can do. Two questions. They said, Were they always that way? They were all beginners. They were all three-year-olds in a play center somewhere doing nothing special. Like, you know. And then the other interesting question was this, because we sort of know that. We sort of know, of course they're all big, it's like everyone's a baby and stuff, but we sort of assume that they were different from the beginning.

SPEAKER_01So the second body of work they asked was to ask: should we have known who those people were? If we trace them back and look at them in their grade two classroom, maybe they weren't the highest achieving student, maybe they weren't the one that started playing piano earliest, maybe they were the what was it? Were they asking more questions? Could they concentrate longer? Did they have a better memory? Like, was there something about us that would allow us to go back into our classroom tomorrow and go, hey true, you know, it's worth investing in you, but you know, in Johnny, we'll we'll put him in the other class.

SPEAKER_01And the answer was no. There was nothing about who you were that predicted where you'd be in the future. What predicted where you'd be in the future was the amount and quality of practice, supportive environment around you, often parents and coaches around you to help you do it. But at the end of the day, it was the amount and quality of practice that allowed you to accumulate those talents and abilities. And once you start digging into that, digging into that backstory of growth, that backstory of improvement, that backstory of, you know, from beginner to middle.

SPEAKER_01And the thing is this that, you know, everyone starts off really ordinary and you get a little bit better and no one cares. And you get a little bit better and no one notices. And you get a little bit better. Really still, no one notices. And you get better and you get better. You go to the practice, you improve to do, and at some, at some point you reach a standard where everyone notices and they go, Wow, that's amazing.

Drew Janetzki (host)You're an overnight success. Sorry I took the words out of your mouth.

SPEAKER_01That's exactly right. And we delete the backstory. And fundamentally, a a difference between a fixed mindset and a growth mindset is someone with a fixed mindset sees that gap as permanent. Someone with a growth mindset sees the journey. You know, they understand that it takes a lot of effort to make something look effortless. And that's one of the sort of lines that we give teachers, you know, easy as earned, these sorts of ideas. That the the when we're talking about primary schools, you know, our kids don't have backstories, significant backstories yet.

SPEAKER_01And the gift we're giving them by filling our environment with growth mindset messages is the understanding of their capacity to build forward stories. And that's where the other part that we talked about last week becomes so important because a growth mindset is the invitation to grow. The growth mindset says, I can change. Learnership says this is how I go about achieving the change. And when, as leaders, we create an environment where the culture is about learning and growth, helping students become skillful learners and understanding that they're capable of growth, then they're unstoppable.

SPEAKER_01That's setting them up to thrive in that future that we've talked about.

Drew Janetzki (host)I just keep going back to that to that story to sort of finish this up with young James in year seven. What advice would you give now to that teacher from your perspective of this knowledge? Well, you probably wouldn't be here. You might be a world-class musician in your in your you could have been. You never know. Who was the most successful artist of the eighties? Who was? Tell us that fun fact.

SPEAKER_01Bill Collins, a drummer. There we go. When you combine his work with Genesis with his solo work, most successful artist of the 80s. That could have been me. Could have been. Well, what's stopping you, James? Well, that's interesting because today I understand. I understand I can build musical abilities. In fact, musical abilities of all abilities is one of our best understood pathways to talent and ability. How well do you reckon I play drums today?

Drew Janetzki (host)I don't know. How well do you play drums today? You don't at all, too. Not at all. No, not at all.

SPEAKER_01And see, that's the thing. Today I make the choice. Today I know I've got a limited amount of time and energy. I can't be good at everything. I don't live long enough to be good at everything. So I've got to choose to invest my effort in certain areas. And I do choose to develop my abilities in what we're doing right now and understanding learning and growth and helping leaders change schools. And I choose not to develop my skills in music because I know how much time and effort that's going to take, and I don't want to spend it.

SPEAKER_01But today I have that choice.

Drew Janetzki (host)Yeah.

SPEAKER_01When I was seven years, 11 years old in year seven, I didn't think that choice was open to me. And that brings us back to that whole agency piece.

Drew Janetzki (host)Yeah.

SPEAKER_01Like I said, there's a big difference between not getting better at something because you don't want to and not getting better at something because you don't believe you can. When we're talking about building agency in the world, you know, challenge is going to come along. And someone with a fixed mindset, when it comes along, looks inside themselves and says, Can I? Do I have the abilities? And when the answer is no, they've got nothing left. Then they're the victim of their circumstances. Someone with a growth mindset, the challenge comes along, they go, Can I deal with this?

SPEAKER_01They say, No, not today. But I can do something about that. And understanding you're capable of growth says, now I want to become a really effective learner so I can achieve that growth. And that's the learnership part.

Drew Janetzki (host)Yeah. So in terms of finishing up on this, it's been another fascinating episode. Really, what are you taking away, listener, from this episode and your reflectives? And there's many things that we just unpacked a little bit in mine. I've thought about that spelling group as a school, real school context. What practices? This is a question for the listener. What practices are you doing that could be considered a real fixed mindset or a fixed ways of doing it?

Drew Janetzki (host)And is there a challenge that you could, as James has said, walk through your class, class or your school to see what are the fixed mindsets that are that are occurring? Also acknowledging the growth mindset as well. James, to finish this this part, where would our listeners go for further information around mindset? Yeah, look.

SPEAKER_01Obviously the book. Book learnership, you can pick up from my website, from Amazon, and all the rest of it. But also, if you want more of this, I've got a whole bunch of resources, a copy of the mindset continuum, examples of nudges, all that sort of stuff sitting on my website, jamesanderson.com.au. So have a look at those as well.

Drew Janetzki (host)Yeah, terrific. Really thought-provoking podcast today. So thank you. And we look forward to stay with us, and we look forward to. I am really excited about our final podcast in this series. I've got, and James can attest, I've got earmarked with all different notes. We're going to be looking at James' latest work, which I'm really looking forward to. It's called From Feedback to Advice. So looking forward to that. Thanks, Drew.

Drew Janetzki (host)Thanks, James. That was part three of the lead learner with James Anderson on why mindset is a continuum, not a label. If it changed how you hear the words fixed and growth, send it to a colleague and follow the show so part four finds you. To find out more about professional learning with the association, visit nswppa.org.aufessional learning. Thanks for listening.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Learning Is a Skill, So Who's Developing It? (The Lead Learner, Part 2 of 4, with James Anderson)

    Nov 11, 202654 minAudio

    Learning is a skill, and in this episode of The Lead Learner, educational leadership author James Anderson asks the question every principal should sit with: who in your school is actually developing it? Speaking with...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Masters, Not Victims: What Learner Agency Asks of a Leader (James Anderson)

    Oct 8, 202646 minAudio

    Victim or master? In the opening episode of The Lead Learner, our new four part series with James Anderson, we ask what learner agency really asks of a school leader. James makes a deceptively simple case. A student...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Thomas Guskey: Select Talent or Develop Talent, The Question That Shapes Every Educator

    Jul 30, 20261 hr 1 minAudio

    If professional learning is “working”, where can you see it first: in a staff room conversation, a polished program plan, or in what students do differently tomorrow? We sit down with Dr Thomas Guskey, Professor...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. How do I fit everything in? Annette Gray on leading as a coach

    Jun 10, 202659 minAudio

    If leadership feels heavier than it used to, you’re not imagining it. We sit down with leadership and coaching specialist Annette Gray to get honest about what effective school leadership looks like in 2026, and why the...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. We Change Brains Angela Falkenberg on National Advocacy, Student Anxiety and the Power of Primary Education

    Apr 28, 20261 hr 20 minAudio

    What if the most powerful thing a school leader does every single day is something most people never even see? In this Season 4 episode, Drew Janetzki sits down with Angela Falkenberg National President of the...

    Credit the people on this episode