Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Productivity and Profitability Media Series

Productivity and Profitability Media Series artwork

A guide to ewe containment feeding with Deb Scammell

Oct 26, 202643 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

If you are looking at building a new containment system, or refining the set-up you already have, make sure to tune into this month's episode of the Productivity and Profitability Media Podcast Deb Scammell has spent years helping Australian sheep producers use containment feeding more effectively, first as a drought management tool, and now it is being used increasingly more by producers to protect pasture and improve ewe performance throughout the season. Working with producers across South Australia, Debs specialises in how the right setup can make a real difference to the way a business operates. Her work has shown that containment is about more than keeping sheep off paddocks when feed is short. It can help producers maintain ewe condition, improve lamb marking rates and give pasture the opportunity to recover ahead of lambing. But getting it right takes more than building a set of pens. Deb works with producers to get the fundamentals right, from location to feeding systems and ration formulation through to water supply, mineral balance and knowing when to bring ewes in and, just as importantly, let them back out. Her research has also highlighted the importance of ewe health, including mineral deficiencies and the risks of overfeeding and getting the balance between grain and roughage wrong. This episode is full of tips and advice for getting containment feeding right. Deb shares what she has learnt from years of working with containment systems, including the mistakes she sees most often and the management decisions that can make the biggest difference to the outcome. MLA Resources. Containment feeding resources MLA Resource: Increasing production using containment areas MLA Resource: Producer demonstration site information BIGG Resources: Ewe containment BIGG Resources: Ewe containment videos SA Drought Hub resources: Livestock and fodder management This episode is proudly brought to you by neXtgen Agri, in partnership with Meat and Livestock Australia. We would appreciate it if you could take a moment to complete a short survey about the series. By participating, you’ll enter the draw to WIN a 1-hour online consultation with Mark Ferguson. https://forms.gle/9apCMhawfbGRyAUb8

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_01Welcome to the Productivity and Profitability Podcast, brought to you by Meat and Livestock Australia and Next Genagri International. I'm your host, Mark Ferguson, CEO here at Next Genagri. This podcast is all about the Australian red meat industry, bringing you the latest information, practical tips, and stories from people doing remarkable things across the industry. There's no shortage of great people out there, and my job is to bring some of them into your farming day. Okay, let's get into this month's episode. Welcome to this month's edition of the Productivity and Profitability Podcast, a partnership between Meet and Livestock Australia and us here at NextGenAgri.

SPEAKER_01You're with Mark Ferguson, CEO here at Next Genagri. This week on the show, we welcome Deb Scammel. Deb has a long history of working in nutrition there in South Australia, but has been heavily involved in the whole area of containment feeding and and dealing with extended dry periods and making the most of opportunities around containing animals and making sure we can maintain that really incredible stocking rate through those dry periods so that we can bounce back out of those out of those drought periods with the maximum number of stock possible to get back up to fighting rate as quick as possible.

SPEAKER_01Deb has done a lot of work through PDSs as well as other projects around understanding the impacts of various management uh scenarios around around containment feeding. So it's a wealth of knowledge, and I'm sure you anyone out there who's looking at putting in containment or wants to learn a little bit more how to manage theirs a little bit better will get a lot out of this interview with Deb Scammel. We'll get straight into that one now. Welcome to the Productivity and Profitability Podcast, Deb Scammel.

SPEAKER_00Thank you. Thanks for having me.

SPEAKER_01Thanks, Deb. Great to have you here. You're the resident guru at all things containment, probably by uh by necessity rather than maybe desire there in South Australia. Pretty tough couple season where containment's become really important.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, yeah. I think I fell into it in the earlier dryer period around sort of 18-19, and um, yeah, containment's really launched off from there. So a bit of a timing thing, but we've been through another tough run of seasons as you alluded to, where the containment pens have been working brilliantly.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, and we should highlight today we are talking containment feeding ewes, but feedlotting lambs is a different uh context altogether, and obviously there's lots of some crossover, but today we're really talking about that protecting the ewes, protecting the pasture and uh and using your energy to the to the best or the most efficient way.

SPEAKER_00Yep, sounds good. So, yeah, I'll cover off on ewes, which is yeah, feedlotting lambs is a bit of a different scenario, but I guess when we set up the pens, there's definitely a lot of people that'll use them for dual purpose. So, you know, if you are finishing lambs at the end of the season, um it's another use for the same pens, really.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, exactly. We might just sort of kick off with I guess sort of basic setup and yeah, what that kind of what the fundamentals are, and then um yeah, we'll bounce from there.

SPEAKER_00Yep, sounds good. So, yeah, I guess when we look at the basic setup, um for me the most important thing is just to establish how you actually want to feed use in containment. Um, there's so many different ways we can get a successful result, and it really depends on, you know, I guess I go to individual properties and look at sort of labour available, um, how much time we have each day to feed the stock and then infrastructure we've got available as far as feeding mechanisms. So, you know, whether it's a full mixer that you're gonna do a total mix ration, or just you've only got access to a grain feed out cart that you're gonna feed out sort of, I call it slug feeding of grain every day or every second day.

SPEAKER_00You know, I've also got setups that are just roughage-only feeding. So for me, getting the pen dimensions right depends a lot on your feeding mechanism. So I guess I see a lot of the earlier containment publications, we had those rectangle pens with the small area sort of facing the lane way. If you decide you want to feed in a fence line, that actually doesn't give you enough feeder space for you to all line up together. Um, so you know, my guide's around that 35 centimetres per U if you're slug feeding in a fence line, which can be a really quick way of feeding multiple ewes.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, we need to get our idea that we want to do this before you start putting fence posts in and build your pens back the other way, which yeah, I've gone onto plenty of properties, you know, Kangaroo Island after the fires, we've all got the rectangles the wrong way around, and it makes it hard to quickly feed multiple head of stock. So, yeah, I guess um the slug feeding we've sort of talked about. So there's two options there. You can do the trough in the fence line or we can have a trough inside the pen, but obviously that's extra labour or needing a good dog or kid or worker to sort of hold the gate as you're going in and out.

SPEAKER_00So, yeah, often a fence line will work better if you've got the space rather than driving in and out of pens each day. If you trough feed a TMR total mix ration in the fence line, we can go down to a lot less feed space just because I've got access to feed all the time in that sort of system. So, you know, you can still put your trough in the fence and have a lot less than that 35 centimetres I spoke about. The other thing, as I said, you know, roughage-only feeding can work quite well depending on when you are containment feeding.

SPEAKER_00So if you've got access to silage, vetch hay, loosen hay, some of those better quality cereal haze, um, you can actually get quite a long way through the gestation period with just fibre. Um, and the last two sort of methods we've used is having sort of a laneway where we'll do sort of a communal feeding area. So, you know, especially if you've got a bit of time to feed and want to save a bit of cost, we'll often put sort of a communal trough in a laneway that might serve as two or three pens and just let each mob out at a time to access the grain, put them away, feed the next lot of grain out and let the next slot out.

SPEAKER_00So that can work well. And then I guess my least favourite method of feeding in containment, and a lot a lot of people think it's the easiest way to go is self-feeders, and it's just because we don't have much control um over how much grain they're getting a day. So, yeah, I mean if you're very pedantic about monitoring, they can work, but my preference is those trough feeding type setups.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, so I guess just talking about that a bit further, yeah. Obviously, it people like the idea of filling it up and then leaving it and set forget and not have to think about it for a few days and go and watch the kids play footy or whatever, but reality is that yeah, one day they're getting a couple of kilos a day and the next day they're getting nothing or whatever, like it's hard really hard to control that.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, and I guess with the feeders we've got there's some brands available that are much easier to sort of lock down. But yeah, I find commonly with self-feeders, stock are overfed. And you know, we'll talk about sort of common mistakes later, but one of my most common mistakes is just overfed using containment. So, you know, we're trying to get them off paddocks and provide their nutritional requirements, and often people the first year end up providing too much nutrition in containment.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, yeah, exactly. The in terms of sort of investment setup costs, I guess a couple of things. Obviously, obviously, how long's a piece of string, depending on which of the many methods you just ran through. But yeah, I guess what if you're gonna spend one dollar, where would you spend it? Is it water or is it is it cross-based, or what is the sort of yeah, what's the priority?

SPEAKER_00And I guess yeah, it's a little bit hard to answer as far as you know, a a costing. We have sort of I've done a bit of modelling sort of for AWR extension in SA. We've got a fact sheet that we just modelled sort of 2,000 Us in pens, I think it was 250 Us a pen, laneway in the middle. Um, and I just looked at fencing and water infrastructure, and that came up about 26,000 with updated sort of fencing prices recently for the 2000 Us. That's just your ringlock fencing and pens and water.

SPEAKER_00You know, I guess I don't normally price up feeders because there's so many different ways. So if you're on a budget, you know, your communal troughs in the lane can work really well with old guttering C-section. I guess my motto with containment is it doesn't have to be expensive, it just has to work. So, you know, we can spend anything from 10,000 through to 200,000 on containment pens. But for me, it's more about that feeder space, mob size, location, you know, the correct slope and things like that probably have more impact on the success of it than the amount of money you've actually spent.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, and that's probably true against across all of infrastructure and sheep. Like you can have really effective little yards out in places and putting cheap laneways in stuff that can completely change your production system, but don't have to cost a lot of money.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. But yeah, I guess for me, you know, if I'm trying to draw something up for a producer, it's really drilling down into how much time you have available because, you know, as you know, most producers don't have a whole heap of spare time, or most people in general. So yeah, I think the important, you know, if there's a worker, you know, over summer autumn that's got time to keep feeding, that's fine. We might go for a communal trough feeding method, but sometimes I find it's better to spend a little bit of extra money and save yourself a lot of time over the coming seasons.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, yeah, definitely. We're bouncing around a bit, but we might, yeah, we might shoot to sort of common mistakes that you see made in in setup, and then we'll get into maybe common mistakes in in applying those setups. But yeah, what have you seen sort of go wrong?

SPEAKER_00Yeah, so I guess as I said, the first thing is that overfeeding. So I guess realising once you've locked ewes up in containment, they're actually using less energy, they're not walking around the paddock. And so, you know, you've got to look at your breed, you know, feed efficiency of that sort of breed as well, and trying to match their sort of energy requirement at that point in time. So, you know, I guess when we're looking at dry ewes and overjoining, not too tricky because it's a maintenance type requirement. But as you get through pregnancy, you know, my containment rations for clients will kind of change every 10 days as their energy is going up towards that late pregnancy.

SPEAKER_00Um, so yeah, I find often it's overfat ewes rather than skinny ewes come out of containment pens, and that, you know, gets you often a higher chance of sort of ew mortality, bigger lambs, things like that. So it's really just getting your nutrition right. Possibly two bigger pens is a bit of an issue too. Like I think often people think um bigger's better. So, you know, when we look at dust and the risk of those sort of diseases that come with excess dust, um, you know, I'd work on that sort of seven to ten square metres at the most for using containment.

SPEAKER_00Feel lot lambs I work on more like five square metres per lamb. When you get your sizing right and the pens are established over a couple of years, you actually get that urine and um sort of fecal matter kind of matte, and that can actually help sort of stop the dust from blowing those pens. So yeah, often in the first year, if you have a few dust-related issues, respiratory issues, um, by the second or third year, once those pens are used, if they're the correct size, you'll find those issues are cut down. Um probably another one is location that we've, you know, we just mess up the location.

SPEAKER_00So the common one is it's right next to your shearing shed, it's right next to your feeding infrastructure, and it's 30 metres from your alfresco area on your house. Um, and on a windy day, uh you've got that dust and smell and everything just blowing straight into your house. So yeah, it's looking, you know, and this is probably where I do a fair bit with clients. Like most people have a bit of an idea in mind, but it is good to get an extra set of eyes, even if it's a neighbour, and say, what do you reckon here, mate? You know, is this gonna work? Is there something I've actually missed before I start putting posts in the ground?

SPEAKER_00And, you know, I guess when we look at location, um, soil type and slope, most people think they're gonna be using these areas when it's dry, but often we'll keep use there over the break of the season. So another common sort of stuff up is, you know, it's amazing over summer, but we can't actually access the area once it starts raining, or it turns into a bog hole. So we kind of need that two to four percent sort of slope across a pen as well.

SPEAKER_01And light soil or uh what's the what's the break.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, so it's hard where you're in sort of sandy type country, I guess, because you don't always have the choice of the best soil type. But you know, ideally we have a soil type that'll compact down, um, not have too much excess dust. You know, I don't actually mind having that sort of straw and hay mat on the ground as well. So, you know, if your soil type's not perfect, having that 2-4% slope, and then normally the first year I'd just feed the roughage around different areas of the pen and not get too crazy cleaning it out just to allow that sort of mat um to form across your pen as well.

SPEAKER_00But I guess through our the project I did sort of earlier in that um 19, 20, 21 year, which sort of kicked off my containment research sort of journey, we actually found we did have increased U mortality initially associated with containment. Um, and it's often just mineral balance. So because you're feeding so much supplementary feed, as well as getting energy and protein targets right, we nearly we really need to make sure we've got high levels of minerals, um, especially calcium, to kind of balance out what's not coming through in the ration.

SPEAKER_01So, what does that look like practically? That's cosmag and the and and lime in the are there, or is it just lime, or what are we, what are we doing?

SPEAKER_00Um yeah, so I guess depending on sort of your pregnancy stage, so I guess when you're looking at real raw, just meeting calcium requirements, lime and salt can work relatively well. But I guess you've got to remember when you're in pens, they're not able to access anything else except for what you're giving them. So over time you will start to see micro, mineral, and vitamin deficiencies as well when they're on supplementary feed. So, you know, as we get later ingestation, I'd be more tempted to use a formulated, you know, loose lick or low salt block that has everything they need per day, basically.

SPEAKER_01There right now, yeah, cool. So one last thing before we move on to kind of using them in a bit more detail. And uh but water is we know it's kind of almost everything in terms of keeping animals happy and healthy, and um lots of I guess we can go down lots of different rabbit holes there. Quality of the water, back to bacterial load, but also just that filmer dust. So, what do you sort of recommend as a a good option option for making sure they've got uh fresh water?

SPEAKER_00Yeah, yeah. So I guess high quality water is critical. Um, you know, I just love doing a basic sort of water test if it's not sort of main, so you know, just use salt loads and minerals just to see if you're getting excess loads of anything coming through with the water. It just helps us work out that nutritional balance with everything. Yeah, and then obviously with dams and things, we have to be a bit careful whether we're pumping bacteria sort of through there, so it's worth doing a bacterial test as well. But yeah, I guess if you've got, you know, I guess 5,000 parts per million or less of salt, we can sort of get away with.

SPEAKER_00But yeah, high quality water and then also just water back up. So you've got to think that you've got, you know, two, two to ten thousand ewes sitting in these pens, all relying on one source of water. So I often put in a header tank with, you know, I'd work on five to seven litres per U per day and three days supply at least, or however long it's gonna get, you know, you're gonna be able to fix a pump quickly if something goes wrong. Because I hate having to let stock out because you've had a water breakdown. And yeah, then just high flow.

SPEAKER_00So I'm not too fussed about trough space, but we just want really high flow into those troughs all the time. So they're not waiting to drink, especially in the summer months. And I guess I treat it like a lamb feed lot, so I just encourage um water troughs to be cleaned out daily if you've got a lot of um dust film sort of settling on those. So yeah, I guess if they stop drinking, they stop eating. Um, and then we start to get a lot of issues there, obviously.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, big time. And concreting around or not so critical, like just whatever will keep dust down or yeah, and I guess it goes back to, you know, cost setting up.

SPEAKER_00Like I've got producers that'll throw poly troughs or or make up um polypipe troughs the first year that are off the ground, which can be pretty effective with dust as well. But yeah, I guess if you don't do the polypipe raised trough um with the holes cut out in the top, then I'd go for concrete around troughs is ideal because as you know, they sort of bear them out over the time. But yeah, I guess you know what often happens in dry seasons is we suddenly throw these pens up. And yeah, I guess what you start with doesn't always have to be what you end with.

SPEAKER_00So if you don't have budget to do everything properly, you know, put in some troughs knowing you can add a better setup later if you need to concrete around troughs and things once they start to bear out.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. You've mentioned a few different kind of feeding methods. Um, some people have different theories on whether straw should be in the pens or not. Does that depend on what you're what's going in the troughs? Or yeah, how often are you recommending straw or being in the pens for something to chew on?

SPEAKER_00Yeah, so yeah, I'll never feed a you without roughage. So I'm a really strong advocate for roughage, even in a feedlot lamb system where there's yeah, mixed opinions on that, I guess, in the finishing feeding system. Um with ewes, like the rumin to be healthy needs around that 30% NDF or um neutral detergent fibre level. So I want roughage there at all times. In a containment U feeding system, it is a lot different to a um lamb setup where often a fair proportion of the containment U ration is roughage.

SPEAKER_00So I'll use good quality cereal hay and things. Um, I'm actually running a containment health PDS at the moment where we're looking at um high barley rations with straw versus high levels of cereal hay and low levels of barley. Um, we're only just through year one and we're blood testing ewes right through. Um, but the results are already pretty outstanding as far as um more than double the ew mortality and the high-grain sort of straw setup. So I guess in early days we were looking at least cost rations and the cheapest source of energy is just barley.

SPEAKER_00But yeah, over the last sort of five to six years, I've definitely moved more towards looking at U health and getting the results we want in the paddock at the end, rather than just looking at a low-cost sort of ration in those pens. So yeah, I mean, even if we're slug feeding grain once a day, once every second day, I'd have roughage out in the pen the whole time. They never go without. And, you know, a total mixed ration gives you so much control because we can chop exactly, you know, daily how much hay or straw we need plus barley to sort of meet those energy requirements.

SPEAKER_01Do you reckon that's uh like a micronutrient thing? That like hay being better than sort of straw, like the energy and protein to say, and we kind of expect it to be the same, but obviously there's other things going on.

SPEAKER_00Um, so yeah, rumen health. So um we've actually just picked up sort of acidosis indicators. So yeah, often I see sort of our containment health issues or feedlot lambs often relates to acidosis at some point that comes out in further sort of health issues later, but the major one is hypocalcemia. So, you know, your cereal grain is just so imbalanced for calcium phosphorus. Um, and what we're finding is with older use, we almost can't supply enough calcium a day to meet requirements once I've used up bone reserves.

SPEAKER_00So, yeah, we've got a much higher risk of hypocalcemia. And yeah, the the calcium levels of those use on the high barley straw were substantially lower than those on cereal hay.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, right. No, excellent. In terms of you mentioned feeding once a day, twice, or every second day, or you hear stories of less frequently than that. Obviously, uh rumen can process food over or the feed it gets over time, but that consistency of feeding is fairly critical to keep that rumen balanced as well.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, so you know, ideally the rumen after 48 hours starts to convert, you know, grain digesting microbes back to sort of fibre digesting microbes if you've got the fibre, obviously in the pens as well. So yeah, my preference would be to feed, you know, once every 48 hours. You know, as we're starting ewes that are, you know, dry or early in pregnancy, the the grain or energy requirement on top of the fibre is often quite low. So, you know, if we're only feeding a couple of hundred grams every second day, I'm not too fussed.

SPEAKER_00We have a weekend off and feed on a Friday and then the Monday again. But it's a totally different discussion if we get up to a kilo of barley for twin or triplet bearing use right before lambing. Um, my preference would be to daily feeding then. And it's just because of that change in you know, rumen microbes and the risks of acidosis and things like that in later pregnant use.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, yeah, cool. You mentioned before how you're uh when people are designing their containment yards, they're often thinking about they're going to be doing it in the heat of or the height of summer. But in reality, one of the big farm system impacts is actually having in containment around the point of the break of the season and keeping them off pasture while the pasture's trying to get away. What's your sort of trigger points, and there could be several throughout the year for when you should be going in?

SPEAKER_00Yeah, so there's a few different things, um, I guess. Like one of them's condition score of use. And I often look, you know, I look work with a lot of sort of cropping sheep systems. Um, the agronomists hate sheep out on stubble these days, like they just hate that compaction. So, you know, I feel like for me, you know, we do a real quick graze across stubble. I like to sort of people to think about when they're getting their special. Spending more energy, you know, chasing that bit of barley that might be left in a huge double paddock than what they're actually getting out of the paddock.

SPEAKER_00So once you get to that point and condition score reviews start to drop, I'd always put them in containment based on sort of condition score. But when we look at pasture targets, um, you know, I look at that 70% ground cover or higher as being our absolute minimum these days of pasture. So, you know, especially when you look at native pastures, hills, pastures, unarrable country. Yeah, I'm running another sort of long-term pasture trail project, which we've showed keeping ground cover over 70% has serious sort of ongoing benefits for recovery the following season.

SPEAKER_00And, you know, often we try and keep a thousand kilos of dry matter of sort of standing dry feed in these paddocks as well. So it depends a little bit, arable country, you know, stubble, we probably do get down closer to that 50% ground cover. But for me, when you look at your cropping enterprise as well, I think just running a big mob of ewes across a stubble for seven to ten days is probably a lot better than just what we used to do, like set stock them so we could go to the beach and um six weeks later come back and there's nothing left in the paddock and the ewes have lost half a condition score.

SPEAKER_00So yeah, it's that real um, you know, I guess looking at condition scores of you, but also that pasture recovery has been a huge focus now with containment. And I think that's how it sort of moved from that drought tool. So, you know, as I said, I sort of started with containment with private clients, you know, probably 15 years ago. Um, and it was just that real drought strategy. But unbelievable over the last five years, you know, how much work I've been doing in high rainfall areas. And it's just looking at minimum pasture targets and getting that extra pasture sort of around lambing time and getting extra marking percent based around that.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, and it's absolutely game-changing for those businesses being able to like basically hold or increase stocking rate while having more pasture cover, while having better lamb survival, better ear condition, there's a whole heap of things. We'll get into those benefits, but just quickly before we move on, getting animals in. So what's the obviously if they're going on a high-grain ration, you have to get them acclimatised for that. And then monitoring them while they're in there, what's your sort of how often would you be checking that they're doing what what the nutritionist says they should be doing in terms of how they're holding condition or or gaining weight or yeah, yeah.

SPEAKER_00So I guess um condition score, like I'll always condition score sort of in. I love containment pens because it just gives us the ability to break stock into smaller groups, so I think that's a lot of the benefit too. So yeah, we don't just treat a paddock of twins like a paddock of twins. We pull off, you know, twins that are around you know, underscore 3.25, and you know, maybe fat twin twins might go in a different pen and then the ones on target go in another pen. But yeah, I'd you know, often every, you know, I think we never conditioned score as often as we should, but you know, often every six weeks or so it's good just to check that they're relatively consistent.

SPEAKER_00Um, you know, weighing individual use and having, you know, looking at weight change can be an advantage, and you know, things like opti-weighing a pen can be pretty awesome now as well, just to make sure we've got the right weight gain.

SPEAKER_01And then yeah, leading in, so a bit of trail fitting in the paddock, or what's the audio to do all that in the containment in terms of getting the grain ration up?

SPEAKER_00Yeah, so I guess when we look at getting stock used to grain, it is a lot easier, as I said, than a lamb feeling system, I guess, where we want them on a kilo and a half relatively quickly. So with ewes, depending on the stage they come in, often as they move through gestation, you know, we're only starting at 100 to 200 grams a day anyway, and then gradually moving up to that sort of you know, kilos often my maximum for twin or triplet bearing ewes. So yeah, I guess you've sort of got that gradual transition anyway.

SPEAKER_00But my general rule is starting at sort of 100 grams a day. And if we want them on 500, I'd just build that up over five days in those sort of trough systems. You know, for me, the imprinting as lambs is just critical as well. So I think if you're breeding your own U lamb replacements, that's the best thing you can do is actually train them with their mothers. So, and not just to the grain type, but also to, you know, the additive pellet, the loose lick trough, the feeding method you're going to use in containment. So often I'll bring ewes and lambs together into the containment pens.

SPEAKER_00If we've got a trough in the fence line or in the feeding lane, we'll actually just three to four times prior to weaning, feed the ewes and lambs together. And as those ew lambs come through for their first lambing, so much easier just to have a really consistent result in containment. Because you can imagine, you know, we didn't really talk about mob size, but I see it a lot if we get into bigger mobs or you know, it's bought in U lambs that have never eaten out of a feeder or a trough, you just end up with that huge tail in the mob. Um, and they're the ones that you've got obviously that higher risk of e-mortality or something going wrong over lambing.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, great. And I guess it kind of all swings around controlling the controllables, doesn't it? Like having like often maybe maybe we get accused as a sheep industry of sort of wanting to take the easier route, but it's all about these little one percenters or or a few percenters that give out them all up and it adds to adds to a great outcome for mortality as well as productivity.

SPEAKER_00Yeah.

SPEAKER_01What is the terms of production? You mentioned extra lambs coming out of the system. I guess what's when you've done your sort of spreadsheets and economic modeling and stuff around yeah, I guess break-even points of of putting one in, um does it always come out on top or does it depend on on a few things?

SPEAKER_00Yeah, there's a few variables like someone else had actually written the MLA PDS application that I took on sort of early in my consulting career, and they'd put in there, we're gonna prove 10% extra landmarking. And I kind of read it and was thinking, how am I gonna prove this? Because it was with producers that already were doing a pretty great job. Um, but we actually ended up with 12% X like benefit over three years over 13 sites. So um on average, so it was a pretty good result in the end. Um but yeah, so we did sort of cost benefits of um, you know, use in containment.

SPEAKER_00And what I actually found it's interesting is the labour saving and vehicle sort of wear and tear was huge. So I guess we look at containment as an extra time um draw, but you've got to remember you'd be supplementary feeding in the paddock anyway to get the ewes in the same condition score. So we're not comparing and being out on lush pastures versus feeding in a pen. We're looking at that summer-autumn period where we're often, you know, we have inadequate energy in the paddock anyway. Um so what we actually found was, you know, we were saving on these 13 properties between 85 cents and$4 per U in labour, and that all depended on the size of the property.

SPEAKER_00So, you know, some people had spend three hours a day supplementary feeding, like trail feeding around all their hills paddocks. So, you know, they were saving$4 a U by having them in the pens near their feeding setup. You know, there's vehicle wear and tear. Um, so extra feeding cost was sort of 74 cents to$3.70 per U per year, additional to feeding them in the paddock. Um, but that 12% extra land marking, so we ended up having with that 12% extra, like$5.30 to$8 extra U benefit from being in containment.

SPEAKER_00But I couldn't convince the guy to model sort of the benefits to pasture in that original project, which is why I'm running this long-term pasture project now, because I want to prove, like in feed on offer, what that actual benefit is, because we know it's huge. Um and there was a WA PDS that was done that they proved that 95% or greater than 95% of the economic value was actually from the pasture benefit. So, you know, they quantified across six properties:$20,000 to$120,000 a year extra of grass at lambing time.

SPEAKER_00So yeah, I guess our benefits were better control of ewes. So, you know, we got the extra lamb marking because the ewes were in better condition score, we had them split into those smaller mobs. They're closer, they're generally off shears, so you see if they're starting to slip, where you don't always see in the paddock. Um, but also we had so much extra feed on offer at lambing um that we had better lamb survival once they got let out back out. So yeah, I don't know if I really answered your question, but I'd like I've never found a situation where it hasn't been in front.

unknownYeah.

SPEAKER_01That was that was the answer I was looking for. So that's yeah. Yeah, yeah. Yeah. I think there's so many system benefits uh that it all all adds up. I guess we've yeah, you've just just said that it's it's always going to be valuable. But I guess you're you uh advise in a in a part of the world that's been through several changing seasons over the last decade or so, and I guess all around Australia is the same. But when you're working with a client, obviously there's options around supplementing in a paddock, de stocking completely, or destocking some numbers or or containment feeding through.

SPEAKER_01Have you got any sort of advice you generally offer there, or does that all very much depend on the on the circumstances?

SPEAKER_00Yeah, it's very individual decision, I think. Um, but yeah, the last two years lost track of the number of sort of decision-making drought sort of survival workshops we've run, um, which yeah, I feel like it gives you a bit of an insight into how producers make decisions. And I guess, you know, 18 months ago we were sort of looking at the cost of supplementary feeding, thinking it'd only be for a year, not realizing we'd end up going through two years. But oh, you know, we'd ask producers what's your cost of replacement use?

SPEAKER_00And within the same room, some people would say 200 and some would say 300. And, you know, the sales around here at the moment, we're paying probably four to four fifty for a young you um to join. So yeah, I'd yeah, it's it's very individual, I guess. Um, but I think we can sort of get a bit of reassurance with the common trends of drought that hold like most people that ended up holding stock, I think now are very happy they did, even though it was tough at the time to make that decision.

SPEAKER_00But in saying that, oh, I had some clients that were just so burnt out from feeding, they had containment set up that had feed on hand, but they just didn't want to do it. So um there's plenty of people that we realize the decision was just to completely de-stock or 50% de-stock. Yeah. And then there's other people um that were quite happy to keep going that are glad they have now. So I guess there's no right or wrong decision. Um, but for me, when it suddenly turns dry, having the pen set up and having confidence in your own ability to feed, I feel like mentally those producers felt happier because they knew they had the ability to make a decision where there was other producers that didn't have feed on hand or didn't have a setup that they're really, you know, the paddocks were just blowing everywhere.

SPEAKER_00They had to desk. So yeah, I guess when I work with clients in good seasons, it's getting something set up, getting confidence in, keeping ease in pens, and knowing we can achieve really high lambing rates, and then when it turns dry, they've got that confidence in them being able to do it.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, and I guess we're all happier in proactive space than we are in reactive space. And one of the benefits, one of the benefits of sort of knowing that they're going in there at the break of season as at the very minimum means you've bought or stored feed for that period of time and you've you've already got the infrastructure set up, so it's kind of you kind of know that's happening. It might go a bit earlier than you wanted, or they might stay in there a lot longer than you wanted, but it's sort of some of the decision making has already been done.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, yeah, and I think for me it is that confidence because I think the first year, you know, people are nervous about the fact they've got them in those pens and everything's being controlled by them. But you know, people I've had containment feeding for eight or ten years now, they they are just so confident that they can do it well that yeah, it becomes more a cost of supplementation versus d stocking decision rather than not being comfortable actually being able to feed using pens.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, and I guess I mean normally it yeah, you have to do the masks carefully, but at the moment kind of all bets are off with with the prices like they are. You can kind of I don't know how you could lose money feeding anything at the moment. It's um like every and every animal you keep on, and every lamb, extra lamb you get is is worth money.

SPEAKER_00But yeah, I guess it's that decision making when you know we ended up facing two years of dry. Um it's that it's always that crystal ball. Like I think, you know, if we could see through to now, I would have had a lot less people desock. But I guess it's that, you know, looking back at the trends over the dry years, it always when everyone's trying to buy sheep, they go up. But yeah, where that number is, that's a real individual producer crystal ball because yeah, I feel uncomfortable making that decision for people, really.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, yeah, for sure. And and like you say, there's lots of other things that go into it that's just just tired and yeah, I just want to know it break. You've mentioned quite often in this talk about like singles do this, twins do that, whatever. Obviously, making the most of this is is uh is knowing which animals are containing or got which what pregnancy on board and we still see pregnancy scanning done less than we we should have, but really to do this job well, particularly over that break of the season, then knowing knowing the pregnancy status would be an absolute critical first step.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, definitely. So yeah, I mean I you know I do containment rations for clients and then I do a lot for people that sort of ring out of the blue. And yeah, I really find it tough if people rang me and say we've got a thousand ewes, they're unscanned, you know, they might have pulled off the dries, but um, you know, it's a good argument, I guess, to scan the following year because I point out freely that we're controlling everything in that pen. Um, I'm gonna, you know, a single needs 15 and a bit megs at lambing and your twin needs eighteen, I'm gonna go somewhere in the middle at 16 and a half, and you're gonna end up with big lambs in your singles and small lambs in your twins.

SPEAKER_00So um it's really a very inaccurate way of feeding in containment. Um and I guess when you look at the producers that have done this for a lot of years, as I said, I've now got twins in skinnies, average and fat, and then I've got earlies and lates in pens as well. So that's where containment's allowed us to have all these different feeding mobs. Um, and so we can have quite a number of rations going out, different amounts of grain a day, and that's where we're getting the advantage with containment because they're all coming out in that perfect condition score.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, yeah, exactly. And I guess what you often see is when people do something like this, which is yeah, going to containment or even maybe joining ULAMs or do something a bit more specialist than they normally would, you see them their level of knowledge and skills around management of nutrition just go up that knot or two, and and that sort of you see that replicate across the rest of the business as well. They're sort of operating at a different level.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, definitely. Yeah.

SPEAKER_01For those out there who don't have a nutritionist handy or don't have a consultant helping them out, what other sort of yeah, is there a low-cost tool or metric people can measure themselves against?

SPEAKER_00Yeah, so I guess when you look at um, there's so many resources around containment now. So that's yeah, that's what I actually love that we've come so far, is that without anyone actually helping you, there's just so many pre-recorded webinars and things. So I've done a number of setup webinars. Um, we actually produced a really good video um through Brosser Improved Grazing group that's had a whole whack of views, um, and it actually showcases all those methods of feeding that I set about. So we just go across five farms, they all talk about the pros and cons of each of the feeding methods.

SPEAKER_00Um, that's a great one to look up on the Brosser Improved Grazing group website before you sort of decide to build your pens. Um, but yeah, there's, you know, I think realistically understanding new you nutrition is relatively critical. Um, you know, industry courses like Lifetime U Management have been awesome as far as understanding sort of condition score, feed on offer pasture amounts, which are all applicable to containment feeding of youth. So, yeah, I think without a consultant on hand, if you understand you requirements and condition scoring, you can really assess how you're going pretty well yourself and also look at that, you know, use your feed on offer targets to work out when you's can come in and out of containment.

SPEAKER_01Awesome, Deb. You've mentioned a couple of great resources there. Are there any others that you recommend? Obviously, we'll put um MLA resources in the show notes, as we will with um try and link that video up and stuff. Is there anything else that people should head towards?

SPEAKER_00Yeah, so there's actually a great containment feeding resources page now on the MLA website that I actually only just found. Um, and it's got a lot of these things. So a lot of our BROSSA improved grazing group resources are on that page anyway. A few fact sheets I've written on containment feeding use. Um, there's actually a really good resource that's very comprehensive that I wrote for South Australian Drought Hub that's also on that MLA page. Um, and that's a huge booklet, everything from setup to you nutrition to letting ewes in and out of containment that's in there.

SPEAKER_00And there's also a New South Wales DPI resource that's quite good for sheep and cattle feeding that's on there as well. So I think that's a great starting point. Um, and yeah, to have a look through some of those modules, and that's pretty helpful.

SPEAKER_01Excellent. Thanks, Deb. Uh, yeah, it'd been great to have someone of your knowledge on this topic to to join us today and and run run through those tips. So obviously, yeah, lots of great resources that you've had a key part in developing. If people do want to keep following along on your PDS, what's the what's the best way to sort of keep in touch with what you're finding in those couple of PDSs which sound pretty pretty relevant?

SPEAKER_00Yeah, probably through the BROSS or improved grazing group website. So we've got a project page um which will have my old PDS um that was completed in 21, and also the new one that, yeah, we're only first year through a three-year project. So yeah, that'll be pretty interesting. And it's just enhancing basically you health within containment. Um, my Facebook page, otherwise, you can get some updates on there as they come through.

SPEAKER_01Deb, we've covered getting them in there, what we do when they're in there. Um, what we haven't covered is is what happens when you're letting them out. Is I mean, obviously that's pretty easy, throw the gate open, but that's not maybe not be the best thing to do. So, what are your recommendations around um getting them back out of containment when they're going out onto heap of grass they haven't been on for a while? What are you what are you normally, what are your strategies? Um yeah.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, yeah. And I mean, ideally, we're letting them out onto you know our 1500 kilos of feed on off of beautiful high-quality pastures changes a lot season to season, as we've seen. But, you know, if you are letting them out into lush pastures, that's a huge adjustment for the Roman. So you've it really is that 14 days for the microbes to really switch over. So absolute best practice for me is let them out gradually, you know, give them a bit of extra grazing time over that last kind of week or two until they fully adapt to grass.

SPEAKER_00Um, often we follow the containment ration out to the paddock with them. So, you know, producers always don't don't always have time to do that full process, but you know, putting the feeder and the hay out on the grass so they can gradually adapt can help as well. The hard thing we've found in these dry seasons is we don't have that feed on offer and we're getting closer and closer to lambing. So we can get stuck into letting them out too late. So, you know, twins, depending on how far you're moving them, I'd really prefer them to be that three to four weeks prior to lambing.

SPEAKER_00Even if they're going into a bare paddock, I'd then rather feed them out in that area so you're not sort of stressing them and moving them during late pregnancy. Singles we can probably get back to a couple of weeks before lambing. But yeah, for me, I don't generally recommend lambing in those pens, even if it is dry, just because you've got that disease load. So you look at worm larvae, cocidiosis, you know, pneumonia, all those issues in young lambs, there's just a huge risk in those pens. So, you know, in dry areas, we'll often let them into a two, three hectare paddock.

SPEAKER_00It could be sort of a fenced scrub lot in really dry areas. Um, but I want them out of those sort of 10 square meter pens, and I want them in a bigger, sheltered, open sort of space.

SPEAKER_01Perfect. Excellent. Thanks, Deb. Need to let you go and contain build another containment yard to do something important.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, thank you.

SPEAKER_01Cheers, thanks, Deb. And that's a wrap on another episode. Thanks for listening. We truly hope you got something out of it. Head over to the MLA website for tools and resources to help you be at your best. Links are in the show notes. If you're after some more listening, I also host the Head Shepherd podcast, where we go deep on genetics and livestock management. Search for Head Shepherd wherever you're listening to this. See you next episode.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Building flexibility into a WA sheep business with Moojepin Merinos

    Sep 21, 202630 minAudio

    Hamish Thompson from Moojepin Merinos has spent the past few years building more flexibility into a sheep business operating in a challenging part of Western Australia. Farming Merino sheep alongside cropping, Hamish...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Virtual fencing in Australian beef systems

    Aug 25, 20261 hrAudio

    Long before virtual fencing became available, Michael Gooden from OId Man Creek was measuring grass, matching stocking rate to carrying capacity and building a cattle breeding programme around animals that could thrive...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Maximising eating quality and profitability in sheep with David Packer

    Jul 29, 202636 minAudio

    How do you breed a lamb that consistently delivers a better eating experience? For decades, sheep producers have been selecting for traits they could easily measure, including growth, fertility and lean meat yield. But...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Controlling your controllables with Ken Solly

    Jun 29, 202639 minAudio

    Input costs continue to rise, but according to Ken Solly, that is no excuse for standing still. In this episode, Ken joins our new host, neXtgen Agri CEO Mark Ferguson, to discuss why producers need to understand their...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Fertility and fecundity in the Australian sheep flock between 2006 and 2019.

    Mar 18, 202549 minAudio

    Welcome to Episode 20 of the MLA Productivity and Profitability media series! In this episode, we're joined by Dr Gordon Refshaugee to explore fertility and fecundity in Australian sheep flocks over the past decade....

    Credit the people on this episode