Send us Fan Mail What does identity really mean in your procurement career? In this episode, we explore a topic that shows up frequently in coaching - how tightly we link our identity to our role, our performance, or our job title. Whether you’re navigating change, uncertainty, or simply reflecting on your own growth, identity plays a bigger role than you might think We talk about the impact of labels (the ones we’re given and the ones we give ourselves) and how to start separating who you are from what you do. You’ll hear: Why your job title is not your whole story How identity shifts during change, redundancy, or reinvention The link between self-worth, beliefs, and how you show up Why procurement professionals can face unique identity challenges The power of choosing how you present yourself to others This is one for anyone who’s ever felt stuck, questioned their value, or wanted to feel more like themselves at work. Thanks for listening. We’re so glad you’re here. 👥 Hosted by: Donna Bowden | Procurement Career Coach, Narrate Your Career Laura Sellers | Executive & Leadership Coach, Coaching for Procurement 📅 New episodes weekly 🎧 Listen on Apple & Spotify 📺 Full episodes available on YouTube: Procurement Pivots - YouTube 📌 Follow us on LinkedIn: Procurement Pivots 💬 Got a topic or challenge you'd like us to cover? Message us via LinkedIn.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Speaker 1Welcome to Procurement Pivots, the podcast for procurement professionals wanting to navigate change successfully and create career success on your own terms. I'm Donna Bowden, Procurement Career Coach and founder of Narrate your Career.
Speaker 2And I'm Laura Sellers, executive Coach for Procurement and founder of Coaching for Procurement, and between us, we bring almost 25 years of supporting and working with procurement professionals. And it's we bring almost 25 years of supporting and working with procurement professionals and it's fair to say, we've navigated many of our own career pivots along the way, and now we're here to help you do the same.
Speaker 1Each episode will share practical strategies, honest conversations and expert insights to help you confidently tackle the changes and challenges in your procurement career. Let's get started. Hi everyone, welcome to our latest episode of Procurement Pivot. We're both really excited to be here with you again today, and today we're going to be talking about the topic of identity, and I feel there's probably going to be quite a bit to talk about on this one, laura. Isn't there A lot to unwrap? So why don't you start then?
Speaker 1Why? Why have we chosen to talk about identity on today's topic?
Speaker 2yeah, it's a good question and it's certainly a deep one. I feel like we can bring a few things out of these into subsequent episodes, to be honest, but I think, as an overall thing though, we can be so tied to our identity as professionals, as career driven people, and that can be a really good thing. It can also be a some. It can be something that fuels us absolutely. It can be something that hinders us as well when it comes to achievement, when it comes to the high bar we set for ourselves the high expectations that we have of ourselves and maybe of others as well.
Speaker 2So it's definitely something that is worth unpacking and maybe creating some space between identity and what we do and who we are.
Speaker 1So yeah, what about you? Yeah, I think you know this. This is a topic that I think we probably both, in the work that we do, we're both we're touching on this with our clients, but probably in quite different ways, I suspect. So I think you know this. It felt like a really a really relevant topic to talk about, just because it's so multifaceted and it's actually quite complex, I think, when you start drilling down into it. But actually it can totally, totally shape how people are kind of feeling about themselves and therefore, you know, it can influence performance, like lots of different things.
Speaker 1So, yeah, I think it's going to be a great topic to talk about. I'm sure that we've probably we've got much more than one episode to discuss, but this is a you know it's a good start point. So do you want to, do you want to kick us off by kind of starting to kind of talk about what we've kind of spoken about in this area previously?
Speaker 2yeah, and I guess a good place to start for for procurement professionals in particular is that there is this thing around identity between being a procurement professional and the procurement identity as a whole. And the reason why this comes up a lot for me in my coaching sessions is that, for example, I could be working with somebody and they're dealing with a tricky stakeholder and the stakeholder reacts to something that's happened and they just blame procurement. You know, procurement gets the finger of blame pointed at them for something or other, and a particular client I was working with found it quite hard to not take those things personally against them.
Speaker 2So we really needed to do some work on separating the identity of themselves as an individual and and the procurement process and about what had gone wrong and creating that mental space. Because I think I think procurement in particular has an additional challenge when it comes to identity, because you've got this perception of procurement that can be a a challenge in some organizations. So it's like you've got the hurdle of knowing your own professional identity and of who you are, and then you've got the hurdle of knowing your own professional identity and of who you are and then you've got the I work in procurement, either somebody doesn't know what that means or they've got a perception of procurement that's not always favorable.
Speaker 2So, and that you know, I've got examples where there's positive perceptions. Don't get me wrong, it's not all negative. But it can be like an additional hurdle that somebody needs to overcome to really be their best at work.
Speaker 1Yeah, and I think, going back to one of your earlier comments there, in the society that we live in today, I think so many people they identify as their job title. You know it's kind of you know who are you as a person. Oh, I'm a head of procurement, but actually that's your job title. It's not necessarily your full identity as a person, but particularly, I think you know, over the last few years, when we've seen there's been so much change out there, so much restructure, so many more people that have been affected by redundancy in procurement than I've ever seen previously.
Speaker 1And I just think when we, when we connect our job title to our, our real identity as a person, as an individual, like that, redundancy just hits so much harder as well because it's you know, it really does feel like it's happened to you as a person. It's it's you know it really does feel like it's happened to you as a person. It's it's you know, it's your position that's been made redundant. It's not, it's not you, but of course it's affected you as a person. But if you're suddenly, then they're kind of you know you've been working all these years and you know you have defined yourself or identified as that you know as that job title and then all of a sudden you're not doing those things and you can't call yourself that person, then it's, I think, can be really really difficult to kind of, you know, navigate that, that period where you're maybe between roles.
Speaker 1Or even I think this applies, I've seen it where people have retired or taken a career break and actually they then really struggle to kind of figure out it's like okay, well, I'm no longer doing that procurement role, like what's my purpose? So, yeah, I think, yeah, it's just such a such a fascinating topic, to be honest. But I think also, yeah, the way we identify ourselves like often we've not, we haven't always created that identity for ourself.
Speaker 1Like many people, you know, they're taking on other people's kind of description as their own. If that made sense. And yeah, like sometimes you know it could be kind of comments from your childhood, from your past, that you're carrying with you in later life and throughout your career. You know, why do you never speak up in class? And then you know, kind of, as you've gone throughout your, your career, you kind of you know you're taking that that kind of status or that identity that you know I am the person that doesn't speak up.
Speaker 1I'm the person that's quiet in meetings. I am the person that doesn't speak up. I'm the person that's quiet in meetings. I'm the person that doesn't, you know, doesn't do these, because if sometimes it could just be a you know, a slightly a flippant comment, you know that that's made, that you've been, you've taken and you've owned it as your own, as your own identity. So yeah, I think it can be. It can be really quite complex.
Speaker 2Yeah, I think that's a really valid point. Especially after things like redundancy as well, it can be really hard to not take things like that personally and to also like saying somebody's made a comment where you know you say you're so shy, you're so shy, you know, so okay, so I'm not visible, you know, and and I think, like you say, we take on those labels that people give us. We take on labels that we give ourselves if we've, if we've got, if we've got poor self-worth, for example. And I think what you've said as well leads nicely into the topic of something that we work on a lot in coaching, which is beliefs like limiting beliefs, beliefs that hold us back and beliefs that form part of who we are.
Speaker 2So, like you say, there are some things that we've carried with us for a long time. They're very sort of like rock solid beliefs, and not just unhelpful ones, but helpful beliefs as well, about who we are and what we do. But they can, if we haven't got a good grasp of of our identity in terms of purpose, that we've covered before. We're going to cover values with. You know, we've got other things that that build our confidence. If we don't have rock solid foundations there, those beliefs that we have can be exacerbated or you know they can be.
Speaker 2They can feed the thoughts that we have in our head, leading to overthinking, leading to all those things. So it is a complex topic and it's about recognizing where those beliefs come from. Is it and again we've said this before is it ours, is it somebody else's that we've let project onto us? So it's definitely something that comes up a lot and I think you know, when we've talked about this outside of the episodes and about what we wanted to share today, we've seen that it might not be that we use the word identity in a coaching session, but it does come up a lot and and I spend a lot of time saying be proud you'll see it on my content as well, like on LinkedIn and things but where I say, be proud to work in procurement, be proud of what you do, but it's not the whole identity of who you are.
Speaker 2You're also a person outside of your role. So, yeah, a lot of things around there and, like I said, beliefs are at the core of this. I think.
Speaker 1What do you think? And I think that, coming back to that point that you said about you know understanding your positives, I think it's really important, like I think often people can cling on to those sometimes not positive beliefs or comments that have been made by other people. But I think, leading with your strengths, your skills, you know things that you're really proud of and building them into your self-created identity for yourself, like for me, like where this comes in with the work that that I do with my clients, a lot of the work I do with my clients is to help them to successfully position themselves can be internally, externally, for whatever's next you know it could be a move, etc.
Speaker 1And I think you know when you're kind of considering how you want people to perceive you and how do you want to show up and how are you messaging yourself, like for me, like we have that choice of you know what is it that we want to be known for, what is it that we want to show people? You know almost, like you know how is it that we want to show people? You know almost like you know how is it that we want others to see us, like when they're meeting us for the first time. And so, yeah, I think, just remembering and recognising all of those positives and those strengths, when you're kind of building that profile or that personal brand for yourself, or even, you know, when you're just thinking about like intentionally, like how am I going to show up in that next meeting, that board meeting, that you know that, that that first meet with a new stakeholder, etc.
Speaker 1It's kind of, you know, just really thinking about, yeah, I guess, how, how you want to show up and you know what is the consistent message that you want to be giving and you know what is the consistent message that you want to be giving to people. There's definitely something around consistent messaging.
Speaker 2But I want to throw a spanner in the works now and talk about when it comes to how others see us, because we can put a lot of effort into our identity and how, deciding how we're going to show up. We're not necessarily in control of how others see us. So don't get me wrong, there's lots of things we can do that are positive, that that that fuel who we want to be and how we want to show up. But when it comes to identity and those labels that you touched on earlier on, I think there's a lot of value in detaching ourselves from those labels because we can do all this work.
Speaker 2We can decide how we're going to show up. We then take courage to take an action and we realize that we've we've done all this work and the other people who have given us those labels don't see it right away, and that can make us want to give up and think, well, it wasn't worth it. So in a procurement context, I think this is really valuable because procurement can do all this work to evolve itself, to get the function to where it needs to be, and that tricky stakeholder still doesn't see it because they've got this rigid, fixed idea of what you were back then, and even taking it out of a work context, you know, I could have somebody say to me oh, you were like this as a kid you know, and it's like well, yeah, I was a kid, that was 30 years ago, so you know.
Speaker 2So I think it's just around being able to recognize that gap between identities, that other people's perceptions. You can't control them fully, because they're looking through their own lens and their own memories and they even might not have done this work on themselves. So I think, while there's definitely a lot of value in all this work that we're doing, we can't put the identity fully in the hands of others. We need to own the identity for ourselves, regardless of how, whether everybody will see the change.
Speaker 2Yeah, what do?
Speaker 1you think, yeah, I think I, yeah, I, yeah, I understand the point. I think, yeah, you're right, like we can, only we can influence our own behaviour. We can totally influence how we choose to show up, and I do think you know some of that, some of that can influence others, but we can't, we can't, we can't control. You know we can influence, but we can't, we can't control. You know we can influence, but we can't fully control that. But what we can control is how we choose to.
Speaker 1You know how we choose to think about ourselves, how we choose to take actions, how we choose to speak up or not speak up or present ourselves in, you know, everyday interactions, like they're the choices that we can make and they're the things that are totally within our control. And you know, and I think you know, often that will influence some others perception. But I think you know really you need to, yeah, you need to own, own, own your action and your own belief and the rest will kind of happen.
Speaker 1But you can't yeah, you can't, kind of you know fully control how others, but you can influence it, I think absolutely.
Speaker 2I think you're spot on. So I think you know where I was coming from with that is that it's not all fruitless. Some people will see the change right, but I think, putting all our eggs in one basket I love metaphors, don't? I have noticed this with these, you know I keep coming up with these weird phrases, right, but? But basically, putting all of that recognition and that validation in the, in the eyes of others who've given us those labels in the first place, I think you know we need to just make sure we're balancing that recognition with our own recognition, with our own self. So, you know, because everybody we can absolutely influence, I think if we stay in our lane and if we focus on well, what can I do?
Speaker 2What you were saying, the action. Okay, this is the label I've been given. I'm taking action to solve it and I will check in for that feedback and see whether it influences. But also bearing in mind that it's not only that one person you need to prove wrong. It's you know, there are other people you can gain that influence with. And if you stay focused on that purpose that we were talking about in another episode and focused on the identity that makes most sense to you, then, and and showing up intentionally with that, I absolutely think you can influence, definitely. I think it's just not giving all that power away to other people to say, okay, yeah, that label I can take away from you again yeah, and I think the other word that kind of springs to mind for me is just authenticity.
Speaker 1It's like this is not about creating like a fake persona for yourself, like totally changing like who you are. This is about like being really considered to think about what is the best version of your authentic self and how do you want to show that? What does that actually look like and how can you, yeah, really own, like, own those positives, like I think often people you know they forget, like I see it all the time, all the time with the clients that I'm working with Like they, you know, some of the time they're often doing a really good job, but, you know, there are reasons why they're starting to question things.
Speaker 1Maybe their confidence has been affected because of a series of things and, you know, a one-off incident sometimes, but I think often people don't allow themselves to recognize the great things that they do daily and the impact that they're having on people. And I think, just having a, you know, having a real focus on on those positives as well, and kind of making sure that when you are kind of, you know creating this identity for yourself rather than just accepting potentially, you know the kind of the identity that maybe has been influenced by others.
Speaker 1It's just make sure that it is, you know it's balanced and it is it's involving those you know, those really positive things that are unique to you as well.
Speaker 2Yeah, absolutely, and we've all got strength. And once we've done some work on that, you know we'll be able to see where we can employ them. And you know you're absolutely right what you said earlier about authenticity. This is not about creating a new identity that is not aligned with who you are. It's just about making sure you're leaning into the things that are going to fuel you, because we can create this intentionality. But if we've not got a self of, a sense of self-worth and identity to fuel that, when the going gets tough, when we get, when we slip up, when we come across another hurdle, then all that hard work and all that, that identity can sort of collapse.
Speaker 2So I think it comes, I think identity gets reinforced by more than one thing, and it's and, and so it's identity by where we want to go. That's the strategic element, the purpose, the goals, but also it gets reinforced by the values that we hold and by the beliefs that we have, and they all work and off each other and they fuel each other. So, and I was thinking about this, about how, how, when it comes to those beliefs, and about the identity, about how often we we mix up our own recognition and feedback that we get from others.
Speaker 2So, for example and I'll come back to a negotiation example again like you could, if a negotiation doesn't go to plan and you walk out of of the room and you know, there's a difference in in between saying to yourself I'm a bad negotiator, I can't do this, I'm terrible at this. I am, I am identity. Versus that didn't go as well as it could have gone. What can I learn from this? What can I do better? What support can I get? And so there's a lot more self-compassion in that.
Speaker 2You know, none of us are perfect. We're all learning. You know we've all got things that we can learn more of. But I think there's a real difference between that I am not good at versus I'd like to improve this. I'm good at this.
Speaker 1I can get even better if yeah, so for me it's really important to separate identity from what you do and I think that ties back again, kind of just going back to a previous episode that we did on I think it was the self-reflection one actually, where, you know, I think actually we were talking about and you you kind of raised the point of, yeah, the difference between overthinking versus that self-reflection, and I think that reframe that you've just kind of, you know, mentioned that I am bad at negotiating, like you know that that that kind of is is more in that kind of negative mindset, which probably is going to lead to more overthinking, and it's not.
Speaker 1It's not, it's not giving yourself the space to then think about, okay, well, how can I move forward from this in a positive way, how can I learn from this, and you know, and take that learning for the next one, and you know, and and kind of get a different outcome next time.
Speaker 2So I think, you know, it's definitely kind of ties back to to that point yeah, absolutely, and I think you know the the identity thing, just like overall when it comes to our personal identities. A lot of us do if you, if you, if you identify as a high achiever and your career has always meant something to you, and then something happens and and you lose that sense of identity and you're 20 years into your career, for example. It's definitely worth exploring that, because we are not just our careers.
Speaker 2My career means a lot to me. I'm very career driven, but the, the identity that I hold now, as opposed to what I did when I was in house, is very different and so I think you know our identities can evolve, but it's you know when, when we've always been about the career and then something doesn't go to plan, then you know it can really shake that sense of self-worth and it just takes some tweaks to really sort of make sure that we're remembering that there are other things that make up who we are.
Speaker 1Yeah yeah yeah, and actually just hearing you kind of talk about that and I know this isn't necessarily going to be kind of relevant for a lot of people listening that you know. I know we've got people listening that are also kind of running their own businesses or, you know, doing kind of self-employed type roles within the coaching space. And you know, I've definitely seen it that you know a lot of other coaches, like you know, sometimes people they'll they'll identify themselves as a coach.
Speaker 1Some people will identify themselves as a business owner, some people will identify themselves as a coach and a business owner. And I know that kind of business owner mindset for me that changes how I show up in the work that I do. And I think you know, actually when you just think about the coaching side, you're thinking about how you help your clients, whereas actually when you've got that kind of label on yourself as, like the business owner, you recognize that I'm gonna have to do the marketing, the, you know, the sales, the accounts, all of those other things that actually you know.
Speaker 1If you just think about yourself as a coach, you know that you kind of, I think, almost thinking more about the delivery work with specific clients as opposed to, like we've spoken about it lots of times before like such a big part of what we do has to be in making sure that we're constantly visible and marketing ourselves and that we've got, you know, we've got a flow of clients that are able to find us and know what we do. So I think, yeah, that just kind of you know rung true, because I think you know for some people that is quite a big shift going from you know, almost like labeling themselves as the, the profession, rather than also as that business owner as well yeah, I think, but I think that's just as relevant to coaches and business owners as it is to procurement professionals and and growing a business within a business.
Speaker 2Sometimes, you know, and and I think we, like you, say, for part of running the business for us is not just about the delivery, it's also about how we get visible, and you could translate that directly to procurement. So there's a the credibility about being good at procurement and what you do, and then there's the the credibility with your stakeholders, who are going to be what needs you meet, being visible to them, and I actually think there's a lot of lessons to be learned from running a business that you could bring into procurement. And actually there's a whole market out there of procurement professionals who now are business owners and how they show up and what their identity is.
Speaker 2They're no longer in-house, they're external, and that can also shake identity, and so, yeah, I think it's definitely something that you have to really grab hold of with both hands but be able to separate out. Actually, that's not my identity. This is actually something else.
Speaker 1Yeah, and even just again, kind of whilst we were talking but thinking about, you know, right now there's probably a higher number of people that aren't in roles than what we've seen in previous times. And you know, I think, when you think about networking type events and you're meeting someone for the first time like I've seen it so many times where someone said, oh, what do you do? And that person has responded by saying I'm not working at the moment, that's their, that's their new identity, when actually, I think you know, when you really understand your true kind of identity and how you want to share that identity with other people, it's not about whether you're right now employed or not employed.
Speaker 1It's like actually you know that person wasn't asking for your employment status. They're, they're wanting to get an understanding of. You know, maybe, what your area of expertise is and you know what specifically do you do within procurement. So I think even just how we you know how we're conveying our identity to other people can make such a massive, massive difference to then kind of potentially, what opportunities that could lead to, like talking about that kind of networking scenario, you know, responding with a you know I'm not working at the moment that could end the conversation potentially, whereas actually if you say, oh, I'm a, you know I'm a, I'm a procurement professional and I've you know, I've spent 20 years doing xyz and this is the impact that I have, like actually the fact that you're not currently employed is not, is not the be all and end all.
Speaker 1You're kind of you're, you're giving people an understanding of your value and kind of the impact that you've had.
Speaker 2I think you know that's another scenario, isn't it about the identifying and the, you know, attaching all of our self-worth or our identity to the job, whereas actually it could be that I'm really passionate about doing this, I help people to do that and, you know, I definitely think that's something, and you know how many times, you know, do you go and meet someone and then, after you know, after a couple of nice pleasantries being exchanged, it's a natural question to say what do you do then? You know? So it is just around reframing that for yourself to go.
Speaker 2Okay, you know I might not be in a desirable position at the moment, but it's not everything that I am. And again, this always comes back to beliefs for me, about believing, having the helpful beliefs and and and having the not so helpful beliefs, and how we, how we can compartmentalize or or to push some beliefs to one side while we work on the ones that we do have that are good about ourselves. So, yeah, I mean, I think you know, like I said, we said at the start of this, it's a complex topic. You know identity and it's very multifaceted.
Speaker 2I think this has been a good overview as to how it shows up for people in procurement, how it shows up for us as individuals, as business owners, as professionals and I think you know a common theme, I think that goes through all of these episodes that we've done so far is just about how you always start with self Start there and start with well, where am I good, what am I good at, what do I enjoy? Purpose, and then that builds out to your identity yeah, definitely there. And start with well, where am I good, what am I good at, what do I enjoy?
Speaker 1purpose, and then that builds out to your identity yeah, definitely, definitely, and I think, yeah, I mean I would just echo that really, to be honest, I think, you know, in terms of a bit of a takeaway for people listening today, I think, again, it's uh, you know, just just kind of just check in with yourself and just really have a think about you know, how is it that you, how are you, how are you feeling about your own identity and how are you then showcasing that to other people?
Speaker 1And you know, do you feel that you fully understand kind of your? You know kind of, yeah, your, your identity, or kind of how your, um, yeah, you're building your personal brand, possibly dependent on the circumstance, but, yeah, just, I think, just really think about yeah, how, firstly, how do you feel about it and is there work to be done? Could, could you, you know, could, could you benefit from you know, delving a bit deeper and understanding and believing kind of what it is you're saying to yourself, and then just kind of think about you know how's that then you know, how is that then conveyed and communicated to others positively?
Speaker 2Yeah, no, I think that's a great point. So, yeah, definitely a complex topic, but also one that I'd like to pull us through a few threads from, maybe in future episodes. But certainly I think one of the takeaways I'd like to give from this that I've probably not mentioned is just about the self-compassion. We all have these beliefs. We all have beliefs that are helpful and unhelpful. They're not always spoken about out loud, and we did commit that with this podcast. We'd have conversations that honest and about what we hear and what we experience ourselves.
Speaker 2You know, those beliefs exist for us too, right? So it's just about knowing how to navigate them and to not get stuck and trapped in them. Really more than anything, yeah, definitely.
Speaker 1Well, thank you everyone for tuning in. It's great to have all of your support, and we're really enjoying this journey. I think we've said it before, but if there are particular topics that you'd love to delve deeper into, like, please do let us know. We'd love to hear your feedback, and we're just at the point of scoping out some of our future episodes, so we would love to hear from you on your thoughts so far and how we can further shape things as we move forward. Thanks so much, everyone. Thank you, take care.
Speaker 2Bye. Thank you for tuning in to Procurement Pivots.
Speaker 1We hope today's episode gave you actionable tips to help you to continue to move forward in your procurement career, if you enjoyed the conversation, follow our episodes, share them with others and please support us on our social media channels for others that might be interested to tune in.
Send us Fan Mail How do you prepare for your end-of-year performance review and make sure your achievements are recognised? How can you confidently showcase your value, demonstrate your impact and use your annual...
Send us Fan Mail Does the thought of walking into a networking event where you don't know anyone fill you with dread? Do you find professional networking uncomfortable, awkward or exhausting? Or perhaps you know how...
Send us Fan Mail How do you prepare for your procurement team's end-of-year performance reviews and make sure these important conversations really count? What questions should you be asking? How can you make annual...
Send us Fan Mail What does it really take to build a great procurement team? You can bring together highly experienced, capable procurement professionals, but that doesn't automatically mean they'll work effectively...
Send us Fan Mail How do you stay effective under pressure when working in procurement? Managing competing priorities, demanding stakeholders, tight deadlines and increasing expectations can make pressure feel like a...