The AI boom is everywhere, with soaring valuations, endless hype, and CEOs racing to invest. But is this moment starting to look a lot like the telecom bubble of the early 2000s? Chris and Toby revisit the dot-com era, long-distance calling cards, and the fiber-optic crash to explore whether today’s AI gold rush is running on real value… or speculation. With Michael Burry shorting AI stocks and Meta’s chief AI scientist heading for the exit, what are the process signals leaders should actually be paying attention to? And what happens when innovation outpaces the business model? Dive in.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Hey, what's up, Toby? We made it another week. Nice. Hey, Brian. How's it going? I hope we've got another topic. I think it's your week to come up with a topic. Oh, my gosh. Oh, my gosh. If you could think of a topic that was popular in the business world, imagine a world in which every CEO and every employee are talking about one thing, and they're talking about a different thing. Or they think they're talking about the
same thing. What would that thing be? I think what they would probably be talking about is the railroad race and the golden spike of the 1800s. Or perhaps any version of that over the last many centuries as you've industrialized. What I've been thinking about a lot Is is a guy named Michael Burry. Okay. Yeah, and I don't
think that that's a super familiar name. Okay was folks but Author Michael Lewis made him famous in his book the big short Okay, Michael Burry is this is this savant like number cruncher that the housing market take an absolute crater Mm -hmm long before the rest of us did and that Michael Lewis attempted to explain the complex world of of collateralized debt obligations and
crap mortgage and so Michael Bury made his small stack of a gazillion dollars and disappeared and so but his names turned up in the news again alongside folks like Peter Thiel as of PayPal fame and, you know, political puppeteer extraordinaire, making the world the place he wants. But these guys, their names are showing up not often together,
but as individuals that are taking a look at AI and specifically some of the components of this AI boom. And they're starting to ask, at what point is this thing overheated? And so, these two individuals are both publicly recognized as guys that have started to take very short positions or selling against the companies that are so swollen in valuation and Vita being among
them. And what it's made me think about, and I don't think that every employee and their employers are talking about, should we be shorting in Vita right now? But I think a lot. It's funny you call it. You say, you pronounce it differently than I. Yeah, I pronounce it invidia. Oh, invidia. I mean, I don't know if I'm right or wrong. It's probably my accent. I'm from a little further south than you are growing up down in central
Idaho. Twin flats. Yeah. In the big city though, invidia. Yeah. I think yeah, I just assumed it kind of went along with in God of the Vita, you know, there you go Hey another iron button lies long. So, you know, the other the other thing that's happened this week is the Metas chief AI scientist Yan look kind look lacuna. Yeah, he plans to leave Right into the guy going to look at Bezos are probably who knows those guys
just it's like horse trading at the highest level that's - Oh my gosh. Next level. So why do you think Mr. Burry's selling shorting AI stocks? I have to wonder, we've talked at different times about our career history and I remember in the late 90s and the boom of that first dot com magic, I remember thinking software, schmoftware, I
want to be in the infrastructure game. I want to, I want to be where the, the demand will never slack. And so I went into it's all calm where we were laying, you know, thousands of miles of fiber optic cable just in time to watch all of this incredible investment in infrastructure implode. Yeah. And so the correlation that I can't help but observe is all this conversation about, you know, how many gallons of water and megawatts of electricity does it take when we
say thank you to AI? And so the infrastructure, the swelling of it, and to bring it back to our purpose, which isn't just idle musings of two crazy middle -aged guys, but rather process. The thing that I keep thinking about, though, is every enormous leap forward in industrialization comes at a cost. And that cost is either dug out of the small pockets of a small handful of
individuals, but more often out of the masses. And just like the Temple Palm crater, you know, there were huge... So take people back, because it's possible that, you know, our listeners that do not know about that crater, they may have heard about 2008 and the housing problem. the housing shortage, but they may not have known kind of what happened. Like what was the process that took place when it came to telecom? And let's tie those two together. I love it. Yep. Yeah. So for those folks that aren't turning
a little bit gray around the edges, in the early 2000s, right around, it was spring of 2000 exactly when this very hot dot com driven market where we couldn't put enough fiber in the ground and lay it across the oceans, All of a sudden, it caught up. The lack of capacity that drove pricing, all of a sudden, the capacity started showing up. And there was such a fervor that all of a sudden, what may have cost $10 ,000 a month in
terms of subscription for a company to have this really powerful, rich access, went from 10 ,000 to 1 ,000, and from 1 ,000 to 500. And today, we enjoy all kinds of insane speeds. digitally, but it's because innumerable companies went bankrupt in the early 2000s because it's so much investment in the ground that we couldn't catch up. And so a little bit of this is how many chips is enough chips? And also, can companies like Onagata
DaVita or Nvidia, how much further can their valuation drive when there's a natural limit, you know, to how much production is going to take place. And this is the, I think this is the confusing part. And the thing that I saw in telecom, what was interesting was it wasn't a matter of stretching out fiber optic cables. They found was that the hardware on either end continued to get better and they got more value
out of every string. And the software running on those pieces of components got increasingly complex. So let's, let's take this big picture, right? So we're back in college, right? What did we have to do to call our parents? Oh, we had an MCI calling card. You call the 1 -800 number, you put in their number and it literally counted down. And this was, I literally was calling, I think maybe 40 miles away and that was long
distance. Right? Yeah. And it was expensive. My grandmother lived eight miles away, growing up, and that was long distance. Yeah. And so the cost of communication was astronomical. It was super expensive. Which, what did that... Because that NCI nerd made it what, 10 cents a minute? And we thought that was smoking or maybe 15? Oh, yeah, yeah. Something like that. Like it was crazy. Because you were competing against the quarters that went into the phone machines, right? You're right. Yeah. And so the process that's leading up to this is you have...
You have very, very, very profitable long -term things where you have a cliff that no one saw that they ran into it. I recently saw an AT &T commercial and it talked about how AT &T has been around since Alexander Graham Bell. And I'm like, hey, you idiots, you forget that you got bought by someone. Like you were not the buying party. You were the ones that got bought and they kept your name for marketing purposes. not because you were doing such a fantastic job.
100%. That's a great call out, Chris. We may see names that sound very storied and have stood the test of time. Oftentimes, we've perpetuated those names just because they resonate. Because there's some goodwill there, which is an accounting entry somewhere. Let's bring this up to the AI. What is it with AI that Barry sees that he's like, oh my gosh, or even, you know, met his chief AI scientist is like, something's different. Like what, what are they seeing from a process
standpoint that maybe we aren't, or more specifically, maybe we are seeing it, but the CEOs are not yet. Right. Well, at a certain point, if you're, if you're the one driving a train and you told the team to take the brakes out because it's slowing you down. then your only option is to go harder and go faster. Yeah, I'll confess, Burry didn't call me up to say, hey Toby, I'm taking a short position. What? I'm a little hurt,
to be honest, but five bucks against some of these, that doesn't build the position that he needs to help with that choice. But I do think here's somebody who takes a very data heavy approach with this. When we start to see a number of insiders moving into stronger cash positions. I do think there's certainly a valuation question at play. But I also think again and again, we see the emergence of new technology in this mad rush
to try to limp into the future. And what we're finding is that it never stacks up exactly as we thought. When informed investors start making choices that sound contrary to media, That's a really good time to take a deep breath and reassess So what's interesting is I go back to that whole tech bottle tech bubble the dot -com thing and what I go back to thinking about is like If you remember all the browsers, right?
So remember and even before that there was AOL with the internet thing that just drove like Yeah, free CDs, right? Yeah. I mean, if you wanted to watch a two -minute clip, it would have taken you probably 20 minutes to download it. Like, it was incredibly slow. But the demand was there, and AOL was never gonna be dethroned. They just were gonna own the internet. They couldn't figure out how to monetize, right? And so then that
basically stripped out. Like, the process there was like... at a global scale, they had to hook into that telecom thing, right? Where telecom got cheaper, right? Then other people came in and became your ISPs. And then you think about, I'm also thinking about, remember AltaVista and all these browsers, Netscape? Basically, they were really cool at first, and then they became, they couldn't figure out how to monetize. That's
right. And so you ended up with ads and banner ads and everything was basically like, hey, get your attention. And then Google came out with none of that stuff and a better algorithm that cost them money. Yep. Yep. And they would have went out of business if they wouldn't have become the world's biggest advertiser. Yep. The things that are done on the front end. the advertisement where you're exposed to the monetization versus
things that are done on the back end, which is harvesting the data and starting to organize it. And so we've been given the most powerful toy, I think, in our existence as a civilization, which is now AI, and people are using it to make custom Christmas lists. What if I am gluten free and replace all of the ingredients in a recipe? It's not that they're bad things. It's just that people are grappling with it and the valuations
have been driven up. And so from a purely a process perspective, the speculation has gotten so far out of hand that we start to see folks that have earned a fine living, an extraordinary living, assessing human emotion and the way that Economic cycles actually move starting to make other choices. And so the good news I think for Joe consumer, you know in an office place is that The time and again these things explode. Mm -hmm On a
got a devita valuation has driven all kinds of crazy Innovation, I'm sure yeah in the chip manufacturing space that we can't even guess out But everybody wants a hate of that, you know, everyone's these AI valuations Correct. And, you know, like we talked a little bit about, you know, the acronym pump, right, where it's just process. What is the process, right? And the process is, as a user, I go to a GPT or an LLM. I use that, right?
What are the unintended consequences of that? Everybody's communicating the exact same way, right? Where does the money go? Not sure. That is the question right and how much money is there to go correct? and because eventually if you're investing as this as a comp as a corporation into AI you're gonna want some sort of return and generally return generally companies are wanting return on the upside on the revenue and not on not on reduction of labor costs like that
is almost like exclusive Capitalism 101 is the private equity playbook right drive drive revenue Shrink expenses and just basically milk as much profit as you can well that the other piece in that Chris is is Take good hard assets and put debt on those Yeah, load up load up functioning healthy assets with debt Yep, and then pump and dump till you're right. Yeah, that playbook is an important one Yeah, yeah, and so you've got
a lot of corporations that are basically I believe pumping money into AI because they believe there's an upside on the revenue and I don't see anyone making more money on AI. You know, I think I do pay $20 a month for my... I do too. Open AI subscription. Do you think that's going to be enough to sustain all this? I don't think so. I mean, it's just like Yahoo, like Yahoo, right?
They were really cool, but you got to pay the piper. Yeah. It's fascinating though. And I think that as organizations, operating entities, and even as consumers, we derive a benefit. We just don't always understand the timing or depth of the benefit. And so I'll say, the trade -off from MCI cards for 10 cents a minute long distance to being able to stream entire videos on a handheld
device. We're in a world that was unimaginable to us as teenagers, right? But the trade -off is that there's a world out there of information about us that we don't even know the depth of which other people are exploiting that, right? Well, and and then the reality is is like the last P of the you know, little pump after an image power right and right now the CEOs Have the power to invest Because there's still a belief in the upside of AI Yeah, and so what happens
when that power? Disappears and that's that's again where we end up with this telecom bubble this This real estate bubble this Internet bubble. That's that's where you end up with these bubbles where it's like it just gets out of whack and all of a sudden Someone's got to pay the piper Yeah, and then and the other data point that I think is kind of arresting Chris along this paying the piper and the timing of infrastructure was Another I came across just maybe two weeks
ago, but it was a discussion with open AI Talking with the government about downside protection Is one of the challenges well, you know all this exciting AI, but that's an enormous amount of computing power Which translates into a demand for literally thousands of data centers. Yeah, and so Here's some folks that understand the cyclical nature of this and they're saying before we commit to a gazillion dollars of data center investment We don't want to get stuck holding
the bag. Yeah, it is not cheap. Oh, it's staggering Yeah, I think we'll see some change. And I think the customers will get the benefit. I think some people, some companies will end up getting themselves in big trouble. And if you think about like, oftentimes it's not the early company that wins. It's the later adopter. It's the Microsoft that comes in and kills Lotus Notes. It oftentimes
it's not it's not the innovation oftentimes because they They're too busy making a market and it's the people that come in after like a Nintendo His historic like the Nintendo NES that we grew up with Mike Tyson's punch -out which find that game I would love to own it and probably terrible as terrible as I was back then But a little bit of nostalgia. Anyway, so Nintendo didn't use new tech. They used old tech and they repurposed it. And I do think that we're going to follow that same pattern where, with AI, they're going
to have all of these incredibly expensive models that can do all sorts of things. But my guess is, is ChatGPT 3 .1 or 4 .1 is going to do just fine. Yeah. No, it's super interesting. Are you the blockbuster video? in 2005 or are you Netflix who you're gone all in on streaming instead of mailing physical DVDs. And so it's hard to say.
We could have just as easily done this episode talking about who's bullish on AI and Jeff Betts, this brand new Prometheus startup with pocket change that he's dumped into it for like a $6 billion valuation. It's a messy landscape, but I think if history is any guide, you know, all the energy and hype suggests that we're going to have some process surprises. And yet again, that pump acronym is revealing, right? Well, and the thing is, is like, it's not super clear,
right? The effectiveness, the popularity is clear, but the actual getting paid and getting... getting LLMs built into your systems that add value, that actually do not require a human, that is yet to be figured out. And so maybe that's what we should talk about next time. I like it. Let's do it. All right, man. In the meantime, let me know if you have five bucks and you and I will double the short position I'm prepared to take out. Let's do it, man. Man, when you swing, you
The Process Debt Podcast: Improving knowledge work processes to help you reach One Peace Flow. Stop curing cognitive burnout with physical inactivity. Discover how building a balanced ecosystem of off-screen hobbies can...
The Process Debt Podcast: Improving knowledge work processes to help you reach One Peace Flow. Chasing every new AI tool creates friction and burnout. Learn how to pinpoint your spot on the adoption curve and eliminate...
The Process Debt Podcast: Improving knowledge work processes to help you reach One Peace Flow. Overcome the costly last mile problem in knowledge work, streamline messy workflows, and unlock single-task focus with...
The Process Debt Podcast: Improving knowledge work processes to help you reach One Peace Flow. Stop losing productive hours to invisible friction, endless rework, and fuzzy handoffs. Here is how to audit hidden waste...
The Process Debt Podcast: Improving knowledge work processes to help you reach One Peace Flow. Discover how obsessing over vanity metrics creates hidden process debt, destroys deep focus, and how a four-step framework...