In this episode of Process Debt, we discuss how process transformation should adopt the mantra of "Buy vs. Try" and explore why so many organizations opt to "buy change" instead of building it from within. From billion-dollar consulting contracts to executives chasing quick wins, we unpack how outsourcing transformation often becomes a way to pass the buck rather than solve the problem. We contrast this culture of buying with the power of "triers" - curious, connected employees who dig into the white space between processes, experiment, and leave a lasting impact. Along the way, we share stories of over-engineered solutions vs. $19 fixes, short-term career mindsets vs. long-haul investment, and why true change demands rolling up your sleeves, not just hiring the next McKinsey deck. If you've ever wondered why "transformation" keeps getting sold instead of solved, this episode is for you.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
We are going to revisit our topic from last week, which was try versus buy. It's too good. We didn't go deep enough. We did make it to 20 minutes though. So that was impressive. But the thing that I want to talk about this week is really around try versus buy and how simple consultants have made it to buy. with showing very little impact unless you're selling opium by way of
McKinsey, by way of doctors, by way of nefarious practices. Chris, I recently saw an article. God, I wish I would have flagged it. They were talking about the billions of dollars that Fortune 500 companies spend on things like digital transformation or strategic reset. All of these things as a consulting industry, we're bringing in people
with very low context that don't understand the complex mechanics and they're creating beautiful PowerPoints or they're introducing powerful dashboards of data. that are superficial, right? Because the audience is this executive. And executives are rewarded for growing. The rewards, show me what somebody's rewarded for, I'll tell you where their attention goes. Oh, 100%. Consulting does a really powerful job of feeding that need to
have something to present up. So talk to me about how there's something more in your mind. It struck me that this is such a recent piece. because it's literally a multi -billion dollar industry just talking about what could happen or should happen and not making it happen. I think it's really interesting. It's probably why I will never be an executive because I want accuracy.
Yeah. I want accuracy. I want results. I want people to, when they say that they predict something, I want their prediction to be validated. Like, what's your confidence level? And, you know, I saw a meme on Instagram about, you know, ask Chad GPT to create a Mackenzie slide deck. and then analyze the words that that McKinsey slide deck would get and you end up with synergies
and optimizations and all these big words that sell really well. It's a really good story. And the side benefit is if McKinsey doesn't do well or Boston Consulting doesn't do well, it's not your problem. Right. It's like the best way to pass the buck. It is. You can vilify them and then you can hire them into a different functional area tomorrow. Yeah. And you have a different
team from the same. Correct. Well educated organization. Correct. Yeah. No, it's, I think, you know, this, the idea of the culture of buy versus try, I think some of that has to do with how long are we invested within this organization? Oh yeah. And so if I was making a 40 year commitment to a company. Sure. then I wanna leave everything I touch at least a little bit better than I encountered it. Because I'm gonna reap the rewards multiple
times, right? Investment rule of 72, if I do a 10 % improvement, then the value of that's gonna double in seven years. And so as I move through an organization, leaving things better than I found them pays both me and all of my collaborators that I'm working with for the next 30 years, it pays us dividends. But if my career is two years, or if I'm measuring in quarterly increments, those try investments that take time, a series of experiments, a series of refinements,
those don't happen in 90 days. Well, the other interesting thing is like, I'm going to think about like new employees, right? So you hire a new employee, right? They're impressive. You've never heard their stories before. You don't know their strengths or weaknesses. You know, and generally you get someone who's at, you know, who's a competent professional, they will be very competent and kind and have some EQ, but it takes a while to understand the strengths,
weaknesses, the good, the bad, and the ugly, because we're all humans trying to do our best, right? Yeah. And so the best triers are going to be the people that know where to try. And maybe it's as simple as if you're an executive, you don't even know where to start. Yeah. So it's easy to start with synergies. Transformation. Transformation. Impact. More hay -owl. We need more calabino. Leverage. Scale. It's interesting
because what you described, and I think today's hiring process, is pretty abrupt. And if I think about hiring a new resource, we have some screening, maybe I have some technical acumen, periods of interviews, maybe plural. I have some EQ, cultural fit within that team, not necessarily within the company's DNA, but usually just at a team level. But in general, I would dare say most
hires happen within... you know, four to six weeks unless there's HR reasons that it's slowed down. So you've essentially spent maybe, I mean, at least personally, a lot of my interviews, both as an employee, but also as a consultant, it may only be an hour or two of interview and I made an offer or I'm asked for a proposal. Yeah. And the funny thing is like that offer could be early in your career. It could be 50 grand later in your career. It could be 150 grand,
could be 300 grand. And basically all I'm being offered, I'm not being offered a career. I'm being offered paycheck. I was talking with a friend today over lunch and she is a really brilliant chief HR leader. And I was saying to her, earlier in my career, I almost, I was interviewing and I was offered a job as an actuary. I am not the kind of introvert or statistic table Nazi that would have been an awesome actuary. I would have
been a distraction. to everybody I worked with and an annoyance to leadership. I would have certainly been fired within the first year for not getting what they needed. But what's interesting was when they were asking me about what I wanted, what I didn't say but was 100 % true is I want a paycheck. I have bills to pay and you're furthest along the process and I have an urgent need to cover my costs. But as we get later in our career,
hopefully, we kind of discover who we are and what we're about. And so I was saying to her, today, I have a paycheck. I have a lot of learning as well. So I'm not looking for a paycheck. What I'm looking for is a purpose. And I'm looking for a sense of fit. And I'm looking for value alignment. Is this an opportunity for me to show up and do something I'm really passionate about? Or is it just a paycheck? I think in the spirit of the buy versus try, so many organizations today, it's a consumerism transaction when we're
hiring. We're not asking, is this the kind of person that reflects our DNA? Do we have our values aligned? Could they potentially become part of our leadership and contribute to our overall health over the course of 10 to 15 years? I don't think we're thinking in that longer line, and it takes a long time to become a good trier. and develop that deep knowledge of how an organization actually functions. Well, you've talked about your time at Nike in kind of their heyday, in which they basically, it was part of their culture,
that they kicked people to other parts of the org. Like it was 18, it was 18 months stints, if I remember correctly, and they would basically go and they would learn this other thing. Like imagine like the wealth of knowledge that you get by bringing other stuff, other things, like, and I've thought about this a lot, like, Would love to be a consultant if you could start me as a new as basically a new hire and Train me how to do something because I guarantee you four weeks in I've got 25 different problems solved.
I guarantee it Because you have fresh eyes and experience Correct. Yeah, I like give me give me four weeks in any job I will I will basically have all sorts of things for you to solve right and you know That's a try. Yeah. Right. That's that's putting your boots on, putting your gloves on and going to work. Right. Whereas it feels like. You know, maybe maybe I'm missing something
here, but most consulting just feels like it's a flyby of what could be and, you know, of the flavor of the month. And so a couple of years ago, it was blockchain. You know, blockchain had zero value. So we created crypto. It's been great. You know, now it's gen AI, right? What is gen AI? Define it. Good luck getting a good answer from many people. They will, or getting one flavor of an answer and that like, look, AI is nuanced. Like an LLM will, it predicts
the next word. And so if you can, if you understand that you're going to be better off versus just thinking it's magical. You're like, no, it's just. It's a writing machine. It's pretty, like I'm not complaining. No. Well, I think what's interesting is that if we think about the script of how a business operates, you know, or like notes on a page of sheet music, it's not just the notes that matter. It's the white space in
between. You know, your comment, I love that, that Nike story stuck with you. What I was so impressed with was when they took people that were, had a pretty good social EQ and were inherently curious and were collaborative and they started to move them around, they started drawing connection across all the white space between these teams, between geographies and they call them product engines. But for any business, we have all these different service lines. somebody can spend an entire career in just one piece of the business.
And it means that the depth of their relationships is shallow and they don't have context outside of their area. And so from a cultural health, I found that to be extraordinarily powerful because all of a sudden it's not just empathy you have because you're familiar with what your counterparts are doing, but you also know who to call to ask for that tri -level of insight. So that's super powerful. Last week you touched on something and I want to go back to it because I don't remember the specifics, but there were a handful of things
that if I wanted to hire or cultivate triers in my business, what are some of those characteristics of how I might identify somebody that's prepared to try, that's going to take the time to really unpack and invest in building something that's more long -standing versus just throwing up some quarterly results because they expect to be shopping for a new job in two to three years. I mean, I would consider myself a trier. And if I go back to my career, my biggest successes have
always been just being curious and just being like, well, why does it work that way? And specifically in handoffs, I've been ridiculously lucky in just figuring out why does department a do this thing and department b do something else or system a do something and system b do something and you're like there seems to be something amiss here or or i just i just expect more um i i you know um when i i used to work at bodybuilding
.com yeah you know these are audio so you guys won't know this but i am totally jacked just kidding not jacked Oh no, I was in operations. That was the only non jacked department at buddy building. Anyway, um, you've got your marketing guy. You didn't get the supplements that everybody else got the marketing guys. You're like, oh, they're pretty over there and all the operations are like, we've, we've had too many beers or something. I don't know. Anyway, uh, but when I was there, we, we, we were shipping stuff from
different warehouses and we had, we would ship stuff from the wrong warehouse a lot. And then when we went and looked to what was shipping, it was always like our most popular product. It was optimum chocolate whey. And it was just baffling people. They just could not figure it out. And I'm like, well, why does it ship from the wrong warehouse? It's like, well, we were missing that product, whatever the product was, in the warehouse that it was supposed to ship from. Right. So it might be ordered in LA. Correct.
And it's being sourced or shipped out of New York. Exactly. Exactly. Like specifically, you order it in Oregon. It comes from Pennsylvania because it didn't have some sort of ketone, something or other. And so I'm over here in the corner raising my hand and saying, hey, you know what would be awesome? I'll tell you what would be awesome. Just tell me the item that you expected to be in, you know, the West Coast, DC. Yeah. But was not, but was in Pennsylvania. And I created this report and everyone was like, oh my gosh,
this is so great. And you're like, that was a try, but it was caused by me being curious and saying just because it doesn't exist doesn't mean I can't ask for it. And it took me a while to explain what I was trying to do, but once they got it, it just became so obvious. That's the funny thing about tries is when the try works and not all of them are going to work, but when the try works, It's so obvious what we've been
done. Yeah. Well, it's like a baseball player with a, with a 400 average. Like how much is that guy worth? Oh yeah. Out of control. Right? No. And, and that's only four out of 10. Yeah. And yet we don't, we don't have baseball cards for our staff. Yeah. We don't know what calendar to track. They're meaningful. Think the other I think the other thing is triers have to be system thinkers Me or they will just make their
little silo efficient and not care about the system Yeah, and you know, I also think being able to Go into different groups like again, I don't know why companies don't collect these little like these little internal consulting teams Because my guess like my guess is is there's a there's a portion of your company However, how whatever size your company is like let's just say it's 2 % Okay, so you got 2 % of your
company that did for some rat for some random reason their superpower is Trying and figuring out little nuanced things that like gets them all sorts of credit and and But no one else saw Like if you had a little team, you've got a 200 200 percent company. You got a little team of four that basically just goes and sits stuff, learns stuff, and then just goes and makes recommendations and has some pull within the org, it would be pretty incredible what could happen. Because the thing is, is like these changes aren't big oftentimes, they're really small. That's the
thing that's blown, like that's the thing that blows my mind. Is sometimes these tries are like, you know, I think there's a story of this company they call in the console. I don't even know if this is a true story, but it's. It's a good analogy. They spent millions of dollars because for some reason these boxes were coming through and they weren't being filled. There were boxes coming through and they would box them up and ship them out, but they had no product in them. So they spent millions of dollars fixing the line. The line was better and it did a lot better job. And then one day they just found out that these
boxes were just not like ever making it to the million dollar checkpoint. What some you know the story goes and again this could be fake but the story goes Someone who was working just went and got a fan because he was tired of the million -dollar machine because it made all this noise It was a pain. He just put the box fan up It blew the boxes and if the box didn't have product just blew the box off the line problem solved right so like But but but I think you love I love that story though Rubble solved. Yeah, so
you got some guy with it with a $19 box fan that's on discount at Walmart is just solving the problem. It's a lot like the story of the U .S. spending literally millions of dollars creating a pen that would write upside down in space and the Soviets just use a pencil. I think often that desire to over -engineer because we're not close enough to it or we don't take a step back. And I think a lot of triers will adjust their perspective.
To your point about curiosity, I'll ask somebody that may not be working in the process, but they're dependent on it or they're an input. And gathering those perspectives gives you a much more complete view of what's going on. I think the triers also have tried more. I know that sounds so dumb, but they've just tried more. And so they've failed more. So they have a better predictability of what will work. Yeah, Chris, I'll tell you You
know, I've spent the last 20 years predominantly as a consultant. Oh, we're gonna go any of the stations Yeah, it's an admission, but I'll tell you the if there's a singular secret to my success It's discovering who those connected triers are Because the challenge is that oftentimes a trier is asking questions that executives can't answer. Yep or they're pointing at things that are good enough, they might be fragile, but it's not a priority. And as a consultant, you're usually
brought in by somebody with authority and budget. It's a director or an executive, right? And what they're asking is, I happen to perceive a problem and you, consultant, I'm not a McKinsey guy, right? They're not asking me for an army of analysis. What they're asking for is bring me some recommendations and help me understand how we execute it. And so my very simple motion, and to your point, every organization should have 2 % of their workforce doing this. It's working on the business, not
in the business. 2%, right? And all you have to do is, you don't have to have deep knowledge of every process. You just have to understand through interview, talk to me about your process. The priors talk about it differently. They also don't expect, they don't accept the status quo. No. There's always one more thing, isn't there? Well, there's always like, can we go and get this data piece? Or do we have to do that? And
so they're always kind of experimenting on what will versus what won't work. Yeah. Tinker as a descriptor of what you just said, right? And maybe it's optimizing. They want to play with things a little bit. I think the triers are also when you hear Elon talk about Doge, and he's like, I'm going to go save all these monies. The triers are like, dude, you can save your money in Medicare or the military. Those are
your two options. They just stop there. They're like, look, I understand math, statistics. The piles of money are hanging out in the buckets that you aren't playing with. You're playing in the wrong sand, at the wrong beach, my friend. That's right. Well, it's kind of like in modern day organizations, we spend an exorbitant amount on salaries and on software. If we look at the actual dollar spent on people, process, and technology, process is not where money is spent unless there's
software strapped to it or heavy pieces of equipment that are really - Oh, sure, sure, sure. So the white streets falls apart for sure and you know What's interesting like what I've what I've thought about a lot is like you can take process and you can tie it to the strategy, right? Yeah, like if the process can align with the strategy versus Like I think a lot of oftentimes business is about connecting To the community right and so there ends up being more politics than normal, but we are we are over again my friend it is
Try versus lie. We had more to say on this. We did. Awesome session. All right, man. Well, I guess we just keep trying. We'll just keep trying. There you go. We're only trying to bat a 400, brother. There you go. All right, man. All right, have a good one, bet.
The Process Debt Podcast: Improving knowledge work processes to help you reach One Peace Flow. Stop curing cognitive burnout with physical inactivity. Discover how building a balanced ecosystem of off-screen hobbies can...
The Process Debt Podcast: Improving knowledge work processes to help you reach One Peace Flow. Chasing every new AI tool creates friction and burnout. Learn how to pinpoint your spot on the adoption curve and eliminate...
The Process Debt Podcast: Improving knowledge work processes to help you reach One Peace Flow. Overcome the costly last mile problem in knowledge work, streamline messy workflows, and unlock single-task focus with...
The Process Debt Podcast: Improving knowledge work processes to help you reach One Peace Flow. Stop losing productive hours to invisible friction, endless rework, and fuzzy handoffs. Here is how to audit hidden waste...
The Process Debt Podcast: Improving knowledge work processes to help you reach One Peace Flow. Discover how obsessing over vanity metrics creates hidden process debt, destroys deep focus, and how a four-step framework...