Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Process Debt

Process Debt artwork

The Birthday Paradox of Process

Sep 5, 202519 minAudio

What do birthdays, coin flips, and endless Zoom calls have in common? More than you’d think. In this episode, Chris and Toby unpack the famous Birthday Paradox - how just 23 people in a room give you a 50% chance of a shared birthday - and connect it to something every business leader struggles with: complexity. Why do we keep pulling more people into meetings, projects, and decisions - when more often, less is more? From the days of skunkworks teams in the 90s to today’s bloated virtual calls, we explore: Why our intuition about “more voices = better outcomes” often fails. How meetings became overstuffed and under-productive post-COVID. The role of clarity, purpose, and decision rights in cutting through process debt. What Toyota’s culture and even backyard deck builders can teach us about lean, effective collaboration. If you’ve ever sat through a meeting wondering “why am I here?” - this one’s for you.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Hey, what's up, Toby? We made it another week. Hey, happy Friday. I know. We made it. All right. So we're just going to go right into it today. Let's do it. So I have a question. OK. How many people need to be in a room before there's a 50 % chance, a coin flip, that two of them share a birthday? 30 days in a month 12 months in a

year That gets to be a really big number. So that's clearly wrong. Otherwise, this wouldn't be a trick question, right? You see how I'm trying to pull it apart. Oh I mean I think about it for myself I so rarely encounter people that have my own birth that share a birthday with me that I'm inclined to think the number has to be you know, 30 ish maybe even 45 before I arrive at a matching but I have a hunch you're gonna tell me I'm wrong. I'm probably coming at this question wrong. You're totally wrong, Toby. I wouldn't have asked a question if you

would have got it right. How many? The answer's 23. 23, and is that for me to find somebody in the room with a matching birthday or there's a 50 % chance that I will share a birthday? 50 % chance that two people in the room will share the same birthday. Boy, how narcissistic is that of me that I'm imagining that I would be one of the two, right? I believe... you get to like an over a 90 % chance at about 40 people. OK.

OK. Or something like that. But the number's smaller. And the reason we're talking about this, this is not the birthday podcast. This is the podcast. But it was my birthday recently last month. Anyway. It was. Happy belated birthday, by the way. It comes down to the challenge of the interdependencies. and the impact of those number of people. So like what's funny is like we think that intuitively we think that if there

is to be a 50 % match that this number is going to be higher. It actually is smaller just because of raw statistics because when you walk into the room that one person doesn't match with like when one person walks into the room they match with that one person. Then when two people walk walk into the room, they match with two people. And when the third person - Potentially agree, yeah. Yeah, they potentially match. And so basically it creates this thing. And I think we have the reverse problem oftentimes in business, which

is pull in not the appropriate amount of people. Because of that, one person comes in, two people, it's interaction between two. Three then you've got three links for you know Everybody's linking with each other and I think that is a that is definitely an area that can have process step Well, let me step back for a second. So sure this birthday paradox That the number is smaller than we expect to be able to find a match between

two items This feels this feels like it would hold true when we're doing product market fit And so if I have a new solution versus I have five solutions taking to market, and how many am I trying to match them against different customer segments or use cases, the more numbers I have, it probably isn't the full compounded number, right? The 25 to the nth or whatever the calculation is. My high school math teachers would slap me,

because I'm sure that's where we first encountered that. But it would be a much smaller number. But I think what you're touching on is that we often follow that same line of logic where more is better when, in fact, when we're building teams or trying to arrive consensus rather than matching. Yeah. Consensus is you're suggesting maybe even a smaller number is better. Yeah. Why do you think that is? I mean, I understand intuitively I get there, but I love that you think about these things usually before we jump on a call on a Friday. So unpack it. I think,

I think it's because we're, we're, we need community. We're territorial. So like the bigger something is, the more people we pull in. Which, you know, I think, I think, and I've also been noticing just in my, in my meetings, you know, before, before COVID, it was two or three of us in a, in a room. Imagine that talking face to face with, you know, reading those non latent verbal cues of like, hey, you dumb ass, that was something

stupid, which you can't say out loud, otherwise you go and talk to HR. But now I'm just seeing more and more, just the larger number of people in meetings. Because it's so much easier just to add somebody to a Zoom or a Teams meeting versus coordinating their logistics of where they're physically at. Is that why you think it's happening? I don't know. That would be, I guess I'm expressing an intuitive assumption.

It's a really good call out. It's just easy to just interrupt someone's day. It's funny that you say that. Someone was talking about texting being what a telephone call was historically, meaning when we grew up, the telephones were on the wall. Imagine that. That was a thing. Um, indeed, you know, the big old kids will never understand the rotary phones where it's like, gosh, dang it. I don't want to have dial a nine

because it just takes forever. We can't be friends. You have too many nines in your phone. Yeah, we do. We digress. Yes. But, but, but it's interesting that we basically have injected our lives with distractions and pulling people into something. has almost become a bad habit of bad process. Based on convenience. Yeah. I do know the best way to kill an otherwise healthy initiative is

to basically send it into that endless cycle with let's add one more person and we have one more stakeholder and now we have to bring them up to speed and everybody's opinions are equal. Feel like I feel like process by committee specifically designed by committee is a certainty to fail. Oh, yeah, right and so It's it's interesting that you raised that question because I'm hearing you say too that even in a physical meeting Somebody will step out and say hey Bob. Can you join us

in the conference room? When Bob might not have traditionally been necessary to arrive at a decision or move forward in the past That's really interesting you think that people are less confident Or that the complexity has increased and therefore we need additional experts. I wonder if it has to do with just a social disconnection that we got. Yeah, that hungry for more humans in our little space. And we replaced it with people with screens.

Because it was easy. And then we just build. And I don't know, I wish I had grand solutions on how to solve this. But I just think sometimes that the less is more, especially when it comes to process. Yeah. Well, I know when I first started doing process engineering work, this was old school. The prevailing wisdom was hammer and champy. So this was new and emerging insights about how to redesign processes and make them

more effective in the early 90s. they were building it on this concept of what is a skunkworks team? How do we find a small team? Let's remove all the other distractions so that they can stay solely focused on the project and the effort. And at the time, the thought was, gosh, is five people too many? Is six people too many? But the goal was to be really intentional about making sure you have the right people in the room. a

lot of the logic was the byproduct of fewer channels of communication, fewer conflicting opinions. Sure. You didn't have the same overlap of expertise. And so you were taking an expert at their word. But in the early 90s, the Internet was still like, you know, still being designed in Netscape. Was it DARPA browser? Yeah. You mean a couple of professors and a bunch of military guys? No.

And it was all pre -AI where we could have a confident and often wrong opinion injected almost immediately. So it is hard. I mean, maybe the question I would ask is like, in today's world, how do we figure out who is the expert voice to help guide decisions? If socially we want more people in the room, maybe there's a role for them. Maybe we want them to be present to it and witness the conversation, but nobody ever

says, hey, Toby, can you come join us and just shut up? Like you don't have an opinion in this, but we want you to hear it live. And maybe that's, and at least for me, that's probably the right answer is like, did you try to shut up? Can we mute you and just have you listen? That should be our next podcast. I'll just talk. I tried that one time this year. It was awful. It was no fun. Maybe we'll do that. I'll join you, but I won't say anything and everybody else. Is that just Chris by himself? Yeah. You can edit me

out of the... Yeah, I don't know. I mean, thinking back about some of the recent decisions, some of the choices that have been made that were effective, was there a certain pattern that you saw emerging? Because I think what we're talking about is arriving at healthy decisions that don't create all this debt to be serviced. Yeah, I think a lot of it like I've always been super successful and I have a small team Yeah, and it's like this is where we're headed. This is

what we're doing We have choice. We have choice a choice B. It's it's this it's the The closer you can get to the big the people doing the work Yeah, I think the more efficient you can be as long as you're aligned And maybe that's the problem. The more people you have, the more opinions you have, right? You get to 23 people in a room, you've got two strong voices that agree that might not be aligned and you're heading to crazy town. Well, in a large group too, you're going

to have things like the formal and informal hierarchy and the political powers that teams exercise, things we don't always talk about. This point of alignment, too, though, makes me think, I was jokingly saying, Toby, you're invited, but you don't get to talk. I do think there's probably a place to say, we're going to be having a conversation. And these are the only people that have a voting say in this. And I don't think we are as intentional about how we structure our meetings to let people know what role we're inviting them to fulfill.

Or even what the purpose of the meeting is. Yeah. There's no reason why you can't have meetings that are all about building camaraderie. Whether it's remote or whether it's going to lunch or whatever. That's just good for the soul. And then there's other ones where it's like, look, this is a decision -making meeting or this is a research meeting. But oftentimes it's like, we're just all here pretending like we know what we're doing, but we don't really know and it's

not clear. Chris I think that's super interesting because what you're suggesting is Could be a very simple solution and it begins with whoever's convening Yeah, and if you don't have an agenda at least you should have a purpose so that people know why they're being asked to forego an hour You and I have a friend who's recently taken on a new job. He's about 18 months in and he said I'm in no less than six hours of meetings a day Six hours of me Not all of which are his

that he's convened. Yeah. Yeah. And so he just said, I don't know when I'm supposed to get anything done. Well, and I think that that's ultimately the problem, right? Like we've we basically if we tried to get everybody in the room. And I don't know if it's because we don't want to be offended or we don't know. Like we're trying to get this group think that actually could be helpful because we don't know where we're headed. Right. But it's almost like it's almost like if you're not aligned. It's almost like the next best thing is to pull people in. But that doesn't,

that isn't necessarily the right move though. Yeah. And I don't know why, I don't know why we do that. Like I'm thinking back, you know, in a thousand years ago, why would we have done that? Right? And maybe, you know, if we're out on the plains in the Savannah in Africa, you and I, just hanging out, having a grand old time. But my guess is, is maybe, maybe it's that simple. There's this human nature thing where if things are not clear, You surround yourself with community. Yeah And and because it's so simple we grab more

people put them on a room put them in the room and The reality is is like that's that may or may not be needed Hey at least for my part. I know there's times where The hierarchy like the org design hierarchy is different than the decision rights Yeah, and There's times where I find myself in a meeting and realize we don't have the proper decision maker. Oh Yeah, yeah, right And so in this exploration, it's one thing to say hey We

randomly have two people that share a birthday. It only took 23 of us It's very different to say can we commit to a course of action that changes people's lives on a day -to -day basis? Yeah, who's authorized to actually make that decision? Yeah, so It does feel like with all the screens going on and all the technology, we forget sometimes that ultimately, you know, the impacts we're making can be really significant on that very common element. Well, we get confused

between what is crafting versus what is community -type effort. Yeah. Right, like... I think I mentioned that these guys built the deck on my backyard and they had a plan, right? So they had a plan and it was basically like this small team. Again, it was like three to five people just doing what they needed to do. They came in, they were fully autonomous, did their thing.

If there was a question that the contractor would call me and I would answer and we were off enrolling. But they knew what the end state was. Did they ask the electrician how long the two by eight should get cut down to? Did they ask him how much cement was required for a footing? I kind of feel like what you're touching on with the deck, which is super simple and probably these guys are executing without any confusion. Yeah.

There's no asking, right? So it's only if you run into a problem, right? And yet it's almost like we want to all bring the problems or something. I don't know. I don't know. I don't know really what the, what the, what the right answer is, but I do think it's, I do think, you know, the point here is if you're, if you don't think about sometimes, I guess the point is, is sometimes if you have bad habits, they can lead to on the

unintended consequences of just bad process. I'm also hearing too though from a process perspective that that there's there's a correlation between Complexity and then the importance of clarity perhaps Yeah, it's not more complexity means more bodies It's that more complexity means we need to be able to unpack it in such a way that we can get the clarity to take that correct And then what are your what are your constraints, right? So like, you know, I know I know As I

mentioned before, huge fan of Toyota, you know, One Piece Flow, like in many, many reasons I love the way that they do their business. And they spend three months thinking, thinking and arguing and thinking some more and arguing and thinking some more and arguing. And yet it's just part of their culture because, and they also, they also They've also kind of flipped

the script as far as who's the most important like in their culture The most important are the people that are actually doing the work. I Don't think that I think that's very contrary to our Western capitalists minded hierarchical design. Yep, you know because it's Because it's very easy to be nebulous and then go and take take credit When something emerges, oh my god, so true. It's like it's like You know, it's like my wife, when she, you know, she planted a garden,

you know, it's, it's not like she goes out to the garden and say, look at those seeds that I made. You're like, no, they're just, the seeds just grew. Like, that's just what happens. But like I think the business can be that way. No, it's true. Chris, I think I love this, the birthday paradox. Interesting, probably not the best way to try to solve complex problems. No. Maybe a very common way, but not necessarily the best way. Yeah. This week, next week, just move intentionally.

Yeah. And we'll catch everyone next week. Thanks, man. Good stuff, buddy. All right. See you. See you.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. The Four Categories of Hobbies Every Knowledge Worker Needs for One-Peace Flow

    Nov 16, 202623 minAudio

    The Process Debt Podcast: Improving knowledge work processes to help you reach One Peace Flow. Stop curing cognitive burnout with physical inactivity. Discover how building a balanced ecosystem of off-screen hobbies can...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Where Are You on the Adoption Curve?

    Nov 9, 202622 minAudio

    The Process Debt Podcast: Improving knowledge work processes to help you reach One Peace Flow. Chasing every new AI tool creates friction and burnout. Learn how to pinpoint your spot on the adoption curve and eliminate...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Two Years in Review: Navigating Process Debt and the Last Mile of Knowledge Work

    Nov 2, 202624 minAudio

    The Process Debt Podcast: Improving knowledge work processes to help you reach One Peace Flow. Overcome the costly last mile problem in knowledge work, streamline messy workflows, and unlock single-task focus with...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. The Invisible Warehouse of Waste: Why Knowledge Work Breaks Down and How to Reclaim Flow

    Oct 26, 202620 minAudio

    The Process Debt Podcast: Improving knowledge work processes to help you reach One Peace Flow. Stop losing productive hours to invisible friction, endless rework, and fuzzy handoffs. Here is how to audit hidden waste...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. The Scorecard Trap: Why Obsessing Over Vanity Metrics Kills Knowledge Work Flow

    Oct 19, 202625 minAudio

    The Process Debt Podcast: Improving knowledge work processes to help you reach One Peace Flow. Discover how obsessing over vanity metrics creates hidden process debt, destroys deep focus, and how a four-step framework...

    Credit the people on this episode