Welcome to Process Ailments - Try vs. Buy, where we explore the aches and pains of business processes through the lens of personal wear and tear. This week, Toby's battle with "old man knee" becomes the perfect metaphor for what happens when organizations ignore their process health. We kick things off with a laugh - is it a blood clot or just tight quads? - then dive into the deeper lesson: not every pain means disaster. Some are compound fractures (urgent breakdowns), but most are soft tissue injuries - nagging issues that worsen when ignored. From there, we explore a core tension in modern organizations: Buy: The flashy, top-down push for new systems like SAP - expensive, visible, and often effective, but loaded with hidden rehab work that rarely gets addressed. Try: The gritty, everyday work of process rehab - subtle, high-value, and cheap, but often invisible and undervalued. Why do we replace when we could repair? Why do we glorify the new while neglecting the maintenance? This episode is a call to rethink our instincts - in both our bodies and our businesses - and make space for the slower, less glamorous work that leads to long-term strength.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Well, hello, Toby. It's another week of the process. How are you? I'm good, buddy. How are you doing? Good. We were on the road last week, so we're back. Today's topic, you're kicking it off. I'm kicking it off. What's the topic? I probably sound like I was enjoying time away from the office, and I was. Nice. I was also dealing with something that comes for all of us eventually, and it's a little bit of joint pain. I had a case of old man knee. And now bear with me here,
because I think we'll bring it around for our listeners who may be asking, I don't care how old these guys are. Well, you know, it's it's really great. I don't know about you, but we had the fourth of July holiday. I'd actually taken some personal day before the fourth just to clear my head and really enjoy the weekend. And then a week enrolled into vacation, which was fantastic. Yep. When I'm on vacation. I want to go as hard as I did in my 30s. And strangely,
in my mid -50s, my mind and heart might be willing, but my body don't play ball the same way, right? And so just around the fourth, I remember waking up and trying to move, and God, my knee was so stiff. And I'm fortunate that I don't experience a lot of arthritis. Playing hard with the kids or trying to keep up with the young people or, you know, dancing at a wedding. I feel things differently, but in general, I take pretty good care of myself. Yep. Oh my God, Chris, my knee was killing me and it hurt beneath the, uh, it
hurt beneath my knee cap and it hurt at the back of my knee. Yep. And it was so stiff when I wasn't moving and I'd get up to walk on it and I immediately thought, Oh my God. I didn't think like, is it a strain? I thought. It's a blood clot. I got a blood bite. It's the African whatever spider and it sucked my heart out. So I immediately think, oh my God, I've got a blood clot. It's hit my knee. Is it going to go to the heart of
my brain? Everything's over. It's a good life and I'm done. Are we changing our podcast to the two old guys get old podcast? Bring it back. That's right. Old man ailments. But, you know, as I reflected on it and I walked it out, I didn't immediately go, who do I know that can tell me what's really going on? It's like, you know what? I'll work it out. And then I keep hobbling around on it. It would get better. And then I would sit for a prolonged period of time. We were on
the road last week. And so I had a long section to drive and I got out of my truck and I thought, oh my Lord, I wanted this thing amputated. It's hurting. Yeah. Well, so finally, I'm like, I need to get into the PT, somebody that can actually feel the, the joint. And she said, uh, you've overblown it. It's not a blood clot. So for a week and a half, I'm thinking it's the worst. And then she goes to like, well, and the other good news is your meniscus is fine, but what
you do was you probably move too fast. You've, you know, you've tightened up your quad and your hamstring and it's like, And so a lot of this pain is something that you could have stretched your way out of, Chief. And I'm sitting there kind of going, how much agony and heartache was I trying to ignore, making the most of my short, short life before that blood clot hit that didn't exist. Right. And so here's where we bring it back to our Processed Dead podcast. We have an
old man whining and complaining. In spirit of our podcast, one of the things I was thinking about is How many times do leaders or process owners experience a symptom that they didn't expect? And then how quickly do we go to the worst possible scenario? Yeah. And we're like, oh my God, how much can we get done in light of this thing getting ready to completely blow up? Yeah. Instead of reaching out to the expert. You know, there's somebody that has the special, highly specialized training, especially in mature
organizations that have a fine process. They're in the belly of it, right? What's funny, what that makes me think of is the whole, you know, I'm thinking about processes, right? The podcast. And I just think what's interesting is as processes get old, right? As we get old, we get more brittle, right? Which is unfortunate, but it's, you know, something we all have to go through. Totally.
And to your point, as stuff gets brittle, right? Like stuff starts to show up, right? The older car, when it starts to hit 150 ,000 miles, like stuff starts to happen, right? And you also get overly anxious and there's a mechanic or a physical therapist or whatever that can help us out. Yeah. I think too, and we've talked a lot about our early career experience. Early on, we were fascinated with the mechanics of the process. Yeah. And
we wanted to monitor each of those mechanics. Like that was a source of passion. And then over time, we get a bigger view of how an organization works. Yeah. And that mechanics of a specific process become less critical. Yeah. And so I've had this knee since I was born. I never became expert at how the knee joint functions. And well, but I never would call right. Got me in within 24 hours to say, Hey buddy, don't sweat it. And so. organizationally, your point that you just
touched on about maintenance, I think is such a good one. We may still be in the process that we started our career with, especially if you've been with a company, you know, three, five, 10 years, you've been very expert part of it, but the organization is shifting. And that process may be getting stretched, you know, or maybe it's not getting stretched enough and becomes - Or it's not even needed anymore. Yeah, right. So unlike a knee, you know, business - Unlike a knee. It can evolve too. So maybe liver would have been a better medical example. Setting that
aside, you know. That's funny. It also makes me think of like, how our body, when our bodies break down. Yeah. Right? Like a compound fracture or a broken bone. Yeah. Is actually better, I think also for businesses, than it is a soft tissue injury. Oh boy. Yeah. Right? Like you tear an ACL and you don't have a surgeon. And you're basically living in the 1800s. Hello, Kane. Oh, that's it. You're done. Yeah. And if
you take this back to the business side, what's interesting is we think the strains and pains are compound fractures and they're not. Right. It's a bunch of tissue. Yeah. Correct. Correct. Right? And it's like, no, no, no, no. If it gets really bad, you're going to know. You're going to know. You would swarm it. You would solve the problem. Everybody would come out of the woodwork. And instead, some of these things,
they're just nagging. They're nagging injuries or nagging processes or nagging whatever. And a lot of times we don't do anything about it. We don't. Chris, we complain. I would love to say that I just don't complain. Just make a bold face lie. Who me? Complain? What? Okay, random question. Completely off track. But if Instagram
didn't have funny memes, would you go on it? Probably not. Funny memes and then guys telling me what I should be doing for my health as I go. Yes, that's true I should be doing that and What else should I think I knew that but I should be doing that and then I just yeah You're right. I'm somewhat Completely off -topic and we'll bring it back but completely off -topic. I'm somewhat below I somewhat believe that our algorithms Make us unhappy like they're in the we we we
as the engineers of our algorithms that we don't know that we're in, make ourselves unhappy by clicking on things that make us unhappy. Yeah, we're our own worst enemies, aren't we? Yeah, yeah. And then we're upset all day because we click. For me, it's I clicked on that productivity thing. And it's like, oh, god, I'm just not productive. And you're like, oh, my god, maybe I should just do the work. All right, anyway, back to you. Back to your injury, right? Yeah. Well, and I
think you touched on the point of it and it's like, what is the maintenance? You know, and when we were, when we were teenagers and playing sports, we were told to stretch and we were also damn flexible. It seemed silly. Yeah. Right. And then for those that continue to perform and compete at a higher level, stretching became increasingly important because that was the only way to maximize. But when we start to talk about process, we have that same kind of required maintenance routine, but we don't always prioritize the maintenance piece. If we're getting the right outputs, you
know, the input and then we get the output, we don't think about what's taking place in the middle until it's a compound fracture, until it completely breaks. Well, the other thing that's interesting about the body, right, is we're so... our bodies are so able to be adjustable, right? Like many businesses, really. Yeah, right. Right. You could have injured this 10 years ago. Oh my gosh. Right? And never even known it. And your body just kind of worked around it. You
were sore one morning and the next day you were fine. And then you did something today and all of a sudden, or whatever, or over the weekend, and now you're like... Like, like, and I think that... I think that that maintenance when it comes to businesses and processes and asking why we do things and actually listening to the response, like, I, I slowed down here because
I'm just thinking about different social cues that we follow in business. that actually don't help process. What I mean by that is like, what I mean by that is like going back to Instagram and health, right? It's, you know, I'm gonna do this later, or is this really helpful? And
a lot of times, the real response that we should give, If we're psychologically safe, it would be, that's not helpful. I got nothing out of that. And the answer comes by and says, how are things going today? And you're like, hey, everything's good. What you're saying is, I feel good. And sometimes what you need to be doing is saying, hang on a second, what I'm doing isn't working. So that some of that social interaction too smothers. Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. And it's like that injury,
right? It's not a big deal at first. Right, but it's the second it's the second injury or that's the injury that that's caused by you getting out of kilter Right, so you hurt your knee and all of a sudden it's your ankle hurts, right? Like this happens in businesses, right? So like you hand off a report you hand that up you hand that off upstream and The upstream people don't ever use it or they're reading it wrong or whatever Like it just it's really interesting like to be honest at the beginning of this I was like
I don't know how we're going to get anywhere unprocessed at because we're just going to be two old guys complaining while our knee is. So that's fine. We'll see what happens. Well, Chris, we've done worse broadcasts. We have. I will say, you know, to kind of tie it back, when I think about what process maintenance and debt management looks like, you know, I would say, and I'm thinking about some of so much of the work I did around Sarbanes -Oxley, you know, now a lot of that focus was 15 years ago, but When it came to the financial processes, we were actively measuring every month. What does our
throughput look like? How long does it take to perform a transaction? How many transactions have to get cleaned up? And so there was dimensions of duration and is our duration for a process cycle still the same? We were looking at the quality of the transactions moving through. So it doesn't have to be overblown. It's not like we have to rigorously scrub our process every day, but Even on a quarterly basis, if we take a moment to really ask, is the throughput happening?
Are people getting internal or external customers? Are they getting what they need in a timely fashion? Those are indicators of process health. Not necessarily knee health, but process health. And that's really what tells us if we're accumulating debt. Well, one of my big PUs in the business world is an ever -changing, consistent deliverable. Yes. Right. Whether that's a QBR or monthly something or other or whatever. Like I, and I get, I get
the desire for executives to improve those, improve them, make them look better. But oftentimes the better is more pretty and more pretty isn't necessarily better. Right. Like more More pretty hides a lot of sins. Yeah. We've talked about that before, right? A one -off thing that's done really beautifully
is expect to become a daily report and it's an impossible task. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. It just, it just doesn't work. I think that's a form over function kind of thing, right? And focused on functional health. With our bodies in process, we're going to be happier in the long term. Right. Next topic, rehab or replacement? No. First of all, I don't think you're going to get your knee replaced yet, but the reason why I bring that
up is what I've seen consistently through my career is that processes get so bad. That it requires a replacement. And it's in the act of replacing where the impact is. It's not necessarily in the act of what the replacement is. Meaning processes run amok and they're so bad or something
doesn't work. Then you come in with an SAP or another different piece of software. That comes in, you have to undo all your bad processes, hear a bunch of complaining, stand up a bunch of spreadsheets where the software doesn't work. But generally, I've not seen an implementation that has been fully funded and where executives are behind it. that hasn't had a decent impact.
Now, whether it's the right solution or not, or whether they spent the right amount of money, that's different. But the act of saying, no, we're gonna go change to something really does make processes better. It's pretty fascinating. God, we could do a series of podcasts on rehab versus replacement. I've probably implemented... ERP or ERP -like enterprise -wide systems across multiple functional teams, you know, a couple dozen times with different clients over the years.
And I will tell you, the single most valuable piece is what you just described. Let's tear down today's process and understand how it's working. And then understand how it should work. And that's a book we've worked. That's just good rehab. Either you're going to replace it and do the rehab, or we just do the rehab. is a fragile trust. Yeah, you can never get executives to be like, you know what we're going to do? We're going to go spend a quarter of a million dollars on the same system that everybody complains about.
I know. And yet that probably would work pretty good. Dollar to donuts all day long. The value is so much higher on doing the process improvement. But it's not shiny. It's not definable. I will say when... When we've given a process, redesigned project a name, like code name, watermelon, or something sexy, watermelon's pretty sexy, but when you can name it, and executives can identify a body of work with a name, it makes it seem
more tangible. It gives it shape, right? Yep, yep. So, yeah. No, it's everything like... Good question. I was thinking about merger M &A, right? Oh, sure. So mergers and acquisitions, it's always buy or build. And it's almost like it's buy or try. And I'm actually being a little bit serious on this. Within your internal organization, it should be buy or try. It just should be. And
my guess is the try actually, I don't know. It would be really interesting if there was a study on that. where the output of the try, because the buy, you basically are forcing people to change, right? Whereas the try, you basically need a lot more executive buy -in, a lot more like, this is what we're doing, a lot more, no, it has to follow this way, a lot more design.
But you don't have to train people how to use the tool though. I'll tell you my hypothesis on why there's such a bias towards buy. and we send your value try is that a try exercise takes place in the weeds. That's a guy doing hand -to -hand combat with transactions and bad profits every day. A buy happens at the executive, the board, or the private equity level. And we mask all the suffering and all of that rehab, all that integration and adaptive adoption work.
All of that gets pushed. down and that becomes invisible. But what we get to talk about is a big transaction. We don't make the headlines by thinking we've retooled our supply chain process in this small segment and it's 40 % more effective. Is that because the try doesn't have a name? I think it's not a name. There's like, yeah, back to the name where it's like the decision has, they are constantly in the view of the decision
of the try. Whereas the buy, they basically have to show up, force something, come back when it's done, or come back when it should have been done because it got pushed by a year and a half and $80 million. Most of the headlines that I think about off the top of my head, it'd be an interesting study, but how many headlines are about organizations saying, we took a hard look at some of our core process and we've improved it by 20, 30, 40%.
Sure. Right? Those are more of the exceptions. They're almost always the soft stories instead of the hard news stories. There's, there's no dollars behind them. No, the hard news. Like that's the hardest part, right? Yeah. Like there, there's no, there's no sales department from the SaaS, the SaaS company that's saying, yeah, we save 20 % of our time and you know. No. Well, it's hard, even, even when, uh, And I'm sure you've experienced this being a process guy. You come to them and say, this is broken. If we fix it, it could materially impact. It could
be shaving days off delivery, or it could be saving hundreds or thousands of dollars. Sure. Those don't feel as tangible as cutting a check to buy something. Yeah, yeah. Well, and I would say just culturally, and we'll end it here, but I would say culturally, we are a consumer society. And so therefore that buying is, the decision is easy. It's simpler, right? It's finding budget, right? Whereas the try is more of a deeper thinking. And I would say the people that are good at trying
are hard to find. Yeah, well said. Like your tires. It's a different skill set because it's... It's influencing, it's leading, it's hard human work. It's making hard decisions in known ecosystems. It's holding people accountable to those known non -Excel processes. It's staying on. And the
thing is, it could be so cheap, because really all you need is one or two people and the executive to say, I need it this way. Like that's the funny thing. Yeah. Chris, I think this episode is the culture of buy versus try. Cause what you called out is a cultural mindset, right? Ship from consumerism to maintenance and reinvestment. Yeah. But yeah. Culture of buy or try and old man knee. Maybe that's how this will go. Old man knee. Cry or buy. That's it. I love it. Have a great week.
The Process Debt Podcast: Improving knowledge work processes to help you reach One Peace Flow. Stop curing cognitive burnout with physical inactivity. Discover how building a balanced ecosystem of off-screen hobbies can...
The Process Debt Podcast: Improving knowledge work processes to help you reach One Peace Flow. Chasing every new AI tool creates friction and burnout. Learn how to pinpoint your spot on the adoption curve and eliminate...
The Process Debt Podcast: Improving knowledge work processes to help you reach One Peace Flow. Overcome the costly last mile problem in knowledge work, streamline messy workflows, and unlock single-task focus with...
The Process Debt Podcast: Improving knowledge work processes to help you reach One Peace Flow. Stop losing productive hours to invisible friction, endless rework, and fuzzy handoffs. Here is how to audit hidden waste...
The Process Debt Podcast: Improving knowledge work processes to help you reach One Peace Flow. Discover how obsessing over vanity metrics creates hidden process debt, destroys deep focus, and how a four-step framework...