One year of Process Debt is officially in the books! 🎉 In this milestone episode, Chris and Toby take a surprising detour from discussing Wall Street internships to exploring a lollipop factory in Boise, where defects are easy to spot (nobody wants a half-melted Rodman Pop). However, in knowledge work, defects often hide in plain sight. What qualifies as a "bad lollipop" when your day is filled with emails, PowerPoint presentations, meetings, and dashboards? Is novelty the same as productivity? How can you determine if you're producing valuable outcomes or just cluttering the system with appealing but ineffective work? Join us as we delve into why defining what is "good" in knowledge work is challenging, how invisible waste sneaks into our calendars, and why applying Six Sigma principles to PowerPoints might not be as outrageous as it seems.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Guess what, Toby? It is episode 52 of the Prosthetic Podcast. Dude, that's awesome. We're coming up on a full lap. I know. We made it. We made it. I love it. Lap around the sun. Like far up. I'm kidding. What's on your mind this week? I have been thinking, well, first of all, you may not know this, but I had two completely opposite internships. when I was in college. So first
one at Merrill Lynch, just in a local branch, just kind of learning about the stock market. That was the first one. It's a solid internship. The second one, completely different at a lollipop factory. At a lollipop factory. What was there? I kid you not. I was eating lots of lollipops is what I was doing. So jealous they can. It was a local lollipop factory in Boise, Idaho. They made the Rodman pop. If you remember Dennis
Rodman, he was the worm. He had a worm pop. That was their kind of lame name. Man, how did I miss that? I know. So anyways, this leads to the topic. It's his most enviable internship at this besides bringing it old Dennis Rodman. Yeah. So we had defects. Meaning you would put the lollipop in and it would press it around the stick. And maybe you didn't have enough of the lollipop mixture. Nobody wants a partial Rodman. Nobody wants a
partial lollipop. They had lots of defects. Like there were lollipops all over the place that were partials or they didn't print well. You could take home as many lollipops as you wanted. I didn't have health insurance because of an internship, so I could have got diabetes, but you know, whatever. But what was interesting of what this made me think of recently was in knowledge work Where do defects go? Because in
the lollipop factory we had we had these defects and we had like bags like hundreds of pounds of lollipops that just didn't make the cut and So this is made me think about my day job Where do like word does? Knowledge work have defects. Do you not, do you not have a Agnex to your trash can by your feet specifically for bad ideas and effective deliverables? Chris, that's a really
great question, right? That power probably sucks. Throw it in the trash. Okay. Get off your computer, get it out of there. Or it infects everything. What are you doing? You raise a good question. And you know, with a physical good, We have a very clear expectation for what that looks like. How do we, what's the template for a good idea and a good piece of knowledge? What a slippery slope. The thing that, you know, the thing that
is, was kind of eye -opening, you know, when you start this internship is that, and maybe the difference between a factory and typing emails all day is that Because you're moving physical product, that physical product that is defective is obvious. And if it's obvious enough, the problem is fixed. It's both fixed. Whereas if you send
out an email that has a misspelling or you have a PowerPoint and you continue to basically communicate in a way that's not received, that could definitely be considered a defect. But it's never seen it. It makes me wonder You and so many folks in the world of lollipop manufacturing actually produce better products than the modern knowledge worker and I might almost argue that by definition we don't know what our spec is anymore and so we
kind of shuffle information and to your point if the spelling is correct and if the logic is Holds together at all that it's hard to argue that you missed the goal, right? So yeah, so in a modern computer driven world where we get paid to be plugged into little monitors all day long What's a good work product? And where does the bad how do you identify the bad work product to put in the bag to be taken home each night?
Yikes. Yes. Have you slept at all this week? I've been sleeping. But it is really interesting, right? In that like knowledge work is a lot about novelty. But novelty isn't productivity. Novelty is just novelty. Yowzer. And so like, you know, I think the reason why process that has always stood out like kind of been this earworm that I've had and we've talked about it for years.
You and I have. But I think it's because I'm so kinesthetic and so I learned by doing and So oftentimes I'll be and I might be a little bit ADHD But like I'll be sitting in meetings and I'm like, why are we here? Like what are we doing? Do we know who our audience is? Do we know who our customer is in this meeting? I think Most of the time you could probably say you don't Like you're just here because we're supposed to have meetings and if a meetings on my calendar I should show up That is how it works,
right? I tell you how many, how many mid to latter quarter career professionals I work with that do say, I have a whole series of meetings, I'm jammed up, I'm packed. It's one thing if you're being called on to make decisions, but a lot of it, what is it that we're transforming input, activity, output? Well, what's interesting is in knowledge work so like in contrast to the lollipop factory They're these big old bins,
you know, like these big basically pots in that which you would cook the You know the sugar mixture and you would add in the flavors and do all the things right? But you would get it you'd basically get it hot and then you'd put it in these kind of roller things and the roller things would kind of turn it into a little rope a little rope would be stamped right the interesting thing is like You can't delay. You can never delay. And that delay creates the defects, right? So like, there was these women that would be putting
the sticks in to get it stamped. And it was really pretty awesome to watch them. They would just basically put the sticks in and they would lay the lollipops down on the dryer. But the reason I bring that up is like, in knowledge work, there's no hardening of that candy. there's no urgency to get anything done. And so it can be this perpetual meeting and clarification during the meeting, after the meeting, pre -meeting, post -meeting.
Just, let's just do another meeting and talk. Yeah. Well, and so if you have anybody at the table that has at all a procrastinating bone in their body, that one brief meeting can turn into a month's worth of follow -up and nothing ever happens. Yeah. Even as you say that, Chris, I'm looking around my desk at the six half -finished things that I... Yeah. Maybe that's a unique thing, but we've talked about those moments of
getting into flow and having enough clear running room to really be super productive. There was a lot of good things that happened today, but one of them was not... crossing important objectives off my list. And I started the day with two or three, and I finished the day with the same two or three plus two more. So somehow I managed to go backwards and didn't get a single finished Dennis Rodman hollypop out the door. I know. That does remind me of like everybody in January,
like, what is it, your New Year's resolution, my New Year's resolution is still just 20 pounds. Only 25 more to go, you know, something like that. Like that's what college work feels like a lot of times. Well, Chrissy, I think it's an interesting thing because, you know, as Gen Xers, we were told that the path to success, and I think it was in terms of professional success and certainly not working in the heat or the cold of whatever weather you're exposed to, but it was go to school, get a good job and, and
do good work. And the difficulty, in this professional realm, unless we're providing some very clear cut transactional service, you know, for in the business of banking and our job is lending or as an attorney, we're producing a specific deliverable for a client. Oftentimes it's hard to see what the transactional start and stop of something is, especially when we're inside of a big organization. You know we could toil away for for weeks or months or years and not see the completion of
the whole cycle necessarily So yeah Well, there's a bit of a lulling to sleep right because you can have so much ways with the knowledge work that You know everybody productive. Yeah, not effective Where it's like the real defective knowledge work is just doing useless well, you know And it's so hard to know, you know, I think we talked about this a couple of weeks ago, just being aligned oftentimes or misaligned. Like
we talked about communication and how that's kind of like, hey, we need this thing. And you're like, is that really what you need? Are you looking for something deeper? Kind of doing that five why analysis. And I think, you know, because we're social and because we're territorial and communal. beings We can get away with that waste because of the communities which are the our places of employment, but But you can't do that
on the factory because you've got money that goes into raw materials and that raw materials Has to you know turn into a sucker and get a wrapper on it. It is interesting and I think you make a distinction too between knowledge work that is directly facing a customer where it's the product versus knowledge work inside of a really complex organism that we call a corporation, right? And the more steps removed we are from servicing a customer, the boundaries become and
the less clear the actual purpose of the work becomes, or at least is at risk of becoming less clear. Yeah. And one of the things we've talked about a lot is like, What's the output? And I think a lot of times we confuse outcome, what actually happened with the never ending process of meetings and emails and PowerPoints. You know, like one of the things we've done in the past was a cashflow calculator, which was like, look, if you just broke your finances out and you did
a prediction every month, if we simply did one thing in business is we just analyze people's ability to predict and be accurate. we would find oftentimes we are promoting the confident, inexperienced, right, or the confident storytellers. And maybe not necessarily the people that are more accurate. Well, Chris, so the idea of what is defective knowledge work, I like this topic that we've talked through it. There's some examples
where it is, it doesn't produce an outcome. That feels like wasted time, but Maybe there's other elements, like how do listeners approach this idea of managing to lower defects? How do we six -signa the defects out of knowledge work? I think we have to be really curious and inquisitive, right? So like the funny thing is you're talking about defects and I instantly went to really nice PowerPoints that have no basis in reality,
right? Where you get Crops or you get resources based on that pretty output but really from a system standpoint that could be a defect because you're actually not helping the system because you're rewarding you're sending resources to areas that either aren't proven or Aren't questioned or right, you know, whatever well and how many hours go into beautifying a PowerPoint concept for an audience of ten or less They I know that
I've but that's the norm. That's what was expected Not a productive use of time and energy But yeah prettier it is what it feels right the more qualified the opinion appears Well, the thing is it just works that's the problem right like it's almost like it's our internal Storytelling in a human defect of like we'll believe a story Because we have to, because our world is so complex. If you have props, it's that much more believable.
It's super interesting, this idea of defects. I think we could all take a minute to ask ourselves, like, what defects am I living with that absorb my attention, my energy, or simply clutter the landscape of important things? So sometimes it's just bad requests, right? Oh, the urgent? Absolutely. Over the important? If you can do Excel or you can, you know, create a Power BI report, the
urgent over the important is just a, that is just a, man, that hits me good because I've been in those roles where I've seen people get destroyed by like, oh, you have another flavor of the month report. You're like, well, is it accurate? And you're like, well, we're not really sure. It's impossible to know, but we're going to do it anyway. Yeah, yeah, how many times are we gonna use this? Oh, just this one time. It's like well, you're never gonna you're actually never going to improve That report if you're just gonna be at one time cuz I know it's funny I had a really
good a good friend that was just phenomenal at creating just stitching data together and creating yeah reports and You know, he was telling me one time where he he delivered the report his report kind of got some legs within the organization And it kind of led to two camps of thought that were completely different. That would definitely be the same data supporting two. Yeah, two contrary opinions. And he's like, Oh my gosh. Yeah, that
would be a difference. I think even as we talk this through, it just makes me think we have the international standards for everything under the sun. You know, from ball bearings to grease viscosity to actual process work, I guess, goes back to this. To define a defect, we have to know what the standard is. I think today's conversation is that question of, if you don't know what good is like, if you don't know what the use of the output is, then there's probably more inquiry,
you know, that's necessary before you just lunge in. Yeah. Well, the interesting thing is like I would say is is it simply repeatable And if it's not repeatable and you're not doing a one -off analysis Then you probably are there's probably a land of defects In your email in your you know Excel folders and your power bi reports if it
You're living with defects and actually probably causing defects. I want more Dennis Rodman lollipops. I mean, there you go. I'll have to look them up and send you and see if anybody's selling them on eBay. But we made it through a year, my friend. Happy year. Year of conversations. Thank you for letting us do another year of these. See you next week. All right. See you. Bye.
The Process Debt Podcast: Improving knowledge work processes to help you reach One Peace Flow. Stop curing cognitive burnout with physical inactivity. Discover how building a balanced ecosystem of off-screen hobbies can...
The Process Debt Podcast: Improving knowledge work processes to help you reach One Peace Flow. Chasing every new AI tool creates friction and burnout. Learn how to pinpoint your spot on the adoption curve and eliminate...
The Process Debt Podcast: Improving knowledge work processes to help you reach One Peace Flow. Overcome the costly last mile problem in knowledge work, streamline messy workflows, and unlock single-task focus with...
The Process Debt Podcast: Improving knowledge work processes to help you reach One Peace Flow. Stop losing productive hours to invisible friction, endless rework, and fuzzy handoffs. Here is how to audit hidden waste...
The Process Debt Podcast: Improving knowledge work processes to help you reach One Peace Flow. Discover how obsessing over vanity metrics creates hidden process debt, destroys deep focus, and how a four-step framework...