Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Practically Ranching

Practically Ranching artwork

#93 - Stephen Koontz - Uncertainty is a Cost

Oct 28, 20261 hr 6 minAudio

Send us Fan Mail Dr. Stephen Koontz is a Professor and Economist in the Department of Agricultural and Resource Economics at Colorado State University, specializing in agricultural commodity markets, agribusiness, and risk management. In this episode, we talk about beef industry infrastructure, packer concentration, imports, price discovery of fed cattle and changing technology in the valuation of feeder cattle. Links: https://www.podbean.com/ew/pb-498yg-1b86543 - Working Ranch Radio episode stephen.koontz@colostate.edu

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SpeakerWell, hello there, and thanks for listening to episode 93 of Practically Ranching. I'm your host, Matt Perrier, and we're here thanks to Dalebanks Angus, your source for practical, profitable genetics since 1904. We're excited to host our annual bull and heifer sale Saturday, November 21st, northwest of Eureka, Kansas. We'll sell 150 bulls and five registered fall heifers. We'd love to have you at the ranch or bidding online at cci.live. For information on the cattle, check out our searchable online catalog at dalebanks.com or email us your address for your printed copy.

SpeakerIn addition to the sale, we'll have a nice set of fall-born registered replacement heifers, selling those currently at private treaty. There are 25 head in the group, and, uh, will make a great start to a registered herd or to add to your herd already. Just email me at mattperrier@dalebanks.com if you'd like information on these private treaty heifers. This episode's guest is Stephen Koontz. Dr. Koontz is a professor and economist in the Department of Ag and Resource Economics at Colorado State University, specializing in agricultural commodity markets, agribusiness, and risk management.

SpeakerI'm gonna share the impetus of this discussion in just a few minutes, so I won't, uh, bore you with those details now, but it ended up being a pretty wide-ranging conversation where I think we hit just about every lightning rod issue that fires beef producers up. So I guess I should prepare myself for any hate mail or ribbing, uh, that may come after this. Some of the main topics are price discovery of fed cattle, we've talked about it before, the confrontational nature within our beef supply chain, same, overcapacity at the feed yard and packer levels, new technologies at the feed yards for sourcing and, managing cattle, uh, packer concentration, packer ownership of competing proteins, imports and exports.

SpeakerI'm sure we left one or two hot rocks unturned, but not very many. This is another one of those episodes that probably is not going to give you any black-and-white answers. I'm not sure any of these podcasts ever do, but I hope it'll give you a bit of perspective as we visit with our neighbors and, and other industry participants. I hope it arms us with some more information and some more perspective and maybe some more- insight into how our beef supply chain functions after those calves leave the ranch and the farm and go on into the supply chain.

SpeakerI'll elaborate about this in the opening, but I wanna thank Justin Mills at Working Ranch Radio Show for having Dr. Koontz on his podcast a week or two ago, which gave me the idea for this follow-up conversation. Like you'll hear, I really suggest that you listen to that episode, maybe even before you go any further on this one,'cause we'll reference it several times, and we try to kinda give a summary of that discussion, but, um, it was a really good one and one I think you would like to hear as well. I've put a link to that show in our show notes, or you can search for Working Ranch Radio on your podcast platform.

SpeakerAs always, I appreciate you listening. If you like what we're doing here on the podcast, give us a rating or a review or share the podcast with somebody else. We appreciate your time, and I hope you'll enjoy this conversation with Dr. Stephen Koontz

matt_1_10-26-2026_105624we have, uh, actually crossed paths a time or two. I don't think we've ever officially met, but the first time I heard you speak, I was at a cattle industry meeting. I think I may have been incoming president or something of Kansas Livestock Association, and there was...

squadcaster-hiie_1_10-26-2026_095624of KLA,

matt_1_10-26-2026_105624Yes. Yeah, years ago, uh,'16, I think. And I wanna say this was before that, so we're talking 10 plus years ago. Um, NCBA had formed what they called, I think, the Live Cattle Marketing Working Group or something to try to address price discovery within our industry and figure out the, you know, A, if we had enough cash cattle that were able to function in all regions and make sure that we had something to base these grids off of, and if we didn't, how should we?

matt_1_10-26-2026_105624And, uh, there were a lot-- I mean, it was, tensions were high. Everybody was, you know, trying to kinda guard their territory and their belief system and, and we had plenty of heated discussions. I don't remember all of them, but I remember this guy from Colorado State stood up there at the front of this room and very calmly said,"I have an idea, but you all probably aren't gonna like it." And you, you outlined this thought of"market makers" where we would pay people in the feed yard industry probably, who could and wanted to or they still were maybe able to trade cattle in the cash market, and we would pay them to do that.

matt_1_10-26-2026_105624And I leaned over to, I think Clayton Huseman or someone with KLA staff was next to me, and I said,"That is the craziest thing I've ever heard." And, and he said,"Yeah, it may be just crazy enough that it's worth looking at."

squadcaster-hiie_1_10-26-2026_095624Probably the only thing that's gonna work as far as I can tell,'cause we're in the same, we're in the same spot.

matt_1_10-26-2026_105624We are

squadcaster-hiie_1_10-26-2026_095624You know, we're not, y- you know, everybody says,"Well, Kansas will get back to reporting when When somebody comes back online, I forget who, and I was like, you know, I've talked enough to AMS to know that, uh, all of those are, are really skinny. And you gotta have somebody, you know, that... And, uh, it's unfortunate AMS hasn't been much help in figuring out, you know, what category can we, can we trade some cattle and, and actually make a market that, that folks are happy with.

squadcaster-hiie_1_10-26-2026_095624And'cause everybody wants to be on the formula. Nobody wants to do that work. And, and, you know, if you, if you taxed everybody just a little bit, all the formulas just a little bit to pay somebody to, to trade a cash market and pick the guy you wanna trade to make the cash market or, or, or woman. I mean, you know, I don't care who you pick. Pick somebody to make a cash market for you and do it. Do it on a weekly basis,

matt_1_10-26-2026_105624Yeah.

squadcaster-hiie_1_10-26-2026_095624Know, if the, if the industry doesn't ever wanna do that, I think the cash markets are, are going away. I mean, they're just You know, that, so we have a, we have a executive order for AMS to report, what is it, Colorado, Kansas, and Texas all together in what, as one region, and I don't, I, you know, we need a southern price. We need a southern price. There is a discrep- there is not a discrepancy, um, wrong choice of words.

squadcaster-hiie_1_10-26-2026_095624There is a difference between the North and South and what cattle are worth. We need a N- we need a northern price and a southern price, and we really need two prices, and that's probably enough to, to make it work

matt_1_10-26-2026_105624Well, we could dedicate the whole podcast to that, and I've had a few over the last few years that we talked about that. Uh, but I, I believed it then. That's why KLA had their working group going in'15 and'16 trying to address this, and this is way before so many of the Black Swan events"We've been having these discussions for at least five or six years and largely 10 years trying to figure out," um, and here we are once again. We're in pretty good cattle times. This is the time to be d-addressing some of these things when we can take the emotions out and say,"What do we need to do to make sure that we don't have to lose," you know, you call them for-formulas, I call them value-based marketing, opportunities to value these carcasses, but we have to have some sort of a base, whether that's off of a retail price index or a cash market

squadcaster-hiie_1_10-26-2026_095624it's, I think it's important to have a cattle price because, um, you know, you need a, you need a calf price, you need a feeder animal price, you need a fed cattle price, you need a wholesale box beef. Um, all those prices are going to the composite value, and then, you know, the retail price is kinda out the window. I don't think, know, effectively, we really don't have retail prices because what is collected is the... So the, um, commerce goes in and scans the,

matt_1_10-26-2026_105624That barcode.

squadcaster-hiie_1_10-26-2026_095624so they will scan the packages of the retailers that will let'em in the store. And for example, I, I m- I might be wrong on this, but I seem to remember that Walmart isn't part of that. I Nobody gets into Walmart to see what Walmart's up to, and that's, you know, not... That by itself is a problem. And then so you have none of the, the shopper card discounts that show up on the price, so the price is easily 30% overstated, and, and sometimes 60%. So, you know, you kinda gotta throw the retail out the window and figure out where...

squadcaster-hiie_1_10-26-2026_095624I, I do think all the different levels, as long as there's different businesses in the different levels and they're not integrated. You know, for example, the pork industry, you have so many, uh, hog farmers that own packers and packers that feed hogs that, that, that, that h- that farm level hog price isn't much needed. What you need is a wholesale price, I think they have, they have effective price reporting at the wholesale level. It's less than what they, what they think it is, but I...

squadcaster-hiie_1_10-26-2026_095624You know, if it was a big enough problem, I think they'd do something about it. hog guys are pretty, uh, pretty proactive

matt_1_10-26-2026_105624are that. They are that. Well, that isn't, and we may come back to that if we have time at the end, but that's price discovery, fed cattle price discovery topic, while very important, it's probably not the thing that I wanted to talk to you about today. But I- as I listened to you and heard your, your voice, uh, come across the podcast waves last week, it, it reminded me of that time when I thought you were the c- you were the looniest guy at that whole NCBA convention But again, the more I think about it, the more it probably has some legs.

matt_1_10-26-2026_105624But so I, I, I have a confession to make to my listeners. I don't love to listen to other beef industry podcasts simply because I'm tempted to call the guy or gal I heard on that one and have another discussion. And so I, I usually tell myself,"Don't do it," because just send people... If it was a good podcast, send people to that one. So I'm gonna do a little of both. I heard you talking with Justin Mills on the Working Ranch Radio podcast a week, week and a half ago, and I thought it was a great discussion.

matt_1_10-26-2026_105624I thought you all hit on some really good topics, and there were several of those I thought,"Man, that could be a podcast in and of itself." And so hats off to you and Justin. I don't usually do this, but I called you up and asked, or emailed you, and asked if you'd do another one, and you graciously said yes. So first off, if people have time, I would suggest that you go to Working Ranch Radio and listen to your episode 270, episode 270 on Working Ranch Radio show. Um, in case you aren't able to spare that 30 or 40 minutes right now, I'm gonna give what I would call the CliffsNotes version of your discussion,'cause we're gonna reference a few of these points that you all talked about then.

matt_1_10-26-2026_105624A- and if I miss any of these, Dr. Kuntz, you tell me, correct me, and, uh, tell me what you really said or what you meant to say. Um, first off, as we talk about decreased cattle inventories, I think I heard you say they're largely smaller here in the U.S. due to drought in several different areas, prolonged. Um, there are also decreased inventories because of New World screw worm and, and ceasing the import of Mexican calves. And so that has resulted in quite a bit of excess feed yard capacity in the South, um, processing capacity throughout, but largely in the South.

matt_1_10-26-2026_105624And as we talked about, or as you all talked about in the processing segment, this excess capacity is gonna result, has resulted and is gonna continue to result in some closures because they, unlike maybe some of our family ranches who just kinda tough through those times of loss, they have stockholders who don't let them do that for very long. This, um- I thought was really interesting, you said that beef segments have historically been confrontational, so cow-calf, quote-unquote, versus stockers versus feed yards versus processors versus retailers, all trying to make sure that on the buy and on the sell, they make some money.

matt_1_10-26-2026_105624So we've historically been really confrontational, and we tend to demonize each other. This emotion-laden relationship often makes it difficult for markets to work efficiently. Is that close?

squadcaster-hiie_1_10-26-2026_095624Yeah, I, I, I can't disagree with anything you said

matt_1_10-26-2026_105624Okay

squadcaster-hiie_1_10-26-2026_095624I mean, we, we tend to think in backup that, um, you know, markets work and you need to back up and let them work, and the problem is you can have are k- there are things that, that do prevent markets from working well. And confrontational relationships, a lack of communication is one of those things, and a lack of understanding or a lack of a kind of transparency or a, a vision of what's gonna happen next, um, for the next three months, six months, uh, two years, can, can create real issues in resource allocation and how do you, how do you set up a, a supply chain and, and make sure it works and, and is functioning over time?

matt_1_10-26-2026_105624And going into this or going into that, you made a statement, and I'm gonna make you say it again'cause I, I didn't get it verbatim. But in regard to cattle supplies today, inventories of cows, calves, feed yard cattle, whatever the case may be, can you tell me again what you said there, if you remember it, about comparing today's cattle numbers to those of the 1970s and'80s or'50s or'60s?

squadcaster-hiie_1_10-26-2026_095624You know, you've gotta be careful with somebody who wants to compare things to the'60s,'70s, or'80s. You know, are they up to something? Because, um, you know, the cattle are, the, the cattle are, are much bigger today. Think back to 2022. We have very tight... We, we have pretty small numbers even in'22 or'21 compared to the, for example, the peak in the'70s. Uh, but we had record, uh, beef production in 2022.

squadcaster-hiie_1_10-26-2026_095624Uh, the production was absolutely record. Well, well, how do you, how do you have record beef production with cow numbers down so far? The carcasses are so much bigger. You know, the animals themself, the fed animals are so much bigger. The carcasses are so much bigger. You know, the typical, um, the typical calf, uh, is a, is a bigger thing nowadays.

matt_1_10-26-2026_105624Yeah, and I, I think that most of us recognize that and get that, that as far as pounds of beef sold, we've been fairly similar through the decades. We just do more with less today. And, and there's some, there are some, um, unintended consequences of that at the ranch level and, and, um, some costs associated with that in terms of animal welfare and, structural issues and things like that. And I, I think those are things we need to address. But yeah, I, I just thought it was interesting that, um, you kinda called out folks that wanna just blame all the woes of the beef industry, on the fact that we have fewer cattle today than we did before

squadcaster-hiie_1_10-26-2026_095624positive thing, uh, there is, you know, if you think about it, we can, we can supply what there is for a market with a much smaller cow herd. Uh, we're just simply able to do a lot more terms of, um, uh, pounds of beef at the wholesale level going into retail. Uh, we can s- we can satisfy that market much more effectively with a much smaller cow herd because we're... we grow them, uh, so much more effectively, and that's not to...

squadcaster-hiie_1_10-26-2026_095624I'm not, I'm not trying to, create any issues with animal welfare or should we be doing that. That's, that's, uh, um, you know, I, I d- I don't wanna ignore those problems. I'm not saying they're not important. I'm saying this is where we are now. We, we simply have a lot bigger cattle than we've had in the past, and we don't need anything like the herd size we did in the'60s or'70s to, to satisfy a market and even, uh, produce enough to effectively export to much of the world

matt_1_10-26-2026_105624So as we talk about those lower cattle numbers, whether that be because of drought, uh, whether that be because certain times of the year we don't- we just don't produce as many calves coming to market here in the US, we've filled those gaps with typically, historically, Mexican feeder cattle imports, sometimes Canadian fat cattle or fed cattle imports, beef on dairy, dairy calves before that. As we look at that, especially over the last year or so when those Mexican cattle were pulled out of the mix because of new world screw worm and closing that border, what's the cost to our industry of just saying,"Let's not let any more imported cattle in.

matt_1_10-26-2026_105624We're gonna do with what we can, just with our domestic cattle"? And then our consumers at the same time are still demanding the same amount of beef. And so we, instead of importing calves and getting the goodie of them as they go through the system, feed yards, processors, et cetera, we import beef and nobody makes any money except the importer, or the retailer that bought that. W-What kind of cost? I don't know that we have to go exact dollars and cents, but I think personally there are some significant infrastructure challenges to do that when we do grow the herd a little bit, not to 1970s size, but do grow that and all of a sudden we don't have any place to go with these cattle because we shut the Mexican cattle out.

squadcaster-hiie_1_10-26-2026_095624Yeah, you know, the, the thing with the, the beef industry is it is so big and it's, uh, there's segments of it that are so land intensive that, you wind up with separate ownership at different stages of the system. So cow-calf ownership tends to, you know, it'll spread over and do some stocker operations, but it-- they, they tend to not be too involved with cattle feeding. If you have a big cattle feeding organization, they're not reaching back into the ranch level, and they're not involved in packing.

squadcaster-hiie_1_10-26-2026_095624So you have separate profit centers throughout the supply chain, which is, you know, much less so in, for example, poultry, uh, and less, less so to some degree with respect to hogs. So y- you know, in the end w- w- with smaller numbers, and if we, you know, if we limit imports from anywhere In, in any dimension, you're gonna lose capacity at some point in time.

squadcaster-hiie_1_10-26-2026_095624We will lose cattle feeding capacity in the Southern Plains without Mexican cattle. And, and again, what we do on the borders is not gonna change the nu- I don't think it's gonna change the number of animals that we'll have in, for example, North America. Uh, those cattle will be in Mexico. Uh, will they be fed in Mexico and then packed in Mexico? Or will they come up here and be potentially more efficiently fed here, be packed more efficiently here, then where does the meat go?

squadcaster-hiie_1_10-26-2026_095624It, it may go back to Mexico, it may stay here. You know, but, but simply closing up the borders doesn't change what's happening in North America. It does create incentives. You know, once you close that border with Mexico, those, those cattle are, have to stay home. Well, if they have to stay home, let's figure out how to feed them. Let's build some infrastructure to get some cattle feeding going. Um, they'll probably import, uh, grain sorghum, milo to, to feed them. They, they do that very effectively with poultry, and they'll probably expand some of their packing capacity that they have in northwest Mexico.

squadcaster-hiie_1_10-26-2026_095624So, you know, the, the, you know, where does it happen? Uh, keeping, keeping the borders closed is gonna, is gonna do things that, that, um, disrupts our infrastructure here, in particular cattle feeding, in particular in the Southern Plains. And, you know, that, that industry became very effective in satisfying kinda early You know, that, that's the place you can feed cattle, uh, most effectively through the winter, have supplies in the early spring. Whereas, uh, what's going on, you know, the, the cattle that are showing up now in, in October, you know, that's very effectively fed in the Northern Plains and the Upper Midwest.

squadcaster-hiie_1_10-26-2026_095624So, so we had some seasonal diversification, in the past that's, that's less so now. So i- in, in the end, we wind up, tightening up supplies of packing capacity, feedlot capacity. we'll, we'll run stocker operations out of business, and once you, once you lose that experience, it's, it's typically hard to get it back, and it, it's not something that, uh, that once you stop, you can just restart

matt_1_10-26-2026_105624Do we have any good data yet to know just how much of that infrastructure has been built in Mexico, if any? Or did they limp through and get by and those cattle will resume to normal?

squadcaster-hiie_1_10-26-2026_095624good question. I don't know. You have to have better connections with, with, uh, investors than I do. But I do know that there are people, um,"Hey, this is now an opportunity. Let's go take a look at it. We'll do some investing here." There are individuals there that, that are good businesspeople, um, are trustworthy, good at what they do, and if they had a little more capital, they could probably do a little, do a little more of it, and, uh, there's plenty of that going around. We've proved that with respect to the, with respect to the poultry industry, it, it w- I think it would be unfortunate to, to prove it again with respect to beef

matt_1_10-26-2026_105624Whether it's accurate or not, some of the talk you hear on the street is maybe it's not the most trustworthy. They may be good businessmen, but might not be the most trustworthy folks that are making some investment in processing capacity and down there.

squadcaster-hiie_1_10-26-2026_095624you know, you've gotta know who you're dealing

matt_1_10-26-2026_105624Yeah, sure

squadcaster-hiie_1_10-26-2026_095624and, um, know, I, and I don't wanna come across as talking down or speaking bad about anybody in that capacity. That's, that's, uh, that, that's, uh, that's a country that's not very far away that certainly has developing country issues with respect to, infrastructure and property rights and things like that. And, the better that becomes over time, the better everybody is gonna be, both in that, uh, in that s- society and in their neighboring societies

matt_1_10-26-2026_105624Sure. as we talk about the feed yards, you mentioned a couple times in that podcast last week about feed yards using technology and more information to better source, maybe better predict outcomes, and assess the value or purchase value of some of those calves and yearlings that they're, they're buying. Let's get more specific. What, what do you see feed yards using today, and maybe what do you envision them using in the coming months and years when it comes to assessing what they're willing to pay for a set of calves, that are either coming through a market on a video, direct trade, whatever the case may be?

squadcaster-hiie_1_10-26-2026_095624Yeah, um, that is a great question. I wish I could give you a straightforward answer. The more I talk about this, the less those folks are willing to talk to me.

matt_1_10-26-2026_105624Okay, I see

squadcaster-hiie_1_10-26-2026_095624gonna shade my answers just a little bit'cause,'cause I like being able to call them up and say,"What the hell are you doing?"

matt_1_10-26-2026_105624That's fair

squadcaster-hiie_1_10-26-2026_095624know,"What are you doing? What's going on?" So I don't wanna lean on anything that sounds like trade secrets, and there are some really innovative businesses ha- that are It, it, it appears to me they're, they're pretty effectively using things that might um, tinker around the edges of, of using AI to collect visual information, on, on animals, things like uniformity, things like identifying temperature and potential sickness and things like that.

squadcaster-hiie_1_10-26-2026_095624but, but one of the main things they've done is they've created an, an entire history of what they've done business for Uh, easily 20 years. 20 years' worth of business records. I can go through all of the cattle I've fed for the last 20 years and figure out, you know, so let's take a snapshot in time what I was buying in October and what did really well and what didn't, and let's chase back through where I think I got those animals from, because they've done v- they've been very effective at identifying...

squadcaster-hiie_1_10-26-2026_095624understanding is they've been effective at identifying where the animals have come from. Now, there's still some randomness. There's still some environment. It's, it's still an imperfect system. The identification is, is tougher than it used to be. But I tell you what, it's gotten really good with respect to the beef on dairy. Those beef on dairy calves, we know exactly where they came from. We know exactly what bull they were bred to. We know... You know, we don't have a real good history on the, on the performance of the dairy animal, but we have a better history of that animal's genetics than we do many beef cows.

squadcaster-hiie_1_10-26-2026_095624So, there's a level of information there that's now quite good, but almost every cattle feeder I've ever talked to has an extensive database on everything they've ever done, and they try to replicate things that were, were done really well, and they try not to do stuff that didn't make money. So you dig through your records and you try to figure out, was that a feeding issue? Was that a temperature issue? Was that water? Was that weather? What was that? And, and if it's something as straightforward as, uh, time of the year, where I bought those animals, who I bought them from, um, and if they did great, let's, let's go get them and do those again.

squadcaster-hiie_1_10-26-2026_095624There's, there's a lot of that that goes on. And that was, you know, that was my understanding, and this has been, you know, years and years ago. Lots of those, uh, significant cattle feeding organizations really, uh, looked hard at their records to try to figure out what was successful and what wasn't

matt_1_10-26-2026_105624Yeah, I've often commented to customers, other cow-calf producers that, um, the feed yard probably knows more about our cattle than we do, um, when it comes to the health, the gain, efficiency, of course carcass value, things like that. And, and they do keep track of it. And, uh, so as, as we talk about, you know, privacy of information and, and even national identification programs and, and folks having some heartburn sometimes about somebody knowing where those cattle came from.

matt_1_10-26-2026_105624Well, I know a stocker operator who buys one and two calf purchase out of the southeast and gets truckloads of them, and he has a very simple Excel spreadsheet that he retains back tags and he knows whether those cattle had a permanent ID or not, he knows exactly what barn those came from, who bought them. And if he has problems, he goes back to them and lets them know, and if it still doesn't remedy itself, he starts buying somewhere else.

matt_1_10-26-2026_105624And so

squadcaster-hiie_1_10-26-2026_095624else

matt_1_10-26-2026_105624the industry, that's, that's what we are. Now, you bring up beef, beef on dairy.

squadcaster-hiie_1_10-26-2026_095624really good at that. I mean,

matt_1_10-26-2026_105624Sure

squadcaster-hiie_1_10-26-2026_095624if you think about, you know, you think about what do I do to do my business better? And, and some of the feedlot industry has done a very effective cost-cutting exercise. You know, and what are some of the things they don't need? And this has been years and years, but it was a real hard look at personnel. You know, what people do we have that are... and, and what kind of value are they adding to the business? And if we really don't need them, we'll, we'll do without them.

squadcaster-hiie_1_10-26-2026_095624And in that whole process, they created a data system where, you know, you have one or you have a few people that are really effective within that data system, and they can use it to make decisions. And this is in part where, where formulas have been so successful. You know, having somebody buy and sell in the cash market, you know, doing bid and ask all the time with packers, I mean, that's days' worth of work that may, that may produce... When you look at the business, they don't look at it as, as producing anything effective.

squadcaster-hiie_1_10-26-2026_095624Hey, let's go, let's take that person and put them with data responsibilities, and then negotiate a, a formula that, that works well for the cattle we feed and the type of feeding systems we have

matt_1_10-26-2026_105624And as we look at the beef on dairy side of things, specifically from an information and, um, you know, controlled management, that's a competitive advantage that they have over beef cattle. I mean, let's face it, I, I, I don't love that. Now, on the quality and consistency standpoint, they are also very consistent feeding, consistent grading. They're very consistent genetics, uh, one more competitive advantage they have. But as beef producers, as, as what I would call, ranch type, uh, Bos taurus beef type producers, I think that we can address that, but we're probably going to have to do things a little differently.

matt_1_10-26-2026_105624We're probably not going to be able to be scared of passing that information along and, and allowing ways for that buyer, stocker, operator, feed yard, even packer, to know exactly what that calf has had from a, a management standpoint, genetic standpoint, nutrition, the whole nine yards, and, um, I think there'll be a value associated w-with that, um, my opinion going forth. I just don't know how exactly, whether that's tied to a, a 12-digit RFID tag, or as you had mentioned, we jump right over that and go straight to, you know, bio scanning, retinal scanning, facial recognition, whatever the case may be, and that's, that's where it'll be interesting

squadcaster-hiie_1_10-26-2026_095624you know, I think RFID, something that, that this is kind of an aside but, um, if you look at, uh, ranches out west there's, there's more and more that are considering, collars and virtual fencing and things like that. And once you commit to going that direction and collecting that level of information, you know, once you're doing that now you can, you can be more precise in terms of what information do you really have on that individual animal. I, I don't think we need to I'm not suggesting going the path of genetic testing and things like that but, but another really interesting thing to do is, is for a cow-calf operation or ranching operation to maintain some of that ownership.

squadcaster-hiie_1_10-26-2026_095624Make sure you have a nice big batch, make them as uniform as you can, and then maintain some level of ownership as those cattle go somewhere else. How much can you maintain ownership, what percentage do you need to commit and in order to get performance information back? How did those animals do in a stocking operation? How did they do in the feed yard? How did they do with meat grading? That, that's a lot of, uh, potential that can make some improvements at the cow-calf level.

squadcaster-hiie_1_10-26-2026_095624How did those animals do in the meat? Out of your 100 cows, are there, are there three that need to go? Are there 15 that need to go? You know, it's simply knowing what that is and, um, having some level of information there so that when I make the next steps in, in culling I'm doing exactly the right things. I'm doing the things that make money the folks that wanna come buy because, because they, they have figured out they're, they're not gonna give you all the profits back but they will share some of that profitability.

squadcaster-hiie_1_10-26-2026_095624There's a huge variation in profitability of pen by pen by pen. And if you can figure out where that comes from and do something about it then, then that is, that, that value is often higher than the average value of the whole pen. The variation across and within pens of the population of animals we have. If we could do something just to get rid of some of the tail end that would really, that makes the whole thing look so much better. Not just look, but, uh, value so much better

matt_1_10-26-2026_105624There, there are so many feed yards that are willing to do that, partner with, with a producer,'cause it's good for them. It's, it's a way for- they can source cattle. It's a way for them to know... I mean, if a producer wants to own part of their cattle going forth, you probably know they've done the right things going back. And,

squadcaster-hiie_1_10-26-2026_095624Right

matt_1_10-26-2026_105624there's no better... I probably are, but it is definitely an educational moment to feed those cattle and see the challenges that folks face as those cattle go to the feed yard. It's not for everybody, but, um, but it is something and, and this may be a time as... I can't believe I'm even uttering this, but as, as cow-calf producers look at profits over the last year or two, and hopefully a few years going forward, with some tax consequences, this might be an opportunity to say,"You know what?

matt_1_10-26-2026_105624This is the year I'm gonna retain a third interest in those calves to whomever I sell them, and get data back and, and, um, kinda grow into this." And so, yeah, lots of opportunities

squadcaster-hiie_1_10-26-2026_095624think maintaining ownership to, to increase profits needs to be the message. I

matt_1_10-26-2026_105624today, no

squadcaster-hiie_1_10-26-2026_095624it's the maintaining ownership to, to increase information and make better decisions going forward. Uh, if you're not doing that now, uh, thinking about how to do it next is, is gonna be an awful good idea. Um, let me... I, I'd also like to throw another thing in. Um, from a, from the standpoint of cow-calf operations and thinking about the future, um, you know, I run into young people all the time that would love an opportunity to, to, be involved in a ranch, to own some cows, to, to do that type of thing.

squadcaster-hiie_1_10-26-2026_095624There's a lot of young people, uh, that are, that express interest in doing that, the limitation is we- they simply don't have the money to, uh, to purchase land, to rent land, to lease land, whatever. It's, it's, uh, it's cost-prohibitive to get back into the business, and I do think there's an opportunity for, the established generation to do something in that capacity, try to figure out a way to get young people back and involved.

squadcaster-hiie_1_10-26-2026_095624you know, and it, it's gonna involve, uh, transferring some of that You know, you've gotta give some of your business away to the, to the next generation to have them be successful. And that's, you know, I wanna be careful saying that. I'm not, I'm not advocating doing that. But, um, that can... You know, you brought up tax consequences. I think that's a way to, to help mitigate some tax consequences and get somebody, get somebody lined out that you think might have an interest in doing this in the future, and try to grow some of that.

squadcaster-hiie_1_10-26-2026_095624And, you know, fund some of their business and maintain a little bit of ownership in it, have more information, help'em make good decisions. I do think there's, things, there's opportunities to do stuff that I- that's something that I'm not hearing individuals do. There's a lot of individuals that are thinking about, how do I do things to make my business make more money, which is great. But what do you do to, what do you do to, um, to help the next generation, to extend, grow the industry, make it more successful?

squadcaster-hiie_1_10-26-2026_095624Uh, those types of things. The, you know, I'm thinking about, uh, big-picture, long-term that are, that are not just, um, you know, how do I, how do I, uh, how do I sell off my business to, um, an investor that wants to pay a lot of money for it, that

matt_1_10-26-2026_105624Sure. Sure. Yep. Yeah, that's not generally something that any of us like to hear.

squadcaster-hiie_1_10-26-2026_095624there,

matt_1_10-26-2026_105624Oh, it

squadcaster-hiie_1_10-26-2026_095624there's an opportunity to think a little outside of the box. And I've run that by people before and boy, it's fallen flat. It's fallen flat like a couple of other crazy ideas I've had. So,

matt_1_10-26-2026_105624Well,

squadcaster-hiie_1_10-26-2026_095624so,

matt_1_10-26-2026_105624like I said with the first one, sometimes it just takes some of us a little while to mull it over and realize that it's maybe not as crazy as we thought

squadcaster-hiie_1_10-26-2026_095624You know, and, and I, I think there's an opportunity here. There's, there's really good money in the cattle business right now. There's gonna be some, some, some huge tax questions down the road. Let's, um, get some... You know, like I said, there, there's plenty of young people that would like to go do

matt_1_10-26-2026_105624Oh yeah

squadcaster-hiie_1_10-26-2026_095624or expressed to me that they're interested in doing this, and the, the overwhelming thing they can't get by is, uh, you know, not enough capital, to be able to do it. They have the interest, they have the potential love of doing it, they have some really good skill sets, and they just, they just can't come up with the money

matt_1_10-26-2026_105624It's, it's a challenge, no doubt. No doubt, re- uh, especially starting from scratch

squadcaster-hiie_1_10-26-2026_095624Yeah, I, that was a real side direction for you. I

matt_1_10-26-2026_105624That's all right.

squadcaster-hiie_1_10-26-2026_095624that's

matt_1_10-26-2026_105624No, hey, uh, I think that's what makes a podcast good is, is plenty of side directions. Um, I am gonna take us back over toward the end of the chain on the packer side. Um, you don't have to go to very many sale barn cafes or industry meetings or alongside the road to hear us producers talking about wanting to break up the big four packers. I think that over the last year, year and a half, uh, with one or maybe two packers, um, shuttering a plant or two, uh, slowing down and, and just working five-day kill weeks, um, it looks to me like maybe economics are slightly breaking up, quote-unquote, the big four packers.

matt_1_10-26-2026_105624I don't know how far that goes, but what are the consequences of, quote-unquote, getting what we want? Um, and when I say we, that's a stretch because I don't, I probably don't fall into that camp. But, uh, you know, if we have more smaller regional type processors, we've got more people in the market to buy fed cattle, but maybe we lose some efficiency.

squadcaster-hiie_1_10-26-2026_095624Not maybe.

matt_1_10-26-2026_105624we will. I, I-

squadcaster-hiie_1_10-26-2026_095624lose efficiency and it's, it's hundreds of dollars a head. You know, what, what are you willing to, what are you willing to give up on that calf price for more packers? This is a, this is a persistent question. I've done research on this my entire career. My I started out doing research on this topic, and I've I- I actually enjoy getting away from it. There's other things I like to do work on now because they're, they're so much less confrontational and you have, you have, you have far less follow-up that's, uh, that's, um, not much fun to do.

matt_1_10-26-2026_105624I, I can only imagine

squadcaster-hiie_1_10-26-2026_095624but I, but So I have a I- I think I have a better way of, of Not a better than you. I think I have a better way of presenting this issue, and I don't I'm not saying with respect to how you presented it. This is the way I like to pitch it to producers. Uh, so I want you to put on your cattle feeder hat. You are a cattle feeder. You're a cattle feeder, you've been a cattle feeder for a long time. You plan on being a cattle feeder for a long time yet to come. Would you rather sell to, uh, one to two packers with$300 a head slaughter and fab costs, or would you rather sell to, let's say, three to five packers with, uh, five to$700 a head slaughter and fab costs, would you rather sell to eight or nine packers with, uh, with$1,000, at least$1,000 a head slaughter and fab cost?

squadcaster-hiie_1_10-26-2026_095624What ind- in what industry are you gonna make more money?

matt_1_10-26-2026_105624The first one. Sure

squadcaster-hiie_1_10-26-2026_095624the first one without a doubt. And, and that is why we have as big of plants as we have, and the expertise across those plants needs to be coordinated. You need to have plants in a variety of regions that you're not freighten so far, but that's why we have the big plants that we do have. And going forward for the next couple, three years, we're probably gonna have, uh, you know, did you I mean, the on feed report on Friday, what are we down, placements are down, what, 12%?

squadcaster-hiie_1_10-26-2026_095624You know, we've got, what, three months this year of down double-digit percentage compared to the prior year. If I'm a packer, that is, that is a real problem come February We, we

matt_1_10-26-2026_105624Yeah

squadcaster-hiie_1_10-26-2026_095624we have, we're over capacity in the packing industry to the tune of one big plant and one

matt_1_10-26-2026_105624today

squadcaster-hiie_1_10-26-2026_095624till, still today, and going forward. In particular, going forward. One big plant and one regional plant. And, you know, if those plants run, they're going to lose millions of dollars. What investor wants to sit there,"Okay, we're gonna, we're gonna be in this business for the next, uh, four quarters, and we're gonna lose millions"? And I'm not laughing'cause it's funny.

squadcaster-hiie_1_10-26-2026_095624is not funny at all. And, and who's gonna You know, so, so whoever it up and says,"All right, we're gonna close a plant," they're gonna write that plant off. That's millions of bucks for everybody else to benefit

matt_1_10-26-2026_105624Mm-hmm.

squadcaster-hiie_1_10-26-2026_095624That, that's why it's so hard to move forward on this because the individual that makes the decision eats the cost and the rest of the industry benefits. And, and that's, that's going to happen the next couple... somewhere in the next couple years, we're gonna lose another regional plant. And I'm not talking about what, um, and I, and I like to be careful naming names,

matt_1_10-26-2026_105624Sure

squadcaster-hiie_1_10-26-2026_095624I'm not talking about what Tyson's doing, what Tyson is proposing to do with Pasco. Okay, just selling it doesn't change the problem.

matt_1_10-26-2026_105624Yeah, it's still... Right

squadcaster-hiie_1_10-26-2026_095624I mean, the- one of these plants is likely to close, and there also needs to be probably a regional plant that needs to close. We just have way too much packing capacity for the number of cattle we have for the foreseeable future. And that's bullish for calves, and that's gonna be real strong beef prices through the spring. But, uh, there's quite a few packers that aren't gonna make any money this spring it looks like to me

matt_1_10-26-2026_105624The counterargument, I can hear a few yelling at their truck radio as we speak, is,"Well, these guys three years ago, four years ago, were making$1,000 a head, and so surely they stashed some of that money away." It doesn't necessarily work like that, though. And I-- Looking forward, I think they probably recognize that it's gonna be a lot of years before they get back into the black, and especially may never see that again. I mean, that, that was probably a one and done

squadcaster-hiie_1_10-26-2026_095624after a, a period of profitability, there's an avalanche of retirements at the, at the packing industry. So I think you lose... And, and, you know, that, that's, that's meant to be a little bit funny,

matt_1_10-26-2026_105624Right

squadcaster-hiie_1_10-26-2026_095624it's also, you know, it's also people going,"Okay, this was our time. It's time to cash out." But the bad part is you lose that experience. You lose the people that went through that and know that, that, that happens. And, this gets back to the confrontational thing. Um, you know, we're, we're mad at somebody that, that something with our product and, and makes money at it.

matt_1_10-26-2026_105624Mm-hmm.

squadcaster-hiie_1_10-26-2026_095624I mean, that's just, that's ludicrous. That's like me being upset that I trained some students and they go out and become millionaires. How in the world can I get upset at that? That's what I'm supposed to do. I mean, it's, it's, uh... You know, where, where does that come from? The, the, they don't share enough or I'm, I mean, it, it's a segmented industry. You have to work within the confines of what you do. If you think it's a great thing, then invest, you know, invest downstream. If you think pa- or retailers are making too much money, I'm sure there's an opportunity to, to open a retail operation in your community, and that is a hard job that's not gonna make you much money, and it's not much different from, from the packing industry.

squadcaster-hiie_1_10-26-2026_095624I think the packing industry, we get, we've simply got overcapacity for, for the next couple of years. That's the downside risk in this market, is, is whoever closes whatever facility it is and then the, the, the, the rearrangement of relationships of where cattle go to see the efficiency. And you know, we're, we're talking about losing efficiency, you know, a couple of hundred bucks a head. in today's calf market, that's probably not a lot of money, but somewhere down the road that might be pretty important

matt_1_10-26-2026_105624Sure. Yeah, without a doubt

squadcaster-hiie_1_10-26-2026_095624this is, this is just one of the issues that this industry has the segmentation, the size of the investment it takes to go across different stages. then you create the, you know... Then, then you create, well now they're trying to own everything, that, that whole discussion. I, I think it's a real bad idea. You know, there's some folks talking about, you know, not only do the packer, big packers need to be broken up, they need to not have other species.

matt_1_10-26-2026_105624Right

squadcaster-hiie_1_10-26-2026_095624W- well, we have, we have c- firms that are running beef packing plants that if they just ran beef packing plants, they'd be- they'd have been long closed. They're, they're actually making money on their chicken operations and their pork operations, and that allows them to, to... You know, it, it's gotta- that's gotta be a horrible committee meeting where the beef guy wants some money to, to do some renovations in the beef plant, and everybody looks at him like the$500 million sink in the business.

matt_1_10-26-2026_105624And

squadcaster-hiie_1_10-26-2026_095624I mean, with the, the... We, we have a better, we have a better beef industry, beef packing industry because they're diversified across the species, I think. if we just had packers, uh, open and close, uh, if they made money, um, boy we'd have to, we'd have a ton of volatility that we do not have today

matt_1_10-26-2026_105624Yeah, it's a little like the earlier discussion we had about imports. Would you rather have Mexican feeder calf imports that we get the opportunity to keep an infrastructure open and going for the next cycle high in cattle numbers,

squadcaster-hiie_1_10-26-2026_095624Yeah.

matt_1_10-26-2026_105624import that beef? Would you rather have beef processors who also process pork and maybe poultry and consequently can, yeah, stay open for the next time that we have larger cattle supplies and we need that, that shackle space? And that's--

squadcaster-hiie_1_10-26-2026_095624Let's, let's,

matt_1_10-26-2026_105624to me that we would even ask for that

squadcaster-hiie_1_10-26-2026_095624let's op- let's open up a can of worms with respect to the, you know, the beef imports.

matt_1_10-26-2026_105624Sure

squadcaster-hiie_1_10-26-2026_095624When I talk to producers, one of the things I like to ask them is, you know, what's, the, what are the biggest primals? And they go through the list, and then I ask them,"Well, what about the 50s? What about the 50% lean trims?" That is an enormous primal, especially when you're feeding cattle to, you know, close to 1,500 pounds,

matt_1_10-26-2026_105624Mm-hmm.

squadcaster-hiie_1_10-26-2026_095624There's some 1,200 pound carcasses.

matt_1_10-26-2026_105624Yes

squadcaster-hiie_1_10-26-2026_095624grade four.

matt_1_10-26-2026_105624A lot of fat. A lot of fat.

squadcaster-hiie_1_10-26-2026_095624yield grade four.

matt_1_10-26-2026_105624Yeah. Or f- or five

squadcaster-hiie_1_10-26-2026_095624they're, they're damn delicious. They're prime. They're delicious, but they got a lot of trim,

matt_1_10-26-2026_105624Yes

squadcaster-hiie_1_10-26-2026_095624and that trim has been pretty valuable. I mean, it's especially valuable in the summer, but it's only valuable if you can blend it with 90s make hamburger. And you've gotta have more 90s than the 50s to make an 80% lean hamburger. we really, we need that. You know, if you don't import the lean beef to blend with those 50s, then those 50s are worth a lot less, and that is one of your biggest primals.

squadcaster-hiie_1_10-26-2026_095624So, you know, y- do you really wanna take a dollar off something that's 150 pounds of a carcass? I, I mean, that's, uh, not if it's walking out the door at the retailer for$10 a pound as 80% lean hamburger

matt_1_10-26-2026_105624Yeah, and that's, uh, it's such a, a complex business that we're in today. And, and a lot of us as cow-calf producers may not love how complicated and/or complex it is, but folks have figured out where they can make profit on everything but the moo. And if we jerk the rug out from under the way they've been able to do that, it makes it tough

squadcaster-hiie_1_10-26-2026_095624the-- one of the things we need to remember is, is uncertainty is a cost,

matt_1_10-26-2026_105624Mm-hmm.

squadcaster-hiie_1_10-26-2026_095624and creating uncertainty, creating disruptions, you can't ever, you can't ever create uncertainty and create disruptions and, and average things out on the cost side. All those costs, they elevate, they become big, and they stick there for a while. And, and that's one of the... You know, this is one of the things I think, uh, cow-calf folks might in particular have a, have a problem understanding in that you've got a business that, that sells...

squadcaster-hiie_1_10-26-2026_095624You know, they may sell over the summer. They may sell some stuff on the video. That's always a great diversification strategy, sell some stuff on the video. But all the calves leave in the fall.

matt_1_10-26-2026_105624Mm-hmm.

squadcaster-hiie_1_10-26-2026_095624You know, they leave one time a year. They make, they make one big marketing, activity. There's one big marketing activity, whereas as soon as you get away from the ranch, it is a throughput business, and disruptions, disruptions do nothing but put on hundreds of dollars, maybe not hundreds, but certainly tens upwards to hundreds of dollars per head of cost. So simply disruptions, uncertainty, all of that stuff, um, you know, creates risk and, and mi-much of it is not stuff that's, uh, the risk management tools easily mitigate

matt_1_10-26-2026_105624That uncertainty, like you said, is, is probably hardest on the margin operators who are buying these cattle and then selling them someplace else later on down the road. But it's, it

squadcaster-hiie_1_10-26-2026_095624if, if you have a doubt, what do you do?

matt_1_10-26-2026_105624Exactly. You're not gonna do anything. Yeah

squadcaster-hiie_1_10-26-2026_095624you scale back, you cut back, you build in a bigger cushion

matt_1_10-26-2026_105624Yeah. And we saw that with some social media tweets and, and what have you 60 days ago. And, and I think I felt it then that the supply and demand fundamentals obviously were still the same. I, I, I didn't think this was the end of this phenomenal five, six-year bull market that we've been in.

squadcaster-hiie_1_10-26-2026_095624Yeah.

matt_1_10-26-2026_105624and it's now proving that. I mean, my goodness, it-- this thing feels poised... Well, I'm not gonna make any predictions, but it is a very strong market. And when it can shake off that much noise and do what it has done

squadcaster-hiie_1_10-26-2026_095624have very tight supplies. Very tight supplies don't change two years

matt_1_10-26-2026_105624minimum

squadcaster-hiie_1_10-26-2026_095624um, I'll have to quote Derrel Peel. I don't know if you've talked to Derrel. He's one of

matt_1_10-26-2026_105624He,

squadcaster-hiie_1_10-26-2026_095624people.

matt_1_10-26-2026_105624was on about six months ago

squadcaster-hiie_1_10-26-2026_095624say, you know,"Stretch it out as long as you want to. This is gonna take forever to, to..." I'm, I'm, I'm misquoting him there, but,

matt_1_10-26-2026_105624But it's a good accent.

squadcaster-hiie_1_10-26-2026_095624he's, he's been the, he's been the,"Well, this isn't going away anytime soon," and I can't... You know, I've disagreed with him, and I've always been wrong. you know, you gotta quit doing stuff when you're always wrong. So I... The supply side doesn't change for, for quite a while, and the demand side has been phenomenal. And the things that create the downside risks are gonna be the demand side. Do we mess with quality when supplies are so tight?

squadcaster-hiie_1_10-26-2026_095624It's funny, my, my family feeds cattle, and we've, we've always fed cattle to, to prime. We fed cattle on the East Coast, and there's no market. You know, there was a restaurant trade. You hit the restaurant trade. and essentially the rest of the market has caught up with what I knew

matt_1_10-26-2026_105624Yeah. Decades ago.

squadcaster-hiie_1_10-26-2026_09562430 years ago, that, prime is a really good product. So I don't think we'll, we'll do things to sabotage quality grade, but, you know, the sizes are gonna be huge. The carcasses are... You know, and I think, the packing industry has really done a, an, an interesting job with respect to, you know, what they might call value added, which is the real aggressive trim, and then the, the things that, for example, NCBA has done with, uh, identifying, different muscle cuts within, within, you know, a cheaper cut, identify a muscle cut within that cheaper cut that is higher value that can be, be, uh, marketed as something different.

squadcaster-hiie_1_10-26-2026_095624You know, that has been very effective. And, and so we've done some really effective things going forward. uh, corn price is coming off. We're gonna have more pork. We're gonna have more poultry. will have more substitute meats. Uh, we will have some meats to compete with that$10 a pound hamburger. There'll be substitute meats that will compete with that$10 a pound hamburger. and, you know, do we have an economy that will continue to support that real aggressive, uh, beef pricing, or does, um, five-plus gasoline and concerns about, uh, job opportunities from AI, do they create some concerns in the economy and, and some pulling back?

squadcaster-hiie_1_10-26-2026_095624You know, I think that's a downside risk. Those are downside risks. Substitute meats economy, and then you take some packing capacity out, that's, that's not gonna be a disaster. It's not gonna put the top in. Um, it sure, it... There's a lot of things out there in my mind that are downside risk. The upside risk is the supply side, the supply side and the really strong demand. That's... We're gonna, we're gonna continue to be shocked by beef prices going forward. They're gonna be, they're gonna be big

matt_1_10-26-2026_105624And I think those two things are what have trumped everything through the years. And yeah, I mean,

squadcaster-hiie_1_10-26-2026_095624Yep.

matt_1_10-26-2026_105624think that is very, very much in our favor. And as we cow-calf producers look long term, and you mentioned this on, on, um, Justin's podcast Going forth, you'd mentioned that cow-calf producers may not be willing to stay in the cow-calf business for a mere 50 to$100 a head profit if you average it out over, over the years and over the decades, and you think that'll limit expansion. I, I don't disagree with you, but give me a little more of your thoughts on there.

matt_1_10-26-2026_105624Is that just, is that just other opportunities for these young producers to work elsewhere? Is that a changing cultural interest is that a cost structure, like you mentioned a long time ago, the, the capital costs of getting into cow-calf production are substantial with land prices what they are. What, what drives that, and where do you see that going?

squadcaster-hiie_1_10-26-2026_095624yeah, it's all of the above and it's different things in different places, different things with different people, but any one of those things can be the trigger and they all add up going the same direction. You know, over the years if you look at cow-calf returns, um, you know, really into the early 2000s they were, they were really minimal and the cow-calf production was in part, important from the standpoint of diversifying. You know, if you had a crop operation and, and also ran some cows on the, the, the edges, the marginal ground, the, the piece here, the piece there, that kind of thing, that would support, that would provide you income in those years where the crop prices or the forage prices might be bad.

squadcaster-hiie_1_10-26-2026_095624So that went along for a long time and then we've had people gradually exit the business and, and once you go out, you know, I've, uh, it's rare, you know... Talk to somebody who's, who's sold their cow herd

matt_1_10-26-2026_105624Hmm.

squadcaster-hiie_1_10-26-2026_095624two years later, you wanna get back in?"

matt_1_10-26-2026_105624Exactly. Exactly

squadcaster-hiie_1_10-26-2026_095624Don't be standing in front of their pickup when you say that because you know, or, or s- or say that in front of their spouse, uh, you know, then you'll, you'll get a react- you'll get an honest reaction after that.

matt_1_10-26-2026_105624Yeah, it's work

squadcaster-hiie_1_10-26-2026_095624it's, it's a combination of things but it's, it's, fewer people and then you throw on top of this the, the, you know, without a doubt we've had some environmental changes I believe in the Southern US, especially the Southwest, just hotter and drier and that's, that's tough for forage production and that's that region that grass is really important for the base, really large base of the cow herd in the US. And unless the cow herd moves, uh, further east to get into the southeast and further north, and again that's a, that's a big if and that's real long term and, and I don't have to worry about that stuff'cause I'm gonna retire before that matters

matt_1_10-26-2026_105624You--

squadcaster-hiie_1_10-26-2026_095624much

matt_1_10-26-2026_105624That's another consistency you've used between these two podcasts is, is, uh, your impending retirement. So

squadcaster-hiie_1_10-26-2026_095624Oh, I, you know, I, I tell people when are ca- you know, they ask me when are cattle prices going down? I say,"I don't have to worry about it. I'll be, I'll be out of here by then."

matt_1_10-26-2026_105624Another 10 or 15 years, right?

squadcaster-hiie_1_10-26-2026_095624it's, it's a moving target. Whenever they fall and I have to talk about it, I'll, I'll find something else to do

matt_1_10-26-2026_105624It, it may be like those, um, those folks in the processing segment that you said, uh, retire a- as it's coming off its high. So maybe we better watch

squadcaster-hiie_1_10-26-2026_095624this is, this is great. I, I love forecasting cattle prices now. Pick a big number and, and you'll be wrong to the downside. That's,

matt_1_10-26-2026_105624That is a nice mistake. That is a nice mistake

squadcaster-hiie_1_10-26-2026_095624um, you know, to... In all honesty, I, I do a little less of this than I used to. I've had an opportunity to do some things, uh, with respect to working with students that are, that's taking a little more time, attracted some really good graduate students that are working on projects for me. you know, I'm look- I actually, I've looked forward to doing those things more than... These types of issues we're talking about, I think they're really important, but they're hard to solve, you know? And, um, and no matter what you say, somebody's gonna be mad, and that's, that's just a lot less fun than some other things I have opportunities to do.

squadcaster-hiie_1_10-26-2026_095624You know, I don't mean to be negative or, facetious or anything like that, um, you know, there's, there's really good things to do out there. And if you don't like your job, you need to, you need to find something else

matt_1_10-26-2026_105624Sure, sure. Yeah, I understand completely

squadcaster-hiie_1_10-26-2026_095624I'm not about to do, go do a podcast. You guys work too hard for that

matt_1_10-26-2026_105624well, one only needs to look at how few I have recorded over the last six months to know that, uh, the hard work I've been doing has not been behind the microphone, and it's suffered here

squadcaster-hiie_1_10-26-2026_095624See, and, and, but what you've described is really similar to what I live with in working in extension and research, in that, know, you talk, you go out and you do something f- you know, you write up a couple of pages, you talk for 30 minutes at a meeting, and it's taken you weeks to do that background research to get you prepared to do that. And I, I see the same thing with respect to, know, folks that do a good job with their communications business also face that as well. You guys do a lot of background research to get that, to get that couple minutes you need, and that needs to not be undersold.

matt_1_10-26-2026_105624Sure. Sure.

squadcaster-hiie_1_10-26-2026_095624I

matt_1_10-26-2026_105624that. That's very kind. And luckily I, I do that because I have a seed stock herd and customers who depend on me knowing what's going on in the greater industry, and, and hopefully this and newsletters and things like that to them are a way that we can kinda, kinda share that. Because I think when we hear somebody like yourself or anyone else, the, that you can gain some perspective that you may not have been able to see firsthand, or it gets your mind thinking about something that maybe you wouldn't have heard if it, if you were just talking to mom or dad or the neighbor or whatever the case may be.

matt_1_10-26-2026_105624I, I... It's beneficial. Yeah. Yep. I mean, any, any of the places we go, and quite often they're going to be dominated by that emotion that you mentioned before, um, quite often by that, that f- kind of animosity toward the person that's, that's buying or maybe sold us the animals. And things like this, I hope, give us a little bit of breath of fresh air and a little perspective. May not, may not always agree with everything that you or I or anybody else said, but hopefully gets us to stretch our mind a little bit.

matt_1_10-26-2026_105624So I think it's beneficial.

squadcaster-hiie_1_10-26-2026_095624Think it's, I think it's real important to, to do things like, you know, go to BIF, go to the, the, those types of meetings as a cow-calf producer. I believe it's important to participate in your national association, and your state associations. Make sure you're active there. But I also think it's a really good idea to, um... You know, it's hard to find the downstream associations, but, but try to find some meetings where, where you see who's talking about food service. Go, go to the food service meetings.

squadcaster-hiie_1_10-26-2026_095624Go to some of the restaurant meetings. There's, there's some interesting, industry association meetings that happen in Chicago where they, show, the equipment associated with food manufacturing. Attending some of that is really eye-opening., To see what happens beyond what you're comfortable with is, is really important. The other thing I really like to do, me personally, it drives my family crazy, but when we travel, I love to go into grocery stores somewhere else just see what they're eating.

squadcaster-hiie_1_10-26-2026_095624You know, what are they, what are they eating? What's on the shelf? What's in the, what's in the fresh case? What's in the meat case? It's, it's a really big world out there. There's lots of things that are not what you think they are

matt_1_10-26-2026_105624Those observations are, are gonna tell us more than we realize, especially going to the local

squadcaster-hiie_1_10-26-2026_095624Th- those things have always been rewarding to me. Do the thing that, uh, that you think might not, you know, you might not like. Go give it a shot.

matt_1_10-26-2026_105624Yep.

squadcaster-hiie_1_10-26-2026_095624be surprised.

matt_1_10-26-2026_105624Yep, that's...

squadcaster-hiie_1_10-26-2026_095624mean you. I

matt_1_10-26-2026_105624Yeah

squadcaster-hiie_1_10-26-2026_095624it's, it's often a, it's often an interesting activity

matt_1_10-26-2026_105624Yep, no doubt about it. So, well, we appreciate your time. We appreciate your perspective and your knowledge and sharing that. I will, if it's okay with you, I will probably include your email address in the show notes, and if anybody has further questions about anything, hopefully they can reach out to you if that's all right?

squadcaster-hiie_1_10-26-2026_095624eas- uh, uh, you knew that or not, I'm easy to find.

matt_1_10-26-2026_105624Okay

squadcaster-hiie_1_10-26-2026_095624there's not very many Koontz's at Colorado State.

matt_1_10-26-2026_105624That sounds great

squadcaster-hiie_1_10-26-2026_095624them is my daughter, and if you send the email to her, she'll forward it to me. Say,"What, what, what is this person talking about? They don't want me, they want you."

matt_1_10-26-2026_105624She must not be down the hall in ag econ, I guess

squadcaster-hiie_1_10-26-2026_095624No, no, no, no. Uh, I'm, I'm apparently not qualified to, to advise, some people about career paths, so I, I have to, I have to know what my strengths are, and that's,

matt_1_10-26-2026_105624Stay in your lane. That's good. That's good. Well, thanks again, Dr. Koontz. We appreciate all the work you do and being on here with us today.

squadcaster-hiie_1_10-26-2026_095624Thank you very much. Appreciate the time.

matt_1_10-26-2026_105624You

squadcaster-hiie_1_10-26-2026_095624the ask

matt_1_10-26-2026_105624bet. You bet

Speaker 2Thanks again for tuning in to Practically Ranching, brought to you by Dalebanks Angus. We're putting the finishing touches on the sale, and we hope you can join us in person or on the internet on Saturday, November 21st, 2026. Digital catalogs are available online at dalebanks.com or email me at mattperrier@dalebanks.com if you'd like to get a printed one in the mail. Thanks again. We'll talk to you again soon.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. #94 - Sale Preview and Sire Overview

    Nov 11, 202622 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail Join Matt as he gives an overview of the sires of the bulls and females in the Dalebanks Angus 55th Annual Sale, to be held Saturday, November 21, 2026, at the ranch headquarters northwest of Eureka, KS...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. #92 - Jeremy Kinder, Get In the Right Rooms

    Sep 9, 20261 hr 3 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail Jeremy Kinder is the owner and operator of 6K Ranch near Faxon, Oklahoma, along with his wife Katy and four children. Currently, the operation consists of a commercial cow/calf and stocker cattle...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. #91 - Ted Schroeder - Presidential Posts, Industry Infrastructure and other Market Makers

    Aug 25, 20261 hr 8 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail Ted Schroeder is a Distinguished Professor of Ag Economics at Kansas State University. His research on livestock marketing and price analysis provides information and direction for the livestock and...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. #90 - Joe Morgan, Chasing Premiums at Poky

    May 6, 20261 hr 3 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail Joe Morgan is CEO of Poky Feeders, a custom cattle feeder in Scott County, KS. He began feeding cattle after his graduation from Iowa State University in 1973. He began at Poky in 1985, and has grown...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. #89 - Derrell Peel, Today's Market: Scary Good...or Panic Slowly?

    Apr 8, 20261 hr 20 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail Derrell Peel holds the Charles Breedlove Professorship of Agribusiness in the Department of Agricultural Economics. He has served as the Extension Livestock Marketing Specialist since 1989. His work...

    Credit the people on this episode