Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Power Pulse

Power Pulse artwork

Beyond Compliance: Securing the Digital Grid

Oct 16, 202617 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

As grids become more digital and interconnected, cybersecurity has become inseparable from reliability. In this episode of Power Pulse, we explore what cybersecurity really means for today's electric power systems - and what often gets misunderstood. Drawing on his 42 years of experience working with utilities, policymakers, and industry standards bodies, cybersecurity expert Steven A. Kunsman explains how threats are evolving, why compliance alone is only a starting point, and how real-world attacks have fundamentally reshaped how the industry thinks about risk. The conversation explores the convergence of IT and OT, the critical role of international standards like IEC 62443, and why "defence in depth" is essential to protect substations, control systems, and mission-critical infrastructure.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

This season on Hitachi Energy's Power Pulse podcast, we're turning our focus to Grid Automation. Expect bold ideas, real stories, and insights straight from the experts shaping today's power grids. From smart digital solutions to the challenges and opportunities of a more flexible, sustainable energy system, we'll be covering the topics that matter most. As grids become more digital and connected, cybersecurity is now essential to reliability. In this episode of Power Pulse, we explore what cybersecurity really means for today's electric power systems and what often gets misunderstood. Drawing on his 42 years of experience working with utilities, quality makers,

and industry standards bodies, cybersecurity expert Steve Kunsman, explains how threats are evolving, why compliance alone is only a starting point and how real-world attacks have fundamentally reshaped how the industry thinks about risk. The conversation explores the convergence of IT and OT, the critical role of international standards, and why defence in depth is essential to protect substations, control systems, and mission critical infrastructure. Hello, Steve. Hello. Welcome to the Power Pulse podcast. How are you this morning? I'm doing fine. Yourself? Very well, thank you. So I hear you've been in the company and in the protection control and

automation business for 42 years. Yes, I have. It's been a long journey, that's for sure. 42 Years.That's a very long time. Yes. And I've been in development. I've developed products for the business. I've been in global product management and today I'm leading our technical team in North America on promoting the solutions that we have for grid automation. So as an industry veteran, Steve, I understand the policymakers and industry consortia often rely on your insights. How did this begin? Yeah, that's a great question. Hitachi Energy has been extremely fortunate to partner with US Department of

Energy, their Caesar organisation on many aspects of grid security and supply chain risk management and cybersecurity. Initially, we were asked to participate on Department of Energy's executive securing energy infrastructure task force as an expert on OT control systems in this space. And Department of Energy was given the task from Congress to give a report on the state of the union of the grid security and what the grid is doing. Securing energy infrastructure, that task force has come out with several deliverables from cyber informed

engineering, which is a concept to allow non-cybersecurity engineers to understand the impact that they can have on cybersecurity solutions. And then also some efforts have been developed where I actually participated in developing a reference architecture or cybersecurity system for the electric industry. And then that was further turned over to ISA99, which is an industry consortium that developed standards around 62443. So we are presently developing electric energy OT security profiles

for the different control systems in the electric industry. In addition, we were asked to participate and testify in a FERC, which is the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission from the US in their cybersecurity supply chain risk workshop. And we were able to provide some of the goodness that Hitachi Energy is doing in this space and show that cybersecurity is forefront. So let's look at the cybersecurity landscape for the grid. And more recently, we're seeing a shift into digitalization in an industry that's very much known to be analogue. Is there still a fear of using digital as a way forward?

Do you find a lot of resistance? There absolutely is. And the fear comes from basically digitalization and the perception that having ethernet communications inside the substation will open up the attack surface to adversaries from the outside. We can actually go back to the 80s where we transitioned from electromechanical control systems to microprocessor and that was a huge challenge as well as you introduce software into the control system. Now moving to digitalization, we're replacing some of the key components in the power system with digitalized

units and the ability to then have this data available for the protection and control opens up a whole new world of opportunities for reliability and also data management. So what do utilities misunderstand about what cybersecurity risk actually comes from within the digital substation? The risk is there. The question that needs to be asked is how do we manage the risk that's in the system? There are performance-based standards that are regulatory that give the utility the guidelines on what to do for managing the cyber risk,

but then there are also technical standards for cybersecurity that provide the blueprint on technical solutions and defence in depth applications inside the substation. Can you tell me what a common misconception about cybersecurity in substations is? Yes. A few years ago, there was a misbelief that digital substations and running ethernet communications outside of the control house in the substation into the switchgear breakers transformers violated the NERC SIP regulatory standards and that's not the case.

Through standardisation and through working with the various bodies, we were able to identify ways to securely be able to deploy digital substations and also satisfy the requirements of the regulatory side. The second misconception is when I hear asset owners or industry peers say that all you need to do is put software defined networks in the solution and that's all the security that you need that is so wrong because the defence in depth strategy is that you want to have that solid core all the way through the cybersecurity solution. So again,

the software defined networks will create the hard shell and leave you a soft boiled egg on the centre. So what you're saying is digitalization is unavoidable now. Yes. I believe that we're going to see with utility grid modernization plans, the need for power interconnecting systems, data centres, the demand for growth, the number of interconnections that utility is facing today is far more than they did in the past. And to implement their traditional substations, they cannot keep up with this demand.

So digitalization provides a lot of benefit to them on the cycle time of delivering these solutions and then also the ability to get data out of the substations to be able to drive reliability metrics and have early indications of potential failures of different components like transformers breakers. Steve, you're mentioning digital substations. Can you tell our audience what a digital substation is? Yeah. What I can do is tell you what a conventional substation is and then what is different on digital. So conventional substation had traditional protection control connected to

breakers and transformers, collecting analogue information via current transformers, potential transformers, and then all this control wires to be able to control the breaker. Digitalization moves the conversion of the analogue signals at the breaker at the transformer and then passes the digital communications back via ethernet into the substation control system for protection. Thank you. So this grid modernization that you've just mentioned is driving to digitalization. Does it ever break down? And if so, where does it break down?

Yeah. So the grid modernization, so the drivers behind that are the influx of data centres going in that have a heavy demand for power system, the renewable conversion and integration and these independent power producers trying to connect into the grid. And the sheer number of substation interconnects that need to support this is putting utility in a position where they can't keep up with these interconnection requests. So digital substations allow for the utilities to do faster integration because the time that it takes to deploy a digital substation is significantly

less than a conventional substation. Then also the benefit that you get from digitalization is the reduction of significant wires because these traditional CTs, current transformers and potential transformer connections are now reduced to ethernet communications. Okay. And would you say standards enable say for digital transformation or do they slow them down? From standardisation, there are various standards out there from IEEE IEC that support the digitalization and digital substations. And I think that's one of the key elements that have also motivated a lot of

manufacturers as well as utilities. Using open standards reduces the dependency on a proprietary interface from different manufacturers. So this allows the utilities to also use multiple suppliers in a single substation using that open standard. And the key one for digital substation is IEC 61850, which is a communication architecture standard that defines various aspects of the digital components and how they need to interface together and how to test them together. Right. Okay.

I'm going to ask you to tell me a little bit more about the concept of defence in depth and what does it look like inside a modern substation? Sure. Cybersecurity from a best practises perspective, defence in depth is set up to be able to have different layers of defence in your substation. If we look at the security architecture, you have the ingress point of the substation, which is typically protected by a firewall. That firewall by itself is not enough to protect all the components that are within that substation.

So here what we establish is different conduits and zones within the substation and each one of these zones provides that different defence layer in the substation. And here's where we use the standard IASA/IEC 62443 to provide the best practises around doing the security components, the security features with inside our products and technology and developing the security architectures around this defence in depth strategy. Thank you, Steve. And when it comes to reliability and performance,

how do you balance these with cybersecurity? Yeah, that's a great question. And I can go back 2007. I was invited as a vendor on the NERC SIP panel and they were asking questions. What is NERC SIP? So NERC CIP is a North American Reliability Corporation and they develop the regulatory standards for the US regulated market and the CIP is the critical infrastructure protection. And in 2007 is when they first went enforceable and the standardisation committe brought a bunch of vendors together and asked questions.

And what was key about that is they were all concerned about putting IEC 61850 into the substations, putting ethernet into the substations because they feared that this would cause the adversary's easy access to the equipment. And what I quickly reminded them is don't forget that the R in NERC stands for reliability, not resistance. So from that perspective, what we did is we justified the information that can be attained from a digital substation is paramount to the reliability. And what we need to do is find ways to secure that substation to be able to

allow for the real-time data outflow so our analytics like asset performance management or other type of machine learning analytics can analyse the health of that transformer, health of the breaker and then provide predictive maintenance algorithms to our customers. And so from a reliability perspective, if you can get this digital information from the substation that absolutely will drive the need and the importance of the digital substation. Is everyone across the board convinced that cybersecurity should be front of mind?

I'm not so convinced that's the case. Okay. So who do you have to convince that they should really pay attention? I think the key thing is, again, going back to the NERC CIP standards. Those are reliability standards. They define the basement or the bare minimum that the utilities should be doing. When we take a look at industry standards like IEC 62443, here it's built on foundations of years used in the industrial control system market and we're now using this in electric OT control systems, operational technology control systems to be able to provide this foundation.

And there, when we look at best in class or best practise for cybersecurity standards, there's different levels of security that we need to have in our products to be able to defend an adversary that's at the doorstep of the product. On the security architecture is again, building upon this defence in depth, ensuring that the most critical part of the system is unattainable or difficult to attain. So again, from a defence in depth, the security principles behind that are to be able to deter the adversaries. If they do get into the system, delay them as much as possible and then be able to mitigate any type of

risk that's in there or mitigate any type of threat that's in the system. This compliance you've just mentioned, it's a baseline, so everybody has to adhere to it, but it's not a full cybersecurity strategy. When you put your strategy together for cybersecurity, does it fall within your wider business strategy or does it stand on its own two feet? Yeah. So I think one thing to clarify is the regulatory standards are performance-based standards. They tell the asset owners or the utilities what to do. The technical standards, IEC 62443, IEC 62351,

they are the technical standards that tell you how to do something. So cybersecurity should be an integral part of any strategy for asset owners, for companies and so forth. The key thing is that cybersecurity needs to be baked into an organisation. The difference between regulatory and technical standards. So the regulatory standards, that part of the utility that is under that programme, they're mandatory compliance to those standards. The technical standards are best practises. What I always state in many of my presentations is if we focus on compliance,

we're missing an opportunity for education, awareness of the organisation to bring them together to understand the main goal behind cybersecurity and the principles there. Technical standards will provide the blueprints and if you follow the blueprints of this, the incremental step to regulatory compliance is much easier. Thank you. Throughout your 42-year career, what is the most avoidable cybersecurity threat that you've seen? The biggest issue that I see is just doing the perimeter protection on a system because when we take a look at threats, it's not a question of if,

it's a question of when adversaries will be in the system. And we see now with the activity of nation states, the increased penetration on these systems, we take a look at what happened in the Ukraine back in 2015, 2016 timeframe, which actually was a wake-up call to a lot of the industry that says adversaries from the outside can penetrate through the enterprise level and get into the OT control system and being able to get in there and identify that the adversary is in there is the most important thing. So I believe monitoring of these systems is key.

Being able to have those defence mechanisms, as we discussed earlier, the defence in depth is a critical part of that, that if they do break through one layer, there's another defence mechanism in there that tries to fort them or hold off that attack. And again, monitoring systems there, I think are also extremely important because if they do get into part of the systems, you need to be able to detect them and then be able to minimise the impact of that adversarial threat. So Steve, one last question, if I may. Is there a parallel to be made between personal cyber hygiene and what is happening on the grid when it comes to cybersecurity?

Yeah, I think absolutely. So I think if we see the event of AI and the incidents that are occurring in our daily lives, spoofing emails, phone calls from apparent people that have their voice recorded and sounded like one of your relatives, I think it's very important that we understand the risks that are out there today and what we do with our personal cyber hygiene, I think is very relevant to where we need to make sure that the grid is. And in the future, as we continue this grid modernization, cybersecurity needs to be paramount and forefront on any asset owner's mind,

on any solution that we as grid automation deliver into the system needs to be done with the rigour and the robustnes that can withstand adversarial threat. From the modernization perspective, cybersecurity going out into the next two, three, four years is going to be also extremely important because of that aspect and these digital systems if they're not protected, if we don't understand where the risk is in the system. And this is also handled by our risk mitigation or risk assessment strategy and risk assessments

that we do for the systems to be able to identify if we have the right security features in the system that will support the risk tolerance of the asset owner. So again, I think this is going to be an integral part. I think the organisations need to embrace cybersecurity from awareness, understanding and execution perspective. Thank you very much, Steve, for coming in today. It's been wonderful chatting with you. Thank you. And that's it for today. We'll be back soon with some great content. But before you go, remember to give us a follow so you don't miss an episode.

Thanks for tuning in. See you soon. This episode was brought to you by Hitachi Energy, created, introduced and hosted by Bárbara Freitas-Daniels, content and script writing by Elizabeth Kollross, Diane Galaz, Kristin McKinsey. Produced and edited by Creative Chimps. Guest speaker, Steve Kunsman.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. From Insight to Action

    Oct 24, 202614 minAudio

    As power systems grow more complex, energy planning now blends long-term strategy with daily operations. In this Power Pulse episode, Bret Toplyn draws upon his nearly 15 years of experience driving analytical software...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Frontiers of Grid Automation Research—Working as One Hitachi

    Oct 19, 202624 minAudio

    In this episode of Power Pulse, we explore the frontiers of grid research with our guest Bo Yang, who shares how digital innovation is reshaping the future of energy systems. From early work anticipating the rise of...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Why modern technologies are the only path forward for optimizing the grid

    Sep 18, 202619 minAudio

    As electricity demand accelerates and new loads arrive faster and at greater scale, utilities are being forced to rethink how the grid is planned and operated. In this episode of Power Pulse, John Glassmire explores why...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. AI in Action: How Utilities Are Modernizing Grid Operations

    Aug 5, 202619 minAudio

    How are utilities putting AI to work today? Milli Comstock shares real-world examples of how artificial intelligence is helping modernize grid operations - from predictive maintenance and asset performance management to...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Welcome to the Digital Factory!

    Jul 1, 202616 minAudio

    Factories are undergoing a digital transformation, adopting new technologies to improve efficiency, quality, and traceability. For us, this comes to life through the Digital Factory. By connecting people, machines, and...

    Credit the people on this episode