Ben, Steve, and Jared discuss BCO 41. Send us Fan Mail Support the show Official Website: politymatters.org Support the Show: Buy Me a Coffee Twitter/X: @PolityMatters Facebook: Polity Matters Page Scott's Twitter Jared's Twitter Ben's Twitter
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_01Well, hello and welcome to Polity Matters. My name is Ben Ratliff, and I'm joined, as always, by my good friend Jared Nelson, and we have a guest with us today, Mr. Steve Tipton. And we know that you all love it when we have Steve on, because you have told me. Uh Scott is nowhere to be found. We think maybe he's at Youth Camp. Uh his house had lead stuff going on, and the state was making him clean it out last week, so maybe he got stuck somewhere in a basement or a crevice. Do they have basements up in that part of the world?
SPEAKER_01We don't have them down here, so I don't know. Jared, any basements in that part of the world?
SPEAKER_00Oh, definitely. All over Illinois.
SPEAKER_01Okay, yeah. I've heard of basements. Uh they sound cool. I'd love to be a part of one one day.
SPEAKER_02Um you believe they exist, but you have no personal experience. With as many tornadoes as there are in the Midwest, you have to have basements.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, you'd think that we'd have we'd have basements for that purpose here in the Delta, but nope, we just hide inside our bathrooms, which are not safe at all. Uh we just a little bit of housekeeping. Uh we're still uh well, actually, I don't know when this is gonna air, but hey, send us a note as to how polymatters has been helpful for you, and we will put you into a drawing to uh get a copy of Per Almquist's new commentary that he signed for us at General Assembly. Uh and I mean just to be up front, it's not creatively signed. He didn't uh you know dedicate it or anything.
SPEAKER_01There's there's no inscription. It is literally just his name. Almost looks like it was printed above his name in in the title page of the book.
SPEAKER_00So uh I think he actually gives us the secrets of BCO 44 in it.
SPEAKER_01Ooh, ooh. Maybe he skipped forward and wrote those in that chapter that I and I didn't catch it. Wow, that's impressive. Uh we are here today to talk about BCO 41. Um BCO 39, you'll remember from last time, lists the modes uh by which acts and decisions of a lower court are brought under the supervision of a higher court. And so last week, uh when we referenced that, we talked with Fred about general review and control. And now we're getting into the other three um uh modes uh that these things happen by, which are reference, appeal, and complaint.
SPEAKER_01Uh and so we're getting into references. Steve, I was just gonna pitch to you real quick. Anything we need to say or think about before we get into chapter 41 and the particulars of it?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, so um as you just said, uh it's uh there are a number of ways that uh you know acts and decisions of lower courts are brought up to higher courts. Uh there is the the general way, the normal way, I guess you could say, um, is or the ordinary way, right? Review and control. Uh Presbyteries review this the minutes of of uh the courts below them, uh the General Assembly reviews the records of the courts below them, etc. Um, and then there are kind of three extraordinary ways reference, appeal, and complaint.
SPEAKER_02Um obviously appeal and complaints are for other episodes, but they're dealing with you know particular decisions. Um a reference is generally an issue that is before a lower court uh and they're having some difficulty um dealing with that issue, right? So so they need help. They're asking they're they're referring the issue to a higher court um either for advice or just simply to dispose of the matter altogether.
SPEAKER_02And so uh chapter 41 is uh you know, again, detailing uh how all those things work. And uh it's probably not in one sense so helpful to kind of go section by section by section. Um probably better, I mean, kind of what we're doing now is just kind of thinking about them broadly and generally, and then um the sections sort of give specific advice as to how the higher court is to deal with them, um, and then even what the lower court needs to do even as they're making a reference.
SPEAKER_02Um but generally speaking, references are uh kind of two different varieties, what we might call non-judicial and a judicial reference. Uh a non-judicial reference is primarily some uh decision that the lower court is trying or question the lower court is trying to answer. And for whatever reason, they don't feel uh that they have the capacity to answer that question to sufficiently answer it, and so they're gonna they're they're gonna refer that question to a higher court.
SPEAKER_02Um what would be like an example of that? Yeah, so like y'all are just gonna get into the whole thing now.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, all right, cool.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, we're just gonna get into it. I love it. Yeah, we're gonna dive in. Um so um perhaps a question r regarding the interpretation of a particular portion of the constitution. Um so every court has the responsibility and the right to interpret the constitution for themselves, um, although, again, that's subject to general review and control. Um but there may be an aspect of the BCO that, I mean, far be it from us to say this, there may be some aspect of the BCO that is confusing or uh is hard to understand.
SPEAKER_02And so the lower court could refer a question on how to understand, how to interpret, how to uh sort of uh bring into action some aspect of the BCO. Um, you know, sometimes, although I said there's judicial and non-judicial, sometimes those those non-judicial references are touching the judicial process, right? So um what is um how do we um how do we fulfill the requirements of the rules of discipline in this particular case?
SPEAKER_02Or um what is a censure um what what centers are available in this particular circumstance or whatever? Um and so there's there could be some benefit to appealing to a broader knowledge base, right? Maybe in my little church with my handful of elders, we've never thought about or had to deal with uh a case of um, you know, um trying to think of an example, um, you know, uh a child who um uh you know refuses to obey their parents.
SPEAKER_02I mean, that's whatever. I can't imagine a church that's never faced that, but it's the only thing I can think of. Um and so we're we're appealing to the larger body to say, you know, what are some ways that our constitution uh you know touches this issue, uh, deals with that issue, and it may be the case that somebody in the presbytery has dealt with that situation. Um perhaps a better example, uh, Ben, feel free to cut the last example, but a better example would be something like um, you know, we have a ordained ruling elder who uh has gone to seminary and now wants to become, you know, a teaching elder, um, although this is more a question for the presbytery anyway, but you know, do we need to reordain him or do we need to just simply install him?
SPEAKER_02I mean, that that's a question of interpreting the constitution that maybe the court that's handling that issue doesn't really know the answer, and so they might refer it to uh a higher court to give an answer on that. Um and some examples, uh all you really have to do is go back and look at CCB's uh the Committee on Constitutional Business's minutes for the last you know 50 years or whatever, they handle non-judicial references. And so the types of questions that they're asked are are you know, obviously the types of questions some presbyteries had at different points and how to interpret the constitution.
SPEAKER_02What does the constitution mean in this given instance or this given circumstance?
SPEAKER_00Um and you can find a lot of those answers in Smith's commentary, uh Omquist has some in the PCO uh BCO, PCA history webpage will have some of their past answers. And so there may be times in which you're gonna ask something that has been asked before, and you can just go there and find the answer. Oh, absolutely.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Well, here let's get it. Let's let's let's tease out some of these sections because I think we're gonna get into all these all these details in uh in in much more. I mean, Jared, is there anything you want to refer to before we do this?
SPEAKER_00Any references you'd like to do.
SPEAKER_01Let me refer everybody uh to 41.1. A reference is a written representation, an application made by a lower court to a higher court for advice or other action on a matter pending before the lower court, and is ordinarily to be made to the next higher court. Um so we've already gotten into it a little bit. There's a reason, right? Usually a lower court um is going to make reference because they need help with something, and that's going to be in 41.2. Uh but I think mainly what I want to look at here is what what says ordinarily it's to be made to the next higher court.
SPEAKER_01Uh I I don't think it's implying that references can go down.
SPEAKER_02No. That would be kind of odd to refer a matter to a lower court.
SPEAKER_01Um GA refers to the Presbyterian court next, isn't it, Steve?
SPEAKER_02Yeah. Yeah, no, I yeah, the General Assembly refers a matter to the session of Covenant Presbyterian Church in Panama City, Florida. Right. All right, nope, we'll we'll we'll deal with it. Yeah. Um yeah, ordinarily the next hire. So um uh uh uh you you can send something directly to the General Assembly, obviously again, through Committee of Constitutional Business. Um and I've only I mean I'd served on it for a couple of years. I I don't recall any off the top of my head, I don't recall getting any uh references from sessions per se.
SPEAKER_02Um but at least here ordinarily you you you could do that. I I I think you know perhaps you might want to, particularly if you were in a certain instance where you were you you believed that the presbytery had a particular view that you didn't agree with, um, you know, like let's say they they found something in your minutes and you think you did it right and they don't think you did, what would be the point of referring that issue back to the very body that you already know kind of what their opinion is, so you could refer it to the next hire.
SPEAKER_02Um but that's again, that's that's more on the advice section.
SPEAKER_00Um so would this be something that you would ask for advice before you do something? You're like, if we do this, we might get pinged. Let's just ask them if we can beforehand so that you know we're we at least have a little bit of cover if this becomes an issue.
SPEAKER_02Well, and I think the language even on a matter that is pending before the lower court, that in one sense, the proper way, or maybe not the proper way, but a proper way you could imagine this is let's let's imagine we're a session right now and we're we're debating a difficult topic, and there's a motion on the floor to do something and we're discussing it, and we decide that we don't have enough information and or we are divided in how we think the constitution applies in that particular instance, then you know, a motion to um you know to refer this uh to the presbytery for advice would be sort of a procedural mo.
SPEAKER_02I mean, I know most sessions really don't operate on that level of Roberts Rules, but just you know the idea would be a motion to refer to the presbytery for advice, or even even to take action on the matter, to decide because we can't. Those things would be uh appropriate and uh in one sense you uh the matter that is pending is this idea that it is a um it is a live topic of discussion. Um now again, sessions particularly and I imagine almost all of them do operate under more of the relaxed Roberts rules for like a small committee type of thing, and so you can have discussion when there's not even an emotion on the floor, and that's fine and good, and and and you ought to do that.
SPEAKER_02There's no reason to have the level of formality at a 10-member session or whatever. Um but even as you're discussing that matter and you're saying, okay, again, it's difficult, we're divided, whatever it is. I know I'm talking about 41.2 then, but uh but then we we're gonna send that up because we need that advice, we need that action, or we need them to take action on it. Um and and in that sense, I I think it's less a hypothetical than it is uh a concrete particular that the session is dealing with.
SPEAKER_02Uh it's not trivia time, you know, it's not try to stump the CCB, but rather we're actually dealing with this and we don't know how to proceed, and so we need your help.
SPEAKER_01Almquist makes a point here. He says that sometimes the ordinarily could be a situation where a presbytery has received a reference from a session and they just don't know what to do, and so they send it straight up to the GA right away. And so it's it's um it's not necessarily bypassing the presbytery as much as it is just they don't respond to it, but they give it to the next court to respond to instead.
SPEAKER_02Um, and I think even in that instance, the presbytery is still taking the action to refer it to the next level. So yeah.
SPEAKER_01Um I think my next my the next time I'm gonna write an overture, I'm gonna write an overture to combine 41 one through six into one paragraph. Uh I think they all believe it. For the ease of future for the ease of future episodes. That's right. Yeah. Uh 41-2 among proper subjects for reference are matters that are new, delicate, or difficult, or on which the members of the lower court are very seriously divided, or which relate to questions involving the Constitution and legal procedures respecting which the lower court feels the need of guidance.
SPEAKER_01So you might have somebody send a reference uh that says, Hey, we've never seen this before, we don't know what to do. Or um, we this is a very delicate situation and we don't trust ourselves to handle it properly. We need we need more wisdom. Uh or um we don't know what we're doing. Please help. That could that could be one that goes up. Uh it's interesting here, isn't it, that the uh there could be division in a court. So if a session is split, uh Pearr has a reference uh, I think in his book on this where he says, like, you know, a presbytery tried a case twice and they kept getting split tie votes on the on the judicial decision, and so they sent it up to be tried by the by the GA, I think.
SPEAKER_01Um or maybe that was just an example he made, but uh yeah, or constitutional difficulties if if you don't know what to do, which we've already talked about a fair amount. So Jared, what you got? You're muted. Can't hear you. You're still muted.
SPEAKER_00I I was just gonna say, um I this seems like it would look different for advice versus action, right? So advice, you're trying to get some advice so that you can act on it. But if you're in a place in which you're like, we don't think that we can do this, you can take the action and say you guys are gonna be the ones that have to do this. In fact, this happened fairly recently, didn't it, with a uh judicial case where a presbytery referred a case to the SJC. And it's one of the, I think the first case that the SJC actually tried as the SJC, uh, because uh the I think of Central Indiana just said, Yeah, we don't we don't want to try this case.
SPEAKER_00Like we we feel like there's enough things that are are going wrong. We keep on being told we'd we've done something wrong. Why don't you guys just do it for us, I guess. Yeah.
SPEAKER_02Well, yeah, and I think in that situation, I mean it it was it was a lot of these things. Um there was there was a lot that was new that was going on. Um definitely delicate. It was very difficult. They were seriously divided in how to proceed and how to go forward with it. And I mean it really wasn't a we just don't want to do this. Um it was we've been trying to do this for over a year and keep getting sort of uh stymied in some sense along the way.
SPEAKER_02And so I think in those senses, uh it's uh it's very helpful. Um but but also you know, think about particularly like a in a church setting where you have uh, you know, let's say the session files charges against one of its own members, like a another a ruling elder, and uh everybody on the session is both uh supposed to be witnesses and somebody has to be a prosecutor, and um then you have, you know, then they're all supposed to be judges at the same time, and there's just no way for them to even be able to do the judicial work because of the nature of the issue.
SPEAKER_02Um, that would be one of those cases where uh a reference would be in one sense, I mean, I don't want to say required, but certainly required in the sense of there's absolutely no way for us to do this.
SPEAKER_00Um typically session, right? Yeah. What's that? Well, so typically you would ask for advice and then defer that action until you got the answer back. Maybe unlike what Overtures did l this last year, in which they asked for advice and they kept on moving and didn't wait for them to get an answer back for C C V. But so typically, if you're asking for advice, you're waiting on the action. If you're referencing the action, you're just like, okay, you guys do it. You're too slow.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, I mean, um, so I think yeah, references sort of contain both of those ideas, though. So but but but there's a difference though, I think, with what you're describing. Um so a court, particularly a court that has committees, can refer items to other committees for advice, but they're not binding themselves to even wait for that or anything like that. I mean, you know, in one sense, um, I mean, obviously, if you just make a motion to refer it to the administration committee, it's taken out of your hands and given to the administration committee.
SPEAKER_02Um in that case, you know, you have one committee saying, uh, sure, we'd love to get their advice. Uh but it but anyway, that that was slightly different. But as a as a session, if you're gonna refer something to the presbytery or the presbytery is gonna refer something to the General Assembly, then uh they certainly ought to I mean the idea is you should wait until you get that response back. Um the trouble, of course, with CCB is it meets once a year outside of some sort of special.
SPEAKER_02I mean, if you if they get a reference, they can meet, but they rarely do. They usually wait until April or whatever, and then they give you a reference, and it could be 11 months after, you know, you're like, I don't understand what to do. What took so long? Golly, guys. I imagine that if we got a reference, CCB got a reference, like let's say in May, and it was significant, and a lower court was really struggling in how to interpret something, we they would probably have a called meeting.
SPEAKER_02You can do that very you know super easy these days with Zoom or whatever. So I mean they probably would do something like that, but but there's no uh outside of the CCB agreeing to take it up, there's really no mechanism to do that. Whereas with a presbytery, at least you have more regular meetings where they can meet and make a decision and give you a an answer.
SPEAKER_01So well here, let's look at 41.3. Um the you know what can a reference include? What can they what can they actually do? So there's there's subjects of references, but what can they ask for? 41.3 gets at that. In making a reference, the lower court may ask for advice only or for final disposition of the matter referred. And in particular, it may refer a judicial case with request for its trial and decision by the higher court. So it I mean, as I'm reading this, Steve, the semicolon is is what divides the non-judicial from the judicial.
SPEAKER_01So you can get advice or you can get a decision from the higher court on something, or it can be a judicial case and you're requesting them to take care of business for you. Yeah.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, so um, and even under like non-judicial references, um I don't know of any instances in the PCA where a presbytery you know sent to the General Assembly and said, We're referring to you the matter of whether or not we should have four stated meetings rather than three. You know, you decide and you tell us, or something like that. So that that that final disposition of the matter referred um is very rare, maybe even, dare I say, non-existent, you know, in the history of the PCA.
SPEAKER_02But it but it's at least a possibility where you can say, and I think it's more likely, just again, given the reality of the circumstances, it's more likely that a session would say the the decision we need to make on this is so difficult, uh, or we're so divided. Uh it's not a judicial case, but we're we're asking you to make a decision uh on this matter. And then the Presbytery could, we'll get to that later, they could take it up and make a decision. Um but when it comes to a judicial case, um, it does seem that uh in that instance, you're not asking for uh you know advice about the judicial process, which I would still consider to be in many ways a non-judicial reference.
SPEAKER_02Um but you are actually saying we want you to take up this uh judicial matter, uh, you know, be it a case or a case without process, or be it a uh I mean, even a thirty one two investigation in theory, you could ask the SJC to take that on for you, um, or an appeal or a complaint. I mean, uh, you know, obviously an appeal. those are slightly different things, but or a reference. Or a reference. Yeah. Well, I mean, yeah.
SPEAKER_02But but again, yeah. So it is that you you're asking them to in a in a judicial reference, you're actually asking them to basically become the court of original jurisdiction on that issue.
unknownYeah.
SPEAKER_01Pear made a point I thought was really interesting. And Jared, I don't know if other guys reference this or not, but there was a I didn't read Morton on this, that the the 12th General Assembly had a constitutional inquiry about what precisely is passed up to the higher court in a judicial reference. Is it that they that all they're allowed to do is try the case or can they amend the indictment and the charges, you know, is can they investigate more and and the the constitutional inquiry response was basically that the whole matter goes up as if that it belongs to that next higher court originally and they can do anything that's allowable, they're permitted to to take action in any of those ways.
SPEAKER_01And so yeah, amending the charges, things like that. Which is which is pretty cool. You know, I mean and and of course you don't want to hand you know it's it's not like we're handing it up but tying an arm behind their back, right? They they get to do whatever is necessary to to deal with the matter. And we'll talk about some more things related to that in these other sections.
SPEAKER_02Well yeah I mean it is kind of like I mean a way a double edged sword, right? I mean you're saying I can't do it, we're giving it to you, but then you don't get to determine how the higher court actually conducts the case, deals with the matter, what decision they make, what censure they give I mean if you're going to refer it you you have to be willing to uh to allow that higher court to actually deal with it. Um I well and one other thing if I could say come on go on and and and this is one of the the difficulties too with judicial cases is that um when a lower court gives by reference a a judicial case to a higher court you lose a level of appeal.
SPEAKER_02So when a session says we can't deal with this we're going to give it to Presbytery um at least in that instance the the the church member still has an ability to appeal that decision to the SJC but when the SJC you know uh took the reference from Central Indiana um there was no opportunity for appeal. There was no higher court you could take it to and so um that's one of the reasons why at least historically I know the SJC has been very reticent to take those kind of references because of that reality.
SPEAKER_02Now on the other the other side most of the appeals that come to the SJC not all of them but but many of them are alleging sort of technical defects in what the lower court did. And again at least in theory when you hand a case over to the SJC you know the men who read these court cases all the time and are supposed to be you know the most knowledgeable in the PCA about these judicial matters their capacity to make an error in procedure should be less than you might find at the average Presbytery or even the average session.
SPEAKER_02But still you do lose you do lose the level of appeal.
SPEAKER_01So little known fact when the SJC doesn't know what to do they uh refer up to the polity matters so just that's everybody knows. I didn't know that. Okay yeah yeah well they'll tell you when your when your uh your your uh initiation takes place you'll um after my hazing you would tell after all that's done yeah um yeah I I think I I was trying to read through a little bit Olmquist uh is the only one I read this week by the way if anybody can tell Olmquist talks about this in 413 saying that that the higher court can do only what's asked of them.
SPEAKER_01I don't I don't know why he made that point here in particular but he's just he he says like look if if the lower court makes reference asking for advice that's all that the higher court can do. We're gonna talk about it in a minute how they're not required to but that's all that they can provide. They can't take jurisdiction of the matter and make it make you know take action on the issue for the lower court they can only do what's been asked of them. And so we'll get into a little bit more of that in uh in 40 415 here in a second in terms of their um obligation and and things.
SPEAKER_01So Jared are you good? Okay. 414 a reference may be presented to the higher court by one or more representatives appointed by the lower court for this purpose. It should be accompanied with so much of the record as shall be necessary for proper understanding and consideration of the matter referred. This reads to me kind of like how uh a church is supposed to show up at Presbytery and prosecute the call upon the teaching elder they want to be their minister. It doesn't always happen by a representative it just is often in writing um and so and these days the way things are electronically that's that's what's going to happen.
SPEAKER_01But the important part maybe we should talk about is that a reference needs to be accompanied with as much of the record as ne as is necessary for the matter to be dealt with.
SPEAKER_02You don't hand a uh a halfway thought through idea up and ask for them to to do the rest of the research for you basically yeah well and this is one of those areas where uh another of my uh jobs well I don't I don't have any more but where I was helping out the administrative committee with um you know even even there's you know non-judicial references there's judicial references and then there's email the state of clerk or the PCA um which has you know no no standing in one sense it's just you know not even pious advice sometimes but um so we would get questions all the time and as you answer the question that's presented in the email and then you get a four page response and you find out oh you didn't tell me everything you asked me one very specific question and then now you're gonna try to use that and shoehorn that into a situation that is entirely not entirely different but the context matters and now whoa whoa whoa wait wait wait that's not what I was saying I I wasn't telling you you could do that or you couldn't do that or whatever.
SPEAKER_02And so I think in a similar situation here the record is probably going to be minutes in that sense. I mean that's really all you have unless it's maybe you know a committee's minutes or something like that or some narrative that the clerk can provide but that it's going to give enough information to the higher court that they know what you're asking and why you're asking and and as much information as they can so that they can make a decision and they don't have to come back to you. I mean that's one great uh thing about having a representative because they can ask or they can answer questions the higher court may have about the issue um but ultimately you know you need enough information that you can make a really good response to I I will say that this is probably observed more in its breach with the CCB committee.
SPEAKER_02I mean most of the times you get just like two sentence questions and and and everybody's like what's behind this what what else is going on here? But and then there are others that they give you plenty of information and you can answer them but but it seems um more often than not it it's just a very you know simple question but it's the you know it's it's the circumstances and the implications of that that can be much more difficult.
SPEAKER_00And the the provision for references for advice gives it a little bit more of an official flavor than I think we've all done unofficial references whether it was email the clerk or whether it's just call it my buddy email Fred Greco. Yeah email Fred Greco or Steve Tipton or Howie or something like that and say hey what's your advice on this of you know Fred Greco?
SPEAKER_02Yeah and so I think then a court would actually take and use an official reference versus just saying like hey I called up my buddy and this is what he said like well that's that's a little less informal yeah I mean I've always been well when I was working for the AC I mean that was like one of the scariest parts is thinking someone's going to stand up in a presbytery meeting and say well Steve Tipton in this email from the AC said and again have it used in a way that was entirely you know tangential to the question they were actually asking or whatever else so yeah that that was always a little bit frightening.
SPEAKER_02That's why there's a uh a a a disclaimer at the bottom of your email that's like seven pages long uh telling you this is only advice you know this etc etc but uh not legal advice so forty one five although references are sometimes proper in general it is better that every court should discharge the duty assigned it under the law of the church.
SPEAKER_01A higher court is not required to accede to the request of the lower but it should ordinarily give advice when so requested what wisdom right here every court should basically try to do what they're supposed to do all the time and don't just defer things up don't get in the habit of asking for help on every single little thing. Yeah maybe we should say that that references should be unusual to some degree or another.
SPEAKER_02Yeah yeah well and I I think too that this comes back to our our doctrine of the church and and and why we are different than either a congregational or episcopal form of government where I mean in a congregational church they they don't have anybody to ask I mean maybe the association but but there's no um there's no requirement you know that none of these things apply in a congregationalist church pastor could ask his dad but that's probably about as I mean that's that's about it. His dad may be his boss but um but in like an even in like an episcopal church where the the the bishop is apart from you outside of your organization in one sense he stands above you and so you ask that advice and it's really sort of coming not quite ex cathedral but I mean there's a sense in which it's coming down from on top but in in the essence of the Presbyterian government is that at every level from the General Assembly down to the session it is made up of presbyters men gifted and called by God to do the work that God has given them to do.
SPEAKER_02And so you have both the blessing of um God working in the local church through the gifts that he's given to those men as they do the work that's before them you have that blessing but you also have the blessing of okay this is too difficult, too new, too strange for us. And so we're going to ask our brothers in a higher court of which we are a part right it's not going to somebody outside you but asking this group that you are actually a part of to say can you help us with this and so it it's the both and right it's a great reminder that a local session is by God's design and gifting and calling sufficient to do the work of that church.
SPEAKER_02And yet at those moments at which it comes upon issues that it feels more keenly its own insufficiency it has the opportunity to ask for help from brothers who they labor alongside in their presbytery or presbyteries in the General Assembly.
SPEAKER_01Fred and I talked about this last week uh it's it's back to 113 in the book all church courts are one in nature constituted of the same elements possessed inherently of the same kinds of rights and powers and differing only as the Constitution may provide we're one church and so we act like that. Yeah it's super cool. I'm glad not to be a Baptist when we get to stuff like this I mean also my dad wouldn't know what to tell me what to do so so yeah.
SPEAKER_02Sorry dad everybody okay well and then and then the other piece um the idea that just by giving a reference does not obligate a higher court um it it it doesn't have to take up the matter um and particularly again I mean in judicial cases it can say whether it's for the reasons we just talked about a minute ago no we take it up he's gonna lose a level of an appeal or whatever else or because it just says look you're closer to the situation than we could ever be.
SPEAKER_02And sometimes that's bad being that close to the issue. Sometimes it's the only way you could ever get to the you know to the matter at hand like you know those people you know their character you're gonna be able to determine who's more believable let's say than others because of your close association with those members of your church if they simply come before the presbytery and we don't know them from Adam how are we going to to do that part of our responsibility to determine who, you know, what what witness what testimony we need to weigh heavier or higher than the other that's again one of the reasons why I mean we'll get to you guys will get to that later but even under appeals and complaints that that idea of the great deference that the higher court is to give to the lower court in matters of believability of testimony would you know them better.
SPEAKER_02So even in that case even outside of the review and control aspect you're much better uh able hopefully to make those determinations and so uh there could be a lot of reasons why they don't want to take it up I I do think it's important though that that if they're asked for advice I mean you know ordinarily and again ordinarily is a is a marvelous word um doesn't mean always but but certainly under normal circumstances if you're asked for advice you should give it um and I I don't know of many instances in where a higher court has ever refused to do that.
SPEAKER_02Now they may refuse in the sense we talked about earlier where they said that's a stumper we don't know the answer either we're gonna we're we'll we'll send this up on up but that's different I think than saying no we're not gonna give you any advice on that.
SPEAKER_01Isn't isn't it Scott's favorite word in the book ordinarily? Jared? I think ordinarily it is 416 when a court makes a reference it ought to have all the testimony and other documents duly prepared produced and in perfect readiness so that the higher court may be able to fully consider and handle the case with as little difficulty or delay as possible I'll ask the question that's in my head what's the difference between 414 and 416 414 says it has to be accompanied with so much of the record as is necessary and 416 says it should have everything put together and sent up so that they can make a decision quickly.
SPEAKER_00Is there a difference? It seems like you have to take that testimony so um if there's some testimony that you need to get don't make the court do it try to take that testimony and then send it up as kind of how I read it.
SPEAKER_01Sure. So if there's anything that if there's anything they need to make the decision or give the advice you need to take care of that so that they don't have to which is what 414 says I think it it just it just sort of expands it.
SPEAKER_02Yeah I do think it's it's it's actually interesting though that it says imperfect readiness. I mean I I would think our a doctrine of original sin and total depravity would suggest that there is no such thing as a perfectly ready uh record of the case but um Jared you could look up the history of this chapter or any of these sections I didn't glance at that webpage today.
SPEAKER_00It's it's nearly blank. He uh either there's no history to it or but if you look at Ramsey this is so much of 41 is word for word.
SPEAKER_01416 just sounds and reads so archaic almost like that perfect readiness line Steve like that just seems like an old way to say something. Yeah this is the 1800s language. Maybe 41 needs some needs some overture work. Maybe we'll play with that sometime.
SPEAKER_02Well I mean what else should we say? No I mean Ramsey Ramsey is a little um does does take some I I looked at it uh earlier today um but it it talks about this idea you know that you you can make a reference at any stage right it's not just before the trial begins like you could start taking testimony and go oh wait a minute this is way outside whatever and then but at that point obviously everything that you've taken thus far you you don't roll back and and say well let's start over again at the indictment level I mean you take what you've got to that point and you send it up and you say this is where we stopped this is where we just this is where we found out we can't go further.
SPEAKER_02Um but he also says this you know manifestly which is an interesting word because none of us saw this but manifestly it is not contemplated that a judicial case will be referred referred before the evidence has all been taken and yet this is not forbidden since the very difficulty might hang around questions as to the taking and admission of evidence. So I mean I it it seems that he's saying again ordinarily um that once you begin something you you're gonna take all of that testimony up until the point where you have to make a decision and then you're like okay given all the testimony we've taken we can't make a decision now we're gonna give a reference um but that seems to be the more ordinary idea not in the sense of how it actually works but in how the sense of at least how Ramsey's reading it um but that at least it's possible that somewhere in the middle you come to a difficulty even of taking the evidence or determining what evidence is um is applicable.
SPEAKER_02And in one sense I mean I could see that as a a major issue in a trial where someone you know wants to admit evidence and the court is divided on whether or not that evidence is actually admissible. Because if you just simply go forward and then it goes to appeal, not only is the inadmission of that evidence in one sense an appealable issue but you actually can't bring the evidence in at the appeal right the app you know you you can't bring new information in an appeal that wasn't before the lower court and so it you know again if you're evenly divided or or seriously divided you can't decide which way to go that may be a good issue that you send up and say um either A give us advice tell us should we allow this or should we not or B regardless of what advice you give us we're just asking you just to take the thing and to run with it.
SPEAKER_01Everybody feel okay cool that was fun well as Scott's lead ridden house would ordinarily say this podcast is over. Thanks for joining us if you're interested in learning more about what we've talked about you can check out the show notes but I don't think there's going to be anything there. Uh thanks to Steve for joining us listeners uh this is episode 98 of Polity Matters and we have big plans for episode 100 which happens to fall right around our second birthday so stay tuned in a couple of weeks for what's coming we don't know what it'll be and in fact I might even have to add something to the end of this episode in a month when we air it to let you know what the details are but pay attention.
SPEAKER_01If you have enjoyed the show do consider following us on Twitter and Facebook at Polytters and make sure that you're subscribed in your podcast app of choice. If you have questions or comments you can talk contact us at Politymattersfeedback at gmail.com you can go to politymatters.org and see lots of details about the show and there's also a link somewhere in all these different places where you can click and uh support our work and we can get you some access to some uh you know sub supporter exclusive uh social groups and other things like that. I don't know if you want to be a part of it.
SPEAKER_01It gets a little weird but it's kind of fun. So uh jump in if you feel like it let me know. Thanks again for spending your valuable time with us and uh until next time say goodbye gentlemen bye gentlemen goodbye y'all take care
Ben, Jared, and Scott are joined by Brad Voyles, president of Covenant College, as the RAO series continues through the agencies and committees of the General Assembly. Brad shares how he went from Bellhaven and RTS...
Jared and Scott are joined by Andrew Rein, coordinator of Reformed University Fellowship (RUF), as the RAO series continues through the agencies and committees of the General Assembly. Andrew shares how he came to RUF...
Ben, Jared, and Scott are joined by Steve Dowling, interim coordinator of Mission to North America (MNA), as the RAO series continues through the committees and agencies of the General Assembly. Steve marks one year in...
Ben and Jared are joined by Lloyd Kim, coordinator of Mission to the World (MTW), as the RAO series continues through the committees and agencies of the General Assembly. Lloyd shares his path from Southern California...
Ben, Jared, and Scott are joined by Stephen Estock, coordinator of the PCA's Committee on Discipleship Ministries (CDM), as the RAO series continues through the permanent committees and agencies. Stephen shares his path...