Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Polity Matters

Polity Matters artwork

94. A Good Church, A Bad Church, and Nowhere (BCO 38)

Jul 29, 202549 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

He's never introduced, but you can't deny the dulcet tones of RE Howie Donahoe, who joins Scott and Jared to get into BCO 38. Presbytery Clerks Download Page Send us Fan Mail Support the show Official Website: politymatters.org Support the Show: Buy Me a Coffee Twitter/X: @PolityMatters Facebook: Polity Matters Page Scott's Twitter Jared's Twitter Ben's Twitter

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_02And this gets us now into the main uh event for today, which is uh BCO38. And so we're going through cases uh without process, and some are disciplinary, others are just by uh natural removal. Um can you guys still hear me? Okay, because my my airpods are pinging, and so I'm just trying to make sure you can hear me. And so we'll we'll begin in uh BCO 381 when it says uh this when any person shall come forward and make his offense known to the court, a full statement of the fact shall be recorded and judgment rendered without process.

SPEAKER_02In handling a confession of guilt, it is essential that the person intends that the person intends to confess and permit the court to render judgment without process. Statements made by him in the presence of the court must not be taken as a basis of judgment without process except by his consent. In the event of a confession, a confession is intended, a written confession, i.e. a sufficient summary of the facts, the person's specific confession, and any expression or evidence of repentance must be approved by the accused and by the court before the court proceeds to a judgment, and the co-signed documents shall be appended to the minutes, regular or executive session.

SPEAKER_02No other information may be presented without written consent from the accused and the court, and this prohibition includes individuals, prosecutors, committees, and commissions. A censured person has the right to appeal according to BCO 42. The person has the right to be assisted by the counsel at any point in accord with the stipulations of BCO 3219. And so that's the first part of 38 uh 1. And so, well, how does 38.1 then begin to set us up for cases without process?

SPEAKER_03Well, first off, I would say because of all the changes to 38.1, um, it's kind of misleading to call it a case without process because there is significant process, and if the process isn't followed, uh the appellant can prevail. Um so it's kind of a misnomer, but it's essentially there's it's not a trial, it's an out-of-trial um confession of guilt and an out of trial censure, if appropriate.

SPEAKER_03Um this paragraph has been changed at least three times, uh, usually with additional stuff. Um the first change that I was involved in was Pittsburgh Presbytery way back in the late 80s when our minister went forward at a presbytery meeting unbeknownst to the session and confessed to something and then walked out of the room.

SPEAKER_03And um that kind of threw everybody for a loop. We didn't know what to do, so uh that's where the change came in that indicated that you know it needs to, he needs to the court needs to know that he intended to confess and that he intended for the court to administer censure without process. So that was a change that was made, and then there was a change a couple years ago that defined what this written document was that has to be co-signed.

SPEAKER_03It's not just a full statement of the facts, it's uh the uh kind of a summary of the facts, his confession, and any expression or evidence of repentance. Um the goal of that was to try to get a document that all things can be based on. So whoever's working with the confessing uh person uh uh on behalf of the court will come up with a document that that person or the the confessor and the usually the commission will judge to be sufficiently complete to render a censure.

SPEAKER_03Um and then last last year the thing that was added was if it's a personal offense, uh the court needs to discern whether the offended party agrees that it's a full statement of the facts, because it may not be.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, we'll we'll read that here in a s in a second. Okay, um I just wanted to ask the question uh first. So this seems to do with a uh a case, not really necessarily a case yet, but um somebody else isn't accusing a different person. This is a person that's accusing themselves, they're coming forward, they're saying this is um an offense that I've done, and I'm I'm just gonna lay it on the table and confess to it and have the court deal with it. So that this would be a bit of a different than what we see in the previous chapters, right?

SPEAKER_03Yeah, I would say this that would be the purest case, but those are, in my experience, kind of rare. Um a more common one would be uh it comes to the attention of the court that there might be something uh unbecoming in, let's say, a minister's life or doctrine. However, they learn of that, then someone goes to the minister and starts talking to him about it, and you know, he doesn't have to engage with an investigating committee.

SPEAKER_03That's maybe a different topic, but um and uh the presbytery investigating committee might say, well, to save everybody the trouble of going through a full trial and a full appeal, um, are you willing to confess to this and that? And he'd say, Well, I'm willing to confess to this, but not that. And then the uh investigating committee can work with him saying, Well, listen, if you don't confess to that, uh then we're gonna have to go to trial.

SPEAKER_03So, you know, and it's kind of a I wouldn't call it a negotiation, but it's you know, you're trying to help the person confess, you're trying to get a true, thorough, real confession, and um with his knowledge that uh any censure is going to be based on what he puts on paper and uh is co-signed by him and whoever the representative of the court is.

SPEAKER_01So yeah, I and I think one of the reasons we were uh kind of excited when we had you for this was I think you wrote the second paragraph uh of this, and so or at least your Presbytery was involved with it. So if Scott wants to read us that, then maybe you can tell us about what's the the reason that this was was necessary change on there that uh just went through in the past couple of years. So Scott, do you want to read that?

SPEAKER_03That begins with in any instance?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, we'll have Scott read that, read that, and then we'll have you comment on that.

SPEAKER_02So BCO 381 finishes in that second paragraph by saying in any instance involving a personal offense, the court shall attempt to inform the offended persons of that part of the confession that the court deemed pertinent to the offense against him or her. The court shall invite the offended person to provide the court comment on the confession prior to the final approval of the confession by the confessor and the court. The court shall encourage the offended person to enlist the help of an advisor in preparing any such comments.

SPEAKER_02In all instances, the court shall report the way such offended persons were informed of the parts of the confession pertinent to them. And so the first part of BCO 381 deals with perhaps both the confessor and the court signing on to a confession of someone's own guilt. And now in personal offenses, this has been added to now include those the person has himself offended. And so, what was the thought process behind adding this uh to 381, Howie?

SPEAKER_03Yeah, first off, um they're not included in the same way as the court and the confessor. Um but what precipitated this, it was in our presbytery where there was a case without process that involved a minister and a female, and I think at the presbytery meeting when the committee was recommending that the presbytery approve X as the full statement, either before we voted or after we voted, somebody said, Well, did the personally offended person corroborate the statement?

SPEAKER_03And it was kind of a squishy answer. I think it was after we voted, and then found out later that the person who was personally offended did not and probably would not have corroborated it. So we wanted to add a paragraph that protected the court, protected the confessor, and protected the personally offended person. So there's a little bit of uh wiggle room in this, so that the court has to attempt to inform the offended person of whatever part of the confession the court deems is pertinent, um and invite them to comment on it, but they don't have veto power over the process, they don't have veto power over the statement of facts, but at least this is a requirement that the court needs to seek some kind of a response.

SPEAKER_03Now, there'll be situations, we had one recently where a wife uh declined to comment, and that's her prerogative. Um, and you know, in a married situation, it's probably not unusual that a wife might not comment. Um and we decided it would be smart to try to enlist help for that personally offended person. So in the case I just referenced, uh, we found an elder's wife that worked with her and um informed her of the she got to see the written confession and decided whether to respond or not.

SPEAKER_03So um, you know, I interacted with the person that we appointed or suggested that she counsel with rather than directly with her. Um so yeah, it's just a way to make even more sure that whatever confession the court is signing off on is actually a full enough confession.

SPEAKER_01So yeah, it seems wise that if somebody is looking at 38-1, especially as a way to kind of hit something off at the past, you know, get it out of the way so that you can say we've already dealt with this, it at least takes into consideration that if if that person was, if there's another person that was offended against, that we actually know what they did. I mean, you can think of like somebody saying, Well, I verbally assaulted this person. And then if you actually talk to them, you're like, well, he actually verbally assaulted me and pushed me down, and you're like, okay, we didn't have all the facts, and so uh it'd be nice to know that before we just say, you know, we've accepted his confession and um now we're moving on.

SPEAKER_01Uh well, we have to know if we have all the facts before we move on. So I I was happy when when this came through of like, yeah, this seems like this would be uh at least it should have been wise that you should have done this before, but putting it actually in the book that you need to make some sort of an effort. Um I was glad for that.

SPEAKER_03And the other reason for it is that everything is based on this written confession, this document that's co-signed by the court or the representatives of the court and the confessor, and uh presumably nothing else. Here it is. This is the the these 431 words is what you base the censure on. And that's why I think uh it's really best, at least at a presbytery level, that it be a commission that has full authority to take care of it from beginning to end.

SPEAKER_03Because once you get in front of the presbytery and somebody asks a question or somebody makes a speech, uh it could really poison the whole uh procedure. And we've sustained uh several complaints in 38-1 cases because additional material was added before voting on the censure. Williams versus Chesapeake, Wilburne versus Pacific, Evans versus Arizona. Uh we recently had one, uh I think it was Nashville, where a guy uh signed the confession in a 38-1, and then the Presbytery imposed deposition, and he said, wait, wait, wait, wait, wait, I didn't know you're gonna do that.

SPEAKER_03And he lost his appeal because once you sign the paper, it's kind of out of your hands. So we got a lot of 38-1 cases, which makes me think that I don't know how to write legislation because I don't think everybody was wrong. I think it was the author probably, but I don't know how to fix it.

SPEAKER_01And you sent us like a sample of a document. Is that something that like uh people can send to you for or something we should put on there for because this this is uh helpful, I think, if you're actually trying to create a document, this would be a helpful sample for somebody to work their way through.

SPEAKER_03I was invited to present that at the clerk's conference, President Clerk's conference in December, and I think Per Onquist put that on a website somewhere, he said, I think. But on the clerk's website?

SPEAKER_00I think so. All right.

SPEAKER_01So people can look for uh 38-1 sample uh document on the PCA clerk's uh website, and if you if you're going through this, well if you if you use it and screw it up, I'll have to recuse myself if the case comes up because I'm to blame.

SPEAKER_03All right.

SPEAKER_01That's great.

SPEAKER_03But we also have a I don't know if I included this or not. Pacific Northwest had a shepherding committee, and it wore the black, it wore a white hat and a black hat at the same time, and we divided that up, so we've got a preliminary investigating committee now, a five-man preliminary investigating committee. We're essentially the cops. If the shepherding, if the ministers and churches committee calls you, they're the white hat guys, you can talk to them without jeopardy. If somebody from the PIC calls you, it's the cops, and you better mirandize yourself or consider doing that.

SPEAKER_03Um and usually if there's a 38-1 case, they'll refer it, the moderator and the clerk will refer it to the PIC and and we take it from there.

SPEAKER_01So could have those committees separate in in some ways, yeah.

unknownAll right.

SPEAKER_02Anything else we need to cover on in some regards, like when you're dealing with 30 381s, is it is it somewhat that if you come forward as your own accuser that you'll have a a kinder um experience with the court itself, like you might have a lesser censure or something of that nature. I'm I guess I'm trying to wondering like if I find myself in this situation, is it better to come forward for the sake of my entire life uh or to have it go to trial?

SPEAKER_03Well, if I was somebody's defense counsel, I would say, I mean, it depends on the offense, but I would talk on his behalf with the chairman of the commission and say, listen, he's willing to admit A, B, and C, but um he doesn't think D, he doesn't think he did D. Um if you're gonna insist on him confessing to D, we're gonna have to go to trial.

SPEAKER_03Um, you know, he's willing to confess to A, B, and C. And I I know it sounds like you're politically bargained negotiating and stuff, and that seems odd in a church, but um I hate trials. Um they're just complicated and uh a lot of times they're very disruptive in a presbytery. Um and what we do in our presbytery, or at least what we're about, we're going to do, is the commission um the commission can tell the guy, well, if you confess to A, B, and C, we're gonna we're gonna impose a definite suspension of 12 months.

SPEAKER_03Um they don't have to tell them that, but in the case I referenced out of Nashville, um in a concurring opinion, I wrote that ministers ought to be careful signing these things without knowing what's gonna be recommended or hopefully what's gonna be imposed, because if you're thinking it's it warrants indefinite suspension or definite suspension, uh, and you sign it and they depose you, that's that's your tough luck. So um the other thing about PCA courts is that we don't have sentencing guidelines.

SPEAKER_03A guy, a guy may think that he's confessing to A and that warrants a four-month definite suspension, and the commission or the presbytery could say, well, no, that's we think you should be deposed. So I think a conversation about what's the likely censure would be would behoove the person making the confession. But you know, um we all want our own repentance to be uh pure and motivated by the love uh for Christ, not for consequences, but it's just I don't know.

SPEAKER_03Yeah, I we had sometimes the perfect, to quote Reagan, sometimes the perfect is the enemy of the good.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. Well we had at um our session level we had to deal with a 38-1 at one point, and for us it at least was the evidence that the process of repentance had begun because he's the one that came to us, and and he's saying, I've already done this, I want you guys to know about this. And he basically was like, But dust off your BCOs, we we need to take a look at this. And so we took that as a this is a really good sign, and it it really kind of warmed our heart, and we didn't like to be dealing with it, but um we thought this is actually showing the work of the Holy Spirit on their on their hearts, and so it yeah, it did influence us and how we we dealt with it.

SPEAKER_01So I imagine it would that way, at least at the session level, people that know their flock and and and want to shepherd them well.

SPEAKER_03Yeah, if somebody comes forward and confesses something that no one would have found out about except by that guy's confession, that's beautiful.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, even better than Nathan and then David there. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. So do we want to go on to 38-2?

SPEAKER_02Yeah, 38-2 switches it up just a bit. Uh, when a minister of the gospel against whom there are no charges is fully satisfied in his own conscience that God has not called him to the ministry, or if he has satisfactory evidence of his inability to serve the church with acceptance, may report these facts at a stated meeting of Presbytery. At the next stated meeting, if after full deliberation of the Presbytery shall concur with him in judgment, it may divest him of his office without censure.

SPEAKER_02This provision shall in like manner apply with any necessary changes to the case of ruling elders and deacons, but in all such cases the session of the church to which the ruling elder or deacon who seeks demiss belongs shall act as the presbytery acts, and the similar cases with a minister is concerned. And so perhaps it's helpful if we distinguish between deposition and divestment. What is the distinction?

SPEAKER_03Divestment is an administrative deposition rather than a disciplinary deposition in a sense. Um and there's a wide variety of situations that can fall under 38.2. Um, I think it's reasonable to conjecture that not all men that go into the ministry are gifted and qualified to go into the ministry. So at some point in time, some guys will say, Well, you know, I've I can't keep a job as a minister.

SPEAKER_03Um so I don't I think I should go into another field of work. Um or uh a guy's without call for a lengthy period of time, and um there's another chapter that deals with with that, but um he could say, I guess I don't know, I don't think I'm called to ministry anymore because no one wants to hire me. Um and then he could, you know, he goes through this process with the presbytery which has to have you know a stated meeting and they have full deliberation and they either you know agree with them or they try to talk him out of it or something else.

SPEAKER_03Um but there's also situations where um although I I hope I'm not shoehorning it into this section, but sometimes a minister will do something that makes people question whether he should still be a minister. Yeah, it's not really necessarily case without process or an indictable thing.

SPEAKER_03And he says, well, I'd like to just rather than go through unpacking this or whatever deal, I'd like I think I'd like to divest. And then the Presbytery has the decision of whether, well, does this need to be pursued as 38-1, or does this need to be pursued as formal process, or is this the best of all worlds to just let this guy divest? So sometimes I'd recommend the latter, but um it depends on the facts.

SPEAKER_03But if it was the latter, it would fall under this section here, I think.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, I knew a guy, uh it was in the OPC, but he was uh a pastor for a while, and then just for after a while, it's like, I just don't I think I can keep up with this, uh, wanted to go into a different field, but he still wanted to serve the church, and so he divested, um, but then also uh or was divested, but then he came back as a deacon because he's like, I want to serve the church, it's just I don't think I should be the guy preaching. And so it it was this like okay, there wasn't something scandalous that happened, he just didn't feel like he was called to do this. So it's good that we have a provision for that.

SPEAKER_03I think if you if you divest or uh if you div voluntarily divest or even divested against your will, you have to go through ordination trials to come back. If you're deposed, once the presbytery lifts your deposition, you're back as a minister without call. Um I don't know how that bears on anything, but it is a difference. Once it's divesting is a more significant.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, I think he demitted.

SPEAKER_00Procedurally, yeah.

SPEAKER_02Okay. And demitting is the same thing as divesting.

SPEAKER_03Yeah, dimitting is what the minister does, divest is what the court does.

SPEAKER_02And so we see in 38, too, though, that it's not typically something you do um half-heartedly, that it takes some time to divest. It seems around two meetings, uh, the Presbytery has to be made known of your request, and then at the next state of meeting after that request is received, uh you may act upon it. And so there's at least a a trial period to discern, I think, for the court to discern um whether this is the right way to go or to better understand the facts on why the man's divesting um or seeking to be divested.

SPEAKER_03I mean, they were we lost a good number of ministers during COVID or and you know, some of those guys um you know, were younger ministers and um older guys in the PCA were able to talk to them and say, listen, I don't don't don't question your call because this is just a weird, weird time. Um so yeah, I mean it's there will be guys that might think they need to leave and they really don't need to leave.

SPEAKER_00So yeah, that's called Mondays for pastors.

SPEAKER_03Yeah.

SPEAKER_02Oh my, oh my. Don't resign on a Monday. Okay.

SPEAKER_01Well right.

SPEAKER_02Do I do a moving on to B 383? Uh, we'll do A and B separately. Uh A is when a member or officer of the Presbyterian Church in America shall attempt to withdraw from the communion of this branch of the visible church by affiliating with some other branch, if at the time of the attempt to withdraw he is in good standing, the irregularity shall be recorded, his new membership acknowledged, and his name removed from the role. But if at the time of the attempt to withdraw there is a record of an investigation in process or there are charges concerning the member or minister, the court of original jurisdiction may retain his name on the roll and conduct the case, communicating the outcome upon completion of the proceedings to that member or minister.

SPEAKER_02If the court does not conduct the case, and his new membership shall be acknowledged, his name removed from the rolls, and at the request of the receiving branch, the matter under investigation or the charges shall be communicated to them. And so here we have both uh the process for a church member but also an officer of the church seeking to withdraw its membership and to join another body, another body that is a true branch of the church. And so, what are some qualifiers for things that could perhaps slow a transfer of a church member down?

SPEAKER_03Yeah, I mean, this is kind of the renunciation of jurisdiction paragraph. Um and the SGC has pretty much ruled that if you're not, if there's not a record of a 31-2 investigation, which probably would be demonstrated by a motion adopted in the court's minutes, if that doesn't exist and there are no charges against you, and you send an email to the session or to the session and say, listen, I'm um I'm withdrawing from the PCA.

SPEAKER_03I intend to join uh First Baptist, um you note the irregularity and remove his name from the roles. Um there has been some uh SJC I don't know if it was another Evans versus Arizona, but what does affiliated with some other branch mean? Does he actually have to be received as a member? Um and if I recall correctly, the SJC uh ruled that we didn't need to need uh definitive evidence that he had joined the other church, uh, because sometimes there are branches that don't provide that as a document or whatever.

SPEAKER_03Uh so basically he just says I'm withdrawing from the PCI. Um unless there's uh investigation or charges, and then if the court wants to, they could conduct a trial in absentia. Um I can't recall whatever happening, but it's possible.

SPEAKER_02Perhaps a question concerning like some prudence with how we might deal with those asking to be withdrawn, drawn from our membership. Uh, is that when perhaps someone comes under investigation, they often flee. Uh I'm thinking more of the church member than the pastor. Um should is it wise for the church to continue pursuit of that? And perhaps when they just ask to be removed and leave me alone, don't talk to me ever again, when should the court just stop?

SPEAKER_02Um uh to avoid perhaps even legal jeopardy and the civil court, but where's some wisdom for dealing with someone who is seeking to flee discipline, who's a church member, and they say, please just leave me alone. If you don't leave me alone, I'm going to sue you.

SPEAKER_03Yeah, I think there's a um another provision in the book where someone that wants to do that, um, that you counsel them that they uh really should transfer to another branch. But if they uh and then in the end you can say, well, this is a removing your name from the roles is an act of pastoral discipline that you've brought upon yourself. I don't remember which section that is, but um but I've been around long enough to know that at some point they're just not gonna answer your emails anymore or talk to you on the phone or whatever, and you know, there's not much you can do.

SPEAKER_03But I mean they're accountable to the Lord if if they're if the session said um we think this is bad for your soul and this is wrong, and I mean he's gonna be accountable for that advice that he disregarded.

SPEAKER_01But um, yeah, th this section almost seems to also prevent like a um uh a a bitter session. You know, somebody withdraws and then they were like, Well, we're gonna do a trial against you. No, just like if somebody is moving, uh, if you haven't started that investigation, you haven't started that process, you they just need to be allowed to go and have some of the their rights as a member.

SPEAKER_03Yeah, essentially because that process hasn't started yet, technically the person isn't fleeing process because it hasn't begun. Um there is an important provision at the end there is if they're under if they're under an indictment, for example, and the session decides, well, we're not gonna conduct a trial at absentia, um they shouldn't send they need to be careful what they send to the receiving church. Um and it says at the request of the receiving branch, which I understand that to mean that it would it would be okay.

SPEAKER_03Unless the sending session or the original session informed them of that. So I think it makes sense to read this as understanding the session could say, well, uh, we can't transfer them in good standing because there was an investigation in progress, um, details of which we can supply upon your request. That way they're kind of insulated legally, maybe I don't know, I'm not an attorney, but um yeah.

SPEAKER_02And then BCO 383B is uh basically a similar provision going with those outside of the visible church. Uh when a member or minister of the Presbyterian Church in America shall attempt to withdraw from the communion of this branch of the visible church by affiliating with a body judged by the court of original jurisdiction as failing to maintain the word and sacrament in their fundamental integrity, that member or minister shall be warned of this danger, and if he persists, he sh his name shall be erased from the role, thereby, so far as the Presbyterian Church in America is concerned, he is deemed no longer to be a member of in anybody which rightly maintains the word and sacrament in their fundamental integrity, and if an officer whereby withdrawing from him all authority to exercise his office as derived from this church, when so acting, the court shall make a full record of the matter and shall notify the offender of its action.

SPEAKER_02And so this is not withdrawing to another branch of the visible church, but uh a branch of the church that the PCA doesn't recognize as a true branch of the church.

SPEAKER_03Yeah, so the way this usually plays out in the presbytery is uh Minister John Doe announces he's going to the RPCNA. Um so 38-3 kicks in, and then at the Presbytery meeting, someone could make a motion regarding 383B. Uh unless someone makes 38-3 boat 38-3B motion, it's kind of a done deal.

SPEAKER_03But um, you know, someone could say, well, I don't think the RPCNA, I think the RPCNA is a branch that paragraph B is talking about, therefore I think paragraph B should apply, and then there's debate in the presbytery as to whether or not that denomination is um fits into B or not. That could be, I mean, we probably have different lists of what denominations fit into B.

SPEAKER_01I would think that would be a hard case on appeal that uh if they're a Napark church, yeah, we're probably like, yeah, no, I I think they're we we we generally recognize them. Although I I could see this as more clear-cut, it's Roman Catholic Church or it's Jehovah's Witness or something like that.

SPEAKER_00Aaron Powell Well, yeah, Jason Jason Stellman left Pacific Northwest and went to the Catholic Church.

SPEAKER_03That was pretty pretty easy to do B there.

SPEAKER_01Trevor Burrus, Jr. So for others, is it basically just the discretion of the court, like uh PC USA or something like that, of uh when something like that comes up, is that appealable or is that just like hey, whatever the Presbyterian complaints.

SPEAKER_03I'm surprised we haven't got one yet. But um some would say, you know, I think the uh uh uh well just AC that someone says I think the ACNA is uh category B. Presbytery didn't judge it that way. I file a complaint and goes to the SJC, and I hope we never get that case, but um I mean it's possible.

SPEAKER_02Yeah. Moving on to 38 uh 4. Uh when a member of a particular church has willfully neglected the church for a period of one year or has made it known that he has no intention of fulfilling the church vows, then the session continuing to exercise pastoral discipline in the spirit of Galatians 6 1 shall remind the member, if possible both in person and in writing, of the declarations and promises by which he entered into a solemn covenant with God and his church, and warrant him that if he persists, his name shall be erased from the roles.

SPEAKER_02If after diligently pursuing such pastoral discipline and after further inquiry and due delay, the session is of the judgment that the member will not fulfill his membership obligations in this or any other branch of the visible church, then the session shall erase his name from the role. This erasure is an act of pastoral discipline without process. The session shall notify the person, if possible, whose name has been removed. Notwithstanding the above, if a member thus warned makes a written request for process, the session shall grant such a request.

SPEAKER_02Further, if the session determines that any such offense, any of such uh a member is of the nature of process is necessary, then the session may institute such process.

SPEAKER_03Yeah, so 38-3A involves a member going to a uh a good denomination, 38-3B going to a bad denomination, 38-4 going nowhere. And um, you know, this is probably, I'm guessing every session has probably had this. Um so willfully neglected the church for a period of one year is um kind of a subjective wording. Usually, you know, sessions say, Well, I've we haven't nobody's seen these this family for a year.

SPEAKER_03Um sometimes they'll send an email to the session saying, uh, remove me from the rolls, I have no intention of fulfilling the membership vows. And the session says, Well, where are you going? Well, we're not going anywhere, we just want to be off the rolls, and then you complete the process of 38-4 there. Um we used to have in one of the churches I was in, what we call it the Fisher Cut Bait Letter, uh, for people we haven't seen in a while, and we tried to make contact, but you know, uh we just they just weren't really that interested anymore.

SPEAKER_03Um and then we put in a letter essentially the essence of 38-4. Um, but we just called it the Fisher Cut Bait letter.

SPEAKER_01Um I think every clerk needs to have you know that first letter of, hey, we haven't seen you in a while, we love you, you need to come back, and then has to have that letter of like, hey, you really like you're in danger here. Uh so both of those as sample letters there.

SPEAKER_03Yeah, for sure.

SPEAKER_01I I wonder with there's that language of pastoral discipline. This is an act of pastoral discipline. Uh I've sometimes heard this referred to as uh almost like soft excommunication. How how does the session understand what they're doing in 384? Is this soft excommunication? Is this what is this? Yeah.

SPEAKER_03Yeah, what we would say to them is that when you look at the membership vows in 57, um, the word church is capitalized. In the book, Book of Church Order, the only time that the word church is capitalized is when it's referring to the PCA or the universal church. So when you're taking those vows, you're promising to support the church, capital C. And 384 talks about someone who isn't going to go to any church.

SPEAKER_03So the pastoral discipline is I mean, you took a vow to be a supportive member of Christ's church, and you're not even going to another church. So it is kind of a it's a self-excommunication. I mean, you could you could even put that in in the letter. It's you're removing yourself from the covenant family without apparently understanding the the weight of that, whatever. And they may write back and say, well, no, no, no, no.

SPEAKER_03We we I mean we're we're still looking and we we don't want to, and then you could say, well, all right, we'll keep you on the rolls until you find another church, or I mean the session can handle that however they want, depending on the on the people, but um to say, I mean, it's essentially renouncing your covenant with the church, Capital C church.

SPEAKER_01So Yeah. I I think it's helpful in um Morton Smith's commentary. He has a an outline of the steps required. And I think it's helpful. He has one, the the personal visit, you know, you're you're trying to go after them. Number two, warning them in writing, uh, perhaps both personally and in writing, and then it has some due time for further inquiry. So I think it's helpful for for sessions to know you don't send the letter and then your next motion is to erase them from the roles. You have to give them some time to respond uh before you get to the fourth step, which is then you have a removal from the roles.

SPEAKER_03Yeah, because time is really not of the essence. It's not something that has to be done today. Um it may be that they uh they say, well, you know, we don't really like Elder Donaho up front on Sunday morning. And then the sessions got away, oh, you know, maybe we should ask him not to be up front on Sunday morning. Ever again. Or something. I mean, there was a reason they joined in the first place, and now they wanna they wanna leave, and you um a lot of times they won't tell you why.

SPEAKER_03Yeah.

SPEAKER_02Uh half the time it's they're getting ready to get divorced, and they don't think that staying a member is a good idea or whatever, but what's interesting in this section is that the member still has rights when the session seeks to remove them from the roles without process. Um, and so the member at the end there says, notwithstanding the above, a member thus warned making a request for process can have his process. And and so, what are some examples perhaps of that process?

SPEAKER_02What would that look like? Trying to prove they were there in the last year or what that's a great question.

SPEAKER_03Um because it doesn't define the process. Uh we had a case recently where the SJC ruled that if you want to increase a minister's censure from indefinite suspension to excommunication, you have to have some kind of process. You just can't do that by a motion. But the SJC didn't define what the process is. I think uh I think Jim Eggert in Florida is crafting an overture to define that process a little bit.

SPEAKER_03But um in this case, I guess it would be, yeah, they would say, well, here's why we haven't been there over the last year. Um uh what led you to believe we had no intention of fulfilling our church vows, we're still giving, or you know, I don't know. It process just means you've got to have a discussion about it, I guess. But certainly, um, I don't think it would be uh like a trial process because someone who's exhibit a rain dough hasn't seen you in 12 months.

SPEAKER_02So we're gonna ask for process.

SPEAKER_03Yeah.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. Well, looking at all this, I don't if we don't have more questions on section four there, um, this this actually might be a section that is referred to a lot by sessions. Um, probably you're gonna deal with more cases without process than you are for them, especially with somebody that's not been there for a year. What would you want to tell sessions that are opening this section of the book and they're trying to do this right? Anything pastorally you want to say to them or process that they need to remember just looking at this whole chapter?

SPEAKER_03Well, certainly on the having been there for a year, um, hopefully there's contact during that year. Because all of a sudden now uh uh Jane and Bill Smith get a letter saying we haven't seen you in a year, and they write back and say, Well, you haven't called us in a year either, you know. So that one year thing is just I don't know, somebody wrote that and said, Well, we gotta put some kind of a number on it. Um but yeah, pastoral care, you you're gonna know well before a year.

SPEAKER_03That this this couple and this family is not really that interested anymore. And uh, you know, we we oftentimes help people find churches they're more comfortable with um in our area out here in Boise. And we used to do that in Pittsburgh too. And um let me think, what else? Um the 38-1 thing, um if I was to write another, I'm not going to.

SPEAKER_03If I was to write another change to that, I would say uh courts are strongly encouraged to, although nobody likes strong. Courts are encouraged to use commissions to do 38-1s, because we had a we had a 38-1 in our presbytery not too long ago, where the uh the investigating committee was a commission to decide whether the confession was complete or not.

SPEAKER_03We judged it as being complete and sufficient for, and we recommended a censure of indefinite suspension, but the censure was debatable. We didn't think to say we recommend it be non-debatable, you know, two-third vote to limit debate kind of thing. And during the debate, uh things were raised that probably were additional to the confession, and uh it's just hard to stay on the written document as the entirety of what we're basing this uh censure on.

SPEAKER_03If you allow QA or you know, I think it should be this censure because so I think it's really it's really tailor-made for commissions rather than the whole body. So and you put your put the people on the commission that you think are the best for the job, you know. Create an ad hoc commission if you need to, but um taking it to the floor, it's uh you're just asking for trouble. And I've moderated 38.1 things, and as a as a moderator, I'm up front and I said, no, no, no, no, no, no, we can't go there.

SPEAKER_03No, no, no, we can't go there. And it's just it's just not worth it. Just let the commission decide it.

SPEAKER_01Well, is there anything else that you wanted to uh to plug or things that are coming up? I think this will come out just before uh General Assembly. So um just for people to come up and say hi to you if they see you at General Assembly.

SPEAKER_03Uh yeah, but they have to provide me a Tootsie Roll pop. That's a requirement.

SPEAKER_02You'll know who listened to this by the Tootsie Roll. Yes. Zero Tootsie Roll.

unknownYeah.

SPEAKER_03No, I think um there aren't any chapter well, there's no 38-1 stuff coming up this year, or uh so no worry about that.

unknownYeah.

SPEAKER_03Not yet, anyway. That I know of.

SPEAKER_02You got a few days, don't you, like tomorrow?

SPEAKER_03Although Pacific Northwest probably sent in a historically long overture this year.

SPEAKER_00Yes, it did. 20 pages. So yeah.

SPEAKER_02Yeah. You you're you're a wild man for making us keep those warehouses.

SPEAKER_03Oh no, no, no.

SPEAKER_02I uh I rebelled against warehouses years ago. I know, but you uh you said you had to keep all of the rationale. Oh yeah, yeah. He says it's a 20-page overture and he forces us to keep the rationale on that.

SPEAKER_01So the handbook is longer this year, thanks to Howie. Yeah.

SPEAKER_03I know Dr. Chapel wasn't thrilled with that.

SPEAKER_01All right. Well, I think at the end, uh uh Ben is gonna insert uh introduction uh so they know who we're talking to. Uh I don't think we properly introduced you, but uh Ben will put that at the beginning and then he'll give us some sort of uh an outro too, but Ben can't talk right now, so uh we'll just go ahead and and finish up here and uh just uh thank you for uh giving us some of your time, especially with 38. This is this is great. Um I think it'll be helpful for people um to to try to figure out how to how to apply this.

SPEAKER_01And I especially liked your your categorization of uh uh there's a section for going to a good church, a bad church, and nowhere. So that's that's now my headings in my video over those sections. Yes.

SPEAKER_03Thank you very much, Halley, for your and you can feel free to do anything you want with those 38.1 things I sent you.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. Um well, yeah, people can look those up in the uh uh the corks page and yeah, if it's there. Yeah. All right. Well, um, I think it's going to, when Ben hits stop on recording, it's gonna upload your audio track and then uh just make sure we have that before you fully sign off. Anything else we need to do, Ben? Do you have any final uh words to Okay.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Hosts

  • Ben Ratliff Co-host Feed-stated
  • Jared Nelson Co-host Feed-stated
  • Scott Edburg Co-host Feed-stated

Guests

  • Howie Donahoe Guest Feed-stated

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. 150. You've Got to Come Visit

    Nov 17, 202642 minAudio

    Ben, Jared, and Scott are joined by Brad Voyles, president of Covenant College, as the RAO series continues through the agencies and committees of the General Assembly. Brad shares how he went from Bellhaven and RTS...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. 149. Two Keys on the Nuclear Submarine

    Nov 10, 202642 minAudio

    Jared and Scott are joined by Andrew Rein, coordinator of Reformed University Fellowship (RUF), as the RAO series continues through the agencies and committees of the General Assembly. Andrew shares how he came to RUF...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. 148. From Birthing Babies to Geriatric Care

    Nov 3, 202634 minAudio

    Ben, Jared, and Scott are joined by Steve Dowling, interim coordinator of Mission to North America (MNA), as the RAO series continues through the committees and agencies of the General Assembly. Steve marks one year in...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. 147. ProtoPresbytery

    Oct 27, 202643 minAudio

    Ben and Jared are joined by Lloyd Kim, coordinator of Mission to the World (MTW), as the RAO series continues through the committees and agencies of the General Assembly. Lloyd shares his path from Southern California...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. 146. Broker of Relationships and Resources

    Oct 20, 202643 minAudio

    Ben, Jared, and Scott are joined by Stephen Estock, coordinator of the PCA's Committee on Discipleship Ministries (CDM), as the RAO series continues through the permanent committees and agencies. Stephen shares his path...

    Credit the people on this episode