The guys spend time hearing about the PCA's long lost sister, the OPC. With guest Andrew Miller. Glorifying and Enjoying God: 52 Devotions through the Westminster Shorter Catechism (Boekestein, Cruse, Miller) Send us Fan Mail Support the show Official Website: politymatters.org Support the Show: Buy Me a Coffee Twitter/X: @PolityMatters Facebook: Polity Matters Page Scott's Twitter Jared's Twitter Ben's Twitter
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_02Hello and welcome to Polity Matters. My name is Ben Ratliff, and today I am joined by Jared Nelson and Scott Edberg, and we are glad to be back together again. It feels like Scott's been in and out of town as we've been recording. We are, as if you've been paying attention in the middle of a series that we're doing over the summer. We don't I don't know if we have a name for it, guys, do we? Where we're just talking to other Presbyterians about how they're Presbyterian.
SPEAKER_02Uh and uh after we stop recording, we compare uh and and see who's the real Presbyterian, but we're not giving out those conversations. Um we are glad to have with us today from the Orthodox Presbyterian Church uh Reverend Andrew Miller uh joining us to discuss with us the OPC GA and give us some insight into their denomination and what's going on there. And I'll just say before I ask Andrew to introduce himself, uh, we've we've done this now with uh gentlemen from the ARP and from the EPC. Uh this has been extremely encouraging to me.
SPEAKER_02I was just telling Jared earlier, just talking with the the teaching elder from the EPC was a great encouragement. I sometimes forget about the EPC, which is a whole other conversation, I suppose. But um it was good to be reminded of what's going on there and they need our prayers, and and it's good to, as Andrew was talking about before we hit record, this uh coming together as brothers, even though we're in separate denominations, is is a good thing to do and it honors the Lord. And so we're glad to have these conversations. Andrew, uh, I'm talking too much already. Why don't you talk a little bit, introduce yourself to us, tell us who you are, where you're from, how you got to where you are, about your family, uh you know, all those different things that people want to know.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, thanks for having me on. Um, it's a long story in some ways, a short story in other ways. I mean, I my wife and I actually grew up in the PCA, so we're uh we're pretty friendly with all you guys um and um have a lot of friends in the PCA, so um appreciate the relationship we have. But uh I um grew up in the PCA and then um went off to to college at Grove City College, went uh from there to seminary in California, Westminster in California, and then I was um ordained uh as a pastor in 2014 in Fredericksburg, Virginia, um in the OPC there, uh Bethel Reformed Presbyterian Church.
SPEAKER_01So I pastored there for um about a decade um because I was a I was a year-long intern there first and then a pulpit supply. So all told, we spent about 12 years in Fredericksburg, and then just last year uh took a new call to be a regional home missionary up here in central Pennsylvania. And uh so we moved the family up to Chambersburg, Pennsylvania, and we've been here about eight, seven, eight months uh on the job. It's a new role. Um, if you don't know what a regional home missionary is, but it's a uh servant of the presbytery.
SPEAKER_01So I I um am kind of uh hired by the partnership of the OPC denomination. They paid for part of my uh salary, and then the presbytery pays for uh most of it. And I help them plant churches, and so sometimes that means being the pre-church planner, church planner, kind of being there and getting a group together and helping them get going and doing Bible studies and then helping them call a church planner and then overseeing it on the session and all that.
SPEAKER_01Um it can it can really look different depending on what season. So um that's the new role. Our website is uh goodnewscentralpa.org if anybody's interested. And um you can find me on Twitter, uh Andrew Miller OPC. Uh you guys got to know me through Jonathan Cruz. He and I recently authored a book um glorifying and enjoying God, 52 Devotions through the Westminster Shorter Catechism. So that's been nice.
SPEAKER_01You got it there. Uh that's been pretty exciting for me to have that out. Um, and as it comes to General Assembly, uh, I think this was my seventh G GA that I've been to out of a nine possible ones. We ended up having kids the years that I couldn't come, and I didn't pull myself away from GA for that. Um I'm on the um OPC's Appeals and Complaints Committee for the General Assembly. So we don't have an SJC like you guys do, um, but we have an appeals and complaints committee, and uh we try to tee up all of the appeals and complaints for the assembly and save them time and and summarize.
SPEAKER_00So anyway, that's that's the box, right? There's a box that says complaints or constructive compliments, and people put that in the book. We are the box, yes.
SPEAKER_02So people put gum in it from time to time.
SPEAKER_01Um I've send people that Jeff uh from from uh the office. Sorry.
SPEAKER_02We no, no, you're good. You you were leaning into it a little bit there. Uh the one of the first things we want to ask you is about um, you know, in the world of Presbyterian churches and denominations, what sets the OPC apart? And and maybe maybe the big ones that we would have on our minds are sort of uh doctrinal standards and and polity and the particular ways those are worked out, and then maybe anything else that comes to your mind of since you have familiarity with the PCA and the OPC, you might you you probably have a great uh understanding of the differences between the two of us.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, well, I love I love both. I mean, I tell people if you're choosing between the PCA and the OPC, then you're already winning, right? I mean, um that's a great choice to to be in a position to make. And um, you know, some people call the OPC the uh the quote only perfect church or the frozen chosen. You guys maybe heard that in the PCA too, but uh I like to point out that the OPC was the PCA before it was cool, uh, in that our name was the Presbyterian Church of America, and then we got sued by the PC USA and had to change it um back way back a hundred years ago.
SPEAKER_01So um, but no, uh to be serious, uh they're both great and we have the same standards. There's a lot of um fellowship between the OPC and the PCA. We're a lot smaller than you guys, about a tenth of your size. I mean, we have about 340 churches, 35,000 members, and I think you guys have around 300,000 members. Um, I don't know, you guys would know better than me, but we're a lot smaller, um, a lot less, you know, I I I think of it in terms of just because of your size, you you have a much broader range of um church practice and church life, you know, in terms of you've got churches with the praise band up there and all that kind of stuff, and then others that are uh much more traditional.
SPEAKER_01And in the OPC you have some variation, but there's a lot less variation, a lot more um, a lot smaller tent in some ways uh than than the PCA in in my experience. And our GAs are very different. Um, so we'll we'll talk about that in a few minutes as well.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, what is what is the main difference between so when the PCA gets together, we we just had our GA and had um, I don't even know what the final count was. It was near 2,000 commissioners or something like that.
SPEAKER_02We hit 2100.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. And so beforehand, we have to do everything by committee because you can't do it, have a deliberative body of 2,000 people, uh, but you can of you know 100 or so. And um, so it's it's a big uh ordeal, although it's quick. We got ours done in a few days. Um, it seemed like yours is quite uh of a different experience in the OPC. How is yours? How do you organize your GA differently than the PCA does? Yeah, it's it's uh it's intense.
SPEAKER_01So we meet for about a week. We start on a Wednesday night, and then we go until Tuesday at lunchtime the next week. Uh this time we extended it um way ahead of time and went until Tuesday night. And so we're we're you know doing five, six days of work. We take Sundays off, of course, but it it's very different in terms of size. So the OPCGA is 150 people total, uh, plus about 20 people, 30 people, depending on the year, who are committee representatives who don't have a vote.
SPEAKER_01So this year, actually, I didn't have a vote, I was a committee representative, and so I got to go. Um, but it's a delegated assembly, meaning that it's not just that you can choose to go to the General Assembly if you're an officer, your presbytery has to pick you and select you. And um, and so you're a called a commissioner. So, you know, in a sense, the presbytery's commissioned you to go and um you know vote your conscience at this higher level. So um we don't really have any commissions that do the work.
SPEAKER_01We do all the work on the floor. We heard, you know, 10, 11 um appeals and complaints, and we we have some mechanisms to save time. So, you know, the very first thing we do is we pick a moderator, we decide on the docket. Uh that's Wednesday night. We have a worship service, and then we get into that.
SPEAKER_00And and who was your moderator this year?
SPEAKER_01It was JV Fesco, so he did a great job. Oh, I've heard of him. Um yeah, yeah, so he was a good pick. Um and um, and then the next day, Tuesday, or sorry, Thursday morning, you go straight into advisory committees. And so this is where all the business gets divided up among the commissioners, and each of these advisory committees reviews the work of all the standing committees and anything that's gonna come before the body. Like you can't just bring new um new motions before the floor of the assembly, it has to be related to the other business, and it usually has to go through an advisory committee, which is just another set of eyes, and they're they're getting all the information.
SPEAKER_01So for an appeal and complaint, for example, um uh the uh a whole assembly, they get a docket ahead of time and they can review these things, and it's got the appeal and the complaint or whatever, uh, and it's got a basic background, but there's always so many documents that you get uh for any appeal or complaint, and only the advisory committee gets all of that information. And then they can, of course, say, Oh, the assembly really needs this document. Um, they need to see this, you know, this witness testimony or whatever it might be.
SPEAKER_01So the advisory committee um kind of helps cut down on time and save the assembly time, but all the decisions uh they come before the assembly, and it's it's the assembly doing everything.
SPEAKER_00So, what were some of your big ticket items uh this year at uh the OPC's General Assembly? What were some of the things that took up some of your time or that people were doing some prep work to get ready to deal with there?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, um, and we have a an um annual report that's on the website there. If you go to the opc.org and click on general assembly, you can read it. But there's all kinds of things that we do at a general assembly, so we always hear fraternal greetings. Um that's like normal. And I think this year we actually overdid it. We had something like something like 12, and you know, they each talk for about 10-15 minutes. Um sometimes they're really uh really good, sometimes they're um a bit nervous, and um but it's always it's a nice thing that we get to hear.
SPEAKER_01Um we had a guy from PCA came. He came, I forget his name, but he was from Seattle, uh, and he talked about the weather in Seattle and and said it actually doesn't rain there as much as you would think. Um, because we were in Seattle this year. Um we always meet on a college campus as well. So we're uh you know the OPC pays for it, they fly you out there, they put you up in these dorms, and we we eat together, all that.
SPEAKER_00Um how much does it cost an average uh delegate to go to the OPC uh GA?
SPEAKER_02Well, you're talking out of pocket expense, aren't you?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, well, you want to make it really bad.
SPEAKER_02Oh boy.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I mean, what do you think? Do you have any guesses?
SPEAKER_00Oh, I just you know, if it's anything like the PCA, you know$1,000, is that right?
SPEAKER_04I'd guess like$200 for those guys. They know how to stretch a penny.
SPEAKER_01We do. Um, so uh they capped uh travel for next year at$1,000 a person. Um so you know that covers your flight and your baggage and your parking and um you know food at the airport and that kind of stuff. And uh and then once you're there, you know, you're eating you're eating in the cafeteria at the at the car. So they don't cover you know all the guys going out for beers afterwards, uh, which is really the best part sometimes.
SPEAKER_01But um yeah, so it's it's very cheap compared to you guys, uh at least for the um, you know, out of pocket for the commissioners. Um so you know, going back to the business, you we have devotions every day, we we sing together. That's always the highlight. Uh hearing all these guys singing together. I'm sure that's a highlight for you guys too. And um we hear reports from all of our committees, so home missions, foreign missions, diagonal committee, um, all these kinds of things.
SPEAKER_01And um yeah, we had a lot of big business this year in some senses. Um I don't know if you guys listened to the Reform Forum podcast about this year's GA, but one of the things that turned out to not be very um controversial in one sense, in that we we didn't really get into any debates, was that the home the uh Christian Education Committee had suggested changes to our ministerial recommended uh curriculum.
SPEAKER_01And one of the things that the guys on Reform Forum pushed back on was that they got rid of the the name Van Till from the apologetics uh criteria. And uh I they they also thought that they watered down the biblical theology aspect of it. Um and I say that it didn't end up being very controversial in that we simply uh it came up and we said go back and keep thinking about this and bring us back something um a little bit more thought out.
SPEAKER_01So uh yeah, that was one of the items, but I can keep going. Uh any any questions?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, with that committee, did they is that also the one that was looking at a a modernized version of the Westminster standards? Uh did you guys ever figure out what you're gonna do about that? Yeah, good question.
SPEAKER_01So we didn't deal with that this year, but we dealt with that last year. Um, and you know, in good Presbyterian fashion, we kicked the can down the road another seven years. Um so uh we don't do anything quickly, we're kind of like the ends of the Presbyterian world, right? Uh the ends, you know, at the OPC, we're so conservative that we we we're gonna take seven years just to think about changing our standards some more.
SPEAKER_01Um so yeah, it for what it is, what it is. Um and I yeah, I don't know if you guys have any thoughts. Should we update our language? Because some guys were saying, well, you know, this will affect our fraternal relationships if we have a modern version and all of our Napark brothers have uh an archaic version, and uh, but it seems to me like the OPC just likes to set the trends, so you guys would soon follow, right?
SPEAKER_03That's what I think. I don't think we would care much. No, we would just use it as needed.
SPEAKER_00Well, we should do it. The the addition that you guys put out of this the confession is one that I give to new members, uh, because I think it's helpful for new members to be able to read it in a little bit more updated language. Nice.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I like to say we're a small church, but we we have an oversized impact on the reformed world. Um, maybe that's self-aggrandizing, but maybe it's self-consolation.
SPEAKER_02I think as long as you guys go to GA for free, you can say whatever you want in front of us. Yeah, I think we're uh you guys seem to have a lot of uh social things around food since you eat together the cafeteria. I'm I'm particularly interested in anything related to ice cream. Do you guys gather around frozen desserts at any point during your week together?
SPEAKER_01Or is there a trick question for this? Any any finger good.
SPEAKER_02Any socializing around ice cream treats?
SPEAKER_04Uh if no, Ben is obsessed. He's obsessed with ice cream at General Assemblies, not just our own, but others. I want to know, I want to know where they are.
SPEAKER_01I mean, I I remember when we have it at Dort College, um there's usually always a day where this three o'clock snack is ice cream.
SPEAKER_02That's it.
SPEAKER_01Uh so it's you know, you're you're definitely not talking out of school.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. I just I'm trying to set a precedent um so that the PCA has no way to wiggle out. Everybody does it, is is gonna be my argument when the time comes.
SPEAKER_01So I'll say this that sometimes the best fellowship is is after the assembly in the evening. Um some of these campuses are very gracious and they have a fire pit that they let us gather around. So this year it was not like that, but um the previous year and and a few previous years, they've had kind of a president's um house that has a fire pit, and they just say, okay, go ahead and use the fire pit in the evening so people bring beverages and um cigars and pipes and things, and just kind of hang out and um fellowship around the fire um in the evening.
SPEAKER_01So that's always a highlight.
SPEAKER_00I I think that's one of the most difficult things about having an assembly of over 2,000 reps, is there are people that went to GA that I know that I didn't even see this year, you know. And it's I I think and that's the one thing that you guys have with having uh just over 100 people that you can actually get together and uh and have fellowship and see everybody that was there. That's nice. Yeah, thanks.
SPEAKER_01You want me to keep going through uh some of the major things we did? So um we had, like I said, 10 appeals and complaints, and some of them were pretty interesting, and some of them not so much. Um but the first one was surprising, the appeal that we had. Uh we reversed the discipline of somebody who is detained by civil authorities and he was unable to speak in his defense because he's behind bars.
SPEAKER_01And uh, you know, there's there's more to it than that, but um, I was I was kind of surprised that the assembly um voted to send that one back to the session uh for a redo. Um, but that was interesting. You know, I guess guys really want to defend due process and the ability to speak in your own defense, um, and felt like that session maybe had had rushed things until that person's um legal trial, uh criminal trial panned out.
SPEAKER_01Um you know, the session seemed like they they acted because they wanted to um nip any kind of scandal in the bud. They had somebody arrested and they wanted to um you know do church discipline. So that was interesting. Uh we had four complaints from one church, and um the first complaint from from that church um against their presbytery uh was about uh how presbyteries can inquire into kind of evil reports of something happening at a local church.
SPEAKER_01And um the uh session thought that the visitation committee of the presbytery had been too negative in their report back to presbytery, and um the assembly didn't seem convinced by that. And um another related issue to that was whether or not a presbytery or session could ask for help in investigating problems. Um, so you know, say you have alleged problems at a at a session or a presbytery, you know, what what's okay in terms of getting help and what what do you need to do yourself?
SPEAKER_01Um and you know, how how can you consult with others? You know, it's one thing to do that with getting accounting help. And then what about when getting help involves kind of spiritual care? Like, would it be okay to um bring in a consultant from CCEF or something? And uh the assembly narrowly um narrowly denied the complaint um about getting any help at all. And uh and that was an interesting one, and it and it it made me think about uh just how there seems to be still an influence of Jay Adams and his you know competent at counsel approach.
SPEAKER_01He seems to have some followers in the OPC, but not not a majority, at least in this case. Um in other words, even though you might be, quote, competent to counsel, it it does make sense sometimes to get other helpers uh involved. So I don't know if you guys have any thoughts on on those. I can keep going.
SPEAKER_00We just dealt with uh an overture to change our BCO to allow people to get help with counsel uh from the presbytery. Um and that was approved. So we'll see if that makes its way through the presbyteries. But that's been a question both from getting help from other pastors as well as there was one that failed that was to get help outside of the denomination, have some third party come in to investigate and to encourage uh churches to do that. And basically our response was, well, you can do that, but we're not gonna encourage or discourage it.
SPEAKER_00Um we can just leave that up to you.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, that's good. And that's kind of where we ended up with this one, but it wasn't it was pretty narrow, um, you know, like two-thirds to a third or something like that. It um maybe closer than that. We had a lot of close votes this year, um, which was somewhat unusual.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, it's harder to identify if in the OPC there's certain camps. I mean, we might have narrow versus broad in terms of the PCA or contemporary versus more traditional, but in the OPC it almost seems more apologetic approaches and things like that. So it's hard to tell like who are the camps. When I talk to people in the OPC, I can't be like, okay, you're on this camp or whatever, unless they they talk to me a lot about Van Till or uh our fesco's apologetics stuff.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, it's an interesting question for me to think about. I mean, there's definitely camps, and there's definitely um ways of reading the assembly, right? If you've been there for a few years, you can kind of tell from where the speeches are going, how people are gonna vote. Um, some years it's easier, some years it's it's harder. Um, and there are definitely camps, but I mean they're different than in other denominations. I mean, everybody agrees on means of grace and um some of this stuff, uh, but it's more on the detailed things, kind of like this, right?
SPEAKER_01The J. Adams counseling approach, you know, how what is a pastor in their depth to be? There's probably uh some camps in terms of like um complementarianism, and some that would be more comfortable talking patriarchy, and others who would say, let's not talk that way at all. Um so um, yeah, there's and then even, you know, I was thinking about this with you guys, uh, just with this podcast coming up, that I think the majority of the OPC is probably on millennial.
SPEAKER_01And you know, our our whole thing as the OPC has been we we know we're not gonna influence culture and we're okay with that. Um, you know, we're happy to just um preach the gospel and make disciples and be faithful. And um, but I wonder if that's also one little camp within the OPC is is those that would be more interested in cultural influence. Um but yeah, it it is hard to say exactly what the camps how they're defined.
SPEAKER_01Um yeah, I don't know if you have any thoughts on that. Um well I can keep going. Um we did so we had four complaints from that same session, and we we did uphold one of them, which was that the presbytery did hire an outside uh third party to investigate some alleged trauma and things like that, and the third party used some um principles that the commissioners, the majority of commissioners, found questionable, suspect.
SPEAKER_01Um and so they sustained that complaint. And then there was uh another complaint from that session that was related to the two-year statute of limitations. I'd call it that, but um it's not really a statute of limitations, but you know, it's how when you bring a charge, can you bring a charge about something that happened a long time ago? Can you have witnesses that are relating things from eight years ago, that kind of thing? And um in this particular case, uh the General Assembly said, okay, we're we're not gonna sustain this complaint that if this person has objections to the evidence and the witnesses and the charges about two year beyond two years, they can always bring up those on an appeal if they're convicted in a case.
SPEAKER_01So um we didn't wanna it seemed like the assembly didn't want to short circuit a trial um by an by a complaint, if that makes sense, which I think is an interesting thing. I think you guys just dealt with something like can you bring complaints after you've had charges filed against you? Um, because it does seem to me like it's an area that we need to think about in the OPC, because you can really just throw up all kinds of roadblocks uh to proper oversight um by making complaints when you're under charges.
SPEAKER_01I don't know. Did you guys just deal with something like that?
SPEAKER_04Yeah, we had an interlocutory appeal, I think that's how you pronounce it uh process, where in the midst of um doing process, you basically set aside any uh complaints against that process until after the process itself is completed. We had an issue um in central Indiana where uh there were just constant complaints whenever the Presbytery did something, there was a complaint. And it just the timeline for the actual process went years longer than it needed to because of frivolous um at times complaints.
SPEAKER_04And so I think the issue that the assembly was dealing with at last GA was, well, let's set those aside. You can make the complaints now, we will deal with them after, and we'll deal with them appropriately. But you can really gum up process by extending the length of process. And if you if you see the writing on the wall, you might just needlessly do that just to extend your time. And so I think it's it was a wise thing that the assembly pushed through. It wasn't controversial. I thought it might be, but it didn't it didn't really have any pushback.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I'm not saying that's what's happening in this case, but um but it definitely seems like something we should think about because it does extend the timeline out quite a bit. Um another issue that uh was interesting is that um we had a church that put out a study paper arguing that women can teach in Sunday school in a mixed adult class, and um they're they could do so in the as a general office of believer.
SPEAKER_01And um, one of the members of that church complained against the session's uh position, and then that was denied by the presbytery, but then it came to the General Assembly and it was upheld, so the complaint was sustained. So that church was then told you got to go back and you know retract the paper and tell the congregation that you erred. Um, so that one was interesting, especially given that there was a very similar case in the 90s, in I think it was 1990, uh, where a woman was teaching in a small group and someone complained.
SPEAKER_01And the same it was the same result where it was said that's not okay, but it was a very narrow margin. This was also a narrow margin. Um and we both times in 1990 and this year, 2024, there were protests about um that decision. But I think this year we got fewer signatures on the uh on the protest. And if you look back in the 90s, there were some big name people signing that protest. I think Richard Gaffin is one name that you guys might recognize, but there was a lot of recognizable names uh in that 1990 uh protest.
SPEAKER_01And uh so one of my questions is, you know, is is the OPC getting more conservative on that point um over the years? You know, there's some some churches that get more conservative over time, some that get get liberalized. And um, you know, there's certain things in the OPC that don't fly now that have you know been just fine in the past. You know, I think about Old Princeton and theistic evolution, and you know, certainly that's not a okay uh uh as a view for officers now, or John Murray and the Covenant of Works, right?
SPEAKER_01Denying that. Um, I don't think that would fly in a lot of Presbyteries now. So um that's just an interesting question for me. And then the other, you know, I was thinking about you guys, and I was gonna ask about the whole, you know, PCA is called the grassroots denomination. You know, what does that what does that mean? And what does that mean for GA decisions being top-down? Because, you know, in this case in the OPC, you know, it's kind of a top-down thing where uh local church was saying, you know, we think this is okay, and the General Assembly said no, that's not okay.
SPEAKER_01So um, yeah, what do you guys think about all that?
SPEAKER_02I think Scott is just primed to answer a question like this now that he's uh seated on our uh permanent administrative committee.
SPEAKER_04As a member of the permanent committee, I have this from the committee. Now I don't do I have to be like Mel Duncan, like disclose I'm not acting on behalf of any committee in any podcast. Um I think what it typically means, like practically for the PCA is that it's only top-down when it it needs to be, and it rarely rises to that occasion unless there's controversy. And so if there's a controversy in the church, there might be an issue that gets top-down litigation. You think of um we had an issue where a church allowed a woman to preach in the pulpit on a Sunday, and that that gets nipped in the bud pretty quick by the actual assembly itself.
SPEAKER_04But if it's a minor issue, there is always uh seems to be a granting of liberty. We even saw that this year when we were debating constitutionalizing a chapter in the Book of Church Order with the directory of worship, where the assembly is slow to enact or enforce top-down sort of behavior. That also comes with background checks, as we also saw, there's always a deferral to the lower court, it seems, unless there's a matter of extreme importance or controversy.
SPEAKER_04Side B, sexuality, um, women preaching in pulpits, those are all big tier issues that the assembly will act on. But if it has the opportunity to not act or say something, it typically is where it defers to. Um, and so some things don't get dealt with. Like you're just talking about uh a lady teaching in Sunday school. Um, that won't, we won't even have the discussion on that in the PCA. Um, though we are probably very mixed on the the question, more mixed than the OP.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I wonder if that would even get the debated on the merits or if it would be a, you know, is our constitution clear or is this left up to the session? I think probably that would be where the debate would be, would be whether or not the general assembly has the author, you know, the authority or the clearness in order to speak into it rather than the issue itself.
SPEAKER_04When we talked with um the ARP too, it's kind of like we're somewhere in between our assembly's authority, it's somewhere in between like the mainline general assemblies with the PCUSA and like a general synod where it has less authority. It's like we're somewhere in between that, where the General Assembly and the PCUSA have all sorts of edicts that they force upon their congregations. Um just watching that this week. Um, that's not so much the PCA. It seems like the PCA wants to air towards a synod type of authority, uh, but it will, if necessary, flex the assembly's authority.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, and that's an interesting question for us too, because I talked to one guy who was saying, well, you know, that's it's not binding on me. Um, you know, in other words, we upheld a complaint against one particular church, we didn't enact a policy. Um, and so the question is, you know, if we have other churches uh that actually put out the same paper or have the same practice, um what are they liable for, right? I guess somebody could bring them up on charges and somebody could file a complaint that might have a good chance of being sustained, but um by by doing what they did, the assembly didn't come out with a blanket policy.
SPEAKER_01Um but it would be wrong for that church to keep doing what it's doing, because that would be thumbing its nose at its authority, um, you know, it's its father, fathers and brothers in the faith. So yeah, it's they're interesting questions. And and one of the interesting things for this GA was that I felt like we were a little inconsistent on this question because we had another complaint that was against a session that had enacted a policy that they would never admit Baptists into membership who were unwilling to baptize their kids.
SPEAKER_01And, you know, it in both of these cases it's kind of like, well, maybe you don't agree with them, but do are we willing to let them kind of have freedom to come up with this policy? And that that's what the assembly chose. They did not uphold that complaint, and they said, you know, it's fine for this session to come up with that policy. We don't necessarily agree with it, but we will let them have that latitude. And yet the assembly didn't say that with women teaching Sunday school. I think just because of the air that we're living in, with um, you know, a lot of people being afraid of feminism invading the church and that kind of thing.
SPEAKER_01So um, but it seemed a little inconsistent to me personally.
SPEAKER_00Well, were there any other big ticket items or um also wanted to ask you just kind of as an overview, looking at this General Assembly compared to some of the other General Assemblies that you've been to, uh, what may be encouraging that you've seen in terms of trends, or what may be some challenges for the OPC in the in the future moving forward?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, um, I mean, there were a couple other things that were they got a little bit of fireworks. Um we had a special committee on equipping church officers to protect the flock. So not quite as in-depth as your Docker report, um, but kind of doing putting something on the books. Um and then uh we also had I think we I think we created a study committee to talk about what's good and wise in the question of um giving criminals uh a second chance.
SPEAKER_01So so somebody maybe who's converted in prison, could they become a church officer later down the road? You know, we believe if you're in Christ, you're a new creation. But there also might be other things to think about, um, you know, particularly if you have a sex offender, um, that kind of thing. So we created a study committee, I think, for that to give guidance to to sessions and presbyteries. Um but you know, in terms of overall, you know, it was an assembly that I don't think made everybody happy, right?
SPEAKER_01In other words, you know, there were a lot of split votes, and some went some people's way, and other times it went a different way. And so I think it was one of these assemblies that nobody comes home from being like, oh man, that was a great general assembly. You know, you come back and you say, well, you know, there was some good and there was some bad. Um, one moment that was particularly encouraging to me was um we had a man who was a pastor and he's complaining that his presbytery started to uh start the process of divesting him for lack of gifts.
SPEAKER_01And I won't say his name, but if you follow Twitter, you probably know who this is. Um and we didn't uh sustain his complaint, and um just we were very pastoral, and that a guy asked the the moderator, and he was probably out of line to ask this, but we're pastors and and elders, and so he said, Could you just could Mr. Moderator could you uh pastorally address this man and and ask him to hear the church speaking to him tenderly?
SPEAKER_01And it was a a beautiful speech off the cuff that the moderator Davy Fesco gave about accepting hardship and suffering in Christ Church. And um it was one of those moments where you're like, yeah, I'm glad to be in the OPC, you know, I'm glad to stand aside alongside these guys. Um you know, I I don't know, I mean, I'm hoping that that person hears that, but I know from other people that they heard that um impromptu speech by the moderator and were powerfully affected by it.
SPEAKER_01So, you know, that that was a great thing. Um you know, I'm I'm thankful for the fact that we give everybody a voice. You know, one of the differences between the OPC and and uh and others is that because we have such a long assembly, we make sure we hear everybody. And so one thing I should tell you is that there was one um motion to call the question. And uh that you know, it's not something the OPC does. And I want to tell you that it failed by one vote.
SPEAKER_01So imagine 150 people voting and it fails by one vote to call the question.
SPEAKER_04Um so we never fail those votes in the PCA, even if we've only had zero speeches for the idea before us. If you call the question, we will vote to call the question.
SPEAKER_00We will we don't care, we are ruthless. That that that actually happened in our assembly this year.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, OPC is very different, but at least, you know, at least that vote signals to people you've got to stop talking because people are getting tired of hearing, you know, it's sometimes that um right, uh every not everyone is everything's been said, but not everybody's had a chance to say it. Um and uh, but it's a good thing that we let people say their piece and have their day in court. And uh, you know, I think one thing to work on as far as a challenge for our assembly is uh just to articulate for future generations what does it mean to be a a churchman?
SPEAKER_01You know, I'm thankful everybody has good decorum, uh I think for the most part in their speeches. But, you know, there's um there was an article put out a long time ago, maybe you guys have read it by John Meether called Confidence in Our Brethren. And, you know, it's about subs uh confessional subscription in the OPC, and you know, our models a bit different than the PCA in some ways, but um, you know, just that's part of churchmanship is having confidence in our brothers, right?
SPEAKER_01Not looking at anybody with suspicion and and not seeing agendas and I don't know, I don't know. Um you don't want to have people going around and and trying to be a sheriff of the denomination. Um you know, how do you how do you try to fix inadequacies and weaknesses without being um imposing and and kind of going around trying to fix the denomination, right? Do you love do you love the church the way she is, even recognizing that you're always reforming?
SPEAKER_01Um so yeah, I don't know, those are some rambling thoughts on some encouragements and challenges. Um, but I think we kind of always need to teach people what does it mean to be a good churchman? And how do we have confidence in our brothers, even when we do differ on these kinds of questions, like should women be teaching Sunday school? Um, you know, how do we how do we get alongside, uh work alongside each other um in those cases?
SPEAKER_00So well, um I have one more question, but I don't know if Ben or Scott have any other questions before I How about it? Mine's a little bit random. Um so you guys work together with the URC to um come up with the Trinity Psalter hymnal. Our church actually just uh adopted that about a year and a half ago. And but I was I was wondering uh first of all, um you know the PCO wasn't involved.
SPEAKER_00I I don't know if we just we got an invitation but didn't respond. I don't know who's who's at who's at fault there, but um I I wondered about the uh reception of it in the OPC. Were you guys using the Trinity Psalter hymnal at your uh General Assembly? And do you do you know what the reception's been like? Because I know I I filled the pulpit at an evening service at an OPC church that was hanging on to those blue Trinity uh hymnals, but when the Trinity Psalter hymnal act came out, they actually switched to those. So I didn't know if there's been any kind of study of the reception of that in the OPC.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, great question. Um we got those at the General Assembly in 2018, um, and we actually did a joint uh General Assembly and Synod with the URC in 2018 at Wheaton College. It was great. Um, where you know they had their assembly in one building or their synod, and we had ours, and then we would meet together for lunch, we would do devotions together, you know, the meals were all together. That was a great time, and um, it was great to get that hymnal.
SPEAKER_01It's I would say that it's um widespread in its adoption in the OPC, and that's had a powerful effect on recovering psalm singing. Um, because you know, I know that in Virginia, in our church before this, we had this little red Trinity Psalter companion to the Trinity Psalter or to the Trinity Hymnal, and it just wasn't great, it didn't have the music in it, and uh a lot of stuff was hard to sing, and uh this has really helped um increase psalm singing in the OPC.
SPEAKER_01I mean, in the church that I served in Virginia, every every time we would worship, the first song we did was a psalm from the the Trinity Psalter Hymnal. So um there's still some churches out there that are hanging on to the Trinity Hymn, and there's there's a few hymns in there that I wish made it into the Trinity Psalter Hymnal, like the communion hymn, Till He Come, uh Till He Comes. That one is is really good. Um just that reminder that we're partaking of the supper until he comes, and one day he will wipe away all the tears from our eyes and do away with sin.
SPEAKER_01But uh yeah, it's it's been a great blessing. There it was funny because there was a lot of talk at that assembly about, you know, is there a future of the URC and the OPC merging? And um, but it seemed like the URC was still kind of figuring out who it is. Um you know, they're they're still a pretty young denomination, right? Only 30 years, if you want to call them that. Um they're they're not they're kind of a confederation of churches, and in some ways I think they're a lot more congregational than the OPC.
SPEAKER_01I mean, for example, they they have their uh members kind of do a little bit more of a subscriptional um membership than the OPC. I mean, we just have these five membership questions about being a basic Christian.
SPEAKER_04Um so that's uh pretty much like all the Dutch denominations require their communicants to actually profess the whole of their constitution, which is not like Presbyterianism at all. Right.
SPEAKER_00Now the important question though on um the Trinity Psalter hymnal is when you sing Psalm 23, is the proper tune the uh crimond A or Tarwathy C?
SPEAKER_01Well, we all know the answer to that one, right? It's it's Crimond or Crimond or whatever. I mean, that's that's the classic.
SPEAKER_00Well, it's the Queens, but the Scottish tune is Tarwathy, so nobody agrees with me on this.
SPEAKER_04So he has really cold takes on psalms.
SPEAKER_01Um one question I had for you guys was that at our assembly we noted that we're kind of hurting for foreign missionaries. You know, the OPC model from for foreign missionary is great in the sense that you don't have to raise funds, it's all you know done unitedly through the denomination. Um, you know, presbyteries and and our home missions committee will fund the guy for years. Um, but we have a shortage of missionaries, and in fact, they called a day of fasting and prayer to pray that the Lord raises up men to go out there.
SPEAKER_01And I was just wondering if is that something that you guys are dealing with as well in the PCA.
SPEAKER_04It seemed like it. Um we had a report from the uh coordinator for MTW and it had like he had a slide. I mean, it was a dismal slide that showed what they projected to have by like 2030 on the field, and then it's like, what do we have today? And it seemed like it was like a 10%. And it's like, well, we're halfway through the decade and you're you know, you're missing 40 at least 40% of what you projected. And so are we gonna, how are we gonna make up that difference within the next six years?
SPEAKER_04Um, because we're so off. So it seemed we seem to seem we seem to have the same issue of trying to meet those kind of goals.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, our model in the PCA is having churches, individual churches, support the missionaries more than just the denomination together, which uh has disadvantages, I think, to the missionaries in terms of funding, but there is an advantage to the church and that they have a connection to a missionary that they're praying for. When they come back, they make sure that they visit those same churches so that, you know, those those 10, 12 people uh that they're praying for throughout the year, that then they are coming back to see them.
SPEAKER_00Um, so I've I've gone back and forth that sometimes I want to be more like the OPC and fully fund them. And then there's other times that I'm like, it's good to see our missionaries and have the people in the congregation know about this one particular work in Cambodia that's happening rather than all of them at the same time. Right.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, there's pros and cons to both approaches. Yeah. I've I've often often thought about that just because sometimes that connection is missing, you know, that um you have to work harder for individual congregations to know about the work of each missionary. Um but the advantage is not having to go around fundraising and all that kind of stuff.
SPEAKER_02So well, gentlemen, is there anything else we need to address talk about that we can ask?
SPEAKER_00Other than how the uh how can the PCA be praying for our OPC brothers?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, um that's a good question. Um I mean, I think uh pray for us to flourish uh alongside you guys, right? Um, you know, it's not a an either or thing. And I think ultimately one of the things that I try to emphasize is that you know, even in my new role, I'm serving a denomination and a presbytery, but first and foremost, I'm serving Christ and um not just a denomination. And so I think just praying that we would be growing and that our churches would be full of people singing God's redeeming grace um in the same way that yours are, right?
SPEAKER_01Um and so I think just praying for us at all would be great. Um just remembering we're out here, you know, we're your your your little little little older brother or something, um little older sister. Um but uh I think there should be a lot of love and cooperation between our our two bodies, um because at the end of the day we're we're right next to each other um on so many things. So yeah, just just pray for us and and work with us.
SPEAKER_04We will pray for another joining and receiving for your sake.
SPEAKER_01We will we will just don't say no this time, okay? You know, it takes two to tango, and yeah, yeah. Didn't it work out where one one year you said no and then the other year we said no?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, yeah. And now that we're even, we can actually do a real ask next time. Not now that we've gotten that out of the way.
SPEAKER_01Well, you know, I I heard that uh Robert Godfrey had some kind of pan-reformed idea where you would have everybody joined together in some sense, but then there would be kind of different synods. So there'd be like an OPC synod and a URC synod and a PCA synod. And um, yeah, I'm I'm not sure how what I think about that, but um yeah.
SPEAKER_02If that's the way we we get synods, I'm on board. That that would be that would be the sell-in.
SPEAKER_04Synods are a terrible idea. Stop. You just stop.
SPEAKER_02Oh, it's all for you, Scott. No synods. We'll get ice cream sometime and talk about it. We don't need more bureaucracy. Stop. Anyway, as Kevin Corley would say, this podcast is over. Thanks for joining us. If you're interested in learning more about anything that we've talked about, check out the show notes. I'll put links to some of Andrew's uh things and places that you can find him, uh the book that him and uh the the two other guys write, Jonathan Cruz and uh what else is the other author? Bill Bookstein. Yeah, we're really uh appreciative of that that volume. Uh they gave it to us at Twin Lakes this last year.
SPEAKER_02It was uh a good gift. Um Andrew, thanks for coming on and and uh spending time with us. Uh you guys can check out the show notes uh in your podcast player, go to Politymatters.org and you can see them there as well. If you've enjoyed the show, consider following us on Twitter and Facebook at Polity Matters, and be sure to subscribe in your podcast app of choice. If you have questions or comments, anything we can pass along to our brother, you can contact us directly on social media or at Politymattersfeedback at gmail.com. Uh for now that's all we have for you. Thanks again for spending time with us.
SPEAKER_02Until next time, say goodbye, gentlemen. Adios. Thanks for having me on. Y'all take care.
Ben, Jared, and Scott are joined by Brad Voyles, president of Covenant College, as the RAO series continues through the agencies and committees of the General Assembly. Brad shares how he went from Bellhaven and RTS...
Jared and Scott are joined by Andrew Rein, coordinator of Reformed University Fellowship (RUF), as the RAO series continues through the agencies and committees of the General Assembly. Andrew shares how he came to RUF...
Ben, Jared, and Scott are joined by Steve Dowling, interim coordinator of Mission to North America (MNA), as the RAO series continues through the committees and agencies of the General Assembly. Steve marks one year in...
Ben and Jared are joined by Lloyd Kim, coordinator of Mission to the World (MTW), as the RAO series continues through the committees and agencies of the General Assembly. Lloyd shares his path from Southern California...
Ben, Jared, and Scott are joined by Stephen Estock, coordinator of the PCA's Committee on Discipleship Ministries (CDM), as the RAO series continues through the permanent committees and agencies. Stephen shares his path...