Jared and Scott are joined by RE John Bise to work through matters pertaining to process against TEs. Send us Fan Mail Support the show Official Website: politymatters.org Support the Show: Buy Me a Coffee Twitter/X: @PolityMatters Facebook: Polity Matters Page Scott's Twitter Jared's Twitter Ben's Twitter
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_01Do you have it started for um for Ben to be able to cut off the beginning and yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_00We are recording now, and so hopefully it all works right and I don't get fired.
SPEAKER_01Okay. Um well I'll start us off with something. I'm sure Ben will probably put some sort of an intro on it, so I'll I'll be minimal. But um so I'll start us in 3, 2, 1. Um Welcome to Polity Matters. And today we are continuing our look at the BCO uh in chapter 34, uh looking at special rules pertaining to process against a minister uh teaching elder. So joining me is Scott. I am Jared Nelson, and Ben is not here.
SPEAKER_01That's why you're not hearing him right now uh introduce that. But we do have a guest that can help us uh with his absence, and that is uh we are welcoming back again uh John Bice. So uh John, uh know you from a former uh moderator and member of the SJC, but uh, is there any fun facts that people don't know about you that you'd want to share right now?
SPEAKER_02Uh I think all my secrets have been exposed.
SPEAKER_01Well, I do feel underdressed. I'm the only one without a uh bow tie today, so um, but we'll we'll manage. Um well we're we're looking a little bit at 34. And instead of talking about things that happen at session level with process, now this is gonna be an area that um uh often goes up on appeal to the SJC, which is uh for teaching elders for a minister, and of course their court of original jurisdiction uh begins at the presbytery. And so I'm just gonna read these sections and then we can comment a little bit about it.
SPEAKER_01Um I might give some nerdy history. Scott can give us some analytics, and then John, you can give us uh your your wisdom as always. So uh let's just go ahead and dive into this. So chapter 34, uh beginning with the first section here, reads Process against a minister shall be entered before the presbytery of which he is a member. However, if the presbytery refuses to act, in doctrinal cases or cases of public scandal, and two other presbyteries request the General Assembly to assume original jurisdiction to first receive and initially hear and determine, the General Assembly shall do so.
SPEAKER_01So let's break this apart, just the first sentence. Uh, what are we being told here that process against the minister shall be entered before the presbytery of which he is a member? What does that mean, guys?
SPEAKER_00We're reminded that uh perhaps most importantly, where the jurisdiction of a pastor lies, his membership, uh, we say this perhaps ad nauseum is not in the local church, uh, but actually in the presbytery. And so process against a minister, it'd be inappropriate to begin in the local church because he is not a member of the local church. Instead, he is a member of the presbytery. And so this is perhaps the framing, the introduction. If there are an issue that you might have with the minister, or if you've seen an issue with the minister, the appropriate place would be the presbytery to address those concerns.
SPEAKER_00Um and so it perhaps is a little different because the pastor is on the ground at the church. You might think that's where I need to address my issues. But when it comes to uh sin and process, that actually begins in the presbytery, not the church.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, John, have you ever actually seen a session attempt to start process with a minister and not realize chapter 34, one is there?
SPEAKER_02Yes. Uh, you know, we've we've seen instances in which individuals try to bring charges against ministers at the presbytery at the session level. And um, you know, that's simply reflective of the fact that many people simply fail to make that distinction that Scott noted. Um of course it's an interesting parallel to the fact that um it's it's the Presbytery that approves ultimately the call of the minister, even though the church makes the call, the Presbytery nonetheless approves it and places the call in his hands.
SPEAKER_00I was at the Orthodox Presbyterian Church uh Presbytery meeting this well last week, and what I learned there is that the ministers are members of the churches of the region. And so no matter what church they attend in that presbytery, they are members of that church, as all the churches in the presbytery, which is somewhat unique. It's not merely the presbytery they're a member of, but their membership has a dual focus in every congregation within its bounds, which I thought is perhaps peculiar, I'm on at least on my ears.
SPEAKER_01I think this might be a difference between the PCUS and the PCUSA, the Northern and Southern Presbyterians, but um since ours is copied off of the PCUS BCO, that's where our membership is. Um the the second part of this is uh maybe gets into a little bit more detail and more uh interesting uh elements because it's not in the PCUS BCO, uh, but it is in the PCA BCO, uh, which is this provision if a presbytery refuses to act uh in cases of public scandal or doctrinal issues, and if two other presbyteries petition the General Assembly to assume general uh original jurisdiction, that the General Assembly takes up original jurisdiction.
SPEAKER_01Um I had noted in the previous episode that we did some of the history of this in the old PCUS. There was a professor uh named E.T. Thompson who uh was going to be brought up uh, well, was was teaching at Union Theological, and uh a lot of students were coming away from there with more liberal views, and there were several presbyteries that were concerned about this. Uh so at least four different presbyteries uh uh overtred the General Assembly uh to do something about it because they felt that the Presbytery was not doing anything.
SPEAKER_01Uh and those failed because the original 34-1 was just one sentence, and the understanding was, well, that's his um his court of original jurisdiction. You can't take him out of there. Uh although they also said, hey, we investigated them and everything's fine, we're not going to start the process uh on this. And so when the PCA came into existence, this was ringing in their heads and they added this provision. Um John, maybe you can tell us have you ever seen this uh provision uh in use? I know there was an attempt a couple years ago to use it, uh, but maybe you can fill us in a little bit on that.
SPEAKER_02Well, let me just go a little beyond what you said, because in addition to uh that case, there was an another one, predecessor, and I'm uh I'm sorry, I don't I don't have the uh strength of recollection, but there was there was also a predecessor case um in the former church where that um where that came into play. And ultimately um efforts to have the assembly take up those matters failed, even though um there was an assertion by a man who I believe subsequently became part of the PCA that it was the responsibility of the assembly to speak to matters um of politoling and polity, and so that argument was placed.
SPEAKER_02But um yes, there have been efforts in recent years, and there have also been over the years um a number of instances in which um because cases either have not gone to the SJC or were turned away, uh there have been efforts to modify the BCO to change this from two presbyteries uh to some greater number. Um there's also been um debate over whether the uh phrase uh refuses to act means takes no action or fails to take an appropriate action.
SPEAKER_02So uh this couple of little lines uh are laden with uh, or I guess the couple is laden with uh with areas of dispute that have uh have had a history, uh, both in a in a recent case uh but as well as several others over the years.
SPEAKER_01Um yeah, there was a recent effort at an overture to change this, and um it basically the compromise was not knowing what refuses to act really meant can we find that as to refuses to start process or adjudicate or something. Um but if you're gonna change that, others said you don't want to have uh a witch hunt happening, two Presbyteries start petitioning to have all these people brought up on uh original jurisdiction, and so to change that to 10%.
SPEAKER_01Uh some people thought, well, should it be 5% or should it be something different? And so that compromise ultimately they couldn't really find the the right balance there. Uh maybe somebody will try that in the future. Um but this this is an interesting provision in that you would if you this were to be engaged, you would have a trial at the SJC level, the GA level, right? Um That's correct. Yeah, something T. David Gordon pointed out. Uh I was talking to him about this that scared him a little bit is you have no court of appeal. So if you if this happens, it's SJC and you have no appeal from there.
SPEAKER_01That's that's your only court, uh, unless, of course, we um uh institute synods, which I know Scott is all for, right?
SPEAKER_00No, I hate synods, terrible idea. More bureaucracy.
SPEAKER_02No, no, no. Well Jared, you you're you're correct in reciting that uh uh I looked it up and it was the uh the 2022 assembly at which that uh last effort was made, and uh it involved work uh between um Harry Donahoe and Fred Greco, um, who frequently come at things from different directions, but uh you know the goal was to try to come with something reasonable um because some feel that two is um an unreasonably small number, given the expanded number of presbyteries since that was originally drafted in.
SPEAKER_02But then if it's got to be more than two, how many more? And as you said, things really broke down both over what's the appropriate number or percentage of presbyteries, but also uh there was dispute over what is it that constitutes uh refusal to act. Yeah.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I think what ultimately sank that in the presbyteries was that there are many presbyteries that are so small that 10% becomes a single church. And is that that would be even lightening the stipulation? And so I think I think it got a majority of the presbyteries, but nowhere near the the threshold to actually be considered again, and it is probably largely due to the fact of the sessional issue of uh presbytery taking original jurisdiction from a session and being in a small presbytery.
SPEAKER_00I I was surprised my presbytery voted for it, even though we only have nine churches. A fraction of a church has to send it up and we'll take uh original jurisdiction.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, because this was parallel to 33.1 that deals with this at the session level. If there's a church that you're taking something out of there, and so we like to have it even. So both of those were being amended, and um people were pointing that out about 33.1. Yeah. Anything else that we need to talk about here with 34-1?
SPEAKER_00John, can you define what fails uh refuses to act means?
SPEAKER_02Well definitively. No, I can't define it definitively. As I said, there's been dispute uh about that uh fairly broadly as to whether it means does nothing or doesn't take the appropriate action. And so uh that was part of the discussion that went on a couple of years ago, and it had uh that has been going on for quite some time. It goes all the way back uh to the issue in the in the previous denomination.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, in history, I think this has only really been activated once in uh the Woods case back in '99 or two thousand or two thousand, somewhere in that. And uh more recently it was seemingly it was gonna happen, but actually that's not how the case that some people were trying to use 34-1 got before the SJC. So it hasn't been used a whole lot. Maybe it's partly because that's confusing. So yeah.
SPEAKER_02The the Woods case preceded my time on the SJC. Um, you know, I've I've taken a look at some of the information, but uh it arose in that, and then more recently in another um notorious uh uh case. Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Well, maybe we can move on to 34.2. Um there we read as no minister ought, on account of his office, to be screened in his sin or slightly censured, so scandalous charges ought not to be received against him on slight grounds. Uh what is this trying to do for um a process that would begin against a teaching elder, against a pastor?
SPEAKER_00Smith notes uh there it's trying to deal with two dangers. Uh that is, a Presbytery dealing too lightly with an offense, and perhaps a Presbytery on the second uh accepting charges against a minister too lightly. And so a Presbytery will be tempted to either dismiss legitimate charges or perhaps take uh frivolous charges too seriously. And that's perhaps the it's a really short section, but really difficult to apply uh just because you're trying to avoid both ditches of uh trying to perhaps maintain justice in in the court.
SPEAKER_00Uh so it warns us on those two things. Don't deal with an offense too lightly and don't accept uh light offenses or frivolous offenses um too seriously.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, what's the what's the principle there? Because we wouldn't charge somebody in the congregation with doctrinal cases on some things that we would charge a pastor for doctrinal cases. So in some ways the the standard is higher. We would charge more for a pastor, but how do we know if uh if we're getting into an area in which we're being too nitpicky on a charge um or we're brushing something under the rug? Is there any kind of principle or any examples that we can think of?
SPEAKER_02I would say that the two principles that that I would look to would be the one of whether or not um the matter poses risks either to um the vitals of religion or to the reputation of the church. Um you know, some things are simply matters of of personal weakness um uh and are of say trivial because you know they they can still be sinful, but they're they're sins that do not have substantial impact.
SPEAKER_02And so um, you know, that kind of a situation would not require a trial. On the other hand, you don't want to overlook something that even though it may not have um drama associated with it, if you will, that has um significant adverse impact on the name of Christ, the reputation of the church and the and the like. And the same would hold true from a theological perspective with regard to the teaching. Does it strike at the vital?
SPEAKER_02And Scott, I'll go ahead and anticipate your question and tell you that I can't give you a definitive answer as to what strikes at the Vitus.
SPEAKER_00Certainly not pay-to-communion, right?
SPEAKER_01God wants to touch every third rail he can. All right. Well, if I think if uh Waters was here, uh he would talk about it comes down to the judgment and subjection of the courts, but um we'll just move on since he's not. Um 34-3 reads uh if anyone knows a minister to be guilty of a private offense, he should warn him in private. But if the offense be persisted in or become public, he should bring the case to the attention of some other minister of the presbytery.
SPEAKER_01So back to our distinctions of private and public. Um how do we know, though, when a private matter has been persisted in and is worthy to be brought up or has become public? What does that mean? Because I if I put it on Twitter, has that become public? Is that what it's getting at?
SPEAKER_02I think there again, it's a matter of uh judgment of the court uh and of the individual who might potentially bring a claim. You know, if if uh if I knew of something you know concerning in your um theology or practice, Jared, I might call upon Scott and uh, you know, first I might warn you privately, then I might call upon Scott to assist me in that process. Um but uh if it persisted um or if it began, you know, I think if it made it into the public realm, if you will, by social media, there's a reasonable likelihood that should be viewed as being uh public.
SPEAKER_01Anything to add to that, Scott, or are we good?
SPEAKER_00I think we're good. We talk about private and public offenses quite a bit already. So all right.
SPEAKER_01Then moving on to uh 34-4, there's an A and a B. I'll read A first. Uh when a minister accused of an offense is found contumacious, uh, which we see a reference back to 32-6 there, he shall be immediately suspended from the sacraments, and his office for his contumacy. Record shall be made of the fact and of the charges under which he was arraigned, and the censure shall be made public. The censure shall in no case be removed until the offender has not only repented of his contumacy, but is also given satisfaction in relation to the charges against him.
SPEAKER_01Uh, we've heard language that's very similar to this, but this is um a provision that uh tells us um if somebody is contumacious, uh that is they are persisting in this, they are not cooperating with the court, they're not um entering into this process, uh, that they are uh at some point uh suspended from office and suspended from uh the sacraments. So um any any comments on what this looks like or how how to know when this comes into effect.
SPEAKER_02Continuacy uh you know is you know the the persistence. And so I think that uh this is really a situation where I would think that for the most part it would be the Presbytery that would be aware of the facts that would um uh drive the case. Um but it's it's striking to me that um you know that upon immediately upon a finding of contumacy, uh a minister is to be suspended both from the sacraments and his office.
SPEAKER_02So um and it's and the uh censure shall be made public. So um you know, I would think that before that provision uh were um activated, the Presbytery would would have very strong indications and and very significant bases for doing so. In in one sense, it goes back to the issue of um 34-2 that you know you want to you don't want to do this lightly.
SPEAKER_00It's a good reminder that this is in the context of uh process, not um anywhere else. And so you can't just find a member in good standing with no charges against him contemnacious because he's a knucklehead for saying something you didn't like at Presbytery. Uh this is within the context of trials and leading up to trials, and so once process is engaged, the court itself has the power to cite and and to force participation of someone who's been accused of something, and it's failure to participate that often leads to the contemnacious uh verdict.
SPEAKER_00And that's where you get at perhaps the end of A, where it's not only uh when they have repented of their contumacy that um this begins to reverse, but also is given satisfaction to the charge. And so there are two issues that at play here. It's not only you jump to a new ladder with dealing with the contumacy, they must first repent of that, and then you have to get back to the original issue that led to the contumacy in the first place. Um and both of those are are seeking to be resolved um before perhaps even removing all of these censures being dealt with.
SPEAKER_00And so it's not as There's a little more going on uh in thirty-four-four relating to those things.
SPEAKER_01Right. On A, it seems to also be um worth taking note the difference between suspended and the actual deposition or excommunication. In some ways you're on a on ramp there, but you can get off of that if if they start participating with the process. But then B, uh it has a provision if they don't cooperate with that. It says uh if after further endeavor by the court to bring the accused to a sense of his guilt he persists in his contumacy, he shall be deposed and excommunicated uh from the church.
SPEAKER_01Um any thoughts there on how long is that endeavor supposed to be?
SPEAKER_00As Guy Waters would say, it's at the discretion of the court. And as John Vice would say, it's at the discretion of the court.
SPEAKER_02And I think that would be driven by you know such issues as the uh the significance of the offense, uh, you know, how long uh did it go before it became public, um, and what are the outward um evidences of um repentance, as well as the passage of time. And I think in these cases um what the court is is really charged with doing is is protecting uh both the purity of the church but also the the purity of the reputation um of Christ and of the church.
SPEAKER_02So um in a restoration situation like that, uh it's both valid to be uh cautious. On the other hand, um it should not be an impossible task.
SPEAKER_01Well, we've had for an answer a lot, the discretion of the court, but um 34-5, I think, continues in that a bit, with a really interesting section in my mind that um some of our rules are not just a black and white one zero. You're gonna have to make some judgments here, but 34-5 says heresy and schism may be of such a nature as to warrant deposition. But errors ought to be carefully considered, whether they strike at the vitals of religion and are industriously spread, or whether they arise from the weakness of the human understanding and are not likely to do much injury.
SPEAKER_01So not all heresy, not all schism, not all doctrinal error uh is the same, uh, and there's some discretion that's here. What are we looking for here over if we catch wind of um something that was said in a sermon that was disturbing or something that was uh written in a position paper of a of a pastor or article? Uh, how do we make a distinction here of whether or not this rises to a level in which it needs to be pursued and whether um it's not really something that's uh subject for deposition, um perhaps to say, you know, there's an admonition here, but not deposition.
SPEAKER_02Once again, I think I think we're talking about matters of discretion, but I think that the um the issue of striking at the vitals is a is a significant one. You know, it would there's certain things that we could list, you know, issues you know that would uh challenge or deny uh the deity of Christ that would deny you know the sufficiency of his um work, um, things of that nature would would clearly uh fall into this category.
SPEAKER_02On the other hand, there may be some that are simply um you know misunderstandings of scripture, misapplications, things that are inconsistent, and which uh frankly, um, you know, there are probably items that are taught um that simply um uh uh an individual congruent might not even pick up on the fact that it's contrary to scripture. Certainly, if you've got something that's of a secondary or tertiary nature such as that, then uh simply going to the man and speaking with him privately about it is is the thing that's called.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, we actually had to deal with this provision once in our presbytery. I'll be careful exactly what I say, but it was for a document that was uh just before our presbytery. And there was real concerns about how things were worded and things that actually dealt with Christology. And as we worked our way through it, realized that the uh minister had no intention of saying the things which were we thought were natural and logical consequences of what he said, it it really was just a not understanding the logic of what he was saying, worked with the committee, reworded everything, and and 34 or 5 was one of the things that stopped us from really um engaging in charges right away because we just said, wait a minute, this this perhaps is just poorly worded.
SPEAKER_01Uh, and nobody really knows about it except us here at Presbytery. So if we could deal with it here and you're not gonna say this uh in public, I think we're gonna be fine. So uh it's good to have that discretion uh available to you so that every uh you know bad word choice doesn't uh bring you up on charges.
SPEAKER_02And that and that goes to the uh to the issue of uh whether or not it's being industriously spread. You know, if this is a um you know a discussion among pastors and someone uh floats on a topic that he's been considering that he's struggling with, uh that's a whole different uh item from someone um flaunting something that is clearly contrary to our standards, campaigning within his congregation and the presbytery uh to get folks to modify their views.
SPEAKER_02So discretion once again.
SPEAKER_01Yep. Well, 34-6 uh continues, uh if the presbytery find on trial that the matter complained of amounts to no more than such acts of infirmity as may be amended, so that little or nothing remains to hinder the minister's usefulness, it shall take all prudent measures to remove the scandal. Um this almost seems like to be 34-5, but in the midst of the trial, you kind of discover this to say, okay, uh maybe this did touch on the vitals of religion, but now it's amended wording, it's it's something that can be changed, and uh it's not something that is uh an error that's really deeply held and continued in uh there is an off-ramp to process there, it seems.
SPEAKER_01Um anything further to say on that? All right, 34-7. When a minister pending a trial shall make confession, if the matter be based, and you're gonna have to help me with this word. This is this is 1800s wording here. Flagatus, such as uh drunkenness, uncleanness, or crimes of a greater nature. Uh, however penitent he may appear to the satisfaction of all, the court shall without delay impose definite suspension or depose him from the ministry.
SPEAKER_01So um here we have some uh sins that you can't just say, well, you can amend that, just stop drinking so much. Um, I guess if you if it's several uh acts of drunkenness in public or something like that. Um some things can't be amended, and even if you promise not to do it again, remove the scandal. Uh anything else that we see?
SPEAKER_00You know, it's interesting here is the shall, without delay, impose a definite suspension that the court is mandated, according to the book here, to actually render a verdict, and in that verdict include at least a definite suspension. And so if a minister comes forward with the sins that you just outlined, you you'd think of like a six-month suspension, a year suspension, two-year suspension that has to be definite in some sort. Um, or even if it's a greater issue, the deposition itself.
SPEAKER_00Um, but the court doesn't seem to have the liberty to just merely admonish in this regard. It it seems that the court must, even if there is great remorse, uh institute one of these two censures.
SPEAKER_02Well, and I think that's reflective of the notion that um there are sins which are uh particularly um onerous, which particularly harm um the reputation of the church and the reputation of Christ, and that regardless of the death of one's um repentance, uh something is demanded in the way of um reaction and response to that. Um that's why this is here.
SPEAKER_01Well, uh it is uh helpful if you're looking at somebody that you know you have a minister that confesses that they have um they were guilty of that DUI they were pulled over for, or something like that. There's there's immediate action that has to be taken there, uh, even while the matter's pending here, um, if they're making a confession of it. So 34-8, uh, if we continue on here, the a minister under indefinite suspension from his office or deposed for scandalous conduct shall not be restored even on the deepest sorrow for his sin, until he shall exhibit for a considerable time such an eminently exemplary, humble, and edifying life and testimony as shall heal the wound made by his scandal.
SPEAKER_01A deposed minister shall in no case be restored until it shall appear that the general sentiment of the church is strongly in his favor and demands his restoration, and then only by the court inflicting the censure uh or with that court's consent. The removal of deposition requires a three-fourths vote of the court inflicting the censure, or a three-fourths vote of the court to which the majority of the original court delegates that authority. So what what is this? If somebody has been deposed or they've been indefinitely suspended, um what sort of guidance are we getting here for the person that's asking for restoration?
SPEAKER_02I think in part what we're getting is that it should be um only with uh great caution. Uh there should be a period of exemplary behavior. And it's it's interesting to me that the um comment is made that uh that it should appear that the general sentiment of the church is strongly in his favor. You know, our belief is that these sorts of things are injurious to the church and uh and to the name of Christ by virtue of the um assault, if you will, on the reputation of the church.
SPEAKER_02Um therefore, um, if if the church um demands uh or is is willing to receive a man back, I think that's indicative of um the restoration of uh reputation, if you will, and the feeling that the reputational harm that had been inflicted has been in large part uh abated by subsequent exemplary behavior.
SPEAKER_02Um it's interesting that the uh the last sentence of of 348 uh is something that uh I believe is a a relatively new addition to the book. Um that that sentence was not there prior to, I think it came in uh 2013 or 2014. Um at the 2013 General Assembly, the 41st, um Pacific Northwest uh brought a an overture which uh sought uh the removal required a two-thirds vote of the court inflicting the censure, or two-thirds vote of a court to which um oversight of the censure had been assigned by majority vote of the original court.
SPEAKER_02That in the course of the assembly was amended and became a three-quarters vote. But uh I think that arose out of some cases in which um ministers were restored with relatively modest margins um supporting that restoration. And so Pacific Northwest brought this up as a concern that it should be more than a simple majority.
SPEAKER_01And I have my suspicions of who that might have originally written that overture. Um but it does tell us, I think, that uh it doesn't seem like this provision has the idea that somebody who's deposed from office is just being deposed and a couple years later he comes back. It feels like this is there's a provision for your restoration, but there really needs to be a lot of factors involved with a considerable amount of time uh that there's not lasting wounds, that the whole church is really welcoming this.
SPEAKER_01Um, it probably shouldn't be the pattern. It's more the exception that you find somebody that has been deposed because of scandal that comes back into the ministry.
SPEAKER_00Right. Yeah, what you see in this section is a life, uh a humble life uh that is not engaged in leadership, not engaged in the ministry uh as a leader at all. It's you've sat in the pew and have not sought the ministry, and it seems that the church itself, you know, the outward call, the external call uh is being placed back in there by the church, not by the individual. And so I think that's where perhaps the three-fourths is helpful, that it's not merely the man who feels called back.
SPEAKER_00It's that the church itself is almost demanding him back um based uh on all the evidences that are outlined here. Um and so it's a truly exceptional circumstance, um, uh as John had talked about previously, with the damage that scandal can do when a minister uh falls, uh, to demand him back is an extraordinary circumstance. Uh and that extraordinary circumstance I think is outlined pretty clearly and well in 34.8.
SPEAKER_01Well, if we're ready to move on to 34.9. Here we read, When a minister is deposed, his pastoral relation shall be dissolved, but when he is suspended from office, it shall be left to the discretion of the presbytery, whether the censure shall include the dissolution of the pastoral relation. Uh what's going on here?
SPEAKER_00You can no longer be a pastor of a church if you're not a pastor in the deposed department. Um, and the suspended part, if it's a definite suspension, it might just be a limited time and that censure might be removed. And so the relation need not be needlessly dissolved depending the offense. What I find interesting here is that the presbytery actually has the authority to somewhat unilaterally dissolve the relation of a suspended minister without the perhaps concurrence of the congregation.
SPEAKER_00And so this is helpful in our polity to remember that while the church might call upon the presbytery to call a man, it's up to the presbytery to actually issue that call. And in the same way, the presbytery has the authority to dissolve said call in the midst of process without it without the church. The church may not want that person as their pastor, but it's ultimately up to the presbytery in those circumstances. Um, even if they want him, they might not think it's wise to still have him.
SPEAKER_00And so uh there is perhaps a Presbyterianism in clearly on display in 34-9.
SPEAKER_02I think it reflects the notion that uh that it it is the Presbytery not only of which the uh pastor is a member, but that the Presbytery is exercising um its oversight with regard to its care for the individual churches. We can easily envision a situation in which a beloved pastor um has a congregation that might uh want to overlook something that uh that the congregation might think was a light matter, but the presbytery thinking it more substantial, more potentially harmful to either the peace and purity of the church or to the reputation of the church and of Christ, um, would insist that the relationship be dissolved.
SPEAKER_02And so there's a protection against potentially the congregation uh treating a pastor too lightly, if you will.
SPEAKER_01One thing more to add on this? Thirty-four ten. Whenever a minister of the gospel shall habitually fail to be engaged in the regular discharge of his official functions, it shall be the duty of the pr presbytery at a stated meeting to inquire into the cause of such dereliction and if necessary, to institute judicial proceedings against him for breach of his covenant and engagement. If it shall appear that his neglect proceeds only from his lack of acceptance to the church, Presbytery may, upon the same principle upon which it withdraws license from a licentiate for lack of evidence of his divine call, divest him of his office without censure, even against his will, a majority of two-thirds being necessary for this purpose.
SPEAKER_01In such a case, the clerk shall under the under the order of the presbytery forthwith deliver to the minister concerned a written note that at the next stated meeting the question of his being so dealt with is to be considered. This notice shall distinctly state the grounds for this proceeding. The party thus notified shall be heard in his own defense, and if the decision shall pass against him, he may appeal, and if he has been tried under after the usual forms, uh this principle may apply with uh any necessary changes to ruling elders and deacons.
SPEAKER_01Um what is 3410? What's the circumstances in which 3410 is trying to uh give us some sort of a solution? What's the problem to which 3410 is the solution?
SPEAKER_02I I think I think it's basically a pastor who is lazy and who's not fulfilling the call to the pastorate. It may be that he's um simply not preparing well to be in the pulpit. It may be that he's not caring for his flock, uh, and that could be in any number of ways. It could be pastoral care, uh, it could be um you know his own behavior personally.
SPEAKER_02Um but it strikes me that for the most part, uh, as I read this, it seems to be simply a matter of a man not doing a reasonable job and failing so miserably that it's it's clear that it's not um you know that it's impacting the health of the church and that uh he's simply not applying himself.
SPEAKER_01It seems the first part of that definitely has that in mind, and judicial proceedings then would be uh brought against him. Uh though it it also seems to have another possibility that's out there. Um maybe we call this the Charles Simeon um possibility. Uh if it shall appear that his neglect proceeds only from his lack of acceptance to the church. I wonder if this is, um, I don't know if you know the story of Charles uh Simeon that uh he had leaders in his church that uh didn't want him there, lock the pews so that people couldn't sit in the pews for evening worship, uh, just didn't want him there.
SPEAKER_01And uh I suppose this would be some sort of a, you know, there's a provision that this may not be the fault of the person. Um maybe they just don't like, you know, um uh his his football team or something like that. I don't know. Uh but there may be a non-fault sort of uh reason for them to divest a person, um that the church just didn't accept him and doesn't want him in that role anymore. And so uh it's not necessarily his his fault, his laziness. Um I don't know that I've I've necessarily seen that in a church.
SPEAKER_01Um but yeah.
SPEAKER_00What I find interesting is that it's divesture, not deposition. And so the it's a little different in regards to becoming a pastor again. It's not the same perhaps threshold of reversal where we were just talking about the need to demand it a three-fourths. uh resolution, uh a simple majority, he could come under care of another Presbytery. Um and so it's just removing the credentials um with that censure. And so it's a little easier to get back in under this circumstance than the circumstance we've been discussing a few moments ago.
SPEAKER_00Have you ever seen this applied John?
SPEAKER_02I've seen it applied. You know, I've I've seen instances where we see church members who uh are unhappy with pastors and sometimes that relates to their perception as to how a pastor is performing. But um you know to me this is this is clearly a situation where the presbytery takes action. Interestingly 3410 doesn't say anything about how this action is prompted.
SPEAKER_02So you know I could envision a situation in which disgruntled members of a congregation might go to the presbytery and say you know Pastor Smith is is simply not performing as he should and ask that the the Presbytery approach him or something of that sort. But um I can't recall a situation in which I've seen a case that grew out of this. The second paragraph talks about the fact that um um the the party um notified of that concern has the opportunity to be heard in his own defense and he may appeal the the decision so it's it has a judicial element in in the sense of appeal.
SPEAKER_01But um yeah this has to be one of those provisions that made its way into the book at some point because things like this happened. And you just have to imagine for a 3410 situation in a presbytery to occur that there's such a breakdown in the relationship between the pastor and the and the congregation um it's one of the times in which you are thankful for Presbyterianism that can step in and hopefully find some sort of a resolution there.
SPEAKER_02Interesting too that it uh the final sentence may apply with any necessary changes to ruling elders and deacons.
SPEAKER_01The pastors aren't the only ones that can get lazy you better uh hasten yourself John you don't do enough on the SJC we're coming with you with this provision I think everybody on the SJC should be exempt from this because they do more work than I think anybody else in the denomination 34 of 10 against you it's been a rather busy season so you're saying if John doesn't read those thousand page briefs that we can't use this provision?
SPEAKER_01Well is there any final thoughts or or pastoral wisdom about 34 in the BCO that we want to say before we sign off i'll I'll come back to where we started this this whole chapter to me um really um hinges on a couple of things it it it really drives home the issue that uh the pastor um or pastors plural are are charged with um living lives that are exemplary in their holiness and piety and that uh they're to be held to a high standard on the other hand um we need to be cautious that as Scott characterized it uh we not drive into either ditch that of being um overly light and uh indulging sin nor that of being unduly picky in pursuing sins that are of minimal impact and may simply be a matter of uh human frailty well i'll I'll end a little bit differently in saying as uh Thomas Murphy may say um this podcast is over a Thomas Murphy who wrote a pastoral theology that Law College just came out with that I've been reading through which is amazing and will make you feel like a lazy pastor if you start reading through it of all the duties that you have as a pastor.
SPEAKER_01So um on that note thank you so much John Bice for being with us again giving us some wisdom on this uh thank you Scott for being with me and we'll see if uh Ben makes it back from wherever he's at uh for our our next episode uh he'll add a little tag on the end here for all the things that I'm forgetting to say about where to find us and all those sorts of things. So uh thank you and uh say goodbye gentlemen.
SPEAKER_02Goodbye Jared and Scott thank you and thanks to Ben for the work that you're doing with this and thanks for having me. It's uh it's fun to be with you and uh I appreciate the fact um that uh you're providing this source of um knowledge uh to the broader church I actually had a fellow in our officer training class come up to me a couple of days ago and he said I was listening to the podcast and lo and behold there you are well thanks for the encouragement and thanks for everybody for for listening.
Ben, Jared, and Scott are joined by Brad Voyles, president of Covenant College, as the RAO series continues through the agencies and committees of the General Assembly. Brad shares how he went from Bellhaven and RTS...
Jared and Scott are joined by Andrew Rein, coordinator of Reformed University Fellowship (RUF), as the RAO series continues through the agencies and committees of the General Assembly. Andrew shares how he came to RUF...
Ben, Jared, and Scott are joined by Steve Dowling, interim coordinator of Mission to North America (MNA), as the RAO series continues through the committees and agencies of the General Assembly. Steve marks one year in...
Ben and Jared are joined by Lloyd Kim, coordinator of Mission to the World (MTW), as the RAO series continues through the committees and agencies of the General Assembly. Lloyd shares his path from Southern California...
Ben, Jared, and Scott are joined by Stephen Estock, coordinator of the PCA's Committee on Discipleship Ministries (CDM), as the RAO series continues through the permanent committees and agencies. Stephen shares his path...