Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Polity Matters

Polity Matters artwork

92. Regarding Paul Settle

Jul 15, 202542 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Jared sits down with Mel Duncan and Jason Helopolous to discuss the influential ministry of Rev. Paul Settle. Send us Fan Mail Support the show Official Website: politymatters.org Support the Show: Buy Me a Coffee Twitter/X: @PolityMatters Facebook: Polity Matters Page Scott's Twitter Jared's Twitter Ben's Twitter

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_03Alright, I'd like to welcome uh my two guests, the AD listeners, uh, as well, to a special edition of Polity Matters. We're dealing with some stuff after GA that is uh taking a little bit of a break from the BCO and thinking about some uh founders and some churchmen uh that are worth highlighting. And uh one of the first that I thought of is uh somebody that ties together my two guests that I have today. So, first uh Mel Duncan, do you want to briefly introduce yourself?

SPEAKER_00I'd be delighted too. Good to be with you today. I'm Mel Duncan, I'm a ruling elder at Second Presbyterian Church in Grainville, and also the clerk of Calvary Presbytery.

SPEAKER_03And then I have another guest. Jason, do you want to introduce yourself?

SPEAKER_01I can do that. I'm Jason Halopoulos, uh senior pastor at University Reformed Church in East Lancey, Michigan. And Jared, we have known each other a long time now.

SPEAKER_03We have. We first met in uh in Dallas, right?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, like 20 years ago. Something like that. It's been a while, yeah. It's been a long time.

SPEAKER_03Yeah. And that was because where did you do your internship?

SPEAKER_01I did my internship at Park City's Presbyterian Church here in Dallas.

SPEAKER_03And that will be relevant, as we'll see a little bit uh later on, in that the two guests here have in common that they both had a lot of interactions with. One of the first people we want to talk about for uh ministry and a churchman, and that is the man, uh the pastor, uh Paul Settle. Um both of you had interactions with him. Um people will probably know Paul Settle from uh questions in uh uh licensure and ordination exams of name uh founder, and sometimes Paul Settle's name will uh be that in Canada Credential.

SPEAKER_03Sometimes I'm trying to mouth that to people as they're they can think of Morton Smith or they can think of uh of uh the first uh moderator, but a lot of times uh Paul Settle doesn't necessarily uh fall off the lips. He was a part of uh Churchman United, one of those groups that was uh instrumental in the founding. Some may know that he was the eighth uh moderator uh of the General Assembly, but um kind of knowledge of him may be limited to that. And so I want to talk a little bit about his role as a founder, but also as a churchman and as a as a pastor today.

SPEAKER_03And so both of you had interactions with him. Um, and I thought maybe we could start just with uh answering that question. How did you know uh Paul Settle? What was his role at the time in terms of your uh interacting with his ministry? And you could uh go first with Mel and maybe you could fill anything that I missed in terms of his background and sure.

SPEAKER_00Uh well, Jared, I knew Paul Settle as my boyhood pastor who I made a profession of faith under. He was the man who taught me to love the Bible. He was the person who modeled and really showed me what expositional Bible teaching was. He was also, even as a young boy, I realized that he was a churchman. He was involved, he was a leader. Um he just cared deeply about the church.

SPEAKER_00And so uh growing up under his ministry, I came to feel like I was a part of the uh the meetings, the purposes, the conferences, the conventions he was a part of. He was the kind of person in the life of the church who brought people together. And he was a rare variable in the PCA because everyone loved and trusted Paul. Uh, even in those early days, there were different parts of the family in the PCA. And Paul was someone who had the respect and and even admiration of everyone.

SPEAKER_00Uh, Paul Settle comes to Greenville uh to uh be a part of the uh PCA General Assembly that meets in Greenville, and while that General Assembly is going on, a pulpit committee from Second Pres is pursuing him to be our minister. And so after the long hours of assembly was over, uh elders and members of our church were meeting with Paul for him to come and be a part of our church, and so he follows Gordon Reed as the uh he's the tenth senior minister of Second Presbyterian Church.

SPEAKER_00And and Paul's ministry was characterized as someone who was was a renowned and revered pulpit teacher. Um I I like to say uh Paul Settle helped get Second Press's head right. Uh he was uh just a remarkable teacher. Uh and um he complimented that by just being a remarkable Christian man. So I look forward to being a part of this conversation with you about Paul, remembering Georgia Settle as well, his beloved wife.

SPEAKER_00Uh Paul was a just a treasure to the PCA. Um I could go in a lot of different directions on this, but let me just, I was thinking as we were going to meet today, some things I wanted to say about Paul. Paul loved the Westminster standards and the confession of faith. Um, he he loved to teach that to people. One of my most prized possessions is he gave me his Westminster Confession of Faith. And I just love his little notes in there about the confession.

SPEAKER_00Uh he wrote a study guide for it too. He did indeed write a study guide. And Paul was a churchman. Uh Paul was an interesting combination of both a lion and a lamb. This is an analogy that my pastor has taught to me. There's certain kind of people who can pull that off. Paul Settle was able to do that. He was versatile in ministry. He was at small churches, big churches, he was at agencies and committees. Uh, but through it all, he was the same person.

SPEAKER_00And then the last thing I want to talk about is he was an amazing basketball player. And I hope maybe we can circle we can circle back around to that because he was an amazing basketball player. So I want to I want to put that on the table. And Jason, why don't you run with that a little bit? Well, I'm I don't know about basketball. This is news to me. Well, perhaps we should start there. Uh he was a high school basketball phenom in the state of West Virginia. Really? In his senior year in high school, he is put on a church, or it's not a church, excuse me, an all-star state basketball team that has Jerry West on it and Hot Rod Hunley, two of the most famous NBA personalities.

SPEAKER_00And uh Paul could have played on a major college basketball level, but he had already had a sense of call in his life to be consecrated to ministry. And so he goes from West Virginia down to Greenville, South Carolina and goes to Bob Jones University. And uh I have several memories of him playing basketball. One is before he uh resigned from ministry at second to take up the call as the director of Ridgehaven Ministry.

SPEAKER_00He called me one day and said, Is your brother Ligan and John going to be home over the holidays? And that's and I said, What do you what's going on? And he said, Well, I would like to play a two-on-two basketball game. And so me and Paul Settle took on Lig and John Duncan in two-on-two. You better believe me. At least that's the way I remember it. But just like his theology, he was classic. He he it was like watching something out of the 50s. You know, he had good form, perfect technique, uh, and and uh he he could hold his own.

SPEAKER_00He wasn't he didn't play dirty, I'll say that. But uh but he was just in every way he was a man in fool. Loved Paul Settle.

SPEAKER_01I think you play with Jerry West. I think Jerry West is the the He's the logo. He's the logo of the logo, yeah. Can you imagine? Paul Settle could have been the NBA logo. There you go.

SPEAKER_00We could have put that as our GPTA logo and Paul Settle Matcall.

SPEAKER_03If you ever look at this picture when he was coming into the Eighth General Assembly, he was an interesting dresser, too.

SPEAKER_00He had the plaid of his grandfather owned a habadashery concern in Charleston, West Virginia. And Paul was known for being a snappy dresser. And uh that, of course, that picture captures the the uh cataclysm of fashion in that area. I think that's probably the best way to put it. But he he was he was a well-groomed man, he would always looked really good. And uh uh but he was something that's excellent.

SPEAKER_03So that was um from I think 76 to 91. That's right. Yeah, he did he did some other things. He was um at the one of the first directors, I think, of Christian Ed in the PCA. The first director.

SPEAKER_00He was the first, and his wife founds women's ministry in the CCA, the women in the church ministry. Uh Paul had worked at Coral Ridge with D. James Kennedy. Uh Trinity Presbyterian. Trinity Pre the historic Trinity in Montgomery. And of course, towards the end of his ministry is when y'all get to know him at Park Cities, a flagship church in Texas. And through it all, Paul is quietly discipling men. He's teaching the standards to officers and sometimes other staff members.

SPEAKER_00And then he had this heart for men going into ministry. Wherever he went, he always had a group of young men. I remember at second, there was a group of a dozen college, post-college students. And everywhere he went, I heard there were groups like this where he was having them over for dinner, taking them out to eat, but talking to them about theology and the need to pursue God's call in ministry. And that was true at second. Um one of my brother Ligan's uh favorite pictures is that group when he was in college age in Greenville, that he was part of a group of men Paul was cultivating to pursue ministry.

SPEAKER_00And it was because of that that just about every PCA agency or committee at one point or another tried to get Paul to be their entity head because he just got it. Paul Paul got he understood the tension between local church ministry and the need to plug into the bigger church as well.

SPEAKER_02Yeah.

SPEAKER_00Well, and I I think a few other things, Dad.

SPEAKER_01I mean, he was not only did he lead uh Presbyterian Churchman United, he was the chairman of the steering committee that starts the PCA. Uh when he is, you know, the the eighth moderator of the PCA at that eighth general assembly. To me, in many ways, that that models what Paul was in so many ways, and that here he is, he's a moderator of the General Assembly, uh, he was a trusted voice, he's a leader, and yet by everybody's account, every single person that walked to the microphone, he called him by name.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. I mean, he just knew the PCA.

SPEAKER_02Yeah.

SPEAKER_01And he knew people, and he was a leader at the highest level in the denomination. You know, when the PCA, even before it was beginning, as he is leading Presbyterian Churchman United, I mean, he's going to presbyteries and to churches and meeting with all kinds of sessions and meeting with entire presbyteries and walking them through many of the errors that are happening in the PCUS and leading them through a lot of these discussions.

SPEAKER_00It actually goes back before the PCA. Paul was part of a group of seminary students at Old Columbia Seminary in Decatur, Georgia. And I've heard about this from different people. Morton Smith has told me about this group, Mr. Settle has told me about this group. But in the in the late 50s and 60s, there were conservative students at Old Columbia Seminary that were part of this discussion, that the old denomination was fading theologically. And uh Paul was part of a group of Columbia Seminary students, the James Kennedy was part of that group, that they would meet and pray and talk about the need to reform the church.

SPEAKER_01More PCA founding pastors were graduates of Columbia than any other institution.

SPEAKER_00A lot of people don't know that. And so that that group really for the next generation holds together and is a part of every PCA reforming impulse that's out there. Yeah, Paul is going around visiting churches. Um he's working with uh you know PCA future founders, uh, he's involved in writing and ministry. Uh he it it's it's remarkable. I mean, Jason, it kind of reminds me of you. It's remarkable how many different things he's doing all at the same time.

SPEAKER_00And uh Paul held that tension of life and ministry together. But I gotta say, I I think each of us will have a memory of Paul. Um he was just a very kind person. And you you had a sense, it's like you're talking to your grandfather that you could you could just sit down with him and say, I just don't understand this. And he could explain it to you, and he just made sense of God's word, but also of the world to you.

SPEAKER_00Agreed, agree.

SPEAKER_03So, did you know all of that when when you met uh Paul Settle? How did you meet Paul Settle and what was that like?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, so I will I only allow this out of the box. Jared and I share something in common that we kind of keep under wraps and try and not bring into the public view, but for the sake of the podcast, Jared, I feel like we probably should. But we are graduates of Dallas Theological Seminary. Yes. And uh while I was in Dallas, I was at Dallas Theological Seminary, and Paul was at that time associate pastor at Park City's Presbyterian, and he used to do a Westminster Confession of Faith study group for DTS students.

SPEAKER_01Wow. And so we would show up at his house on a Saturday morning, I don't know, maybe 7 a.m., 6 30 a.m. I can't remember, but Georgia would cook us a big breakfast, and then we would sit around and study the confession together. And uh, you know, it was it was just incredibly impactful. Uh I can remember a Saturday morning where there are two other DTS students, so there's three of us. Ed Clowney's in for a visit, so he's staying with the Settles.

SPEAKER_01And so it's Paul Settle, Ed Clowney, three DTS students walking through Romans 9 together. And uh it was just it was incredibly formidable times. And you know, I have no clue at the time who Paul Settle is, or I just know that he's an older man, he's a pastor, and he's willing to spend time with us. And uh he he was a man that was not only kind but he didn't have errors. Yeah, I mean just he humbly spent time with these 20-something year olds that knew nothing.

SPEAKER_01I knew nothing about the confession and uh grew incredibly over those years sitting with him.

SPEAKER_00We're recording this at a conference right now, and one of the talks at the conference was about a famous seminary professor who was rather imperial when he taught. You never got that with Paul Sutton. You you kind of you kind of wanted to be familiar with him because he he made you so comfortable. Um I I had that same kind of experience with Paul towards the end of his life. I went to him and said, you know, when you were my pastor, I I really was a boy, and I I would love to study the confession with you.

SPEAKER_00So the last few years of his life, we would meet once a week and just study the confession again. I love it. And uh it it was just it was just fun to talk to him about about those things. And he had taught it so many times he was really good at it.

SPEAKER_01He was great at it. So I had that benefit, and then RTS, so at the time, Westminster Dallas was starting there at Prague Cities. Right. And so though I had been through the confession a couple of times with Paul at this point, and we had gone through some books together, he and Sinclair were teaching the confession together as a class. And so I said, Well, can I please audit that? Yeah, so I sat in on that class and uh listened to two of them go back and forth on the confession, which was just oh, just a wonderful time.

SPEAKER_01But you know, the the humility of him, one of the stories is just you know, at the time I didn't think a lot of it, but since I've been a pastor, it just sits on my mind a lot. He sits on my shoulder a lot, Paul does. There are different people that sit on my shoulder, he's one of them. There was a time I can remember one of those Saturday mornings, I asked some question about um the uh about prayer and was asking uh Reverend Settle, I I I don't understand, you know, how how do my I know that my prayers are tainted, how are they, you know, acceptable before God?

SPEAKER_01And and then I also asked a question on baptism and was trying to sort through uh covenantal baptism at the time. And I don't know what his answers were, but what I remember is, and this is back in the time of answering machines, is that later that week there's a message on my answering machine when I come home to my apartment. And it's Reverend Settle, and he says, uh, in the voice, you know, say uh uh he said, Jason, I've been thinking about how I answered your questions on Saturday, and they weren't sufficient.

SPEAKER_01And he left like a five-minute message on my answer machine answering the questions. He said, I I needed more time to think about it, and here's how I would answer you now. So you know, an older pastor, you get this young whippersnapper seminarian, uh, you've given an answer, you move on. You he had so many people to pastor at a huge church like Park Cities, and yet he took the time to say, I that wasn't good enough under it. Oh, it's very well.

SPEAKER_03So what would you say then that you learn from him either as a mark of um you know, some people have marks of grace and holiness on them that you see that you say, I I wanna I wanna image that too, you know, kind of uh imitating me as I imitate Christ type things, um, or lessons that you just learned from him as a as a churchman or as a pastor, things that you you carry with you, um, anything else that you would want to uh put your finger on in that in that mold.

SPEAKER_01I think a couple that we've touched on. Uh one I always think about him, and that he reminds me of old Princeton, is what he's he reminds me of uh or did um is that he was willing to stand up for truth, uh he was willing to fight the good fight of faith, um, and he was willing to say hard things, and he did that in the course of his ministry, uh fighting for truth. And yet he was always a gentleman, and I've always appreciated that about Reverend Settle.

SPEAKER_01Uh the other is the humility uh tied to that. He was he was also he was just a shepherd and he truly loved people. Uh and then a couple of other things stick out in my mind about him is that one, uh he was such a churchman and he believed in laboring in the courts of the church, and he labored hard in them, but he didn't do so to the neglect of the pastor that he was in. Uh and that that's being a faithful Presbyterian in my mind.

SPEAKER_01Uh if you're a pastor, you you labor hard in the courts of the church, because we're Presbyterian, um, but you don't forsake your local church, and Reverend Settle did that well. One of the things I I I remember thinking again, young guy, uh you know, thought more highly of myself uh than I should I should have. And I remember sitting in some of his Sunday school classes at Park Cities and thinking, oh, some of these things are antiquated that he's doing.

SPEAKER_01Because what he would do, he was teaching seniors, and he would pass out tests, and he'd have him take a test. And I just thought, oh yeah, this is nuts. I mean, this is antiquated. What are you doing? Uh and it was brilliant, and it was good. Because he always he was so concerned about Christian discipleship and education, and hence why he was the first uh you know chairman of uh CDM, um what at that time was C E M P. But he he was willing to challenge people even in their 70s and 80s as he was pastoring them parking.

SPEAKER_01He's like, I'm gonna teach you, and then we get to the end of this, I'm testing you. And I loved that about him.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, I that's so good, Jason. I I you know that I guess what I would add to that is um you you could always count on Paul Saddle not only saying the right thing, but in the right way. And throughout his life he had to say hard things at different Times and um you know when it not not to go back to basketball again, but just like there are certain players you can just count on, you can count on Paul Settle in a certain situation, and uh so it it was not unusual uh that Paul would be asked to moderate not only Presbytery meetings that would be sensitive, but general assemblies.

SPEAKER_00After he moderated in the late 70s, uh he would frequently be asked to moderate General Assemblies in the 1980s because they just knew Paul would do a good job, and sometimes if there was a moderator that just needed to step away, Paul would be the one who would come in and moderate a meeting. Um Paul would say truthful things in hard ways, I or hard ways in truthful but effective ways.

SPEAKER_00I remember as a teenager, I asked him to write a reference for me. And he gave me a good reference, but it was a hard reference. And I remember reading that like a baseball player reads his scout, the scouting report, going, how did he know that about me? And it's because he knew me. And I I you know it hurt when I first read that reference, but I treasure that because I realized my pastor really knows some areas of my life that I need to do better in.

SPEAKER_00Um Paul was um he was just utterly uh without guile, and uh I I don't mean to make him into the perfect man, but he was one of the best men that I ever met in my life.

SPEAKER_03Yeah, I actually only knew really Paul Settle by reputation, except for meeting him once, uh, if you remember when you brought him to Twin Lakes when you're uh but I knew him by reputation through you, through people at the Park Cities, they were affected by his ministry. And one of the things I kept on hearing about was the way that he was not only a pastor, but he was uh a good husband. And um especially at at the end of his life and the or at the end of uh the life of his first wife. So I wonder if you both could tell a little bit about um that story about his um his first wife and uh and his uh role not just as a pastor and churchman but as a husband.

SPEAKER_00I'd be happy to start that. Uh I've been privileged to know both the first and the second Mrs. Paul Settle. Dear ladies, uh Georgia Brown Settle was just a godly woman and pastor's wife. I I can remember as a young boy sitting on her couch and talking to her about my problems, and she had a sympathizing tear and also made good uh pancakes for me, too, uh Jason. Um yeah, uh she she developed Alzheimer's.

SPEAKER_00Um and Paul was uh the model of a caring husband for her. I think that occurred uh kind of later in his time in Dallas, and uh Paul uh realized that the right thing to do would be to bring her back home to Greenville. Uh, and so he ended his life in ministry uh back in Greenville where he had pastored, and Georgia came home. He had some family in the area, and so it was just logical for him to do that.

SPEAKER_00But uh I remember both visiting uh the subtles in Dallas, but also being with them uh in Greenville, how he was just the picture of a faithful, godly husband caring for uh a person who no longer really remembered him. And uh it was astonishing how I had seen him in kind of a almost in a superhero way as you as you kind of view your boyhood pastor just watching him as a faithful husband caring for someone suffering from Alzheimer's.

SPEAKER_00And he did an amazing job with that.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, it was amazing to watch in Dallas, even as you saw her start to decline. And uh, you know, there were some of those mornings that we would get together, and she was already suffering some, and and and he would help to compensate for, and yet they kept doing ministry together as long as they could in that kind of way, uh, just investing in others. And that's even to go before that, you know, you think about Reverend Settle, uh, he has a huge impact on the PCA.

SPEAKER_01Georgia has an incredible impact upon women in the PCA for decades uh and will play a key role in women in the church in the PCA, will play a key role with many of the women's ministries that will develop out of CEP. And Paul Paul encouraged her in that regard and really set her free to use her gifts, and she became a trusted voice with women in the PCA.

SPEAKER_00And and uh yeah, it's really true. I mean, that you a lot of even women's leaders today are like the grandchildren of Georgia. So um, and uh yeah, Paul Paul was um by God's grace, uh he he ended well. He he was a good father uh to David and to Lynn and a good husband to Georgia. Later, uh, after Georgia goes to be with the Lord, uh he marries uh Mary uh Aiken Russell, uh who is a dear widow at Second Presbyterian Church, and uh they had a fruitful marriage in their latter years, and then the Lord calls Paul home.

SPEAKER_00And uh Paul was um at the end of his life was the men's ministry coordinator at Second Press. He had uh he had done so much. I mean, in addition to his pulpit ministry and his church ministry, he had been active on different boards that served the broader church. He was real active at Westminster Seminary. Uh Paul was a part of the board that kind of uh helps in the resurgence that's been going on at Westminster Seminary in recent years.

SPEAKER_00Loved Westminster Seminary. Uh you know, he had worked for the Presbyterian Guardian for World Magazine. Uh he had just done a lot of different things. Greenville Seminary. Greenville Seminary. He he's really the first entity head of Gringville Seminary. Um he was just really a very fruitful minister. And uh through it all, he had a lot of wonderful pastoral relationships. Yeah, I was here that year he came to Twin Lakes Fellowship, and that was a special memory as well to have him here.

SPEAKER_00Um but uh yeah, what a what a life well lived. Um I I would say to you, if you're looking for signs of Paul Settle, if you're listening to this podcast and you're trying to connect with the PCA, you'll see Paul in the gentlemanly uh comedy that we think of with the PCA. Uh Robert's rules, lightly followed, um uh always um courteous but uh but pointed like good debate is at two points of the sword.

SPEAKER_00Uh you'll you'll see that in the in the friendly polity of the PCA. Uh you'll also see a man who knew his theology, who knew history, and who would faithfully tell you what the letter of the law was. I think about Paul as a churchman. You know, there are times where we have to say the hard things to one another. Paul would say the hard things, and his his whole ministry, he he had to say hard things, but he said it in such a way that you were drawn to what he was saying, not in a way of dividing, but okay, Paul's trying to bring the church together.

SPEAKER_03Yeah, I kind of kind of noticed that in his 25th anniversary, because he wrote the history of the PCA, kind of coffee table type book. Right. Right. And one of he had some concerns about uh the PCA that you could tell if they came out through it, though it wasn't, you know, hit you over the head with it. Uh but one of them was uh partisanship. Um what do you think he would say about um the PCA today? I mean, he he saw the PCA well past its founding. Uh did he have any concerns about um whether it be the uh um the way that we debate or uh partisanship or any other things?

SPEAKER_03What were some of his concerns about the PCA after the founding of the direction that he was seeing it going?

SPEAKER_00I've had some of these conversations. You may have had some too, Jason. How would you answer that?

SPEAKER_01Well, I would say he was, I mean, he was concerned about different things that were happening to the PCA. I remember having some of those conversations with him, and uh he was he was always willing to press into those and have the conversations, and yet he always wanted to speak as a way that people they disagreed with would speak for themselves if they were in that conversation. Um one of the conversations that most sticks in my head that I had with Rev Massell, we were at an IHOP.

SPEAKER_01I can remember where we were at, and I can see us sitting in the booth. It's in Dallas. In Dallas, at an IHOP, having breakfast, and it was the federal vision days, and I'm getting ready to come into the PCA, and there is all kinds of debate, and the PPLN had just uh had just done some things as well, and I'm looking at the landscape and going, there's a lot of conflict. And I remember saying to Reverend Settle, Reverend Settle, um, how soon do you think the PCA is going to split?

SPEAKER_01And is this really worth devoting my life to this denomination kind of going in it? When's it going to split? And remember him again, that that deep voice he had, he, you know, he said, Jason, he said, as long as there are, and he he said somebody's name, as long as there are men like this, I'm not worried. And and I look back to that, and I and I've told this story before, but I I remember the when he said that, I thought, that's absolute nonsense.

SPEAKER_01Like you're putting your trust in men. And I thought, he he doesn't know what he's talking about. All these years later, you know, I look back and I think, I know exactly he's right in that men follow men. And in many ways, Paul experienced that because men followed him. And he knew that look, if you have some of these men of character and some of these men that are willing to stand strong when it's needed, and willing to be gracious and long-suffering when it's needed, and know and have wisdom when to weigh in, when to be patient.

SPEAKER_01You can keep these things together, but not only keep them together, but it can grow in faithfulness over time. And Paul to me is an example of that. And many of these founding fathers of the PC are examples to me of that. And that's one of the ways that he sits on my shoulder. And and I just think about some of those conversations we had, and even in that moment, what he was in essence advised me, saying, Look, Jason, that there are men like this. And it was also kind of a little nudge to me, Jason, be a man like that, you know, as he set that person before me.

SPEAKER_00Do you allow Lord of the Rings analogies on this podcast? It is allowed, yeah. Since since he brought this up, this is I think this will be apt. Um the the there's a wonderful moment in the story of the Lord of the Rings where a famous battle has occurred and a famous city is is lying and there are no gates, the gates have been knocked out. And there's a discussion about what do we do? Because we need to go back out to war, but we have a city without gates. And and one of the characters says to another character, men are better than gates.

SPEAKER_00And and what we're talking about is someone who was a man who was better than a gate. And and that's what Paul Settle was about. Paul Paul knew because Paul had to put it all on the line with other founding father godly men. And there came to be an esprit de corps and a trust amongst those men. And then you find this as you're a churchman, uh, maybe you're listening to this podcast ten years from now, and you feel like you're all alone because you're having to make an argument that no one wants to hear, but it's the right argument to make.

SPEAKER_00And you'll find in people like Paul Settle, you learn how to make a persuasive, godly argument over and over again, and you become a man who is the gate for the institution. And that's what Paul Settle was. Paul uh lived a full life, he loved the church, uh, he went wherever he was asked to go, and he and he made a compelling biblical argument, and then he trusted in the Lord. And then others of us came along and we saw Paul and we've we've tried to be like him in that way.

SPEAKER_03Yeah, I think it it speaks volumes in um you have the by faith uh article when he passed away, just of the the different people from you may identify them from different camps that all had something good to say uh and and were affected by him and the way that he conducted himself, which may lead to kind of a final reflection. If there are especially uh some people will listen to this podcast to get ready for their PCO exams, and so they they stumble on this, and they're a young uh elder or pastor uh getting started.

SPEAKER_03Um what what's their takeaways? What what can they learn? Because you know, you had um extensive interactions with them. I knew him by reputation and met him once. Um these are uh others will will never meet him. What what actually can they take away and say, here's a here's a lesson uh in a in a young officer or pastors uh starting off either from his life or character in ministry. What's something that they can take away from Paul Settle's ministry and life?

SPEAKER_00Well, I think it's what I would say is what you do on your podcast every time is that there are principles that are really more important than the actual color by dots that we sometimes approach with our polity. Is learn the principles of church government. Learn learn about ministering and declaring, learn learn about joint and several, learn, learn about the big ideas that unite the church together and then apply them fairly to the situation. That's what Paul was. I mean, a good churchman is a good umpire in a baseball game, and you you come to trust their judgment as they apply the rules fairly.

SPEAKER_01Uh you know, Paul believed that the church was worth laboring for, that she was worth loving and expending herself for. And uh and she is because Christ died for her. And so think about him, you know, I only knew him as an old man. Uh but you know, when he started a lot of these labors in a greater way within the PCUS, he's a very young, young man. Uh and you you take a lot of these men, you know, he and uh D.

SPEAKER_01James and Kendy Smart and a lot of these guys, they they looked up to someone like a Nelson Bell and they respected him and they were willing to follow him, and yet they were also men that labored hard in their own respect, uh, and were willing to put their shoulder to the plow uh because the church was worth it. Uh and so I I think that was a good balance a lot of those guys had uh where they were willing to respect the men that were older than them, that they believed were principled and holding on to things well, and they were also willing to throw in their weight uh and labor hard.

SPEAKER_01And so I'd say that to a young man uh is uh don't let them look down on you because of your youth, uh, and yet also be willing to give a listening ear to these these older men that uh that you respect and and believe are chasing after Christ hard.

SPEAKER_03What do you do you have any final thoughts or things you want to get in before we wrap up?

SPEAKER_00Uh you know, I'm I'm thinking of a conversation I had with him when he was coming under care, and I want to say it was the Presbytery of Orange. Now, I don't know what his first call would have been, but it would have been in North Carolina, Virginia, somewhere in West Virginia. Is it West Virginia? Okay. So well, I want to say it's a Chapel Hill area, because I think the Presbytery of Orange is around. Am I right on that or am I wrong on that?

SPEAKER_00Because I know he he grows up in West Virginia, but he's at his first Presbyterian meeting coming under care, and uh he's, you know, young Paul Settle, full of love and truth, and he's asked about the Virgin Bird. And someone says to him, Do you believe in the Virgin Bird? And Paul, I mean, this is the PCUS in the 1950s and 60s. He says, Yes, I do. And he says, someone laughed in the Presbyterian meeting. And another person gets up and says, Why on earth would we vote for someone who would believe that Jesus was actually born of a virgin?

SPEAKER_00And he said to me, he said, you know, it was kind of a good preparation for what he was going to do in his life, which is be involved with starting a new church. And he and he said to me, He said, You know, I've often thought about, you know, that person who was mocking, you know, they were mocking me. They were mocking me out of their own conviction, but their conviction was wrong. And I said to him, Well, how did you respond to that? And he said, I told the truth. I told the truth. And that's that's Paul Settle to me.

SPEAKER_00Love it. Yeah.

SPEAKER_03Everything else?

SPEAKER_01Well, the other thing maybe we haven't mentioned that that was true of him was he was a pastor of pastors. Uh it was no mistake that as the first I ever heard of, that maybe there were others in the PCA, but when I was in North Texas, you know, he enters into retirement. But the way he enters into retirement is they make him pastor at large of the presbytery. I remember that. In effect, bishop of the presbytery. And uh, but it fit him so well in that he always invested in pastors.

SPEAKER_01And uh he was not going to stop doing ministry, though he was still caring for Georgia, and he's retired. He was gonna be pastor at large and still help uh younger pastors sort through things. And um that that's that's how I will always think of Reverend Settle because he uh he shaped me greatly in that way, and a lot of his wisdom and really just his model, his model of ministry uh has impacted my entire life.

SPEAKER_03Well, thank you too very much for sharing some of your memories and thoughts about Paul Settle. Hopefully it'll make him more of an answer when people are asked. Uh, name a couple of founders of the PCA in their exams. Uh, but uh again, thank you for uh your time, Mel, Jason, and uh thank you, Jared.

SPEAKER_01Appreciate what you do. Uh very thankful for you.

SPEAKER_03Thank you.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. 150. You've Got to Come Visit

    Nov 17, 202642 minAudio

    Ben, Jared, and Scott are joined by Brad Voyles, president of Covenant College, as the RAO series continues through the agencies and committees of the General Assembly. Brad shares how he went from Bellhaven and RTS...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. 149. Two Keys on the Nuclear Submarine

    Nov 10, 202642 minAudio

    Jared and Scott are joined by Andrew Rein, coordinator of Reformed University Fellowship (RUF), as the RAO series continues through the agencies and committees of the General Assembly. Andrew shares how he came to RUF...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. 148. From Birthing Babies to Geriatric Care

    Nov 3, 202634 minAudio

    Ben, Jared, and Scott are joined by Steve Dowling, interim coordinator of Mission to North America (MNA), as the RAO series continues through the committees and agencies of the General Assembly. Steve marks one year in...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. 147. ProtoPresbytery

    Oct 27, 202643 minAudio

    Ben and Jared are joined by Lloyd Kim, coordinator of Mission to the World (MTW), as the RAO series continues through the committees and agencies of the General Assembly. Lloyd shares his path from Southern California...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. 146. Broker of Relationships and Resources

    Oct 20, 202643 minAudio

    Ben, Jared, and Scott are joined by Stephen Estock, coordinator of the PCA's Committee on Discipleship Ministries (CDM), as the RAO series continues through the permanent committees and agencies. Stephen shares his path...

    Credit the people on this episode