Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Polity Matters

Polity Matters artwork

144. You're the Umpire

Oct 6, 202653 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Jared Nelson and Scott Edburg are joined by Mel Duncan, moderator of the 53rd General Assembly, to walk through the first two chapters of the Rules of Assembly Operations. Chapter 1 covers calling the General Assembly to order, the opening sermon and exhortation, the stated clerk's enrollment report, and the election of the moderator, including nominating speeches, ballots, and clickers. Chapter 2 turns to the moderator's duties: presiding, inviting others to preside, calling the next assembly to order, and the floor privileges of former moderators. Mel describes the moderator as a servant of the assembly rather than its master. "You're the umpire," he says, and the job is to call balls and strikes. Along the way he talks about why a moderator has to know the docket, how much the stated clerk carries, the unwritten duties that come with the office (study committees and a committee for fasting and prayer among them), and the practical challenges of sound, lighting, microphones, and the kill switch. He also gets into a point of order and the clickers, and closes with gratitude for the PCA. Questions or comments? Reach out at politymattersfeedback@gmail.com. Send us Fan Mail Support the show Official Website: politymatters.org Support the Show: Buy Me a Coffee Twitter/X: @PolityMatters Facebook: Polity Matters Page Scott's Twitter Jared's Twitter Ben's Twitter

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_01Well, welcome to Polity Matters. Uh, my name is Jared Nelson, not Ben Ratliff. He is off today attending to his family while Scott and I have been given the keys, and so we're trying to hold down the fort. And we've just begun talking through the RAO rules of assembly operations. And there are several different things that are covered in this uh section of the binder that deal with different people and their different roles. And uh the very first two chapters deal a lot with things that the moderator does, and so we thought, what would be a better person to have on to help us with what the moderator does, other than the moder moderator?

SPEAKER_01So we have with us today Mel Duncan, the moderator of our previous General Assembly. So why don't you uh introduce yourself and uh tell us a little bit about how things are going for you, Mel?

SPEAKER_02Jared, Scott, so good to be with you. And of course, our prayers are with the Ratliff family. We're all praying for sweet Maggie these days and for her well-being and surgery. I am indeed Mel Duncan. I'm a ruling elder in Greenville, South Carolina, and was so privileged to be the servant of the 53rd General Assembly and serve the PCA as the moderator. I'm a uh child of the Second Presbyterian Church of Greenville and uh have served as a ruling elder here since 2002. I've been the State Clerk of Calvary Presbytery since 20 uh 15, 2016, uh, and have been active in the in the church essentially my whole life.

SPEAKER_02I'm I'm excited to be a part of this conversation. I love the RAO, as Dr. Roy Taylor loved to remind uh the highest court of the PCA, we are governed by a patchwork of rules in the PCA, and and the General Assembly is uniquely governed by the RAO, that middle part of the BCO, that colored section of uh pages within the uh BCO, those yellow pages, goldenrod colored pages.

SPEAKER_02And uh those rules are unique to the summer meeting of the church. And uh when when I was getting ready for GA, I spent my days uh reading those over and over again. Those rules uniquely prepare the church for the for the highest court at annual meeting. And so I'm looking forward to talking with you about the first few sections today, Jared and Scott.

SPEAKER_01Thanks. I do I'll just insert this. I remember beating you before you uh probably remember meeting me because uh I think it was my first General Assembly that I was telling guys, hey, we need to go, it's wrapping up. And they said, No, you have to stick around for the committee of thanks. And so uh, yeah, your role has changed. I'm I'm a little bit sad that you weren't uh the one doing that that, but uh I think uh I think the gentleman that you uh selected may uh step in and do a decent job.

SPEAKER_02I did my first thanks in Pittsburgh in your neck of the woods in 2003. My brother was the moderator that year, and I was paired with a legendary PCA churchman named Henry Lewis Smith, who's sort of a sort of out-of-central casting PCA elder statesman, an octogenarian type from from the deep south. And he was a real character and he knew everybody. And uh it when when I met him, he said, Mel, just sort of, you know, kind of go along for the ride.

SPEAKER_02I know what I'm doing here. And and he had a formula for these things, and uh he he liked to begin the resolution of things with a with a psalm that had some sort of a geographical connection to where we were in terms of the land. And then he liked to do a story about a PCA founding father that had some connection to where we were, and then he liked to have rhetorical flourishes in there, particularly if there was a founding father who had died, or there was a fun story connected to something going on in that assembly.

SPEAKER_02And then he would say to the partner he was working with, now you can do one paragraph in the middle, and you need to thank the host committee, make sure you thank the host committee, and then you can do something at the end and and then turn it in on time, and then he would leave. That would sort of be, you know, he was very dramatic. Uh, but I did about a dozen with Henry Lewis Smith before he died, and really enjoyed working on those and hope I get to do them again, though uh Cornstarch uh took over for me this year and uh might be hard to top him uh as well, but uh but I have enjoyed doing a few of those thanks resolutions over the years.

SPEAKER_01Yes. Well, speaking of uh some things that other people uh did this year actually, the beginning of Article I for the organization of a General Assembly's meeting in RAL uh talks about things that our previous moderator just did, and you'll get to do next year. It reads in Wad 1 the General Assembly shall be called to order at the designated time by the moderator and shall begin with a worship service, including its deeds in a prayer, a sermon or exhortation by the retiring moderator and celebration of the Lord's Supper. So we have uh here the very first things that happen at an assembly.

SPEAKER_01Things that uh Kevin DeYoung uh was over uh this year. Uh he gave a sermon. This does lead me to my first personal question here. Uh, do you think that you're gonna be doing a sermon or exhortation next year, or have you not decided? Since since you can have a substitute if you if uh you want to.

SPEAKER_02I have decided, but I'm not sure it would be proper for me to announce that or to reveal that on polity matters. I I I want to reserve the right to let the host committee to announce those things. But I I do know that the I mean one of the things that I've appreciated from having been behind the curtains as a member of a host committee when we hosted here in Greenville in 2013 is how much work is involved in preparing the worship service.

SPEAKER_02And I know we worked for three years ahead of time in in the elements of the worship service and which local churches would be involved on which night and and the choirs and the musicians. And, you know, we had to pull about a five different churches, communion service uh trays and things together to make it all work. And we practiced one day, uh, you know, getting everybody together. And we uh I I remember when my dad ran the uh the the General Assembly in Greenville in the in the early 70s, he actually went down to Memorial Auditorium and and they they he he he didn't think they were doing it quick enough.

SPEAKER_02And and so they they he got the timer out and and they practiced it because he thought they that there were multiple levels involved. It was a bigger arena. But yeah, uh my intention is uh I I don't want to reveal my intention on polity matters at this point. Let me just say that.

SPEAKER_01But you're hoping to break some news, but not for well I I'm I'm sorry.

SPEAKER_02I'm sorry, Jared, but uh but but you're right. The the RAO begins with the moderator and worship. And uh the it it it's interesting how the BCO and the RAO, the first thing that jumped out for me with our RAO one is how there's an organic unity between GA and Presbyteries. And the first thing that happens at a presbytery meeting is the first thing that happens at a GA, and that is worship. And we often at Calvary Presbytery, the first thing you hear at a Calvary Presbytery meeting is probably first thing you hear at your presbytery meeting, Jared, is we bang the gavel and we say the first order of business today is worship.

SPEAKER_02And that's what that's what you heard with Kevin DeYoung Tuesday night. And and so it was that uh he gaveled us in and then began the worship service hosted by the good folks in in the Ohio Valley Presbyterian.

SPEAKER_01Yes. And then the very next thing that happens is something that the moderator is not as involved in. One, two, uh the stated clerk shall present a report on the enrollment of the commissioners and declare if a quorum is present. If it is present, then the assembly shall be declared to be properly constituted for the transaction of business. So something of a uh a technical element here, but it is good to know whether or not you actually have a quorum if you can uh start business here. It was interesting to have uh John Bice uh doing that in his uh acting role. And uh so that was somebody who had been a moderator in the past.

SPEAKER_01I I am kind of interested how many of our clerks have been moderators in the past, haven't they?

SPEAKER_02Well, we've had Morton Smith, uh, who was a moderator and a clerk. Uh we've had John Bice now. Uh we'll we'll have uh Fred Greco now, who's who's been both a moderator and a clerk. Uh Roy Taylor's been a moderator and a clerk. Brian Chapel's been a moderator and a clerk. I don't think Paul Gilchrist was a was a moderator, but he was a clerk. So four of our five will have have done both both positions. Um you know, the stated clerk's official report is a little bit of a census, it's a little bit of a State of the Union, it's a little bit of a, you know, it it's almost like a presidential address, even though the Stated Clerk is not a CEO, but he does represent the denomination in a lot of formal ways.

SPEAKER_02Um so it's both a formal beginning of the meeting, but it also reminds us that in a in a previous generation, before we had polity matters, before we had uh the internet, before before we had newspapers, the Stated Clerks report was vital to just a basic understanding of what the church was. We didn't we didn't know a lot of the demographics, we didn't have a lot of the data, we didn't have the the resources, and so that report was vital to knowing really what the church was.

SPEAKER_02And so that was uh that was a vital part of understanding the who and the what of what the church was, the State of Clerk's report.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, and now we're we had a had a record attendance, no, I think wasn't this the largest assembly we've had.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, and and in terms of numbers of the largest ruling elders, and I know we didn't we didn't get to the the percentage in terms of of ratio, but you know, the uh one of the big stories is the resurgence in in both in overall attendance and and ruling elder participation, and you know, so much of that is is not just polity matters, but a lot of different populist endeavors to promote interest in the PCA. And um I think part of that is the PCA administrative committee.

SPEAKER_02I mean, Scott, you're a part of that, I'm a part of that. Jared is a is an important churchman in the PCA. People are talking about the work of the church, and that's promoting a general interest and involvement, and that in turn is promoting churches not only being involved, but giving and promoting, you know, helping people get to GA. So all of that is part of the the business of the Stated Clerks uh telling the story of the of the PCA.

SPEAKER_02And it let me just again take this opportunity to say John Bice is a gentleman of the first order. You know, we while it didn't happen in the the Stated Clerk's report later in the meeting during the Administrative Committee report, the PCA had a chance to thank John and Jane Bice and to celebrate them uh for what they did. You know, we've had some amazing ruling elders serve the church this year. Steve Dowling stepped up uh in his role as an interim. Uh John, as a provisional stated clerk, uh stepped up and in an unusual situation for the PCA served the church so well.

SPEAKER_02It was really neat. You if if you didn't know the difficulty the PCA's experienced in the last couple of years in leadership positions, it's it's run so smoothly by these men, uh you wouldn't know that there had been changes in transition. They've done such a good job with it.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, and the I think as the AC um called on John to serve as the provisional clerk, uh uh we we encouraged him that it'd be a part-time gig. And I don't think it was. He did so much more than we expected him to do and and serve so selflessly.

SPEAKER_02The second part-time interim position lasted 19 years, you know, that that kind of thing. And and you you know, it ended up being a lifetime for her. But um, yeah, yeah, such such with John. It ended up being a essentially a full-time commitment. And and it it's a full-time job. And and I mean the PCA is what is it? I think it's a billion-dollar organization now. I mean, it's the size of a small American state if you look at the the PCA and its totality, and the administrative committee is the tip of the spear.

SPEAKER_02And so John did a great job with that.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. The time of the uh for such a time as this ruling elders, I think of that uh with yourself doweling by some. So well, the this is the first uh point in which you had some experience uh in this past year. So I'm interested to get some of your thoughts on one three. Uh the first order of business shall be the election of a moderator. There shall be only one nominating speech, not to exceed five minutes for each nominee. No seconding speeches shall be permitted. So you have you've experienced this.

unknownYeah.

SPEAKER_01What's it like to sit there and and hear somebody talk about you for five minutes? Yeah.

SPEAKER_02Well, I've I've been on both sides of this. And and um, you know, I've uh four four years ago I was on the other side of one of these elections, and um and and and in God's kindness, I was on you know, the positive side of this election this year, and I I it it the Lord was kind to me this year, and honestly, the thought that went through my mind was the the the old saying that the Lord you know gives, the Lord takes away, blessed be the name of the Lord.

SPEAKER_02And um the the you know, in in the olden days, Jared, when these sorts of things were more deliberative and people were more uh inclined to to storytell, PCA nomination speeches used to be more theatrical. You know, the in in the 19 in the 1980s, I can remember going to PCA General Assemblies as a boy, and you would hear stories about men who, you know, they would tell you what uh cabin at Camp Alpine they stayed in, and and fellow PCA ministers they stayed up all night long keeping the campfire alive and and classmates at seminary and mission trips, and and it it it would be very long and and there would always be a reference to a dog, and and you know, there would just be there they would just be very long sentimental kind of things.

SPEAKER_02And and in and we're just we have a much shorter attention span nowadays, and so much so that we have a rule in the RAO that a a speech can only be a certain length, and and and and that's a good thing, I think, because we got a lot of work to do. I mean, as you know, this was the largest docket we've we've ever had in the PCA General Assembly. And I just want to say, as the moderator this year, I thought the PCA General General Assembly as a whole folks exercise remarkable self-control.

SPEAKER_02I mean, we got through before dinner on Thursday night. That's amazing considering how much we had on the docket to do. Um but y yeah, uh the the speeches it it's it's un uncomfortable, you you know, to hear those things and and uh but at the same time, um you know, my my pastor gave me my my nominating speech and that and that was the honor of a lifetime. I I love my pastor, and and to hear that from him is I mean, uh you you you hope you know it was the honor of a lifetime is the kind of thing you you imagine would be would be said at your funeral, and I got to hear while I was alive.

SPEAKER_02So so it was very it was very wonderful to hear some of those things. And I get my wife was able to be with me, so it was very special. So and and again, it was an honor to have been elected.

SPEAKER_01So yeah, my my one reservation though is I was there for the old style where they would say all these things about a person without saying their name, and the very last sentence would be, and so I would like to place a denomination the name of so and so. And I I kind of miss that old style.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, it it it was more it was a different world, you know. We we were just more familial and and but we've got to get to the business nowadays, Jared.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, what one final thing is I the OPC's General Assembly was in my backyard, so I got to go over there for opening day. And they do allow seconding speeches, which I thought was interesting. So there was another guy that gave up, came uh stood up and uh talked about the people that were nominated. So I I can imagine in an assembly of over 2,000 uh people, if anybody could get up and talk, uh that would that would not that would not help with for our business, no. Yeah.

SPEAKER_00Now what was your first uh thought when when you won that election? I I was holding my breath and I wasn't even up to be elected. So how how were those final moments with those slow votes and clickers? How did you work through that?

SPEAKER_02Well, when when the the numbers were going up on the screen, I was sitting by my wife, and the you remember it went over 2000, and when it went to 2005, my wife whispered to me that was the year that our first child was born. And she whispered to me Ford, which is the nickname of our first child. And then it went to 2006, and she that was the total number of votes, and she said Francis, and then it stopped at 2009, and 2010 is when our third and last child was born, and she said, Oh no, it stopped before Frank before Mary was born.

SPEAKER_02And and so that was actually kind of what was going on in my mind, and and and so I it's complicated, Scott. But but at that moment, Dr. Phillips, who always races to the conclusion before anybody else, immediately went, yes, yes. And and I realized, oh dear, I think I've won. So so it you know, when when that happens, you you have it's like being shot out of a cannon. You know, you you immediately have to gather your things and race to the forward and you know, be prepared to stand for three days and and lead a meeting.

SPEAKER_02And so uh I gathered my things and I I mistakenly I think I gathered like a suitcase worth of material. And so I I you know took about 50 pounds of material with me down in front of the hall and was trying not to be the quasimodo, you know, as I was walking forward with all of my material and it you know, not be dignified as I was, you know, trying to carry all this down. And and then you, you know, you hop up on the stage and ah, there's Kevin De Young and you shake his hand, and ah, there's John Vice and you shake his hand and ah, there's four thousand people looking at you, and and it's it's time to it's time to get going.

SPEAKER_02And and it's it's it's a little overwhelming and and it's it's also very sobering. You know, you're you're looking at the church and and you're also mindful that the the church is gathered to do the work of the Lord, and and so I said a quick prayer, Lord help me uh serve faithfully, and uh may I may I do the business that's been called to do to the best of my duty and and may your will be done in your name, amen, and and then get at it.

SPEAKER_02And it and it's helpful. I mean, Scott and Jared, you you've served uh with distinction in in presbytery meetings and in session meetings. Once you get into the familiar uh roles of a of a meeting, it it comes naturally. It took it took a few minutes, the sheer terror of it. But once the you got into the flow of it, it was not unlike a a presbytery meeting. There were just by a factor of you know several hundred uh it it was a normal meeting.

SPEAKER_02You you appoint people and then you get into the docket.

SPEAKER_01And and get over the echo.

unknownYeah.

SPEAKER_01There's a terrible echo.

SPEAKER_02Well, the the echo you don't ever really get over that, but you do adjust for it. And yeah, the first time you you speak in front of those, it it there's just a a resonance there that you just you have to you do have to just get used to it.

SPEAKER_01Well, one four actually has a detail about what we've been talking about, which is the the election process. It just says that if more than one commissioner is nominated, election shall be by ballot on ballots provided by the state of clerk. Tellers appointed by the stated clerk shall gather and count the ballots and report the tabulation to the stated clerk. If no nominee receives a majority of the votes cast, a second ballot shall be called on the two nominees who receive the highest number of votes on the first ballot. The moderator shall declare an election when a nominee receives a majority of the votes cast by the commissioners present in voting.

SPEAKER_01So I've been there where there's been just one nominee where there's been two. I I don't know if there's ever been three nominees before.

SPEAKER_02There have been two. I don't think there have ever been three. There have been multiple nominees. For the stated clerk, when Gilchrist was the stated clerk, I think there were four. But this actually brings up the Sparkman point of order later in the GA about is a a clicker a ballot? This would raise the issue of I don't want to jump ahead in in the in in the purpose of the program here, but yeah, I I think in in this issue the the clickers would solve uh RAO 14 for us there.

SPEAKER_02But uh that being said, the uh we while it took a long time to count, we did eventually get to the number.

SPEAKER_01Well then it just tells us at 1.5, as soon as the moderator shall have been declared elected, he shall assume his constitutional duties as moderator, which is Article 2, which gives not a whole lot of duties, and yet uh I don't think this spells them all out. That's why you're here for us. Uh two one says the moderator shall preside at all sessions of the assembly except when he may invite another commissioner to act temporarily as a presiding officer. Maybe you can help us with when might somebody want to do that. Why would somebody not want to be in the chair?

SPEAKER_02Well, uh this is actually something that I referenced on a program that we recorded last summer, I think, when we were talking about remembering Paul Settle. When Paul Settle was active in the PCA, particularly in the 1970s and 80s, Paul was a really gifted uh churchman and parliamentarian and had served as the moderator at the 6th General Assembly. And he would often be called to relieve the PCA moderator, particularly if it was a ruling elder who wasn't gifted at leading meetings in the late 70s and early 80s, simply to help him out, particularly when it would come to overtures or back in those days.

SPEAKER_02Remember, the PCA did the judicial things. We didn't have the the SJC. We we did those in the meetings. And remember, there were some gnarly GAs where we would do judicial items, you know, that we we would do midnight judicial things. And it was those were hard general assemblies in the in the 80s, uh, just dealing with judicial cases. And so oftentimes Paul would be tasked with just coming up out of the assembly and taking over the General Assembly and just helping.

SPEAKER_02And I I don't know if they had Paul in mind when they put this in here. I don't know the history of this, but it wouldn't surprise me at all if Dr. Smith or David Coffin wouldn't have thought about doing this because um I know for a fact that Paul Settle, four or five different times, significantly stood in at different General Assemblies as a moderator. And it it wouldn't surprise me if this might not be a Paul Settle clause that made it into the RAO.

SPEAKER_02So there there's there's a little historical anecdote for you from Uncle Mel.

SPEAKER_00Did you see the did you watch any of the SBC general conference this year?

SPEAKER_02Yeah, I did.

SPEAKER_00And they have they have like parliamentarians right behind the moderator.

SPEAKER_02Like literally whispering in the ear. Yeah. Yeah.

SPEAKER_00It's like, what do I do next? It's like, oh, okay, I gotta do that next.

SPEAKER_02Right. Right.

SPEAKER_00Just the the pride of being a Presbyterian.

SPEAKER_02It's it's so it's so true. I mean, it's literally the guys telling the guy word for word what what to do for sure.

SPEAKER_00Just comical because you could hear him whispering in the background and then he'd just repeat the exact same thing.

SPEAKER_02Right, right, right.

SPEAKER_01Well, uh 2-2 has a little bit more of uh what the moderator's duties shall be. So we read here the moderator shall call the succeeding assembly to order and preside over its sessions until a successor has been elected. Ordinarily, he shall present their retiring moderator's sermon or exhortation. If the moderator is unable to act, the stated clerk shall call the assembly to order and preside over its sessions until a moderator has been elected. Um I don't know if that's been a provision that's been needed if there was the previous moderator it passed in the previous p uh year or something. Yeah, but uh it's I guess it's there in case that's um Yeah.

SPEAKER_02You know, um Jared, I was thinking about this in anticipation of talking to you today along with Scott. The the moderator is a servant of the General Assembly, and in in so many ways, the servant clerk is a servant of the moderator. I I work as a as a clerk in a presbytery, and I always tell my moderator that my job is to serve you. And so when I meet with a moderator after he's been elected in Calvary Presbyteria, a moderator serves for a year.

SPEAKER_02I usually before the first meeting of the year take him out to lunch. And if he's never moderated before, I say, here's here's how you moderate. And I have a little kind of journal of here's what happens in a meeting, here are the seven kind of charges or proclamations or things you could do after a candidate's committee action, or you know, a licensure or an internship type thing, or here are some things that you just need to be prepared to read uh or to declare, or here is a type of prayer you might be asked to do.

SPEAKER_02Uh we have some kind of honorific things we do. We always open each meeting with the prayer by the oldest teaching elder, and we always close the meeting with a prayer by the oldest ruling elder by year of ordination within an APARC church present. And I keep a list of those handy and I try to figure that out before the meeting begins or ends. Um and so a stated clerk's job is to try to help the moderator do that. And in the same way, a moderator's job is to serve the court.

SPEAKER_02And to do that, you need to protect the right of every commissioner to be heard, and you need to protect the the rules to be followed uh in the meeting. And you know, at the end of the day, uh you're the umpire. People may not like the way you called the ball game, and that's fine. They they they have every right to boo and hiss you, and to say you are blind and you do not know the rules, and you are absolutely uh incompetent, and they may uh bless your heart all they will, uh and that's fine, but you're the umpire, and you've got to call balls and strikes, and you've got to decide whether the meeting is running too fast or too slow, uh, whether somebody is calling the the question too too much, or uh whether a matter is is being ground uh too much.

SPEAKER_02And um, and and so that means that the the moderator has to have a sense of the purpose of the meeting and the heart of it. And that means you've got to know the docket. You've got to really know the material. I I sort of intentionally told my presbytery that I really wanted to serve on overtures because I wanted to, I told my presbyter I wanted to be the moderator. And I said that because of that, I really wanted to serve on overtures. And because I wanted to see with my own eyes and hear with my own ears the debate, because I knew I was going to have to be calling overtures numbers and repeating the names of the overtures, and I needed to know where they came from, and I needed to know in my mind, okay, this was the argument, and this was the I needed to know such and such a person is the person who brought this argument, and I I sort of wanted to have a sense of that so that I could in a fair-handed manner kind of know where to go uh with that.

SPEAKER_02And and and so you're you're an air traffic controller, you're an umpire, uh, you're you're kind of uh, I mean, you're you just have to be a mater D. You you have to do all of these things. And you're it's also being a moderator in the PCA, Jared and Scott, it's it's also Easter Sunday. I mean, there's that level of craziness at the moderator's chair. There's a lot of activity, there, there, and there's just a lot of busyness up there.

SPEAKER_02And uh so you have to be very calm and you have to be very clear, and you have to uh because a lot of people are looking to you to explain what is happening. Uh there are a lot of people at a PCA General Assembly who've never been to a PCA General Assembly, and they need the moderator to explain to them what we are doing. And and so you've got to try to do all of those things at at the same time. And so the moderator uh needs to provide order. Um I would like to think that that I did I did my best to to do that.

SPEAKER_02You you've got to try to, you know, we've got uh you Jared, you may have observed this, we've got some colorful personalities in the PCA. And we we've got some brothers who really like to be heard. And they really, you know, they just they want to they want to be heard over and over again. And and we've got some brilliant people in the PCA. I mean, absolutely brilliant people. I I'm I never I I I I know our brothers in the OPC are more that reformed than us, and they're smarter than us, and they know more than we do.

SPEAKER_02But I'm I always come away from the PCA with wow, we have some amazingly just committed, brilliant uh churchmen in the PCA. I mean hundreds of them. And I I I think I think we we are well, I I you know, I I love the PCA. I I think we're the best church in in, I think we're the best reformed church ever. And I think we're getting better all the time. And I think you know, part of what's happening in the PCA General Assembly is that it's the place where the debates are are supposed to happen.

SPEAKER_02And I thought this year's General Assembly, with all the things going on, the the PCA exercised really good debate. You know, we we collectively decided that we were going to take 90-something overtures, reduce that down to like nine different categories, and then have debates in those categories. That was incredible self-control that we did that. And we trusted one another, and then we had good debates on that, vigorous debates.

SPEAKER_02We disagreed, uh, and we only had a few dissent, and that's fine. I mean, the the dissents are a BCO path for us to formally fuss at one another and to go on the record that you know, Scott has no idea what he's talking about, and I want to go on the record and say Scott is insane with his point of view, and that Jared is absolutely correct, and I want to sign my name to that. And and the book allows us to do that, and the whole world can see uh that my point of view is wrong or my point of view is right.

SPEAKER_02And and the it's the moderator's job to sort of keep everybody between the ditches in all of that. And so I think section two is the broad principle behind that. You are the servant of the tr of the court, you're not its master. Your job is to protect the right of the commissioner uh so that everybody plays by the rules. You're supposed to keep the assembly moving. And then the last thing I'd say is that the the gavel is a is a tool, use it well, hand it uh back at the end of the meeting, uh, and then give it to the to the next person.

SPEAKER_02If someone is listening to this, and I hope every PCA person is using Polity Matters as a tool. I hope you're a seminary student, you know, you're at Covenant, RTS, Westminster, Greenville, you know, whatever good seminary you're going to uh to to become a PCA or an Apart minister, and you're using this to learn your your BCO. I I hope one of the things you get from this is when you learn how the RAO works. So if you want to be a PCA moderator, pray about it.

SPEAKER_01Well, uh as we're looking at the end of uh Article 2, it actually may launch us to another question because 2 3 just ends with any former moderator attending the General Assembly shall have the privilege of the floor. So if you're not a commissioner and you're a former moderator or you went to another denomination, I suppose you still can have some privilege of the floor uh at the assembly. But there's nothing after that, which leads you to ask the question what are the unwritten uh duties of the moderator? You've you told us some of them, but some of them could come up like study reports. You got to appoint a study committee.

SPEAKER_01But are there any other elements of kind of the unwritten rules that we just tasked the moderator with without without writing it down?

SPEAKER_02So I've I've been asked so far to appoint a committee to answer a dissent to General Assembly that's come up. I appointed the study committee. Uh there was an overture that has called for a day of fasting and prayer, and I appointed two men to help us develop a statement on that. That actually should be going out. I think it either today or tomorrow or Monday, some advice to the presbyteries on how to do a good plan for fasting and prayer for the sake of revival in our churches and in our presbyteries and denomination.

SPEAKER_02Really look forwarding, look look forward to how that may uh bless the church. Um I think there's some some honorifics. Um there was a luncheon at GA with all the living moderators. That was kind of an interesting club to go into. Um there are some, I think some there's a cooperative ministries committee that I'll be privileged to chair this coming year and that I'll be a part of for the next six or seven years or so. Uh I think I'm already on the administrative committee, but I think I'm I'm a part of that for a while.

SPEAKER_02And then I get to be a part of next year's General Assembly, kicking that off and and and gaveling it in and and being a part of the selection of the next moderator. And of course, next year it'll be by custom, it'll be a teaching elder. So uh those are the things that I'm aware of, Jared. Uh that that there may be something uh that I I've not yet been told, but uh that that's what I'm looking forward to.

SPEAKER_01So of the other things that uh we could ask you, I I'm interested in a few of your your memories of uh last year's assembly. One would be what was your funniest moment uh that you were up front that you remember back and you just have to laugh?

SPEAKER_02Well, uh there were a number. I mean, I think leaving my brother at the mic uh comes comes to mind. Uh my my oldest brother was was wanting to speak in a matter and and I and the time had expired, and that that's gonna make for an interesting Thanksgiving, I'm quite sure. I I I think uh you know, the the the obviously clicker gate, I think is the story of Louisville. Um I I I think the the the people wandering around in the halls and the technology dilemmas was was was a challenge.

SPEAKER_02The the people in the back of the room trying to, you know, come to the mic and tell me how to figure things out. Some of the some of the technicians who came to speak to me uh couldn't speak the language well. And that was um that was kind of fun to you know, they were trying to tell me what to tell folks and I couldn't quite understand them. Scott, that's always kind of a fun thing, isn't it, when someone's trying to give you technical information and you can't understand exactly what they're telling you.

SPEAKER_00So the best the best part of that is that there are people giving you diverging technical information that doesn't agree with one another on how to fix the problem.

SPEAKER_02I I okay There was one fun moment on the stage, men, where I was asking my parliamentarians about a a matter that had been challenged, the chair had been challenged, and I think I had six men at one point, and two of the men said they weren't sure, and two of the men said one way, and two of the men said the other. And so I sort of had I sort of had to kind of go with my gut on a matter. But the the truth of the matter is that the the thrill of uh it was absolutely a blast to to be in front of the men.

SPEAKER_02I I loved every minute of it. People were so kind. You you have a sense of the PCA family and the body of Christ and uh just so many wonderful PCA people. I love the PCA family. Um it it was just a great week. Uh so many old uh you know, old PCA home week. I we gotta get the PCA uh polity uh matters ice cream thing going. We gotta make that happen. But uh it it it it was great. It was absolutely great.

SPEAKER_02And uh PCA administrative staff was terrific. Could couldn't have couldn't have been more pleased with the whole thing.

SPEAKER_00What was the hardest part about moderating?

SPEAKER_02The um the the sound is horrific. The light uh you you really can't see more than about the first hundred feet in front of you. Um the back row um of microphones you I really couldn't see. Um the Steve Dowling had told me this b ahead of time, but I had no idea how significant Matt Bradley would be. Matt keeps track of the folks at the microphone for you, and Matt was indispensable to to my work.

SPEAKER_02I I mean Matt was incredible in terms of the order of people at the microphone. And he was great. You know, they they put a a kill switch on the microphone. I think they called it the Fred switch after Fred Fred uh moderated one year. And you gotta get used to doing that. If you ever moderate, you gotta learn to do that because when you talk, otherwise everything you say will be heard by you know 3,000 people in the hall. And you've you've gotta learn you've gotta learn to be um careful about that.

SPEAKER_02Um But uh there were there was very little about it that was negative at all. There I had I had a sense from the moment I got up there that there were you know several dozen people either on the AC staff or the the clerks, the recording clerks, or the parliamentarians that were trying to help the moderator do do his job. And um you know, there was even a sweet lady from the AC staff who showed up with cookies one day. So I mean, how can you how can you not love that?

SPEAKER_00We talked about like the funniest parts for you.

SPEAKER_02What was the most encouraging parts that you'll look back to at the assembly um for the last year or two You know the the the Catholicity of the church I think comes to mind, Scott? I I think the the sense of the the PCA in places that I don't know about, the the missionary, the church planner. You know, I I know about the PCA in the Southeast, I know about the PCA on in R UM, but the the PCA churchman in in Canada or in Asia or the PCA churchman in a part of the United States has never had the reform faith, or or the missionary in a place that's never really had the reform faith.

SPEAKER_02That that PCA uh churchman inspires me. Um the the PCA faithful churchman who's finishing well, I I'm past the halfway point in life, and so you know, every day I'm mindful, Jared and Scott, of I just want to finish well, you know, and and you know, when I you know, Scott, when I see a Randy Thompson, my my I I get amazed by him. Uh when when I see some of those older uh brothers in the Lord, I'm I'm inspired by them.

SPEAKER_02Uh I love those men. And I also am mindful that I'm not gonna have that many more years with them, and so I want to soak up life with them when I'm around them. I got a little misty-eyed. You know, we had a PCA founding father pass away during the opening night of GA, and and and that kind of made me uh have a little taste of heaven. You know, I I have some folks in the PCA General Assembly that I profoundly disagree with on, you know, a host of issues.

SPEAKER_02And when you can find a way to work with them, uh, and you can just take a moment and thank the Lord that, you know, Lord, thank you that we can find some common ground on some things. And it reminds you that, you know, even in these areas where we just profoundly see things differently, the Lord is at work. So that those things encourage me a lot. I I have a uh just a profound sense of gratitude because I I love the history of the PCA.

SPEAKER_02The the PCA is is when you look at our founders. I know we've talked about this on Polity Matters before, but theologically we are so much more reformed, soteriologically, we're we're just so much better than our founder, and and I'm grateful. We got a long way to go. Uh we've got to do a lot better of practicing the polity that y'all are trying to teach us. And we've got to make our polity more you know more a part of who we are and not just theoretical.

SPEAKER_02But I like the direction we're going in.

SPEAKER_00I was thinking of when we were talking about the middle part of chapter two in the RAO on having to call balls and strikes. Perhaps your your work was more of that than typical because of the clickers. Was it hard to try to even, especially during like the nominating report, to discern who actually won those votes? And how how how how is that received? You know, you're the guy that has to call the ball or strike, and perhaps that's the most divisive part, having to do that without a clicker.

SPEAKER_00And so how is how is that hour for you up there?

SPEAKER_02You know, Scott, I but that's always the most divisive moment in the week, isn't it? It it's a because we all love our friends and we've gone to school with these folks, or we've been in Presbytery with these folks, and and a lot of times just the people we know we assume are best, and and so it becomes very personal and and we become irrationally committed to our friends winning. And so all I can tell you is that I just did my very best to listen to to hear who won.

SPEAKER_02And I I think people uh trusted the judgment calls that were made. I mean, there were several times where uh objectively uh to me people just lost and I and I just said, look, I heard somebody win or lose, call division. If and and I and I what I like to do is just invite people to call division because that's the best way to resolve something. And we just we just knew that that nominating report, which should have taken 15 minutes, was going to take all morning.

SPEAKER_02And it just was uh it was ordained to be that kind of a day, and we got through it. And um, you know, I wonder looking back on if God wasn't m giving us that long of a morning to prepare us to be self-controlled during the overchurge report later on, because we just had to come to realize that we're not gonna be able to to do this during the overchurch report because we're gonna have a long we're gonna have clicker gate coming up and we're just not gonna be able to do this.

SPEAKER_02And you know, Howie and Steve had done such good work preparing the the plan, and Guy Waters had done such a good job preparing the plan for first for for RPR and then for overture that um I I think the the assembly was well served with that. Um but with with nominations, I think what's happening in the the the PCA is more interested in and is more involved, and so we're just going to have you know tightly contested elections.

SPEAKER_02And that means we're just gonna have to be very patient and it's just gonna take longer to do that. And um, I mean, Scott, you and I are on the AC. We've just got to get better technology before Milwaukee next year, right? That that's the answer to all of that, right?

SPEAKER_00That that is the answer. It's almost like the sun stood still for us with all of those hard reports. That's the closest thing I could think of how we were able to cut through the RPR report this year and and the overtures committee report, which allowed us to really take time on a matter that, yeah, takes 15 minutes, but to fourfold that, and we were still able to get done by by dinner time. It's the Lord was kind to us.

SPEAKER_02Scott, I'm gonna go back at the the my favorite moment of assembly, I think, was the RPR report when we were talking about the Eastern Canada matter with communion, the the the citation of the church that had had communion served to folks who were not in the worship service who got communion. Do you remember that matter? And there were people complaining about that, and a man stood up and said, You remember?

SPEAKER_02I I am the man, and I accept this citation and I don't have any problem with it. And I uh to me is a little bit more complex than that, but it was basically just saying, I I'm guilty, my church is the offending party, we accept that, and we don't want y'all to debate about it, just we're guilty as charged, and we're gonna fix. And now I I know it's much more complicated than that, but just accept the story and go along with it.

SPEAKER_02Um I it it was just so it's just such a godly thing that that commissioner did, and it was just such a wonderfully Christian response. And it it was it was just a wonderful way to to see a commissioner and a churchman respond to that. And it and it was a picture of how the RPR process actually went so well this year. I I if you ask me what I was probably most nervous about as moderator was RPR, because y'all know that RPR, unlike the rest of General Assembly, is under simply Roberts' rules.

SPEAKER_02And you you can almost have anything happen in in RPR in a way that really can't happen under overtures or under the other denominational reports, because you can you can amend and you can do all kinds of crazy, you know, parlor room tricks in RPR in a way that you can't in overtures. You can really only do a few things in the rest of GR. And so I was really worried about a lot of you know zany things happening in RPR when in truth, because of Steve Tipton's good chairmanship, it was really this one of the smoother parts of GE.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, I think that'll be the gold standard for how to handle the report overall moving forward. And the the RPR committee over the last couple of years has really embraced the use of technology to try to streamline some of their internal work. And I think this year we got to see some of that on the floor itself and how it's streamlined our our debate together. And so, yeah, uh I was completely surprised. Sometimes it's really open to dealing with um some of the issues and referring things back. Other times the assembly trusts RPR.

SPEAKER_00It it's always a surprise on how the assembly will field some of the discussion um concerning their report.

SPEAKER_01Well, after uh what I think was a surprisingly smooth GA considering what happened, you can't uh choose uh where you're gonna be called on in terms of uh what sort of uh events are gonna happen during the assembly. But I think I texted you this at some point afterwards that it seemed like you uh were uh put there for such a time as this. The humor and the gentleness I think helped diffuse what could have been a lot of tensions. I think that's something that other moderators need to remember and look back to is how to de-escalate rather than escalate uh a situation. Um is there any final uh words or final thoughts that you wanted to have before we wrap up?

SPEAKER_02So grateful for what you guys are doing. Uh grateful to be PCA, honor the lifetime, appreciate everybody, and uh I guess I would say uh I hope one day my son gets to do what I have been able to do my whole life, which is be a ruling elder in the PCA.

SPEAKER_01Well, it's it's great to see when a a whole family has a uh commitment to being good churchmen. As some may know, both you and your brother were moderators, and uh was it actually not the first time that happened? Uh, Mark and Joel Bells both were were moderators. And uh Joel, I believe, passed away in the past uh year or two. Yeah, sure. Founder of of uh World Magazine. World Magazine, yeah. Yeah. I guess what I'll have to say to end this out is as the Bills uh brothers uh would say, uh this podcast is over. We're thankful for the time that you spent with us, uh Mel and talking about some of these things and helping us to understand it.

SPEAKER_01You can see all the uh our listeners can see the notes, uh show notes, and follow anything that you want to look at. Uh other than that, you can say goodbye, gentlemen. Goodbye. Thanks.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. 150. You've Got to Come Visit

    Nov 17, 202642 minAudio

    Ben, Jared, and Scott are joined by Brad Voyles, president of Covenant College, as the RAO series continues through the agencies and committees of the General Assembly. Brad shares how he went from Bellhaven and RTS...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. 149. Two Keys on the Nuclear Submarine

    Nov 10, 202642 minAudio

    Jared and Scott are joined by Andrew Rein, coordinator of Reformed University Fellowship (RUF), as the RAO series continues through the agencies and committees of the General Assembly. Andrew shares how he came to RUF...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. 148. From Birthing Babies to Geriatric Care

    Nov 3, 202634 minAudio

    Ben, Jared, and Scott are joined by Steve Dowling, interim coordinator of Mission to North America (MNA), as the RAO series continues through the committees and agencies of the General Assembly. Steve marks one year in...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. 147. ProtoPresbytery

    Oct 27, 202643 minAudio

    Ben and Jared are joined by Lloyd Kim, coordinator of Mission to the World (MTW), as the RAO series continues through the committees and agencies of the General Assembly. Lloyd shares his path from Southern California...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. 146. Broker of Relationships and Resources

    Oct 20, 202643 minAudio

    Ben, Jared, and Scott are joined by Stephen Estock, coordinator of the PCA's Committee on Discipleship Ministries (CDM), as the RAO series continues through the permanent committees and agencies. Stephen shares his path...

    Credit the people on this episode