Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Polity Matters

Polity Matters artwork

102. We Do Have a Time Limit (BCO 43)

Sep 23, 202553 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Jared and Scott are joined by Art Sartorius to discuss Complaints. Send us Fan Mail Support the show Official Website: politymatters.org Support the Show: Buy Me a Coffee Twitter/X: @PolityMatters Facebook: Polity Matters Page Scott's Twitter Jared's Twitter Ben's Twitter

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_00Well, welcome to Polity Matters. Uh, Ben is out today, and so uh I'm gonna be attempting to lead this uh discussion on chapter 43 of the BCAO on complaints. Uh but we do have some help uh that is with us, uh a man named Art Sartorius, and I wanted to ask you if you can uh introduce yourself and why we might have asked you, uh maybe even getting into a little bit of your uh various uh questionable uh vocations uh in the past. Uh so who do we have joining us, uh Scott and me today?

SPEAKER_01This is Art Sartorius, as you said, and um I was described by you as being help. I'm not so sure if that's an accurate description, um, but I am a PCA teaching elder out in Rapid City, South Dakota, so the uttermost parts of the world. And um I uh have been a teaching elder uh I guess since 2008. Before that, I was a ruling elder.

SPEAKER_01Um, and when I was a ruling elder, I had been a lawyer. So uh that's sort of my background. Um the topic we deal with, complaints, I guess uh my experience with complaints began pretty early on once I became a teaching elder. I think it was um the first meeting I attended as a presbyter here in the Siouxlands Presbytery.

SPEAKER_01Uh a man was asked to be investigated regarding his views, and then uh right after that motion was made, complaints started arising. Um, and through that whole process, there were several complaints along the line. Um, since that time, things have settled down. Um, and I am now a member of the SJC, so I now see complaints from the other side too.

SPEAKER_01Um, so that's who I am. That's some of my background. I hope it's helpful.

SPEAKER_00Yes. And uh, did you have some training as a journalist too?

SPEAKER_01Well, I have a degree in journalism. Um I worked on a local small paper for about a year, and it wasn't long after that that I went to law school. So not much of a career as a journalist.

SPEAKER_03Are you gonna try selling used cars anytime soon, Art?

SPEAKER_01No, but I did just buy a used car. Would you like to buy it?

SPEAKER_03Yes, yes. So we get the trifecta of most beloved career paths.

unknownThat's right. That's right.

SPEAKER_00All right. Well, we're gonna just launch into complaints. We've already uh covered uh to some degree appeals and uh the other chapters leading up to 43. So we're just gonna have you help us a little bit uh on this chapter. We can uh make some comments too. Scott and I have at least read this chapter at some point in our lives. Um, but we're starting off with the definition of it here in 43.1, and this may take a lot of our time. Uh, this is where Ramsey and Smith actually have some things to say. Uh, but 43-1 uh reads as follows: A complaint is a written representation made against some act or decision of a court of the church.

SPEAKER_00It is the right of any commuting member of the church in good standing to make complaint against any action of a court to whose jurisdiction he is subject, except that no complaint is allowable in a judicial case uh after process has commenced. Uh if at any time uh after the process has commenced uh BCO 431 complaint is timely filed, uh the court's adjudication shall be delayed until after the judicial case has been completed, or if an appeal is filed after it has been fully adjudicated or withdrawn.

SPEAKER_00During judicial process, the accused may raise BCO 3214 objections on a variety of matters, and the original court shall uh decide each. Those decisions could be reviewable on appeal. Um so perhaps our first question is going to be appeals seem to narrowly deal with um judicial matters. Uh what does a complaint uh deal with? What is subject to complaint?

SPEAKER_01Well, uh really the the subject matter of complaints is extremely wide, and I would even say it can include uh at times things that could be subject to appeal as well. So, for example, if a um if a person has been accused, he's gone through judicial process, he's been found guilty, um it could even be possible, perhaps, that another member of his church or another member of a presbytery could complain against the guilty verdict if he doesn't appeal it himself, if the appeal has been done, which most likely would happen if it's going to go that far.

SPEAKER_01You don't see that, but you do see instances where someone has been acquitted and members of the court will then complain against the acquittal. So that could be it. Um we've dealt with things on the SGC uh in which you have uh uh you're actually dealing with a matter which what has been complained about is the moderator's ruling on a point of order that is then upheld or not upheld by the by the presbytery.

SPEAKER_01So it could be as limited as that. You can even start imagining things, and you know, if a conceivably if a church decided we want to have a church picnic on a certain day, someone could complain with against that because that is decided by an act or decision of the session. Um again, those aren't things you normally would see, hopefully you wouldn't see, but uh but it could be pretty broad.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, I mean, an act or decision seems to entail almost anything that the church court is doing. Um but uh also thinking about if somebody is dealing with this in a church court, if somebody's listening to this because they're dealing with a complaint, what's the basis of a complaint? It seems like something unbiblical has happened um against the standards, uh, but is there a limiting factor? I mean, can you just say I I don't, you know, you decided on this carpet color, you don't realize that it it contrasted poorly with the pulpit, and so I'm going to complain.

SPEAKER_00Um, is there any limiting factor on the basis for doing a complaint?

SPEAKER_01Well I I would say if you're looking at the language there at the beginning, there's not really too much limiting there as far as that concern. There is there are limitations. Um the person has to be a communing member of a church, he has to be in good standing in the church, uh, he has to be under the subject, under the jurisdiction of the church, uh the either the church court or the presbytery, uh, which then that that is probably the single most limiting factor you have.

SPEAKER_01Um when you start thinking about who's under the jurisdiction of a court, well, that would mean as members of a presbytery, you really can't complain against decisions of another presbytery because you're not directly under that court's jurisdiction. The the other matter um I think becomes a little more complicated because when you read that first language, a complaint. Well, well, let me the second sentence of that, the first paragraph there, it is the right of any community member.

SPEAKER_01That sounds extremely broad. Uh, and yet when you start thinking about jurisdiction, the the rulings that have come out of the SJC have have limited jurisdiction, so that, for example, if I'm a member of a church, I can't make a direct uh complaint against the action of a presbytery because the I'm not directly under their jurisdiction. Although they are making decisions that affect my church, um, I don't have a direct right uh to appeal.

SPEAKER_01That that's based on the various decisions of the the SJC in the past. Someone could still challenge that, but but um but that's generally what it would be. Let me give you an example. If if um the presbytery um license someone to preach within the bounds of the presbytery, that affects the local church. But a person in the local church, uh a person who's not an officer, uh just a member of the church, would not have that direct uh line of appeal to um, or a rather complaint to complain against the licensure.

SPEAKER_00Scott, do you have something?

SPEAKER_03Yeah, I was as I was reading, as you read this, Jared, this is actually a newly minted paragraph. It's been doubled in size by the last GA as it relates to that second part that you read on uh interlocutory appeals, that is, uh complaints in the midst of appeal processes. And one thing that our last assembly decided it would be prudent is instead of allowing complaints to be handled in the midst of judicial process, that they're kind of set aside until the process is complete and then taken up uh together.

SPEAKER_03And I think the at least if I recall, the rationale for adding this uh paragraph into 43.1 was the abuse of complaints as it relates to judicial process, where an accused might complain about every little action that the court does in order to slow down the trial itself and span it out for, you know, it could be up to years, um, as we've seen in some cases. And so this is meant to perhaps expedite as we can in Presbyterianism, expedite uh uh appeals and complaints by almost setting them aside for a time until the appeal is completed and all process is concluded.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, I'd I'd also encourage anybody if you can get onto the BCO historical site or get a copy of Morton Smith's commentary. He has a lot of qualifications on here, the differences between appeals and complaints. Um, and some of those limiting factors are interesting uh during a judicial process if you're not subject to it. Um there's also an interesting uh uh inquiry that came into CCB at one point, and it was a question about congregational meetings, because those are not a technically a court of the church.

SPEAKER_00Well, uh the response was you can't really complain against a congregational meeting, but you can complain against the session about whether or not they should have had that congregational meeting, whether they should have put that uh question before uh the congregation and how they acted uh in response to whatever uh they heard from the congregational meeting. So, in a sense, you can't complain against your congregational meeting, but you can complain against the session um that made it. So, anything else we need to say about uh 43.1?

SPEAKER_01I I just might follow up uh in regard to that point. Um one thing that happened in some recent now completed SJC cases, uh there was uh a uh congregational meeting in which men were elected to church office, ruling elders or deacons, um that uh action was complained against.

SPEAKER_01And as you said, uh because the congregational meeting is not an action of a court, uh that was uh there the complaint was denied. But then when those officers were um were installed, it was the act of installing them that became subject to complaint, and that complaint was heard.

SPEAKER_00One other question, I don't know if you'll know the answer to this. Uh it made me wonder, especially with our distinctions between assistant, uh associate, and senior pastor. Um, can any of the teaching elders complain against an action of the session? Since in some ways they're not under its jurisdiction, but they might be a member of session, or they might not be as an assistant.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, well, um you know, ruling, I would I would think I'm trying to imagine a situation. Uh the ruling elders, of course, are members of the church, so they could uh complain against the action of a session, I would think, yes. What about the teaching elders? Teaching elders are members of the presbytery, so they don't have a right to complain against the actions of the the session. All right.

SPEAKER_00Well, moving on then to the it seems like the rest of the chapter really is defining things uh from there. Um so uh 43-2 is going to and 43-3 really are going to get into timing uh and some of those details. So let me just read 43-2 and see what uh we have to say on this. Uh a complaint shall first be made uh to the court whose act or decision is alleged to be in error. Written notice of complaint with supporting reasons shall be filed with a clerk of the court within 60 days following the meeting of the court.

SPEAKER_00The court shall consider the complaint at its next stated meeting or at a called meeting prior to its next stated meeting, provided that the complaint has been filed with the clerk at least 10 days uh in advance. Uh, if the complaint is filed with less than 10 days' notice, the court may consider the complaint at a later meeting, not more than 60 days later. No attempt should be made to circularize the court uh to which complaint is being made by either party. Uh so what are we getting here?

SPEAKER_00Why why is the complaint first made to the court whose act or decision uh somebody has a problem with?

SPEAKER_01Well, I I think that's one of the best sections, that's one of the best portions of the complaint, because what you're you're doing is giving a court a chance to correct an error if they thought they made an error. Um it's it's a gracious thing to do, to just say, hey, I think you you did something wrong here. They can rethink it and they can correct their own error, uh, recognizing that courts can err. And so that's that's a um that's a marvelous provision.

SPEAKER_01I think that's that's wonderful that the the uh session or a presbytery gives that is given that opportunity becore before a case is moved to the presbytery or the uh general assembly. Give them an opportunity to correct the wrong if you think they've made her wrong. Doesn't mean they always think they made her wrong, but yeah.

SPEAKER_00But it does cut down on paperwork if the court just says, oops, sorry, or if the the complaintant is then convinced by more reasoning. Yeah. We do have a time limit, 60 days. Um feels like this is a bit arbitrary. You kind of have to pick a date if you're not gonna say you can complain about something that happened five, ten, fifteen years ago. Um so there is a time limit uh that's there, and then you have to meet um after that complaint has been noticed. So maybe your timing of filing a complaint would be so that you don't have to have another called meeting, but you're either gonna have to have a called meeting or a stated meeting, and then you have to reconsider basically what you did in the previous um uh the previous time together.

SPEAKER_00So some of those are making sure that you're in that um that window uh there. Um but the ending of that is interesting. Uh I don't know if you can give us some help on what it means. Uh no attempt should be made to circularize the court to which the complaint is being made by either party. What does that mean?

SPEAKER_01Um let me say first, since I am a member of the SJC, that I'm not making any statements with any view toward a pending or impending case on the SJC. Um and I probably, even as I say that, probably won't answer this maybe as directly as I might personally feel. Um, but um but the idea of circularization, I I actually first even explored that when I was uh first dealing with filing a complaint and was trying to figure out well, what in the world does circularizing mean?

SPEAKER_01And you know, if you look at various definitions, sometimes there's been a um one definition could be going around, which almost seems like, oh, you're trying to go to the next higher court as opposed to having it before the court you should be. Um but the general uh proposition as it's developed over the years is that you're not circularizing as if you're sending circulars to members of a court to persuade them how they should vote before the members are um are gathered together to vote on the matter.

SPEAKER_01Um and you can see how that happens. Um, you know, if if if I want to file a complaint, yeah, I might be inclined without this rule to go to other presbyters and just say, hey, I think this has merit. I want you to consider it. Will you please join me in this? Will you vote the way I I like? Would you like to hear more arguments on it? And um and the uh sentiment is is no, you shouldn't be able to do that.

SPEAKER_01Um I would say that there have been some past cases that deal with the idea of this isn't really meant to hinder individual presbyteries, presbyters rather, from having small conversations with others in their presbytery, or you could think of it on a church session as well, other elders, um just a few conversations about what this is all about, what we ought to be thinking about, what we should do.

SPEAKER_01Uh, I think the the most interesting part of the section though that says, do not, you should not make attempts to circularize, is it says at the end it's not to be done by either party. Well, if you think about who are the parties, and I'll focus in on the question of a presbytery, who are the parties to that? One of the parties is, of course, the complainant or plural complainants.

SPEAKER_01The other one would be the presbytery. How does a court circularize itself? So, and that's a question I don't want to try to answer for you all. Um, but but that's it's an interesting question, at least in my mind.

SPEAKER_03Yeah, we talked a little we we talked a little about circularization last week with Dr. Waters, and it it's interesting how in my experience in Presbytery, it's the definition is somewhat fluid. It's like a a scary word. We want to avoid circularization, and sometimes it's even said on the floor of Presbytery, like at a meeting, you can circularize yourself on the debate floor, but that's not really the context. Like you're not circularizing your your yourself by debating an issue, it's what goes on outside of the meeting and how parties conduct themselves on any given issue, whether it be something small like where we're holding our retreat for our youth camp, you know.

SPEAKER_03Oh, well, one caucus wants it here, another one wants it there. Uh, but it's outside of the meeting where you're trying to garner support caucusing for a position before you ever have the debate.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, because you have to talk to some people, uh, probably even within your presbytery. If something happened, you're probably going to call up somebody and be like, hey, do you think this is worth? A complaint, and if I did that, would you join me on it? Um, if there's more than one complaint and he's talked to somebody, so that can't be circularizing. Uh, so we're we're thinking this is probably like caucusing or campaigning, we're trying to have the argument before everybody in the presbytery um can can hear it.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. All right, can we go on to part three and try to figure out more on timing? The dates. That's that's the most fun part of the BCO, right? The the timing. Um 43-3. If after considering a complaint, the court alleged to be delinquent or in error is of the opinion that it has not erred and denies the complaint, the complaint uh may take that complaint to the next higher court. If the lower court fails to consider the complaint against it or at its next stated meeting, provided that the complaint has been filed with the clerk within at least 10 days in advance, uh, the complaint uh may take that complaint to the next higher court.

SPEAKER_00If the complaint is filed with uh less than 10 days notice, the court may consider the complaint at the later meeting, not more than 60 days later. Written notice thereof shall be filed with both the clerk of the lower court and the clerk of the higher court within 30 days of notification of the last court's decision. Uh notification of the last court's decision shall be deemed to have occurred on the day of the mailing, if certified, registered, or express mail of a National Postal Service or any private service where verifying receipt is utilized, the day of hand delivery, or the day of confirmed receipt in the case of email or facsimile.

SPEAKER_00Furthermore, compliance with such requirements shall be deemed to have been fulfilled if a party cannot be located after diligent inquiry or if a party refuses to accept uh delivery. Um so notification. Um this is I almost want to use the the language of appeal to the next higher court, but this technically is an appeal. You're just taking your complaint to a higher court if um you don't like what the the lower court said or the lower court brushes you off, refuses to hear it, something along those lines.

SPEAKER_00Is that is that fair to say what this is saying to us?

SPEAKER_01Yes, it's it's it it is whatever it is elevating to the next higher court. Um the the changes that have been made to this over the years. Um I'll just go back again to a time when I first filed a complaint. Um I always uh filed the complaints using uh Federal Express next day delivery because you didn't have specifications like does it count as being delivered when you put it in the mailbox?

SPEAKER_01When it's received, how is that? And so it was just a way that it would confirm that it was received, would confirm that it was mailed by a certain time. You had all of that done. Uh, here you've you've actually put that in, and I think if I remember right, when these were um first being considered of matters of deeming giving notification that the the words United States Postal Service were used.

SPEAKER_01And someone from Canada wisely said, Do you remember you have Canadian people in the PCA as well? And and so um, you know, so the language has been uh changed. Um the other thing that that's that I think is sort of interesting in in this is that you have the idea of notification of the last court's decision shall be deemed to have occurred on the day of mailing.

SPEAKER_01Well, it could be um to it could be that there's actual notice given, you know, in instead of even communicating by mail or email or any of the things that are given. It could be just here it is, here's my complaint, given by hand. Um the last court's decision is is is terminology that when do you get the last court's decision also?

SPEAKER_01Um there have been times when courts have adjudicated things and for what they deem to be prudent reasons reasons decide not to give notification of their decision immediately. They want to talk to lawyers, they want to do other things, they they withhold it for a time. So um it it's that idea of actually giving the notification of the decision is an important factor.

SPEAKER_03It seems so sorry. Yeah, it seems like a no-brainer until you start thinking about the details, and that's kind of church process in general. It seems really simple, and then you start thinking of the details, and like time frames, and they're very important. All the time frames are uh excruciating uh when it when you're doing a trial, and the BCO doesn't always give you specifics, uh, but here it does, and uh you wouldn't think about it until you have to actually send out your complaint.

SPEAKER_03When does it matter? Uh you know, and so it this is helpful, though it may seem really simple and you know, like a no-brainer, it's helpful to have these clarifications.

unknownYes.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, and another clarification is there in four, because if you remember on appeals, an appeal in in many aspects suspends what had been the action of the court. Well, this specifies something a little different. Uh, 434 for a complaint. Notice of complaint uh shall not have the effect of suspending the action against which the complaint is made, unless one third of the members present when the action was taken shall vote for its suspension until the final decision in the higher court.

SPEAKER_00So this is saying if there's a decision and you're complaining against it, it doesn't mean that that decision isn't going to go through unless you get one-third of the people that were there to vote for it. I I do have them in my mind when would that one-third vote to suspend that action? Uh would it be as the complaint is being considered? If you have a notice of complaint at that meeting, maybe a third would say, okay, let's suspend this until we hear the complaint. Um that would be the only detail that I has a question mark in my mind there.

SPEAKER_01Um it also might be interesting to note that some decisions can be made by commission as opposed to uh the full court um is the one-third one-third of the commission. Um I mean, those those are probably not common things. I don't recall ever seeing something like that come up. Um but potentially you could have something like that.

SPEAKER_00Anything else we need to straighten out on four? Otherwise, you can go to five, which really gets into the details of how the complaint is actually argued. Uh 34 or 43 uh five, the court against which complaint is made shall appoint one or more representatives to defend its action before the higher court, and the parties in the case shall be known as complaintant and respondent. The complaintant himself may present his complaint, or he may obtain the assistance of a communing member of the church of the Presbyterian Church in America who is in good standing in presenting his complaint.

SPEAKER_00So the the court um when a higher court is considering this, it's not as if the entire church and session have to show up to Presbytery when this goes to a higher level. You can have um one representative of one side, one representative of another side uh that comes in and presents um anything else that we need to know about this uh provision here.

SPEAKER_01I think it's um one this has been another section that's been changed a little bit where it it broadens the representation of who you could get. It's not just someone from your church, someone from your presbytery. It can be anyone in the PCA. So it's a benefit there to uh to potential complainants to seek help from out from other sources and representation.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. While you don't want um it to be too far and for there to be some sort of class of lawyers, no offense to lawyers, uh, that arises in the PCA. Um you do want somebody to not fail in something just because they didn't know the process or didn't know the rules. And so uh clerks have this uh job too, to be informing everybody involved of what comes next, what their rights are. All right, 436. It shall be the duty of the clerk of the lower court to file with the presbytery of the higher court or the clerk of the higher court, uh, not more than 30 days after the receipt of notice of complaint, a copy of all its proceedings in connection with the complaint, including the notice of complaint and supporting reasons, uh, the response of the lower court, if any, and any papers bearing on the complaint.

SPEAKER_00If the clerk of the lower court shall neglect to send up the proceedings on the complaint, uh he shall receive a proper rebuke from the higher court, and the act or decision complained against shall be suspended until the proceedings are produced so that the higher court can fairly consider the complaint. So make sure you have your paperwork uh in order. Um, but a couple questions may arise from this. First of all, what is a proper rebuke?

SPEAKER_01I've seen a rebuke that that's arisen from this. And it, you know, it's I mean, it's it it is an expression of dissatisfaction that the deadlines haven't been made. And, you know, pretty strong language. You need to get your ship in order and get it taken care of. I haven't seen it go much further than that, though.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. But this is another provision in which an action might be suspended. Um, and perhaps that is in there just so that a lower court can't run out the clock of just noncompliance and we'll just let this action happen and then you can't do anything about it later. Because I've seen decisions from the SJC that, in a sense, uh at a certain point to say there's really nothing that can be done, even if they had done something wrong, because the action is now passed. Um, so this prevents a lower court from trying to just make sure the action happens so that it can't be corrected.

SPEAKER_01And and there well, I would just say there's nothing, there's nothing wrong with a clerk contacting a higher court and saying, I'm having trouble getting these things all to all together. I'd I'd like, I'm not gonna make the deadline. I've I'm striving to get this done and think I'll have it done by then. And then the proper rebuke might not come at all. You know, it's and I think that's a worthwhile thing. Uh again, I'll use my Presbytery as an example. Um say a complaint arises out of an acquittal in a in a judicial case.

SPEAKER_01Um that means that you have to have a full transcript of the trial. And the rules um that require you to have a transcript, when you have the trial, you only have to have it recorded. So you can have an instance where you need to have a recorded um um testimony, all of the testimony then transcribed. And when you're working from a recording, that can be a more difficult thing.

SPEAKER_01And um uh so sometimes it takes some time. And and I have seen a case like that where the SJC was very um very kind and just said, we understand it takes a while to get that done. We we won't have the hearing when we wanted to have it. We'll delay it till a little later time.

SPEAKER_00All right. A few more parameters are going to be given to us in 43.7, including the concept of abandoning a complaint here. Uh there it reads, uh the complaint shall be considered to have abandoned his complaint if he fails to appear before the higher court in person or by counsel for a hearing thereof uh after he has been properly notified. But a complainant may uh waive in writing his right to appear with permission of the court and not be considered to have abandoned his case.

SPEAKER_00In the case of such failure to appear, the judgment of the lower court will stand unless the complainant uh gives to the court a prompt and satisfactory explanation. So if you're going to complain, uh make sure that you're willing to see it out. Um, I do think uh there's some other ways in which people will have been considered to have abandoned their complaint, such as if they resign from church membership or leave the church or leave the presbytery, which could be um probably more often, which is maybe why you would want to have more than one person on a complaint if you're gonna complain something and you may not be there to see it through to get another person or two with you to say if we all think this is wrong, then can you be on it in case one of us uh isn't here in a year or or whenever it's gonna be decided?

SPEAKER_00So anything else we need to say about 30 or 437?

SPEAKER_01There again, I it doesn't compel the complaint to appear either. He can waive his right, he just needs to do it in writing, and then the higher court will make their decision based upon one side arguing and whatever's been submitted in writing, the complaint itself or the a brief.

SPEAKER_03Do you often see complaints abandoned at the SJC?

SPEAKER_01Um there have been. Um you have to understand, I'm my tenure on the SJC has not been decades like some of the other men who are on the uh on the SJC, so I I might not have um uh the best memory of those times that it's happened. Um you you you have I have seen it though, and you've also had the the times that uh Jared was talking about when um someone might um leave the membership of the PCA and the matter will be um be deemed abandoned.

SPEAKER_03Yeah, we were talking with Guy Waters last week about appeals and has similar language in the abandonment of an appeal. And you just think of how much work it takes to do some of this. And so I would just I would think that it's quite rare for someone to abandon an appeal with all the work they might put into it, uh, unless they just left all together.

SPEAKER_00Well, uh next provision may not have a whole lot of commentary with it, but uh we we can read it and see what it talks about in timing uh 438, subject to the provisions below. After the higher court has decided that the notice filed with the clerk was timely and that the complaint is otherwise in order for it to be heard by the higher court, it shall hear the complaint or in accordance with the provision of BCO4 uh 15.2 and 15.3, appoint a commission to do so. Ordinarily, the court or its commission shall schedule a hearing uh in a manner that reasonably accommodates the schedules of the representative parties and affords each party a prior opportunity to file a written uh brief upon such terms and in accordance with a briefing schedule established by the court or its commission in the reasonable exercise of its discretion.

SPEAKER_00Um I don't know if there's a whole lot to say about this other than they schedule a time in which is convenient for everybody to make the complaint for them to hear it.

SPEAKER_01Correct. And and most of these now, at least on the SJC level, are done uh virtually. Um they're done, they're done by Zoom or similar uh mechanisms that allow us to see each other and do that. They used to be done where you would actually be traveling to a location where everyone who is serving um in the SJC, it's a panel that normally hears, normally hears it and then presents it to the whole of the SJC. But um, but that was um that that's pretty much ended.

SPEAKER_01There have been a few that still happen that way, but but now it's usually all electronic.

unknownRight.

SPEAKER_00And then what does it actually look like is in 43.9, um, which is a little more interesting, uh, at the hearing, uh, after all the papers bearing on the complaint have been read, the complaint and the respondent will be given the opportunity to present argument, the complaint then having the right of opening and closing the argument. After the hearing has been concluded, the court or the commission should go into closed session and discuss and consider the merits of the complaint. Uh the vote shall be then or later be taken as to what disposition should be made of the complaint, and the complaintant and respondent notified of the court's decision.

SPEAKER_00Um I've I've seen a few of these in Presbyterian. Sometimes it'll even look almost formal, like uh you may see a minority report at General Assembly. Almost seems like that. One person goes up and presents, another person does. Um, and then there might be some structure in between that the um trying to figure out how much time does each side get. Uh is there time for questions in between and then closing arguments. So that's what it would look like in uh in that court. Uh anything else to say on that, um, such as the nature of closed session or anything like that?

SPEAKER_01Well, closed session is just the the members of the court or the the members. It's it's like executive session, but not exactly the same. But you but it's just the members of that are hearing it, the members of a commission that are hearing it, um that that are meeting at that time to make their their deliberate do their deliberations and make their decision.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, executive session, you can't talk about what was said there, but closed session, you may be able to talk about the arguments, even if you're not attributing it to a particular person, right? Yes, correct.

SPEAKER_03Would there be any reason to reject uh complaint out of order? Outside of maybe the time frame stuff.

SPEAKER_01Um well time frame is the most common one, of course. Um there I I guess my my answer to the question to answer directly is yes. And then if I try to give you examples, I might uh not come up with any right away. But um but uh yeah, I mean, I mean there have been there have been things where like it could be apparent in the record of the case that someone has filed a complaint, but they're not a member of the church anymore.

SPEAKER_01They've they've left the denomination. There can be things like that. Um so that would be one I can think of. But there are circumstances that, yeah, you would rule it out of order. I that's the one that comes to mind, other than timing.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. And it doesn't specify when notification happens, but hopefully it is timely. Um 4310, uh to finish off, uh the higher court has power in its discretion to annul the whole or any part of the action of a lower court against which complaint has been made, or to send the matter back to the lower court with instructions for a new hearing. If the higher court rules a lower court error by not indicting someone, the lower court refers the matter back to the higher court uh, or and the lower court refers the matter back to the higher court.

SPEAKER_00It shall accept a reference uh if it is a doctrinal case or a case of public scandal. Um maybe this reminds us that actually a complaint doesn't mean that there's a whole new trial if it's a judicial matter or something like that. Um often uh it seems like higher courts are just directing the lower courts to do a trial or you should have done a trial and you didn't, uh something along those lines. Um I think the the SJC has only really done like one trial or a couple of trials in its entire history. Um so usually the higher court isn't doing that on appeal from a lower court.

SPEAKER_00Is that right?

SPEAKER_01Um usually not. Um, and I think the the as far as trials are concerned, the SJC really doesn't want to do that for good reasons because you have um you you have a better uh group to judge matters when they're closer to the facts that are involved. And so and so in a Trial situation, you won't uh normally see the SJC wanting to get involved. Um, I think what's interesting about 4310, though, when it comes to um what it says the higher court can do to annul the whole or part of the action of the lower court or send the matter back to the lower court with instructions for a new hearing.

SPEAKER_01And um there's there could be issues that arise as to does the higher court say the general assembly or presbytery dealing with the session, do they go too far if they're doing anything other than annulling the past decision or giving instructions for a new hearing? Like if they give instructions and basically say this is what you need to do, rather than say just have a new hearing, are they overstepping their bounds?

SPEAKER_01And um, so that would be a question. Again, it's not something that I think comes up very often, but there are reasons why you might not. I mean, as far as as annulling a decision, I think uh Jared, you had mentioned earlier something like with the passage of time, the matter becomes moot. Uh so you know you're annulling a past action in which the time is past has made the issue that was dealt with moot.

SPEAKER_01Why would you uh really annul the past action? You would just say it's no longer uh relevant. Um you wouldn't ask them to have a new hearing on something that can't be undone. Uh so it's just it the there could be questions there on what the higher court can do, or do they have some inherent power to do something beyond just annulling the whole or ordering a new hearing?

SPEAKER_01And I I think the the last line, if I'm getting ahead of myself, forgive me, but the last uh sentence of 4310 is interesting too. If the higher court rules a lower court erred by not indict someone, and the lower court refers the matter back to the higher court, it shall accept, that is, the higher court shall accept the reference if it's a doctrinal case or a case of public scandal.

SPEAKER_01And um there again, I'll just speaking from the perspective of the SJC, the SJC trying a case, and again, complaints can lead to retrials of cases. Um that's not something that uh the SJC is well equipped to do. You you if you're gonna have a trial before the whole panel, you either have to take or the whole of the SJC, you have to take the whole of the SJC to the area where the case uh has all the facts and witnesses, or you have to bring all the witnesses to the SJC, which would probably be in Atlanta.

SPEAKER_01So you're bringing in people from all over the place. And even with a panel, you're doing the same thing. You're it's a smaller group, but you're there's a lot of expense involved. And so the mindset, I think, of most on the SJC is we don't want to, we don't want to say somebody's erred by not indicting someone, but then again, you have to understand that that shouldn't govern whether you rule the complaint or not. Um you know, it just might weigh heavier on your mind.

SPEAKER_01What can we do other than then um then send it back and say you failed by not indicting, you know? Uh that could go in the mind. I hope it's not going on in too many minds, but it could.

SPEAKER_03Yeah, it kind of reminds me um just a few years ago with the Heron trial and just all that was included in it and the cumbersome nature of having everyone having a panel be flown out to Indianapolis and to spend the better part of a week conducting it, and then you all on the SJC just received basically the report. And it's like, how do you how can you really even, even if there were a minority on the SJC being so remote and removed, you almost just have to trust the panel as they sat there and waded through all of the uh evidence and testimonies and all of that.

SPEAKER_03And so I can see why the SJC, I mean, just the it's a financial burden, it's uh difficult in actually dealing with the information. There's a lot of hoops you have to jump through when considering trials at the highest court make it difficult.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, and and not even getting into uh what's the definition of a doctrinal case and public scandal, and we're talking to somebody that there was a long conversation about how do we even define what that is. So yeah. Well, anything else that we need to say about complaints? Somebody might be listening to this just because they're a clerk in a presbytery or a session and they're they're having to handle a complaint or somebody's thinking about filing one. Um, what should we keep in mind?

SPEAKER_01I think um I think there's two things just to be thinking about. One, at least as as far as matters coming up to the General Assembly, the SJC as the commission of the General Assembly, I would say complaints are the the most frequent matter we get. Um it's not uncommon for complaints to be dismissed because of time and things like that.

SPEAKER_01So you you really need, if you're considering a complaint, you need to know the rules and um and pay attention to the the time. And and if you don't know, if you feel uncomfortable with what you're reading, you get help. Um, you know, even if you call uh an SJC member, the SJC member will say, I'm not gonna talk to you about this, but there are other people that have served on the SJC in the past. Here are a few names, maybe they'll help you a little bit with it.

SPEAKER_01And and um, you know, just try to have all your ducks in a row. Know what you're why you're complaining, what you're you're wanting. Uh, I think it's wise to make sure it's an important matter. Um you know, like I like we were saying, theoretically you could complain over the color chosen for a church sanctuary. Um, but um, you know, those aren't things that are um that are worthy of of the time of dealing with, I think, in in the advancement of the gospel of Christ.

SPEAKER_01So maybe you should leave a few things alone. Um, but anyway, I would read the rules, try to understand the rules.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, I think everybody will have to uh have some sort of uh a struggling in their own hearts and even prayers over submission to the brethren, but then also uh the glory of God and uh when to file a complaint. And so um finding some pastoral advice on that I think would also be good just before something like that happens. Uh well any any final thoughts, Scott or Art?

SPEAKER_01I I don't have anything to add on.

SPEAKER_00Scott?

SPEAKER_03No, nothing. All right, all right.

SPEAKER_00Well, um first uh Art, uh it's always a delight to see you, and uh it's even more of a delight whenever I see you at GA and I see your wife, who is uh probably has the most infectious smile I've ever seen. So be sure to say hi to her and um yeah. And um, well, I guess as Ben would say, if he was here, uh this podcast is over. Uh you can look into our uh our notes to see some of the uh notes from this episode. I don't think there will be much of any uh other than looking up some references in Smith who were in uh um in Ramsey.

SPEAKER_00Uh but um that that's all we have for uh now. So you can say goodbye, gentlemen. Good to Bobby.

SPEAKER_01Goodbye, thank you very much.

SPEAKER_00Yes.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Hosts

  • Ben Ratliff Co-host Feed-stated
  • Jared Nelson Co-host Feed-stated
  • Scott Edburg Co-host Feed-stated

Guests

  • Art Sartorius Guest Feed-stated

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. 150. You've Got to Come Visit

    Nov 17, 202642 minAudio

    Ben, Jared, and Scott are joined by Brad Voyles, president of Covenant College, as the RAO series continues through the agencies and committees of the General Assembly. Brad shares how he went from Bellhaven and RTS...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. 149. Two Keys on the Nuclear Submarine

    Nov 10, 202642 minAudio

    Jared and Scott are joined by Andrew Rein, coordinator of Reformed University Fellowship (RUF), as the RAO series continues through the agencies and committees of the General Assembly. Andrew shares how he came to RUF...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. 148. From Birthing Babies to Geriatric Care

    Nov 3, 202634 minAudio

    Ben, Jared, and Scott are joined by Steve Dowling, interim coordinator of Mission to North America (MNA), as the RAO series continues through the committees and agencies of the General Assembly. Steve marks one year in...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. 147. ProtoPresbytery

    Oct 27, 202643 minAudio

    Ben and Jared are joined by Lloyd Kim, coordinator of Mission to the World (MTW), as the RAO series continues through the committees and agencies of the General Assembly. Lloyd shares his path from Southern California...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. 146. Broker of Relationships and Resources

    Oct 20, 202643 minAudio

    Ben, Jared, and Scott are joined by Stephen Estock, coordinator of the PCA's Committee on Discipleship Ministries (CDM), as the RAO series continues through the permanent committees and agencies. Stephen shares his path...

    Credit the people on this episode