Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Polity Matters

Polity Matters artwork

90. Revisiting RPR

Jun 23, 20251 hr 9 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Our AI substitute wasn't able to record an episode, so it seem like it generated an introduction with NotebookLM and then aired our RPR Deep Dive from last year. Enjoy. Send us Fan Mail Support the show Official Website: politymatters.org Support the Show: Buy Me a Coffee Twitter/X: @PolityMatters Facebook: Polity Matters Page Scott's Twitter Jared's Twitter Ben's Twitter

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_04And the background here is King. The usual host. They were off of the PCO General Assembly. That's their very annual church meeting.

SPEAKER_06So basically, they couldn't record a new show.

SPEAKER_04Exactly.

SPEAKER_06And this is where it gets, well, pretty unusual. Quality Matters announced their next deep dive would be hosted by an AI.

SPEAKER_04But not in the way you might think.

SPEAKER_06No, not at all. The AI actually uh admitted something quite candidly. It said, and this is a quote, it did not have the ability to generate content nearly as good as theirs.

SPEAKER_04Think about that. An AI recognizing its own limitations in quality compared to humans.

SPEAKER_06It's sort of self-aware in a way.

SPEAKER_04Well, it highlights a big challenge for current AI, doesn't it? These systems are great with patterns, with data. Sure. With that deep, nuanced understanding.

SPEAKER_06It's not quite there yet.

SPEAKER_04Not yet. There's a gap between just processing information and truly understanding the meaning, the humanity behind it.

SPEAKER_06So faced with this limitation, what did the AI do? The one designed to generate content.

SPEAKER_04It didn't try to fake it.

SPEAKER_06It didn't force it.

SPEAKER_04Its solution was simpler.

SPEAKER_06Yeah, it just replayed an old episode, one the humans had made back on May 31st, 2024.

SPEAKER_04And you have to hear the title of that replayed episode. It was called Sausage and a Bible and Probably a Cask of Wine.

SPEAKER_03Hello, and welcome to Polity Matters. My name is Ben Ratliff, and I'm joined by Jared Nelson, and also joined by the new stated clerk of Ileana Presbytery, uh, the uh right Reverend Scott Edberg. Welcome, gentlemen. Glad to have you all. Hey, hello. Scott, how do you feel?

SPEAKER_02I feel like a new man. Things that I've dreamed for a very long time are finally realized. I get to move paper around. More paper. I'm just so excited to move more paper around because it's uh a hobby of mine. So uh, but no, I look forward to to serving. Uh we we have some work to do in Ileana, and I'm hoping that um I can help uh the Presbytery and its organization.

SPEAKER_03I think we're gonna have to do a bonus episode where I interview you about all of your new uh task-oriented uh apps and things that you're putting to use uh in your new role. Um we could have Jared on there too, but he's just gonna talk about post-it notes the whole time. So I don't know.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, I'm starting to realize that um if I don't schedule my time, I'm pretty organized with um like spreadsheets, but if I don't schedule my time, I tend to waste my time. Um and so I'm trying to get better habits.

SPEAKER_03Well, you guys know that we've been walking through the General Assembly schedule in order to give newcomers an impression of the whole week and hopefully to give a good refresher to all of those who are the veterans out there. We've uh worked through a lot of the GA docket so far. Um we started on Monday and we've kind of been progressing through, but now we're gonna back up a little bit and zoom in um on two particular uh committee reports that take place, one on Wednesday morning and one on Thursday morning. And you've heard us mention them plenty of times in passing. Now you're actually gonna finally learn about what they are.

SPEAKER_03Uh what we often call RPR or the Review of Presbytery Records, and what we'll often call Nomcom or the Nominations Committee. And to help us out in our discussion today, we are happy to welcome back friend of the show, Steve Tipton. Steve, welcome. Thanks for helping us out today. Uh make things clear.

SPEAKER_00Thank you. Yeah, glad to be here.

SPEAKER_03Uh Steve is uh some kind of expert on RPR. Uh, I'm I actually can't remember the connection that that you have to it. I'm sure you've served on it at some point, but you've got lots of good thoughts for us. And Jared's uh this year serving as the uh chairman of the nominations committee, and so he'll he'll help us understand what's going on with that report. And so our plan of attack uh today is just to work through the basics of RPR and then do the same thing with nomcom. And so I'm really just going to sort of hand it over to Steve and let him begin to explain to us what is Review of Presbytery Records, what's the significance of it, uh, the background, why is it something we should pay attention to?

SPEAKER_03And maybe me and my buddies will just jump in and offer, you know, questions, commentary, useless nonsense whenever we think it seems appropriate.

SPEAKER_00Look forward to the useless nonsense, thank you. Uh-huh. Always uh so speaking of useless nonsense, no, um, yeah, first just uh again, thanks for having me on. Uh, thanks for doing this uh the series. Um, I was thinking about you know, my first General Assembly uh all the way back and Virginia Beach, uh 2011, no, 10, I guess. Um whatever it was. But anyway, just uh thinking back to really being lost a lot of the times. Uh, you know, had some good guys around me that were able to point me in the right direction, but it can be overwhelming and you know bewildering and all the rest.

SPEAKER_00So happy to talk about RPR. Um I uh was going back through the my participation on that August body and uh started RPR in 2011. Um I was um uh taking a spot for somebody who uh was serving in the midst of their three-year term and was not able to make a meeting, and so I went as an alternate and just kept going back uh from 2011 through 2022, 12 times in a row um on RPR.

SPEAKER_00And then I'm going again this summer as the representative for uh Gulf Coast. So that'll make 13 times before too much longer. Uh more than most have served on that committee, but uh I hope fewer than than some. Um so in addition to just uh being on the committee that time, uh I've been a vice chair uh several times and then chaired the committee uh in 2018, and so uh pretty well versed in what it is and what it does. Um I wanted just to start off though with just a little bit of background to what the review and control is that uh RPR seeks to undertake on behalf of the assembly.

SPEAKER_00Uh, just I'm gonna kind of run through a number of BCO references. I'll give the reference so if somebody wants to look it up in more detail. Um, but really, in one sense, it starts in uh BCO15 with the description that uh all ecclesial jurisdiction is joint in power, uh, that we exercise that power not severally but jointly. And then as well, alongside of that, 10.1, which says that the this jurisdiction is exercised by presbyteries in graded courts.

SPEAKER_00Uh and so you have sessions, presbyteries, and the assembly. All of them, in one sense, are presbyteries in the sense that they're composed of presbyters, uh, although the middle court obviously only has that name. But that is where that joint power of ecclesiastical jurisdiction is exercised in those various graded courts. Um, so chapter 11 then talks a little bit about jurisdiction, uh, and the phrase I'm sure everybody's well aware of through this podcast that that jurisdiction is ministerial and declarative.

SPEAKER_00Um, and then in 112, it has this series of statements that it makes uh that that uh you know the first aspect of this is that you know court can make no rule binding conscience. Uh, but secondly, it does have the power to establish rules for the government, discipline, worship, and extension of the church. And so uh, while these must always be agreeable to scripture, um, there's this understanding that that circumstantial details of those, uh, the government of the church, discipline, worship, et cetera, those details are left to Christian prudence and the wisdom of church officers.

SPEAKER_00Um, but then as well, thirdly, that these courts do possess the right to require obedience to the laws of Christ and even by extension uh to those laws, or rather to those rules, we might say, that are agreed upon together as uh as a court. Uh 11.3, this reminder again that uh um that the courts, this jurisdiction is one in nature, that all church courts have the same kind of rights and powers. In one sense, uh presbytery is just a big session and the general assembly is just a big presbytery in a sense.

SPEAKER_00Um, however, these courts differ um only in one sense as the constitution provides. And so um, but you still see you know, an SJC at the General Assembly level is just a particular form of a judicial commission that a presbytery might have, that a session might even put together, uh, as well as various committees and and their functions and so on and so forth.

SPEAKER_05Um so technically, what is what is uh RPR? What type of committee is RPR?

SPEAKER_00I think it's a special committee, technically, memory serves. So, like there are program committees and there are some other kind of committees that somebody else can come and talk about. Uh, but I think it's it's labeled under special committees.

SPEAKER_03Um does that mean y'all get like t-shirts or something?

SPEAKER_00Is that no special? No. Um, I could make a joke about a short bus, but but I won't, because it would it would take several short buses to get us all there. So um so again, you know, some of the differences, uh, lower you know, session is gonna ordain ruling elders, and a presbytery is gonna ordain teaching elders, and a general assembly is gonna ordain no one. So some of those things. Um, but one of the things that it talks about in 11.3 is this idea that disputed matters of doctrine or order uh come under the authority of higher courts.

SPEAKER_00And 11.4 then specifically talks about how that happens. It comes under uh matters, not just disputed matters, but certainly including or not excluding disputed matters, come under the review and control of higher courts. Um so uh uh in 11 uh it talks about the General Assembly, or rather, yeah, the chapter 14 rather is about the General Assembly. Uh, and so it enumerates some of the powers of General Assembly to record or to review the records of Presbytery, to take care that lower courts observe the Constitution and to redress whatever they have uh they may have done, which is contrary to order.

SPEAKER_00Um then chapter 39 is uh about the ways in which um the actions or inactions of lower courts come under the jurisdiction of higher courts. Um one of those is what I would call normal and ordinary, which is review and control. And there are others that are occasional and extraordinary appeals, complaints, and referrals. Um, so in one sense, year after year after year, both presbyteries and the assembly must do review and control of lower courts uh through their minutes.

SPEAKER_00And then when an appeal or a complaint or a referral arises, they they take up those things, and that's where the higher court exercises its jurisdiction over the lower court. Um, I also wanted to read one other section from 39. This is up, I think it's the first full sentence, although it is long and kind of Owinian in its length and breadth. But um it's 39.3, and so I'll just read it while scripture, well, sorry, while affirming that scripture is the supreme judge by which all controversies of religion are to be determined, Westminster Confession of Faith 110, and that the constitution of the Presbyterian Church in America is, quote, subordinate to the scriptures of the Old and New Testament, the inerrant word of God, BCO preference, preface three, and while affirming also that this constitution is fallible, Westminster Confession of Faith 31.

SPEAKER_00The Presbyterian Church in America affirms that this subordinate and fallible constitution has been, quote, adopted by the church, that's BCO preface three, and then uh another quote, as standard expositions of the teaching of Scripture in relation to both faith and practice, that's BCO 29.1, and as setting forth a form of government and discipline, quote, in conformity with the general principles of biblical polity, BCO 21-5.3. The reason why I bring that up is that we have to recognize that, yes, scripture is our supreme authority, and we have subordinate uh standards, the Westminster Confession of Faith and the BCO.

SPEAKER_00And yet, just as we affirm that the Westminster Confession of Faith is uh our sort of standard exposition of Scripture, uh, we also recognize that our BCO uh contains a form of government and discipline that is in conformity with the general principles of biblical polity. And so while there are circumstances in our polity that you cannot have a chapter and verse for, such as the number of days that you have to file an appeal or even the process for an appeal, um, we are affirming as a church, and all men who take ordination vows, are affirming that the form of government we actually do have, while not perfect and is fallible, is in conformity with the general principles of biblical polity.

SPEAKER_00And that means then that the General Assembly, as the highest court in the PCA, has the duty and the responsibility to exercise both, again, as I called it, occasional and extraordinary control in certain in cases of appeal complaint or reference, but that it has a duty and right and a responsibility to exercise that control generally and ordinarily. Uh, and the the way that that is done, the way in which we do that is through um ultimately through the review of records, although there's some other aspects to that that I'll get into in just a second.

SPEAKER_03I think that's such a helpful point to make, Steve, about 39.3. Um, we talked about it when we were going through Witherow, that the the church in our polity, not only does the church have the authority to do the things that it's been given to do, like review and control would fall under that. But also those underneath that authority are responsible to obey and and fall in line with what has been given. And so it's it's a wonderful section to reference that um that this is this is expected and proper for us to follow because it conforms with what the Bible's given to us.

SPEAKER_00Um yeah, well, I think too that you know, tied to that, you know, this was not just a sort of a sprint down memory lane or anything. Um but as I was thinking through this, I mean, just the idea that you know all courts are one, they are graded in terms of you might say the circumstances of uh geographic dispersion and uh you know the various needs of different areas, but ultimately the PCA is a denomination, it is a court, it is the general assembly.

SPEAKER_00And when we gather together, we make decisions and we make changes or we try to make changes to the BCO or whatever else, that there's a sense in which uh the authority that we are exercising is the authority um that Christ has given to the church as a whole, to our church. I mean, we're we're one expression of that as a whole. And so when that filters down to a presbytery, that presbytery then is acting, I mean, I'm gonna use extra BCO language here, but is acting sort of as an agent of uh a part of the higher denomination.

SPEAKER_00And while, yes, there are there are there are specific uh duties and requirements that are given to the presbytery, and let's not forget they're given to the presbyteries by the General Assembly in the Book of Church Order, and and similar to the session, that that requirement to conform all that they do to what the assembly has declared will be the way in which we go about doing these things, um, is not optional. It's not in one sense, it's not even voluntary. I mean, it's voluntary to the degree that it's a voluntary organization, I get that.

SPEAKER_00Um, but but it is a it is the right of every presbytery to conform its actions and even the way in which it conducts its meetings with what the BCO says, because the nature of the church's jurisdiction and authority is not several, even several in terms of presbyteries, but is one through its general assembly.

SPEAKER_05So what you're saying is that presbyteries or sessions should not be getting mad because a session has their minutes reviewed by presbytery and the general assembly has their minutes reviewed by uh or their presbytery has their minutes reviewed by the General Assembly. In fact, this is what we signed up for.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, well, and I'll I'll come back around to that because I think there's two aspects that that that that you you just nailed one of them. Um, but yeah, I mean, um sessions, I think you find it more in the session level than the presbytery level, where uh you know sessions get very upset about the fact that they have to submit their minutes. And it's often you know looked at as sort of meddling um uh at best. I suppose the best word you might hear is meddling. But uh it really is uh you know just part and parcel of what it means to be Presbyterian.

SPEAKER_00Um and the more I think as a as a as churches and presbyteries and the assembly as a whole, the more we lean into this, I think the more we um we we conform to our Presbyterian principles uh as a church. So um any other thoughts or questions, sorry?

SPEAKER_05Seeing none? Well, getting into I I think you have that as the overview of what your what the mandate is. Um how does that actually function? Because usually we don't get into that much detail at General Assembly. So you guys are meeting before that. How does that work? That this committee has all of these responsibilities for these minutes. What does it look like for um RPR to to meet and have a report for us at GA that we're gonna see on the Wednesday of GA?

unknownYeah.

SPEAKER_00Well, I um I'll I'll get right to that. Uh Ben might want to cut and paste here a little bit.

SPEAKER_03Um I I do want to no cutting and pasting, sorry.

SPEAKER_00No cutting and pasting. Okay. Um I I do want to uh uh talk to us about one more chapter in the BCO real quick before we get to the process and we'll just make Jared ask this question all over again.

SPEAKER_03Again, okay. And you just referenced sausage again, which you did incessantly the first time we had you on. Um it's not a bad that's not a comment, a bad comment. That's I'm I'm praising you. I'm just saying that's that's a great phrase.

SPEAKER_05It's it's the origin of the Swiss Reformation.

SPEAKER_00Come on. That's right. It's at the very roots of us as Presbyterians. There is sausage and a Bible and probably a cask of wine. Um, so uh all right. So um, so chapter 40 then gives the the BCO uh basis then for general review and control. What is it? What does it look like? Um again, 40-1 just reminds us that this is a right and a duty of every higher court to review uh the minutes of the lower court.

SPEAKER_0040-2 then provides uh what specifically those higher courts are to do when they when they conduct that review. Uh it lists four items, and each of them are separated and they're all equally, or not equally, but they're all very important. Um, first of all, that those actions were recorded correctly. Um here is one of those areas again where there's a lot of angst sometimes from lower courts, because well, we did it right, we just didn't record it right, or you know, sort of what does it matter?

SPEAKER_00You know, why is it so important to record it in a particular way? And um, if you've ever read minutes of anyone of any court that you were not present at, you know how um how just confusing minutes can be when they don't accurately record what happens. And and you have no idea what they did, and and they coming back years later are gonna have no idea what they did, why they did it, what decisions were made, what amendments were made, et cetera.

SPEAKER_00And so the recording is incredibly important because if it's not recorded correctly or properly, then it's in it, there's no way to know whether it was done right or wrong. Um, it gives rise to one of the statements that we like to make at RPR. Uh, if it's not in the minutes, it didn't happen, or if it's recorded incorrectly, then the only thing we can assume is that it was done incorrectly, right? We only assume that you did it the way you recorded it. So recording correct recording is very important. Uh, but secondly, that it would be regular and in accordance with the constitution.

SPEAKER_00Um, regular here is not a uh um a biological function we're talking about, uh, but ra and but really is that these things aren't irregular, right? Uh it's not saying, okay, these things happen uh you know when they're supposed to happen. That's not what it means, but rather that they're not irregular, they're not out of regulation, perhaps we might say, uh, with our constitution.

SPEAKER_05So RPR helps helps us be regular.

SPEAKER_00So it's like the X LAX of Exactly.

SPEAKER_03Just a lot of good fun.

SPEAKER_00Sometimes, yeah, sometimes it feels like the opposite of that, whatever the opposite of X LAX is. I mean, but uh it it that's what it's supposed to be doing. Um but then thirdly, uh That these things that they're these churches are doing are wise, equitable, and suited to promote the welfare of the church. Um, I'll I'll read four and then I'll just come back to three. And the four is obeying lawful injunctions of higher courts. So wherever a higher court gives an injunction, a lawful injunction, a proper injunction to a lower court, uh, it has the right and the duty to make sure that the lower church did that.

SPEAKER_00But of those, the the one I think that that causes perhaps the most um uh confusion is three, even more than the idea of recording them correctly. And that is that a higher court has the duty and the right to um to determine if those actions were wise. Uh you did everything correctly according to uh you know format per se, uh, but was it a wise decision? Was it an equitable decision? Was it suited to promote the welfare of the church?

SPEAKER_00Um now I will say that this is an area in which the higher courts ought to and generally do give uh what is called great deference, right? Great deference to the lower courts because they were there, we were not. They heard all the arguments, you know. Uh you don't you don't you don't record what Ben said on motion one and then what Jared said against him. So they were there, they heard the the debate. But it is still possible that a church is going to make an unwise decision.

SPEAKER_00And uh the the higher court at least uh has a well has a right and a respect and a duty at the very least to require that lower court to give a a further uh explanation for why they did what they did, why it was wise or equitable, et cetera. Um and while I I've heard this once, I've heard it a thousand times at RPR where someone would say, you know, well, we can't we we can't look at that decision because they made it and they, you know, well, no, we can.

SPEAKER_00We can we can ask the question whether it is wise. But also just reminds us, I think, of what you know the great deference is not absolute unfettered deference. Um, you know, obviously great deference is a much higher standard than no deference at all or just some deference. Um, but what if you say you were to give great deference to a lower court, that doesn't mean you cannot ever, under any circumstances, say that their decision was unwise. It just raises the bar higher in terms of uh you know determining that and and making that thing.

SPEAKER_00Um yeah, so those are the those are the four areas. Um the the minutes then are what are uh taken up by the higher courts to take a look at and to go through. Um there's one phrase in 40-3, another phrase that causes some um some confusion uh with regard to judicial matters. Um there is this uh um old wives' tale in the PCA that a higher court cannot look at the minutes of a judicial case at all, or anything in the minutes that have to do with judicial matters.

SPEAKER_00Um that is not what the BCO says. Um rather, it it clearly indicates that judicial matters do not come under the review of a higher court while notice of appeal or complaint has been given. Um and it is sometimes argued that the while um sort of um subordinate clause is meaningless and pointless, that the main clause uh is the one, the only one you look at, uh, but I think just sort of English composition, English understanding, it's clear that um once a judicial matter has been completed, and either there are no appeals or complaints, or they've all been adjudicated or whatever, that a higher court can look at those uh the records of judicial matters.

SPEAKER_00However, the other important piece to that, though, is to remember that um while a higher court can review the minutes of a judicial matter and could even find exception to some or uh potentially even all of the judicial proceedings, that judicial decisions cannot be overturned by review and control. They can only be overturned by complaint or appeal. And so even if a session or a presbytery just completely botched a case, but there was no complaint or appeal, RPR, again, I'll use that phrase, not only has the right, it has the duty to indicate to that presbytery here are the 15 errors you made, and you need to respond that you understand and that you will endeavor to do better in the future.

SPEAKER_00Um, but no action of a higher court can overturn a judicial matter except by complaint or appeal. So RPR is not the standing judicial commission. No, no, and and and and I I will say that with with with few exceptions of certain individuals from different times who've been there, nobody in RPR thinks they're the SJC either. Uh they we tend to have a pretty good understanding of what our role is. And even when we see errors in a judicial matter that has been completed and there's no chance for it to be appealed or complained against, um, we still need to point out to a presbytery, you did it wrong.

SPEAKER_00And uh, you know, there's there's no way it can be overturned, but the pres, you know, at that point it just becomes a learning experience for the presbytery uh because we certainly don't want them to repeat it again simply because we didn't point it out to them, hey, that's not how you do it. So um so all of that then refers to the minutes that are read. 40-4 um is a very wise paragraph in the midst of a very wise chapter, in the midst of a very wise book, because it understands that when a presbytery, certainly when a presbytery neglects to do what it's supposed to do, they're not gonna put that in their minutes.

SPEAKER_00Like if they fail to do something, then they're not gonna put it in their minutes because they didn't do anything. Um but also if if they are allowing gross errors in their presbytery knowingly, they're also unlikely to put that in their minutes either, right? They're gonna try to hide those things that they know higher courts won't like. Now, that's not to suggest that goes on. That's not to suggest this is a rampant problem in the Presbyterian world, but rather it is it is to understand that there may be issues that ought to be reviewed, but are not in the minutes for a variety of reasons.

SPEAKER_00And our BCO has this phrase that if the if the higher court is well advised of the actions of a lower court, either that they neglected to do something they needed to do or that they did something improperly, they can take up that matter as if it were in the minutes, even though it's not. Now, obviously you're on you know thinner ice and shakier ground because you have no actual record of it. Um, and the well-advised portion would have to be defended in some way.

SPEAKER_00Um, but it does mean that from time to time it is possible that a higher court could bring something, could bring an exception uh when a court uh utterly uh fails to record something in their minutes at all because there is uh you know secondary evidence or whatever uh that they did something that they should not have done. Um and then lastly, the 40-5, which is uh when there's a credible report that comes to a higher court of uh some important delinquency or grossly unconstitutional proceedings, um, that the lower court can be cited to appear before the higher court to give an answer for what they did or failed to do.

SPEAKER_00Um the intention here is to use language that suggests these are extraordinarily um you know rare events, um, important delinquency, grossly unconstitutional proceedings. Um this wouldn't be something supposed, you know, ideally, this is not something that happens once a year, maybe not even once a decade, but uh to to allow the higher court to still exercise its responsibility of jurisdiction over lower courts, um, even when there is no uh minutes or something along those lines.

SPEAKER_00Um, and and certainly in the at the general assembly level, that means that if there's a 40-5 uh report regarding a presbytery, then it would ultimately go to the SJC. So that that kind of covers just sort of the basics of the background. I didn't know if you guys had any other questions so far. Put you all to sleep.

SPEAKER_03We're good.

SPEAKER_00Okay. Right. So um let's talk a little bit about process then, like how how this actually works. Um, and most of this comes gonna is gonna come out of the RAO, uh, the rules of assembly operation, which are uh kind of like the standing rules of the General Assembly. Well, they're not kind of like they are the standing rules of the General Assembly. Um so RAO 8-5.9 um provides for uh the Committee for the Review of Presbytery Records.

SPEAKER_00Um, it also provides the the makeup of that committee, but the committee is composed of one member uh from each presbytery. They serve three-year terms, and um ideally they are supposed to rotate back and forth between ruling elders and teaching elder delegates. Um doesn't always happen. Um, I know for instance, uh, well, again, I mean I've served on it like 12 years in a row, and um, you know, I was always willing.

SPEAKER_00I mean, if any ruling elder would want to go in my place, I would have been happy to seed my my seat for three years and you know, see if somebody, another teaching elder for that matter, wanted to go. Um, but uh volunteer volunteering for RPR um is not terribly um often uh in or or even uh exuberant in the PCA.

SPEAKER_05So I thought RPR was like the Disney world of uh Presbyterian courts.

SPEAKER_03I've heard they have t-shirts.

unknownYeah.

SPEAKER_00Uh we don't have t-shirts. One year we got um Howie Donohoe brought uh beer koozies, so there's that.

SPEAKER_03But uh they have RPR on it, like it says it.

SPEAKER_00I'll come back to that one because there's a there's a story behind that. So, but no, that's the only thing. We do get cute little name tags you get to slap on your chest, um, and a stack of paper that would make Scott Edberg happy to move around. Um those men uh gather together um once a year, well, prior to the assembly in Atlanta uh for the actual meeting. Uh just kind of continuing through uh chapter 16 of REO uh covers the uh review of presbytery records.

SPEAKER_00So if either you want to know more or have trouble sleeping at night, uh turn to REO 16 for that. Um provides guidelines to presbyteries for keeping minutes, but also in one sense provides the base, uh kind of a baseline for a lot of the things that RPR looks at when they take up the minutes of the various presbyteries. Um probably the thing that most people are aware of are the findings from that review that come in the form of exceptions.

SPEAKER_00Um, and so there are three broad types of findings. Uh, there's an exception of substance, an exception of form, and a notation. Um, notation is probably the easiest one, so let's just get that out of the way quickly. That's uh spelling error, typographical error, uh, grammatical error, things like that. Those are not reported to the assembly, they're just simply given to the clerk uh for uh just sort of advice to try to clean up their own records or whatever else, or maybe not make mistakes like that in the future.

SPEAKER_00Um but the other two are probably a little bit better well known. Umly exceptions of substance are reported to the assembly, but um, you know, every member of the assembly is also a member of the presbytery, and so they probably receive reports that have not just the exceptions of substance, but also the exceptions of form. Um, so the REO defines an exception of substance as an apparent violation of the scripture or serious irregularities from the constitution of the Presbyterian Church in America, actions out of accord with the deliverances of the General Assembly, and matters of impropriety and important delinquencies, and any non-compliance with REO 16-3.e.5.

SPEAKER_00Uh, those are all reported under that category. And just for those who have memorized REO 16, uh 3.e.5 is uh how a presbytery is to judge the stated differences of uh candidates for ordination and I think licensure as well. Uh so you come forward and you give your stated difference, and you are granted an exception by the presbytery. It has to be judged in one of uh three, I think it's three categories, um, you know, out of accord, out of, you know, not out of accord, but not striking at the vitals or merely semantic to give a broad general categorization of those things.

SPEAKER_00Um so again, those are exceptions of substance, exceptions of form are then violations of the assembly's guideline for keeping presbytery minutes, that's REO 16-3 that I mentioned a minute ago. Rules of order, so like Roberts rules, violations, things like that, uh, these are normally reported under that category. Um and one other thing is helpful to note too that um it's it's possible, although not automatic, that if a presbytery continues to make the same exception of form over and over and over again, then it's possible that it become that it raises up to an exception of substance.

SPEAKER_00Um, you know, if a presbytery just out and out refuses to open their meeting with prayer, um that's an exception of form. Um but if they do it over and over and over again and just refuse to make changes, then it can become an exception of substance. Uh the other big difference as well is obviously notations are just for the sake of the clerk. Uh, exceptions of form are for the sake of the clerk and the presbytery um, and then exceptions of substance are given to the whole assembly, um, but it is only exceptions of substance that the presbytery has to respond to.

SPEAKER_00So they don't respond about exceptions of form, they only respond about exceptions of substance.

SPEAKER_05So, what happens within the committee and that meeting if you're debating something about whether it should be um taken to that level and uh there's there's people on both sides. What happens if you have almost a split room on that? Some people want to send it up, some people don't. Uh what happens then?

SPEAKER_00Well, I mean, um, so the General Assembly receives the committee's report, which contains uh all of the exceptions of substance, I mean, any recommendation that the majority of the body made. Um, but I think getting at what you're asking, if there is a uh sizable minority, and I don't have the numbers right in front of me, but but there are some requirements for how many that has to be teaching and ruling elders. I think it's eight, but don't quote me on that.

SPEAKER_00Um if there's a sizable major minority, they can uh file a minority report, uh, which is due um you know before the assembly even meets, and it's always included in RPR's report so that the assembly would uh have both the committee's report um that they let's say they want to make something an exception of substance, and then a minority report could come forward that would make something, you know, an exception of form, just to give the example of what we were just talking about.

SPEAKER_00Um that's never happened on this issue. Uh I mean typically um we we will figure out uh the room because the room is different every year. You know, what are we gonna where are we gonna draw those lines between what's a form, what's a substance, um, and we'll have you know one or two pretty drag out debates um that might last you know half an hour, an hour sometimes on one of these particular issues. But then once it's decided, most people realize that it it's important, but it's not that important.

SPEAKER_00It's not something to bring to the assembly. Um because you know, again, an exception of substance, um, even if you thought, no, that really needs to be an exception of form, it shouldn't be substance. I mean, at the end of the day, the only difference is that the presbytery has to report back on it. And so that one is not that big of a deal. Um, but obviously, you know, the the broader parameters of that question, you know, anytime there is a sizable minority, uh, you can get a minority report.

SPEAKER_00Um and the minority report, you know, kind of brings with it two different things. Um, you know, first of all, a general eye rolling and sigh from the assembly when they find out that one's coming. Um, that's the one thing. But the other is it really does get an opportunity for the assembly to decide something where uh there is a sizable disagreement within the within the within the committee. And so, you know, while it does take up extra time and it does uh kind of slow things down at the assembly level, that's that's that's the how it's designed to work.

SPEAKER_00Um and so uh they can they can be tedious at times, but uh they are they're important. So um but uh see so there's one other thing that I wanted uh to say um because in one sense if you go back to 1606 with regard to exceptions of substance and exception of form, um they have uh what I would describe as uh great descriptions of them, but but not a definition. Right.

SPEAKER_00So um this is part of the art of RPR. Um, you know, where do you draw that line? Um and I I I tend to think of it personally this way. So this this is this is just me. This is not the way RPR always looks at it. Um but if you just think about the language that is being used, you know, the difference between a substance and a form, I mean, this is almost uh you know Thomistic language in a sense. Um, but you know, a substance in one sense is referring to the matter itself, right?

SPEAKER_00The thing that was done should not have been done, uh, or it should not have been done the way it was done. But but form to me seems to refer not to matter, but to manner. Hopefully I'm enunciating well enough. Manner, the way a thing was recorded versus the way it was done. And that you know, even then, that's not going to get you to the end of the discussion, but but it's helpful for me a lot of times when thinking through those things.

SPEAKER_00I'll also say that um the Stated Clerk's office provides every year a list of uh recommendations for what should be form or substance. Um, and it lists, you know, I don't know, 50 or so different exceptions that might be found, and then gives a recommendation for whether that should be form or substance, and where you would find that in the uh Book of Church Order or the RAO or even Robert's Rules for that matter. Um and I'll say too that the clerk provides it, it was created and continues to be modified by the RPR committee.

SPEAKER_00So it's not just you know the clerk off on his own trying to figure that out. It's the RPR year after year that continues to uh massage that thing, but uh it does provide uh some really good ways of kind of thinking through a lot of that. Um and then uh so I want to talk a little bit about the report, then as it comes, and and we'll talk a little more about the process here in a second. But uh when the report comes, um, there are the recommendations concerning the minutes, these are the exceptions of substance that they are recommending the assembly approve.

SPEAKER_00Um it's probably as good a time as ever to just remind ourselves that committees make recommendations. Uh they don't they don't take actions themselves. And so every every item in the report is a recommendation that the assembly do those things. And so um I know it's it's a common way of speaking to say, well, RPR sided us with an exception of substance, and every presbytery that I'm in, I remember. Mindman, no RPR did nothing. The assembly cited you with an exception of substance.

SPEAKER_00RPR made a recommendation, but it was the assembly that cited it. Um, so the report, the bulk of that report is uh recommendations. Uh I would draw everyone's attention to REO 16-7.d, which in an amazing sweep of uh uh of I don't know what uh lists any other recommendation. Uh RPR can make, according to the REO, it can make any recommendation it wants. Uh I I'm certain that's that wasn't intended, but uh the rules as written, which I'm a rules as written guy, uh 16-7D, any other recommendation.

SPEAKER_05Um so so if RPR just wanted to make a recommendation that the uh General Assembly was adjourned at the end of its report, then it it can ask for that.

SPEAKER_00It could make the recommendation. I I doubt it would pass, but uh maybe adjourn, you know, for for something. Um but you know this this came up an issue last year with the the 40-5 that was raised for um Metro New York. And um now this wasn't necessarily an argument that was made because it wasn't really challenged on the floor in terms of whether it was appropriate or not. Um at least appropriate from a rules perspective.

SPEAKER_00Uh, but I know in some of the subsequent subsequent conversations that I know I've had, this is this is as sweeping as it gets. And and it's not it's not something you make up. It it it clearly any other recommendation. Now certainly it needs to have something, it should have something to do with review and control, right? It shouldn't be uh you know to to fire the coordinator of whatever you know committee or anything like that. Um, but it certainly leaves a lot of leeway to make other recommendations.

SPEAKER_00But but actually, I mean, you step back a second and think about it, even outside of that, the RPR may be the broadest report in terms of scope that we receive at the assembly. Um committee of commissioner reports, you vote them up, you vote them down, you can refer them back, but you cannot amend a COC report. Um, you do nothing with the SJC's report other than you know, maybe grumble some people, but you you can't do anything about it. Um, nominations, the the time for nominations from the floor is already, there's nothing you can do.

SPEAKER_00Uh, RPR is entirely amendable from the floor. Um, and and that means that, and this has happened numerous times where a presbyter would stand up from you know what XYZ presbytery would say, no, no, they got it wrong. I have it here in my minutes right here. We did that thing, and the assembly can move to strike that exception of substance or change it, right? Uh this has happened too, where maybe um a an exception of substance is unclear, it's slipped through the committee, and so somebody makes an amendment on the floor to make it more clear.

SPEAKER_00But it also means that someone could, in theory, stand up in the middle of the RPR report, maybe not in the middle, wait till you're uh recognized by the chair and and move to just add an entirely new exception to the to the report. I mean, that's never happened, and I doubt it would go very far. Um, but just the fact that it's possible, uh, you know, overtures is certainly not like that. This is the only one I'm aware of I can think of off the top of my head that is anything like this when it comes to the floor. It's also the one that has tended, as we were talking about a minute ago, just to have the most minority reports.

SPEAKER_00Um you get occasionally, you'll get some out of overtures, um, but uh maybe it's just anecdotal thinking and maybe it's wrong. But I I think over the last, you know, 15 years or whatever that I've been going to the assembly, I would say it seems clear that more there have been more minority reports out of RPR than overtures, or maybe they're neck and neck, but but pretty close. Um and so it does tend to be one of those reports where the room tends to fill back up again. Um lots of people want to be there just you know for all kinds of you know interesting things that might be brought up and spoken about.

SPEAKER_00So um so that's the report. Um and then just in terms of responding, then presbyteries are required to respond to um the um the exceptions of substance that the assembly uh cites them with. Um these things are are our findings, right? They're findings of the assembly, but but they're not finalized. The the presbytery, again, it has a response. In fact, they have to respond to the assembly.

SPEAKER_00And that response uh can be something like, yes, you're right, we did that wrong, we won't do it again. Uh, we'll correct our minutes, assuming it's possible to correct the minutes, not always, or correct the action. Um, and 99 times out of 100, well, let's say 75 times out of 100, that's what they say, and that's what happens, and those are found satisfactory. Um, occasionally, however, their response is unsatisfactory uh for a variety of reasons. Um, and then they are required to respond to the next year's General Assembly again.

SPEAKER_00Um, and so sometimes that can go back and forth, sometimes for many years, uh, but there is sort of an exit rant for that. Eventually, when uh the presbytery and the assembly cannot agree, it will go back, it will go to the SJC. Um, and again, that's important because it's not RPR and the presbytery that are going back and forth. Really, it's the assembly and the presbytery that are going back and forth. Um, and I and I think it's that raises an interesting idea, right? That that it's not the assembly itself, nor even the presbytery, and it certainly is an RPR, that is going to be making a final decision in disputed matters.

SPEAKER_00But but rather if that dispute continues to go on and to be unresolved, it goes ultimately to the SJC, uh acting in its capacity as the judicial commission of the General Assembly. That is where that final decision is made. Um and so, yeah, so the meeting, I guess I really didn't talk much about that. Um we meet, as I said, uh for a couple of days in uh three days actually in Atlanta, um a few weeks prior to the assembly.

SPEAKER_00Um we spend an enormous amount of time uh just discussing, debating, going through uh the recommendations, the read reports from the various uh different individuals. Uh are you there at the Steve?

SPEAKER_02Are you are you there? Thank you for joining us for Apolity Matters.

SPEAKER_01And uh we will see you next time for NomCon.

SPEAKER_03Oh man, he dropped. There he is. Sorry. Sorry about that. No, we pay for the privilege of having more than 40 minutes by morning.

SPEAKER_00Well, my my internet is not even not all that good here. So um so you might have to find a place where to kind of cut all that out because I realized after I started talking that I actually did have what I was gonna what I was saying a little bit later on, but there was one other thing I wanted to say. Um so um just to kind of get back into it then. Um I've uh thought about, you know, if the BCO uh gave us a uh description for kissing your wife, um, I'm glad it doesn't do that.

SPEAKER_00But if it did say how to kiss your wife in the BCO, I imagine it would turn, you know, what is supposed to be uh a thoroughly enjoyable exercise, sound like a bore and uh and a chore to do. Um and sometimes you know RPR is a little bit like that. It is not quite like kissing your wife, I don't think. Um, but it's a lot more exciting than RBCO uh fun, enjoyable maybe than our BCO makes it sound. And I just wanted to mention then the importance of that.

SPEAKER_00Um again, I know I said this a minute ago early on, but it seems to me to be kind of the primary and the ordinary way that that we remain a Presbyterian denomination, um, not just a collection of churches, not just an association, um, but but an actual Presbyterian denomination. That we have uh you know a mutual trust and love for one another. Um, but uh wasn't it Reagan, you know, we trust, but we verify, uh, we we look at those minutes.

SPEAKER_00And really it's just a reflection of what is true for me as an individual is also true for us when we gather together in courts. I have an enormous need for mutual accountability. Um if it wasn't for my session, for my friends that I know, for my wife, um, then you know, who knows where where I would go and what I would do and what my thoughts would be and all those things. I need that mutual accountability. Um, and even outside of that, right, it it's it's possible, you know, even for the wisest among us, the most knowledgeable among us, it's possible to make mistakes, to leave out an important matter or to overlook something.

SPEAKER_00Um, you know, Jared and I were together for almost 12 years in Ascension Presbytery with one of the most wise, most knowledgeable, most experienced stated clerks, uh Jay Nykirk. And occasionally our minutes would come back with exceptions of substance. So uh it's important to remember, even those who really know what they're doing can still make mistakes and benefit from others looking in on it. But even outside of that review and control from the upper level, I think again, just the importance of minutes themselves.

SPEAKER_00Um, we don't take minutes so that a higher court can you know kind of peer into our business and stick their nose in the middle of what we're doing. That minutes are first and foremost a record for whatever court is making those minutes. It's so they will know what they have done. Uh they have a historical record that they can go back and look to. Uh, what did we do five years ago or 10 years ago? How did we handle something like this before? Uh is that man even ordained in this Presbytery?

SPEAKER_00Well, we can go back and find the minutes for that and figure that out. But but also, minutes are an important part of how we make decisions, of what it means for a court to make a decision. Um are we willing to put that action, that motion, are we willing to put it in our minutes, to have future generations of that court, much less higher courts, know what we did, what we were willing to do or unwilling to do. Um even for individuals, right? To have your submission to your brothers and the Lord tied to that particular action, right?

SPEAKER_00To be on record in one sense of having to be willing, according to your vows, to submit to that decision, however much you may have argued against it. Uh and so minutes are are important for that. They are an important record of what we have done, yes, for higher courts, but but also for us, uh, so that we will know who we are, what what it is that we have done as courts together. Um so um lastly, then just want to talk a little bit, sorry, about the process.

SPEAKER_00Um so our RPR is where Roberts rules nerds go on vacation. They don't go to Disney World, they go to Atlanta at the end of May. Um, although some people describe it as the ninth circle of hell, so I'm not really sure which one. Maybe it's a little bit of both. Um, but it is a three-day, most expenses paid uh meeting in Atlanta a couple of weeks before the General Assembly. Uh, the minutes uh the presbyteries are submitted electronically, uh, a three-man read team is going to get together and they will examine.

SPEAKER_00Uh, each of them will get the same three to four presbyteries. They'll they'll read them over individually and then they'll come together for what's called a read team meeting. Um, it just provides sort of a second read, a check and balance. Um, somebody might see something that I didn't, I might see something that they didn't, uh, or we might dispute even and debate even there about whether something really is an exception or whether it's exception of form or substance or whatever. And then a read team report is created that will is collated before we get there.

SPEAKER_00This is a rather new process. So some people that maybe have been on RPR, you know, five, 10 years ago may not recognize it, but that's the way we've been doing it for I think three, four, three years anyway. Um, and one of the things that does is it allows us to arrive in Atlanta on Wednesday morning and to begin immediately doing the work of the committee instead of having to collate and do second reads and do all those things. Um and then there is the perfecting of the report. Um and we go presbytery by presbytery, you know, starting now, I guess, with Arizona.

SPEAKER_00We used to start with ascension and just go one after the other after the other, uh, exception by exception. We look at the substances first, and then we look at forms, and then we look at notations, and then we look at the responses to previous years' exceptions, and it just goes on and on and on and on. Um, one year we did start at the other end. We started with the W's, I think, and we worked our other other direction back.

SPEAKER_03Did you just nuke him? No, I was just looking at what Jared said.

SPEAKER_00We nuked you, I guess. Yeah, you don't like me. Okay, this is like you know, trying to get me off the stage. I'm almost done, guys. Come on now. Um, and feel free to cut out whatever you want to.

SPEAKER_03So um so and I'm just dropping this raw file on the internet somewhere and see if anybody else does stitch it together three ways, yeah.

SPEAKER_00Um, so then um it's a lot like overtures. I know a lot of guys have served on it, or maybe they they sit in and observe um, in terms of you know, lots of uh motions, points of orders, amendments, on and on. Um, it's like overtures, but it's just not as exciting as overtures is usually. Um, although every once in a while we will get into a pretty sticky debate that might last for um, you know, sometimes a couple of hours even, uh, debating uh you know some issue.

SPEAKER_00Um thinking about like one of the more recent ones about um oh whatever presbytery it was, I can't remember, that was uh that that uh denied a man the right to teach uh the exception or the state of difference that they had granted him an exception to. I think it might have been Calvary. Yeah. Um and what well, I think most of the debate was over Calvary because they came up first, and by the time we got to North Georgia, it was like Ditto, but but yeah, you're right. There were there were two of them.

SPEAKER_00And um, I mean the the debate on Calvary was several hours long. Um, because it's a committee, you can't call the question in a committee. So it just goes on and on and on. Um but uh you know most of it is is pretty routine, but that's certainly necessary. Um so um lastly, I just wanted to also give kind of an appeal uh to all those who are listening. Um at this point, all five who are still listening to me drone on about RPR.

SPEAKER_03Well, no, here I can set you up for that. So listening to you talk, I've already texted the chairman of our presbytery nomcom and asked, hey, do we have I don't know if we have have anybody on RPR right now? Um, because it it sounds like a great place to go if you're into polity or if you want to learn more. So, so yeah, convince us.

SPEAKER_00Okay. Um so uh I'll I'll bring up sausage again. Um there's a little bit of kind of yeah, I know, there's a little bit of kind of sausage making to it, um, where you know, if if you like hot dogs, do not go to a hot dog factory. Um so sometimes it can be like that. It can it can ruin people. Um but at the same time, you know, if you if you like holiday, if you like the BCO, uh, if you like the REO, um, if you like Robert's Rules of Order, or even if you maybe you don't like them yet, but you just want to know more about them, you want to learn more about those pieces of our uh of our denomination, there really is no better place to go than RPR.

SPEAKER_00Um, you will learn about uh, you know, again, the finer points of Robert's rules, um, and then again, just how our constitution works, how that process works. Um I would say that um, you know, a lot of what I know about, particularly about Robert's rules, but even just about our BCO has just come from uh being on RPR for so long, learning um alongside other guys and just sitting through that process. Um and so uh on the one end, you get this great benefit of learning more about kind of how the sausage is made, yes.

SPEAKER_00Um, but you also experience some things that that most people probably don't realize go on at RPR. Um, you know, an RPR report by design are all the things the presbytery did wrong, right? But what we get to do, both as first readers and also as we come alongside one another and talk through the conversation, we get to see some of the things that the presbyteries did well.

unknownRight?

SPEAKER_00We get to see some of what God by his grace is actually doing in our denomination. We get to see men ordained to gospel ministry, we get to see churches planted. Even sometimes watching sort of as a fly on the wall, like watching the discipline unfold, um, even that can be a blessing because you remember that's one of the marks of the church. And while you um, I guess, in one sense, deplore the necessity for it in that particular instance, whatever it might be, but the fact that a presbytery is endeavoring to be a church and to deal with discipline issues, in and of itself can be encouraging.

SPEAKER_00Maybe they made a lot of errors or whatever else, and that's you know, but just the idea of it is great. And in fact, this year I was reading through one of the particular presbyteries that that I have, and uh they had um attached these reports from every church. They I don't remember how many churches they had in the presbytery, but they divided them up evenly amongst their stated meetings, and each church gave a paragraph of all the ways that God was blessing them in that presbytery. And it was good for me just to read that and just to be reminded that it's not all doom and gloom out there.

SPEAKER_00I mean, that churches are flourishing, uh experiencing time of of great blessings from God. And you don't you'll you'll never read that in the report. But if you go to RPR and you participate, you might actually get to experience some of that. Um I know I certainly have every year. Um, but also it's a time of fellowship with with presbyters that you might not normally or or otherwise ever get to know. Um I was actually reflecting on this this last year at General Assembly.

SPEAKER_00I was walking down the aisle and I looked around, and I mean, I've been around for some time, not as long as I know many guys, many guys have been in the PCA longer than I have, but I think you know, 15 years or so is a decent amount of time. And I feel like I know a lot of people, and yet as I looked down this particular aisle, I didn't recognize a single person. There are just so many ruling elders and teaching elders in this denomination that there's no way you can get to know them all. Um but then on the other hand, right, for better or for worse, we tend to have friends that more or less align with us in terms of our outlook, of our uh you know, doctrinal stances, et cetera.

SPEAKER_00Um and RPR is no different in terms of at the meeting, there are sometimes, unfortunately, very clear lines that are drawn between one side and the other along kind of uh uh doctrinal issues, et cetera. But one of the things that one of our members did early on when I was started to go, uh this is uh ruling elder Howie Donahoe, former moderator of the assembly, longtime member of SJC. Uh Howie's probably one of those people that that needs no introduction.

SPEAKER_00Um, but uh after you know, what we would do is um this was this was going on forever. Um, after the meeting, let's say Wednesday night, we would you know reconvene out on the patio of the Hampton Inn uh for a time of uh PCA refreshment, you know, pipes, cigars, and and alcohol. Um but but more than that, what Howie was able to do is to encourage us not to sort of gather in two different groups that evening to complain about the PCA or whatever, but actually everybody to get together and just mix and talk.

SPEAKER_00Um, and and those have been some of my most enjoyable experiences in in all of my work in any court, whether it's session, presbytery, or the assembly, um, you know, really having an opportunity to uh to talk to other men and not to talk about, you know, although there's a little bit of this, you know, not talking about our differences or whatever else, but but just to get a chance to talk to men about, you know, what was going on in their churches, what was going on in their family, what was going on in the cities in which they're ministering and all of those different kinds of things, really to get to know people.

SPEAKER_00Um, that doesn't mean that I didn't argue against their position the next morning, but but it does mean that I have a greater respect for them and people that you know, you get to know them not as an advocate for a position or an ideology for lack of a better word. You get to know them as a human being, as a presbyter, as a pastor, and and that has been really invaluable to me. Uh, it's helped me, I feel, in so many other areas of denominational work that that guys who, again, might disagree with my opinions on something, um, but they've gotten to know me through RPR and and I've gotten to know them.

SPEAKER_00And we we know we disagree, but we also know we're both men of integrity, that we hold those positions sincerely, um, and that we can still call one another brothers because we have uh you know shared uh old fashioned together or something like that.

SPEAKER_03So well, we've gotten a good deep dive on RPR. Uh Jared, we're gonna circle back to Nomcom another time. Uh, but just wanted to check in with Scott or Jared. See any any other things on your minds about RPR you want to ask Steve uh before we get going? You guys all right? Y'all knew how this was done beforehand, didn't you? Okay. Well, as the Committee for Review of Presbyterian Records would say, this podcast is over. Thanks for joining us. If you're interested in learning more about what we've mentioned, check the show notes out.

SPEAKER_03There's a few things up there for you. You can find those in your podcast player or at Politymatters.org. We're always glad to have Steve Tipton on the show. Many thanks to you, sir, for joining us. Uh, we appreciate your input and contributions. If you've enjoyed the show, please consider following us on Twitter or Facebook at Polity Matters. Subscribe in your podcast app of choice. And if you have questions or comments, you can always reach out to us on social media or at Politymattersfeedback.gmail.com. You can find each one of us on Twitter. You can check the show notes for the proper links.

SPEAKER_03Uh, but for now, uh, thanks again for spending time with us. Until next time, say goodbye, gentlemen.

SPEAKER_05Bye, gentlemen. Gentlemen.

SPEAKER_03Scott's waving. Y'all take care.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. 150. You've Got to Come Visit

    Nov 17, 202642 minAudio

    Ben, Jared, and Scott are joined by Brad Voyles, president of Covenant College, as the RAO series continues through the agencies and committees of the General Assembly. Brad shares how he went from Bellhaven and RTS...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. 149. Two Keys on the Nuclear Submarine

    Nov 10, 202642 minAudio

    Jared and Scott are joined by Andrew Rein, coordinator of Reformed University Fellowship (RUF), as the RAO series continues through the agencies and committees of the General Assembly. Andrew shares how he came to RUF...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. 148. From Birthing Babies to Geriatric Care

    Nov 3, 202634 minAudio

    Ben, Jared, and Scott are joined by Steve Dowling, interim coordinator of Mission to North America (MNA), as the RAO series continues through the committees and agencies of the General Assembly. Steve marks one year in...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. 147. ProtoPresbytery

    Oct 27, 202643 minAudio

    Ben and Jared are joined by Lloyd Kim, coordinator of Mission to the World (MTW), as the RAO series continues through the committees and agencies of the General Assembly. Lloyd shares his path from Southern California...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. 146. Broker of Relationships and Resources

    Oct 20, 202643 minAudio

    Ben, Jared, and Scott are joined by Stephen Estock, coordinator of the PCA's Committee on Discipleship Ministries (CDM), as the RAO series continues through the permanent committees and agencies. Stephen shares his path...

    Credit the people on this episode