Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Polity Matters

Polity Matters artwork

46. EPC Roundup

Jul 16, 202451 minAudio

Ben and Jared are joined by Dustin Jernigan from the EPC to get the deets on their 2024 General Assembly. Send us Fan Mail Support the show Official Website: politymatters.org Support the Show: Buy Me a Coffee Twitter/X: @PolityMatters Facebook: Polity Matters Page Scott's Twitter Jared's Twitter Ben's Twitter

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_02Well, hello and welcome to Polity Matters. My name is Ben Ratliff, and I'm joined today by Jared Nelson and a special guest. Before we get to that, uh just want to remind y'all where we're at. You know, we're taking a little slower time this summer, coming out every couple weeks, and uh spending some time talking to gentlemen from other denominations about their annual uh meetings. Uh we've we've met with uh um an elder from the ARP last time, and this week we're gonna delve into the world of the EPC, and I'll let our guest uh explain that and what that is and everything in just a few minutes.

SPEAKER_02But we're glad to welcome uh Dustin Jernigan to the show today. Dustin, thank you for joining us. Uh we're we're glad to have you maybe uh give our listeners just a glimpse into who you are, real quick, before we jump into all the details.

SPEAKER_01Hey, uh thanks for having me on, guys. Uh, appreciate it. Uh my name's Dustin. I did my MDiv at RTS Jackson. I will uh, Lord willing, graduate with my D-Men from Beeson uh in December. I am the last of the D-Men students at Beeson. I did such a poor job that they decided to cancel the whole program uh after I graduated uh in December. Yeah, they've switched to a PhD program now. Uh I pastor a uh medium-sized church out in Oregon.

SPEAKER_01Uh, you may have vaguely heard of uh parts of Oregon and Northern California uh in the last few years, always trying to break off and form its own state called the state of Jefferson. Um and so I'm sort of in the heartbeat of that region of the country. Uh it's, you know, yes, it's southern Oregon, but really it's the state of Jefferson, and Bigfoot is our mascot. And we we our daydream is that we are our own 51st state. Uh so try to I always try to compare it uh to we're the red part of California and Oregon, but we're not Republicans.

SPEAKER_01We're more like libertarians, if that makes sense. Uh, libertarians who smoke weed, probably, would be maybe a funny way of putting it. Um, so uh I'm a son of the South. Uh most of my family's from Alabama, but I am doing ministry here in the Pacific Northwest and have been for six years. And uh happily married to my wife, Caroline, and we are expecting baby number six in August.

unknownWoo. Love it.

SPEAKER_02When did you graduate from RTS Jackson?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, I uh chipped away for several years, uh working on basically my last 30 to 35 hours. Uh so I was trying to get to all like eight campuses. I made it to six eventually for my last 30. And uh I graduated in 2015.

SPEAKER_02Okay.

SPEAKER_01And so it took me, it took me about eight years to get my MDiv, which is hilarious because my my key memory of going to RTS for the first time was I sat next to a PCA guy who's now pastoring in Huntsville. And I said, Hey, you know, how long have you been going to seminary? And he said, This is my eighth year. And I remember rolling my eyes and thinking, I will never take eight years to graduate from seminary, and yet here I am.

SPEAKER_02Well, that might be where we overlapped. I finished at Jackson in in 2013. Um maybe that's what it was. But uh we're trying to get Jared uh inducted into RTS or maybe get Dallas inducted into RTS. I don't know what Scott's game is, but uh we we like to feel let Jared feel alone, but also included uh in his seminary education. Jared's here by the way. There he is. Um Dustin, what's the EPC? And I don't know, you know, you've you've been around the southern world.

SPEAKER_02Like maybe if you're able to give us a comparison of the PCA a little bit for most of our listeners who are in the PCA, can you kind of help them make the connection?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, so um you guys have a podcast on church government. So I would imagine most of your listeners are probably vaguely familiar with Presbyterian church history. Uh, you know, so there's, you know, there's always been factions or, you know, differences um in the Presbyterian church, right? There were the old lights and the new lights, there were the northern Presbyterians and the Southern Presbyterians, uh, then there's sort of the evangelical wing within the Presbyterian Church. And the EPC uh really comes out of the Northern Presbyterian Church.

SPEAKER_01And we are the evangelical Orthodox Presbyterians. Uh the PCA, you know, I think they all started splitting off around the 60s. Is that correct? Is that when the PCA was formed? Yeah, 73. 73. Yeah. 73, yeah. So, you know, you have to look at, you know, some of these church plants within the broader context of American history, you know, I think. And, you know, the north-south divide is real, uh, not determinative, but it is, there is a sense, you know, uh, I think where that plays a part um socially, politically, you know, mentality-wise.

SPEAKER_01And so there were a lot of orthodox, uh, godly Presbyterian churches that for various reasons didn't split off with the PCA or the OPC. Uh, you know, who's to say what their reasoning was? Maybe they thought they could preserve uh, you know, what they had. Uh, but eventually what happened in 1981 uh is the EPC was formed, and it actually stems from a Bellhaven professor, Wynne Kenyon. Did you ever have him when you were at Bellhaven? I loved Wynne Kenyon, man. Yeah, so uh that's a story that plays large in the EPC ethos and culture because uh he was uh forbidden from being ordained in the Northern Presbyterian Church because he would not affirm uh, you know, proactively, I guess, women's ordination.

SPEAKER_01Uh he said he would serve alongside women officers, but did not support it personally. Well, he didn't get ordained and he was never an ordained minister. And that was really the impetus for a lot of the um, you know, sort of theologically conservative, right-leaning Presbyterians up north to say, you know, that's it. Around the same time, another guy was ordained, I think around Pittsburgh, actually, Jared. Uh some I it's my recollection, it was in Pennsylvania or somewhere up north, and he denied something crazy like the bodily resurrection of Christ.

SPEAKER_01And he was ordained. And so, you know, you get this group of, you know, guys in the Northern Presbyterian Church, and we're like, okay, so we won't ordain this guy, but this guy just denied like something fundamental to Orthodox faith. And so they start the EPC, which uh stands for the Evangelical Presbyterian Church. And the real difference, I guess, you know, where we land is we would fall within the new light Presbyterians, which I believe the PCA has its roots in the old light, or would be more sympathetic to that. Uh, the EPC is more broadly evangelical than it is like totally reformed.

SPEAKER_01And then the, you know, the two most famous things are that we uh allow each church and presbytery to decide the issue of women's ordination. And then the other issue is we allow each congregation to decide what they believe about the charismatic movement. And so the story goes that one of the founders of the EPC was a very liberal Presbyterian living up north and persecuted the conservative Orthodox guys. And then he had the baptism of the Holy Spirit, uh, private prayer language, all that, becomes an Orthodox, Bible-believing, evangelical.

SPEAKER_01He goes to the PCA and says, Hey, I'm no longer a liberal. Can you guys let me in? Oh, by the way, I'm a charismatic. And they were like, Yeah, no. And so uh that's that was another one of those uh sort of founding things. I would say the interesting thing about that is the charismatic bent to the EPC. Um, I've been in the EPC, gosh, uh, I think I started in 2011 and I was ordained in 2015. There are not a lot of like charismatic Presbyterians in the EPC yet.

SPEAKER_01I'm not saying they don't exist, but it is, we're a Presbyterian denomination. That just is not a major ethos. Uh, I would say more of the ethos, honestly, is just we're not strict cessationists. That's probably more where the EPC is. It's just we don't talk about it a lot. We're not going to argue about it. And, you know, it's not like we're out there running around with like Bethel and wanting to sing Bethel songs. Most of us would be deeply worried about that. It's just that we don't find the cessationist argument totally compelling. Um, the women's ordination thing, that's probably the most contentious thing, which technically each presbytery decides if they're going to ordain women pastors, and each congregation decides whether or not they want to call women as uh ruling elders and deacons.

SPEAKER_01And so um, since I've been in the EPC, uh, well, really historically, the EPC was predominantly a complementarian denomination with a few egalitarians. And over time, that has completely shifted. And, you know, as a complementarian, I look at our denomination and uh it's functionally egalitarian, and it's increasingly so. Uh, to where uh every year we lose several prominent complementarian leaning churches.

SPEAKER_01And so, you know, that that kind of dips into General Assembly a little bit, but um, yeah, that's that's probably the best primer on the EPC. We're not as reformed as the PCA is gonna be. The officers are expected to hold the Westminster Confession. Uh, we do not have a book of confessions, we are Westminster uh confession only. Um, and a lot of them are ex-PC USA churches who uh are Orthodox in the fundamentals of the faith.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, and I think that's why um we have some relations with the EPC. I think occasionally we'll have a delegate that will come to our um general assembly, uh, but we're not in Napark together. So that'll be something of the of a difference there of um between the two of them. And one other thing I wonder about, because I don't know a lot about the polity of the EPC, is um so if you're familiar with the OPC, they have a delegated assembly. Um their presbyteries elect some delegates to go to their general assembly. PCA, uh, if you're a teaching elder and you can get there and pay the fee, you can you can be there uh along with um ruling elders from the churches at least too.

SPEAKER_00Um what does it look like for the EPC in their General Assembly? Is it more towards a delegated, more towards just open or somewhere in between?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, it's an interesting question. Um so the EPC, you know, they're coming out of the PC USA. So they still got those scars, and I don't know if you want to use a modern term, the trauma, right, of coming out of the PC USA. And so uh actually so I yeah, I would say actually, the the book of order says um that in the presbytery meetings and in the general assembly, the goal is actually two ruling elders for every teaching elder. And that is the case for presbytery, that uh, you know, at our church we have three pastors, me, my assistant pastor, and then a part-time assistant pastor.

SPEAKER_01So we are every presbytery supposed to send the three of us plus two ruling elders per teaching elder. And uh, when it comes to general assembly, the same thing holds true. Every teaching elder is supposed to be at general assembly, and you are supposed to bring with you two ruling elders. Now, whether or not that happens, I don't think it really happens. But the that's baked into our constitution because going back to the liberalization of the PC USA, those founding guys like Andy Jumper at um Central Press and um the guy at Ward Church up in Detroit, they felt like they lost the PC USA and the Presbyterian church went astray because of teaching elders, that it was the liberalization of seminaries and it was a um clergy-led revolt against orthodoxy.

SPEAKER_01And their theory was if you actually empower the ruling elders, the ruling elders are going to be the people who hold the denomination accountable better than the liberalized clergy. So uh yeah, so technically that's that's what we say. That's the goal. We talk about it uh every presbytery, you know, in our presbytery review, we get those numbers like, hey, everybody, like we didn't send enough ruling elders. You know, don't forget this is what we said we would do. Um so yeah, I I don't know what the breakdown is at General Assembly, but we strive to be a ruling elder empowering denomination.

SPEAKER_02Jared, I think we've got an overture for our GA next year that we need to write. Uh something similar to that. Because there's plenty of us in the PCA that are going to agree with that sentiment you just expressed about ruling elders sort of leading the direction in the conservative, you know, more more complementary and conservative, whatever direction you may call it. And we've seen that in our own denomination over the last five or ten years of the the movement. Um as ruling elders have increased in our assembly numbers, we've seen better, better direction, uh better movement in the long run. Um yeah, Jared, go ahead.

SPEAKER_00So so um just thinking about this year you you attended um GA. And so could you tell us a little bit about what are you guys what are you guys covering at GA? What are some of the big things that you're going into GA knowing? These are some of the big things that we're gonna be talking about. What did you what did the EPC have on its radar to tackle this year?

SPEAKER_01Uh, you know, I've been going to GA since 2014. And um, you know, Ligan Duncan, who, you know, comes off and on to the GA, he always says the same joke. I love coming to the EPC General Assembly because you guys are the nice Presbyterians. And, you know, that stems back to like a lot of us, you know, uh come out of the PC USA, or we were leaving uh places where um evangelical faith was maligned and ridiculed. And so um you've got to kind of, I think, place yourself in that situation to where imagine, you know, you're being laughed at at the presbytery floor for espousing the biblical sexual ethic or the inerrancy of scripture.

SPEAKER_01And now, after probably hundreds of thousands of dollars have been handed over to your former denomination, so you can just leave, you're now finally in a group of people who love Jesus and want to adhere to the word of God. And so the longtime ethos of the EPC is like, thank God we've left Egypt. Like we're out, you know, and like I don't I don't have to distrust the people around me. I I'm just so thankful they love Jesus and we've all gotten out of it together. And so that ethos of um unity and the essentials, uh, liberty and non-essentials, and charity and all things is very much like that's the that's literally the motto for the EPC.

SPEAKER_01So we're unified in the fundamentals of the faith. Um, when things come that are non-salvific, charismatic stuff, women's leadership stuff, that's not essential. Uh, we're not gonna persecute you over those things. But the ethos is charity and everything. So we're gonna be be nice, right? We're gonna be loving. Um, well, uh, I don't know if it's coming out of, you know, the last few years or the political climate or whatever, but this General Assembly was unlike any General Assembly I've ever been to. And everyone I've known has said the same thing. Uh, it was very contentious at times, it was very awkward at times, uh, it was painful at times, and there were there's several things that we are just not equipped to handle.

SPEAKER_01Uh, I think we're not equipped to handle as an EPC, because most of the time we get a GA like, there's no business. Like, like we actually don't even call it our General Assembly now. It's called the General Assembly and Gospel Priorities Summit. So it's more about leadership training around our four priorities of church planting, biblical leadership, world missions, and something. I forgot. Um, I don't know. We we have some, we've got these things we're supposed to be focusing on every year. And so we get these talks and we get these trainings, and uh, you would not know it's a group of reformed Presbyterians at all.

SPEAKER_01It would feel like a non-denominational leadership summit. Uh, but then you know, we have to tack on like a couple of hours of business. Normally it's very boring and we don't do anything. And this year we had several things that were very, very hard for us to work through. And when you never use a muscle, and then all of a sudden you're asked to like lift 200 pounds, you're like, oh, snap, all of my all of my bad habits are mounting upon me. Um, so those, so those struggling things are um uh our stated clerk uh was in his first three years, and uh he's a very nice man.

SPEAKER_01Uh, I'm sure he's a very godly man, probably more godly than me. Uh, but last year he jokingly referred to himself as our bishop uh from the General Assembly floor, and he uses the title president and CEO very liberally when describing his role. Uh, so that was concerning, and so we had to vote for his re-election. Uh, so that was awkward uh and painful at points. Um the EPC, since uh George Floyd's passing, has been painfully working on a pastoral letter on racial lament and hope.

SPEAKER_01And you can imagine how dicey that is. And uh, the committee that's been working on it had been working on it for about two years, and they sent out a provisional document several months ago, probably three months ago. And uh then every presbytery got uh had time to talk about it. And there were a lot of concerns that baked into that paper were elements of critical theory. Uh, the assumptions of critical theory were the also several of the assumptions in the paper. And so uh since it was propagated to the presbyteries, it's been edited significantly.

SPEAKER_01I think a third of it has now been removed. But we also talked about approving that, uh, which we did at General Assembly, but not without a lot of consternation and discussion about the language and the assumptions baked into our uh statement on racism.

SPEAKER_00Uh so on that, did you have um was it something where people were more satisfied by the time it got to the floor and had been edited than what it had originally uh been? Um, was this or was it still something that was had a lot of controversy around it?

SPEAKER_01Both of those things. So I don't know if the PCA does this. We have two things. Well, the EPC doesn't do a lot, but we do two things. We have position papers, which could be less than a page to like 15 pages, and it is a public document that you can download on the EPC website. And it is like, what is our position on euthanasia or what is our position on abortion? And we're like, we are pro-life, and here's what we think. And fascinatingly, it gets into IVF at the end of it, uh, which is wonderful.

SPEAKER_01Uh, but uh the uh position paper famously on like women's ordination is less than a page long, and it basically says Christians who love Jesus can agree to disagree, and that's our position on it. It's not a justification of that, it is a public-facing, here's where we stand on any number of these issues. Uh then internally in the denomination, we have another set of resources called pastoral letters, which are inward-facing papers that only teaching and ruling elders can get access to. And so we have a public statement on biblical sexuality that we reaffirmed in 2017, which I think both of you would be very comfortable with.

SPEAKER_01But then we also have a pastoral letter on sexuality, which is like 70 pages long, which is like, okay, how do you put this into practice as a church leader? Or you could hand it to your ruling elder and say, okay, well, since we're holding the biblical sexual ethic, what does that look like in practicality? It's much longer. So the racial letter is not a public document, it is meant to be a training guide for our teaching and ruling elders. Um, there was a lot of consternation about the letter. Everyone agrees that the revision is much better.

SPEAKER_01Nobody denies that. Everybody's like, yes, you took out all the things that were really bothering us. But there still was very heated discussion at the GA about this document. And that's what's different about this GA, because we never do anything in our business meetings of consequence. Even when we passed the like pastoral letter and the position paper on sexuality, everyone's like, duh, yeah, this is what we agree with. Like, does anyone disagree? And it's like crickets. Well, this year, you know, you've got the guys lined up uh to speak for and against it. And um so we passed it.

SPEAKER_01So that, but that was contentious, I would say. Uh, and everybody would would be able to say that that was that was that was a test of the bonds of the EPC. Um, you know, and uh the other I probably the the big thing you should probably be aware of is um Memorial Press has been attempting to get into the EPC. So thanks, guys. Appreciate that.

SPEAKER_02They're they're not one of us, one of ours anymore.

SPEAKER_01So yeah, yeah. Um you know that scene in The Force Awakens, you know, when Kylo Wren sees Darth Vader and he's like, I will finish what you started. You know, like there are definitely some guys in the EPC looking at y'all that same way, like it's time to finish what the PCA started. Um so uh memorial, from what I understand, uh from reputable people, uh, they sent uh observers to last General Assembly.

SPEAKER_01They've been observing the Presbytery of Met America, which is the St. Louis Presbytery for um at least the past few meetings, and they have petitioned to join the EPC. So what happened is the St. Louis Presbytery appealed to the denomination and said, Can you please answer all of these questions about biblical anthropologists? Anthropology, self-identification. At what level can a presbytery or a denomination tell a church how to use its facility if we're uncomfortable with the chapel?

SPEAKER_01Can we actually, you know, mandate a church not use their facility in such a way? And what do we think about progressive sanctification? And how how much should somebody be able to identify by sin patterns? And basically, um my impression is the St. Louis Presbytery, at least a significant chunk, want to let memorial in. Not everybody, I'm sure, but there's enough people that they want to let memorial into the EPC. But thankfully, the Ghost Guys, uh, which is it's a complementarian presbytery, and that you might be interested to know that.

SPEAKER_01Uh, the St. Louis Presbytery is all complementarian. Um, in fact, the the founding EPC Church Central in Clayton, Missouri, uh, where I used to serve, uh, they don't even have female deacons, uh, at least not when I was there. Um so uh so this complementarian presbytery is thinking about letting in memorial, but they know that that would be very contentious. And so they've appealed to the General Assembly and they've asked for uh our theology committee and our ministerial vocation committee to basically speak into this.

SPEAKER_01Um so what happens in that, though, is several of us are deeply worried about memorial getting in. And uh another presbytery, New River, in I think Virginia or maybe North Carolina, somewhere back east, they make an overture to amend the book of order for the EPC to say that if you identify as uh homosexual in that self-identification, you cannot be an officer in the EPC, whether deacon, elder, or pastor.

SPEAKER_01If you continue to identify as you know, homosexual or same-sex attracted, you may not be ordained in our denomination. Um so they make that overture.

SPEAKER_00And then and the language, the the language seemed to be very similar to one that the PCA had had in the past.

SPEAKER_01Yeah.

SPEAKER_00Yeah.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. So this Presbyterian overtures the GA and says basically we need to preemptively shut the door on memorial getting in. Let's amend the book of order, let's clarify. We don't need to study this. We have a statement on sexuality we just released in 2017. We have a 70-page pastoral letter on this. Uh, the EPC has been clear on this for 44 years. Uh, we just we don't want anything to do with this. Well, the Mid-America group, they appeal their own overtures to overtures to kick it to theology and ministerial committee, basically, like, let's send this to committee for a couple of years.

SPEAKER_01Well, then I think five other presbyteries, when they hear about the New River overture, they send their own overtures to kick it to committee. So now there's like two groups, you know, at work. One group says, we need to nuance this, this is a nuanced topic, let's kick it to committee and think about it. And then the other group is like, no, we don't need to go to committee. This is pretty clear. The answer is no. Let's amend the book of order, let's just do it now. Well, um the commissioner's handbook is released.

SPEAKER_01Uh, and there are 11 pages in our commissioner handbook from Mid-America basically arguing their case to every commissioner why it should go to committee, that it's a complicated issue and stuff. Um so it feels very much like the GA office and most Presbyteries want this to go to committee. Um, the resistance is like, no, we don't need this to go to committee. Let's just solve it right now. Um, they feel like they are not being given a fair shot to make this case.

SPEAKER_01And there's all this discussion now going on within the denomination that we are not going to have that discussion from the General Assembly floor, that before anyone can talk about it at the GA, somehow they're going to silence that overture and not allow the GA to speak. So some guys uh write an open letter basically arguing for why we should not let memorial in. And it's an Old Testament, New Testament exegetical work, followed by the history of the Presbyterian Church, followed by some thoughts about practicalities and memorial.

SPEAKER_01So hundreds of EPC uh people, ruling elders mostly and teaching elders, sign the open letter to basically counterbalance the discussion going on. Like the side to kick it to committee seems like they've gotten a full-throated defense for why it should go to committee. And then those of us on the other side uh wanted to make our case. So that's all baked into this General Assembly. Uh, are we going to talk about this or not? Or is it gonna get tabled to a committee?

SPEAKER_02Can I ask you a question real quick? Um Yeah, this is fascinating. Uh, in order to change what what what's required for the EPC to change their book of order? Like for us, it takes one GA plus presbyteries plus a second GA. How does it function for y'all? It's the same thing, exactly.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. Okay. So so the so the the narrative is approve it at this, you know, the argument for the new river, keep memorial out, is approve it at this GA. Then every Presbytery gets to have their own discussion to either ratify or deny. And then next summer we can we can make the final conclusion. What we don't want, or sorry, I mean, I signed the open letter if you can't tell. Uh, I'm I land on the other side of this. Um, the other side is like, no, let's let our theology committee work on this and they will make a ruling, and then Mid-America can do what they want based on the permanent theology committee and based on the permanent ministerial vacation committee.

SPEAKER_01Uh that's where you know the divide is. Okay, so to make matters more complicated, our previous stated clerk, uh, a man named Jeff Jeremiah, uh, who's from the Pacific Northwest, who was our stated clerk for nine years the last nine years, um, he's the first man to sign the open letter. Wow. And it's very much assumed and believed that current leadership is very sympathetic to letting memorial in. But I can't confirm that, but it seems like that's a reasonable belief.

SPEAKER_01And so now it's kind of like, oh, this is this is getting this is getting awkward. And again, this goes back to my uh earlier statement. EPC is not set up to be contentious. We're not we are set up to be really friendly with fellow Christians who love Jesus and disagree on some things and happen to be in Presbyterian churches who um, you know, are not as reformed, but probably hardcore evangelical, you know, good people. Uh we're we're not set up, we're not trained very well in Robert's rules. You know, we don't ever have to use them.

SPEAKER_01It's like, you know, we it's like a muscle we don't ever use. Okay, so fast forward to this General Assembly. Uh the first day, as soon as business begins, uh people from the New River basically presented a problem uh or a complaint because uh when we start General Assembly, what we're told is that our permanent judicial commission has ruled that we're not gonna talk about the New River overture, but that's just gonna automatically go to the standing committees.

SPEAKER_01And as soon as that's declared, I don't think the PCA has a permanent judicial commission. Do you guys have that?

SPEAKER_00We do, but they don't tell us what we can talk about at GA.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. Yes. So the our permanent judicial commission also does not dictate what's talked about from the GA floor. And so, you know, there's about five people in the room who know what's going on, and they're like, ah, this is not okay. You know, you can't the PJC cannot say that we can't talk about it. Um, it is not their job to refer things to committees. That's the job of the General Assembly to refer to committee, not uh, and it was a five to four split on whether or not.

SPEAKER_01So some guy gets up there and he's like, look, nine people should not dictate what the GA talks about. Well, uh the leadership basically overrules that statement. And so the first day of business uh is very awkward because they're just basically shut down and we change the order of some things, and we re-elect our moderator on the first day when historically it's reserved for the last day of the General Assembly. And um so that was that was the first day.

SPEAKER_01Second day uh of the General Assembly when it comes to the business meeting after all of the trainings and stuff. Um second day, as soon as business begins, the former stated clerk walks directly to the microphone and says, I have a complaint, you know, issue. What happened yesterday was unconstitutional. Uh, you know, you the PJC does not have the constitutional right to kick this to committee. That needs to be something basically he's trying to say we need to talk about it from the GA4.

SPEAKER_01The moderator uh does not sustain that complaint. And uh, you know, uh you can actually all these videos are on YouTube. Uh do you guys put your General Assembly on YouTube? Uh, yeah. Okay, yeah. So you people can people can watch this. Um and uh so you know, when our former state clerk's complaint is not sustained, you know, he he was, I think he was shocked. I think it's an understatement. And, you know, essentially he appeals to the floor. And so uh now it's like, okay, do we want to let Jeff talk about this unconstitutional thing and he says he has a solution, uh, or do we just want to shut this down?

SPEAKER_01So it's a voice vote. Uh, speaking as someone who is voting in favor of Jeff's concern, I felt like we pretty clearly won the voice vote, uh, but the moderator calls it in his own favor against Jeff. And so then, of course, you know, 50 guys start shouting call for the count. And so then we have to vote by standing up, and the majority actually vote with Jeff. So then we do sustain, we we don't sustain the guy's other non-sustainment or whatever the Roberts rule is for there.

SPEAKER_01So Jeff gets to basically lay out why it was unconstitutional and then what the solution is. Um, shockingly, and this is probably where the GA turned, uh, the current stated clerk approaches for a point of privilege, and he says, I agree with Jeff. And he says, I like Jeff's solution, and this is what this was not okay, and the PJC needs to fix this, and we will we will agree with Jeff.

SPEAKER_01And so, you know, uh, but those five minutes between those two things happening, I mean, it's like watching mom and dad fight. You're like, okay, what's going on? Like, how do I how do I get out of this? This is so awkward, and it's the EPC. We're the nice ones. We don't, mom and dad don't fight. Um okay, so um basically that's Wednesday night. So Thursday, we're gearing up to talk about the racial lament and hope paper, and we're gearing up to talk about the new river overtures, plus all like the six or seven other overtures against the new river overture, right?

SPEAKER_01So we've been so we're all gearing up for Thursday when we talk about memorial and the racial letter. Uh, the racial letter passes, although it was contentious, but the real uh discussion happens the last item on the docket basically Thursday is okay, what are we gonna do about memorial? Are we gonna talk from the General Assembly floor or is this gonna get kicked to committee? Uh when the stand when the standing committee chair comes up to talk about the recommendations about these issues, basically what she announces is that Wednesday night, um, some members from New River Presbytery, including one of the guys who wrote the open letter of concern, met with some people from St.

SPEAKER_01Louis's Presbytery. And they formed a coalition committee that will study this issue for the next two years and present their findings. But for the next two years, there is a General Assembly will of the GA that no church ordain a same-sex attracted identifying as such. Not uh, you know, I know that's language is important, but if you identify in that way, you cannot be ordained in the EPC for the next two years. No church is to touch this for two years until the committee gives their resolution.

SPEAKER_01And so basically that's the alternative motion. And they list out all nine people that are going to be on that committee, including somebody from New Rivers, a couple of people from Mid-America, and then you know, a couple other people to kind of fill out the committee. And so um everyone cheers, and it's like the culture of the EPC won. See, we are still nice. And uh so it passes overwhelmingly, and that motion dismisses all of the other overtures from the other presbyteries. So that's that's where we stand.

SPEAKER_01So there's a two-year will of the EPC that we don't uh we don't agree if you continue to identify as gay and a Christian, that that is appropriate for an officer, uh, that there are some issues with self-identification we're uncomfortable with. But technically, um the actual resolution is now pending for two years.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, it sounds like you're it's not so much that you've solved it, but you delayed having to talk about it for a couple of years.

SPEAKER_01So you could put it that way. Or we're gonna talk about it for several years while we try to figure this out.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, so does that mean y'all won't receive memorial for the time being?

SPEAKER_01No, we we can't. Yeah, and memorial and uh St. Louis, you know, was like very, very happy with that. They're like, yeah, we'll go back and say, hey, we we can't even make a call on this for at least two years. So I think that's the question. Uh, and then you know, um, there's there's um there's disagreement in the EPC over that. Uh there is, you know, there are churches that want them in and there are churches who don't. Um, so I don't know where we're gonna be in two years. So it'll be very, very interesting.

SPEAKER_00Uh yeah, there's a there's an interesting lesson there, I think. Just in if you try to avoid discussion and debate, it doesn't necessarily make it better. Um, as somebody that is somewhat conflict uh avoidance uh um driven sometimes. Um it's not always the best thing to avoid the conflict as much as to actually have the debate, or it spills over into outside of the court. And even if it's awkward, um, I think it's much better to have those debates and discussions in the court rather than say you can't have them there. Well, they're gonna happen.

SPEAKER_00They're just not gonna be in a place where you're actually face to face talking with uh the person across from you.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, yeah. Yeah, we're uh yeah, we have, yeah. The EPC is in an interesting place. Um so yeah, we'll see.

SPEAKER_00Well, well, that seems to be uh some of the things that are challenging right now in the EPC and definitely areas for people to to pray about. Um anything that you're from the from the meeting that that was probably taking up a lot of the oxygen, but anything that you were particularly encouraged about um happening in the EPC right now?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, I would say two things. Um I would say first off, um it's very exciting to see us um see more uh black church plants and you know uh people of color uh pastoring, you know, I would say that that's been an emphasis is um trying to diversify. So that's sweet. It's encouraging. It's encouraging to see it. You know, uh I come from the South, and you know, that's a a wound uh some of us carry. Uh and so that's encouraging.

SPEAKER_01It just it just is. It's sweet to see. Um, you know, the church where I was hosting it.

SPEAKER_00I was I was just uh gonna ask, was has that been an act of trying to recruit uh people to do church plants and things like that, or has that been more of just more people have been interested in planning it in the EPC or both?

SPEAKER_01Uh I don't know. I would venture to say that it is a uh thing that leadership feels like is important to pursue. And our biggest EPC church is Hope in Memphis, which is pastored by Rufus, uh wonderful African-American man. And he has recruited several church planters uh to plant around Memphis. And I think the General Assembly Office sees that as this is great. And uh I also, I mean, I would venture to say that um the leadership pipeline for the EPC has grounded to a halt.

SPEAKER_01And, you know, uh we're in this awkward tension of needing officers and pastors to be able to pass pretty rigorous ordination requirements and to subscribe to the Westminster Confession, but also be okay with potentially seeing female teaching elders and charismatics at your presbytery. And so there's just not a lot of people who, you know, that's their that's their thing. So uh we're struggling, I think, in some leadership capacity. So this might be a beautiful answer to that.

SPEAKER_01Uh the other thing I would say that is encouraging is uh there was an overture to amend the book of order to grant sessions the authority to commune baptized children and uh adults with intellectual disabilities in the case that they can't verbally profess faith. And so, you know, what do you do with an autistic guy who can't verbally profess faith? Well, the way our book of order reads right now, like you can baptize them, but you couldn't commune them because there's no verbal profession of faith.

SPEAKER_01And so um the GA hymn and hauled about it, and they ultimately voted no, uh, probably because people are concerned that you have to verbally profess faith in Christ to be able to take communion. Uh, but the other uh group said no to that overture because I think they would say, well, sessions can already do that if they if they so choose. That's the sessions right. Um in lieu of that, what I was encouraged by was uh we commissioned another pastoral letter on how to respond to disabilities and the ministry.

SPEAKER_01And it's to be a pervasive guide on developing disabilities ministries in the EPC. Um, and that would be an internal facing document, but it would be available to every teaching and ruling elder. Hey, how okay, if you don't want to commune this person, well, how do you become, you know, autistic friendly as a church, or what do you do with the special needs ministry? And the PCA, you guys do a great job with that. You know, you've got um your own little disability ministry thing, you've got enfold. So uh that's encouraging. Uh that's near and dear to my heart.

SPEAKER_01I have an autistic and severely uh disabled son. So um, yeah, anything that we do to kind of move the ball closer to uh making room for people with disabilities, I'm all for. And um I think the reformed faith has a beautiful answer to people like that, that it's in God's providence and it's not a mistake. And, you know, uh God makes the blind, the seeing, and the lame. Uh so that's encouraging things. So the disabilities, pastoral letter would be cool. Um, but I mean, in general, it was a it was a hard general assembly for us where uh, you know, we're just I I I I don't know how thick of an institution we are.

SPEAKER_01And these are these are pretty high level, high trust kind of things. And like you said, there's a lot of the oxygen is taken up uh out of the room.

SPEAKER_00Is there anything you wanted to follow up on that, uh, Ben, before I ask some of the last two questions?

SPEAKER_02No, no, no, keep going.

SPEAKER_00Okay. Um, did you guys have a PCA fraternal or corresponding delegate at your General Assembly? Yes, we did.

SPEAKER_01Uh I think his name is Ed Norton. Is that does that ring a bell? Yeah.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. So in thinking through um your experience at GA and uh I don't know exactly how well you know the PCA, is there anything, any parting words that you wanted to pass along to uh PCA brothers who might be um listening, either uh encouragements or what we should be doing uh from our perspective that might be of aid to the EPC or or in prayer for them?

SPEAKER_01Hmm. Yeah, I'm I don't I I mean I would appreciate any prayer um about the memorial thing. I think there's a lot of teaching elders who are just ignorant, uh not in a bad way. I just mean like it's not on their radar to think about memorial stuff and what went on there. So if you have friends in the EPC, you know, uh maybe call them and share your thoughts on this. Um, you know, we want to get it right. Uh and it seems there there does seem to be some complexity. It's my understanding that he was exonerated by his presbytery.

SPEAKER_01Is that is that y'all's understanding uh when he was, you know, investigated uh or something.

SPEAKER_00So if you want some of our our history of it, it gets a bit complicated, but there was at least one case in which um it ended with um, in a sense, an acquittal of what the presbytery had done in that case. Um, although I think there's some resources uh with the PCA sexuality report that I think are helpful for some of the issues. Um our own presbytery wrote a report or um committee did that reviewed his book, Time to Care, and had some concerns about um the compatibility of that book with our confession in about five different.

SPEAKER_00points. Um so there was things like that that were kind of bubbling in the background when they left. So um the question is if they hadn't left would there have been something else that was on the horizon? But that's that's uh kind of what if history there.

SPEAKER_01Sure. Yeah. So I mean that would be helpful just all the information, you know, if there's guys in the PCA around the country, you know, if you've got a local EPC guy, maybe pick up the phone or email them and just chat about that. Um you know I don't I mean I I would just pray for the EPC. I think we're we are in a uh decisive moment where um what does it mean when we say unity and the essentials, liberty and non-essentials? Like how how much of a tool is that uh when it comes to some of these other topics uh you know and how do you square that with with a confessional church?

SPEAKER_00You know there's just inherent tension baked in that uh you know we becomes difficult uh who defines what the things that you can have liberty on are and at least in my book sanctif sanctification is part of the gospel too.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. Well yeah it's just uh you know I mean we had another discussion about baptism and communion uh there was an overture to uh amend the book of worship to clarify that um ministers may invite baptized believers to partake of communion and uh that's implied in our book of worship uh we have a book of worship that's actually constitutional wouldn't that be fun for you guys there you uh it is uh stated that the session may admit baptized children to the table upon profession of faith and all that stuff but it it doesn't speak to baptized adults and so this was an attempt to align our book of worship so that yeah ministers can invite all baptized believers in Jesus' name and we saw it as a you know wonderful teaching opportunity if baptism is truly the replacement of circumcision it only makes sense right to see baptism as the uh initiation rite so to speak and for communion to be um the renewal of the covenant uh well that got shut down easily 7030 uh and the kinds of arguments that people made against clarifying that to me uh uh uh were surprising and it just reminded me that like either we're not totally reformed or we're not so totally tied to the confession uh or people just haven't ever thought about it and they're just like saying what they think off the cup.

SPEAKER_01Um so whether where you land on that I think probably have y'all been in the room and you heard the kinds of arguments that people would make, you know, it would be like that's not how reformed people think. You know it's like but there's no Bible verse. And I'm like yeah but you can derive things by good and necessary consequence. You know I wanted to stand up at one point and be like then why do you baptize children? Why do you baptize infants? You do it because by good and necessary consequence and an under a covenantal understanding of how the old covenant and the new covenant interacted so anyway so that was um I'm off on a tangent again but I'm still recovering from this general assembly you know um but all that to say I guess that would be a I would say the EPC is in flux and we're we're going through our identity crisis and the it's a little bit like what does unite our denomination it doesn't really seem to be a robust reform theology and uh there are several instances where we're not unified on stuff like memorial or the sacraments uh you know the racial letter so like what is uniting all of this all of these churches um and you know then simmering under the surface of course is the complementarian egalitarian divide like okay is this tenable how how tenable is this compromise and uh you know I'll leave it to the Presbyterian historians to project as to what will become of the EPC in the next 10 or 20 years well if Jared's finished I have before I close this down I've got one more question.

SPEAKER_02Okay what how how many food based social events do do y'all have at the EPC General Assembly?

SPEAKER_01Specifically anything focused around ice cream oh okay so um you know seminaries come they'll do like their special breakfast thing and then during lunch we have breakout lunches which is more training and so you know you come you get your little box lunch and then there's like you know 10 or 15 little training seminars and then there's dinner available every night uh so in that sense you know all the meals at least at GA are all stuck together but ours is three days it's a three day general assembly um so I don't I don't do I feel like there's something embedded in an ice cream social.

SPEAKER_02Maybe I got maybe I didn't get invited to that you know maybe I'm on the wrong side do you guys have ice cream socials is that a thing y'all doesn't that's an excellent question Dustin that's uh that's a question I've been trying to ask for the last six months uh we used to we're trying to make it come back so I'm just always interested I heard the OPC had one so I'm I'm I'm eager to talk to somebody from from that denomination.

SPEAKER_01I'm sure they had uh flavors from vanilla to vanilla I'm sure oh man touche well Jared you good I'm good yeah thanks a lot for coming on and talking to us about this yeah and then anything you want to add anything that's still lingering you wanted to make sure to say or you you all right yeah I mean I would say uh I love the EPC uh very sweet people very godly people uh I I I I might sound too negative coming off of this GA if that makes sense maybe I'm a I I might sound a little too down on it but um in a lot of ways uh I would plead with my PCA friends to don't forget about us we we love you guys um we wanted to be a Napark Napark would not let us in um so there's affection from the EPC to the PCA so uh and you know you might meet more of us eventually well here let's uh let's close down I was trying to think of a name to use and we're just gonna use our buddy Scott as Scott Edberg would say this podcast is over.

SPEAKER_02Thanks for joining us dear listeners if you're interested in learning anything more about what we've talked about check out the show notes and your podcast player or at politymatters.org our many thanks to Dustin Jernigan for joining us uh that that D and the J I know okay so it's everybody Dustin Jernigan there he is if you've enjoyed the show uh please consider following us on Twitter or Facebook at Polity Matters and be sure to subscribe in your podcast app of choice if you have questions or comments you can contact us at Politymattersfeedback at gmail.com or find us on social media be sure to check out uh show notes for the proper links thanks again for spending your valuable time with us until next time say goodbye gentlemen see you guys y'all take care

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. 150. You've Got to Come Visit

    Nov 17, 202642 minAudio

    Ben, Jared, and Scott are joined by Brad Voyles, president of Covenant College, as the RAO series continues through the agencies and committees of the General Assembly. Brad shares how he went from Bellhaven and RTS...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. 149. Two Keys on the Nuclear Submarine

    Nov 10, 202642 minAudio

    Jared and Scott are joined by Andrew Rein, coordinator of Reformed University Fellowship (RUF), as the RAO series continues through the agencies and committees of the General Assembly. Andrew shares how he came to RUF...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. 148. From Birthing Babies to Geriatric Care

    Nov 3, 202634 minAudio

    Ben, Jared, and Scott are joined by Steve Dowling, interim coordinator of Mission to North America (MNA), as the RAO series continues through the committees and agencies of the General Assembly. Steve marks one year in...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. 147. ProtoPresbytery

    Oct 27, 202643 minAudio

    Ben and Jared are joined by Lloyd Kim, coordinator of Mission to the World (MTW), as the RAO series continues through the committees and agencies of the General Assembly. Lloyd shares his path from Southern California...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. 146. Broker of Relationships and Resources

    Oct 20, 202643 minAudio

    Ben, Jared, and Scott are joined by Stephen Estock, coordinator of the PCA's Committee on Discipleship Ministries (CDM), as the RAO series continues through the permanent committees and agencies. Stephen shares his path...

    Credit the people on this episode