Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Polity Matters

Polity Matters artwork

88. Some Sense of Order (Overtures 2025 Part Two)

Jun 12, 20251 hr 7 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Alex Ford is back! We quickly put him to work sifting through Overtures with the guys... http://pcahistory.org Overtures discussed: 2, 3, 4, 5, 9, 11, 12, 17, 18, 19, 20, 26, 27, 28, 29, 33, 34, 35, 36, 41, 42, 44, 45, 46, 47, 48, 49, 50 Send us Fan Mail Support the show Official Website: politymatters.org Support the Show: Buy Me a Coffee Twitter/X: @PolityMatters Facebook: Polity Matters Page Scott's Twitter Jared's Twitter Ben's Twitter

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_04Where are we? We just finished six, and now we're moving on to Ooh. We're gonna talk about worship and sacraments and the directory for public worship, which uh nobody on this podcast has strong opinions about at all. Uh number f number five from Calvary. Grant BCO 60 through 63. That's not 60-63, for those of you who may be reading it. It's 60, 61, 62, and 63, four chapters of the BCO, full constitutional status.

SPEAKER_04And the the most uh fascinating part about this overture to me is that it is less than one page. It wants to grant full constitutional authority to four chapters, and it is not even a page long. There's just a bunch of whereases, and the therefore is two and a half lines. So what do we think, fellas?

SPEAKER_00I can kind of see why they did this. If you're thinking we should start working on the directory for worship and getting it to a place in which it's functional in our book, these are fairly uncontroversial uh chapters. Although when you get into the details, it would be nice to revise some of these things. Um I've seen suggestions too of maybe a couple of these chapters about like the sick should be in the appendix uh rather than uh having a full chapter. Um so I think what what this would do is like if you if these are controversial enough that you think you should start with them, that's good.

SPEAKER_00But if you think that things need to be revised if we're gonna tackle the directory, um then you may be more inclined to look at 26 or something different, a different process, or just nothing altogether. Um I I I tend to like the idea of a directory, but I think it needs revision. And so just to adopt these without revision, uh I think is gonna have a bit of pushback.

SPEAKER_04Yeah, and just so folks know, the chapters we're talking about are Visitation of the Sick, Burial of the Dead, Days of Uh Fasting and Thanksgiving, and Christian life in the home. The last four chapters of our book of church order. Nothing, Alex? Nothing. Is twenty-six where the real debate is?

SPEAKER_03Is that yeah, I think I I'm with Jared that if we're going to do uh constitutionalization of these chapters, they need revision. Um Dr. Coffin, I believe, pointed out several of the the issues with these particular chapters, which are of the directory for worship, these are the probably the least controversial. And yet there's still problems innate to making as is the making them as is into constitutional provisions.

SPEAKER_03Um because they're not as clear as they need to be, because they restrict things in unhelpful ways. As I say, we I I would not want to just cart blonde or uh just drop these into the the constitutional portion without any amendments or edit edits to what's what what's here.

SPEAKER_04Alex, you and I haven't talked about this before, so I don't I don't know this is not me asking any kind of lead-in question. I really am curious. Um where do you fall on the on the idea of it's it's they're not constitutional, so there's no there may be not be a point in revising them, would be one side. And the other side would be, well we should revise them after they've been made constitutional. I mean or or is it some combination of revise them as we're making them constitutional? Just curious where your thoughts are on all that.

SPEAKER_03I think the question there is, is it a good idea to have a constitutional directory for worship?

SPEAKER_04Yeah, okay.

SPEAKER_03If it is, then first we've got to fix them so that they're usable and not contradictory, and then make them constitutional. If we make them constitutional, then we just break the constitution for a little while until we get a chance to fix the thing. And that's that's not helpful.

unknownOkay.

SPEAKER_04That's great. Thank you. That's helpful thought. Um 26?

SPEAKER_03Which is why we should talk about 26.

SPEAKER_04Yeah, for sure. From Northwest Georgia, erect an ad interim committee to revise the directory for worship for authoritative use. So uh, well, there's a lot here. Let me see. Um down down in the resolves, uh form an ad hoc committee to finish the work of revising the directory uh that uh not yet given full authority in accordance with scripture and the standards for authoritative use in the PCA according to the rules uh of the BCO, utilizing various NAPARC denominations directories, including scriptural confessional references, uh present various chapters of the GA for adoption until the work is complete.

SPEAKER_04Um then there's there's language about how it is to be established as well, um, and then a provision down there about the finances. So I know there's been a lot of chatter about this. I've been out of these conversations generally for the last little while, so I'm gonna rely on you guys to kind of lead us through the thoughts on this particular overture.

SPEAKER_03Uh just before we actually talk about this overture, I will point out that we're only allowed to approve two at interim committees in any given GA or at any given time total. Uh we have at least three and possibly more, depending on how you divide up the Christian nationalism ones. Um we have at least three that have been proposed. So if we give approval to this, that uh necessarily means at least one of the others has to be answered in the negative.

SPEAKER_01And I gotta give you the response from the AC, though, which is it's also more difficult to approve these uh because you have to amend the budget. Uh that's what the advice of the AC is. Uh if there's not already stipulated funding for a study committee, then the budget of the actual denomination needs to be amended, which is by a two-thirds vote. Um we've had weird approaches in the past, but that's currently the clerk's advice uh on the issue. And so he argues that two-thirds of the assembly needs to approve any study committee if there's no funding already presented.

SPEAKER_01Um so you could I mean that's might that might even be debatable on top of all that.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, that's um I think these committees tried to copy uh the language from other uh proposals in the past. And so this seems to be a new take on it to say that there'd be a two-thirds and you have to change the budget.

SPEAKER_03Um I remembering correctly that in the last couple of years we changed the provisions for at interim committees to require that the budgeting be included in there and not just, oh well the AC will pay for it from whatever. Uh and maybe that I wonder if that's kind of what where that's coming from.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, it's I think it's RAO 93. And uh yeah, it's just whether or not designating it would be GIFs counts, or if it's saying, well, you can't guarantee that gifts are actually gonna come in.

SPEAKER_03That um specifically said it was an unfunded one. There will be no monies allocated to this, which is an interesting choice.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, which could be a question on this. Do you need much more than a Zoom account uh to do some of this work? Um well, this is uh an interesting provision in that it gets into the revising, if we get into the substance of this, it gets into the revising of the directory in order to bring it into constitutional status. Um there are provisions within the BCO already that seem to assume that the directory is constitutional. Um when it tells sessions to govern worship in um 12.5, it tells them to use the directory.

SPEAKER_00Um I think it assumed that it would have been uh approved at a certain point. Um so it it leads to interesting questions. Uh this actually came up in an SJC case uh in which um it had to do with um what a session could have control over in terms of the benediction and limiting what you can use for that. And this came up because you know the benediction is mentioned in the directory, and yet the directory is not constitutional, but the part saying that the session should use a directory is. So how do you use that in your reasoning?

SPEAKER_00Um so this would allow for it to be revised. Uh I think one thing that this has going for it is that this would draw from a broader cross-section of the PCA, hopefully the with the moderator uh making a committee like this, which hopefully would take away people's pet projects. It seems like we only consider BCO chapters when something happens, like with marriage that was actually approved, but just one section, or with preaching. And uh then it there's some issue behind it rather than drawing on um well, what does the PCA actually do?

SPEAKER_00And I think even something that could be in mind if the Overtures Committee wanted to do it is to say not to make it any more restrictive. Um, I think we've forgotten what a directory is for, which is to be some guidance in in creating worship. Um, you think about it now, how does a new church plant or somebody that's come into the PCA, uh, how do they construct a worship service? Probably what they've known before, or they grab Chapel's book, or they grab uh Terry Johnson's guide, uh, but we don't really have something that the PCA says. This is kind of our broad guidance on this.

SPEAKER_00Um the pushback comes from those that would say, I don't want to be told narrowly what I'm doing my service. You know, if you start to get this to a prayer book status of here's your forms, here's exactly how you do it. And I think the big question is who gets to do the leading of worship and certain elements. So the question would be, are you going to tighten that up? Well, you're gonna have a certain segment, uh, even if it's small, that's gonna be objecting to that. Are you completely silent on it? Uh do you make allowances for it?

SPEAKER_00So those are gonna be the questions that are gonna be uh the more difficult ones. But uh the current directory we have is from the 1930s, and um we don't really read it anyway. Here's my test. Have you ever been into a church and they start with a doxology? That's actually what a directory says to do, which apparently was popular in the 30s, and I haven't seen a single PCA church do it. Um so um we probably could have something that would be helpful now. The question just is, you know, uh overcoming the actually setting up a committee, and if you can overcome the fears that people may have of this is narrowing down our practice and you're gonna start telling us what we have to do, which I even have from, you know, uh we don't do offerings as an element of worship.

SPEAKER_00Um if if it was just made constitutional right now with no revisions, well, we're supposed to have that as part of our worship service, and we don't. So um I totally understand that. And so there would need to be either the committee or making of this committee that would have provisions for this, isn't just to make it more narrow, maybe even to loosen up in a few places.

SPEAKER_04Okay. Well, still still in the the area of worship, uh overture 12 from Providence Presbytery seeks to amend BCO 58 to specify only officers may distribute the Lord's Supper. So speaking about constitutionality of the directory, this is one of the chapters that is constitutional. Um, and they want to add some language that says uh here the bread is to be distributed by the minister or to other officers for distribution, and similar language uh down for the cup.

SPEAKER_04Uh my my just first take um is is that this is helpful clarifying language. I think I get I have had the question come to me several times over the last many years that hey, who's allowed to you know to help out, help distribute stuff if a church only has a you know a couple of elders and one may be absent on a Sunday? Is a deacon allowed to help distribute the elements? You know, these kinds of questions are helpful. Um and so while I'm sure that that this may have uh different angles attached to it, I I don't know. Uh I think it is is a helpful clarification in in giving guidance on who can do the supper.

SPEAKER_04But I mean you guys may know this. I I wonder if some of this is coming around because uh people are worried that churches are having non-ordained uh individuals help uh hand out the supper. I don't know if it's meant to clarify or meant to prohibit uh practices that people don't like, but um maybe y'all know better than I do.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, I think one of the questions that would come up from this is some people have talked about what is distributing the elements. And I actually think part of this is the original BCO didn't make a distinction between administering and distributing. Um early um Reformation ways of practicing the supper where you come up to the front and you were at like a table and the minister was there, so there was nobody taking the elements from the table somewhere else. Now we sit in the pews, and then the question is okay, now we're we're separating administering or instituting from distributing.

SPEAKER_00Uh, where does distributing stop? At the edge of the pew, if you're passing it down the the aisle, some have said, okay, now what if you're handing it to somebody else? My wife hands it to me. Is she distributing the elements? Um also you have a maybe you have a church plant and they have some guys that are training to be officers, but they're not officers yet. So the question I I think is, is uh ordinarily you're going to want the officers to distribute. Are there does this make provision for the fact that you may not have that um everywhere?

SPEAKER_00The only ordained officer you have is a pastor uh or or something like that. Um so I think that's where the objections are.

SPEAKER_03The practice of some churches, and I think well, I will say that, but the practice of some churches is not to have the officers be the only ones who walk around with the elements. That the officers are very clearly the ones administering, as you kind of you mentioned the difference between administering and distributing. But that there are others who are employed in distributing, uh, you know, whether that's a a large church and the there just aren't enough elders to pass it around or, you know, whatever. I think there's going to be some pushback from that as well, because is it necessary that an officer be the one walking around with a plate?

SPEAKER_03Do we really need the officers to be the ones doing that? If they're clearly in the front administering the supper. This feels like using a nuke to swat a fly. Um I don't like the way that you're doing it in your church, and so I'm going to put in a constitutional provision to say that you're wrong. Maybe I'm overstating there, but that's that's kind of what the this doesn't feel like a constitutional provision matter. And seems like, as you mentioned, Jared, it's creating it's going to create some problems in ways that are much bigger than the one that it's trying to solve.

SPEAKER_01I don't know. I like the provision. I think the elders are responsible in safeguarding and fencing the table, and perhaps sometimes we take such a hands-off approach where you you fence the table generally and let everyone individually decide, and I think this I think elders should be intimately involved with the table so much so that as they're handing out the elements and distributing them, they know who shall and who shall not get the elements. Um if you're in the context, say if like people come up to for the supper, and neither are ordained officers, and they're the ones handing you the bread, they're the ones handing you the wine.

SPEAKER_01They don't know if you're under censure necessarily. Only the elders do. And so I think there is credence for this, and I I am, you know, full disclosure, I served under the man who authored this. And so I have, you know, I'm all my disclosures out there. Uh I think it's a fine provision. I I think it is not as ne I don't think it hasn't as harsh of a negative result as perhaps shared. I I think it's perhaps helpful. And if you're if you don't have the officers necessary, there are other ways you could distribute the elements that require less of a workload, people coming up, etc.

SPEAKER_01etc. So I think it may have some hindrances, but I think it's a good provision, at least theologically, to think through as officers are in charge of the care of the sheep, even as they distribute the elements.

SPEAKER_04I want to just play around a little bit for a second. You you talked you said a lot about elders just there. So would you seek an would you seek to amend this hypothetically on overtures to to change it from officers to elders?

SPEAKER_02No.

SPEAKER_04No. Our deacons don't always know who's under censure necessarily, depending on how public we've chosen to make it. Um so just I just I'm playing with you.

SPEAKER_01I think if uh you're thinking through those kind of issues, I would feel much more comfortable sharing um an issue with the deacon that we're having than my seven-year-old kid, or my wife even, for that matter. Um, and so I think deacons can be cued in. I mean, we had an issue at Providence where it was a very intimate session issue, but there were also physical issues that we had to have concerns about in the congregation, and so we warned the deacons ahead of time, hey, we're dealing with an issue, we're not going to get into the details of it, but we think for the preservation of the safety of those in the church that you should know about X.

SPEAKER_01And so I think I'd I'm more comfortable sharing intimate details with deacons on a need-to-know basis than um that 21-year-old girl or that uh that father who's not an officer. I I don't know. That's my personal guide on it.

SPEAKER_00I I think you both make really good cases for the wisdom of this practice. It's just the question is going to be is if putting it in as a constitutional requirement can um satisfy all of the minor exceptions, or you know, you're training somebody to be an elder, do they help distribute? Can the session choose to do that? All of these different things that people can imagine. Um, how do you how do you make a provision that that takes into account all of those different things? So that that's gonna be the objection that it has.

SPEAKER_00Uh everybody may be, or 90% of people may say this is the wise way to go, but how do we how do we put that into our constitution in a way that makes allowances for uh those those situations that we come up with?

SPEAKER_04I didn't think this would be one of the ones that I'd really, really have to think about, but uh I think I'm gonna have to really think about this one.

SPEAKER_03The the issue that I have is having ministered in uh destitute areas, you can easily, especially out west, uh in the Pacific Northwest, you can find yourself in a situation where you just don't have very much access to elders, uh or or deacons for that matter. Uh and does that mean that we then require men to fly in, especially in Alaska, uh, to be able to serve the meal uh every month? I mean that seems an undue burden.

SPEAKER_01Will you be there? Satan? You'd be there and you just have people come up.

SPEAKER_03Which is great if your church is 30 or 35. It gets a little more complicated if you've got 75 or 100 and just haven't particularized yet. Anyway, all of that to say, the uh my my hesitation is with admittedly probably a fringe case there, but one that I think we need to be aware of, that it's easy for the PCA in the southeast, in the east, not to know nearly as well because the West is kind of forgotten most of the time.

SPEAKER_04What was that? 12. Okay. Let's keep cruising. We're not doing bad in terms of time. It's gonna be long, but it's not gonna be it's not bad. Let's uh let's go to 19 and 33. We'll do 19 first since that's in order. Uh from Eastern Carolina. Seeking to amend BCO 57 to revise the membership vows, which I I have I mean, even just that alone makes me kind of grimace a little bit to amend the membership vows.

SPEAKER_04But let's let's let's get into it. So um adding an entire new first vow for membership. Uh do you agree that you're made in the image of God and designed by God to glorify God and enjoy Him forever? So turning it into uh six membership vows, basically adding shorter catechism one uh to the beginning, right? I mean, more or less. Do we like this? Do we not like this?

SPEAKER_03The argument in favor is that we want to ground our the beginning of our theology and the beginning of our statements in creation and the good creation rather than in sin, which is where we start now. I don't disagree with that desire. I'm not sure the membership vows is where to do that, but and in addition, as several have pointed out, the sessions are uh have liberty to add to the membership vows within reason, as I understand it.

SPEAKER_03Um they can't obviously you can't take things away. Um I'm not sure that this provision is necessary.

SPEAKER_04Uh just Alex made me think of it to to point out that it also adds some language to what would become question what is currently question number one and currently question number five. Um do you acknowledge yourself to be both beloved and sinners in the sight of God? And then to question number five would add uh would change promise to study to rather to promise to promote the purity and peace of the church. So sorry. To catch us up. My bad. Jared.

SPEAKER_00There was a attempt to change the membership vows to add something that was explicitly Trinitarian before. Uh which has come up before if if you have a member that's denying the Trinity, you know, what's uh is that something that they had vowed to maintain or not? Um and we didn't pass that. Um I think implicitly question one, two, and three are Trinitarian, so it's implicitly in there. But we didn't add explicit Trinitarianism to the vows. I I don't know that this is gonna have much of a better chance uh to to get in than that does.

SPEAKER_00Uh we don't want to mess with the vows unless there's a real need there uh that can be argued. So that's that's gonna be the challenge of this.

SPEAKER_04Cool. That was 19. 33. So many things on my screen at one time. Alright, here we go. Uh overture 33 from our friend uh Fred Greco. And uh seeks to amend BCO 572 regarding the examination of young persons for admission to sealing ordinances. Uh just gonna point out that these, you know, this is the third now, I think, in a row that we've looked at that is seeking to amend the constitutional part of our directory.

SPEAKER_04Just uh interesting point of fact. Um would add uh a couple uh sentence, uh one sentence, a few lines to the end of 57.2. The examination uh shall include an evaluation of the young person's credible profession, the young person's understanding of the meaning of the supper, and the young person's understanding of the questions in BCO 575, which presently are only five questions and could become six, I suppose. Um so uh yeah, it's it's just seeking to regulate how we uh examine children coming uh to the table.

SPEAKER_00This is good advice. I think everybody should be doing this, you know, evaluating credible profession. Do you understand the Lord's Supper? Uh do you understand the vows? Like these are the these are the things that we do.

SPEAKER_03Yeah, does this just be constitutional?

SPEAKER_00Do you put it in the advice and put that good advice in there?

SPEAKER_04Okay, so we have let's see, we just did 19. I'm trying to keep track so I can keep up with myself. 19 and 33, and now. Oh, I think we can skip all of these unless y'all really want to talk about presbytery boundaries. So two, seventy. I want to I want to talk about that. So the one that which one was withdrawn? I forget the numbers. Uh 21. 21 was withdrawn. That was our presbytery withdrew it because uh so originally there was a church on the far west side of our presbytery, Covenant Presbytery, that was gonna move over into Hills and Plains because they were Fort Smith was just so far out of the way, it was impossible to get them to Presbytery.

SPEAKER_04They were gonna join uh Hills and Plains be a little closer. Uh at our most recent Presbytery meeting, like ten days ago, we uh established a study committee to study multiplication of our presbytery. So they, at the same meeting, after we approved the study committee, uh the pastor from Fort Smith asked for us to uh re rescind our overture for them to leave in order for them to see how the study committee goes and what we might do in terms of multiplication in the future, so that they might still be a part of course.

SPEAKER_04I I don't know if I I'm sure I can say all this. Our long-term goal, of course, is to have Arkansas be their own presbytery. Um I don't know how the hills and plains parts of Arkansas feel about that, but um I think that's probably the hope is maybe we're gonna have an Arkansas Presbytery soon. We've been trying to plant churches and we're getting to the point where maybe they could be self-sustaining. And uh so I thought that anyway, kind of cool uh to see that happen and to see the growth, and um, it's encouraging that Arkansas's got some more Presbyterians in it um to the point now where we can have this conversation.

SPEAKER_04So Presbytery boundaries. Presbyteries can't change unless the GA approves it, and so uh two, seventeen, twenty, not twenty-one, thirty-six, forty-five, and forty-six are all having to do with presbytery boundary changes. And um it's nice to check all those off the list and to keep going. So let's talk about study committees. Uh everybody's favorite phrase. Overture number three to start with from Arizona. To erect an ad-interim committee on Christian nationalism. Now, you guys, I don't have them uh joined up in front of me.

SPEAKER_04You may tell me that there are a few that deal with the same kind of thing and five.

SPEAKER_03It's three, four, forty-seven, forty-eight, and forty-nine all effectively deal with Christian nationalism and church-state relations and kind of how all of that plays together somehow. Um 48 is the one asking for a pastoral letter, a committee to do a pastoral letter, which is both better and worse. Uh better in the sense that it'll be easier to pass, uh, worse in the sense that it's gonna do less, um, and is less likely to actually garner the kind of traction that it needs to to deal with the issue.

SPEAKER_03But yeah, th those five are the ones that are all one way or another touching on uh that that same topic of Christian nationalism or church and state relations and that sort of thing.

SPEAKER_04Yeah, that's good. So do we want to you guys want to take some time and talk about it or comment on these? I mean, I think generally people know how I feel about study committees.

SPEAKER_03So I agree that study committees that we've we've done a lot of those in the last several years, well, last ten years really, uh, and as such, it's a steep hill to climb to get another one approved. That said, the problem of how do we as believers, how do we as a church interact with the state and expect the state to interact with us has become a live issue in the last few years.

SPEAKER_03I don't know how much it's affecting members in the pews everywhere, but I've seen it affecting members in the pews. I've seen it even more affecting uh officers, particularly online, unfortunately. But this is a live issue and it it's a a thing where we it would benefit the church to have some clarity. Uh assuming the moderator can find seven men who well represent the ends of the spectrum and and therefore can gain credibility with the different opinions to the folks who hold those different views, uh I think this could be a really beneficial thing to have some version of a committee.

SPEAKER_03Personally, I think of the five that are before us, I think overture four is probably the best version of it, probably with some amendments, but I I think uh some version of overture of ad interim committee touching on Christian nationalism would be beneficial.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, there there's such a diversity in the reform tradition of church state relations, establishmentarianism uh is even in some churches that we have good relationships with, the RPCNA, uh the Free Church of Scotland, I think still in principle is establishmentarian. Um so there's that issue, but then there's also the ethno-nationalist issue. I think the ethnonationalist issue is the bigger issue that um I think you can have a variety of ideas of church-state relations uh within the PCA, but not of the idea of um I don't know, certain things that are attached to um ethnic uh groups and uh to deny our unity that we have in Christ and in Adam.

SPEAKER_00And so, yeah, the question really is how do you get down to that? Is it the uh pastoral letter? Is it um a study committee on it? Uh is it passing around? I thought uh Kevin DeYoung had a good article that was reviewing um Stephen Wolfe's book, um, got into some of those uh questions there too. So um it's a real issue, it's just how you how are we going to deal with it? Study committee has uh the problems of um all of the study committees this year is how you fund it. Um so that may be actually what's debated more than the substance of it.

SPEAKER_03In some ways, I think the funding is the easiest portion because if you look, a number of these presbyteries that have put this forward have promised a certain amount of funds, and from what I, you know, just the short back of the napkin math, it seemed like there's sufficient promise from the sending presbyteries to cover the entire study committee. 15,000 a year or whatever.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, I think it was 9,500 and they were looking for at least some of them. So yeah, I I tend to I'm still it is a serious issue. I wonder how faddish the issue is and if it's sustainable. Um I my gut is that the Christian nationalist movement currently is unsustainable uh and it will flicker away. That's kind of how I see it in due time. It doesn't have the weight to support itself, and so in five years from now, like many fads, it will be gone.

SPEAKER_01That's that's my gut. I know that, but I'm not in a church that has had much in significant influence. I know it has hurt many churches uh in the PCA, and I know there's been church splits because of it. And so I'm not discounting that. I know there's been real pain. I just wonder how sustainable the movement is. My gut is that it's not sustainable, but that's just me.

SPEAKER_04Yeah, we've seen it somewhat play, not not in any large degree like I know some other churches have, but it has for the most part trickled. You know, guys have just kind of either they lose interest or they become um uh disillusioned by watching the the big names in it, you know. They kind of see after a while, like, oh, I don't think I'm interested in going that way.

SPEAKER_03I think the fact that it's fad-ish is not necessarily a bar from us speaking to it. There I'm looking down the list of study reports that we have um already that we've received in the past, and there are several that I think we would classify as fads now, but they're fads that passed in part because we spoke to them.

SPEAKER_04Yeah.

SPEAKER_03Um you know, things that that were a flash in the pan and really nobody's talking about anymore, which is great. But we made our position clear on on the issue and that allowed it to be, you know, ushered on along much more quickly. And I think that's the category that this falls into.

SPEAKER_00Now your document actually grouped a different study committee in there, the AI one.

SPEAKER_04So yeah, we don't wanna we don't want to overlook that one. Um I don't want my robot overlord to get mad at me for ignoring uh uh overture 49 from Pacific Northwest to erect an ad interim committee on artificial intelligence. Interestingly, another one that was sent to all of the uh permanent committees is what it looks like. Uh so Scott, what did the AC think of this one? I know it's just because of the money, right?

SPEAKER_01Sorry, we have uh we have no comment until our June 5th meeting after this publishes. And so we I'm not gonna record it. You'll just have to read for yourself. Actually, I know it's advice.

SPEAKER_04I actually meeting before we publish.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, I actually know uh what our advice is um as a prophet. Um it's going to be the same advice we probably gave to all the other ones. Maybe a little more, I guess. I don't know. I'm guessing they're gonna say funding, funding, two-thirds, REO.

SPEAKER_04Did I hear right that Ridgehaven's um advice in response to all these overtures is just the same for everyone, which is get off my lawn? Is that did I get that right? No? Okay. Um I mean I'll jump in. Like, I'm I make use of different versions of AI for different things in different parts of my life, and I would appreciate uh knowing you know what people think about it. I don't know if I want that from a PCA study committee, but I can appreciate the interest and the recognition that this is a significant issue.

SPEAKER_04Um I you know, we've we've struggled with uh plagiarism and issues with ordinance coming for exams in our presbytery in in the past, and and this is only gonna add to that kind of thing, not just for for exams for ordinance, but across the board in education. And so I I do think it's worth knowing about and being aware of. I don't know what I feel about a study committee.

SPEAKER_00It you should have some knowledge of this because it'll be an issue just in pastoral counseling more broadly than just pastoral candidates, but people who work in your church. So this is a real issue. Um I was actually kind of surprised, I think it was unanimous at Pacific Northwest that this is gonna be a problem in the future to get a handle on. So even if it's not a study committee, you probably should pick up some books on this and and start thinking about pastoral counseling um for people that are gonna deal with this, and then how do you deal with it in the courts of the church?

SPEAKER_04I mean, this will I don't I'm not uh take this for what it's worth. Tony Ranke just uh he's you know he's done a lot of study and writing on technology. Uh he works for uh what Desiring God. He has a um a lecture he gave at Phoenix Seminary just a couple weeks ago now. Um excellent treatment of AI and the preacher. So uh for any of you listening, uh go look that up. You can find it pretty easy online. Uh very, very helpful in considering the reality that we have to keep personality um was his main thing in all of this.

SPEAKER_04Uh while AI can do a lot of those things. Uh and because our theology makes sense, it can actually be right a lot of the times. We have to be careful um when making use of it. Alright. Y'all okay? Let's go on to navigate back. Number 11 of the overture. So that we dealt with uh we dealt with study committees, advisory committees. Number 11 uh is a um uh an overture from South Texas to study incorporating Bitcoin into Session Presbytery Committee and agency balance sheets.

SPEAKER_04Um did I miscategorize? Is this one another study committee? This is another study committee. Okay, oh never mind. We're still in a whole I've got a big section of study committees. There was one. Yeah.

SPEAKER_00It's it's not a separate committee, it's for the agencies to study. Yeah, to which agencies will respond.

SPEAKER_04We have enough to do and we don't need to do this. Is that I mean, is that the way it's gonna be?

SPEAKER_00Well, I think PCA Foundation could probably give us some good uh counsel on this, and that's I think what AC says to do. And so maybe it's just sent just to them.

SPEAKER_04Haven't we dealt with this on the GA floor before? Bitcoin? I feel like somebody got up and talked about Bitcoin a couple years ago.

SPEAKER_01You're conflating two different ideas here. Um the the what we've dealt with on the GA floor, and perhaps what we might continue to deal with, is how does one receive Bitcoin as a donation? This is not that. This is more investing and what it looks like to invest as agencies, churches, etc. And so one is dealing with investing, one is dealing with receiving. There is no negative advice to receiving Bitcoin. We actually need um RBIs uh and uh and Geneva, Geneva Benefits.

SPEAKER_01We need their advice on how to receive it and how to manage it once we receive it, but this is a little more proactive in the idea of Bitcoin itself and as an investment, and to which they actually say, no, it's not a good idea to invest in. That's what I think Geneva Benefits says in their recommendation, uh, that it doesn't rise to the level of uh credibility or something like that, some formal uh uh business speak that I don't understand that they are better at explaining.

SPEAKER_01Uh, but uh it's not a wise thing to invest in. That's basically their advice uh to the overture.

SPEAKER_04But I was right that somebody has said Bitcoin on the floor of the General Assembly before, right? I mean that has happened.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, we on the AC, this is perhaps maybe helpful. Uh like we on the AC there was a com there was a ministry that was asking to be an exhibitor on our floor that was dealing with Bitcoin. And at first we're like, well, if we're saying no to this overture, should we also say no to them? Um but when we were looking at the ministry, it was how do you manage Bitcoin donations? And we're like, well, we're we already do that, so it's okay. So we can invite them. They're not encouraging people to spend their money in Bitcoin and invest, they're saying how are how how can we help service churches who receive this sort of donation?

SPEAKER_01And so they will be here.

SPEAKER_04I'm glad you're here, Scott.

SPEAKER_01Oopsh. I'm alive.

SPEAKER_04So another one, uh, 27, overture 27 from Northwest Georgia. Erect ad interim committee to receive suggestions for permanent committee and agency operations, resources, and expenses. Uh is the title we've got it up there. The therefore, uh, therefore clause down here, we request the 52nd General Assembly to approve an ad interim committee on operations, resources, expenses, uh, with said committee tasks to solicit and receive any recommendations for improvement, optimization, greater transparency from the lower courts for all funded GA works, which shall then be collated, evaluated, and reported uh on its website directly to the 53rd Assembly as well.

SPEAKER_04Um and there's some more language there about funding. Uh is is okay, I I really forgive my uh thing. I've heard people talking about is this the Doge uh overture that people have been talking about? Is that is that what they mean when they say that is this particular one? Okay. So uh I I see I see Alex nodding or shaking his head. Um so I'm gonna I'm gonna ask him what he thinks about this one.

SPEAKER_03I'm not a fan for a whole variety of reasons, not least because it's just an administrative nightmare. Uh what are the what is the committee supposed to do with all these recommendations? Do we just have a pile of you know little post-it notes with recommendations on it to to hand to the AC the at next GA? Um what what do we do with this? This is not a good way to think through, you know. Okay, so it is the is there there's been question, are we efficiently managing the resources that we have, both human resources, financial resources, whatever?

SPEAKER_03Obviously that's a question that's worth asking. This is not how you get there. This is not how you go about figuring that out.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. Well, I I think it was interesting the AC said either negative or refer back, because there's something there. That there's a good idea there of I'm sure if you can have some sort of a comment box that has ideas to save money, that's a good thing. Um do we need to pay for a separate committee that's doing this? I don't I don't think so. Well, there's there's my opinion. I don't necessarily think so. Although it would be nice if you assign somebody an AC to collect these things and to do some things like that. There's some good people in AC that could do that. Scott. He's not doing anything.

SPEAKER_01Spare me of all pain and misery. Uh I think it was referred to the 53rd General Assembly, if I recall my advice. Uh the AC's advice, I should say. Um we were debat we debated it, and it was either negative or refer to the next assembly, and I think they decided on refer next. Or do either or I don't really care either way.

SPEAKER_01My inner like Ran Paul Ron Paul comes out. You see, that I don't care either way, it just keeps happening. Uh, where it's like we must make government larger to make it smaller. That just like it hurts my it hurts the libertarian part of me.

SPEAKER_04Alright. Are we still on together? I lost connection there for a second. I think I'm back. Yeah, okay. I can hear y'all. I just I think I was frozen up. Yeah. But it seems like y'all were talking about.

SPEAKER_00I think we're good to move on to 35.

SPEAKER_04That's what I was gonna do. What a I love it. Uh overture 35 from Pacific Northwest requesting the AC to study and report on GA meeting locations. Um yeah, there are numbers in this overture. So that that's cool.

SPEAKER_01Um This is a very wise overture.

SPEAKER_04Interestingly, so we're gonna be in Chattanooga this year and Louisville next year and Milwaukee the year after that, right?

SPEAKER_00So I had a conversation with somebody in AC that uh is on staff that does these things, and uh there's really good reasons for the places that are picked and that are selected. And um so I don't think it's necessarily something that they're unaware of that they need to study, but maybe just putting it into a report and letting everybody know about it is a good idea.

SPEAKER_03Part of the benefit there, a huge part of the benefit is getting that information public to everybody at the assembly. Not that everybody's gonna read it, but hopefully they will. Um it has been a source of consistent amusement to me that we have the GA in the South and then GA not in the South. Well, the not in the South locations have been places like Memphis and Louisville. I'm sorry, that's that is the south. Come on now. Um Milwaukee's coming up. But I'd love to see us, you know, get west of the Mississippi, not in Texas.

SPEAKER_03We've done Texas, that's great, but that's the only place we've gone west of the Mississippi other than Memphis, which doesn't count. Um and I'd love to see better awareness of the categories that are needed to make that decision. To be able to say, okay, well, this is what it takes to be able to host a General Assembly and and why this is the decisions that they are. I think this is a great idea.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, well, there's uh there are Myriad of reasons. It's really hard to plan these things. Some locations just don't want you because you're a church affiliated group. Like we don't want it, we don't want a denomination that in our city. That's too controversial. But now our assembly is at a weird middling age or size where we are too large for where we used to go, but too small to go to like the actual convention cities.

SPEAKER_01We're in between a rock and a hard place in our current size. And that has put us into us not having the best bargaining, but also we are barely making even on our assemblies. And one hiccup uh and an assembly can be really jeopardized. And so what I mean by that is that we need 2,000 commissioners to break even at every assembly. And we our assemblies have gotten larger, right? Of the last five years, they've been 2,000 on average.

SPEAKER_01But say something goes quiet or dormant, or we choose a location that's not as popular, and so people don't want to travel all the way over there, and so now we go under 2,000. Well, that means we're going, we're gonna be in the red. And so there needs to be, in my opinion, and why this is a good overture, there needs to be a greater study on how to stabilize. Because I in my mind, this our current pattern is not sustainable. We need something that can be replicated without much uh risk to the denomination, and that might mean being more static and maybe even less diverse.

SPEAKER_01I don't know, like it just depends how the research goes. But right now it's like, oh no, maybe in Milwaukee we go under because of the nature of uh being out of the south, or maybe it's fine, but it's really there's a lot of liability in the current structure that we have. Uh Dixie, who's uh the business administrator, is a fantastic woman, and she is very helpful in this matter. And I hope that this passes, and I hope that we can have a little more RD with just not her doing all this, but perhaps a larger group trying to plan this.

SPEAKER_04And that would not be an official study committee of the GA. That's just asking the AC to do the work, right, Scott?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, maybe that's what we should always do. We should just ask the AC or some group that's already a group to study everything. Charge the AC to charge the AC to study Christian nationalism solved.

SPEAKER_04Well, I know he's gonna have to slip off in a second, so since we're in a pause, I just want to say thanks again to Alex for being with us. Um we appreciate it. Uh, it looks like you made it through most of the substantive stuff with us. We're about to get into kind of just you know some some periphery things. So uh appreciate you.

SPEAKER_00Do you have one of those you want to say something about that's left?

SPEAKER_03Uh I will leave by dropping a bomb. Um50, um, I think is should be an absolute slam dunk. This is, you know, Christian care for immigrants is regardless of documentation status, is the the short version of that overture. That should be a slam dunk for the churches are to care for immigrants regardless of how they got here and and who they are and whatever. It won't be for a whole variety of reasons. Um but I I think it should pass, and it's something that we absolutely should do.

SPEAKER_00Well, this is almost an alternative to what MA was saying with legal advice. Well, this is pastoral advice. Um you don't need to get into church-state relations to say you should have a pastoral mind for this. Um I think it's partly what that's trying to do, right?

SPEAKER_03I think that's the key, is that it's not trying to say, you know, as a denomination, we encourage you to violate the law, you know, whatever. We're not doing that. But for for your churches, as you're in whatever area you're in, you're going to encounter immigrants. Whether they're legal immigrants or undocumented or whatever you want to call, whatever category they fall into, these are the people that God has put in your neighborhood. Care for them. It's not your job to enforce the government's immigration laws, it's your job to care for the people that God has put in your in your lap.

SPEAKER_03And I think, as I say, I think this this should be a slam junk dunk. I expect it probably won't pass for a variety of good and less good reasons, but um this should be just no question. Let's go. I mean, I'm I have to bow.

SPEAKER_04Thank you. We appreciate you.

SPEAKER_03Thank you all.

SPEAKER_04All right. I was wondering what was gonna happen when he did that, but I think it uh no w when he left. I was wondering what was gonna happen when he left. So I think it's okay. Um okay, well, it's just the three of us again.

SPEAKER_00Uh uh that that kind of relates to 28 though, which is the overture that asked uh MA to issue an apology for the recommendation and uh to dismiss anybody who was involved with giving those those recommendations uh on legal help. I I don't know if uh that's uh gonna go anywhere. That it seems rather uh uh extreme uh in terms of directing what the uh the committee needs to do.

SPEAKER_00Uh but that's out there, and I think 50 is meant to be an alternative to that. Okay.

SPEAKER_04Well good. Uh so let's um I've got I've got some sense of order for the rest of these. We we've got some administrative matters, there's uh um there's some communication stuff, and then there's some SJC and process uh things that we'll hit in a minute. So let's just kind of work our way through uh it might seem a little random, but let's just go to 18 to start with. Uh over to 18 from Gulf Coast Presbytery directs RUF to update campus ministry manual for GA approval. Uh the context of this, of course, is recent years.

SPEAKER_04Uh there were matters concerning the the RUF uh policy manual and their affiliation agreements, which have been, you know, in process and being updated and things. And uh I'm sure that this is just uh a response to that. Uh I I seem to recall somebody uh writing, maybe it was in one of the documents, that this is just too large to ask for.

SPEAKER_00Does that sound right to y'all, or maybe uh I don't I don't I don't recall Well the the question is is is the 1979 that's referred to in there accurate um or is this already being revised by RUF? So I think we probably need to hear from RUF before we know how this is gonna shake out at General Assembly of what their current manual is uh and if they have a response for why not to do this because they say no.

SPEAKER_04They do. That's that's something we should note. RAUF says no to overture 18. Okay, well not much to say then. Overture 34 uh is from Savannah River, amending RAO sixteen to require reporting on session and diaconate membership and duties, uh adding a section down here to RAO sixteen four C one uh that says uh that um the presbytery should uh include a list of persons who compromise the session and the diaconate of each church arranged by their ordained or given titles, and if no diaconate exists, to report why it has not been established and whether or not the duties have developed upon the ruling elders, unordained diaconal assistants, or any other committee or member of the church.

SPEAKER_00Um again, this has some context in recent debates over the last few years uh related to ordained uh and unordained people and titles and work and uh Yeah, I think this is meant to be a prompt to have the session reporting uh who is doing their diaconal duties because the BCO tells you that if the deacons aren't doing it, it dissolves to the the session. Although some people have set up a non-ordained uh quasi-diaconate uh that has unordained people in it.

SPEAKER_00And so I think it's trying to get to that. The CCB has some questions about whether or not it's asking certain questions that are already, you know, the answer is supposed to be it's it's supposed to go to the session. Um and then there's also a question of what's is the GA is asking a court to report to another court, and so it's it gets a little bit uh into the weeds there. But um yeah, so so the question there is just dealing with CCB's uh question of the the questions that are being asked. Um they're already supposed to be done by the BCO, so give advice rather than ask the question would be the way that I think to resolve that.

unknownYeah. Okay.

SPEAKER_04Great. And uh let's see, let's jump to 41 from Calvary. Uh directing the AC to collect and report each congregation's public worship service times and and to attach them uh on the directory map that's uh at PCAAC.org. I I'll comment on this one to start with. Uh, you know, I've gone on there to look around for churches when we're traveling, you know, to find somewhere to worship. Generally speaking, if you're gonna get a hold of a church to get their worship times from them, they also have a website, which generally speaking is linked on the PCA website already.

SPEAKER_04So while I'm not one to poo-poo on uh on on even just a simple thing like this, I don't know if it's really necessary. Uh the churches that are not gonna respond to this probably don't have websites, and you you're not gonna find it anyway. It's the 21st century, folks. You know, look around on the internet. But y'all may disagree. I don't even probably do.

SPEAKER_00Uh the RPCNA does this on their website, but the RPCNA has a few less churches than we do. Yeah.

SPEAKER_04Um Hey, uh, maybe an idea for an entire new PCA-based podcast where every episode is uh just a couple of guys trying to find the worship times for the churches in the PCA. And over the course of twelve years this will be accomplished. Any takers? Listeners, if you're interested, uh get in touch with me. Uh I can help produce that podcast. We'll make it happen. Uh I think uh it would be listened to by uh a couple of people.

SPEAKER_04So maybe and most certainly people from Calvary Presbytery. So Alright. Uh let's I hope I'm not making fun of Mel when I made all those jokes just now. That would be horrible. 312's coming in. What was that? 41? 42. Direct this uh from Calvary again. Direct the Stated Clerk not to collect statistical data pertaining to age or ethnicity. Uh one of you guys who's more in the know is gonna have to tell me what this is about, but basically the resolved at the bottom says Calvary Presbytery hereby overtures the 52nd General Assembly to direct the office of the Stated Clerk through the administrative committee not to collect statistical data pertaining to age or ethnicity and annual statistical reports.

SPEAKER_04I guess the question is, i is the state of clerk collecting this kind of data? And why should we tell him to stop?

SPEAKER_01The state of clerk is not currently collecting this data. This is a provision that will be implemented over the next year that was made aware when they were collecting data this year. And so this year they said next year we're gonna collect data on race and ethnicity. Um and so there has been wind of it, and for that reason, Calvary had given us a pair of overtures that are dealing with uh perhaps not collecting that data.

SPEAKER_04So is that also overture 43 uh amending regarding data on age and ethnicity? Yeah. So we've got the the pair is what Scott referred to. Um I mean Scott, do you is there anything you can give us from the AC in terms of y'all's thoughts on this, or has this been since your your last meeting?

SPEAKER_01No, no, we we answered. We we think no in both on both of these. Um I the rationale is in there. I I don't I I feel strongly. I was about to say I don't really feel strong. Uh you know, have strong feelings about this.

SPEAKER_04Um yeah, there When you say rationale's in there, you're talking about the commissioner's handbook where the report is found.

SPEAKER_01It's it's substantial enough. Uh my my question perhaps is the greater idea of selective choice of what we gather. Uh I probably have an issue uh just a general issue, like why aren't we collecting gender data? You know, if we're gonna collect age and ethnicity, why not gender? I mean, I think gender would come before age and ethnicity. Um, but for some reason we don't collect that, but we want to start collecting this. And that's perhaps where the why I mean if this was just all encompass encompassing, it'd probably be less discussed.

SPEAKER_01But because there's a selective nature of it, it probably creates more debate. I I think you either keep it how it is or you just collect everything. That's kind of my position personally. Uh don't be selective of what you collect, just to collect everything or keep it how it is, rather than selectively choosing certain data points.

SPEAKER_04Yeah. Cool. We did those. Um I'm I'm running through my lists and I'm seeing that we've dealt with some of these as we've worked our way through. Uh let's jump to I think 44 would be now. Uh yeah, did we already handle 28? Yeah, you address 28. Yeah, 44. Thank you, Jared. Um 44 from P. D. Presbytery, transition by faith to a press release-based publication. Uh several uh points in their resolved statements at the bottom uh that they they limit the types of content that by faith publishes uh to official press releases from the AC and other agencies regarding actions taken by GA, initiatives, denominational decisions, uh, ministry updates from PCA churches, presbyteries, and agencies, highlighting the work of the Church in Missions, discipleship and service, as well as announcements and reports from the GA and Presbyteries ensuring transparency and accessibility of denominational proceedings.

SPEAKER_04Uh, you know, I mean, I guess the context of this one is that in recent months we've seen other types of things coming from by faith, particularly more recent months, and over the years, uh, different types of articles and things. Between me and y'all, and I guess this is and and many people that are listening, I've never understood the precise uh purpose of By Faith in terms of what kinds of things they would release, because it seems like there's all sorts of stuff coming out of By Faith. So my personal thought is that I I'm uh agreeable to this. I uh you know, I think I think having some set standards is wise, and maybe they exist and this would just be narrowing them, but uh as you know, as a TE who's been around for a little while at least, I've never known what the purpose of By Faith was in terms of their uh uh the their um their directives, I guess.

SPEAKER_04So y'all come at me.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, I think it's grown over the years. I mean, you have more editorial comments, you have devotionals that'll come out of there, you have news announcements, and so I think because there'd been some things about like, you know, that would that churches aren't united on COVID response or uh political issues like January 6th or um, you know, what sorts of press releases. Uh there are some press releases that dealt with the character of uh elders that you're kind of like, uh is this is this what I want to read in in the denominational paper?

SPEAKER_00So that's why I think it's uh it's come up. It's just whether or not this is narrowing too much, or or yeah, and that'll be for OC and GA to decide.

SPEAKER_04Could we devise just uh like uh like a a by faith GPT that would just publish stuff on its own without anybody having to run it? You know, all all we're looking at is server costs, which are you know probably minimal in the long run. You know, just get an Apple Mac mini and stick it in in Lawrenceville somewhere and have it run a publication arm. Um you've heard it here first, so if it happens, I'm gonna claim that.

SPEAKER_01Um AI replacement.

SPEAKER_04Or we are I've got two left on my on my list. Maybe that's what the AI study committee can recommend. Um, I should probably flip to it so I can tell you what it is. There it is. From James River. Uh again, another one sent to a lot of different people. Amending BCO 14 to make AC members appointed by committees and agencies non-voting advisory members. Uh so we should probably rehearse a little bit. Folks don't remember BCO 14 from when we covered it back in the day. Uh but presently, uh constituting BCO uh 14 and REO five, the administrative committee consists of eleven members elected at large by the General Assembly, as well as nine members appointed by the permanent committees and agencies, which means that the the AC is twenty members, nine of whom are appointed by permanent committee members and agencies uh not elected by the general assembly.

SPEAKER_04Uh they point out here that it means that forty-five percent of the votes on the AC are cast by men appointed to the committee rather than elected to the committee, and they're seeking to remove um their voting privileges. Um still have the privilege of the floor, um, and what I think it also excludes them when an executive session is called as well. So uh I mean Scott, I don't know how much you want to get into this. You're a member of the administrative committee, uh, but uh you know, maybe one of you guys wants to help us just think through the different aspects.

SPEAKER_04Yeah, you don't want to help. Jared, Jared, what are the different things we should consider on this one or that's worth looking at? Yeah.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, the the thought here is to have uh the AC run by those who are elected by the GA rather than those that are appointed by the committees. In some ways it's having um right now you have oversight, that's almost half the committee that comes from those the people or those agencies that they're overseeing. So there may be a little bit of a conflict there. Um the pushback to that is well, through the AC comes uh budget proposals. So we want to have the people that are there uh represent them um at those budget proposals.

SPEAKER_00Um I think probably the pushback on that again would be they vote on a whole lot more than budget proposals on the AC. So they're in the room for all these other um discussions, whether it's uh staffing uh of AC or anything else that the AC does. Um so that's really gonna be the back and forth there of uh do we want to have more direct oversight just from the GA on AC or role of the uh the permanent committees in having voting members that are going there.

SPEAKER_00No.

SPEAKER_04Okay. Well, uh one more. Just just one more for us to look at, and that is overture 29 from Houston Metro. Amending BCO 15 to clarify the handling of an SJC minority decision by the General Assembly. Uh these kinds of overtures make me dizzy. Uh just you know.

SPEAKER_00Well, I think one of the biggest parts of this, I don't know if Scott wants to jump in on this, but is we've never had a minority report that has been done by the SJC. And the things that are required in order to do that are very expensive, such as sending out all of the record of the case, and it seems to imply the sending out of all of that information is physical. So I I think this might have actually come from the SJC could have had a minority report this year, but when they looked at the process for this and said, we would be costing the denomination tens of thousands of dollars to have a minority report.

SPEAKER_00And if you can do this electronically, then you can actually do it. So right now, the way that it's written, it may not be possible to do a minority report without large expense, and this would make it you're able to actually do a minority report uh without physically mailing out all of the information. So I I think this is coming from kind of from the SJC um to say like if we ever want to actually use this provision, this is we need to have a changing of how we would get the information out.

SPEAKER_04See, this is why I like having Jared around because he can explain things um you know like we're very you know under 18 just to pick an arbitrary number uh and and understand it. So thank you. Uh appreciate that. Well, guys, uh that I mean we just we did it. Uh we're we're under two hours and ten minutes. I'm thinking of releasing this in one long episode, I think.

SPEAKER_00Uh with with only the loss of one member over.

SPEAKER_04We only lost a guy one guy along the way. That's only a twenty-five percent uh you know. I've been watching all of the other PCA podcasts have overture episodes way too early, in my opinion. But I I think we're the only one that can say that we have dealt with every single overture in one singular episode. Um and if Polity Matters is for anything, isn't it for that? So you guys have any closing words uh about any of this that you'd like to contribute or here. I tell you what, let's just say that as as Overture 51 would say, if it existed, this podcast is over.

SPEAKER_04Uh thanks for joining us. Our our uh ex uh great thanks to our friend Alex Ford for joining us today. I appreciate Alex coming on because uh he and I don't interact on a regular basis during the year, but when overtures come around, I always value hearing what he has to say about them, and it helps me think about them in a fresh uh way that I I might not normally uh consider. Uh listeners, as you know, if you're interested in learning what we've talked about, you can uh check out the show notes. There probably won't be a lot down there this time aside from a link maybe to the overtures. Um and uh remember I will have chapter markers uh which you may have already found, and if not, you can use those when you come back uh as you think forward about General Assembly.

SPEAKER_04If you've enjoyed the show, do consider following us on social media at Polity Matters and be sure to be subscribed in your podcast app of choice. If you have comments or questions, you can contact us at Politymattersfeedback at gmail.com. If you're a supporter and you haven't heard from me, please get in touch and let me know what your t-shirt size is, and we will try to hold one for you when we're at General Assembly. Uh, if you're a supporter, I might even mail you one uh if you're not gonna be in Chattanooga. Uh there's a link below where you can support our work and uh you know get your secure a t-shirt for next year.

SPEAKER_04Hopefully we'll try to do this uh every year now. Uh uh I've just been really glad to go through this whole thing and super excited to have some like wearable merch out there. It's gonna be kind of cool. Anyway, uh all of that to say, thank you for spending time with us. Until next time, say goodbye, gentlemen.

SPEAKER_00Goodbye, gentlemen.

SPEAKER_04Y'all take care.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Hosts

  • Ben Ratliff Co-host Feed-stated
  • Jared Nelson Co-host Feed-stated
  • Scott Edburg Co-host Feed-stated

Guests

  • Alex Ford Guest Feed-stated

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. 150. You've Got to Come Visit

    Nov 17, 202642 minAudio

    Ben, Jared, and Scott are joined by Brad Voyles, president of Covenant College, as the RAO series continues through the agencies and committees of the General Assembly. Brad shares how he went from Bellhaven and RTS...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. 149. Two Keys on the Nuclear Submarine

    Nov 10, 202642 minAudio

    Jared and Scott are joined by Andrew Rein, coordinator of Reformed University Fellowship (RUF), as the RAO series continues through the agencies and committees of the General Assembly. Andrew shares how he came to RUF...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. 148. From Birthing Babies to Geriatric Care

    Nov 3, 202634 minAudio

    Ben, Jared, and Scott are joined by Steve Dowling, interim coordinator of Mission to North America (MNA), as the RAO series continues through the committees and agencies of the General Assembly. Steve marks one year in...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. 147. ProtoPresbytery

    Oct 27, 202643 minAudio

    Ben and Jared are joined by Lloyd Kim, coordinator of Mission to the World (MTW), as the RAO series continues through the committees and agencies of the General Assembly. Lloyd shares his path from Southern California...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. 146. Broker of Relationships and Resources

    Oct 20, 202643 minAudio

    Ben, Jared, and Scott are joined by Stephen Estock, coordinator of the PCA's Committee on Discipleship Ministries (CDM), as the RAO series continues through the permanent committees and agencies. Stephen shares his path...

    Credit the people on this episode